Calculating Tax Cuts

The Deloitte team who were behind me in the lockup gave me a copy for the blog of their Deloitte Tax Cut Calculator (now on their website) which is an excel spreadsheet.

It not only shows you how much your tax will be in Oct 2008, April 2010 and April 2011 but also what the same tax would be in Australia.

They have also calculated how much you need to earn to be paying less tax in NZ than Australia. It used to be $1,571,922 but now life gets better in NZ at merely $1,284,992.

The Visible Hand in Economics has also links to three other calculators

  1. Infometrics which gives you the annual and weekly reduction in tax and percentages
  2. Labour, which includes WFF for the breeders šŸ™‚
  3. NZIER which has an Excel spreadsheet

Worth remembering that the annual figure for Oct 2008 will be half that, as it only applies for half the year.

NZIER helpfully also shows you what your tax would have been in 2000 in both NZ and Australia. So if you are on $100,000 you would have been paying the same tax in 2000 ($22,057 in NZ and $22,446 in Australia). In 2010 it will be $30,588 and $26,569 respectively. This assumes 3% wage growth.

Matt Nolan at TVHE also looks at the impact of both tax cuts and huge spending increases on inflation. He thinks it is possible inflation may hit 5%, which would suggest interest rates staying high for a while yet.

Dim-Post on Pollsters

I’ve quoted the Dim-Post on other topics, so really can’t ignore this one!

State funded concubines for polling company directors could be the crucial issue that decides this years election according to a new poll commissioned by the Dim-Post.

The poll shows that just under 75% of those questioned rated the issue of government funded sex-slaves for persons conducting opinion polls as more important than taxation, health-care or environmental issues.

National leader John Key recently reversed Nationals longstanding policy in this area when he announced details of his Nubile Kiwi Enslavement Legislation in a luncheon speech to a consortium of land-mine manufacturers. …

Details of National’s proposed policy are still vague but information from party insiders suggest that once made law the legislation will allow polling company owners and any other marketing company director who conducts political research to roam the streets naked and shoot citizens with tasers before transporting them back to their business or residence for a lifetime of sexual bondage.

Finance Minister Michael Cullen has long resisted supplying electoral researchers with their own private harems citing human rights issues and the potential inflationary effect on the economy but voters now look set to punish his party for his reluctance to address their concerns.

Heh.

McCain on Saturday Night Live

McCain is very good as he urges Democrats to not rush their decision, how cool it would be to leave their convention still not knowing who their candidate will be, and even saying in the interests of fairness he would be agreeable to have both Obama and Clinton on the ballot šŸ™‚

Reactions to Broadband funding

Peter Griffin blogs:

All up the Government has committed around $500 million today to broadband infrastructure investment most of it to be distributed in the same way past funding in this area has – through contestable grants and through direct funding of hospitals, schools and government departments.

It’s certainly not visionary, ambitious. That level of funding isn’t going to change the broadband landscape. It is incremental change that runs the risk of spawning numerous projects that overlap and don’t share a common outcome. …

Labour never indicated it would try to outspent National on broadband, but surely the government could have come up with something more inspiring to convince us that growth and innovation is actually valued in this country.

Ernie Newman from TUANZ:

The highlight is expenditure of $325 million over five years in the framework of a Broadband Investment Fund based on contestable grants available to any legal entity including local government, power and phone companies, and community groups.

There will be quite a complex application process with a gap of almost year from the time an applicant submits an EoI in August, until the result is known in June 2009. The process for a group wanting to lodge an application embraces applicant support, an EoI, an application, analysis and recommendation within the MED, a recommendation by a group of officials, sign-off by the CEO of the MED, and final sign off by Cabinet. It sounds very much like the ā€œBroadband Challenge of old with significantly more money, but with bit more bureaucracy tacked on.

The handouts included a flow-chart to show how decisions would be made on funding. I joked to Ernie that any process which needs a flow-chart to explain it is too complex!

There’s also $15 million in there as capital expenditure towards a new trans Tasman cable. On its own that would get the cable about to Somes Island, but obviously it will be leveraged by private sector investment. Its a good signal.

The investment in international connectivity is welcome.

On the positive side, the fact that money has been allocated is a positive sign. What we have now is cross-parliamentary support in concept for significant public money to be spent on telecommunications infrastructure. That is a big breakthrough from a couple of years ago.

But to be honest, I feel a bit underwhelmed. The amount of money is pretty sparse and I guess I was anticipating more. The administrative processes are complex and slow – I foresee rosy times for the burgeoning Consultation Industry with lots people huddled in interminable meetings. By the time the consultation, evaluation and analysis is done, hamlet by hamlet, will the amount of money left to dig trenches through the streets of Waitotara cut the mustard.

My reaction is similar to Ernie’s. I was expecting more vision and more funding. It’s not about this being something “nice” but about the environmental and economic benefits we can gain from widespread fibre deployment.

InternetNZ says:

InternetNZ Executive Director Keith Davidson welcomes any increase in public expenditure on broadband, which he describes as critical infrastructure and essential for ongoing economic growth. The announcement confirms that the debate has moved to decisions on ā€œwhenā€ rather than ā€œifā€ better broadband is required

ā€œA clear difference has emerged between Labour and National as to how they are approaching this policy question, in terms of amounts to invest, pace of rollout and methods of public engagement. Different levels of detail are also available,ā€ says Davidson.

Budget Roundup

First the Herald:

A tax cut law is expected to pass through Parliament today under urgency – with the support of National. …

Dr Cullen delivered a fiscally tight Budget with a cash deficit of $3.5 billion and forecasts of similar amounts over the next four years, making it difficult for National to say “me too” to Labour’s policies.

It is likely to be squeezed into identifying existing policies it would cut or borrow more.

Mr Key said National would “reprioritise”, and acknowledged it would need to spell out in an alternative Budget before the election which of Labour’s policies it would scrap.

“It’s not a question of whether spending is ‘nice’. Most Government expenditure is ‘nice’,” Mr Key said.

“There are certain times when it becomes luxury, and we think that at a time when New Zealanders are struggling, the number one priority is to put money in the pockets of hard-working New Zealanders and we are prepared to prioritise that over other initiatives.”

Mr Key said National would probably wait until the start of the election campaign before unveiling its own economic package.

Simon Collins looks at the numbers:

In dollar terms, the tax cuts get bigger as your income rises – from $22 a week at $20,000 a year to $32 a week at around $50,000 and a maximum cut of $55 a week at $80,000 by 2011.

But in percentage terms, the biggest cuts are at the bottom – 5.7 per cent at $20,000, 3.3 per cent at $50,000 and 3.6 per cent at $80,000.

I agree it is the percentage changes which are most important. Tax cuts will always deliver more to those who pay more tax in absolute terms. The irony is that the left have spent 15 years attacking that concept and arguing that tax cuts favour the rich as they always get more tax back from them.

John Armstrong sees the budget as giving Labour breathing space:

The last waltz on the Titanic? Michael Cullen’s ninth, probably final and most political Budget yet will not on its own save Labour’s neck.

But then it was not expected to do so. Labour has simply arrived at the tax cut party too late – and probably with too little. But the Budget will have done its job if it keeps Labour in contention until the start of the election campaign, when the real business begins.

By his own admission, Cullen has reached the limits of his “comfort zone”. He has risked sacrificing his longstanding reputation for fiscal rectitude in order to get a short-term political payoff. The net result is someone on the average wage of $45,000 gets an extra $16 a week from October. Hardly a sum to provoke mass rejoicing in the streets.

Brian Fallow notes the empty piggy bank:

Michael Cullen has emptied the piggy-bank in a bid to mitigate the severity of the economic slowdown.

After running Budget surpluses in the range of 3 to 6 per cent of gross domestic product during the good times of the past six years, he has now slashed them to well under 1 per cent over the next four years.

He has in fact cut them so much he needs to borrow money to put into his Cullen Fund. Anyone else doing that would be howled down. It is indeed a “poison pill” budget like in 1990 designed to force the next Government to run a deficit or cut spending.

Vernon Small labels the budget brave and possibly reckless:

That is one brave –Ā as in almost reckless –Ā Budget. …

The plan is to leave precious little room for National to move unless it wants to admit to specific service cuts or borrow-up large. I find it hard to believe that, back in Government, Labour would be able to stick to that spending track, given $750 million a year is already earmarked for health and there are other big wage bills in the public sector.

Even if Labour wins, this will be Cullen’s last budget. His successor will find this an absolute hospital pass, with basically no major new initiatives possible for half a decade.

The Press labels it not a winner:

The cuts are the first that Cullen has made as Minister of Finance despite the fact that the country has run large Budget surpluses for more than four years. They do not begin to come into effect until October this year. Many critics look enviously across the Tasman and see an economy similar to New Zealand’s in many respects, where income-earners have just had a Budget that has given them tax cuts for the fifth year in succession. Many will say the cuts now are too little and too late.

This Budget is not an obvious election winner. But now that Cullen has finally laid his tax-relief cards on the table, the onus is sharply on the National leader, John Key, to spell out what he will do if he is elected to office. Now, or very soon, Key must state clearly not only the size of any tax cuts he will make but also, and most crucially, how they will be paid for. Empty points-scoring in this debate is no longer enough.

As with previous elections, National has said they will present a fully costed budget making clear what spending they will or will not commit to.

The Dom Post is similar:

Finance Minister Michael Cullen has screwed up his courage, abandoned the prejudices of a political lifetime and pushed all his chips into the middle, The Dominion Post writes.

The tax cuts unveiled in yesterday’s Budget represent a desperate last-ditch bid by Labour to recapture voters’ attention. They go against almost everything Dr Cullen has preached in his eight-and-a-half years in charge of the country’s finances.

To fund the $10.6 billion cost of the threshold changes over the next four years he is dramatically reducing the size of the buffer he has previously maintained between government expenses and revenue, increasing debt and reducing the provision for new spending in future Budgets by $250 million a year to $1.75 billion.

Yep, all stuff which Dr Cullen has attacked in the past.

And the NZ Herald:

The revenue he has harvested from rising incomes has been a major contributor to the surpluses that will drop now to a level designed to leave little to spare for the party in power next year. The cash balance will be in deficit after the required $2 billion contribution to the pension fund.

Again Dr Cullen will be borrowing money to invest it in the Cullen Fund. And this will remain the case until 2016!

Dr Cullen can point to nine consecutive years of growth, a record no other Finance Minister has enjoyed in his lifetime, but he would be hard pressed to explain how excess taxation contributed to it.

The money rightly belonged to the overtaxed all along. If they are less than grateful for relief that will come just weeks before the likely election date, they can be forgiven. Dr Cullen says Budgets can lose elections but not win them. The best this one can do for his Government is no further harm.

Fran O’Sullivan looks at borrowing:

Gross debt will expand in nominal terms. But as a percentage of GDP it will still trend around 20 per cent, if GDP grows at the 1.5 per cent rate Treasury has forecast for 2008-09. This could be a very big “if” indeed if the international economic climate gets worse.

Clearly if the boot had been on the other foot, Cullen would have been railing against the imprudent, irresponsible behaviour of a National government intent on bribing voters with their own money to win an election.

Exactly

Whichever party forms a government after this year’s election, it will still be faced with the likely need to reprioritise spending or take on more debt to underpin the tax-cutting programme – at least in the short term, until the dynamic effects of personal tax cuts kick into gear and push the cycle up again.

There will be spending cuts regardless of who is in office. The only difference is Labour calls them “reprioritisation”.

The ten minute Kahui acquittal

Well it was a six week trial and it took the jury only ten minutes to find Chris Kahui not guilty.

I am not surprised. Even before the trial started the case seemed to lack the beyond reasonable doubt element to it.

And informed sources who actually sat through the entire six weeks were adamant the verdict would be not guilty.

The Police have made it clear they will not be charging anyone else, so the sad thing is the killer of the twins has got away with it – whoever they may be.

Having a suspicious nature, and remembering how the family refused to co-operate with the Police, I do wonder whether there was a deliberate strategy to have both parents blame each other – knowing that would generate reasonable doubt for both.

Happy Birthday Mr Prime Minister

He’s spent it all!

Dr Cullen’s ninth and probably final budget is a cunning political device but economically risky and most of all incredibly hypocritical.

The entire budget is designed for one and one purpose only – to try and stuff over National and make it impossible for them to offer larger tax cuts without spending cuts.

Imagine the outcry from Dr Cullen and the left if Bill English as Minister of Finance did the following:

  1. Run a cash deficit of $13.7 billion over four years to fund $10.6 billion of tax cuts
  2. Ran the OBEGAL operating surplus so low that it will not be large enough to fund the Cullen Fund contributions until 2016
  3. Reduced the contingency expenditure provision by $2.5 billion over four years (or $250 million a year)

You would have the left shouting from the treetops that Bill English is borrowing to fund tax cuts, that pensioners should start hoarding catfood because National is planning to starve the Cullen Fund of money, and that reducing contingency expenditure is slashing spending on health and education.

I got to ask Dr Cullen a question on how he would answer the challenge that he is borrowing to fund tax cuts, and he answered that he isn’t, that he is borrowing to fund capital investment.

The irony is that I didn’t agree with the premise of my question – I was in fact quoting what Labour have said for the past few years about borrowing and tax cuts, and the further irony is that Dr Cullen’s response was the argument I have made in the past that borrowing is okay if for capital, not operating expenditure.

As I said above, this budget exists for one reason only – to try and stuff over National. The logical inconsistency of saying we can’t afford tax cuts when the surplus is close to $10 billion, and then delivering tax cuts when the surplus has basically shrunk to zero is staggering.

OBEGAL, the operating balance or surplus after one off gains and losses is forecast to be just $1.0b next year, reducing to $200 million in 2011/12. That is well below a prudent level – I have generally maintained the OBEGAL should be enough to meet the Cullen Fund contribution around $2 billion) and around $1 billion on top of that. So this level of surplus is around $2 billion to $3 billion below that. Cullen has gone from hoarding all the money to spending it all.

Core crown expenditure is forecast to expand from $54 billion last year to a whopping $70 billion in 2012.

Core crown revenue was $58.4 billion last year. The tax cuts sees it stay at around $62 billion this year and next year but then increasing to $69 billion in 2012. So Cullen has core corwn expenditure greater than core crown income for the first time since the last Labour Government. This is a potential repeat of 1990 in terms of leaving the next Government with a deficit.

Net core Crown debt is forecast to go from $1.8 billion to $13.2 billion.

Dr Cullen could hardly contain his glee at having spent everything. Basically the fiscal margin for the next five to six years is close to zero. A further downturn and you have have significant problems. He has happily thrown away his previous fiscal discipline.

So this will make it tougher for National. they certainly will be able to deliver tax cuts larger than these ones, but not massively larger unless they get more rigorous with saying no to various spending proposals. There are not a lot of easy options thanks to Dr Cullen’s empyting or the larder. If by some chance Labour do get re-elected Dr Cullen’s successor will be equally as grumpy with him as Bill English might be – don’t expect any Government can deliver any significant new spending initiatives in the next few years.

I don’t think it is entirely a bad thing that National may have to say no to some more of Labour’s spending. Yes there is a political risk in doing so, but it is at times of economic hardship that people expect the Government to manage its spending more carefully – just as households do. And National certainly has some capital in terms of a lead in the polls that it can use up.

The Tax Cuts

The level of tax cuts is in line with what I expected. If they were part of a continuing series of tax cuts over the last few years, they would probably meet expectations. But by having given nothing back (to the 80% who don’t have Working For Families) for eight years, people will find it really doesn’t even compensate for fiscal drag.

Dr Cullen has spent so much everywhere else that all he has been able to do is drop the 15% tax rate to 12.5%, and move the thresholds up by a few thousand a year.

From 1 Oct 2008 it will be 12.5% on the 1st $14,000 of income, then 21% to $40,000, 33% to $70,000 and 39% over that.

On 1 April 2010 the thresholds move to $17,500, $40,000 and $75,000 respectively.

And on 1 April 2011 they move to $20,000, $42,500 and $80,000.

The table below shows what we currently pay in tax, and what under this plan it will be from now until 2011. The percentage shown is the average tax rate on that income.

Next I look at what the extra income will be for people

So someone working part-time on $10,000 is $280 a year better off or $5.40 a week. Go to near the average wage of $40,000 and they are $860 a year better off or $16.50 a week. By 2011 that will be $1,370 better off or $26.27 a week.

But what has been bracket creep since 2000? Someone on the average wage in 2000 earnt $33,968 and paid tax of $6,623 which is an average tax rate of 19.5%. In 2007 their earnings were $44,123 with tax of $9,430 which is an average tax rate of 21.4%.

Now assume by 2011/12 the average wage will be $50,000 (I suspect it will be more than that). Even under these tax cuts the tax will be $9,700 which is 19.4%. In other words for someone on the average wage, this merely restores you to where you would be without bracket creep.

Now let us look at how we will compare to Australia

So even after these tax cuts are implemented, someone in Australia on $50,000 will pay $2,800 less tax which is $54 a week less. You would pay $6,900 tax in Australia or $9,700 tax in New Zealand. Someone on just above the minimum wage at $30,000 will still pay twice as much tax in NZ – $3,100 compared to $1,500.

So it’s not a bad start. It is reasaonably well balanced, but it is still quite modest in comparison to Australia. Also the proportion of tax paid in the year to March 2009 by those rich pricks earning over $60,000 increases to 55%. Yes the top 15% pay 55% of the tax, and the bottom 15% pay 1%. Now of course the top earners will always pay more, but with wages higher and tax less in Australia, the incentives to move remain strong.

The real challenge is to deliver tax cuts which not only give people some more of their money back, but also are designed to boost economic growth. It is by boosting economic growth that one can really close the gap.

Budget Lockup

Like last year, I am in the budget lockup. At 2 pm I will be able to start posting again, but only on issues Dr Cullen has covered in his speech as he reads it.

Roger Nome, Sonic and Ghost Who Walks are appointed Acting Moderators until then.

Continue reading »

Pacific Island Immigration

There has been a lot of debate about a Massey University study by Greg Clydesdale into Pacific Island achievement and immigration. The Dom Post reports on the study.

The Herald also reports on the backlash from “political correctness bullies”. It has been condemned by Race Relations Commissioner Joris de Bres, despite admitting he had not read it. The same goes for Labour MP Su’a WIlliam Sio who calls the paper disturbing despite also not having read the study.

Now I haven’t read the report myself (but have asked for a copy so I can comment later in more detail), but will make the assertion that there is nothing new about the fact that in areas of education, employment and crime etc Pacific Islanders do not perform as well as the rest of the population. This is not generally disputed.

But what is vital is that one does not just see the hundreds of thousands of Pacific Islanders in NZ just as part of a group. The majority of Pacific Islanders make a positive contribution to New Zealand.

Now how does this tie into immigration policy? Should there be some discrimination against Pacific Islanders because on average they do not achieve as well as other NZers? Absolutely not. I am a strong supporter of a colour blind and country blind immigration policy. We should have objective criteria which intending migrants should meet, and I don’t care if they come from China, the UK or Tonga.

But here is the problem, or the challenge. We actually have specific quotas for immigrants from the Pacific. Now there are public policy reasons for this which I will touch on later, but the fact these quotas exist is why the issue of under-achievement as a group is legitimate to look at.

If we had a truly colour blind and country blind immigration policy where individuals are all treated the same, then the nationality of the applicant should be irrelevant. Every applicant should be treated as an individual, not as a member of a “group”.

But as I said, we do have some specific quotas for Pacific Islanders where applications are decided by random ballot. As far as I can tell they are a Samoan quota of 1,100 a year, a Kiribati quota of 75, Tuvalu 75, Fiji 250Ā  and Tonga 250 for a total of 1,750.

There may be family members on top of that as permanent and long-term arrivals in the last year from Samoa was 1,482 and 773 for Tonga. But that may be family reunifications or other factors.

Now as I said above there are some public policy reasons for having special PI quotas – certainly in the case of Samoa. In 1982 the Privy Council ruled all Samoans are entitled to NZ citizenship. The Government passed the Citizenship (Western Samoa) Act 1982 to over-turn that ruling and restrict citizenship to those already lawfully in NZ. As “compensation” for doing so a Samoan quota was agreed to as part of a Treaty of Friendship. We are morally bound to keep our word under that Treaty.

The other Pacific quotas can be justified on public policy grounds also – as the “big brother” to the South Pacific, it is argued we should help out our small neighbours, and we do with most aid going there, and also the special immigration quotas.

The issue is though, that because these special country quotas exist, it is legitimate to debate the impact of immigration from those countries. I do not believe it is particularly valid to question the impact of immigration from China (for example) because no-one from China gets in purely because they are Chinese. They get in because they have met the same objective test as everyone else in the world wanting to come here. Well that, or they were mates with Taito Philip Field.

Now as I said there are valid public policy reasons to have special quotas for Samoa (beyond doubt – that is an obligation) and other Pacific countries. This Wikipedia article lists the large number of Samoan NZers who are “notable” for their contribution, and NZ should in my opinion do its bit to help our Pacific neighbours.

But the existence of those special quotas means it is legitimate to look at issues such as under-achievement in employment, education and crime for migrants from those countries. A sensible debate can be held on whether the quotas are set at the right level. Even in the case of Samoa the quota of 1,100 is a maximum and applicants still need to meet other criteria like having a job offer. The Government relaxed those criteria in 2004 as not enough applicants were being accepted. It is in no way racist or wrong to debate whether or not that was a good idea, and whether the level of quotas is too high, too low or about right.

Dom Post on Budget

The Dom Post has some advice for Dr Cullen:

The grim reality facing Dr Cullen, however, is that unless today’s Budget contains a circuit-breaker he and his ministerial colleagues can start packing up their ministerial offices …

Prime Minister Helen Clark says the Fairfax poll, showing Labour 27 points behind National, is “totally out of line”. She is wrong. It is a reputable, scientific poll that continues a trend showing voters have become increasingly disenchanted with a Government that preaches to them about what they can eat and how they should discipline their children, but does not trust them to spend their own money.

So very very true. Families are told the Government does not trust them to feed their kids okay, does not trust them to be good parents and does not trust them to spend their own money.

Three years ago Dr Cullen reluctantly agreed to index tax thresholds to the rate of inflation to stop bracket creep shifting more and more middle-income earners into the top tax bracket, but he cancelled what became derisively known as the “chewing gum” tax cuts when the public showed insufficient gratitude.

Today he will again announce cuts, almost certainly larger than those previously promised, but with National leader John Key having cleverly raised the bar by suggesting a National government would cut taxes by more than $50 a week, the smaller cuts that have been signalled will not meet public expectations.

I commented to a journalist yesterday that John’s casual reference to $50 a week was either calculated genius or thinking aloud, but which ever one it was it has been devastating for Labour in terms of expectations.

Dr Cullen can be expected to point out that larger cuts would increase inflation, pushing up interest rates. But that is not an insurmountable problem. Across the Tasman the new Labor government of Kevin Rudd has honoured its pledge to reduce personal income taxes by A$47 billion over the next four years by curbing the future growth of government spending.

Absolutely. And tax cuts have less of an impact on inflation then extra government spending.

That is an avenue that has long been open to the Clark Government. Since taking office in 1999 government spending has doubled from $36 billion to $72 billion and, according to Mr Key, the number of bureaucrats has increased 37 per cent from just over 26,000 to 36,000.

Some of the increases are due to inflation and some to increases in the population, but Dr Cullen and his colleagues have not applied the same discipline to their spending as businesses and families are forced to do every day to survive.

There was some discipline early on but in the last few years the spending increases has been uncontrolled and more and more on low quality projects. In some Departments bureaucrats have even been told they are to bid for more than they actually want, and then to think up things to spend it on. Seriously.

It is past time for the government to take a more rigorous approach to its own spending. Doing so would increase the money available for tax cuts and reduce their inflationary impact. If Dr Cullen does not do so today, voters can take comfort from the knowledge that National will after the election.

And it adds up pretty quickly. $230 million has been spent on the Electricity Commission. Off memory $150 million on TEC. Close to a billion dollars wasted on low quality tertiary courses. Ministries are now bulging with communication officers, the SSC has been expanding out of sight etc etc.

Editorial on MMP manipulations

Very pleased to see an editorial today disapproving of what the Greens have been trying to do with manipulating List MPs in and out of Parliament. The NZ Herald opines:

The most widely disliked aspects of MMP are undoubtedly the lack of accountability of list MPs and the manipulation of party lists. The attempted elevation of Green Party co-leader Russel Norman to Parliament did nothing to improve that situation. This was to be achieved by Nandor Tanczos, a sitting MP, and Catherine Delahunty and Mike Ward, who were ahead of Dr Norman on the Greens’ party list, standing aside. The ranking of candidates, as voted upon at the last election, would have been set aside and Dr Norman would have attained the status and election-campaign advantages that come with being an MP.

It comes down to the fundamental issue that some parties see List MPs as serving the party only, not the wider public who voted for them.

Mr Ward’s opposition has stopped him in his tracks. Similarly shelved should be the notion that party lists can be manipulated to satisfy any whim.

One way to stop it would be to get rid of the ability for a candidate to refuse to take up their spot if they are the next List candidate. Sure they could still resign but parties would be far less likely to try and manipulate the system if a candidate they want out of the way had to be declared elected, sworn in as an MP, and then resign.

A touchy subject

Stuff have been running a blog poll on whether Phil Goff would make a good successor to Helen Clark. A few people suggested yesterday I should promote it but I didn’t because they are very unscientific and no one should take them too seriously.

However I noted with amusement today that obviously the 9th floor was taking it seriously as the poll has now been amended to include the words “(This is a hypothetical question)”.

Ha ha ha – so precious. Demanding that it be made clear it is hypothetical, just in case readers thought the PM was dead or had resigned and no one had noticed I guess.

Even better Stuff then added on a third voting option – ” Your hypothetical question is not welcome”.

Sadly for the complainers the results to date are:

Yes (Goff would be good sucessor) 81% (1,359 votes)
No (Goff would be bad sucessor) 12% (198 votes)
Your hypothetical question is not welcome 7% (124 votes)

UPDATE: I was wrong. There were two different polls. See here for an explanation.

Obama closer but not quite there

According to Real Clear Politics, Obama now has 1,957 delegates – just 68 short of the magic 2,025. Obama picked up 42 from Oregon and Kentucky to 53 for Clinton.

86 delegates remain from two states and a territory. Clinton will probably pick up more than Obama due to Puerto Rico, but assume 50/50 then that puts Obama to exactly 2,000.

So he needs 25 more super delegates after that.Ā  There are 209 yet to pledge so that should not be an issue. His campaign team will deserve to be sacked if on the day of the last primary (3 June) he can not announce two dozen super delegates. And finally it will be over.

The decision in the EPMU case

The Judge was Justice MacKenzie. The full judgement is here Here are some key extracts:

[18] Because there is no legal impossibility involved in the proposition that an artificial person might be involved in the administration of the affairs of a party, to read the word ā€œpersonā€ in s 13(2)(f) as limited to natural persons would in effect create two categories of persons involved in the administration of the affairs of a party:
(a) Natural persons ,who are ineligible to be listed as a third party; and
(b) Artificial persons, who are eligible to be listed as a third party.

Exactly. It would create an illogical distinction. If a “person” is capable of being involved in the administration of a political party, the ineligibility criteria must apply to them, regardless of the type of person (natural vs legal).

[21] Second, in the absence of such a legal prohibition, the question of whether a particular person is involved in the administration of the affairs of the company is a question of fact. The scheme of the Act is such that the determination of that question of fact is a matter for the Commission. Under s 17(1)(c) the Commission must refuse an application if it is not satisfied that the applicant is eligible to be listed. To interpret s 13(2)(f) as not applying as a matter of law to artificial persons, by adopting a narrow meaning of the word ā€œpersonā€ from its context in the wider phrase, would be to pre-empt the very question which the Commission is required to address.

This is why I am surprised the Electoral Commission followed the Crown Law advice, as doing so actually meant the Commission would not be as effective in doing its job in making sure only eligible persons can register as third parties. To be fair to the Electoral Commission, they did say in their affidavit something along the lines of having some reservations about the advice, but by consensus decided to accept it.

Crown Law now have the dubious distinction of having been patently wrong by saying the original EFB did not breach the Bill of Rights and with their definition of “person”.

[22] Third, I can discern no reason, derived from the purposes of the Act, which would justify exclusion, from the category of persons created by s 13(2)(f), of an artificial person involved in the administration of the affairs of a party, as distinct from a natural person who is so involved. The clear purpose of s 13(2)(f) is to ensure a degree of separation between persons involved in the administration of political parties, on the one hand, and third parties, on the other. That purpose is best achieved by excluding from eligibility all persons involved in the administration of a political party, not merely a subset of such persons.

This goes right to the heart of the case – what interpretation best meets the overall purpose of the Act.

[27] For these reasons I conclude that, on its proper interpretation, the word ā€œpersonā€ in s 13(2)(f) bears the meaning given to it by s 29 of the Interpretation Act 1999.

I had had so many lawyers tell me that this must be the case, I would have been very surprised if the case had gone the other way.

[29] For these reasons, I consider that the Union does potentially fall within the scope of s 13(2)(f) of the EFA and that the question of whether it does so must be determined by the Commission before it can be listed as a third party.

As previously stated, this does not mean the EPMU is ineligible. It means the Electoral Commission must now determine if its opinion that EPMU is involved in the administration of the Labour Party. I am of course of the view that there is an overwhelming case that they are involved, and hence ineligible.

If they fail to be registered they can still spend their money campaigning. They just need Mike Smith’s permission and for their spending to count as part of the cap for Labour – the party they have voluntarily joined and are involved in.

[34] The extent of enquiry which the Commission may make, and the processes which it may undertake, to determine whether, in particular, s 17(1)(c) is met, based on the application made under s 15(3), is not specified in the Act. It is a matter for the Commission. The Commission has power, under s 6(2)(aa) of the Electoral Act 1993 ā€œto make such enquiries as the Commission thinks necessary for the proper discharge of its functionsā€. I do not consider that it is appropriate for this Court to direct the Commission as to how it should go about the performance of its functions, or how it should conduct its enquires.

This is where the EPMU counter-claim is turned down. The Electoral Commission I am sure will be pleased they retain discretion as to whether to allow members of the public, like myself, to offer an opinion on matters before them.

[35] There will be a declaration that word ā€œpersonā€ in s 13(2)(f) of the Electoral Finance Act 2007 has the meaning given to it by s 29 of the Interpretation Act 1999.

I doubt there will be an appeal. I can probably now reveal that the legal team were so confident of victory that they were talking of going to the Supreme Court if necessary. In fact I suspect they may even be a bit disappointed they won, as it means no appeal work šŸ™‚

Labour now have to face the possibility that the law they rammed through Parliament may end up making their largest ally the biggest victim.

Victory in Court

Have just received the judgement of the High Court in the case regarding the Electoral Commission and the EPMU, and am pleased to report that the Court has ruled the Electoral Commission was wrong (and hence the Crown Law advice was also wrong) to decide that the ineligibity to be a third party criteria of “a person involved in the administration of the affairs of a party” only referred to natural persons and not legal persons including incorporated societies.

This means the Electoral Commission decision granting the EPMU application is over-turned and the Electoral Commission now has to decide whether the EPMU is involved in the administration of the affairs of the Labour Party.

The EPMU also lost its counter claim asking for the Electoral Commission not to allow objections to applications, before they had made their decision.

I will put the pdf of the decision up shortly.

Back Benches tonight

Back Benches is on tonight live at the Back Bencher.

The MPs are:

  1. Sue Kedgeley, Greens
  2. Rodney Hide, ACT
  3. Chester Borrows, National
  4. Charles Chauvel, Labour

And the topics are the budget, tax cuts and leadership. Sounds fun. TVNZ also tells me they have a special mystery guess!

The show starts at 9.00 p.m. but best to be there by 8.30 pm if you want a seat or want to offer yourself to ask a question. It is, of course, at the Backbencher on Molesworth Street.

Mike Ward refuses to play ball

Let ti be noted that Phil U was right when he blogged in January that there was a plan to put Russel Norman into Parliament before the election by having Nandor fall on his sword. I linked to his story and it then became a major news story – sadly with no crediting Phil as the original author.

There would be significant advantages to the Greens to having Russel, who was only No 10 last time, be in Parliament this year so he could campaign around the country funded by the taxpayer, as other MPs are.

For this to happen, they needed three things. Nandor to agree to resign. Catherine Delahunty to agree to refuse to be an MP, and for Mike Ward to refuse to be an MP.

Mike has refused, as he should. Incidentially Ward was ranked dismally low by the party hierarchy in their initial list ranking for 2008 and massively promoted by rank and file members. But his 2008 list ranking is not important – his 2005 one is.

There were two things which the Greens were trying to do, which sit badly with me. I’ll take them one by one.

1 – MPs resigning before the election

Labour is more guilty than the Greens here, but the idea of a party list is not to shuffle MPs off half way through a parliamentary term at whim. MPs are elected by the NZ public to serve three years and in all but exceptional cases they should. Steve Maharey becoming a VC is a worthy exception (yes I know he was not List but same principle). And Bolger becoming Ambassador is another. And few would fault a Party Leader from departing the scene once they are no longer leader. But these are rare exceptional circumstances.

Generally the public have the right to expect that the MPs they elect by voting for a Party and that party’s list, are going to represent the public throughout the term of Parliament. No wonder there is resentment against MMP when List MPs are treated purely as creatures of the party.

Labour since the election has dispatched Jim Sutton (No 11 on list, No 4 on effective list), Di Yates, Ann Hartley, and Georgina Beyer.

2 – Changing the order of the list post-election

Pressuring candidates to stand aside for someone more lowly ranked to become an MP is also anti-democratic and flys in the face of the public making an informed choice by voting for a party with an expectation of who will be MPs.

The Green Party members ranked Mike Ward No 8Ā  and Russel Norman No 10 last election. People voted for the Green Party on the basis. Yes I know very few voters would now the exact details of the list, but that is not a reason to ignore its importance. If you argue who is on the list does not matter, then why not allow parties to have blank lists and let them appoint who they want at any time to be an MP for them.

For that is what the Greens, and to a degree Labour, have tried to do.Ā  Have the party rather than the public determine who becomes an MP.

More people leaving

The latest migration stats continue the trend:

  • In last 12 months 44,114 permanent or long-term departures to Australia which is 850 a week. this is the highest since early 1989.
  • The net migration to Australia of 30,575 is the highest since September 11
  • Total PLT departures of 79,327 is the highest since records began.
  • Looking at NZ nationals only, 57,359 nationals left and only 22,902 returned. This net loss of nationals of 34,457 is the highest since the 12 months to Nov 2001

Winston’s wish list

NZPA reports that Winston has announced the following policies for NZ First:

  1. No tax on first $5,200 of income
  2. GST to reduce to 10%
  3. Superannation to increase to 68% of net average wage

Now once fully implemented, what would be the reduction in the surplus:

  1. $14.7 billion of income would have no tax, and with a current rate of 15% would be less income of $2.21 billion
  2. GST income would drop by $2.38 billion according to Treasury Ready Reckoner
  3. Superannuation at 66% of average wage costs $7.29b so taking it to 68% would cost around $0.22b

So Winston is saying the surplus is large enough to be reduced by $4.81 billion a year. I suspect Dr Cullen does not agree.

I suspect Winston’s proposals would be bad for inflation – which is no surprise as Winston does not beleive in low inflation. They also do little for home affordability – in fact make it worse probably.

Cutting tax on spending instead of a tax on earning is more likely to be inflationary.

Giving every person a tax cut of $780 or $15 a week will see most of that spent not saved.

Boosting Superannuation (already the most generous scheme in the world) will see most of it spent not saved, as retired people tend to spend their savings (as they should).

My ideal package would be increase GST to say 20%, but compensate for that by a tax free threshold for say the first $20K of income. Say someone earns $25,000 on the minimum wage. They would pay $3.630 less income tax if first $20,000 is tax free. Now their current after tax income is around $20,320. Let’s say they spent $15,000 on rateable goods and services including GST. Well an extra 7.5% on that is only $1.000 so they are $2,630 better off.

Middle to high income earners would not fare so well, which is why I would also move to a a top tax rate of 30%, eventually reducing to 25%. Not got time to cost that but the extra GST would bring in $7 billion so could do a bit lowering income tax from that.

Of course the GST increase would have one off inflation issues, so timing would be important.

The best PM poll

I don’t normally blog on individual blog poll results because they are just a bit of fun, and not at all scientific. But I did find interesting that despite the centre right leanings of most readers, the best PMs in order were:

  1. Lange (Labour) 23%
  2. Holyoake (National) 20%
  3. Clark (Labour) 12%
  4. Bolger (National) 11%
  5. Savage (Labour) 9%
  6. Muldoon (unclassifiable) 6%

Peter Fraser is in fact my favourite Labour Party PM and would be my second choice. My first choice should be easy to guess.

Papers on Goff

The papers this morning look at Goff’s positioning. Tracy Watkins at the Dom Post reports:

Helen Clark’s heir apparent, Phil Goff, appears to be positioning himself for a leadership tilt if Labour loses the election, dropping his previous denials that he had ambitions for the job.

Mr Goff, Labour’s third-ranked minister, has also conceded Labour could lose the election as it battles a mood for change. …

Though he is widely accepted as Miss Clark’s successor should she step down after a Labour loss, his opening the door to that possibility now is likely to spark damaging leadership speculation. …

In response to further questions, he said being prime minister was “not an overwhelming ambition”.

That contrasts with a comment in February when, asked if he had ambitions to be prime minister, he said: “I have absolutely none.”

Goff claiming to have no ambitions to be Prime Minister could almost be called perjury. Even his statement about no “overwhelming” ambition probably rests on a Clintonian type definition of “overwhelming”.

The Herald also looks at his answers:

Mr Goff did little yesterday to make amends for his public admission that he wants Helen Clark’s job if Labour loses the election.

“There is no question about leadership at the moment,” he said yesterday when questioned about his pre-recorded television interview.

A seasoned politician who wanted to end discussion about leadership would usually give such an answer unconditionally, without qualifications such as “at the moment”.

It is no secret that Mr Goff wants to be Labour leader, but it is the first time he has acknowledged it publicly and it is the first time a senior Labour MP has openly contemplated defeat.

The qualification is unnecessary because people always know that the statement doesn’t imply forever. So by stating the obvious “at the moment” tends to be for a reason.

There is of course no chance Goff will challenge. But what he may be signalling is in the event of a loss, he wants a quick change. He doesn’t want Clark to stay on for 18 months, giving other contenders the time to build up support and get the job ahead of him.

John Armstrong also reads the tea leaves:

The body is still breathing – just. But some of the family already seem to be fighting over the corpse.

It is a sure sign that a Government is on its last legs when its members admit they might lose the coming election and discuss – even in passing – what might happen to their party afterwards. …

He may have stated the obvious in saying “there’s a prospect we might lose”. However, no matter how dire things might be looking – and they do look pretty dire for Labour right now – no politician worth his salt admits the possibility of defeat. Never. Full-stop. Period. And certainly not a politician as smart, seasoned, politically wired, competent and ultra-careful as Goff.

Goff is known as ultra-careful. He has been in Parliament since before most university students were born. He has especially been careful on issues of leadership as for the last 12 years he has been the focus of attention. Not once in 12 years has he said what he said last night.

This is the first time Goff has ever opened up on the possibility of his leading the Labour Party. Even if he did not say that much, it was in marked contrast to his line back in February. When he was asked then if he had leadership aspirations, he replied “absolutely none” and instead heaped praise on Helen Clark.

Those who argue this means nothing at all, have no experience with how leadership contenders position themselves. Now trust me, one thing I know about is leadership contenders and coups. I’ve seen MPs and leader’s press secretaries negotiate words so they can express confidence in the leader, yet keep their options open. The language around confidence in the leader is very precise and deviations from it are well understood.

Again this does not mean Goff will try anything before the election. He does not want to be Mike Moore, and he would not win anyway. But it is a signal that post-election he will vigorously contest the leadership and on his timetable, not necessarily Helen’s.

Will the Churches be sent to jail

Despite advice from the Electoral Commission that they should register as third parties, six churches are funding a $100,000 campaign on “social justice” and refusing to register, and presumably refusing to put authorisation statements on the campaign advertisements.

They are lucky to only be spending $100,000 as if they spent more than $120,000 and they were deemed to be election advertisements, it would be an automatic corrupt practice [s66(1)].

The Herald reports:

The churches’ leaflet urges local churches to act directly by “supporting activities at a lower decile school in your area, volunteering your time to help with some form of family support or youth work, or being a good friend to families who may be isolated or in poverty”.

It also encourages them to ask politicians two questions: “Do they have explicit policies about lifting children out of poverty? Do they have clear policies about provision of social services to help children in need?”

Now the second part could be seen as advocating against parties and candidates that do not policies to lift children out of poverty.Ā  And considering the churches use a definition of poverty which makes it basically impossible to have some families not in poverty (this is known as the poverty industry), it is a very loaded question that is promoting extreme income redistribution.

Now let us look at s5(1)(a)(ii) of the Electoral Finance Act:

In this Act, election advertisement … means any form of words or graphics, or both, that can reasonably be regarded as doing 1 or more of the following: …

encouraging or persuading voters to vote, or not to vote, for a type of party or for a type of candidate that is described or indicated by reference to views, positions, or policies that are or are not held, taken, or pursued (whether or not the name of a party or the name of a candidate is stated);

Does the pamphlet encourage people not to vote for a party which doesn’t have explicit policies to lift children out of poverty? I wouldn’t want to say without seeing the full pamphlet, but it is certainly arguable.Ā  What is the point of encouraging people to ask politicians the question unless it is to then take that into account when voting? If anyone has a copy of the pamphlet, could they send one to me?

The Electoral Commission has said:

Electoral Commission chief executive Helena Catt said she gave the churches the same advice that she gave to any group planning election-related advertising – that the definition of an election advertisement was still “a large grey area” and it would be “safer to list [as a third party] than not”.

But Annette King said it was a law of common sense, so how can it be a “large grey area”?

As I said above, a copy of the pamphlet would be most useful.

New Zealand 4th in peace index

Vision of Humanity has NZ in 4th place in their 2008 Global Peace Index.

Ahead of us are Iceland, Denmark and Norway. Now this gives us a real opportunity as they are all naval neighbours.

If we can arrange for a great big naval battle between Iceland, Denmark and Norway then we’ll rise into 1st place. My thinking is to get Norway to sink an anti whaling boat full of protesting Danes. Denmark will respond.

Then Iceland, with links to both Norway and Denmark will try and intervene to stop the conflict, but they get hit accidentally, and then enter the conflict themselves.

Hence in 2009 we should top the index.