A new Kyoto total

What is the total cost of the second hand trains and ferries?

It gets scary when you start to add up the total cost of Dr Cullen’s buying spree.

Now one can always argue about what an asset is worth, but we actually know that Toll purchased it for $394 million in 2003. And the book value is $430 million.

Now Toll convinced the Government to pay $665 million for it. But on top of that you have the foregone revenue from Toll for track use, which has been $48 million a year, but is meant to be $58 million a year. If you capitalise that at 7% that is another $830 million equivalent capital. So the Government has effectively tied up capital of around $1.5 billion. In theory there will be income to offset that, but time will tell as to how much that will be.

But it gets even better for Toll. They also get a six month rent free period on existing premises – must be worth a few million also.

The Fairfax story quotes Toll managing director Paull Little as saying:

“I think we’ve got mixed emotions. We would have preferred not to have sold.

“Today is a day we feel pretty flat,” he said.

I’ll bet you they have no mixed emotions at all. The sale agreement probably included a no gloating clause. Toll have made a massive profit from Dr Cullen. I doubt they can beleive their luck.

I know something about dealing with an Australian company when selling or buying a business. Let me tell you they are the most ruthless bastards around. No matter how friendly and nice it all is, they will aim to screw you for every extra dollar. It is nothing personal – just how they do business. So even if it is a multi-million dollar sale, they’ll take you for an extra $20,000 if they can – just because they can.

And Dr Cullen had shown how keen he was to buy. This was a fatal mistake which strengthened Toll’s negotiating position massively. You have to have the other side thinking you are prepared to walk away if they don’t budge.

I could just have imagined the talk around Toll after each negotiating session. “Oh my God, we have them up to $600 million – who would have believed. Hey let’s go for $650 million just to see how desperate they are. Nah, don’t be a soft cock – I reckon we should ask for $700 million and see if we can get them over $650 million”.

The fuel tax retreat

The Government is pushing through Parliament legislation allowing local bodies to impose additional petrol taxes of 10c  litre to fund roading and public transport in their areas.

There is nothing in the legislation suggesting this will be phased in, but suddenly Helen Clark is claiming it is ridicolous to suggest people will be paying more next year for their petrol, and any new taxes will be phased in over many years,

I challenge anyone to go back to when this law was announced and see if you can find any reference to phasing such taxes in and not allowing it to be implemented in one go.

They say they won’t allow any big increases in the fuel tax.  That pledge will last as long as Labour’s 2005 pledge to cut taxes – until the day after the election.

Ferries and trains owned by the state again

We’re back to the future with the Government giving Toll a huge wallop of cash for their trains and ferries. Toll will be laughing all the way to the bank with their $665 million.

There is a case for the Government to own core infrastructure assets, but I am far from convinced it needs to own the companes that operate on them.

$665 million would do far more for NZ investing in future infrastructure such as fibre-optic cables, than some second hand ferries and trains.

John Key has already said that they won’t be selling any assets in their first term, so I guess we are stuck with them for the foreseeable future. I just hope someone keeps track of how much money we throw into keeping them viable, and what the opportunity cost of investing that money elsewhere is.

$230 million in four years

The cost of running the Government has soared in recent years. The lack of basically any fiscal restraint has seen staff numbers in the bureaucracy explode, with subsequent flow on effects on property prices in Wellington – both commercial and residential. One property investor told me that thanks to Labour has had made $400 million since they came to office, as the demand for more office space has sent rents up up up.

Now Gerry Brownlee has done a release on a great example – the Electricity Commission. This was set up by Labour. We didn’t use to have one. We survived many decades without one. Policy was done in the Commerce and now Economic Development Ministry. But a standalone body was needed to help with better planning. Never mind that every second year we are having “one in sixty years” power shortages.

So how much is this small little quango costing? Well in the last financial year it now costs $80 million a year. Want to know why power prices keep going up? Part of it is to fund the Electricity Commission – around $50 a household.

Another great example is the Tertiary Education Commission. For many years we never had done. The universities were basically self managing, and the Ministry of Education had maybe a couple of dozen staff in the tertiary sector. Labour set up the TEC and its initial years can only be deemed a miserable failure. Rorts involving low quality near worthless courses cost the taxpayer close to a billion dollars – and all on TEC’s watch.

And what has TEC cost? In the year to 30 June 2007 it was around $60 million. So these two new bodies are costing $140 million a year. Now this is not to say there is no value in what they do. But what has been so woefully missing is a hard tough look at value for money. A new Government should take a zero based approach to some Government spending and make sure existing spending is necessary, before even considering additional spending.

And no that is not some mad far right slash and burn policy. It is exactly what Labor PM Kevin Rudd is doing in Australia. Sadly it has been sorely lacking here.

More revelations re Immigration Service

The Sunday Star-Times reveals more information about the Immigration Service, and with great sadness I am starting to conclude that Mary-Anne Thompson’s position is becoming untenable. She appears to have shown a lack of judgement which is incompatible with the role she holds. What is strange is how out of step this lack of judgement is, with what has been a very successful career founded on sound judgement and ability. I can just presume people develop a blind spot when it comes to trying to help their own family.

In one article, the SST reveals:

It was December 2004, Christmas was fast approaching and, in an email to an immigration official, Thompson made it clear that the matter was urgent.

“We would like them to stay with us for three months for a significant family function, and then return to their families,” she wrote, adding “my husband and I are flying to Nadi to meet them (a surprise for them).”

The Fiji-based official, whose name is blanked out in documents released under the Official Information Act, was only too eager to help, arranging visa waivers, usually reserved for emergencies. He even provided his mobile and home numbers in case the family ran into any trouble on arrival in Fiji.

About four months later, Thompson was at it again, asking for assistance to get more family members to New Zealand. “My preference would be a visa waiver, given the certainty of [names deleted] returning back to Kiribati and given that they will live with me and our family,” she wrote.

I am amazed that Thompson was personally e-mailing staff (something which I am sure is not available to members of the public) asking for visa waivers. It doesn’t matter at all that she was not explicitly asking them to break any rules. When you are effectively the Head of the Immigration Service, you can not be and should not be in any way involved with immigration issues concerning your family. The mere fact that a staff member is dealing with their ultimate boss can only be seen as pressure on them.

Thompson should have got another family member (such as her husband) to do the applications, and deal with Immigration Service staff members. It is just incredibly inappropriate to do what she did.

They also talk in some detail about the application which was approved outside the rules:

Flesher says she told the branch manager, Nancy Sandoy, that the application was outside the timeframe. Sandoy said the application should be processed, but said she would make a call, Flesher says. According to Flesher, about a week later Mai Malaulau, the Pacific division director based in Wellington, appeared in the office, brought the file to her desk and said: “Put it in the system, there are slots available in the grid.”

This is what happens when you are the head of the Immigration Service and you get involved in applying for your family. You may not have asked anyone to do favours for you, but who really wants to turn down the boss’ family?

Gordon Campbell on The Listener

Gordon Campbell, a former Listener journalist, writes on Scoop about Pamela Stirling’s description of the “old” Listener as “the house journal of the Alliance Party”. I comment on his comments:

It is not the first time the former Listener as ‘house journal of the Alliance Party’ line has been floated by Stirling. Whether this is the intention or not, the effect is to portray her tenure as having more journalistic integrity than her predecessors, and her staff as being more professional than staff in the past.

I don’t see her comments as meaning a lack of integrity or professionalism. I see it as a comment on the lack of diversity of views the Listener used to have. Just as the NBR doesn’t exactly have a lot of articles promoting higher taxes either. A magazine can have an ideological bent but still be ethical and professional – look at the UK newspapers. The problem comes when a publication has an ideological bent but tries and denies it.

The reality is that the Listener was never the sort of doctrinaire publication that the “Alliance house journal” jibe would suggest. Its spirit was liberal, compassionate and contrarian. The voice it had in our national debate was alternative in the best sense, of standing apart from the mainstream and analyzing it critically. It was that contrarian spirit that saw the Listener endorse MMP, and run fair and balanced profiles of Roger Kerr, Lindsay Perigo, Winston Peters and other polarising figures in its pages.

Of course the Listener in the past has had fair and balanced ((c) Fox News) features. But overall it was very predictably leftwing. The test I used to apply to it was whether I could accurately predict the substance of a story based on just knowing the topic off the cover. And 95% of the time I could – it was almost without fail the left liberal view of the world.

This was in marked contrast to say North & South where I could see they were covering a topic, but never really know what sort of position or angle they would take on it, until I had actually read it.

Now I have no problem with any publication (so long as not state funded) having an ideological leaning. But to try and argue that no such leaning existed, does people a disservice.

In my experience, we at the Listener tended to have a healthy skepticism towards everyone – including Labour when in power in the 80s ( the Listener invented the term ‘Rogernomics’ and it wasn’t meant as flattery) National in the 90s, and Labour again early this decade. Consistently, the Listener bit the hand of power, and would then explain in 2,500 reasoned words why it felt the need to do so.

It is true that the Listener has railed against every Government from the 1980s onwards – but almost always for not being left wing enough. I don’t recall any articles complaining about the killing off of choice in accident compensation, or complaining about making union membership compulsory for employees who want a collective contract. Just being critical of both National and Labour Governments does not mean you are not free of ideological slant.

What the Listener used to stand for was intellectual depth, critical analysis of the left and the right, good arts pages and Bradford’s Hollywood. It was a great ragbag of a read. Again, I beg to differ with Stirling – the current Listener seems anything but diverse. It exhibits instead an increasingly narrow fixation on the lifestyle choices and social anxieties of a baby boomer elite. Someone recently suggested to me that a typical Listener cover story nowadays would run something along the lines of “Is Your House Making You Fat?”

Here Campbell is on stronger grounds. I do find the Listener pretty trite at times, but this tendency pre-dates Stirling to be fair. Around seven or eight years ago I decided to keep getting the Listener mainly for its columnists, having gone off their features as often superficial. Sadly it is not only the Listener going this way – Metro and North & South are now pale shadows of their former glory.

Brash on GST

Don Brash chaired the committee that established GST in the 1980s, so is pretty much an expert in this area. He labels any move to remove GST on food as a “seriously stupid thing to do”.

… we gave serious consideration to exempting food from GST at that time, and decided for three reasons not to do so. Those reasons are still absolutely valid today.

First, it is clear that every exemption from GST adds greatly to the compliance costs imposed on businesses collecting the tax. …

Secondly, abolishing GST on food would be a very inefficient way of helping those low-income families who most need help with their food bills in terms of the amount of government revenue foregone.

While it is certainly true that low-income families spend a disproportionately large part of their income on food, most of the money spent on food across the whole community, and therefore most of the revenue which would be lost if GST on food were abolished, is paid by middle and high-income families. If the Government sees a need to help those families most adversely affected by rising food bills, then the best way of doing that is by reducing the income tax levied on low-income families, or adjusting the Working for Families policy to help those on low incomes.

Thirdly, if GST is abolished on food, why not on other “essentials”, like children’s clothing, doctor’s bills, books, and the like? In no time at all, political pressures would build up to exempt other goods and services.

Compliance costs would go through the roof. Revenue from GST would fall, with the result that the GST rate of tax would need to rise on the goods and services still subject to the tax (as has happened in most European countries). Or income tax rates would need to be higher than would otherwise be necessary.

New Zealand has one of the best GST systems in the world. Don’t succumb to short-term pressures to bastardise it.

All excellent arguments. Luckily Labour are not showing signs of panic and are not looking likely to give in to the calls to do so.

What to do about carbon emissions

Despite Helen Clark’s rhetoric of carbon neutrality, her Government looks poised to do a u-turn and delay aspects of the proposed emissions trading scheme, as political reality starts to bite that you can’t refuse to give tax cuts for nine years and just keep loading cost increases on.

So how should NZ proceed? A few views starting with the Dominion Post:

There is little doubt that the way to reduce carbon emissions is to make them costly, and the emissions trading scheme will achieve that. The question is how far New Zealand should go and whether, for example, it makes sense for it to be the only country to include agricultural emissions.

The need for caution is only underlined by the reality of the New Zealand contribution to global warming. New Zealanders may be large producers of emissions on a per capita basis, but overall contribute about 0.2 per cent of the world’s total. …

Against that background, rushing to lock in New Zealand’s policy is foolish. A more measured approach, with targets linked to what others do, rather than stand-alone statements of ecological purity, is more sensible.

The Hive puts forward a proposed consensus:

  • that a modest greenhouse gas tax be introduced across all sectors as an interim action (there would be an immediate incentive to individuals and business to change behavior – the greater the amount of behavior change the less tax paid)

  • that personal and business taxes be cut by exactly the same amount as the amount that the greenhouse gas tax is expected to raise (thus removing the “cost” of the tax to the overall economy)

  • that Government agree that all revenues raised by the greenhouse gas tax be used to invest in greenhouse gas reduction technologies

  • that New Zealand seek a plurilateral approach to greenhouse gas reduction involving Australia, Japan, EU and the US (ie we all introduce the same policy thus reducing the scope for leakage to occur

  • that we increase the resource devoted to negotiating the replacement for Kyoto I.

I have considerable sympathy for this views, especially Points 1 and 4. The price of carbon is so uncertain that in the short term a tax may be preferable. If carbon reaches $50 a tonne, then reports suggest our farming industry may become unviable. What is especially important though is that any ETS we devise should not be stand alone, but at a minimum ih harmony with Australia, and preferably other major trading partners.

Bill Ralston looks at an inconvenient truth:

New Zealand produces 0.4 per cent of the world’s carbon emissions. This move will reduce our national emissions by 0.1 per cent. So, we are going through all this pain to reduce the world’s pollution by 0.1 per cent of 0.4 per cent. Meanwhile the planet’s greatest polluters, not tied by the Kyoto Protocol because they never signed it, continue to pump increasing amounts of crud into the atmosphere and reap the financial rewards of doing so. So much for New Zealand’s international competitiveness.

This is of course not a reason to do nothing, but the NZIER report points out if we act unilaterally then “carbon leakage” may mean that we suffer economic pain without the environmental gain.

Temperatures

I have to admit I don’t get cold a lot. Ever since I lived in Dunedin, my internal thermostat is set to defrost and I will happily be at home in shorts and t-shirts even if it is only 10 degrees.

The only time I think I was truly truly freezing was when I was in Canada in winter for six weeks and it was minus thirty degrees. My God, that was miserable. You could not go even 50 metres down the road without full ski gear on.

Anyway I complained on Saturday about the travelling companion turning the thermostat in the room up to 32 degrees.  That was bad enough, but driving back to Auckland on Saturday (which was a lovely warm day) I suddenly noticed the air conditioning in the car had somehow moved from a nice pleasant 18 degrees to 30 degrees. My God, who actually wants 30 degree hot air blowing on you, on a sunny day!

I note in the SST that the WHO “recommends temperatures of at least 21C in living areas and 18C in other rooms”. That’s a long way off 30 degrees!

What temperatures do others find comfortable when indoors?

Mongrel Mob video

A good turnout in Tauranga

TV3 had an item last night on the successful march of over five hundred people in Tauranga against the Electoral Finance Act, organised by John Boscawen.

I saw the item at the time, and thought it bodes badly for Winston Peters. It was a fairly elderly group of people – probably many former NZ First voters. And one of the speakers, Ralph Maxwell, is not just a former Labour Cabinet Minister but was last year on the Tauranga Executive of NZ First.

Supporters of the Electoral Finance Act claimed it would fade as an issue once it was passed. On the contrary, it has had literally scores and scores of negative stories about it over the last few months, and there is no reason to think this will change before the election.

Raybon Kan on Grand Theft Auto

I like Raybon Kan’s take on Grand Theft Auto:I played some Grand Theft Auto IV.

People have discussed the morality of this game. I don’t pretend to understand how to play. It seems you steal cars and mug people and have lapdances and sex with prostitutes and commit murder. But I don’t see how morality even comes into it. I certainly didn’t notice morality being worth many points. Maybe I just didn’t get to a high enough level.

I didn’t notice the outcry when everyone was obsessive-compulsively shooting at Space Invaders. How did we know even they were invaders? Maybe they were just life forms we hadn’t met yet.

The moral police should come out with their own game, promoting their own values. Call it Goodie Good Preachy Auto. Have players give rides to hitchhikers and give way and attend church services and generally make all the other game characters feel empowered and safe and part of a community. Hmmm. Let’s see if the market cries out for a fourth version of that game.

That is a great idea. Let the market decide 🙂

Costs rising faster than net income

The Sunday Star-Times reports on how costs for the average family have been increasing faster than their after tax income:

The new figures come as the bad news rolls in thick and fast for New Zealanders on a budget: petrol was last week tipped to eventually hit $3 a litre; electricity costs are set to rise due to low hydro lake levels and the effects of carbon emission trading schemes; food prices are leaving supermarket shoppers gulping and interest rate jumps of recent years are beginning to bite as fixed mortgages expire.

Hickey shows weekly expenses for a household on the average income have risen by $193 since April 2004, while net income has increased by just $156 a week (based on gross incomes rising from $63,400pa to $72,000).

And it’s not just middle income families struggling. A household on $92,000 has had a $217 jump in living costs leaving it $93 a week worse off. A family on $52,000, aided by Working for Families, will have suffered relatively less, but is still $14 worse off.

So in four years a household on the average wage is $37 a week worse off, despite gross income having gone up $8,600. This shows how dishonest it is when people merely talk about gross wages instead of real net after tax incomes.

McCarten lashes CTU

Matt McCarten has lashed the CTU for not supporting the junior doctors on strike – all but calling them scabs:

There is a sacred principle among trade unionists: when a group of workers is on strike you support them to the hilt. To side with the boss is the most serious of all crimes.

Working-class history is full of epic struggles that led to better wages and conditions. Crossing a picket line banished the offender to lifetime alienation as a “scab” with whom no working person of good character would associate. …

So last week I was gobsmacked to see the head of the trade union movement publicly attack the junior doctors’ two-day strike and their union leadership. It’s not as if CTU president Helen Kelly doesn’t know any better – her parents were staunch unionists.

This is harsh stuff from the head of UNITE Union about the head of the CTU, especially as UNITE is affiliated to the CTU. This may be the opening shot in replacing the Government friendly leadership with more aggressive leadership.

Kelly says she hopes the strike “doesn’t give unions a bad name” and the doctors’ union is not a “modern union”. This is because it focuses too much on getting better wages and conditions for its members and lacks professional advisers, “such as policy analysts, economists, lawyers and advocates”. Its crimes include not attending talk-fests with Ministry of Health and DHB officials and other unions to “work towards a better health system”.

She seems to think a modern union levies its members to employ “professional advisers” so they can have meetings with the ever-expanding health bureaucracy. Maybe the doctors are smarter than she thinks. I’m told that if all the DHB bureaucrats had to go into hospital there wouldn’t be enough beds available. I’m sure you need a talk-fest to see what the real problem is.

McCarten is right that there are more administrators than hospital beds.

The doctors’ union says it costs the taxpayer $100 million for locums. They say the $300-$500 an hour paid to locums during the strike, for the jobs that pay them $23 an hour, is more than their entire wage demand.

So instead of attacking the union, the president of the CTU should be demanding that Cunliffe stop lining up with the hospital bosses and make sure the doctors get a decent salary.

Otherwise, the doctors’ accusation that the CTU president seems more interested in looking after her mates in the Government than workers does seem to have a ring of truth to it.

Hasn’t a CTU official just been made a Labour candidate? Really what McCarten seems to be saying is that the CTU should put the interests of “labour” ahead of “Labour”.

HoS on food prices

The HoS editorial is on food prices and tax cuts:

The voters of middle New Zealand, who have long waited for relief, will not stand for being denied it now. Yet answering the well-reasoned call of the child poverty lobbyists would demand every bit of the revenue that will be forgone in giving tax cuts. A party founded on the principles of social justice has no electoral alternative than to turn a blind eye and a deaf ear to those identified by independent research as beneath the poverty line.

In the end, whatever tax cuts Cullen announces on May 22 may be too late to save Labour’s bacon since they would not come into force until after the election – although that increases the likelihood of a vote-buying instant-relief gesture on Budget night.

But whatever administration is installed in the Beehive by Christmas will face an enormous challenge: how to simultaneously satisfy the needs of the struggling middle New Zealanders who voted them in and look after the hundreds of thousands at the very bottom of the economic ladder.

I wonder if it has dawned on the Government what a monumental mistake it was to cancel the tax cuts announced in 2005.

HoS on Auckland Central

The Herald on Sunday looks at the race for Auckland Central, and profiles National candidate Nikki Kaye.

I calculated in March, that based on an average swing, National would win Auckland Central if it beats Labour by 13% in the electorate vote. Of course swings are never average – as local factors always are a big influence.

But the calculations I did in March got me thinking that it would be useful to do an electoral pendulum showing what seats would swap hands at different levels of vote – if the swing applies consistently across the board. So I’ll work on that in my spare time.

Boris wins

Armstrong on cars and prices

John Armstrong reviews a week with bad images on the news for Labour:

It was not the smartest piece of public relations for Labour’s Cabinet ministers to be caught on camera extracting themselves from their sleek and swanky new BMWs when New Zealand families feel forced to ration how much cheese their children eat.

However, it probably did not occur to most ministers what sort of impression they were giving as they rolled up en masse to Premier House on Tuesday morning – at least not until they saw the media pack.

It is an old cliche that Cabinet ministers long in the saddle get too accustomed to the soft leather seats of their chauffeur-driven limousines – and Tuesday night’s television coverage of Labour’s special caucus meeting predictably used the taxpayer-provided BMWs as a visual metaphor for a Government out of touch.

The Government was foolish to allow new cars to be introduced in an election year. It is a classic example of third termitis.

Ministers talked of how Labour had lifted real household incomes, while stressing increased global commodity prices are beneficial to the New Zealand economy.

That was cold comfort to households where budgets are stretched by the combination of rising consumer prices and higher mortgage interest rates.

Neither development is Labour’s fault. But Labour knows it will get the blame. If people think they are suffering a decline in their standard of living, it spells electoral death for the incumbent.

As Gordon Brown is discovering.

John Key had long predicted the weakening economy and the spiralling cost of living would be the major election issue.

When he suggested Labour focus on the economy rather than attacking him, Labour scathingly advised him to get out of the kitchen if he could not handle the heat.

By continuing to hoe into National’s leader, Labour looked like it did not care that household budgets were being drained.

Diddums!

Cullen vs Parker

Fran O’Sullivan calls on Michael Cullen to intervene to make sure the suite of climate change measures being worked on  does not seriously damage the economy:

Finance Minister Michael Cullen now has all the ammunition he needs to force an urgent rethink on New Zealand’s controversial suite of climate change policies before the economy suffers serious damage.

Cullen doesn’t say so in public. But it’s well known he has growing concerns over the zealous approach his Cabinet colleague, David Parker, continues to take to climate change in the face of obvious policy defects.

New Zealand is already heading towards economic recession. Increasing power and fuel prices further to curb the country’s growing greenhouse gas emissions issue – while farmers make the problem bigger by continuing to expand agriculture emissions – is sheer madness.

Households, already suffering from rising mortgage costs, fuel and food bills, will not vote for a government planning to increase their financial pain next year by introducing a scheme which will impact on their budgets, while farmers escape their share of the cost burden until 2013.

I am not just saying this to make trouble, but I do speak to quite a few people working in the industries trying to get changes and almost universally they are full of praise for Cullen’s understanding of the issues and problems, and equally full of disdain for David Parker who is described in terms best not repeated.

There is also looming trouble with power shortages:

Adding to the political angst will be the mounting problems caused by the lack of rainfall this summer.

The heat can only intensify if ordinary householders are slapped with escalating power bills this winter – or electricity cuts – as power suppliers ration dwindling electricity supplies.

Yesterday’s announcement that the major NZ-based manufacturer Rio Tinto, which owns the Tiwai Pt aluminium smelter, is cutting back production in the face of potential brownouts – wood pulp producer Pan Pac may follow – has brought home the absurdity of Parker’s other key decision to enforce a 10-year moratorium on new base load thermal generation.

There is a now a risk that major local businesses, which are not location-dependent, will shift production offshore unless the Government puts security of future power supply back at the top of its priority list. All this suggests that the Government needs to get to grips with cold reality.

New Zealand does need to address climate change issues. But not in a lopsided fashion where ordinary folk – and smaller businesses – feel the brunt first.

The Government has made it to hard to construct new power generation, that it will not be the rain alone to blame if ther are shortages.

In Hamilton

Had a friend’s birthday party in Hamilton last night, so a late and slow morning today. The party was at one of her friend’s places, and then we headed into town for a bit ($5 black russians at The Bank – superb) and then ended up back at the motor inn for some late night wine. Eventually crashed at 3 am. A very fun night.

I normally like a room to be around 16 to 18 degrees – just right for sleeping without getting too hot. I discovered too late that my thin skinned room mate had adjusted the thermostat  – to 32 degrees!!!

Grrrrrr.

Anyway need to check out soon, so not much more blogging until back in Auckland where I am until Tuesday.

UK Labour thrashed in local elections

The results are yet to be announced for the London Mayoralty (Zimbabwe is almost faster with its results) but the expectation is that Boris Johnson has won it off Ken Livingstone, as Labour have been mauled across the board.

Pundits said a loss of more than 200 seats would be very bad for Labour. Well they have lost a staggering 331 seats – a once in a generation annihilation. In fact Labour only came third in the popular vote with 24% behind Lib Dems on 25% and Conservatives on 44%.

It is now being openly speculated that Prime Minister Gordon Brown may be rolled before the election. He is lucky in that there is no general election needed for two years, but unlucky in that that gives lots of time for discontent to simmer.

Congrats to all my friends in the Conservatives – must have been a good night of celebrations.

Number 1 selling NZ non-fiction book

NBR on Govt grants to UN black listed company

NBR had a great cover story this morning by Amy Williams on how the Government has been dishing out money to a NZ company, even *after* it was told it had been blacklisted by the UN for corruption (one wonders how corrupt one has to be, to have the UN stop using you!!). The UN can not prosecute, but asked NZ authorities to prosecute the company – Radiola Aerospace, and it was referred to the Police in May 2007 by MFAT.

Despite this NZTE has continuted to grant Radiola money from its market development fund. Trevor Mallard has visited Radiola, and praised them a number of times – before this revelation which he says he was never brifed on by officials.

McCully on Music Month

People may have noted over time how Labour seems to try and turn every Government opportunity into a partisan event for Labour. One disgraceful recent incident was the attempt to have a medal ceremony for bravery awards in the Labour Party Caucus room.

Murray McCully points out in today’s newsletter the Music Month launch this week:

New Zealanders are now familiar with the sense of entitlement that has become the hallmark of the Clark Labour Government.  Another little reminder of this most unlovely characteristic came this week with the launch of New Zealand Music Month.  Most would consider such an event an opportunity to celebrate the achievements of the New Zealand music industry.  But for Judith Tizard and her colleagues it was merely another opportunity to utilise taxpayers’ funds to undertake a bit of gentle marketing for the Labour Party.

The New Zealand Music Commission receives over $1million a year from the taxpayers of New Zealand.  Some of these funds, no doubt, were used to host this week’s Music Month launch event in Wellington.  And a small clue as to the political character of the event may lie in the fact that the National Party spokesman on Arts and Culture, Christopher Finlayson, was not invited to an event hosted by a taxpayer-owned body – the NZ Music Commission.  Never mind.  We are sure that Mr Finlayson as a scholarly and courtly individual will most certainly not harbour a grudge if he finds himself as Minister for this body in six months time.

Stung by her shameful exclusion from the group of prime female vocalists who entertained the Labour Party Conference (the various nicknames for which do not bear repeating in a newsletter with such a cultured readership)  Ms Tizard was apparently determined to make amends.  She climbed onto the stage to accompany musician Chris Knox (yes, the same one you would have seen performing at Labour Party conferences). And witnesses report that she would indeed have made a valuable addition to the Labour Conference quartet.

Towards the end of the Knox/Tizard number, she was apparently joined by completely non-political and dispassionate media commentator Russell Brown (yes, the same one used by state television on channel 7), at the same time as Knox could be heard by the video microphones making a disparaging remark about National MP Katherine Rich.  All in all, another day in the life of the New Zealand Music Commission branch of the Labour Party.

This is not an isolated incident. People will recall the disgraceful behaviour towards Don Brash a couple of years ago at another government funded arts event.

The Dominion Post also has an article on the launch and reports on Judith’s response upon being told she failed music quiz (to be fair I am sure I would fail it also):

“I don’t know the details, honey; I just write the policy and ask for the money.”

Indeed. And very successful at it also – the asking that is.