Trevett previews budget

Claire Trevett previews the budget issues:

Yet far from being the party’s salvation, this Budget – with expectations riding almost impossibly high – could well be Dr Cullen’s Waterloo. Dr Cullen has drunk from the cup of parsimony far too many times and Victoria University lecturer Jon Johansson said it had led to “an intractable negative perception” of him.

A political science lecturer, Mr Johansson doesn’t think it will matter which figure Dr Cullen pulls out of his hat tomorrow. “When you talk to people about Cullen there is real intensity and negativity. I think he is Labour’s biggest liability.”

I think this is right. In some ways it is unfair as Cullen is an incredibly competent Minister, he has generally resisted doing anything really harmful (like tinkering with the Reserve Bank Act, GST, Fiscal Responsibility Act), has presided over or benefited from eight years of strong economic growth and introduced some policies which will be long lasting – the Cullen Fund and KiwiSaver.

But his intransigence on personal tax rates has negated all that to a large segment of the public. If he had moved earlier on tax, then he might retire with bipartisan appreciation as having been one of NZ’s best Finance Ministers.

However you can’t run absolutely enormous surpluses year after year and refuse to lower tax rates, especially as inflation and bracket creep push people into paying more tax every year. Even worse you can’t announce tax cuts and then cancel them – even if they were small insignificant ones.

The problem for Dr Cullen now is that tomorrow’s tax cuts look insincere and grudging. I doubt a single person in NZ really thinks Dr Cullen wants to cut taxes as opposed to being forced to cut taxes.

Dr Claire Robinson, a political marketing specialist at Massey University, said Labour did not deliver what voters wanted in Budget ’07, and many had gone to National.

“There’s not much Labour can do in this Budget to lift itself from the doldrums. It will take a miracle to shift those voters back to Labour, and Michael Cullen doesn’t believe it is his role to deliver miracles.”

While Dr Cullen has been downplaying the size of his proposed three-year programme, National this week has been bandying about figures of $50 a week in a bid to ramp up the pressure on Cullen.

Mr Johansson and Dr Robinson said the public will be deaf to anything Labour has to offer or to arguments that National would be fiscally irresponsible to offer more.

I am confident National’s tax cuts will not be at all fiscally irresponsible. Bill English will not be delivering deficits in Government.

The bigger challenge for National will be the impact on inflation. However this can be over-stated, and one way to deal with this is to have a smaller reduction every year than one big reduction in one year. Also many people do understand that higher interest rates are temporary, while a reduction in tax is permament.C

Almost a Darwin Award

NZ Herald:

A man who fell asleep in a rubbish skip after “domestic problems” is lucky to be alive after being dumped into a truck that crushes the rubbish.

The South Auckland man was found by the truck driver, who heard him banging for help from inside the compactor only because he had stopped to open a gate at a commercial property in Takinini about 4.20am on Monday.

Industry employees spoken to by the Herald yesterday said it was lucky the man was found because drivers’ routes could involve many stops and they did not always get out of their vehicles before crushing the rubbish.

A rubbish skip seems a very bad place to sleep – for multiple reasons!

More Dim-Post

Clark Announces Inquiry into Ingram Inquiry

Prime Minister Helen Clark today announced an independent investigation into the independent investigation of former Labour Party MP Taito Phillip Field.

The new inquiry will investigate the Ingram inquiry and examine the inquiry’s examination of of its investigation.

The terms of reference for the inquiry do not include inquiring into the narrow terms of reference for the previous inquiry.

The inquiry into the Ingram inquiry will be headed by Ingram inquiry head Noel Ingram.

Also Dim has quotes from Amazon book review of the Book of Mormon:

I kinda liked it. Even though it was mostly boring, it had some cool violent parts where people get heads chopped off, arms chopped off, and there were some good lessons. Just ignore the boring Jesus stuff and focus on the killing and other fun parts and you might kinda like it.

How does he find this stuff?

Gallery on Goff

Two different takes on Goff’s comments from the gallery. Colin Espiner says they are no gaffe at all, while Audrey Young calls them an extraordinary lapse. Taking Colin first:

Fourth-ranked Labour Cabinet minister Phil Goff has really put the cat amongst the pigeons this morning by admitting he’s interested in the leadership.

Granted Goff didn’t tell us anything we didn’t know already. You’d have to be deaf and blind to not know the Mount Roskill MP has been grooming himself to take over from Helen Clark ever since the pair left university.

Heh harsh, but true.

It’s also true that Goff has never denied he was interested in taking over, either. But I can’t recall him ever being quite so explicit as he was in a partial transcript of an interview he gave to Alt TV, which airs tonight.

Ues it is normally done by nudge nudge wink wink.

Given the opportunity to explain himself to reporters this morning, Goff didn’t resile from his remarks – in fact he said he stood by them. He added that Labour was the underdog going into the election, and that clearly some people felt it was time for a change.

So is Goff saying people think it is tme for a change of government, or a change of leader?

Now, full marks to Goff for honesty, but it’s a well-known political convention that senior ministers don’t upstage their leader by talking about defeat in an election year, particularly when the party is staring down the barrel of a walloping.

And they most certainly don’t start speculating about the process involved in a leadership change, bloodless or not, should that party be defeated.

The question, then, is was Goff simply having an off day or was he being disingenuous? Did he make a faux pas or is this part of a wider game plan on his part?

I’m going with the latter option. Goff has been in politics almost as long as Clark. He knows the score. There is no way he would have made these remarks without an end-game in mind.

That’s a big call, but Colin is right that Goff is no novice. As Foreign Minister Goff is well trained in never saying anything without careful thought. And if you look at the actual video of him on Alt TV, he seems very clear with what he is saying – it was not something “tricked” out of him.

Consider also his track record. Goff was one of the gang of four who went to Clark’s office in 1996 to ask her to step down. He held an infamous barbecue at his house in 1999 to which Clark was not invited and rumours have persisted ever since that it was to canvass leadership options.

I seem to recall some “BBQ at Phil’s place posters going around Wellington at the time!

So what’s Goff’s end game? I’m not for a minute suggesting he would sabotage his party. Nor do I think there is even the remotest chance of a leadership spill before the election.

But it is clearly in his interests for Labour to lose, and lose badly. That would prompt a clear-out of the current leadership and its allies and give him the opportunity and the mandate to rebuild Labour and take it in a new direction.

I think his comments to Alt TV, repeated again this morning, were a reminder to his supporters and the wider public that Phil Goff is still in the frame, biding his time, waiting for his opportunity.

When you are 27% behind in the polls, it is normal and natural to start thinking of post-election positioning. Certainly there will be no moves before the election at all, but the list ranking for Labour will be very interesting to watch.

Now Audrey Young has her take:

Phil Goff has breached political convention and openly admitted that not only might Labour lose the election but, if so, he could be interested in the leadership.

While both those things are widely known, it is not done speak aloud about alternative leadership or admit the possibility of defeat. That is politics 101.

Goff’s offending comments were made a couple weeks ago to Oliver Driver’s niche TV show Let’s be Frank and will screen tonight on Alt TV.

They are an extraordinary lapse for such a seasoned politician and canvassing the issue of defeat and leadership is the last thing the Labour Government needs in Budget week of election year.

Yes, an unusual pre-budget announcement – ‘We might lose and if so I want to be leader’.

He reiterated his comments that Labour could lose. He used a little more discretion today on the leadership question, but still implied it could be up for debate soon: “There is no question about leadership at the moment,” he said. “There is 100 per cent support for Helen Clark and I have been 100 per cent in support of her right through this office.”

The use of the term “at the moment” is very significant. It is the traditional phrase used to send a signal.

After being caught unawares in the stand-up outside the caucus room Goff could be heard having strong words with his press secretary.

Dr Cullen’s office has also been having staffing issues. It can get very stressful there when things look grim.

Greens: Kiwiblog “far right”

Am very amused by the press release just put out by the Green Party. They are promoting their You Tube video which I linked to a few days ago, and have got excited over the fact a user called “JohnKey2008” viewed it.

They end the press release, saying:

The ‘Some things are bigger than politics’ video has been well received by online viewers, and has even featured on the far-right website ‘Kiwi Blog’.

Hmmn, far-right. That will teach me to be nice and promote their video for them. Mind you I also blogged one from the Family Party!

To be fair, 90% of NZ is probably “far right” compared to Comrades Norman, Locke and Bradford.

But Wikipedia says “far right” includes:

the revolutionary right, militant racial supremacists and religious extremists, fascists, neo-fascists, Nazis, and neo-Nazis

So is Jeanette calling me a racial supremacist, a religious extremist or a Nazi?

Scoop interviews Russel Norman

I am enjoying the series of party leaders being interviewed by Gordon Campbell for Scoop. Last week it was Russel Norman. Campbell used to work for the Greens in Parliament, but he was very fair in my opinion:

Campbell: So what do the Greens think is a realistic price per ton for carbon?

Norman: I think $30 per ton is realistic for the moment. But its highly likely it will go up. Its an international market, and there are no guarantees around it.

$30 a tonne is higher (off memory – Treasury website is down) that what the NZ Govt is using. I suspect it will go much much higher.

Campbell: At the moment the cost of the first part of Kyoto 1 is either half a billion or double that. By paying whichever it is, by how much will we reduce global warming?

Norman: Our emissions are obviously a small part of the emissions, so we’re a small player. The true role for New Zsdaland is in contributing to a global system. And even the entire Kyoto system if everyone meets their targets, it won’t make a massive contribution at all. It’s the first step. What makes Kyoto important is establishing a system. And that’s the danger. If Kyoto goes down, we can’t make it better.

In fact even if every single country makes it Kyoto targets, the impact on world temperatures by 2050 will be just 0.07 of a degree.

Campbell: Given the contribution New Zealand taxpayers will in all likelihood be making, you’re saying it won’t affect the rate of global warming…would it say, make a 1 per cent difference ?

Norman: No, it won’t make anything like 1 per cent. We’re only O.2 percent of all emissions globally. The two things that are difficult about this is one, the time lags involved and two, that it requires global co-operation – and the Kyoto system is the first step towards global co-operation.

That means that us making our Kyoto target will by 2050 lead to the average world temperature being 0.00014 of a degree lower than otherwise would be the case. So if the average temperature was going to be 19C, it would instead by 18.99986C. The good people of Naaru will thank us.

This is not a reason to do nothing, but a useful reminder that a scheme without China and India in it will have limited effect.

Campbell: Politically, do you see the difficulty in asking New Zealand families and households to pay half a billion at best into this, or three or four times that figure at worst? For something that will make precious little difference if any to the fate of the planet and whose main effect will be to foster global co-operation?

Norman: Well, I don’t accept your premises. I don’t think New Zealand households should pay. I think the polluters should pay. And the prime polluter that is getting off is the agriculture sector. Dairy should pay its share.

Is there not just a small possibility that those costs might end up being passed on to households? You know with higher petrol prices etc? It is a nice slogan, but not the reality. In some areas like dairy extra costs may not affect prices as there is a global market at play, but in many it will be passed onto households.

Campbell: So from what you’re saying, if the Greens are in government after the next election, it will be asking farmers to pay the full costs of its emissions much sooner ?

Norman: : Yeah…and its actually in a good position to reduce its emissions. The technology already exists. Its just nuts. They’re half of our emissions, and we’re saying the sector doesn’t have to do anything.

Campbell: Excuse me, but the technology to reduce methane emissions doesn’t exist at the moment.

Norman: The technology to reduce nitrous oxide emissions exists at the moment, with nitrification inhibitors.

Campbell: But they don’t work so well on hill country terrain. You can’t extrapolate from the success of nitrification inhibitors in low country farming and say the technology to reduce agricultural emnissions currently exists. It doesn’t deal at all with the methane.

Norman: Yeah. That’s right. What we’re trying to do here is reduce emissions back to 1990 levels. We’re not trying to reduce them to zero. Different components when put together, produce a reduction in greenhouse emissions. Organic farming for instance, produces a lot less greenhouse emissions. A price signal to agriculture will help people to adopt them.

One advantage of being a former Green staffer is Campbell clearly knows his facts in this area, and was able to challenge Russel’s assertions on technology. All too rare in the media.

Campbell: What do you think the main priority for centre left voters will be – to get Labour back, or to ensure the Greens are there to keep them honest?

Norman: I think there’s 10% per cent of the population who are very sympathetic to the Greens, and want to make sure the Greens are there. There’s a significant proportion who will make sure the Greens get back. I think we’ll do better, actually.

This is what amazed me – they are so unambitious in terms of the vote. They have actually been up to 10% in some opinion polls, so should be setting a far bigger target. If they don’t want to be a perpetual doormat for Labour they should be aiming to gain enough votes so that it is impossible to form a centre-left Government without them.

But they seem not to want this. They just want their 6% – 10%, which will mean they can be marginalised again.

Goff confirms his candidacy for Leader post-election

Ben Thomas from NBR reports that Phil Goff has confirmed that he will be a contender for the Labour Party leadership if Helen Clark stands aside, if they lose Government.

Mr Goff made the comments in an interview with Oliver Driver for the Alt TV show Let’s Be Frank two weeks ago. The interview will air tonight at 8.30 pm.

Trade minister Mr Goff said he would look at the leadership in the event of an election loss “If I felt that I was the best one [candidate] in that position and that Helen had stood aside voluntarily.” …

The comments are pragmatic, even banal, and reflect recent polling. But it is rare for a government minister to depart from the strong media lines out of the Beehive that polling under-represents government support. …

When asked earlier in the interview whether he was the leader in waiting Mr Goff said “I don’t know – that’s a decision made by caucus.”

Asked by Mr Driver if leadership was an ambition, Mr Goff responded “It’s not an overwhelming ambition.”

“I like the job I do. I’ve done it for the best part of 25 years. That’s been a very long sentence, that one.”

Did Phil Goff just say something along the lines of just being happy being the MP for Mt Roskill?

Younger than McCain

A very amusing video song of all the things younger than John McCain. They include:

  • GI Joe
  • Barbie
  • The AIr Force
  • The CIA
  • Snow White
  • credit cards
  • string bikinis
  • The Pentagon
  • Disneyland
  • Coke in a can
  • Batman
  • Israel
  • birth control (presumably just the pill)

It’s a bit nasty in one or two parts where they present McCain as confused and doddery, but overall it is an excellent use of humour.

Hat Tip: Whoar

A gondola for Cardrona

Very cool. Permission has been given for a $17 million gondola to the Pisa Range skifield in the Cardrona valley.

I know the Cardrona Valley well as I actually worked on Cardrona skifield during holidays and weekends for a couple of years as a student. Was possibly the best job I ever had as I got to ski every day, and the highlight was the moonlight skiing after hours followed by the most awesome parties in the cafetaria. Most brillant group of people you could work with also.

I haven’t skied in the South Island for a few years. A good reminder to organise something for next year!

The Press on MMP referendum

The Press editorial looks at MMP:

The voting system has had ample time to bed in and voters have had enough experience to make a judgment about its future. This is why a fresh referendum on the electoral system, as advocated by National leader John Key, would be timely.

Many New Zealanders firmly believe that when MMP was introduced there was to be another referendum after the system had been trialled. This is actually not correct, as all that was promised was a review by a parliamentary select committee and this was done.

I am amazed that some people advocate that the people can not be trusted to vote on what electoral system we use. It is the worse sort of elitism.

In some respects the system has been a success. Parliament is far more diverse in terms of minor parties, there are more Maori and female MPs and governments now find it more difficult to ram through unpopular legislation.

And every vote now counts, which is good.

However, these apparently positive features have come at a price. MMP governments have been dependent on deal-making with minnow parties, which wield an influence disproportionate to their size and have the ability to hamstring administrations with their demands and frustrate good governance.

This is the major problem – not that minor parties get representation and influence. But that they have disproportionate influence.

Among the MMP lowlights was the unedifying spectacle in 1996 of New Zealand First conducting a political auction for weeks before opting for National. When that coalition collapsed voters were disenchanted by the unseemly sight of a lame-duck National being propped up by waka-jumpers, such as the former Alliance MP Alamein Kopu.

Today a shorthand for MMP’s failings is NZ First leader Winston Peters holding the coveted post of foreign affairs minister but not being in Cabinet. Nor is Peters subject to ministerial collective responsibility outside his own narrow portfolio area, leaving this country in the astonishing position, one which will grow even more untenable as the election nears, of having a foreign minister able to criticise trade policy.

Indeed. And this sort of stuff does harm NZ. We now have a Foreign Minister who probably can never deal with China again.

Many voters are also concerned that a candidate, especially a sitting MP, can be rejected in a constituency but then slide into Parliament through the back door of the list. The rule that a party that has not won 5 per cent of the eligible party vote can still qualify for list seats on the coat-tails of an electorate winner is another aspect of MMP in need of review.

The issue of List MPs that have been rejected in an electorate is a difficult one. You could ban electorate candidates from being list candidates but that then totally undermines a party’s ability to have all candidates pushing the party vote. Also many candidates stand in a seat they have no chance of winning – is somewhat different to actually being kicked out of a seat you already hold.

The electorate seat threshold for List MPs is a real issue. It does result in highly tactical voting. If one did away with it though, you should lower the 5% threshold to 4% or arguably even lower.

Key’s proposal for an initial referendum in 2011 followed, if MMP in its present form was voted down, by another poll on the alternatives to it, will resonate with the public and should be acted on.

Agreed. A key aspect to be clarified would be how you choose the alternatives for the second referendum. And MMP would need to be an option for that second referendum.

Reason No 7,562 for VSM

Almost every single student at Victoria is forced to fund VUWSA, and the salary of its President – this year Joel Cosgrove.

If you do not approve of the jobs VUWSA does, you can not resign. If you are disgusted with the President – you can not resign. The President andor Exec members can treat students with absolute contempt because their funding is guaranteed.

And we see this in a story on the Salient blog (photos by Sean Gillespie), about the capping ceremony at Victoria. Capping is a big day for most students. They have worked three to five years or more to get their degree. It means a lot to them, and their families. It is not about the Professors or the people on stage – it is for the students – the very ones who fund VUWSA against their will often.

Now this photo is of the stage, and the one standing out is VUWSA President Joel Cosgrove. Now the issue isn’t actually being scruffy, even though I think that is a bit disrespectful. I had the privilege of serving on the Otago University Council and even though I hated suits would wear them when it was appropriate. Also as a Council member I was eligible to wear academic regalia even though I had no degree. I remember having a very cool purple hood. I never actually got around to finishing my degrees so my only graduation ceremonies was as a Council member. Anyway the not wearing regalia is not the issue. Salient notes:

At the parade on Thursday Cosgrove was wearing a suit. So why did he feel the need to wear the t-shirt on Friday’s ceremony? He could have chosen something more appropriate to the occasion, but the university should not have allowed him to sit on the stage at all.

This is a prime example of the complete lack of respect he holds for students.

This is the issue. That is just 100% inappropriate. Graduating students walking along the stage should not be confronted with a “I love my penis” t-shirt. The fact the t-shirt is part of a campaign for a good cause – sexual health checks – is irrelevant. It is about what is appropriate for the occasion. Cosgrove was not there as “Joel Cosgrove”. He was there as President of VUWSA.

Now some may say this is an issue over someone being a dickhead, not about VSM (Voluntary Student Membership). That you get dickheads everywhere. And yes that is true. You get dickheads everywhere and sometimes they get elected as President of VUWSA.

But the nature of compulsory membership does make the problem worse. It increases the chances of getting a student President who, like Joel seemingly, has a contempt for students. When they have no ability to resign in protest or even not join because they think everyone involved is a dickhead – well it is little surprise you get a student president who thinks it is appropriate to wear a penis t-shirt on stage at Capping.

Imagine how pissed off the graduating students are – this is one of the biggest days in their lives – they are walking across the stage receiving their degree and the person who is meant to be their representative, who they have been forced to fund paying him a full-time salary, is sitting them with a “I love my penis” t-shirt on.

It’s a bit of a pity that one of the graduating students didn’t have the presence of mind to grab the microphone as he walked past and say something like “On behalf of most of the students here today, I’d like to just say our President is a douche and we wish he wasn’t here being a douche”. They would have got a standing ovation I reckon.

Auditor-General to investigate Immigration Service

The Government is moving in the right direction with its decision to have the Auditor-General investigate the Immigration Service. This is on top of the SSC, Labour Department and Police investigations.

Few would dispute that the Auditor-General has more independence than an internal inquiry by SSC or Labour. In that regard, asking the AG to investigate is a good thing.

Lockwood Smith makes the point that the AG may not be able to investigate what Ministers were told, and when. Certainly it appears in some areas Ministers were never briefed – namely the non doctorate by LSE. But they were briefed it seems on the Oughton report and the investigation into setting up the Pacific Branch.

Yesterday National’s immigration spokesman, Lockwood Smith, said the Auditor-General’s inquiry had to include ministerial involvement. “David Cunliffe and Clayton Cosgrove were briefed but did nothing.”

But Helen Clark said she was satisfied her ministers had acted appropriately on the information they were given.

With all respect, I’d feel much more reassured if there was some verification of that. The issue is whether the public agree that Ministers acted appropriately – and for that to happen, more information is needed.

However it appears the Auditor-General will get to set his own terms of reference – that is a good thing.

Election year promises

The NZ Herald has counted up the promises made so far this year by both Labour and National, and finds that Labour has already announced $4 billion of spending (some capital) in advance of the budget.

National has only made one major commitment to date – the $1.5 billion for fibre to the home for ultra high speed broadband.

This gives some idea of why National will be in a position to offer larger tax cuts than Labour, without it being more inflationary. The large items for Labour are:

* $750 million in new health spending (includes first year of $160 million announced over weekend for elective services).
* $700 million for Fast Forward Fund investing in food and pastoral sector research.
* $665 million to buy the national rail operations.
* $621 million in total over five years to boost Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade.
* $446 million over four years to boost funding for community organisations.
* $251.9 million in total over four years on revamp of Mt Eden Prison.
* $164.2 million over five years for a cervical cancer immunisation programme.
* $150 million a year on educational changes to keep young people in school or training until they are 18.

Family Party Campaign Video

A two minute video from the Family Party. At times it seems like a subliminal advertisement for Sky City Casino!

For those who have trouble keeping up, the Family Party is the merger of the Destiny NZ party and the more fundamentalist wing of United Future. This is different to the Kiwi Party which was the slightly more moderate Christian wing of United Future.

TV3 to go high def on Sky

Yay Canwest is negotiating to have high definition TV3 available on Sky.

The Government and TVNZ is trying to force everyone to have two set boxes – MySky and Freeview. The problem is they have an inferior product in Freeview.

It is not just about the cost, even though it rankles I am paying through my taxes for two TVNZ channels that the Government refuses to allow me to access without an unnecessary purchase.

But the big issue if convenience. I don’t want to have to flip between two boxes to see what is on TV. I don’t want some shows recorded on one box, and some on another. I want to be able to, in fact, just get one listing of upcoming shows and decide which ones to record.

Watkins on Labour

Dominion Post Political Editor Tracy Watkins looks at Labour’s plight:

And, finally, the desperate knowledge that even hitting the panic button probably won’t work. That, barring the heavens answering their prayers for an election-losing blunder by John Key, the two most likely scenarios now are to lose or to lose badly.

I like that – a choice between losing and losing badly. It is at times like that you start looking forward to the next election, and start debating whether one should not spend all (or too much) of their money on the 2008 campaign, or keep some in the kitty for 2011.

There are early signs that the mood in the caucus is already swinging in that direction: resentment is now brewing over the MPs who have refused to give up their safe seats – George Hawkins and Harry Duynhoven among them – to clear the decks for the generational change that will be forced on Labour in the event of an election defeat.

Both Harry and George have been reselected and control their local electorates. But there will be immense pressure to put the party first and step down, so that some of the new talented MPs such as Lousia Wall have a chance of retaining their place in Parliament.

But the party hierarchy faces a pincer movement as pressure builds on two fronts: the first, the desperation of sitting MPs for winnable list slots; the second, the rising pressure to preserve the best and brightest in Labour’s current ranks and make room for some up-and- comers to slot into Parliament post-election should there be an exodus in the event of a defeat.

Since Miss Clark and Dr Cullen are likely to lead the pack, the subterranean- level jockeying for post- election leadership scenarios may have already begun.

There are whispers that the campaign against Maryan Street, a possible deputy leadership contender from the Left of the party, is already in full swing.

The signs of panic, then, may be in their infancy – but they may also be a sign of things to come.

Street as Deputy Leader would be very resisted by Goff and the more moderate faction. Gof would rightly suspect he would be being setup to be interim Leader, and then rolled by the same forces which rolled Moore in 1993.

So who are the contenders for the three top spots. First Leader:

  1. Phil Goff
  2. David Cunliffe
  3. Shane Jones

Goff has to be favourite at this stage. With Maharey gone and Mallard in the sin bin, there is no credible contender from the left – Goff, Cunliffe and Jones are all from the more moderate side.

Deputy has a range of contenders:

  1. Maryan Street
  2. Clayton Cosgrove
  3. Shane Jones
  4. Chris Carter

Maybe Dyson or Dalziel also, but both would be challenging choices having both been sacked from Cabinet for indiscretions.

And then Finance Spokesperson:

  1. David Cunliffe
  2. Trevor Mallard
  3. Shane Jones

Cunliffe is the logical choice, but logic does not always come into it.

Labour’s MPs

With the polls going seriously South for Labour, there is a focus on who will survive. Ruth Laugeson in the SST takes a look:

Under the poll results Labour would lose 14 of its 50 MPs, many of them list MPs. With the list already carrying several MPs who lost their electorate seats last election, competition for the winnable top spots is likely to be fierce.

MPs who now risk relegation to unwinnable places on the list include former Napier MP Russell Fairbrother, Maori MPs Dave Hereora and Mita Ririnui and newcomers Moana Mackey and Lesley Soper.

Matthew Hooton also looks at their challenge:

Its problem is that if it is down to, say, 36 MPs, its caucus will be dominated by tired old faces lacking strong national appeal.

George Hawkins, Ross Robertson and Harry Duynhoven will all win their seats. You’d probably bet on Cunliffe and Chris Carter saving theirs and there’s a chance Mahara Okeroa, Nanaia Mahuta and Lynne Pillay might also scrape home.

Winnie Laban, Lianne Dalziel, Ruth Dyson and the Progressive Party’s Jim Anderton should all be safe, as should the unpopular Trevor Mallard and Pete Hodgson.

Obviously Clark will win Mt Albert and Cullen will be back on the list. Goff and Annette King are completely safe.

These people would be half Labour’s caucus. Some have been important and successful ministers going all the way back to the days of David Lange and Roger Douglas, but with the best will in the world they can’t be called a team for 2011 or beyond.

Some new talent is on the way. Wellington Central’s Grant Robertson is from the party’s powerful lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, takataapui, fa’afafine and intersex sector, but is just as comfortable at a rugby club.

He should go straight to the front bench. Dunedin South’s Clare Curran enhanced her reputation by the competent way she handled the scandal surrounding her role at the Environment Ministry. Louisa Wall potentially has appeal.

Beyond these three, Labour’s rejuvenation programme has largely failed.

Laugeson also looks at post-election leadership:

Labour leader Helen Clark’s position is considered unassailable but interest is building in a successor if she is defeated in the end of year election.

New frontbencher David Cunliffe, who is seen to have taken a firm grip of the health portfolio, is now strongly in the running alongside Phil Goff.

Goff vs Cunliffe would be interesting. Could Jones also stand?

ACT’s 20 point plan

Yes that is Rodney, with his 15 year old co-star in school pantomime. This sets a new standard for what local MPs will do for their constituents 🙂

ACT have released a 20 point plan on an A4 pledge card. I have to say I think it is very smart work, and a good combination of the skills of Roger Douglas and John Ansell, plus of course Rodney. Sir Roger loves having 10 and 20 point plans for everything, while John’s use of plain language shines through. Each proposal lists other countries where the policy is working well (showing it is practical), spells out the benefits in clear language and estimates what a difference it will make to economic growth and the average weekly pay for a NZer.

I enjoyed that under their privatisation line, the countries they list as successfully implementing that policy are “Practically all except Cuba, Myanmar, North Korea”.

Their full list of proposed policies are:

  1. Government waste. Cut state spending to Australian levels.
  2. Tax. Cut and flatten rates.
  3. Local government. Limit to core activities.
  4. Public service: Close departments we don’t need, Reduce bureaucracy, Return bureaucracy to non-political role, Limit Cabinet to 12 ministers, Limit Parliament to 100 MPs.
  5. Red tape. Get rid of all nutty regulations, Appoint Minister of Regulatory Reform, Pass Regulatory Responsibility Act to set checklist for good lawmaking.
  6. Resource management. Reform the Resource Management Act.
  7. Education. Create competitive market.
  8. Healthcare. Create competitive market.
  9. Accident compensation. Create competitive market — as used to work well here.
  10. Welfare. Create competitive markets for sickness, invalid, and unemployment insurance.
  11. Immigration. Welcome more good quality immigrants.
  12. Labour. Allow freedom of contract to make it easier to trial new workers and replace poor performers.
  13. Privatisation. Sell state businesses where private fi rms can serve customers better.
  14. Infrastructure. Build better networks (e.g. roads, water, electricty). Replace user charges with tolls that reward off-peak use.
  15. Tariffs. Cut remaining tariffs on imports. Strengthen bonds with the US.
  16. Housing. Free up more land for homes.
  17. Law and order: Bring back private prisons _ now best practice overseas, Let private firms free up cops for ‘zero tolerance’ policing, Speed up courts (e.g. night courts) to reduce unfair delays.
  18. Climate change. Adopt saner policies. Low carbon tax better than carbon trading.
  19. Constitutional framework. Strengthen. Adopt Taxpayer Bill of Rights. Pass Regulatory Responsibility Act _ to set checklist for good lawmaking. Return to Privy Council. Hold referendum on MMP voting system.
  20. Families at risk. Appoint mentors to teach parenting and life skills.

Again congrats to ACT for putting up very clear policies, in an well articulated manner. Of course I do not agree with all of them, but there are certainly some that have wide support from the centre right.

An academic survey of bloggers and blog readers

Andrew Cushen, studying for an MA at Auckland University, is doing research on political blogging, and has two surveys as part of that research. Both have been approved by the University Ethics Committee, and responses are confidential.

The first (bloggers) survey is only for those who actually run or post at a blog which has political content. It takes around five minutes and it would be good to have as many bloggers as possible take part as the larger the sample the more robust it is.

The second (blog readers) survey is for anyone who reads political blogs. So as you are reading this, you are reading a political blog and are eligible to take part. Those who are also bloggers are also encouraged to do this survey as well as the first one. You don’t need to even post comments on a blog to take part – just read one or more political blogs. The only criteria is to be aged 16 years or older. This survey is shorter than the bloggers one and takes only a few minutes.

UPDATE: Fixed the link for the first survey so try that again if you are a blogger yourself.

Business Council for Sustainable Development

It is very odd. Many, many members of the Business Council for Sustainable Development have been calling for an opportunity to have input into the revised ETS which the Government is finalising. You see it will be very different to the current one before select committee.

However the NZBCSD is against their own members having further input into the legislation and has attacked National’s call for another round of submissions on the revised scheme. The CEO, Peter Neilsen, is a former Labour Cabinet Minister.

It would be useful for someone to ask the members of the NZBCSD whether or not they agree with the press statement gone out. I daresay very few would. Many of their members have pleaded for input into the revised scheme that the Government and Select Committee are working on. Their members include:

BMW Group New Zealand
BP Oil New Zealand Limited
Contact Energy Limited
Deloitte
Fletcher Building Ltd
Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd
Honda New Zealand Limited
Meridian Energy Ltd
Mighty River Power Limited
Rio Tinto Aluminium (New Zealand) Limited
Shell New Zealand Limited
Solid Energy New Zealand Limited
Toyota New Zealand Limited
Transpower NZ Ltd
TrustPower Limited
Vector Limited

I would be amazed if many, if not all, of those firms do not want the ability to be able to do a submission on the revised scheme. Labour has delayed every sector bar forestry from coming in until 2011 anyway, so an extra three or four months is of minor consequence.

And I may be wrong, but I suspect many do not support the Government making a profit of $22 billion from the scheme, as would currently be the case.

Thanks from the arrested Saudi blogger

Both Poneke and myself received a very unexpected but lovely e-mail from Fouad al-Farhan, the Saudia Arabian blogger who was detained without charge for 137 days, and released finally last month. He thanked us for our support.

The Hive also did a lot and Poneke actually asked MFAT officials whether the NZ Government would take action. Sadly the most they would do is have a “watching brief”. No Right Turn, and no doubt other blogs, also lent their support. Oh yes the EPMU also supported the Government taking action.

While I am sure the blogs had no impact on the Saudi Government (hell we couldn’t even get the NZ Government to stand up for freedom of speech), Fouad says that he found it incredibly heartening to be released and read how people in NZ were advocating on his behalf. Through a NZ professional wrestler who once visited his vlllage to promote Anchor dairy products, he has always wanted to visit NZ.

Extracts from the e-mail:

Dear David, I’m Fouad Al-Farhan. I’m the Saudi Blogger who was arrested 137 days because of his political writing in Saudi Arabia. In the mid 80s when I was a kid, the famous New Zealand wrestler Tony Garea (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tony_Garea) visited our small villiage here in Saudi Arabia (Albaha) on a marketing campaign to promote the famous NZ cheese (Anchor). In that days, wrestling meant a big thing to my people. My village people loved Tony Garea before his visit. When he arrived, they made a big welcome festival for him. They even danced and said poems about his heroism. I still remember parts of it.

I replied, pointing out that many Kiwis would find it very amusing that a professional wrestler promoting cheese was our most successful marketing campaign 🙂

All my friends know about my dream of visiting New Zealand for a lengthy backpacking journey. I’m not sure if it’s going to happen anytime soon. I always have great admiration of the NZ people and the country. My best friend who was lucky to live there for a year keep telling me lovely stories about how peaceful and blessed your land is.

We do forget sometimes how lucky we are.

My government put me in a solitary confinement for 137 days. My cell was 2×3 meters. I never saw anybody except the interrogators once every couple of weeks. The rest of the days I was alone. They didn’t allow me to watch T.V, listen to radio, read any books or magazine or newspaper. I was not allowed to have a pen and a paper to write. I never saw the sun. I was completely cut off the world. All I had is our holy book (Quran) and prayer rug. So, I had a lot of time to think about my life. One of things that always came on mind in prison was New Zealand and my dream backpacking journey.

I can think of few things worse than solitary confinement. Hell I go crazy if I have nothing to do for even an hour on a plane. Five months with no Internet, no books, no music, no TV, and most of all no human contact would be unbearable.

I didn’t know that my case has reached NZ. I didn’t know that someone there in that beloved land thought, wrote, and cared about me. Internet is just great and you people deserve the land you love in. Your support and other NZ citizens like (http://poneke.wordpress.com) of my case meant a lot to me. It touched my heart deeply because I already have positive feelings toward your country and people since my childhood.

As I said, many NZ bloggers and others like the EPMU raised their voice in support. Getting this feedback from Faoud is a good reminder that we should be vocal more often.

I loved Tony Garea because my father did. I loved your country because of my best friend stories about it. These feelings have increased because of your support. I just can’t thank you enough for your support. It meant a lot to me more than you can imagine. Fouad Al-Farhan

Hopefully one day Fouad will be able to visit New Zealand. I suspect he will have no shortage of people willing to host him or show him around.

Armstrong on Immigration Service

John Armstrong makes the case for a commission of inquiry into the Immigration Service.

Just how bad do things have to get before the Government sets up a full commission of inquiry to independently investigate the mounting allegations of corruption in the Immigration Service?

Despite growing calls for such an inquiry with judicial powers to summon witnesses, the answer is a lot worse yet.

Remember that none of us at all would have any idea about all this, if it were not for some good journalism. For those who missed it, TVNZ also had some further revelations about a $500,000 contract that wasn’t put out to tender and conflicts of interest with staff.

It is understood the Prime Minister, who returned from overseas yesterday, is satisfied that the three separate investigations now being conducted by the Department of Labour, the police and the State Services Commission are sufficient to reassure the public the allegations are being taken extremely seriously.

But the Government is at risk of being tainted as more light is shed on Thompson’s tenure and whether ministers knew what was allegedly going on. It is consequently putting its faith in the department’s recently appointed chief executive, Christopher Blake, wielding his authority and cleaning up the mess in its immigration branch without having to resort to an independent inquiry.

With no disrespect to Mr Blake, but the last time the Department of Labour inquired into NZIS, it was the “lies in unison” scandal and that report was seen as a near total whitewash – the Ombudsman then used his rarely used powers to investigate – uncovering a very different story.

In another Herald story, Audrey Young reveals that a recruitment agency in 2004 is responsible for finding out that Mary-Anne Thompson did not have a PhD, when she applied for DPMC Chief Executive.

It appears she withdrew her application after the then State Services Commission, Michael Wintringham, discussed the issue with her.

Now there are two issues in regard to what Wintringham did. The first is whether he should have ruled her ineligible for any further senior state sector roles, and informed Ministers at the time. Now one can debate whether or not he was right to do nothing – I happen to think he was very wrong, as clearly history has shown us.

But there is another bigger issue regarding Wintringham. While it was his call as to how to handle it at the time, he did have a legal obligation to record in Thompson’s personnel file the issue of the fake doctorate. Anyone with even a minor involvement in HR knows you record absolutely everything as files notes in someone’s file. It would be beyond belief if the most senior CEO in the public sector knew of a fake qualification, and did not record it in her file. If he failed to do so, then the SSC has failed completely as a role model for the public sector. If he did do so, then questions should be asked as to whether the current Commissioner checked Thompson’s file when the allegations regarding her conduct with the Immigration Service became public.

So MPs and journalists should ask whether Wintringham made a file note or not. This is separate to the issue of whether he alerted anyone. The latter issue was within his discretion (even though he used it badly), but if he failed to make a file note, then that is a major credibility issue for the SSC.

Bullshit

That’s my generous term for the Government’s claim that if one doesn’t rush the ETS into law in June, it increase our emissions and cost us more.

The reason it is bullshit is because Labour itself had already announced that the transport sector would not come into the scheme until 2011 instead of 2009. No sector (except forestry which soaks up emissions, no produces them) is in before 2011 now, so taking 3 to 4 more months to get the scheme right has almost no downside.

The hypocrisy of Labour delaying the transport sector coming into the scheme by two years, and then complaining about a delay of just a few months, is as usual quite large.

It is interesting to look at the Government’s resonse to Key’s six areas of concern:

Key: The ETS should be fiscally neutral rather than providing billions of dollars in windfall gains to the government accounts at the expense of businesses and consumers. National does not think it is responsible for the Government to use green initiatives to swell the Crown coffers at the expense of Kiwis’ wallets.
Parker: The ETS would not result in a surplus of credits for the Government in the short term, and any surplus that might result later depends on New Zealand’s target under future international agreements. The five-yearly reviews of the scheme are the way to take account of that.

First of all, note the weasel words – in the short term. That may just means the first couple of years. Now government officials have admitted a profit for the Government of up to $22 billion. There is no requirement in the current law for this to be refunded to consumers and businesses. Now if anyone really believes the Government would voluntarily reduce the amount of money the scheme makes, then I have a bridge they may wish to buy.

After all, remember how it has taken nine years to get tax cuts – and that has been with some of the highest surpluses in the world.

Key: The ETS should encourage the use of technologies that improve efficiency and reduce emissions intensity, rather than encourage an exodus of industries and their skilled staff to other countries.
Parker: The select committee and the Government are already considering intensity-based allocation within a cap.

Now this is absolute proof positive that any revised bill needs to be opened up to a second round of submissions. A change to intensity based allocations would be a major major change, and the impact on stakeholders would be very different to the current proposed law. It would be economic vandalism to make such major changes without any ability to have comment and input on the new model.

Green Party Campaign Video

The Green Party have released a campaign video via You Tube. It’s not bad with a good message for them – but perhaps slightly too earnest. Good to see a party actually producing a video advertisement for Internet and viral campaigning.

Key on Emissions Trading Scheme

John Key devoted most of his speech at National’s LNI conference today to the legislation setting up an Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS). He made very clear on numerous occassions that he supports an ETS as the best response to the challenges of climate change:

It is to that end that we consider a well-designed, carefully balanced Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) to be the best tool available for efficiently reducing emissions across the economy.

He then pointed out some issues with the current legislation:

  • Submitters on the bill have had their speaking time cut drastically short.
  • There’s been little transparency about the effects the ETS will have on already struggling Kiwi households.
  • Officials have admitted that the Government will profit by between $6 billion and $22 billion from the tendering of emissions permits.
  • No clear analysis of exactly how much the scheme will reduce emissions, and
  • The scheme has been subject to last-minute changes, including the decision to push out the date for inclusion of the transport sector. This decision has flow-on effects that the Select Committee has been given no opportunity to analyse.

Now this legislation is incredibly complex. It took years for the EU to get their scheme worked out. In fact it is so complex that a lobbyist involved with the scheme remarked to me he figured there were only three MPs in Parliament who truly understood it. They were Jeanette Fitzsimons, Michael Cullen and Nick Smith. I inquired as to their view of the understanding of the Minister on charge of the legislation, David Parker, and they were adamant he is truly out of his depth. But they reassured me this was not a problem as he has been cut out of the decision making loop on it.

Labour has been racing towards a political deadline – the 2008 election – and has been prepared to cut corners to get there.

National is not prepared to cut those corners. Not when the financial security of Kiwis is at risk. Not when getting this wrong means exporting jobs, ratcheting up inflation, and viciously squeezing household budgets.

We believe that the current rushed timetable for the design of the ETS and the Select Committee process is reckless, given the importance of the issue. National thinks that this process, left unchecked, is likely to lead to an ETS that will meet neither New Zealand’s economic needs nor our environmental obligations. In particular, it could well have negative and unintended consequences.

So today, I am calling for a delay in the passage of this legislation.

The fact there is an election later this year is no reason to rush the scheme into law. Hell Labour signed up to Kyoto in 2000 and have had eight years to get policy on place. Just because they left it so long is no reason to sacrifice good decision making in a mad rush. And look at the last law pushed through with lots of last minute changes – the Electoral Finance Act.

Now some will say that Key is being populist or playing it safe by calling for a delay. Far from it – his move is in face very much against what is best for him politically. Assuming National wins the election, he will have prime responsibility for getting an ETS into law as soon as possible, and in a way which actually will reduce emissions but not drive industry offshore. There is no way the Greens and environment groups would allow National to do nothing, even if they wanted to.

It would in fact have been politically far easier to let the hapless David Parker rush through the legislation in June and July, and then Key could just blame the previous Government for it, as problems emerged. But by having it pass when he is Prime Minister, Key will be responsible for its implementation.

Let me state clearly: National has not given up on this legislation. We are committed to a well-considered, carefully balanced Emissions Trading Scheme for New Zealand.  We believe this bill can be amended and progressed to that end, and we believe it can be done in a timely fashion.  But the New Zealand Parliament must take the time needed to get it right. New Zealanders’ livelihoods depend on us taking that time.

I have no doubt there will be some mindless abuse which will probably try to paint this as something it is not. But talk to anyone involved with this legislation and you would know the folly of trying to have it reported back to Parliament next month. It is the biggest change to the NZ tax system in 20 years. It is incredibly complex and the current bill will have to be so amended that it is only common sense to allow affected parties a chance to resubmit on the amended law.

National believes that getting it right means adhering to the following principles:

  1. The ETS must strike a balance between New Zealand’s environmental and economic interests. It should not attempt to make New Zealand a world leader on climate change. Kiwis simply can’t afford to pay the price for that particular experiment.
  2. The ETS should be fiscally neutral rather than providing billions of dollars in windfall gains to the government accounts at the expense of businesses and consumers.  National does not think it’s responsible for government to use green initiatives to pad the Crown coffers while thinning out Kiwis’ wallets.
  3. The ETS should be as closely aligned as possible with the planned Australian ETS, with common compliance regimes and tradability.  In my second speech as National Party Leader, I called for close co-operation with our biggest trading partner on this issue, and I continue to call for it.  Given the Australian timetable for developing an ETS, I believe it’s still possible.
  4. The ETS should encourage the use of technologies that improve efficiency and reduce emissions intensity, rather than encourage an exodus of industries and their skilled staff to other countries.
  5. The ETS needs to recognise the importance of small and medium enterprise to New Zealand and not discriminate against them in allocating emission permits.
  6. The ETS should have the flexibility to respond to progress in international negotiations rather than setting a rigid schedule. This way, industry obligations can be kept in line with those of foreign competitors.

I think No 2 and No 3 are key. The ETS should not be a get rich scheme for Dr Cullen at the expense of consumers. But having it tied into the scheme of our largest trading partner is quite vital. No 5 is also important – big businesses should not get an unfair advantage over smaller businesses with the allocation of permits.

Key also touches on the proposed ban on new thermal power, and that as 75% of new power generation under Labour has been thermal, it is dangerous to assume one can suddenly go to 0% thermal for further generation. With the massive delays in getting RMA consent for renewable power projects, there would be a real risk of NZ having insufficient power in the future. The best thing one could do for the environment would be to reform the RMA so one can get renewable power projects built more easily. Until you do that, you can’t ban more thermal.

And finally Key touched on the biofuels legislation, which the Parliamentary Commission for the Environment said should be voted down. Key says:

The Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment has spoken out against the Biofuels Bill, saying it will damage our clean, green image.

National is opposed to a mandatory biofuels obligation until there is a sustainability standard. This standard needs to deal with the lifecycle emissions savings, the effects on the food supply, and the biodiversity impacts.

New Zealanders want to ensure that their efforts to tackle climate change are doing more good than harm. Paying an extra 7 cents a litre for a flawed biofuels policy is not the way forward.  So National will not support the Biofuels Bill in its current form.

Even the Greens say the biofuels bill should not pass in its current form.

So a key speech on environmental issues, and good to see a commitment to getting the policy right, even though it would be politically expedient to let Labour pass a flawed ETS and then just blame them when it goes wrong.