MMP Referendum

The Sunday Star-Times reports that National is likely to hold a two-stage referendum on MMP, if elected.

It would be the height of hypocrisy for supporters of MMP to argue that the public should not get a chance to determine our type of electoral system.  That would be the worse kind of elitism.

Now of course one should not be changing the voting system every three years. But we are about to have our sixth election under MMP, and it is timely to give the voters a chance to confirm their choice in 1993/94, or modify it.

Now personally I would not vote to return to FPP. If the choice is between MMP and FPP, I would vote for MMP. But that in no way means I want to deprive my fellow voters of the chance to vote differently to me.

And there is the possibility one could end up with being able to choose between say MMP and STV.

Winston Peters is against the public having a say. I miht take the liberty to quote his party’s fundamental principles at him:

Electoral reform will be determined by the electors. The Government’s duty will be to ensure the fair representation of all views and the holding of appropriate referenda.

Of course he ignored this with the Electoral Finance Act, but surely he is not seriously arguing against the public having their say on the method of election MPs?

A UMR poll found around 67% of NZers want a referendum on MMP. However MMP itself has 42% support to 39% for FPP.

However it should not be seen just as a choice between MMP and FPP. STV, could be considered again as could SM.

The election date

Bill Ralston reports on speculation that the election date will be 18 October 2008.

My consistent position has been that the last date is the default date and no other date has been decided on, but that any time after the budget, Clark could tactically go early if the polls close enough or the Government gets some momentum.

The last five election dates are recorded as:

September 17, 2005
July 27, 2002
November 27, 1999
October 12, 1996
November 6, 1993

These are a bit misleading though. November is the traditional date, and I believe the date should be fixed for the last Saturday in November. Anyway we had November in 1993. The reason 1996 was early was because Michael Laws was forced to resign from Parliament in early 1996 and Bolger had to either allow a by-election or name a date within six months. If not for that, would probably have been November also.

1999 was November. Then there was a snap election in 2002 when Helen Clark used the preposterous excuse that Parliament was unmanageable because of points of order over the status of the Alliance. This was revealed to be around 11 minutes a day on average, so Clark has a history of going early purely for tactical reasons, with the flimsiest if excuses.

2005 was held on the last possible day, or close to it. Each election can be three years and 50 days or so after the previous one, so we have the chance this time to get it back to the traditional November date.

HoS calls for Bush to invade Burma

The HoS editorial calls on President Bush to lead a multinational force to move into Burma and ensure aid is delivered to those that need it.

There does come a point when a Government’s sovereignty becomes less important than the welfare of its citizens. Has this one reached that tipping point?

More goodness from Australian Labor

Deborah Coddington writes in the HoS:

In Sydney it was lead-up to Budget week, with speculation aplenty about tax cuts, means-testing for wealthy baby-boomers and – something New Zealand could pinch – grocery credits instead of welfare handouts for beneficiaries with a record of abusing and neglecting their children.

Somehow I can’t see Ruth Dyson introducing a similar policy. If Judith Collins is Minister of Social Welfare after the election she might give it a go, but I fear the feisty Collins will be held in check by the National Party apparatchiks as Ruth Richardson was.

Personally I wouldn’t want to be the person trying to hold Judith in check 🙂

It does show again how much more moderate Australian Labor is. They’re introduced policies which are unthinkable for NZ Labour, and if National introduced would be savaged as bashing beneficiaries. Never mind it would be in fact designed to help children at risk.

What I like about the Australian policy is it does not impose the grocery credits on all beneficiaries, just those with a record of neglect. That way it does not interfere with the vast majority of families receiving a benefit, who are caring for their kids.

Oh dear

The highlight of the conference today was the rather huge faux pas by a Young National during the environmental session.

He was asking a question to Nick Smith and was meant to ask about “organisms in water”. Sadly the confused wee boy asked about “orgasms in water”. He has been getting ribbed non stopped since. A large bribe into my bank account has persuaded me not to name him 🙂

Annihilation vs Slaughter

Smith on Labour’s environmental record

I’ve popped into National’s Lower North Island conference in Wellington for some of the speeches. First up was Nick Smith who assailed Labour’s environmental record. Nick pointed out the following under Labour:

  1. Carbon emissions increased 14%
  2. NZ placed 38th out of 43 for growth in emissions
  3. The proportion of energy produced from renewable sources has dropped from 72% to 66%
  4. Coal generated power has increased from 4% to 12%
  5. 75% of all new production has been thermal
  6. The first deforestation since 1952
  7. 40,000 hectares of forests destroyed in the last four years
  8. The Marine Reserves Bill has been stalled since 2001
  9. Funding for pest control has been cut
  10. No national policy statement produced, as promised, on biodiversity

As I heard and saw this, it got me thinking about why you never hear that from the Green Party? It is a mystery to many commentators that they are only at 6% or so, despite Labour having dropped into the 20s.

The Greens need to think about whether they really want to gain significant support or not. Unless they like being a minor prop to Labour, they should set a target of 12% to 15% of the vote – something high enough that it is impossible for a centre left Government to be formed that does not include them.

To do that though, they need to stop being so polite about Labour’s record of failures. They need to take to Labour, like NZ First took to National in 2002 – and NZ First got 11%.

Could you imagine the media reaction if at a leader’s debate you did not just have Jeanette or Russel saying “Oh yes Labour could have done more” but instead was saying that the record was a litany of failure on the environment. The Greens would be on the front page of every paper.

Now one can say that I am fomenting mischief and the Greens attacking Labour will not result in a centre left Government. That is true. However a centre left Government is looking a very remote possibility anyway. So do the Greens want to be a 6% party in Opposition or an 11% party, which would guarantee it a significant role in a future Government?

Armstrong puts it in context

John Armstrong puts the Mary-Anne Thompson issue into context of what responsibility Ministers have:

Try as he might, though, Cullen’s assurances to Parliament on Wednesday were never going to negate National’s assertion that Cabinet ministers were aware of the improper conduct by the head of the Department of Labour’s Immigration Service for months but did nothing about it until public exposure of that conduct forced some action.

It would be going far too far to say there has been a cover-up by ministers in the normal meaning of the term – a deliberate and sustained attempt to conceal what has really been going on.

But neither did those ministers go out of their way to reveal what had been going on.

Neither the Labour Department nor the State Services Commission felt any compunction to inform the public of last year’s inquiry into what was an astonishing breach of public service standards by someone running a major branch of a government department.

This is part of the wider problem in the public service, and the Government. The main focus has been on keeping things quiet and how to “politically manage” serious issues rather than actually confronting the core problems, and subjecting them to public scrutiny.

Ministers should have insisted that these breaches of law and policy be made public. They could have blanked out the names of staff involved.

Were it not for some concerted digging by journalists, the public would still be completely unaware of Thompson’s blatant conflict of interest in filling out residency application forms for close relatives. She would still have her job.

Once the details of the Thompson affair broke through the bureaucratic wall of silence, the two Cabinet ministers who already knew about the investigation inevitably looked complicit in officials’ inept and shoddy handling of the matter.

I think there is a growing realisation that one cannot trust internal inquiries anymore. National should seriously look at a replacement to the Serious Fraud Office which can also investigate the Government. I’ll post more on this at some later stage.

This has been an appalling week for Labour, with high-profile job losses, appalling retail sales data, the failure to be totally upfront about how much was paid to buy back the country’s rail services, further equivocation from Cullen on tax cuts just days out from the Budget, and yet another death knell-sounding opinion poll.

But hey Labour are helping with housing affordability a – a bold scheme to help oh 700 families out of the 1.5 million families in NZ!

Dom Post on Electoral Finance Act

The Dominion Post opines on the law of “common sense” known as the Electoral Finance Act:

In environs more typically frequented by murderers and rapists, election officials, National Party grandees and trade unionists gathered at the High Court in Wellington this week to determine whether the Engineering, Printing and Manufacturing Union is able to campaign during the upcoming election, The Dominion Post writes.

Elsewhere, signwriters were busy adding the name of a Labour Party official to the gaily painted Volkswagen that serves as Cabinet Minister Trevor Mallard’s mobile billboard to make it comply with new election rules.

The law of commonsense is in full swing. It is a law few realised held legislative sway till Justice Minister Annette King airily dismissed Opposition concerns about how new electoral laws would work by telling Parliament last November “the law of commonsense applies”.

This law of common sense which has been repeatedly broken by oh the Labour, NZ First and Green parties which voted for it. Such common sense they Ministers are breaking it.

Instead, the pedants responsible for overseeing election campaigns are insisting that politicians adhere to the arcane rules in an obscure piece of legislation entitled the Electoral Finance Act. We say obscure because Mr Mallard, the Labour Party and assorted other politicians who have been found to have breached it, are clearly unfamiliar with its contents. ACT’s Heather Roy, who breached the act by failing to include an authorisation statement in her weekly newsletter, can at least argue that she voted against it.

And this is the problem for its supporters. If National or ACT break it (which is almost inevitable at some stage) they can just say hey we said this was a bad, confusing law and despite our best efforts we got pinged. But those who voted for the law and foisted it on New Zealand will always face questions of why they are breaking a law they insisted was common sense and voted for.

“It’s one of those things that doesn’t seem entirely logical,” Mr Mallard said after being told his vehicle breached the act. Funnily enough that’s pretty much what the Electoral Commission, the Human Rights Commission and the Law Society said last year before Mr Mallard and 62 other MPs ignored widespread concern that the new rules were undemocratic and unclear.

They can hardly say they were not warned.

In retrospect, the teething problems caused by the new act appear to have been caused by a breakdown in communication.

Government irritation at being forced to jump through the ridiculous hoops created reveals it was never meant to hobble Government MPs, or even probably MPs of any persuasion, but rather to entangle other critics of the Government in a dense thicket of legalese and to limit to a pittance the amount they could spend advertising their views during election years.

Indeed the intention was to protect incumbents.

Sadly, for the Government, election officials have either misread or wilfully ignored the signals that have emanated from the Beehive and for some strange reason are applying the law to everybody. For that, the rest of us have reason to be grateful.

Indeed.

An example of how stupid the law is, can be seen by this very blurry photo below of a candidate’s name badge.

Yes you even need those fucking authorisation statements on a name badge – that’s the small writing at the bottom!

If National wins the election, it should introduce the bill to repeal the Electoral Finance Act immediately after electing the Speaker!

On the campaign trail

The NZ Herald has features on John Key and Helen Clark, as they are out on the campaign trail. First Armstrong following Key:

Some people just shake Key’s hand as he passes and express the hope that he wins and walk off. Votes in the bank. Those that do stop and chat almost on cue talk about it being”time for a change”. They don’t explain why.

This prevailing sentiment for “change” is extremely difficult for Labour to combat as it is based on feelings rather than cold hard logic.

A faltering economy will reinforce that sentiment. But National must be increasingly in two minds about the political advantages of a sharp downturn. One shopper sums things up. “I don’t envy you if you win,” he tells Key, as the entourage heads off to Napier’s seafront for his “ladies’ lunch”.

Indeed, National Governments always seem to come into office when the economy is heading downhill. Happened in 1975 and 1990. Key, if Prime Minister, will have a formidable challenge to grow the economy, slow the exodus, lift wages, cut taxes and maybe hardest of all actually implement a workable Emissions Trading Scheme.

The 29-year-old has voted Labour all her life, but she is not happy with the ruling party’s current direction. With four children and a husband who works full-time, she struggles to understand why Michael Cullen has not already cut taxes.

The irony is that the fiscal situation was far more conducive to cutting taxes from 2004 to 2007 than it is now. I doubt there is one other Finance Minister in the OECD who would not have cut taxes when there was a surplus of over $5,000 per household.

Meanwhile Paula Oliver is out with Helen Clark:

Clark handles the questions with a multi-pronged response. It is a style that isn’t reserved just for these students, but one she is using on her travels all around the country.

First she shows some empathy by acknowledging that the prices of some staple foods have risen faster than inflation, and petrol has zoomed up even more rapidly. “The family notices it in the car, and feeding teenagers who are always in the fridge,” she says with a wry grin to the students.

Then she breaks into what sounds like an Economics 101 lesson as she tries to project an image of someone who understands what is happening and is capable of leading the country through tighter times.

“The key thing for us is running the economy carefully,” Clark says, explaining that inflation remains a risk and the Government would prefer to see it slip back within the Reserve Bank’s target band of 1-3 per cent.

Then she reminds the students that Labour has only just days before done something to help with one aspect of the financial pinch – it delayed the introduction of transport into the climate change emissions trading scheme and thereby put off a further hike in petrol prices.

“We decided because people are already using less (petrol) as prices are high we shouldn’t push it up further,” Clark says.

Even though Clark is now 17% behind Key as Preferred PM, it is a useful reminder that she is a good campaigner, and while the fight may have gone out with some of her colleagues, it has not with her.

Labour’s support falls to half of National’s

The huge 27% gap in this morning’s Fairfax poll suggests that the electorate have not just taken the phone off the hook for Labour, but they have pulled it out of the wall, thrown it in a furnace and scattered the ashes out at sea.

One has to go back 18 years to find the last time a Government was 27% behind – late 1990.

And having the PM trail the Opposition Leader by 17% has never occurred before in a NZ poll.

Also noticeable is the first poll to have NZ First at 5%. It may just be a blip or it may suggest the start of a repeat of 2002, where Labour this time loses support to minor parties.

The total number of seats on this poll would be

  1. National 68
  2. Labour 35
  3. Green 7
  4. NZ First 6
  5. Maori Party 6
  6. ACT 1
  7. United 1
  8. Progressive 1

This would have Labour losing 15 MPs, going from 50 to 35. So who would be lost? Well first what seats would they be left with. If one assumes the electorate vote would also be 27% apart, then you have them also losing 17 electorate seats (including two to Maori Party) – retaining only Tamaki Makaurau (Mahuta), Mangere (WIlliams), Manukau East (Robertson), Manurewa (Hawkins), Mt Albert (Clark), Rongotai (King), Christchurch East (Dalziel), Te Atatu (Carter), New Lynn (Cunliffe), Christchurch Central (Burns), Mt Roskill (Goff), Dunedin South (Curran), Dunedin North (Hodgson) and Rimutaka (Hipkins).

With new candidates in Rimutaka, Dunedin South and Christchurch Central – even they could be vulnerable. But anyway if they hold 14 electorates, they will have 21 List MPs. Now we don’t know the list for 2008, but if we use the 2005 list that gives us an indicator, removing known retirements.

The 21 List MPs would be Cullen, Horomia, Mallard, Dyson, Ririruni, Burton, Tizard, Laban, Barker, Okeroa, Choudhary, Jones, Gosche, Gallagher, Chadwick, Hughes, Street, Parker, Fairbrother, Hereora and Pillay.

MPs who would miss out (if list ranked in same order) are: Mackey, Moroney, Fenton, Chauvel, Soper, and Wall plus those who were not on the list such as O’Connor, Duyhoven, and Cosgrove. And no new blood except maybe Burns, Curran and Hipkins – and none of those seats would definitely be safe with a 27% margin.

The poll suggests tax cuts are a major issue for many voters, and Labour’s refusal to deliver tax cuts despite surpluses per capita amongst the highest in the world is hurting them. This week will not just be too little, but also far too late. It is a deserved response for being so ideologically oppossed to tax cuts,, and even worse promising them in 2005 and cancelling them in 2007.

It is hard to see how Labour can pull back the gap. Their focus may need to shift on how to minimise the loss and still get some new MPs in. One thing they can do is to make it very clear that even if re-elected, this is Michael Cullen’s last budget. They will not win back support by campaigning for Michael Cullen to deliver a 10th, 11th and 12th budget.

Radio NZ on Internet Campaigning

Radio NZ has a four minute item on Internet campaigning, You Tube etc. They talked to myself, “Steve Pierson” from The Standard (who used his real name for the interview which is commendable), Darren Hughes, and Jo de Joux. Won’t have any revelations for those already online but will have been interesting to the wider listeners I hope.

Questions journalists should ask NZ First

NZ First has now filed its 2007 donation return, and have declared no donations over $10,000.

  1. Why did it take four and a half months to file a zero return?
  2. Why did NZ First break the law and refuse to file on time, saying the Leader had to be in the country before they filed, when it is a zero return?
  3. As Party President Dail Jones claimed they received a close to $100,000 donation in December 2007, what is the explanation? Did Jones imagine the bank statement showing the deposit or did he confuse it with something else?
  4. Could the mysterious amount received in December 2007 now be classified as an interest free loan, not a donation?
  5. Who is the Party Official and the Auditor that signed off the donation return?
  6. As Owen Glenn has refused to deny he has assisted NZ First, should one assume he has not assisted NZ First, or that any donation was under $10,000 or that it was an interest free loan?
  7. Is the reason NZ First has not paid back the $158,000 it owes because they had to refund a large donation?
  8. How did they raise $158,000 without any large donations? Lots of bingo evenings?
  9. When will NZ First reveal the charities they claim to be donating the $158,000 to or are we expected to just take their word for it?
  10. Again, why did it take four and a half months to file a nil donation return?

Shabby behaviour as usual

Just to show that there is no shame, have a look at how Labour Ministers both claimed wrongly a National MP had said something he had not, but then how nasty they get, and how the Speaker protects them. From yesterday:

Dr the Hon Lockwood Smith: What changed between the time when David Cunliffe, the then Minister of Immigration, was briefed, as he now alleges, on completion of the Oughton inquiry in July of last year, and when he himself was fully briefed in December last year on the Oughton report—what changed between then and April this year, when the Oughton report was exposed to public scrutiny, other than the fact that the cover-up was over?

Hon CLAYTON COSGROVE: In order to assist the member, I tell him that the previous Minister was not briefed in December. I was the Minister at that time.

Dr the Hon Lockwood Smith: I said you.

Hon CLAYTON COSGROVE: No, the member said “the Minister at the time”, and “the previous Minister”.

Now have a look at the Hansard.  Lockwood clearly refers to David Cunliffe as per-December and Cosgrove as the Minister in December as he says “he himself” in the question to Cosgrove. Cosgrove is clearly wrong with his insistance Lockwood had it wrong.

Hon Dr Nick Smith: You’re wrong.

Hon CLAYTON COSGROVE: I think we may need stretcher-bearers for one particular member. This is a serious issue, and should be dealt with in a serious way. We may need stretcher-bearers for the other Dr Smith. Can I say—

Now again remember Cosgrove is in the wrong here, and Nick Smith is correct in backing up Lockwood. So what does Cosgrove do – resort to the normal smear they use against Nick.

Hon Dr Nick Smith: I raise a point of order, Madam Speaker.

Madam SPEAKER: There is a point of order; it will be heard in silence.

Hon Dr Nick Smith: The Minister, in reciting my colleague Dr the Hon Lockwood Smith’s question, was mistaken in his restating of the course of events. In response to an interjection from me saying that he was wrong, I was then subjected to personal abuse. I think it would be helpful if Dr Smith re-asked his question—in which his dating and timing were correct—because it seems that the Minister was confused about the question that my colleague Dr Smith was asking.

Nick doesn’t respond to the taunt, but just makes the point that the Ministers were mistaken so the question should be re-asked, so the Minister addresses the correct question.

Hon David Parker: I, as well as Minister Clayton Cosgrove, listened carefully to the question, and I am clear that the question that was asked included the imputation that the Minister was the prior Minister, not the current Minister, and that is the point to which Mr Cosgrove was responding.

David Parker jumps in, and also has it clearly wrong, as the Hansard shows.

Madam SPEAKER: I thank members for their interventions. I think if members would keep the noise down, it would be easier to hear. As I have said, interjections do occasion responses. Would the Minister please just respond to the question as succinctly as possible.

Dr the Hon Lockwood Smith: I raise a point of order, Madam Speaker. It would appear that confusion has arisen around my question. It was very clear. I would be very happy to repeat it to avoid that confusion.

Madam SPEAKER: No, I think we should take it in the order it was. I am happy to look at the Hansard. I heard it also in the way that, I am afraid, others did. The member, obviously, feels that he did ask another question. As I said, I am happy to go and look at it later. Could we have a succinct answer to the question, and there is always an opportunity to ask another question—there are still supplementary questions available.

And now the Speaker also gets it wrong, and even worse won’t let Lockwood re-ask the question, despite the fact clearly the Ministers misheard what he said.

Hon Annette King: I raise a point of order, Madam Speaker. We are on question No. 8 and we have had Dr Nick Smith running interference on every question across the House. He is not asking questions; he is just interjecting and yelling out personal comments. I think we have just about had enough today, and I ask you to require him not to continue going on in that fashion.

Annette seems to have missed the log in her own colleague’s eyes.

Madam SPEAKER: Well, I think that today comments have been made from all sides of the House. Obviously, it does create disorder, and it has. Members have noted the comments that have been made from all sides of the House on this matter. Could I please ask the Minister to succinctly address the question, and then we will ask Dr Smith to ask the question again. Thank you.

And then the Speaker totally confused says Cosgove will answer/address the question, and then have it re-asked!!! And then it isn’t!

Labour have been warned many times over their repeated goes at Nick with references to taking pills, and now out on a stretcher. That is bad enough at any time, but Labour may wish to consider the old saying that those in glass houses should not throw stones.

A health sucess story

The NZ Herald reports on the successful Counties Manukau District Health Board which has had a 37% increase in elective surgery rates since 2004, and an 18% increase in total patient numbers – without an increase in facilities.

This shows that a combination of good governance, good management, good staff relations, and dedicated staff can make a real difference. It is not just about throwing money at the problem. Sure the DHB will have had funding increases which will have helped, but that is just part of the solution to improving health productivity.

The growing cover-ups

When the Mary-Anne Thompson scandal first was exposed (and kudos to One News who did the hard work making this all public), I tended to think it would not reflect much on Ministers, and was a case of inappropriate judgement which had been reprimanded. But the growing evidence is of another shabby little cover-up. Why do I say this? Well let us start with what was said in Parliament yesterday:

Dr the Hon Lockwood Smith: Given those terms of reference, why does the Minister allege that that inquiry was merely a matter relating to the employment of a staff member, when the actual final report of the inquiry was Review of Apparently Unlawful Immigration Decision?

Hon CLAYTON COSGROVE: The matter, as the member states, was in relation to an unlawful immigration decision actioned by an individual or individuals.

Note the stress on being actioned by individuals. This leads us to:

Hon CLAYTON COSGROVE: Well, those members preordain the answer to the question, which speaks volumes about them. The advice that that Minister received was the same advice that I received—that matters related to individual employees are employee matters. He was advised of that. He noted that it was a matter for the chief executive, because there is no employment relationship between Ministers and departments, and that is where it stands. He acted by the book. And I say this: if my predecessor or I had intervened unlawfully against section 33, I bet members $100 that that member would be asking a different series of questions about why Ministers had overreached their authority and breached the law. They cannot have it both ways, and the member knows it.

Dr the Hon Lockwood Smith: Is this Minister telling the House that the then Minister of Immigration, David Cunliffe, knew about the inquiry by David Oughton into unlawful decision-making in his department in April last year, yet never asked for or received a copy of the completed inquiry report, nor asked for a full briefing on that final report? Is that what he is telling the House—that David Cunliffe never asked for a full briefing on that final report?

Hon CLAYTON COSGROVE: No. I admire the member’s ability to twist words. What I am saying is that in April the Minister was briefed, and, latterly, in respect of the report, the Minister, like me, had no right to demand, and was precluded from demanding, a copy of that report or the contents—

Hon Bill English: That’s rubbish.

One has to stand back for a second to think about this level of sophistry. The issues is here that the NZ Immigration Service broke the law, broke its own policies, and made decisions it had no power to make – only the Minister could make. Now of course any such breaking of the law and policies has to have been done by individuals – there is no other way a Department can act except through individuals. But to then claim that the report is off limit to the Minister is ridicolous.

The Dominion Post reports on concerns (which I blogged on Wednesday) that the SIS did not pick up any issues in their vetting.

NZPA reports on the problems within the entire Pacific division:

Last night One News said it had obtained, under the Official Information Act, information showing about 60 people work in the division, and that in three years from 2004, 19 cases of serious offences were proven including theft, bribery and fraud. From the 19 cases, nine people were fired or resigned. Three were referred to police.

I suppose these are all employment issues also, which means nothing to do with the Minister.

But get this little gem, also from NZPA quoting Mary-Anne’s lawyer:

Ms Aikman said it appeared the SSC had known about allegations against Ms Thompson for four years but nothing was ever said.

Four years? Please tell me you are kidding.

I am not sure the problems in the Immigration Service can be fixed from within. When you consider the lies in unison scandal (which the parent Department also tried to whitewash), I think a Commission of Inquiry may now be needed.

The battle for the Local Govt NZ Presidency

Two Mayors are standing for the presidency of Local Government NZ. Lawrence Yule from Hastings and Wellington’s Kerry Prendergast.

I have the privilege of knowing both contenders, so can say I think it is excellent they whatever the decision, Local Government NZ will be well served.

I’ve known Kerry (and Rex) for a long time, as you would expect in the small city that is Wellington. Lawrence I have got to know through a mutual friend and he is a very nice guy.

Nominations are open until 31 May, so there may be other contenders. It’s a pretty high profile and influential position so will be interesting to see how it goes.

Frog endorses a market response

Frog Blog notes that Afghan farmers are converting their farms from poppy growing to wheat due to the low prices for heroin and high prices for food.

Good to see Frog so approving of a market solution to a problem, rather than a regulatory solution.

On ZB from 11 to 12

Some questions?

  1. Why has Steve Maharey not resigned as MP for Palmerston North, now he can do so without triggering a by-election? Does anyone think you can be Vice-Chancellor and an MP?
  2. Has NZ First paid back its $158,000 yet?
  3. Have United Future finished paying back the money it owes to Parliamentary Service?
  4. Why have NZ First and ACT not yet filed their 2007 donations return, 16 days after the deadline?
  5. Would Rod Donald have approved of manipulating MMP rules so that Russel Norman becomes an MP (scheduled for end of the month) with less than 30 house sitting days before the election? Is this not just an outrageous rort to allow Russel to use taxpayer funds to travel around the country for the campaign?
  6. Why would Labour’s website not list a single candidate who has been selected of the election? Is it because that is the only way they can get the taxpayer to fund 100% of it. Should Labour pay me for listing their candidates for them?
  7. If Winston is back in NZ now, why hasn’t any journalist asked him why they have broken the law by refusing to file their donations return, and why does it need the party leader to file a donations return?
  8. Has the Crown Law Office yet decided whether a balloon is an election advertisement?
  9. How big a mistake was it for Dr Cullen to cancel in last year’s budget the tax cuts he promised in 2005?
  10. How much damage did that conference song on John Key do to Labour? Was it more or less than the global economic slowdown?

UPDATE: For (4) The Electoral Commission has now received and published the ACT and NZ First returns.

The Electoral Pendulum

Last election Labour got 2% more support on the party vote but it was a near exact tie on the electorate vote with National and Labour not just winning 31 seats each, but receiving a near identical proportion of total electorate votes with National 40.38% and Labour 40.35%.

Now I have put together in excel a little pendulum to calculate what sort of margin is needed in the electorate vote for a seat to go from Labour to National, assuming a standard swing. Of course you never have a standard swing, but it is the only thing to go with. I am using the 2005 election results but adjusted to take account of the 2008 boundaries.

How I have done the calculation is if for example National has a 6% lead in the electorate vote, I take that to be that National gains 3% (half of 6%) at the expense of Labour. You then divide 3% by the overall National electorate vote last time of 40% and apply it to the actual National vote for that electorate.

The bottom line is it means one can look at a poll result, and see what seats would change hands based on the gap between National and Labour on the electorate vote. Now only One News Colmar Brunton publish specific electorate vote results, and their last result was National 52% Labour 34% or a lead of 18%. For other polls one can take the party vote margin as a rough guide to the likely electorate vote margin, as the two tend to follow each other quite closely unless there is a freakishly low party vote result like for National in 2002.

So what are the the seats most vulnerable for Labour, to National. In order they are:

  1. Taupo -2.6%
  2. Rotorua -1.1%
  3. Otaki 0.9%
  4. Hamilton West 3.2%
  5. West Coast-Tasman 4.1%
  6. Palmerston North 13.2%
  7. Auckland Central 14.1%
  8. New Plymouth 14.8%
  9. Waimakariri 16.6%
  10. Port Hills 17.2%
  11. Wellington Central 17.6%
  12. Maungakiekie 22.2%
  13. Hutt South 24.6%
  14. Waitakere 25.8%
  15. Mana 26.6%
  16. Rimutaka 28.8%
  17. Dunedin North 29.2%

The negative figures for Taupo and Rotorua indicate they are already National in terms of a paper majority on the new boundaries, and that Labour would need to score more votes nationwide than National to retain those seats on a standard swing.

A 10% electorate vote lead for National would see five seats go to National on a standard swing. At 15% lead it is eight seats and at 18% it is 11 seats. Now on top of those seats, Labour also look likely to lose two (arguably three) seats to the Maori Party so if there is a 18% gap in the electorate vote, Labour would be reduced to 17 or 18 electorate seats and National would have 43 electorate seats.

Now again, swings are never standard. Candidates and regional variations all have an influence. But the pendulum does show what seats may be first to swap hands.

The Electoral Finance Act and the Bill of Rights

The NZ Herald reports on the arguments in court yesterday on the Electoral Finance Act:

Aucklander John Boscawen – a fierce opponent of the Electoral Finance legislation – along with ACT MP Rodney Hide, Sensible Sentencing Trust spokesman Garth McVicar and Grey Power president Graham Stairmand, want to take a case to court, seeking a declaration that Attorney General Michael Cullen should have told Parliament that the law breached the Bill of Rights.

In the High Court at Wellington yesterday, Dr Cullen sought to have the case struck out. Crown lawyer John Pike argued that parliamentary privilege prevented the court from inquiring into the content of the legislation and the debate around it, and also that there was no settled legal view that the court could declare that the Electoral Finance Act was inconsistent with the Bill of Rights.

It is important to note the arguments yesterday were on the Crown’s application to strike the lawsuit out on the grounds of parliamentary privilege. It is only if they get past this strike out attempt, will the principal issues of whether the EFB and EFA breach the Bill of Rights get determined.

The legal arguments took all day and traversed time and space – judgments from three centuries, spanning four continents, were cited by lawyers from both sides. Justice Denis Clifford reserved his decision, a judgment which will instigate an intense constitutional debate on the roles of Parliament and the courts if he permits the case to proceed.

Nikki Pender, for Boscawen and the other complainants, said the Electoral Finance Act contained myriad provisions which breached the Bill of Rights, and that the Attorney General should have warned Parliament of that – as section seven of the Bill of Rights obliged him to do.

In a sense there are two issues here – whether the Electoral Finance Bill as originally drafted breached the Bill of Rights and whether the final Electoral Finance Act is inconsistent with it.

The NZ Law Society and Human Rights Commission (and almost every lawyer in NZ who has offered an opinion on this) is adamant the original EFB was in breach, and I would put the chance of victory there as well over 95% if the strike out application is unsuccessful. I mean the original EFB would have required every NZer to swear a statutory declaration before even offering an opinion on a political issue. It was, to quote Nicky Hager, something you would expect from the Nazi Party.

The final version of the EFA, while still seriously flawed in my opinion, certainly was a significant improvement over the original EFB and the arguments over how it stacks up with the Bill of Rights are more finely balanced.

Since the 1st of January there have been around 470 articles (and from what I can tell not a single one is favourable to the EFA or the Government) in the NZPA database mentioning the Electoral Finance Act. The Government hoped it would disappear as an issue within a few weeks, and instead it has been a relentless string of negative stories.

I am looking forward to the first reading of the Electoral Finance Repeal Act – hopefully it can be introduced before Christmas.

Cullen ruled election advertisement for National

The Dim-Post reports that the Chief Electoral Office has ruled that Michael Cullen needs to be authorised by the National Party as an election advertisement:

Chief Electoral Officer Robert Peden has warned the National Party that they are in breach of the Electoral Finance Act for failing to register Finance Minister Michael Cullen as an election advertisement.

‘Anything seen to be encouraging voters to support a particular party or individual counts as advertising,’ Peden stated in his ruling. ‘In this regard Dr Cullen is clearly a National Party advertisement.’

National are also in trouble for allowing Cullen to appear in public without prominently displaying the name and address of the party’s financial agent. …

The best satire has that element of truth to it, and this one so hits the mark.

The prostitute news reader

The Waikato Times has done a bit of detective work and discovered that Alt TV news reader Lisa Lewis is not just an occasionally topless girl, but in fact a prostitute.  Now the detective work wasn’t too difficult as Ms Lewis uses her own name on the escorts website.

Ms Lewis is not for the poor though. Her “full service” rate starts at $1,000 for an hour.  Hell that’s almost as much as a lawyer!

The stench of impending death

The Press Political Editor, Colin Espiner blogs on today’s lacklustre pre-Budget briefing by Michael Cullen:

There comes a point in the life cycle of every government when the stench of impending political death threatens to overwhelm the senses. I think Labour may have reached that point today.

Strong words, but everything is going wrong for the Government at the moment.

But the main reason this year was different was because there was virtually no one there. Now, I’ve been following Cullen to business lunches and breakfasts for the best part of a decade, and this was the smallest audience I can ever remember him addressing. For the main pre-Budget address it was pathetic.

I counted 30 people sitting listening to him over their smoked salmon and sav blanc. Last year, organisers tell me around 80 turned up.

That is quite incredible. In NZ’s second largest city, only 30 people wanted to hear what the Minister of Finance would say.

There’s no question Prime Minister Helen Clark still has the fire in her belly, but I didn’t see anything approaching that from the Treasurer today. Frankly he looks like he’s given up the ghost.

The same applies in the House. David Parker looked awful the other day.

Maybe I’m wrong. Cullen is a master poker player. It’s just possible he has several aces up his sleeve for next week, and he’s been bluffing us all along. But if that’s the case, I wonder if he’s left playing his hand a bit late.

By the time he shows his cards, there’ll be no one left to read them.

Oh there will be some surprises in the budget, but nevertheless I think it is all too late.