Shortland Street via Internet

Just had TVNZ do a presentation on the cost of bandwidth in NZ. He asked everyone to guess how much it would cost to deliver Shortland Street every night over the Internet to its 500,000 viewers.

The cost is over the break. No one got it right.

Continue reading »

Employment declines

Today’s release of the March 2008 Household Labour Force Survey confirms that there is a downturn, with the first significant decrease in jobs since the Asian Crisis of 1997/98.

Now Labour in the 1990s tried to blame all of that downturn on the then National Government. I prefer a more rational analysis, and both National in 1997 and Labour in 2008 can’t be primarily blamed for what is essentially a global problem. However both Governments do have responsibility to have the economy as free and resilient as possible to mitigate the effects of global events.

So what has happened in the last quarter:

  • Those in employment have dropped on a seasonally adjusted basis by 29,000, wiping out the gains since December 2006
  • The number of people unemployed rose by 4,000 – a 5.2% increase from 77,000 to 81,000
  • The number of people not in the labour force increased by 35,000 – so these are people no longer looking or available for jobs. The labour force participation rate has dropped to 67.7% – at least a two year low.
  • Most of the fall in employment has been amongst under 25s
  • Unemployment rates (non seasonally adjusted) by ethnicity are Europeans up from 2.2% to 3.0%, Maori from 7.2% to 8.6%, and Pacific from 4.8% to 8.2%
  • Wellington appears to have the largest rise in unemployment – from 2.5% to 5.0%
  • The total number of jobless people (this includes those not available or looking for work) rose from 145,900 to 181,800
  • The number of actual hours worked in the quarter is the lowest since March 2005

Now I think the HLFS has exaggerated the decline somewhat. The HLFS is basically just a big opinion poll. It has a large sample (17,000 off memory) but that still leaves a sampling margin of error. I don’t think there has actually been 29,000 jobs go in the last quarter. But certainly there has been some decline.

The above graph, at The Visible Hand in Economics, shows the market reaction. The concern is not over the decline, as much as the size of the decline.

The only good news is that the chance of a lowering of interest rates this year is now higher. But food and fuel inflation will still make this a risky call to make too early.

Dom Post on Immigration Service

Today’s Dom Post editorial is on the Immigration Service:

The case raises questions about Dr Thompson’s conduct, the conduct of the staff member who ordered that the residency applications be processed, the culture within the Immigration Service, Dr Thompson’s bosses and the adequacy of the inquiry itself.

Put bluntly, it is not acceptable for public servants to use their positions to advance personal or family interests. Nor is it acceptable for senior public servants to leave doubt in the minds of staff about their intentions when personal or family interests are involved.

Dr Thompson should have refused to play any part in her relatives’ bid to come to this country and, when her connections became known, she should have made it explicitly clear to staff that their application was to be treated on its merits just as every other application should be.

By failing to do so she has damaged her reputation and public confidence in the Immigration Service.

To restore it, public service bosses have no choice but to take drastic action. If they do not, service staff will continue to wonder about what a nod or wink from the chief executive means and migrants will continue to suspect that it is not what you know but who you are related to that matters in New Zealand.

It really was an extremely serious failure on judgement to get involved in any way with your own family’s application.  And the wider issues of the culture are the bigger concern – how many other times are policies broken to do someone a favour?

Where the parties stand on the ETS

The NZ Herald has a useful summary of where the parties stand on Labour’s Emissions Trading Scheme.

* Act: “The Government’s ETS is a crock and should be dumped.”
* Green Party: Close to pulling support because of Government backdowns on fuel and industry emissions, but waiting to see final shape of the scheme.
* Maori Party: Could withdraw support because of Government backdowns.
* NZ First: Will discuss future support at caucus next Tuesday, but has concerns about people on fixed incomes.
* United Future: Reserving position until sees final shape. Supports fuel delay but wants more information on costs for householders and “compensation” for extra costs.
* National: Supports concept of an emissions trading scheme. Pleased with delay of fuel sector. Says final scheme must be “durable” and balance economic and environmental issues or it will not support it.

Will it pass 119-2? Starting to look difficult. Unless Labour do something really stupid, National should stay on board and it will pass. But the risk is one will have either the Greens and Maori Party opposing it as ineffective, or NZ First and United Future attacking it as too costly for consumers.

Cunliffe at Telco Day 2008

Am spending all day at TUANZ’s Telecommunications Day 2008. Heard from all the Telco CEOs in the morning and now the Minister is speaking.

He said the aspiration is to have Fibre to the Home within a decade, which means by 2018. That means both major parties are saying they want fibre to the home with National targeting 2014 and Labour 2018. I personally am not too worried about the time-frames (2014 is very ambitious) so long as there is a co-ordinated plan with open access policies.

There was no funding announcement today, as many expected. But he did say a package will be announced in the near future. There will be great interest in that package – both the funding but also the policy. He was very critical of National’s proposal, so again the details of the Government’s proposals will be interesting.

Microsoft eyeing up Facebook?

Kerr on Privatisation

Roger Kerr writes in the NZ Herald:

With the National Party’s decision not to move any state-owned enterprises to the private sector in its first term if elected this year, we appear to have a new political consensus between the major parties in New Zealand: privatisation is bad.

I wouldn’t say that “privatisation is bad” is the consensus, more that “privatisation is very unpopular”.

Indeed New Zealand has done even more to stand out from the crowd: it has gone in the opposite direction with the buy-back of Air New Zealand and now the railways and ferries, the establishment of Kiwibank, the renationalisation of ACC, and the Auckland Regional Council’s reversal of the part-privatisation of Ports of Auckland.

Yep, the state grows and grows.

The position across the Tasman is also instructive. All governments at federal and state level are Labor, and none is opposed to privatisation. Currently the New South Wales government is battling with trade unions to privatise its electricity generators. Victoria did so in the mid-1990s, and in the five years to 2007 electricity prices in Melbourne have risen by less than one-third as much as in Sydney.

Labor in Australia is far more moderate than the counterpart in New Zealand. National has been scared off privatisation because they know a rational debate is so difficult to manage from opposition. I certainly hope that if National wins, they will govern in such a way in their first term to gain the trust of the public, so that if they then propose some modest asset sales in a second term, the debate can focus on the merits of the actual asset being in state vs private ownership, rather than an ideological holy war that all privatisation is bad and all nationalisation is good.

The worldwide moves in the past 25 years to shift state enterprises into the private sector have been driven by the evidence of major economic gains in the form of improved efficiency and profitability, lower prices and better services, and more investment and output.

Indeed. While there are some individual examples which didn’t achieve the above, the evidence if you look at the whole OECD is over whelming. And if we really want to close the gap with Australia, it will be hard to do so with the state running such a major segment of our economy.

This does not mean all private businesses are success stories and all state-owned enterprises underperform. Rather, the point is that, on average and over time, the private sector is better than politicians at running commercial businesses, and governments should not bet against the odds with taxpayers’ money.

Also owning an asset can make a Government reluctant to regulate monopoly aspects of it, because they own it. They try to do hidden regulation, where they drop hints to Directors, or appoint the right Directors, instead of having an open and transparent regulatory process.

Out of some 30 privatisations, criticism focuses mainly on just two alleged “failures”, Air New Zealand and Tranz Rail. Even if true, these criticisms would not weaken the general argument that most privatisations have been successful, but arguably the Government did not need to get involved in either case.

The Air NZ bail out only became necessary because the Government refused to allow Singapore Airlines to invest in the company.

The political aversion to privatisation is costing New Zealand potential gains in living standards. A Business Roundtable study (www.nzbr.org.nz) estimated New Zealand could gain about 1 per cent of gross domestic product a year by privatising SOEs (leaving aside local government-owned businesses).

Unless wages and other incomes in New Zealand are to drift further behind those of Australia and other countries, this is an economic reform that will have to come back on the political agenda sooner or later.

1% of GDP might not sound a lot, but over a decade or so it is massive, and long-term is the difference between having living standards of Australia or of Slovakia.

A sad graduation ceremony

NZPA reports that Chris Elliott will attend graduation in Dunedin this weekend on behalf of his sister Sophie Elliott, who was horrifically murdered earlier this year. Elliott had achieved first class honours, and it will be a very sombre aspect to the ceremony. For my 2c though I think it is very appropriate to recognise what happened, rather than try and pretend it didn’t and just have her name read out.

All murders are sad and tragic, but this one more so than most. I just do not understand how something like this can happen.

No tax free income for New Zealand

Michael Cullen has ruled out making the first few thousand of income tax free. This is a pity because I think there is a strong case that there should be no tax on your income until you are earning more than the minimum amount you need to live on. The welfare system then tops people up to that minimum standard, but it is significantly wasteful to tax people just to then give them that money back as welfare.

In Australia the first $11,000 of income is tax free, and by 2012/13 the first $20,000 will be tax free.

So what does this mean for someone earning say $40,000. Well in NZ you $8,070 of tax which is an average 20.2% and this has not changed since 1999. Now in Australia it used to be $9,802 in 1999 which is an average of 24.5%.

But Peter Costello, and now Kevin Rudd, have shown what you can do if you reduce tax just a bit every year. In 2012/13 someone earning $40,000 in Australia will pay only $3,400 of tax – an average tax rate of 8.5%.

So because Michael Cullen has refused to reduce taxes until forced to at near gunpoint, the NZer on $40,000 who used to pay $1,800 less tax than an Aussie, now will be paying around $4,500 more by 2012/13 – less whatever he announces in the budget.  But it is hardly going to close the gap he has allowed to grow.

Australian tax cuts

Kevin Rudd has confirmed he will deliver $31 billion of tax cuts, as promised before the last election.

He is also trimming $1.3 billion off the government bureaucracy.

He ruled out blowing other savings on quick-fixes and handouts, saying it was time Budgets looked beyond the next election. “I am determined that this Budget won’t be another one-year wonder,” he said.

It will be interesting to compare the two budgets this month.

Tizard rules out dropping the speed limit

Crime in Christchurch

The Press reports on a meeting held in Christchurch last night to discuss the crime problem in Christchurch. Since 2003 violent crimes have gone up 29%, fuelling the concern. Overall crime has dropped but it is violent crime which causes the most concern. The local police commander may have a solution:

Canterbury police district commander Superintendent Dave Cliff pointed to the dramatic decrease in crime in New York City in the 1990s when police began aggressively targeting petty crimes such as subway fare evasion and graffiti.

The approach, known as “Broken Windows” policing, saw low-end crime fall away and was matched by a decrease in high-end crime.

Cliff told over 400 people at the Cut Crime in Christchurch meeting at the Town Hall that a similar approach in Christchurch was on the cards.

He cautioned the crowd they would have to be prepared for the consequences of the move.

“If one of your children is breaching the liquor ban we are going to have to take consistent action,” he said.

Excellent. It would be a great trial for NZ, and if successful there could be a template for other regions. I can’t say for sure that it will work, but the results from New York are positive enough that it should at least be trialled.

Analysing the Democratic Results

Obama has easily won North Carolina (as predicted) by 56% to 42%.  Indiana went for Clinton but only by 51% to 49%.

Clinton’s failure to win bigger in Indiana is increasing the pressure on her to pull out. But it is likely that the contest will go on for at least another month.

In North Carolina the exit poll has a huge differential by race.

White Democrats backed Clinton 62% to 37% and white Independents were 58% to 38%.  Obama however got 92% of Black Democrats.

The Indiana exit poll is also extreme. Of concern must be the fact that only 71% say they will vote for Obama if he is the candidate against McCain.

White Democrats in Indiana went 64% to 36% for Clinton.  Black Democrats were 91% for Obama.

Obama also won the “very liberal” vote by 62% to 38%. They only make up 14% of primary voters.

A critical view of KiwiSaver

The Centre for Independent Studies has published a critical analysis of KiwiSaver. I am actually a reasonable fan of KiwiSaver (but not of how they did it with no consultation with business), so disagree with the conclusions in the CIS analysis. However I support most of their analysis, which I will summarise here:

  • Most people were already saving enough for retirement, with 80% of couples saving enough to maintain a level of consumption similar to or better than in pre-retirement.
  • With KiwiSaver and New Zealand Super combined, it is now possible for a someone on the average wage to retire on a higher income than they enjoy during their working life.
  • It is over the top to have a subsidised saving scheme on top of an age pension that is the most generous in the OECD.

This is a very strong point. People are being over-taxed and over-subsidised now. The NZ Super scheme is the most generous in the OECD as it is neither means nor asset tested. You combine that with a scheme that all bar the very stupid or very poor take part in with an average 10% of salary saved per annum, and you end up with higher incomes in retirement than during your working life.

  • KiwiSaver largely benefits the wealthy, who can afford to save more.

Yep, and every wealthy person I know is making sure they get the maximum subsidy from the taxpayer, and self employed people are upping their salaries so they get to claim their employer contribution as a tax expense.

  • KiwiSaver politically and economically threatens the future of New Zealand Super and makes means testing more likely in the future.

I reached this conclusion during the budget lockup, when it was announced. There is no way in 30 years time we will have both NZ Super (including Cullen Fund) and KiwiSaver. Dr Cullen has actually destroyed the consensus over publicly funded non means tested superannuation. If he was a National Minister, the left would be baying for his blood.

  • Evidence from around the world suggests that subsidies for savings schemes do little to actually
    increase overall savings. Instead, people tend to shuffle around existing savings to take advantage
    of the subsidies.

Yep. Most incentives change individual behaviours rather than change the fundamentals. However as the incentives for KiwiSaver are so strong, and as you have to opt out of it in a new job, I do think it will have some impact on overall savings levels.

  • It is now more rewarding for people to join KiwiSaver than it is to pay off debt or a mortgage, or
    to invest in business or an education.

The CIS paper actually quotes me as saying “You have to be very very poor or very very stupid to turn down an up to 2:1 subsidy”. And indeed, the level of subsidy is so high that it makes sense to borrow money so you can save it!

  • The requirement for employers to contribute 4% of a worker’s salary will put downward pressure on wages and job growth.

Of course. Employers look at the total cost of remuneration. What is unfortunate is those that do not join KiwiSaver may be punished for the cost of those who do join.

  • The total cost will rise to $2 billion a year, which is more than New Zealand spends on its entire defence force.

It is a lot of money, and not sustainable on top of the Cullen Fund and NZ Super. But it is not necessairly KiwiSaver which should go.

  • The easiest way to fix KiwiSaver is to scrap the generous incentives to contribute,

That is one way to fix the problem, but not my preferred one.

CIS are looking at this in terms of what is best for New Zealand, and they may be correct. But first let us look at this from the view of the left:

  1. Penalises poor people who can not afford to save
  2. Gives the greatest advantage to richer people
  3. Allows rich self employed people to avoid more tax
  4. Pushes wages down
  5. Undermines universal provision of superannuation
  6. Privatises savings from the state to the private sector

KiwiSaver is everything the left should hate. I guarantee you if Bill English had introduced this, it would have been denounced.

Now CIS are saying this is bad public policy, even if it is something the right should love (which demonstrates that they are not as ideological as critics claim).

I support KiwiSaver because it is inevitable that it will lead to means (and maybe asset) testing of NZ Super. And I believe in means testing.

I support KiwiSaver because in 20 years or so (once takeup is near universal) the $50 billion or so in the Cullen Fund will be dished out into people’s KiwiSaver accounts. And after giving over $25,000 to each family, no future Government would ever take it out of their KiwiSaver account.

I support KiwiSaver as I would rather choose my investments manager, than have the Government do it for me.

I support KiwiSaver as it will lead to a reduction in the size of the state.

So while I agree with much of the analysis of the CIS, I disagree with their conclusion to scrap the incentives and subsidies. Instead just wait for the Cullen Fund to be privatised and NZ Super to end up means tested, and probably CPI adjusted instead of wage adjusted.

Back Benches on tonight

A reminder to people in Wellington that if you want to see Back Benches filmed live, head down to the Backbencher on Molesworth Street around 8.30 pm for a 9.00 pm start. You can also watch it on Channel 7 if you have Freeview, or on the Internet afterwards.

Incidentially I mentioned last week that one uncouth gentleman used a four letter word that is most unsuitable for live television, and that he was “someone sitting with the Green supporters”

A reader who was in the pub e-mailed me to say that the gentleman was in fact a visiting Pom, who had been roped in by the producer to boost numbers. This makes sense – England is the home of uncouth behaviour 🙂

Officials look at reducing the speed limit

Government officials are looking at reducing the speed limit to reduce carbon emissions. They have estimated a reduction in the speed limit from 100 km/h to 90 km/h will reduce oil demand by 1.4%.

Hell, why stop there. A maximum 20 km/hr limit will do wonders for reducing oil demand.

Bye bye to carbon neutrality

Paula Oliver writes on the big backdown:

The Government looks like it is retreating on its big climate change push as quickly as it advanced the surprise concept of a ‘carbon neutral’ New Zealand.

Prime Minister Helen Clark’s announcement of a two-year delay to transport’s inclusion in the flagship emissions trading scheme yesterday can only be seen as backpedalling.

And with the regional petrol tax delay, they are in full retreat.

It is only 18 months since the Prime Minister first voiced the aspirational target of taking the country to carbon neutrality. A lot has changed since, with food and oil prices surging as high mortgage rates also begin to bite on household budgets.

It is no longer as easy to convince people of the worthiness of paying more now for everyday goods in order to prevent global warming.

It has always been about a trade-off, and the Government has tried to con people that one can go carbon neutral and not have it greatly affect businesses and consumers. I actually accept that one has to bear some costs to reduce carbon emissions, but we should be honest about the fact there will be costs.

Paula looks at the three planks to the Government’s plans:

  1. The biofuels push is languishing in a select committee as the global debate about the merit of some of the fuels rages.
  2. The regional fuel tax – to be used to fund the ‘sustainable’ electrification of Auckland’s rail system – is being toned down so the country’s largest city isn’t slapped with another 5c a litre on the price of its petrol.
  3. And now the first part of the biggest of all the climate change policies – the emissions trading system – is also being slowed down so that drivers don’t feel more pain at the petrol pumps.

This is not a small backdown in one area. Their entire programme of environment sustainability is on the retreat.

The deal of the century

Fran O’Sullivan writes:

The Sydney Morning Herald’s Matt O’Sullivan joked “you only get one Helen Clark in your life” as he told the story of how Toll’s Paul Little stitched up the Kiwi Government for a whopping $665 million to buy back the nation’s trains and rail ferries.

Yes, we are no doubt the toast of the Australian business community for donating so much money to
them.

The reality is that Little’s $665 million Government-backed cheque is three times the valuation that Toll put on the trains and rail ferries when it launched its takeover for the financially stressed Tranz Rail in 2003.

Toll also gets to keep Tranzlink, the company’s NZ-based rail and road forwarding business, together with warehousing and contract logistics operations and gets a six-year rent-free period on its existing premises.

This is where they are very smart. They will still make money from sending freight over rail, and they know the Government will not put prices up because they want more use of rail.

It gets the profit-turning part of the business and despite the fact it was required to pump $100 million into new rolling stock under the agreement it reached with the Government in July 2003, much of what the Government has now bought on the taxpayers’ behalf is a mere hotch-potch of assets masquerading as a business.

I wonder who will be silly enough to accept appointment as a Director.

Surely the Government – as owner – would want the national railway to at the very least break even? The proposed state-owned enterprise may not have to post a dividend and commercial returns to shareholders (like Toll has to) but the reality is that unless some strong financial disciplines are instituted it will simply be another sump-hole for taxpayer funds for years to come.

The dividend policy, if there is one, will be interesting.

The problem is that this is really an election year move by the Labour-led Government to try and make ownership of state assets a campaign issue.

If the Government was truly serious about strengthening the role sustainable transport will play in a carbon-constrained future it would not have stymied plans for regional councils to apply local fuels taxes to fund projects like the $500 million proposal to electrify the Auckland suburban rail network.

As it is it has mopped up an out-of-date railway with taxpayers’ cash – but effectively put a blocker in the way of proposals that would get more people out of cars.

Not a very bright outcome really.

Very astute. Helen giveth to the environment on one hand and taketh on the other.

NRT on Labour’s climate flip-flops

No Right Turn joins the Greens with his unhapiness:

It’s official: the government has delayed the entry of transport – our second largest source of emissions – into the ETS until 1 January 2011. So we will now have an emissions trading scheme which excludes our largest source of emissions (agriculture) for all of CP1, our second largest source for most of it, and which doesn’t impact on anyone other than forest owners until 2010. And this, the government claims, will reduce emissions. Bullshit.

Rather than proceed with such a flawed scheme, why don’t we just wait a few weeks for details of the Australian scheme and look at seeing if we can turn that into a Trans-Tasman scheme.

The official excuse (being reliably trotted out over at The Standard) is that high oil prices will do more than the ETS would. There’s some truth in this – high oil prices have effectively capped usage by driving people towards more fuel efficient vehicles – but the problem is that oil prices can drop. … And there are predictions that prices will also drop over the next one to two years as demand drops due to global recession, before picking back up again. So  … whoever is in government in 2010 is going to face exactly the same pressure to give polluters a free ride as Labour is facing now. And like 2008, 2011 is an election year…

Indeed, it might just keep being indefinitely delayed.

Meanwhile, the government’s veto on regional fuel taxes – also driven by an effort to inoculate against claims that they are responsible for rising petrol prices – will deprive local councils of the very tool they need to reduce emissions and provide people with an alternative to cars. So we get the worst of both worlds: unfettered pollution, and no funding to prevent it. So much for Labour and sustainability.

The irony is that the Government brings in a special law to allow these regional fuel taxes, and then before it is even passed, announce they will not approve any proposals to use the law!!

The Greens aren’t taking this lying down, and have declared that they will not vote for an environmentally compromised ETS. Which means the government will be dependent solely on National to pass it. It’s a dangerous gambit – National’s natural inclination will be to weaken the scheme further – but if they want to renege on their commitments, they can do it without the Greens’ stamp of approval.

The Greens have also said they will be announcing pre-election which party they will support post-election to form a Government. While I am sure it will still be Labour, their decision is getting a fair bit harder.

Blog Bits

Steven Price blogs that the headlines regarding the Berrymans bear little resemblance to the reality of what the Judge ruled which was simply to say that the Coroner was wrong to say that the collapse was primarily the Berrymans’ fault but he effectively amended that to partly their fault.

Bryce Edwards blogs on how Matt McCarten deserves his rating by Metro as a “right bastard”.

Cactus Kate blogs that she has managed to restore Deborah Hill Cone.

Fairfacts Media points out the PM is being somewhat economical with the truth when she claims Telecom wrote National’s broadband policy. I guess she believes if you repeat a lie enough times, people may believe it.

Greens pissed off

I think the Greens are getting very pissed off with Labour. Look at the last three entries on Frog Blog.

First a minor swipe at their “gas guzzling government limos”.

Then a satirical dig at the latest flip-flop:

If there are any other sectors of the economy that have not taken much action in the last few years to cut your carbon emissions and would like a last minute reprieve would you please form an orderly queue outside the 9th floor of the Beehive and await your turn to receive your government climate policy ‘flip flop’. If you are a wealthy special interest such as dairy, petrol or roading you can join our priority queue.

Then the real danger:

The Government will have to look to the National Party to support its Emissions Trading legislation if it is watered down to the point where it provides no significant environmental benefit.

“We are not in this game just so some can make money speculating on carbon prices. Emissions reductions need to be real and soon, or it is not worth doing it,” Green Party Co-Leader Jeanette Fitzsimons says.

Having the Greens refuse to vote for the ETS would really expose the PM’s hypocrisy over her claims of leadership towards carbon neutrality.

More Government flip-flops

At he same time as the Government is flip-flopping on biofuels, and flip-flopping on regional petrol taxes, they also are retreating from having the transport sector in the Emissions Trading Scheme.

Jeanette Fitzsimons is not impressed:

“We’re trying to get the best possible legislation through this term … I think there will be legislation before this election but the question is will it be even weaker than what we’ve got now.” Ms Fitzsimons said further backtracks on the trading scheme should see the Prime Minister awarded a “climate ditherers” award to replace the United Nations Champion of the Earth award she recently received.

I can understand the politics around a delay, but you have to ask will it be only for two years? If petrol prices are still high in 2011, will the transport sector be exempted or delayed further. And if you start doing that the whole ETS may collapse if one sector is left out.

If one was to deliver significant enough tax cuts, they would compensate for any increase in petrol prices. But the risk of delivering chewing gum tax cuts which wouldn’t even meet the increased cost of petrol was obviously too high.

Morning After Pill

The Herald reports:

Girls may be given free access to the emergency contraceptive pill at their local Auckland pharmacies in a bid to reduce teen pregnancies and abortions.

The medicine can already be sold by many pharmacists without a doctor’s prescription, including to girls without parental consent.

I have some concerns with this proposal. Not to do with having it available without parental consent – that has been the case for over a decade. I would hate to see however the morning after pill seen as just like any other contraceptive, and something which is okay to take regularly, as oppossed to in an emergency.

For that reason there is some benefit about having to see a doctor, who can impress upon the recipient the need for proper contraception. One doesn’t want to make it difficult for people to get hold of, but I am aware through friends who have taken it that can cause nausea and vomiting plus some tenderness, so it really is preferable not to have to rely on it too often. Adults know this, but young teenagers do not always.

Obviously it doesn’t affect me directly, but I used to be a youth leader to a group of 14 to 18 year olds, and part of that sometimes involved helping them cope with the consequences of unprotected (or protection which failed) sex, and it really did help to have them see a doctor to get the emergency contraceptive pill, rather than just grab one from the pharmacy.

“Big Dad” told me to lie

The depositions hearing for former Labour Minister Taito Philip Field, or “Big Dad” continues. The Herald reports:

A Thai overstayer who tiled MP Taito Phillip Field’s house in Samoa says Field gave him 1000 tala ($553) after asking him to lie to police about the work he had done for him.

Sunan Siriwan, who referred to Field twice as “Big Dad”, told the Manukau District Court through an interpreter yesterday that “almost everything” he said to a lawyer appointed to investigate the case was untrue.

He said Field told him, while driving in a car in Samoa in or around December 2005, that he had “a problem” in New Zealand and that he should tell the police that he did not work for the MP.

“He told me at that time that you are not working at my place, and he also said to me, ‘Don’t tell the police that you and I met’,” Mr Siriwan said.

He said Field asked him the next morning if he had money, and Mr Siriwan replied that he did.

“Then he gave me 1000 tala, which he has never given me that much before,” Mr Siriwan told the court. “I did not understand why he gave me so much money.”

Hmmn, is this a multi-choice test?

He said he worked mostly seven days a week for eight to 10 hours a day. In return, he was paid “expenses”.

“Some weeks I got 100 tala ($55), other weeks 150 to 200 tala ($83-$110),” he said.

Labour’s commitment to strong wages – except for their slave labour working for under $2 an hour.

He said that about three months after he arrived in Samoa, he received a letter from Field about a work permit in New Zealand. Shortly afterwards, two other Thai men, Kaew and Yao, arrived from New Zealand “to do gib-stopping for Big Dad”.

Such a charming nickname, yet so apt.