The Press on Electoral Finance Act

Saturday’s Press editorial was on the Electoral Finance Act:

The mire that is the Electoral Finance Act grows deeper by the week. It is now more than four months since the controversial legislation came into effect and the last possible date for the general election is less than half a year away, writes The Press in an editorial.

This is the time when political parties and lobby groups should be finalising their campaign strategies, with the confidence that iron-clad election laws provide. But as this week’s High Court case involving the Engineering, Printing and Manufacturing Union has demonstrated, the new regime of the controversial act remains murky.

More than murky. What is and is not an election advertisement is still a matter of conjecture.

This case was about whether the union could register with the Electoral Commission as a third party, or lobby group, under the act, which would entitle it to spend up to $120,000 on election advertising. Unregistered groups or individuals have a far smaller $12,000 spending cap.

This was challenged on the grounds that a “person” involved in the administration of a political party was not eligible to be registered as a third party. Last month the commission, after taking Crown Law Office advice, decided that the EPMU was not a natural person and therefore decided to register the union.

There is a story to be told about Crown Law and its advice, such as the growing number of Departments who are no longer using Crown Law for legal advice. It has become all too political.

But the High Court in Wellington took the opposite position on this issue. It did not rule on whether the EPMU’s close links with Labour would make it ineligible to be a third party, leaving this question to be resolved by the commission. …

A big test of the legislation’s treatment of third parties could come if the EPMU is refused registration by the commission. The union is adamant that if this occurs it will still mount a campaign based around workers’ rights and wages.

They will need to be very very careful. If parties have policies on workers’ rights and wages, then a campaign on those issues could well be seen to be an election advertisement. And the fact that the EPMU is on the record as saying their aim is to influence the election outcome with their campaign means that a Judge could find a breach of the Act was deliberate and a corrupt practice.

Issues-based campaigning by non-registered lobby groups is permitted under the act, and there is no spending limit, providing advertising does not encourage people to vote, or not vote, for a political party or even a type of party. But it would be a neat and delicate trick to run a publicity campaign based around workers’ rights and which cost more than $12,000 without breaching this particular provision, given the politically charged nature of employment relations in New Zealand history.

Indeed.

The commission, which plays a major role in implementing the electoral finance regime, deserves some sympathy. It has been forced to make decisions on a case-by-case basis over issues where the meaning of the act is unclear, as shown by the differing legal opinions over the EPMU bid for third-party status.

Oh the Commission has a damn awful job thanks to this stupid law. Having said that, when they see crappy legal advice from Crown Law (and their affidavit shows they had some issues with it) they could choose to seek alternative advice.

The commission has drawn some unwarranted criticism for its decisions, but the real fault lies with the Government and those support parties which demanded this legislation. Most New Zealanders would believe there is a place for third-party election advertising, because this allows non-politicians to participate in the democratic process. Most people, after the Exclusive Brethren campaign last election, would also argue that there must be financial limits on third parties to prevent moneyed interests buying an election. The act is an attempt to reconcile these goals.

And if the Government has not drawn up the law in secret, but embarked on a public consultation exercise prior to introducing a law change, a much more workable regime could have been developed. But they tried to “screw the scrum” with a partisan incompetent law – and in the process shattering the constitutional conventions around the Electoral Act.

But, even leaving aside longstanding accusations that the legislation screws the scrum in favour of the Government, it is also failing in a practical sense, and one key reason for this is that it took effect on January 1.

A more sensible course would have been to have delayed its introduction, at least for this year’s election. This would have provided a breathing space during which the ambiguities in the act could have been calmly resolved, not allowed to become political points-scoring issues in their own right.

Or to have kept the regulated period at 90 days, so one would have had January to July to clarify the law in respect the regulated period activities.

Labour’s Selections

Craig Foss has noticed that Labour held a meeting this weekend to confirm Rick Barker as the Tukituki candidate, which is curious as he was announced as the candidate before Christmas. Did something happen?

There are rumours that some Labour MPs worried about losing their seats may announce they will go list only.

This could help explain why Labour has delayed its list ranking. Labour has a dilemma. If they give high list rankings to incumbent MPs, then they face having almost no new MPs enter Parliament.

Incidentally my list of candidates still has no names for Waikato and Tamaki for Labour. Anyone know if candidates have been named?  National is now just awaiting a Tauranga selection plus both major parties can do list only nominations.

The great education debate

Wellingtonians who like a good debate should come along tonight to Lecture Theatre Two at Rutherford House at 6 pm.

The details are:

Topic: That New Zealand should implement a system of education vouchers

Affirmative: Roger Kerr (Business Roundtable), Heather Roy MP (ACT candidate for Wellington Central) and Stephen Whittington (LLB Hons/BA student, champion student debater)

Negative: Grant Robertson (Labour candidate for Wellington Central), John Minto (Quality Public Education Coalition), and Arthur Graves (Principals’ Council of New Zealand).


Well done to DebSoc for organising it – a real variety of speakers!

Power Cut

Just had a power cut in Thorndon. Not sure how long it lasted but maybe 20 minutes or so. I went out to Boudeaux Bakery to have a bagel lunch and leisurely read the newspaper.

Should get used to being without power. This weekend I am off to Great Barrier Island for a holiday. The island has no central power supply – no street lights etc. Individual properties generally use solar power or a generator.

The house we’ve hired has power, but not for a laptop, so there will be no phone, no cellphone coverage and no Internet – bliss. Planning to do a few bushwalks, some fishing, just very leisurely.

Ministerial Staff Numbers

I blogged on Friday how Winston when ranting on about John Key having 36 staff, forgot to mention that in fact those 36 staff support all 48 National MPs, and that it is probably a lower staff:MP ratio than any other party.

Now by coincidence on the same day Winston was having his rant, Ministerial Services published their latest staffing list – as of 22 May 2008. A kind spy has sent me a copy.

As I suspected once again, the number of spin doctors (media/comms staff) has increased – now up to 43 of them for just 28 Ministers. I can recall the days when it was around 30.

The total number of staff working for Ministers has also increased – there are now 286 of them. Being a bit bored I thought it might be useful to explain different roles to readers and go through and categorise them. I have divided them into five categories.

  1. Managers. Each office has one person in charge of the office. They are normally called the Senior Private Secretary or SPS. For the PM it is the Chief of Staff, and Anderton, Peters and Dunne all use that title now for their senior staffer. The SPS is the key to a well run Ministerial office. They control access to the Minister, co-ordinate the other staff, oversee liaison with Departments and make sure everything runs smoothly for the Minister. A good SPS is worth their weight in gold.

    There tend to be three types of SPS. The neutral professionals who serve any Minister in any Government used to make up all the SPS’s but now are less than half. New Ministers especially are very wise to take on one of these. The second type is similiar and they are the portfolio specific SPS. Sometimes a Department will supply someone to be the Minister’s SPS if if it a very important portfolio like Finance or Foreign Affairs. The third is the political SPS who is there for that Minister only, and are the de factor chief advisor as well as the office manager.

  2. Communicators. In this category are press secretaries and communication advisors. They are the staffers whose primary job is to sell the Minister’s message. I’ve included the Graphic Designer in this category which is maybe a bit unfair, but their job is producing material for communication purposes. Plus when I held a similiar role, the media lumped me in with the spin doctors so fair’s fair!

    Again there are three types of spin doctors. A very small number of professional press secretaries who have worked for Governments of all hues. A slightly larger number of ex or recovering journalists who accept the job because it pays more than journalism. They tend to be politically sympathetic to their Minister but not necessarily political with a capital P. The third are the political activists, often with a party background.

  3. Portfolio Advisors. These are normally referred to as Private Secretary (portfolio name) and they deal with all issues around that portfolio for the Minister. The more complex portfolios may also have some Advisors associated with it to help the Minister negotiate purchase agreements etc. Most, but not all, of the portfolio advisors are seconded from their Departments. It can be a mixed blessing. It tends to mark you up for rapid promotion if you do a spell in the Minister’s office, but you can get caught up in power plays between your temporary boss (the Minister) and your normal boss (the CEO). Some of the portfolio advisors have been there for years serving many Governments and Ministers and are jokingly referred to as the real Ministers. They know where all the corpses are buried!
  4. Political Advisors. These are basically political staffers who are not an SPS, or a spin doctor. They tend to have titles such as Senior Advisor. I’ve also included Executive Assistants as in my experience they tend to be primarily political. These staff tend to most concentrate on the Minister’s political agenda and reputation. To some degree all staff in an office are concerned with this, but these ones specialise. They will often deal with key stakeholders also and be a liaison back to the party.
  5. Administrators. These are the clerical and support staff that actually make things happen. Ministerial Secretaries, Private Secretaries, Electorate Secretaries, Receptionists and in the past Ministerial Clerks. They do the correspondence, the filing (very very important – everything needs to be kept and located when needed), the dealing with calls from the public etc. These are mainly non political but not exclusively. Sometimes they will have worked for the Minister in opposition. Also in the past young political activists might take up one of these roles as an “entry level” role for advancement.

So having described the various categories, how many of each type are there:

  1. 28 Managers
  2. 45 Communicators
  3. 111 Portfolio Advisors
  4. 35 Political Advisors
  5. 56 Administrators

That’s a total of 286 staff. If I can find someone with a copy of a 1999 directory it would be interesting to see how much it has grown by.

Now which offices have the most staff in each category. They are:

  • Communicators – The PMs Office has 10, Ministers Anderton and Cunliffe have three each and another five Ministers have two each.
  • Portfolio Advisors – Ruth Dyson has the most with eight portfolio staff – three for Social Development, and one each for Employment Policy, CYFS, Disability Issues and Comm & Voluntary Sector. Goff and Horomia have seven. Goff has two for Defence, two for Corrections, one for Trade, one for NZT&E and one for Disarmament. Horomia has four for Maori Affairs, and one each for Education, ERO and Social Development. Even the smallest portfolios tend to get their own advisor nowadays with both National Library and National Archives having their own orivate secretary!
  • Political Advisors. The PM has five, two Ministers have three each, and five others have two each.
  • Administrators. The PM has 14 (they have a huge amount of correspondence and records), one Minister has four, five Ministers have three, and 13 Ministers have two.
  • Total Staff. As expected the Pm has the most at 31. Carter and Mallard have 14 each, followed by Anderton and Goff at 13 each. Somehow Cullen survives with only 12 (not many considering his workrate and areas of responsibility) matched by Cosgrove, Dyson and Hodgson.

And who has the least staff:

  • Harry Duynhoven is the only Minister with no spin doctor.
  • The PM and Mahara Okeroa have only one portfolio advisor each.
  • Okeroa also has the least number of total staff at four. Next lowest at five each are Darren Hughes, Harry Duynhoven and Mita Ririnui

On top of the Ministerial staff, the Government also has the Labour Research Unit which supports backbench Labour MPs. If I get the time I might do a post at some stage on the roles and functions of parliamentary units for non Ministers. And maybe even Electorate Offices. Also one on the role of DPMC as many people confuse that with the PMO and they are very different.

Problems logging in?

A few people are having problems logging in to make comments, and saying when they request a new password, it doesn’t send one.

If you are having this problem, just send me an e-mail saying what your username is and what you want your password to be and I can set it manually for you.

Southern Cross doubtful of need for Kordia cable

The Dom Post reports that Southern Cross Cable Network says there is little rationale for Kordia to put in place its own international cable.

I disagree. I think competition for international bandwidth is highly desirable and am pleased Kordia are doing so – with Government backing. I do have a minor concern about Kordia’s ownership of Orcon as a vertically integrated state owned ISP may have some unfair advantages, but they can be managed.

Even with Kordia’s new cable, I think we will in the future have a shortage of international bandwidth. That is because rollout of fibre to the home will see bandwidth demands increase 100 fold. Let me use an example Ericsson used in a recent fibre to the home presentation.

Let us say at present you have 5Mb/s speed, and a contention ratio of 50:1. As very few users are using their full speed at any point in time, one can have a high contention ratio as e-mail and web browsing takes up little bandwidth.

Now let us say with fibre to the home you are connecting at 50 Mb/s. That means 10 times the bandwidth needed. But the sort of activities you do on the Internet will change – you may be video conferencing much of the day, and watching Hi Def TV in the evening. So the contention ratio might have to change to be 5:1 not 50:1.

So in a neighbourhood of say 1,000 residents the backhaul bandwidth previously needed was 100 Mb/s. Within a decade it will be 10 GB/s.

Prostitution Law Reform

I was a supporter of Tim Barnett’s Prostitution Law Reform Act. In fact for many years I regaled Young Nationals conferences about the unfairness of a law which made it an offence for someone to offer sex for money, but not for someone to offer money for sex. I instinctively dislike most laws which criminalise consensual behaviour.

A report on the law by the Prostitution Law Review Committee has found that the number of prostitutes has stayed around the same, since the law was passed, but that there is less exploitation and better health and safety. So that is good.

One of the issues around the law change, has been the extent to which Councils can restrict the location of brothels. There has been a lot of publicity around a brothel in Mt Victoria, and Rosemary McLeod has a local’s perspective on it.

In terms of public policy, I don’t have a problem with commercial sex being provided from private homes, as that generally is a less exploitive and safer arrangement, but it should be only one or two people.

The Mt Victoria house is seeking or has been given permission to have seven staff working there. Now when it gets that large, I am very much siding with the residents – the impact on the neighbourhood gets to be significant. So one solution might be to limit the size of any suburban brothels so their impact on a neighbourhood is minimised.

Heaven on Earth

The History Channel on Sky has had on the three part “Heaven on Earth” series about the rise and fall of socialism.

This 3-hour documentary explores one of the most powerful political ideas in history. Socialism spread farther and faster than any religion. Then, in almost the blink of an eye, it all collapsed. What happened?

I really recommend people try and get a copy and watch it. It gives a great account of the causes of socialism, the massive misery imposed on millions of people in the name of socialism, and how a doctrine which was once followed in scores and scores of countries is now all but extinct. Of course you still have “socialism lite” with the nicer sounding name of “social democrats”

UK Labour routed at by-election

A couple of days old now, but have to mention the by-election for Crewe and Nantwich (don’t you love English place names).

In 2005 Labour won the seat by over 7,000 votes – 49% to 32%.

In the by-election, the Conservatives won by almost 8,000 votes – 49.5% to 30.5%. So that is a 17% swing to the Conservatives. In 1997 Labour won it by 31% – 58% to 27%.

The highlight for me was the candidate for the Official Monster Raving Loony Party, a Mr “The Flying Brick” – and yes that is his legal name. He is their Shadow Minister for the Abolition of Gravity.

In nationwide polls, the Conservatives are 14% ahead of Labour, which would give them a 76 seat majority.

Clinton’s new plan

It seems Hillary Clinton has a new plan for winning the nomination. Just keep the race going as long as possible, and wait for Obama to be assassinated as Robert Kennedy was!

Well how else does one interpret her remarks:

“My husband did not wrap up the nomination in 1992 until he won the California primary somewhere in the middle of June, right? We all remember Bobby Kennedy was assassinated in June in California. I don’t understand it,” she said, dismissing calls to drop out

So the race isn’t over until the first shit shot is fired!

UPDATE: And maybe her Plan B ties into Bill pushing her to be the VP candidate for Obama. Wait long enough and she might still get to be the first female President!

Scope for further tax cuts say economists

Economists say there are options for National to offer further tax cuts, as a way to help people through the tough times ahead but also to help boost economic growth. The SST reports:

Deutsche Bank chief economist Darren Gibbs said a future National government could accelerate – as well as improve – tax thresholds and tax relief ahead of the April 2010 date set in the Budget.

“Just as Labour has a May 2008 Budget tax package kicking in in October, so could a National government in a May 2009 Budget bring forward the next round of tax relief to October next year,” he said.

It was unlikely there would be cuts in front-line spending (fewer doctors, teachers and so on) to pay for that.

But he said National could pay for more capital spending through public- private partnerships where private money, not public, built infrastructure such as roads that would be tolled.

Plus National has also announced before the budget that it has not signed up to around $2 billion (over four years) of Labour’s spending plans.

The Hive has some suggestions for other areas. They also say they would like to see the trains but who on Earth would be stupid enough to pay $1.5 billion for them?

O’Sullivan on fiscal drag

Fran O’Sullivan says to enjoy your tax cuts while you have them:

Enjoy your tax cuts – you will probably pay for much of them through fiscal drag.

That’s the reality for many higher income earners as Finance Minister Michael Cullen “all but” admitted to me on Friday.

Over the past eight years, he has pocketed close to an extra $2 billion in fiscal drag, based on figures provided to me by his office.

This year it will probably be about another $250-$260 million, which will go a good way towards funding the shift in the top tax threshold from $60,000 to $70,000.

If the $60,000 “rich prick” threshold had been inflation adjusted it would already be at $74,800 (and it moves to $70,000 only this October). When the threshold moves to $75,000 in March 2010 the fiscal drag would have it at $79,400 and in March 2011 when it hits $80,000 the fiscal drag would have it at $81,600.

So Fran is right. The change to the $60,000 threshold doesn’t even compensate for inflation. Someone earning $60,000 in 1999 and having had their salary go up by the rate of inflation every year would have paid $25,100 of extra tax from 2001 to 2008.

And even from 2009 to 2012 they will pay an extra $12,500 of tax just for having been pushed into the “rich prick” top tax rate, even though they are earning no more in real terms than they were in 1999.

But the Finance Minister suggested those earning more than $80,000 (8 per cent) would basically fund their cut through the fiscal drag effect.

Cullen’s “admission” came after the Wellington Regional Chamber of Commerce’s post-Budget luncheon. He noted the top tax threshold was now cutting in at such a low level, it was even catching nurses and teachers – not his original intention.

Yes only classes of non Labour voters are meant to be targeted by it.

With 55 per cent of the total income tax of $26,373m paid by those earning more than $60,000, and 29 per cent by those earning $100,000 plus, calls are likely to increase for more cuts at higher income levels over time.

Those nasty “rich pricks”who fund the health. education and welfare systems can and are going to Australia.

For Star Wars nerds

A fan, Michael Kaminski, has written a 532 page book on the secret history of Star Wars. It has everything – the discarded plot elemenets, how they decided Darth Vader would be Luke’s father only after the first movie was done, what happened to episodes VII to IX.

If people have nothing to do over the next weekend’s long weekend!

Repeal the Electoral Finance Act

One of the opponents of the Electoral Finance Act died yesterday – Grey Power President Graham Stairmand. My condolences to those who knew him – I had not had the pleasure.

On the same day a dedicated group of around 40 anti EFA protesters led by John Boscawen protested outside the venue for Helen Clark’s post-budget speech. Not PC has photos.

Neither of these are reasons why the EFA should be repealed. The ultimate proof of the stupidity and far reaching effects of the Electoral Finance Act comes in this story by Audrey Young.

All references to a “Labour-led Government” were deleted from the Government’s press releases on the Budget for fear of breaching the Electoral Finance Act.

People laughed and jeered at me when I said that the law was so bad it even included press releases, but it does. It is the height of stupidity that one can not even refer to the name of the major party in power in a press release.

Labour should just admit they fucked up, and it is a stupid law. It is probably going to stop their biggest ally from running the campaign they want, and it stops them even mentioning their party’s name in press releases.

“We were advised that the use of the term ‘Labour-led’ in the Government releases could be seen as coming under the Electoral Finance Act and obviously that would not be appropriate because they were Government publications, not Labour Party publications.”

That is a quote from Michael Cullen. Bet he would like to give Mark Burton and Annette King the bash.

It believed the term could be seen as promoting Labour and could therefore meet the new definition of election advertisement under the act.

That would have meant that the material should have been authorised by Labour’s general secretary and financial agent, Mike Smith, and possible prosecution of the Secretary of Treasury, John Whitehead, because Government departments are banned from publishing election advertisements.

Indeed.

Dr Cullen’s own Budget speech contained the term twice but he said he had received advice that because it was a speech in Parliament, parliamentary privilege applied.

It gets even more insane. If it were not for parliamentary privilege, then speeches in Parliament might be illegal election advertisements.

I’m serious. It is time to repeal the law. If it is not repealed before the election there will be court cases galore. Electorate MPs will be fighting off electoral petitions for months and months. By-elections may change the result of the election.

Some may claim that no one thought the law would end up being this far reaching. That is not true. There were warnings and warnings. Submissions were made. Protests were organised. It was all predictable. The Government even gave up trying to defend it and retreated behind their “law of common sense”.

Someone should go ask Annette King how common sense required budget press releases to not mention the name of the major party in Government. You can mention it in 2009 and 2010 but not in 2008 or 2011 as they are election years. You could not get more absurd.

If they will not repeal the law, a compromise would be to return the regulated period to 90 days. This would allow MPs to actually mention the name of their party in press releases for most of the year!

The trains cost $1.5 billion!

Hidden in the depths of detail in the budget documents are the true costs of the train set Dr Cullen purchased. It is projected to be $1.47 billion by 2012.

So how did Toll get the deal of a lifetime?

Simple. Dr Cullen got Mike Williams to buy it, rather than the Treasury!

Treasury you see were too tough in negotiating rail access prices with Toll, so OnTrack were given the job to negotiate the purchase of the trains. Yes, he deliberately sent in the “weaker” team. Toll must regard their $25,000 donation to Labour last year as their best ever investment.

Now who is a Director of On Track? Labour Party President Mike Williams. So what role did Mike “confused” Williams have in buying the trains? Is there not a conflict of interest in being Labour’s chief fundraiser who accepted a donation from Toll and also being on the board buying the trains off Toll?

Talking down interest rates

Both Clark and Cullen appear desperate to talk down interest rates, and are telling all the professional currency traders that they all have got it wrong, and that there is no risk of a delay in interest rates coming down.

The amount of political pressure on Alan Bollard will be immense in the next few months and it will be a test of his independence whether he ignores the clear wishes of the PM to cut rates before the election, even if it means he breaks his legally binding target of inflation under 3%.

A few journalists are saying it is only tax cuts that could keep interest rates high, and this is silly. It is the combination of both tax cuts and extra spending. If you replace a billion of spending with a billion of tax cuts, then in fact it will be reduce inflationary pressures as a proportion of tax cuts are saved not spent.

Martin Kay in the Dom Post reports on Cullen:

Finance Minister Michael Cullen has accused money markets of over-reacting to his tax-cut programme after a blip in the interest rate at which banks borrow for mortgages.

The two-year wholesale rate jumped from 7.7 per cent to 8 per cent after Dr Cullen announced his $10.6 billion, three-stage cuts on Thursday.

Well I know who I trust to be right!

The right to silence

Law Commission President Sir Geoffrey Palmer and Labour MP Russell Fairbrother have called for a review of the right to remain silent if charged with a crime.

This follows the acquittal of Chris Kahui for the murder of his twin sons.

Mr Fairbrother said New Zealand today was different from old English society, which developed the law to protect powerless suspects “against the overwhelming power of the state”.

New Zealand’s human rights-centred law had created many rights which did not exist less than a century ago.

So because we have some more rights, let’s take one away to compensate.

Sadly National doesn’t kick the idea to death, as they should:

National Party justice spokesman Simon Power said he would look at any proposal tabled in Parliament.

“It is fair to say some issues have arisen in the last few days that would warrant a further focus.”

The right to silence is a constutitonal right in the United States. It is also in the NZ Bill of Rights Act.

Look, I hate the fact that some of the absolute scum of society get off, and the fact the right to silence may sometimes help them get off. But we should not be convicting people just because they don’t want to answer every question the Police ask them.

36 staff

The Standard has helpfully put up the video of Winston’s budget speech where he amusingly calls me Rumpelstiltskin and goes on about John Key’s 36 staff.

Did you know that John Key himself in his Wellington parliamentary office employs has 36 people?… they cost the taxpayer, every year… over seven million dollars… Teams of PR people and spin doctors and policy advisers and what for? There is no policy! …

And that’s only the lot within parliament. What about the blogsters, the webmasters, the David Farrar Rumpelslitskenites, the consultants, ad agencies and even more public relations people outside? …

How can John Key go around the country telling the public he’s fiscally prudent when he needs a fleet of buses to carry his entourage? … I actually worked out that [National] are bigger than some pacific island economies!

What is really amusing is that I am pretty sure that I am actually a bit taller than Winston, if push comes to shove!

But Winston and others gloss over a fairly important point in trying to portray John as needing 36 staff. You see in fact the staff support all 48 National MPs with policy, research, and communications etc. So that is 3/4 of a staffer per MP (on top of the Secretary each MP has). So Winston going on about the number of staff is a mere reflection that National has seven times as many MPs as NZ First.

Now I daresay if you look around all the other parliamentary offices, they will have far more staff per capita than National. Again, excluding Secretaries, the staff per party to have the same ratio would be:

  1. Labour 37 (and they actually have around 200 including Beehive staff – admittedly they also have portfolio responsibilitys but I have blogged before how Helen has nine or ten spin doctors just in her office, let alone the 20 or so elsewhere)
  2. NZ First 5 (And I bet you Winston has more than five non secretarial staff)
  3. Greens 4
  4. Maori Party 3
  5. United Future, Act 2
  6. Progressive 1

Now maybe one of those 36 staffers could look up the latest staff directories and send me the numbers for each of the other parties, and I’ll blog whether or not they have more staff per capita than National. I especially welcome the NZ First staff numbers.

Bernard Hickey on the desperate and dangerous budget

Bernard Hickey is strongly disapproving of the budget:

Talk about going out on a low note. …

The result of pulling all the levers in the wrong direction (tax cuts and spending increases) was the destruction of the budget surplus that Dr Cullen had spent the last eight years building up and protecting. Blown in one last desperate act. Dr Cullen and Ms Clark have now said they will fund the cash deficit after investments by running down the Reserve Bank’s reserves and issuing more bonds.

It is the equivalent of throwing it all on the roulette table.

Whatever happened to their mantra that they wouldn’t pay for tax cuts by running up debts? Their (quite powerful) argument that it wasn’t right for National to pay for tax cuts with debt is now dead as the proverbial. Their rebuttal that the debt is only paying for infrastructure is, strictly speaking, true, but debt wouldn’t have to be raised without the tax cuts. There’s no getting away from this. They are raiding the Reserve Bank’s cookie jar and borrowing from foreigners for an irresponsible spending and tax cutting budget.

The Labour line of not borrowing for tax cuts is dead and discredited.  Now as I have said, I actually do not have a problem with borrowing for capital investment so long as the operating surplus (OBEGAL) remains positive and large enough to cover the Cullen Fund and a buffer on top of that. But OBEGAL will not be high enough to even cover the Cullen Fund until 2016.

Also, their argument that only National will fund big tax cuts with big cuts in government spending is also dead. Buried in the budget is a line about unspecified spending cuts totalling NZ$1 billion over the next four years that Labour will have to find to help pay for the tax cuts. Dr Cullen flat out refused to answer my question in the lockup about what type of spending cuts they would be. The only answer he could have given is that he hasn’t dreamt them up yet. We can be sure he won’t enlighten us before the election.

Indeed, Labour is wailing in the House about how John Key will cut spending, and have cut $1.5 billion over three years themselves. They really have no shame.

Any of the last vestiges of Dr Cullen’s hard-won reputation for fiscal conservatism went down into that kitchen sink of pre-election goodies. This is a tragedy for a finance minister who could rightly say until today that he had been one of the most level-headed and careful of economic guardians in our history.

It really has been from Jekyll to Hyde.

Financial markets are greedy, reactive and selfish at the best of times. But they often cut to the nub of an announcement in a flash. Within minutes yesterday, they judged this budget as inflationary enough to make the Reserve Bank’s inflation-fighting task more difficult and therefore likely to delay interest rate cuts.

The New Zealand dollar surged over 78.5 US cents and wholesale interest rates rose sharply.

If Bollard cuts rates now, he’ll deserve to be sacked for repeatedly missing his target.

Here’s Helen Kevans from JP Morgan:

The significant loosening of fiscal policy via larger than expected income tax relief delivered in Budget 2008, and the significant increase in government spending, will leave little scope for the RBNZ to cut interest rates in coming months. Futures market pricing implies rate cuts could come as early as next month, but this now looks much less likely.

And here’s Khoon Goh, ANZ National’s senior economist and interest rate strategist:

This is the largest fiscal stimulus since the 1997 tax cuts. Even with the deteriorating economic outlook, such a sizable package will have the RBNZ on notice. Not enough for them to hike, but certainly enough for them to be wary of the potential reflationary role fiscal policy could play.

Any smidgen of satisfaction or hope from Cullen and Clark that this budget might be able to rise above our stagflationary morass was wiped out in an instant.

This rise in the currency and interest rates will hurt us all and almost immediately. This is another kick in the guts for exporters. Businesses relying on variable interest rates are likely to pay almost immediately, either in the form of higher interest rates or in interest rate cuts that now won’t eventuate.

And at the end of the day it is about growing the national income, not just how to spend it.

It all seems so pointless now. This Budget aimed to put between $12 and $28 a week of tax cuts into wage earners’ pay packets from October 1, a few weeks before the election. However, any taxpayer with a $200,000 mortgage who misses out on a 0.5% cut in interest rates will miss out on $19 a week in lower interest payments. About $40 billion of fixed rate mortgages will roll over between now and the election. The interest rates on those will be around 9.5%, up from around the 8% they fixed at two years ago. That’s nearly $60 a week in extra interest costs. Let’s not forget the $60 to $70 extra in food and petrol costs too for most families.

They giveth with one hand and taketh with the other.

Dr Cullen and Miss Clark have failed the central challenge of our times. We must throw the kitchen sink at beating inflation and turning around a slide into stagflation. Leaders take tough decisions in tough times and we respect them for it. The tax cuts should have been postponed and government spending should have been restrained. Any new spending should have been focused on infrastructure and productivity increases.

This Budget was collectively the most expedient, shortsighted and venal decision in nine years of this Labour government.

It will be their last.

No-one can accuse Bernard of mincing his words. But he is right to be concerned. This budget may give us stagflation for several years if we are not careful – high inflation, high interest rates and low economic growth.

Some commentators have speculated that this could be deliberate. That Labour know they will probably lose in 2008, but that they can reduce National to a one term Government if they leave them a stagflating economy, as people always blame the Government in power. Bill English will have his work cut out repairing the damage.

Another stolen policy

Health Research?

From Murray McCully’s newsletter:

Lobbyists Scam Health Budget
Amongst the apparent beneficiaries of yesterday’s Budget was an outfit called the Health Research Council, originally established to award grants for valuable scientific research in the health sector. In the last financial year it received nearly $70million from the nation’s taxpayers. And yesterday Dr Cullen announced that health research would be boosted by $4 million. The Council is part of a wider portfolio of science funding totalling $550 million, accorded critical review in previous editions of this newsletter. And this week it is the turn of the Health Research Council to receive such constructive scrutiny.

Members of the Health Research Council are appointed on the advice of the Minister of Health. The primary function of the Council, according to S6 of the Health Research Council Act is “to advise the Minister on national health research policy…” So the Council is, through the Minister, responsible to Parliament and it is funded through an appropriation granted by Parliament.

Last year the Health Research Council decided to approve a grant of $701,000 to a group of researchers from the Wellington School of Medicine, a branch of Otago University, to study “policymaking to reduce smoking around children.” The fact that said group of researchers might accurately be described as anti-tobacco activists is underlined by the fact that the application discloses over $1.8 million in grants to members of the group for tobacco-related research over the previous three years.

The summary makes clear what the research will actually involve: “Smokefree policies can be expanded by government policies,” we are told. “So as to help advocates, this research aims to determine obstacles/opportunities within policy processes, for interventions appropriate to specific population groups.”

The subsequent detail makes it clear what the thrust of the research involves: “recorded face to face anonymous transcribed interviews will be conducted with at least 55 past/current politicians…” In addition to researching “policy statements, official advice and party policies,” the project will include “searches for relevant voting records and statements by politicians during the period from 1996 to the present.” All of this, a bargain at $701,000.

So it works like this: a Research Council that is being funded by Parliament to provide quality research for Parliament in the area of health science is instead spending that money researching the Members of Parliament themselves, their speeches, their advisors and their voting records. And the purpose of this exercise is not to come up with new scientific discoveries that might benefit the health sector, but, in their own words, “to help advocates.”

So taxpayers’ money that should be advancing the health of New Zealanders by funding new scientific breakthroughs is instead funding the preparation of resource material for lobbyists about the Members of Parliament who gave them the money in the first place. Which will presumably be useful because those same lobbyists will also be able to lobby for increased health science funding which can then be diverted into further lobbying. Which of course, is what our foolish Government has just done to the tune of $4 million a year. Isn’t that just the scam of the century?

So basically this was a $700,000 grant paid to anti-smoking activists for them to research on how they can be more successful activists!!

I’d like to get a grant from the Health Research Council so I can interview people on how I could be a better blogger!

There have been other examples in the past of how the Government funds lobby groups to lobby Parliament. It is quite simply wrong. Lobby groups should not be taxpayer funded for their lobbying. It is fine to be funded for other activities but it is the thin end of a corruption wedge to have the Government fund lobbying of MPs.

Not touchy – there were two polls

The good folk at Fairfax have informed me that there was no change to their poll on Stuff as I blogged yesterday, and no complaint from the 9th floor. I was confused ((c) Mike Williams) between a poll on the main Stuff site and a poll on The Press site. Now The Press’ site is part of Stuff with the same look and feel but it is editorially independent.

So both polls were on Labour Leadership. I saw one which merely had Goff vs Clark (The Stuff one) and then the other one which had references to this being hypothethical (the Press one) and did not realise they were different polls, and assumed it was the one poll which had been changed.

So my stuff up, but in my defence it can be confusing. Look at the front page of Stuff today and their poll is “Did Michael Cullen’s tax cuts meet your expectations?” with a “Yes” and “No” option. Then go to The Press front page and their poll is “Hooray – tax cuts are here. But is Finance Minister Michael Cullen’s generosity enough” with options of “Yes”, “No” and “I didn’t want a tax cut anyway. I’ll send it back.” They are asking (again) similar questions but in a slightly different way.

Fot those interested the Stuff poll had:

Goff 4,398 56.2%
Clark 3,433 43.8%

And The Press had in relation to would Goff be a good sucessor:

Yes 1,510 75.4%
No 316 15.8%
Your hypothetical question is not welcome 177 8.8%

I’ve amended the original post to make it clear it was wrong.

Drinnan on Broadcasting Ministers

John Drinnan in his media column look at the last four Broadcasting Ministers.

First he looks at TVNZ’s game playing:

Television New Zealand is trying to outbid TV3 for rights to Fox Television programming – begging awkward questions about the taxpayers-can-pay logic underpinning the Kiwi television business.

The state broadcaster has been crying poor. It can’t deliver profits, it has to cut back its news operations and starting this year it needs taxpayer subsidies for the Sunday current affairs programme.

Yet TVNZ – which already holds the rights to Warner Bros and Disney content – is willing to bid tens of millions of dollars to challenge TV3 for shows like Boston Legal, House and The Simpsons.

They would fill TVNZ programming vaults to overflowing and devastate TV3. Then – a delicious irony this – the Government releases TVNZ submissions that accuse Sky Television and its free channel, Prime, of being a domineering, acquisitive menace in the TV world.

Outraegous that TVNZ is trying to steal broadcasting rights off the sports codes who own them.

Then he looks at the Broadcasting Ministers:

Maurice Williamson: “Minister of Market Forces.”

Williamson was an admirer of entrepreneurs Craig Heatley and Terry Jarvis who started the pay-TV firm. Lack of regulation ensured that it was able to grow swiftly and unencumbered. To be fair, Williamson inherited a new system from Labour that was light on regulations Like Telecom, Sky was small, and during his era at least, no threat to anybody.

Marian Hobbs: “Minister of Muddles.”

The road to hell is paved with good intentions, and there were lots of potholes during Marian Hobbs era as Broadcasting Minister. It was a period marked by muddled ideas about social and cultural goals mixed with overseeing the Beehive’s paybacks to TVNZ for imagined wrongs.

… In her era Labour killed off TVNZ’s early, flawed aspirations for a digital strategy to challenge Sky – which some believe was a missed opportunity.

Steve Maharey: “Minister of Broadcasting Bureaucracy.”

Broadcasting was a minor portfolio for a busy minister; Maharey privately lamented the state of the portfolio he inherited from Hobbs. …

Maharey’s approach centred on giving TVNZ whatever cash it wanted with as little scrutiny as possible. An anti-Murdoch phobia held sway with the implementation of Freeview, a new platform for digital free-to-air television that would act as a counter to Sky.

Trevor Mallard: “Minister for Holding the Fort.”

Pragmatic Mallard is largely disinterested in his smallest portfolio, which he picked up when Maharey resigned from Parliament. Mallard was stunned by the “money for nothing” terms of state subsidies to TVNZ and approved by Maharey, and instituted changes.

I like the nicknames. So true.