Tauranga anti EFA protest march tomorrow

Tomorrow Tauranga has its anti Electoral Finance Act and it is looking to be pretty high profile. The local Bay of Plenty Times ran this story on most of its front page yesterday including a route for the march.

The Sensible Sentencing Trust is rallying its 3500 Tauranga members and the community to pound the footpaths in opposition to the law that restricts the campaign spending of electoral parties and supporters.

Those opposed to the Electoral Finance Act say it is unworkable and must be repealed and that neither MPs nor political parties seem able to understand it or work within it.

Saturday’s march will end at Baycourt where former Labour MP and minister Hon Ralph Maxwell will speak. Others could also take the opportunity to have their say.

Ralph Maxwell is (or was as of a few months ago) an executive member in Tauranga for NZ First. The local NZ First committee voted 13-1 to oppose the law.

For those in Tauranga the march assembles at 10.45 am at the corner of 1st Avenue and Devenport Road, then proceeds to Baycourt.

John Boscawen is planning more marches in provincial centres after this one.

Global Warming on hold until 2015 claim Germans

Many will be aware that global temperatures reached a peak in 1998, and have not risen since then. Now that does not mean there is no global warming, because people argue temperatures have to be looked at over longer time-frames such as 30 years.

I certainly agree with that, but note of course every year no further warming happens, means one gets more sceptical of the accuracy of the models (and they are just models) for future increases.

Now a study by German scientists (peeer reviewed and published in Nature magazine) has concluded:

Researchers studying long-term changes in sea temperatures said they now expect a “lull” for up to a decade while natural variations in climate cancel out the increases caused by man-made greenhouse gas emissions.

Now this doesn’t mean that carbon emissions are not a problem. There is little doubt greenhouse gases keep heat in and if nothing else changes will push temperatures up. But the key thing is if nothing else changes, and that is the area where so little is known. How does water vapour for example react to an increase in greenhouse gases.

So while this does not mean no action should be taken to reduce carbon emissions, it does clearly signal how much uncertainty there is over what will happen in the future. Projection models are merely models, and are not scientific facts.

The science is of course what is important, and it is sad to see Frog Blog repeating moronic scare mongering claims from some UN politician that climate change could force one billion people from their homes by 2050. This is sensationalist crap.

Even the official IPCC projections are simply for an increase in sea level by 2100 of 19 to 89 cm. By 2050 it would be way less than half of that.

I’ll be 83 in 2050 and if I am still here I could do with a huge year round jaunt on a super yacht. So I’m prepared to do a bet with Frog Blog. If even 100 million people have been forced out of their homes by climate change by 2050, I will pay Frog $50 million. And if they have not Frog pays me $5 million.

Another late donation return

The Greens have disclosed a large donation from Bryan Forde, but appear to have done so later than required, and also broken the law.

Forde appears to be an Audiologist in Invercargill and he donated $300 in May 2007 and $20,000 on 3 April 2008. A further $4,450 was donated on 28 April 2008.

Now as at 3 April 2008 he had donated $20,300 over a 1 month period. s54 of the Electoral Finance Act says:

54(2) says:

Every financial agent must file with the Electoral Commission a return in respect of every party donation that—

(a) the financial agent knows is from a donor who in the 12 months immediately preceding the date of receipt of the donation (the last 12 months) has made 1 or more previous donations; and

(b) when aggregated with all previous donations received from the donor in the last 12 months exceeds $20,000.

54(6) also:

A return must be filed under subsection (1) or (2) within 10 working days of the donation being received by the financial agent.

Now the Greens were required to file a return within 10 working days, which was Thursday 17 April 2008. The Electoral Commission say they will publish them within three working days so if it went up today it appears to have only been filed on or after Tuesday 29 April 2008. That would suggest the Greens were 12 days late with disclosing the aggregated donation.

Curious minds may like to inquire as to why they appeared to have broken the law they so passionately defended and insisted on. Also why does a donor make an additional $4,450 donation a few weeks after a $20,000 donation?

Beware NZ media

What has just happened in Western Australia should send a chill up the backsides of NZ media as they look to expose Government funded advertising campaigns this year:

Sixteen police raided the newsroom of News Ltd’s The Sunday Times Wednesday, acting on a complaint from the office of Premier Alan Carpenter, himself a former journalist.

The fraud squad was trying to find who leaked information about a government decision to spend $A16 million in taxpayers’ money on an advertising campaign, allegedly intended to help Labour’s bid for re-election. …

The newspaper article, written by staff reporter Paul Lampathakis and published in February, quoted “government sources” as saying the $A16 million was to be spent on strategic advertising campaigns ahead of an upcoming election.

It said Mr Ripper, as chairman of the cabinet subcommittee on communication, had “urgently” asked the expenditure review committee, which he chaired, for $A5.25 million for the first half of the year and a further $A10.75 million until July next year. …

Incredible.

The idiots are now fasting

I hadn’t yet blogged about the dickheads who caused up to $1 million damage to Waihopai, as they are just desperate for publicity. The court should just fine them the cost of the damage. I don’t see why us taxpayers should pay for their activities.

Now I see they are on a fast while behind bars. Good God they think they are some sort of noble victims. They’re simply petty criminals and should be treated like you would a vandal.

ASBOs for NZ

Electoral Commission must prosecute

The Electoral Commission must prosecute (or ask Police to do so) NZ First, and sadly probably ACT, for their late donation returns. A failure to do undermines the law.

There are some situations where prosecution for a late return is not warranted. Parties that didn’t make it into Parliament I would treat somewhat more leniently. They have no MPs, probably no office and no staff and probably no donations.

Likewise if the return is simply a nil return, then again I would not be so worried.

And if the return is just one or even two days late, not the end of the world. However the 30 April deadline is four months after the time period they cover, so there is little excuse for lack of time.

ACT appear to have simply been tardy and say it is with the Auditor.  They really should be asking some hard questions of the person responsible for the tardiness, because it might get them into court.

NZ First’s situation is far worse. They are simply refusing to comply with the law, saying they can’t file their return until their Party Leader is back in NZ on the 16th of May. This is totally unacceptable to say the least, for the following reasons:

  1. This is a simple compliance task. The Party Secretary just fills in the form stating how many donations over $10,000 they got and who they were from. It is not rocket science. There is no role for a party leader in this task.
  2. The suspicion is they do not wish to file until Winston is here to handle any media spin on their donations return. Again totally totally unacceptable. Statutory deadlines are not there to be ignored for the benefit of media management.
  3. It is in the public record that there has been wildly contrasting accounts from the (former) President and the Leader regarding a large anonymous donation in December 2007. The former says they got one and the latter says no they did not. This makes the official audited donations return of even greater public interest.

If the Electoral Commission do not prosecute NZ First especially (I think they should also prosecute ACT, but they at least do not appear to be deliberately flouting the law) then what incentive is there for the parties that do comply with the Electoral Act and Electoral Finance Act?

Sky Movie Downloads

Victory for the Berrymans

This is very good news. Keith and Margaret Berryman have had the High Court over-turn the finding in 1997 of the coroner that they partially responsible for the death of beekeeper Kenneth John Richards in 1994 after the collapse of the Army built bridge on their land.

Very bad taste

Just watching David Letterman from last night,. He just announced the it is Saddam Hussein’s birthday and he would be 71 today – pause – if he hadn’t been hanged. That’s so bad taste, but nevertheless very funny.

Quickest planned trip ever

A brief conversation this evening:

Friend: Fancy going on a road trip
DPF: Yeah, why not
Friend: Great.
DPF: How long for:
Friend: Around a week
DPF: Okay. When are you thinking
Friend: Say early July
DPF: (checks diary) Looks good to me
Friend: Excellent that’s agreed
DPF: Are we doing North or South Island
Friend: Neither – England
DPF: England?
Friend: Yep, we can go visit Frithie
DPF: Oh, why the hell not – should be fun

So in the space of five minutes I’ve agreed on a whim to fly to the other side of the world for a road trip. I like having a flexible lifestyle 🙂

Payne v NZ National Party

Legal beagles can read the entire 27 page judgement here. I’ve extracted some quotes below, interspersed with my comments:

The statement of claim filed by Mr Payne on 10 April alleged that the decision of the Board of the National Party to disapprove his nomination was in breach of natural justice and of s71 of the Electoral Act. He also challenged the validity of the Constitution and Rules of the National Party on the basis that the most recent version was not supplied to the Electoral Commission within the time limits prescribed in s71B of the Act. He further asserted that “the National Party’s undemocratic behaviour” constituted a corrupt practice, being an example of undue influence contrary to s218 of the Electoral Act.

A further issue of possible breach of contract was also considered by the court, which I will touch on later.

The allegation based on s218 of the Electoral Act is misconceived. Assuming, without deciding, that a member of the Board of the National Party could be a complainant of undue influence, the gravemen of the section is conduct directed to a person to induce or compel them by violence or threat of violence to vote, or refrain from voting, for a particular candidate. There is no evidence of any conduct capable of falling within s218.

This is the problem of representing yourself in court.  Even the most inexperienced lawyer would probably know that s218 is referring to the general election, not internal selection contests.

There is another problem with the statement of claim. It is not drawn in a manner which adequately identifies the underlying basis of the claim. In particular, it is unclear whether the claim is intended to be viewed as an application for judicial review, or not.

Again, the problem of do it yourself lawyers.

As Mr Kiely pointed out s71B(1)(c) does not require all changes to the rules to be supplied to the Electoral Commission, rather only changes which relate to membership of the party or the selection of persons to represent the party as candidates for election as Members of Parliament. And, the submission continued, the changes between the 20th and 21st editions did not fall into either of these categories. Hence, technically, there was no requirement upon the party to supply the latest rules to the Commission. That it did so recently, and no doubt in response
to this proceeding, was neither here nor there.

That basically takes care of the issues of which rules were in force.

The above extracts demonstrate the genesis of, and thinking behind, s71. The nomenclature “democratic procedures” attained currency in the Royal Commission’s Report. Although at first blush there may be a tendency to equate the reference to democratic procedures in s71 with the principles of natural justice, the origins of the phrase suggest otherwise. The word “democratic” was, I think, deliberately chosen to capture the notion identified in “Towards a Better Democracy” and subsequently endorsed by the Electoral Law Committee and by speakers in the House. What the Royal Commission, and subsequent adherents, had in mind was a requirement that the selection of candidates by political parties would be participatory; that members of the party may participate in the selection process, whether directly or through representatives (delegates) themselves elected by the membership at large.

This is a pretty core aspect – that the reference to democratic procedures for candidate selection in s71, does not mean that parties are bound by  principles of natural justice (as public bodies are).

With the benefit of reference to the above extrinsic materials the impression I held previously that the candidate selection processes adopted by the National Party probably met the requirements of s71 is strengthened. The text of the section, read in light of the Royal Commission’s Report, was clearly intended to provide a defined level of participatory democracy. Candidates to represent the party at general elections are to be selected by current financial members of the party from the particular electorate or by delegates of that class of persons. But, the participatory requirement was, I think, deliberately framed so as to leave scope for the overarching influence of senior officials of the party, provided that they too were democratically elected by the party membership.

Again, very interesting. Basically it affirms board vetoes etc are not contrary to the Electoral Act.

I am satisfied that the rules of the National Party include a comprehensive code for the democratic selection of constituency candidates. The requirement contained in s71 for participation in the selection process by current financial members of the party from the electorate, or by delegates elected/selected by current financial members of the party, is met. Delegates on the Board consider the nominations and may reject one or more, while the pre-selection committee must reduce the number to a maximum of five. Thereafter, the universal suffrage option provides for current financial members from the electorate to make the final choice by a closely defined democratic process.

Accordingly, the rules of the National Party do satisfy the requirement of democratic procedure contained in s71. Extensive provision is made for members of the party to participate in the selection of constituency candidates. The preceding review of the rules demonstrates as much.

I suspect all political parties will find some comfort in the interpretation of the court.

Section 71 aside, is it seriously arguable that r94(b) is challengable on other grounds? Mr Payne’s case seemed to me to be predicated on s71, but nonetheless I shall also consider this further question.

Mr Kiely anticipated this further aspect. He posed the question whether, assuming compliance with s71, there may still be a breach of the rules actionable as a breach of contract.

Always smart to anticipate an angle the court may take, even if the plaintiff has not asked for it.

Although in terms of r94(b) there is no obligation to supply reasons for a nominee’s rejection, Mrs Kirk’s affidavit identifies three matters which influenced the decision. The first was Mr Payne’s conduct in 2002 when he failed to win the Rakaia nomination and publicly criticised the remaining candidates, Mr Connell in particular, both when he became the constituency candidate and following his election to Parliament. Second, as a candidate for the Rakaia electorate Mr Payne was required to sign an undertaking that if unsuccessful he would not act in competition to the successful National Party candidate. Mr Payne was considered to be in breach of his undertaking because he stood for the Christian Heritage Party in Rakaia and thereby acted contrary to the interests of National. Third, Mr Payne was involved in protracted Family Court litigation with his former wife which resulted in numerous court hearings and, eventually, newspaper comment in 2005 concerning action taken to evict Mr Payne from his Wellington home. In the course of this dispute Mr Payne was also declared bankrupt for non-payment of court costs, but the bankruptcy was subsequently annulled.

Clearly suitable to go direct into Cabinet, as Mr Payne claimed he was.

More specifically the rule itself does not suggest a requirement of notice, followed by an opportunity to be heard. All the indications are the other way, and indicate to me the exclusion of even this rudimentary level of natural justice. The Board is clothed with an unfettered discretion, and is absolved of the need to interview a candidate, or even to assign reasons for rejection. This indicates a power of veto in the widest of terms.

I conclude, therefore, that there is no serious question to be tried based on a contractual breach of r94(b).

So that takes care of the substantive issue. Then Justice Panckhurst looks at the injunction:

Much more significant to my mind is the inconvenience to third parties. Four of the remaining candidates for the Selwyn nomination made affidavits for the purpose of this hearing. I shall not refer to the detail of the individual affidavits. It is sufficient to say that the candidates each ordered their work and personal lives upon the assumption that the constituency candidate would be selected on 7 April. After my decision of 3 April the candidates were placed in a position of considerable uncertainty. Arrangements they had made to enable them to campaign through to 7 April were no longer of any utility. Whether similar arrangements for a resumed final selection process will be attainable, is questionable. Certainly, I accept on the basis of the affidavit evidence that the remaining candidates have been, and will continue to be, significantly inconvenienced until such time as a final decision is made concerning the Selwyn constituency candidate.

Indeed, the disruption has been quite massive to the candidates. With 700 delegates involved they had effectively put aside their day jobs to campaign fulltime.

Counsel also contended that the ultimate relief in this case could be nothing more than a requirement for the National Party to reconsider Mr Payne’s nomination. The reality, he suggested, was that such relief would prove futile. Reconsideration would almost inevitably lead to the same result. Either Mr Payne’s nomination would be rejected by the Board of the National Party or at the pre-selection stage.

Absolutely. There never has been any chance at all that Payne would ever be the candidate, even if he won in court. It really has just all been about an ego boost for him, with no chance of eventual selection.

For the reasons given I am satisfied it is appropriate to review and in the event rescind the interim order made on 3 April. Accordingly the interim injunction granted on that day is discharged.

Yay. Payne can appeal to the Court of Appeal of course but with no injunction remaining, National can proceed with its final electorate selection.

Costs in relation to the interlocutory hearings are reserved. If sought by the defendant, it may file a memorandum in support within 10 working days, after which the plaintiff will have 10 working days in which to reply.

Bearing in mind the previous evidence, I have a suspicion that regardless of the order for costs, any payment might be a long time coming!

Kiwiblog makes World Rock Paper Scissors blog

National wins Selwyn court case

I’ve just received a copy of the ruling in Payne vs National over the Selwyn selection and Mr Payne has lost the case, plus the Judge has lifted the injunction so the selection can now proceed even if Payne appeals.

The judgement is comprehensive and in brief it finds the rules do comply with the Electoral Act are are democratic.

There is also some interesting material on why Payne was found by the Board to be unsuitable. I will blog the pdf later today. About to chair a meeting from 3 pm to 5 pm so probably this evening.

The five candidates, pluss all the local members, will be very pleased that a selection meeting can now be held. I’m not sure when it will be, but suspect as soon as legally possible taking into account notice requirements.

The London Mayoralty

Iain Dale blogs on the different poll results just prior to the local body elections in England. The polls open tonight our time and I expect results late tomorrow morning.

You Gov has it at Boris Johnson 44% and Ken Livingstone 36%. If no one gets 50% second preferences are allocated and on second preferences from the Lib Dem candidate mainly it becomes 53% to 47% for Boris.

Mori however has first preferences Boris 38%, Ken 41% and second preferences Ken 52% Boris 48%.

A lot of interest in who will be right. You Gov does Internet polling and Mori phone polling. You Gov has a pretty good accuracy history but that is no guarantee. What they do tend to agree on though is the higher the turnout, the better it is for Ken Livingstone.

The Livingstone campaign has actually complained to the UK Market Research Society about You Gov. This shows how seriously people take the expectations game.

Fallow on Income Splitting

Income splitting is in the news as Peter Dunne has finally got the Government to publish a discussion document on it. For those who don’t want to read the whole 29 pages, Brian Fallow has a good summary of the issues in the Herald:

Broadly speaking, the left is not keen because it is not well targeted at relieving child poverty, the extent of which the Child Poverty Action Group’s report this week makes clear.

Income splitting is no use at all to single parents, who have the hardest row to hoe.

And it is seen as favouring a 1950s model of the family – with mum at home baking biscuits and looking after the children – that bears little relation to the realities of modern times.

At the same time, the right isn’t keen because of the opportunity cost: like any other targeted tax relief, it reduces how much would be left for across-the-board tax cuts.

Fallow also notes that lowering the top tax rates would reduce much of the demand for income splitting. It is that high 39% marginal tax rate that makes income splitting so attractive.

In terms of who would benefit:

The most populous part of the income distribution among couples consists of families whose main breadwinner earns between $50,000 and $60,000 and his or her partner up to $40,000.

About 70,000 families fall into that group and they would stand to gain between $1000 and $3000 a year.

The largest gains, however, would be among couples with larger incomes.

The biggest gain, nearly $9000 a year, goes to a couple where one partner earns $120,00 a year and the other earns nothing.

His conclusion:

Many families are under pressure, no question. But income splitting only benefits some of them and only because of the structure of the income tax scale. Either flatten it or put more resources in Working for Families. But spare us any more complexity in the tax laws.

It’s hard being Labour

Dim-Post strikes again

From the comments section in the previous post:

Violent Bible Book Should be Banned
The Dim-Post
Thursday 1st May 2008

Lobby group Family First is calling for the Book of Isaiah, a collection of Old Testament prophecies linked to recent anti-government protests to be banned in New Zealand.

A passage from the eighth century BC text was cited as the inspiration for the ANZAC Ploughshares, the activist group responsible for a recent attack on the GCSB spybase in Waihopai.

A press release from ANZAC Ploughshares released after the incident contained a quotation from Isaiah:

‘They shall beat their swords into ploughshares, their spears into pruning hooks; nation shall not lift sword against nation; and there shall be no more training for war.’

‘This book is directly responsible for inciting terrorist attacks against the New Zealand government,’ said Bob McCoskrie, National Director for Family First NZ. ‘The Old Testament is available to teenagers and young children. There is an overwhelming link between this holy book and the recent surge in spybase related crime.’

A Dominican Priest is believed to have been involved in the attack. The group breached three security fences and used a sickle to deflate the kevlar hood covering one of the two satellite dishes.

McCoskrie blamed the easy availability of sacred scriptures like Isaiah on the statistical increase in crimes committed by Dominican Priests and directly criticised the Labour Government for their reluctance to prohibit the import and manufacture of divine tomes.

‘We reap what we sow,’ McCoskrie said.

Heh.

ETS in danger

The Government’s Emissions Trading Scheme may be heading the same way as their Biofuels legislation – with growing realisation the cures may be much worse than the disease.

Colin Espiner blogged yesterday that “climate change policies no longer sustainable”. This may be the first instance of a press gallery journalist saying that, and this week could be seen in future as the tipping point. Quoting Espiner:

A year sure is a long time in politics. Remember “sustainability”? Remember how New Zealand was going to become the world’s first “carbon neutral” country? Remember electric cars, 90% renewable energy, bold plans to slash vehicle emissions by 40%?

The United Nations sure does. It’s awarded Prime Minister Helen Clark a gong for her commitment to fighting climate change, despite the fact that not a single of these pledges has yet been formally implemented, let alone had any effect. Our carbon emissions went up last year, not down. They’ll probably be up again this year.

And yet funnily enough you don’t hear much from the Government these days about sustainability. The plan to allow councils to whack an extra 15c on to every litre of petrol is on the back-burner. The idea to force petrol companies to blend their gas with a minimum 5% biofuel suddenly doesn’t seem like such a good idea when respectable environmental lobby groups are warning that most of the world’s biofuel production is unsustainable, is being achieved by felling rainforest, and has led to a huge increase in world food prices.

Add to this that the scheme at the heart of the Government’s ambitious plans to tackle climate change, the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS), is under heavy fire, and not just from the usual suspects. A bevy of reports from respected consultancies and research firms like the Cawthron Institute, the Institute of Economic Research, and Infometrics say the ETS will cost the country a fortune, will only result in a marginal reduction in greenhouse gas emissions, and could have severe unintended environmental side-effects.

Coming up with solutions which are good for the Environment and do not hurt consumers and businesses greatly is not easy. This is why soundbites such as “carbon neutrality” are so irresponsible. It’s also one reasons why I support roll out of fibre to the home – it is one of the few policies which should be both good for the economy and good for the environment.

Paula Oliver in the Herald reports the Government is now considering delays, as sticking extra costs on petrol at a time when prices are already record high will probably just be seen as revenue collecting. The beneficial effects of encouraging more fuel efficient vehicles and more public transport use are already happening at $1.85 a litre I suspect and a few cents more may have little effect except to piss people off.

Timing is everything sometimes!

Grand Theft Auto IV

I’ve never played Grand Theft Auto. But the more I read how Gordon Copeland and Family First want to ban it, the more I really really want to get a copy. What I love about the releases attacking a game, film or book is how incredibly useful and detailed they are for people:

Grand Theft Auto IV is scheduled for release this week. It follows on from previous Grand Theft Auto games which included constant graphic violence and sexual situations. Players could re-enact having sex with a prostitute, beating her bloody, taking her money and running her over with a car and shooting at police officers.

Rockstar Games which produces the game says the company is going even further in its pursuit of realism with this latest game in the series and players can buy cocaine, set enemies alight, shoot a policeman, drink drive, and visit strip clubs – all with improved physics and animation which makes the game feel more real, according to reviewers.

I mean can anyone rule out that they really are on commission for the promoters. I mean who doesn’t want to set their enemies alight 🙂

Incidentally how many know that there is an autobiography on Gordon Copeland? Yes, seriously.

Another fun night watching Back Benches

After missing it last week, popped in again to the Backbencher last night for the usual live filing of Back Benches. The MPs were Rodney Hide, Jacqui Dean, Te Ururoa Flavell and Russel Norman (not quite an MP yet).

Rodney joined our table before the show and loudly proclaimed the he figured the Nats were pushing fibre to the home for broadband just so I could get better quality porn. I jokingly corrected him that it was so I could get faster porn, not better porn. Rodney then started practising his parliamentary speech about how any Bill for fibre to the home should be called the Faster Farrar Porn Bill. Others started joining in until I pointed out to them all that only Rodney gets parliamentary privilege 🙂

The show went well. The funniest moment for me was when Wallace asked Russel about biofuels, and a few seconds into what appeared to be the start of a very long explanation, Rodney rang the bell to cut him off.

Around halfway through the show Wallace announced they are giving away a luxury item in a quiz, and he held up a 1kg block of tasty cheese which he said was now a luxury item at $15. And the question was what sort of car has replaced the Ford Fairlaines as Ministerial cars.

I couldn’t resist and stuck my hand up and shouted out “BMW 720is”. Wallace was so impressed (or appalled by my nerdiness) he awarded me the cheese. At this stage someone sitting with the Green supporters yelled out loudly “Who is that bald cunt”, Now I have been called a cunt several times before, but never on live television on a news show. I joked afterwards to Guyon Espiner that being called a cunt on live television had never happened to me before, and he replied that it had to him! I forgot to ask whether it was an MP 🙂

Being serious for a second, I do think it is grossly inappropriate to use the cunt word on a live television news show. Not at all worried that it was directed at me, but it was boorish in the extreme. “Who is that bald bastard” would have worked just as well without actually exposing TVNZ to the Broadcasting Standards Authority (which I jokingly threatened them with).

Anyway my cheese victory was short lived. Barry and Heather Soper (I can’t be bothered trying to spell her actual surname) popped in after the show and I boasted of my victory in winning the cheese. Barry immediately says I got the make wrong and they are BMW 730Lds. I don’t think I am wrong, so I fire up the Blackberry and search on my blog site as I know I blogged the model when they were announced.

Sadly I did get the make slightly wrong (hey 730 is close to 720) and they are BMW 730Lds. So what does Barry do, he reaches across the table and takes my cheese claiming he is the real winner of it, despite not even being there for the show.

I then drown my sorrows at my lost cheese in another Speights.

“Big Dad” silences witnesses

More testimony in the deposition of former Labour MP Taito Phillip Field.

Another immigrant has testified, and told how she was told by Field to refuse to meet any further with QC Noel Ingram. Why was she told to not agree to further meetings? In case her answers are different.

She also reveals Field was known as “Big Dad”. I’m sure he was. Her job was to translate instructions from Field to Thai tiler Sunan Siriwan, on what he should say to the Ingram Inquiry.

This is the same Ingram inquiry which had Michael Cullen afterwards claiming all Field is guilty of is working hard for his constituents – the same line Helen Clark had earlier used.

Broadcasters slam Public Health Bill

TVNZ and Canwest have slammed the awful Public Health Bill which would give health bureaucrats the power to regulate, well anything at all, if they think it is for the public good.

In the past decisions to, for example, restrict alcohol advertising on television would be decided by a new law in Parliament, with six months of consideration, public select committee hearings and ultimately votes by all 120 MPs.

This new law would allow the Director-General of Health to ban chocolate bar advertising from all media, if he or she decided it was desirable for “public health”. There would be no vote in Parliament.

But it gets even worse than that. As TVNZ points out, the health bureaucrats could even force TV programmes off the air. They could promulgate a code stating it is illegal to have a TV show which shows characters with unhealthy lifestyles.  So there goes Homer on The Simpsons, and Denny Crane on Boston Legal.

Now is this not far fetched and unlikely. Well, yes – but why on Earth would we even consider giving such draconian powers to the Government. Should one just blindly rely on the Government to choose to be self restrained and not use all the powers Parliament votes it?

Helen Clark has said she does not know of any reduction of freedoms that have occurred on her watch. Such blindness must be how this bill made it through Cabinet.

Who refused to donate to Labour?

44 Labour MPs donated over $10,000 to help bail out their illegal pledge card and other associated spending. But they had 50 MPs last year. So who did not donate or donated under $10,000. By process of elimination they are:

  1. Taito Philip Field (left them mid year)
  2. Damien O’Connor
  3. Shane Jones
  4. Charles Chauvel
  5. Lesley Soper
  6. Paul Swain

It is possible they did donate, but it was just under the $10,000 disclosure limit.

2007 Donations Return

The Electoral Commission has just published the donations returns of parties for 2007. Up until December the old Electoral Act applied. Only donations to a party of over $10,000 get disclosed.

The totals for each party are:

  1. Maori Party $70,000
  2. Labour $1,030,446.39
  3. National 704,100
  4. Greens $181,046.23
  5. United Future $0
  6. Progressive $0
  7. ACT – not received as at 5 pm
  8. NZ First – not received as at 5 pm

Now who were the disclosed donors to each. In order:

Maori Party

Susan Cullen donated $70,000. Susan (who I have met) is probably best known for her work with Te Wananga o Aotearoa and according to the Herald is worth $30 million.

Labour
Do you remember how Mike “confused” Williams told us fundraising to repay the $800,000 was going so well, and in fact having to pay the money had given people the incentive to raise more money.

Well in fact they have effectively levied their MPs to bail them out. Looks proportional to salary. Clark gave $29,099.04 and 42 MPs gave a total of $661,568.40 which is an average of $15,035.65. So the MPs personally paid for around 80% the money the Auditor-General identified as illegally spent.

Other Individual donors were Chhour Lim Nam for $25,000. Steven Wong for $19,000 and Thomas Wang $14,188. Chhour appears to be involved in the Cambodian community, Wong is President of the Chinese Association, runs a potato chip manufacturer and was a potential Labour candidate in 2002. Wong also gave $23,000 in 2006. Wang is an Auckland businessman also.

Corporate donors were Toll NZ for $25,000, Fletcher Building for $20,000, Griffin Property for $20,000 and Westpac for $15,000.

But here is the big story. Despite spending all year railing against anonymous donations, and pledging they will stop them – they were at the same time accepting $150,000 from one anonymous donor and $50,000 from another. (and another $30,000 I missed earlier so that is $230,000)

But really the hypocrisy of spending all year railing against anonymous donations and then pocketing the largest anonymous donation a party has received since 1999 is breath taking.

NZ First

Their donation return is not yet public. It may have just come in today (the due date). I am very very interested in that return.

National

Corporate donors are DMH Developments for $50,000, Fletcher Building for $20,000, Toll NZ for $25,000 and Westpac for $15,000. One individual donated $41,000 – Susan Zhou.

Two anonymous donations – $25,000 and $15,000.

Finally there were three Trust donations – $424,100 from the infamous Waitemata Trust, $69,000 from the Ruahine Trust and $20,000 from the Nationalist Trust. These are presumably the final donations from the Trusts, as the Electoral Finance Act (one of the few good parts of it, and not a part that was in the original Bill) removes any point in donating through a Trust. Generally the trust donations will be a collation of several or many individual donations the Trust has received – Waitameta could represent 21 $20,000 donations or seven $60,000 donations etc. Of course no one knows bar the Trustees, so it is good this will be the last return where one won’t know at least the size of any donations over $10,000.

I actually thought National would have received more donations than this, considering it was logical that some people would donate before the law changed.

Greens

The Green MPs had to dig deep also. Their six MPs donated an average of $19,812.71 for a total of $118,876.20. Jeanette gave most at $34,045.28.

Also big donations from Stuart Bramhall for $30,500, Christopher Marshall $18,670 and Cliff Mason for $13,000.

Bramhall is the contact for the New Plymouth Greens. Cliff Mason is a Pathologist who stood for the Greens in 1999.