Willie donates VC to the SAS Trust
Corporal Willie Apiata has donated his Victoria Cross to the NZSAS Trust. It will be stored at the SAS Compound in Papakura.
I suspect it is not going to get stolen from there!
Poneke reminds us how lucky those of our generation are:
I am from only the first generation in human history whose young men – teenage boys — were not forced by their country’s leaders to fight and kill the young men and teenage boys of other countries and be killed by them. My parents’ generation was the last such generation so far, and, I fervently hope, the last ever.
As a parent, scarcely a day goes by that I do not give thanks to having grown up in relative peace and that there is a good chance my children will not be forced to fight and maybe die in battle against someone else’s children. …
It’s Anzac Day today, and like she started doing several years ago, my daughter, 15, is attending two services. She is one of a growing number of her generation who have taken a great interest in the sacrifices made in battle by her forebears and sets out to honour them by attending Anzac Day events. I asked her this morning why, and her answer was simplicity itself.
“To pay respect for the people who died in wars,” she said. “The First World War could have been avoided but if people hadn’t stood up to Hitler he would have taken over Europe, and much of the world, so we were fighting for peace, odd as that sounds.” …
“I don’t like it when people protest at the cenotaph. They shouldn’t be protesting at the soldiers. They were only doing what they had to. They should be protesting at the governments that started the wars.”
We shall never forget, certainly not now that our children are ensuring that their great-grandparents and great-great-grandparents who were forced to fight and die in terrible, often futile battles long ago, will not be forgotten.
Poneke is such a good blogger, he should consider writing for a living 🙂
Corporal Willie Apiata has donated his Victoria Cross to the NZSAS Trust. It will be stored at the SAS Compound in Papakura.
I suspect it is not going to get stolen from there!
Oh dear do not watch this if you are easily offended. It’s an ad for a new “Priest Off” spray which keeps them away from children who have been sprayed with it. Bitingly funny as National Banana often is.
So true. Original from Stuff.
Another video sent to me by a reader. This one is about Labour rehabilitating Ministers and has the famous dancing scenes by Pete and Trevor! All you amateur video editors keep sending them in.
Lyndon Hood has a very amusing feature at Scoop where NZ Politics is a text adventure. Extracts:
There is a small mailbox here.
> open mailbox
Opening the mailbox reveals a leaflet.
> get leaflet
Taken.
> examine leaflet
I see nothing special about the leaflet.
> See if leaflet breaches electoral finance act
I don’t understand that.
> You’re not the only one. …
A HUGE GREEN FIERCE SNAKE BARS THE WAY!
> kill snake
WITH WHAT? YOUR BARE HANDS?
> slap snake with ‘slippery’ tag
THE TAG STICKS TO THE SNAKE. YOU HAVE INJURED THE SNAKE.
> slap snake with ‘slippery’ tag
YOU ALREADY DID THAT
> slap snake with ‘slippery’ tag
NOTHING HAPPENS
> slap snake with ‘slippery’ tag
NOTHING HAPPENS
> slippery slippery slippery slippery …
and then the conclusion:
NOTHING HAPPENS
> slip-slip-slip-slippery
YOU HAVE BEEN EATEN BY THE SNAKE.
NEW GAME? (Y/N)
> explain snake was suffering from confusion
Read the whole thing. It should become a regular series.
The ultimate Nanny State bill continues with select committee hearings:
Yesterday, Fight The Obesity Trust spokeswoman Dr Robyn Toomath told the parliamentary committee considering the bill that was exactly what people wanted.
“People are desperate for Nanny State’s help. Parents are desperate for help to get children to eat healthily,” she said.
It is not help but coercion they will be getting.
The food industry soon struck back, as the Confectionery Manufacturers Association painted a picture of the Director-General of Health being granted the power to ban Pineapple Lumps, Perky Nana bars and Easter eggs.
This is not an exaggeration. The Public Health Bill gives immense powers to the Director-General of Health – more powers than Cabinet currently has.
Lyndon Hood reminds me of the goodness that is the Borowitz Report for US political satire. Take this item on Monday headlined “Democratic Race ‘Too Mean,’ Say Swift Boat Veterans“:
The Democratic race for President has descended to “a level of meanness and acrimony that is damaging to American politics,” the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth said today.
The Swift Boat group, which became famous in 2004 for attacking Democratic presidential nominee John Kerry, said that they were speaking out because “the current Democratic contest is giving swiftboating a bad name.”
“We have increasingly heard pundits accusing Clinton and Obama of swiftboating each other,” said Swift Boat Veteran Tracy Klugian. “This hurts the reputation of swiftboating.”
Mr. Klugian was quick to draw a distinction between what Sens. Clinton and Obama are doing and swiftboating, which he called “a noble profession.”
“When you try to destroy a member of another party, that’s swiftboating,” said Mr. Klugian. “When you do it to a member of your own party, that’s cannibalism.”
He said that the Swift Boat Veterans for Truth would soon air ads attacking both Democratic candidates for sullying the reputation of swiftboating.
That is just classic.
Petrol is close to $2 a litre. Now most of this is due to global costs, but what is the Government doing to help make petrol more affordable?
Oh it is going to stick on an extra 10c a litre regional tax, and other “initiatives” are predicted to add on another 15c a litre.
Oh yes that will help.
Peter Dunne makes a useful contribution to the political debate on broadband:
“Everyone agrees that’s a good idea, but all we’ve heard so far is the Minister of Communications carping that National is being opportunistic and handing too much monopoly power to Telecom; New Zealand First is similarly outraged that Telecom is getting too much money; and ACT has delivered the standard libertarian rant that hates the Government collecting or spending any money at all.
“Surely the point is that widespread, superfast broadband is a good thing for the New Zealand economy and the only question is: how do we get there?
“It’d be excellent if politicians spent more time working out the answer to that question and not simply whacking each other over the head and feeling they’ve accomplished something.
“If direct government investment like Mr Key proposes is not the answer, then I’d like to hear two things from the critics – first, what is the alternative, and second, why has it not happened to date,” said Mr Dunne.
A useful challenge.
Mauricio Freitas blogged yesterday that there is an online petition asking Sky (or TVNZ or TV3) to bring in the Sci-Fi channel.
I am signature No 541.
| State | Result | Margin | Electors | Cumulative |
| California | Clinton | 8% | 55 | 55 |
| Texas | Clinton | 4% | 34 | 89 |
| New York | Clinton | 17% | 31 | 120 |
| Florida | Clinton | 17% | 27 | 147 |
| Illinois | Obama | 32% | 21 | 168 |
| Pennsylvania | Clinton | 10% | 21 | 189 |
| Ohio | Clinton | 10% | 20 | 209 |
| Michigan | Clinton | 10% | 17 | 226 |
| Georgia | Obama | 35% | 15 | 241 |
| New Jersey | Clinton | 10% | 15 | 256 |
| North Carolina | 06-May-08 | 15 | 271 | |
| Virginia | Obama | 29% | 13 | 284 |
| Massachusetts | Clinton | 15% | 12 | 296 |
| Indiana | 06-May-08 | 11 | 307 | |
| Missouri | Obama | 1% | 11 | 318 |
| Tennessee | Clinton | 14% | 11 | 329 |
| Washington | Obama | 37% | 11 | 340 |
| Arizona | Clinton | 8% | 10 | 350 |
| Maryland | Obama | 25% | 10 | 360 |
| Minnesota | Obama | 34% | 10 | 370 |
| Wisconsin | Obama | 17% | 10 | 380 |
| Alabama | Obama | 14% | 9 | 389 |
| Colorado | Obama | 35% | 9 | 398 |
| Louisiana | Obama | 21% | 9 | 407 |
| Kentucky | 20-May-08 | 8 | 415 | |
| South Carolina | Obama | 28% | 8 | 423 |
| Connecticut | Obama | 4% | 7 | 430 |
| Iowa | Obama | 8% | 7 | 437 |
| Oklahoma | Clinton | 24% | 7 | 444 |
| Oregon | 20-May-08 | 7 | 451 | |
| Arkansas | Clinton | 43% | 6 | 457 |
| Kanasa | Obama | 48% | 6 | 463 |
| Mississippi | Obama | 24% | 6 | 469 |
| Nebraska | Obama | 36% | 5 | 474 |
| Nevada | Clinton | 6% | 5 | 479 |
| New Mexico | Clinton | 1% | 5 | 484 |
| Utah | Obama | 18% | 5 | 489 |
| West Virginia | 13-May-08 | 5 | 494 | |
| Hawaii | Obama | 52% | 4 | 498 |
| Idaho | Obama | 63% | 4 | 502 |
| Maine | Obama | 19% | 4 | 506 |
| New Hampshire | Clinton | 3% | 4 | 510 |
| Rhode Island | Clinton | 18% | 4 | 514 |
| Alaska | Obama | 50% | 3 | 517 |
| DC | Obama | 51% | 3 | 520 |
| Delaware | Obama | 11% | 3 | 523 |
| Montana | 03-Jun-08 | 3 | 526 | |
| North Dakota | Obama | 24% | 3 | 529 |
| South Dakota | 03-Jun-08 | 3 | 532 | |
| Vermont | Obama | 20% | 3 | 535 |
| Wyoming | Obama | 23% | 3 | 538 |
The table above shows the 51 states (including DC) which get to vote in the November US election, and who has won each state in the Democratic Primary, and by how much. It is sorted by most to least electoral college votes.
Of the ten biggest states (comprising 256 of the 538 electors) Clinton has won eight, and Obama just two (one his own).
Obama is still highly highly likely to be the Democratic nominee. But his inability to win in the larger states does mean those lingering doubts about him grow. And Clinton is not going anywhere as Maureen Dowd points out:
Now that Hillary has won Pennsylvania, it will take a village to help Obama escape from the suffocating embrace of his rival. Certainly Howard Dean will be of no use steering her to the exit. It’s like Micronesia telling Russia to denuke.
Heh. Indeed.
Meanwhile Clinton is going more hawkish than the hawks. Look at this:
Clinton further displayed tough talk in an interview airing on “Good Morning America” Tuesday. ABC News’ Chris Cuomo asked Clinton what she would do if Iran attacked Israel with nuclear weapons.
“I want the Iranians to know that if I’m the president, we will attack Iran,” Clinton said. “In the next 10 years, during which they might foolishly consider launching an attack on Israel, we would be able to totally obliterate them.”
Hey if MCain wins, maybe she can be Secretary of Defence 🙂
Helen had to miss out on the gala dinner in Singapore where she received a trophy made of recycled metal from the UN for being one of seven winners in the annual UN Champions of the Earth awards.Now Helen’s record on carbon emissions is worse than George W Bush and John Howard. Kyoto is all about what percentage increase or decrease one should have over 1990 levels and George and John did better than Helen in being closer to their target.
NZ has the fourth worst actual record of annex 1 countries in terms of meeting our Kyoto obligations (we are 29% over target) so one can only conclude, the award is yet another indication of the UN’s long demonstrated preference for rhetoric over substance. Typical UN – does not matter what you do in practice, as long as you churn out the right rhetoric!
But while its great policy, none of this stuff has actually been implemented yet, so Clark has essentially been given this award on the basis of hot air.
I am not sure the policy is that great. They have yet to pass a single policy through Parliament. Their biofuels legislation has been rubbished by the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment and their Emission scheme by Greenpeace. Their Fart Tax failed due to the hypocrisy of treatment of debits and credits.
The future price of carbon is so uncertain, that I more and more think a carbon tax in the short term would be better than the tradeable emissions scheme. Under some dire scenarios the scheme could wipe out out food export sector. from Radio NZ yesterday:
Federated Farmers says the Government’s proposed emissions trading scheme has the potential to extingish [sic] extinguish food exports from New Zealand. The comments are based on a Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry report which shows the projected impacts of the trading scheme on farmers’ profitsm a range of different carbon prices and the corresponding financial impact the scheme would have on different sectors such as sheep, beef, dairy, horticulture and deer. The figures analyse the impact the Emissions Trading Scheme would have had on the sectors if it had been introduced without warning in mid-2006. Among the worst affected sectors are deer, sheep and beef, greenhouse tomatoes and dairy. Federated Farmers’ Dairy Section Chairman Frank Brenmuhl says based on the projections for a payout of $4.14 per kilo of milk solids and a full carbon price of $50 per tonne the average drop in farmers’ profits would be 123%.
Now for those who only have a degree in economic history, a 123% drop in profits means you will be losing money. In other words no food production at all. So we will meet out Kyoto target by importing all our food from overseas. Hmmn that will be great eh.
UPDATE: The Greens’ Frog Blog is also weighing in, comparing Helen Clark getting an award for being a Champion of the Earth to Brian Waddle being named Black Cap of the Year for his cricket commentary. Shit that is funny – Frog is being more sarcastic than me!
It has been interesting to see the various posts and press releases on National’s Fibre proposal. I’ll try and cover most of them:
Phil at Whoar labels it as “what could well be an election winning policy.
Bomber at Tumeke calls it a “Bloody good idea”. Heh shouldn’t that be damn good idea 🙂
Mike at Morphyoss says:
“good on you National for releasing a good policy that will massively benefit New Zealand should they win the election. Now it is up to Labour to respond, remember fibre is extremely important to our economy and it is important that labour do something about that or they will lose the election”
David Slack at Public Address is unimpressed with some of the arguments against:
Here’s my response to the snide folk who have been saying: faster downloading for your YouTube and your porn and your pirated movies. I spend thousands on hosting in the USA because no-one here can set me up with a fast enough server and a big enough data allowance. That money could be being spent here. Ask Rod Drury what it could mean for the Software As A Service businesses he’s involved in.
It’s becoming trite to say it, but it’s nonetheless true: internet infrastructure is as important to us as roads, railways and refrigerated ships. Why not have it in abundance, rather than relatively scarce and expensive? Let a thousand e-commerce sites bloom!
Business NZ says
National’s plan to speed up provision of broadband to most premises is welcome, says Business NZ.
Chief Executive Phil O’Reilly says a public-private partnership is a logical way to spread the cost of such a huge undertaking.
“The challenge would be in working out just how the partnership would operate to ensure as many investors as possible could contribute, and in finding an appropriate regulatory regime.”
The EPMU is also reasonably supportive:
The Engineering, Printing and Manufacturing Union says John Key’s policy of rolling out fibre optic cable to 75% of New Zealand homes is a step in the right direction, but is concerned the task may be impossible given the current skills shortage.
“We really want to see this sort of project happen as any investment that will increase productivity in New Zealand is good for our members but until we see details on wages and training around this it’s hard to see how fibre roll-out will be possible.”
In terms of the issues the EPMU raises about skills and capacity, I don’t think it will be a major barrier (but certainly is a factor). When InternetNZ met with David Skilling of the NZ Institute last week to discuss his fibre proposal, one of the issues we raised was whether there was enough capacity to physically get fibre laid out by 2018 (note National is proposing 2014 as a target). Off memory Skilling indicated that they had talked to two separate engineering firms and their advice was there was enough people and and capacity to do it within 10 years, and even within five years if you really pushed it.
Now that is second or third hand so it doesn’t mean there may not be issues, but it does show some work has already been done looking at the capacity issue. One reason it is important is if supply can not meet the demand, prices could go up significantly. This has been an issue in the roading sector.
Jordan Carter is also pleased:
I am pleased that with John Key’s policy proposal, launched yesterday at a Chamber of Commerce lunch in Wellington, the debate about New Zealand’s broadband future has shifted from “whether” to do fibre to the home, to “how and how soon” to do it.
Professionally speaking, I am pleased there is now a political commitment from one major party to putting money into this. I am looking forward to assessing the various plans that come forward, and I’m sure that InternetNZ will be looking to persuade all parties to invest in this critical infrastructure.
As a Labour person I am quite sure the Nats’ proposal can be bettered, and that Labour will do so. David Cunliffe’s comments have critiqued what the Nats have proposed – the specifics of it, such as they are – but he has not criticised the goal. That’s good, because it is important for New Zealand to get on with it.
As Jordan says, the ball is in Labour’s court. A win-win will be as many parties as possible commited to the goal.
Final point, I ended up next to Williamson at the launch lunch. His zeal for this is impressive, given his record in government. It’s nice to see a genuine change of view and broad, cross-party acknowledgement of the importance of this kind of technology.
I was at the same table, and it is generous of Jordan to note Maurice’s enthusiastic advocacy of this proposal. Some have suggested he would have problems with it, but far from that – he has helped John Key with a fair bit of the research going into this.
In fact I joked to one person, that Maurice was now so enthusiastic about this type of intervention, it was a bit like how a smoker who gives up smoking becomes the most passionate anti-smoker 🙂
Also somewhat amusing was that a fellow guest at our table (not knowing Jordan’s political background I think) stated his view that Labour had done an awful job in this area. Now the last thing one wants is a big political debate over lunch, so Jordan was being very tactful with his response. I actually interjected into the conversation and praised most of what Labour and David Cunliffe has done in this area, and said the work they had done to date built a good base, but this was really about taking a big step up from that base.
Anyway I found it amusing to be defending Labour’s record in this area, in front of National’s IT/Comms spokesperson. I must say though I was disappointed with Cunliffe’s response to the policy, but I suppose he didn’t have much choice unless he could convince Michael Cullen to lend him a quick $1.5 billion 🙂
Finally on the luke-warm but positive side we have Russell Brown at Public Address:
National’s new $1.5 billion broadband spending proposal — it’s a bit soon to be calling it a “plan” — is nothing if not ambitious: 75% of homes with fibre connectivity in by 2014 is not a goal that has been envisaged as realistic before.
It is ambitious.
The initial step is a doubled of the Broadband Challenge Fund to $48 million, and there’s a very welcome commitment to “open access” (whether that means dark fibre or open access on the operator’s terms isn’t clear). There’s no indication as to whether National is talking about a monolithic FibreCo-style operator, or multiple providers whose interconnection is subject to regulation.
They are critical details, and that is why it is not planned any actual digging and laying will start until 2010. One has to get the structure and policy right and you really need time to do that. However while those details are being worked out there are things one can do in the very short-term which will make the task easier – such as ensuring duct or fibe is laid every time a current road is dug up. Some firm guidance (or instructions!) to local government can help reduce the cost a lot, as can environmental regulations.
What benefits would this massive investment bring over new DSL technologies via the existing residential copper network? For a start, it would work as advertised: 24Mbit/s DSL is more a theory than a reality for most users (although Telecom’s programme to bring the fibre closer via cabinetisation will help) and it’s extremely asymmetric — much fast down than back up. The problem of long cable runs basically disappears when you install fibre. You’d be doing it eventually anyway: when the existing copper expires, there’s no point in replacing it with more copper.
Absolutely. Fibre to the Home is inevitable. It is just a matter of timing – do we want to wait until 2040 and be last in the OECD, or try and secure some advantages by being early, to counteract our geographical disadvantage.
Russell also points some credit my way for “tireless advocacy”. While obviously I am an advocate, and have been for some time, I don’t think anyone should doubt this came about because of John Key’s personal belief and commitment to this infrastructure investment. I understand he has spent scores of hours in talks and discussions on the issue, and probably knows the ins and outs better than most industry specialists now.
Two others who are influential and helped make it happen were Maurice WIlliamson and Bill English. Jordan Carter has already noted Maurice’s passion for this plan. Bill has had a bit of stick for his comments a year ago which were sceptical of crown investment. The role of the Shadow Minister of Finance is to be sceptical and hard nosed on colleagues spending ambitions. I wouldn’t quite say his or her initial response should always be no, but hey it’s a reasonable negotiating position to start from 🙂
I am not Bill’s spokesperson (for which we are both grateful 🙂 ) but I think people will find he is fully behind the initiative (in fact I understand all of Caucus is quite wildly enthusiastic about it) and his job is to help make it happen as Minister of Finance. If anyone thinks there is some violent behind the scenes struggle about this policy, I think they will be sadly disappointed.
Now of course not everyone has been positive, and for those who want a libertarian critique I refer you to Liberty Scott who labels it as Think Big Mark II and argues in favour of leaving it to the market.
Also against is NZ First (they just whine about Telecom) and Kiwiblogblog which claims it will be wasteful government spending as we will never need home Internet speeds faster than Telecom’s ADSL2+ rollout.
Sounds to me a bit like the infamous “640K ought to be enough for anybody” statement in 1981, attributed to (and denied by) Bill Gates. I am very confident they will be wrong by similar levels of magnitude!
UPDATE: The Standard has also come out against it.
I think it is has been extremely enlightening that basically all the left wing blogs where the authors use their real names have been supportive of the policy, while the left wing blogs where the authors are anonymous are against. I’ll leave it to others to draw conclusions on whether this is a coincidence or not, and what this may indicate about who the authors are.
UPDATE2: I missed a couple of comments. No Right Turn labels the policy as good at first glance. And since I wrote the blog post, Dancer at The Standard has labelled the policy as a good thing.
NZPA reports on advice from Treasury released under the OIA, which confirm the decision to sabotage the Canadian bid by way of retrospective regulation was economic sabotage, and worse of all breached our legal obligations under international agreements.
The Government’s moves to block Auckland International Airport (AIA) were strongly opposed by Treasury who said it would breach international agreements, scare foreign investors and damage the economy.
Treasury wrote a scathing paper on the suggestions, saying the benefits of the Government’s proposed policy were “likely to be small relative to the detriments”.
It advised against any intervention in the share bid on three main grounds:
* Legal — “It is almost certainly a breach of our international obligations under various multilateral agreements”.
* Commercial — “Such an intervention would create considerable disruption and uncertainty. By affecting investors’ property rights and reducing value it may cause investors to be sceptical … and more wary of investing”.
* Economic — “It is likely negatively impact on international investors perceptions … increase the risk premium for investment in New Zealand with potential to raise the cost of funds for all New Zealand companies”.
It is a pity the Canadian pension fund is not going to court over this. I think they would have a field day. This now puts on the record that he Government ignored the advice of both the Overseas Investment Office and Treasury on this retrospective intervention. Funny how Helen says we couldn’t have tax cuts earlier because of Treasury advice – they do pick and choose.
Some will argue decisions on investment should be at political whim, and not have any consistent rules or laws around them. You can do that, but we will find there is a lot less investment if people can’t trust the law to be applied fairly.
Hillary Clinton, John McCain and Barack Obama finally debate the big issue in the United States – who will be WWE King of the Ring. Great fun – I thought Hillary did best. Of course in NZ we had Raging Bill English actually get into the ring!
Hat Tip: Lindsay A via e-mail
Mike Williams gains attention from both The Press and the Dominion Post editorials today. Let’s start with The Press:
The congress took place just weeks after the Electoral Commission found that Labour had become the first party to breach its own Electoral Finance Act by distributing a taxpayer-funded pamphlet which was deemed to be election advertising. Williams’ comment at the congress fairly invited the claim that Labour intended to side-step the Act, by using as electioneering tools pamphlets paid for by the taxpayer and intended to provide apolitical information.
Prime Minister Helen Clark quickly rejected this idea and no doubt thought she had shut the issue down, but the hapless Williams promptly re-opened it. His denial that he had endorsed the delegate’s proposal was quickly disproved by a recording of what he had said.
Clark must be livid at her party president, but has brushed off any suggestion that he should resign by explaining that Williams had been “confused”. But this is not the first time that Williams has been confused and misleading.
One could almost suggest Mr Williams is a pathological confuser!
Williams has also made a huge contribution to Labour, as the campaign manager in 1999, as president and fundraiser, so the party would be reluctant to lose his services before the election. But the question which must be asked is how many more gaffes will it take before Labour decides it would be a “damn good idea” to look for a new president.
Maybe it would just be a “damn good idea” not to blatantly lie nine times in one interview.
The Dominion Post sees a wider trend:
When the president of a political party says one thing and does another, when a government department suppresses a report that is embarrassing to a senior public servant or when a state-owned enterprise associates itself with a company that uses questionable tactics, they do not just damage their own reputations. They damage confidence in institutions that rely upon public trust to function effectively, The Dominion Post writes.
When TVNZ aired a tape showing Labour Party president Mike Williams had used words he said he had not used at a Labour strategy session his response was to say he was sorry for misleading the public but he did not recall using the words in question. When Prime Minister Helen Clark revealed he had admitted to her that he had used the words, several days before he went on television to deny using them, her response was not to demand his resignation but to question the way TVNZ had used the tape.
Indeed. How dare TVNZ reveal her President lied.
If TVNZ had really wanted to play mischief, they could have kept the tape under wraps for a few more days, and asked Clark, Goff and King if this new version of events as told by Mike Williams was now the correct one. Who would want to bet money that they would have contradicted him? And then think the damage which would have been done if the tape came out after everyone in Labour aligned their stories to the new version. So Clark should not be angry at TVNZ – she should be pleased they aired the tape when they did.
Of course if Mike Williams had never changed the story, and resurrected what was mainly a dead story, TVNZ probably would have never even felt a need to use the tape.
Sigh – my e-mail address has been used on some spam which has gone out far and wide. I don’t think it is personal – this happens every year or so – they generally pick a random e-mail address to use.
But what it does mean is that my inbox is getting a few dozen bounces a minute. Fun.
I seriously think that if I ever met a spammer in real life, and could get away with it, I’d happily shoot them. They try and destroy everything good about the Internet.
No jury would ever convict me!
Lots of stories on this, so just a bit from each. First Mike Houlahan writes the main story for the Herald:
National’s ambitious billion-dollar-plus plan to bring faster internet access to three-quarters of New Zealand homes and companies has been hailed by business and internet groups.
But the Government says it is extravagant and opportunistic.
The partisan side of me is delighted to have Labour saying it won’t match the commitment. The non-partisan side hopes that they will make a similar commitment before the election.
Peter Griffin blogs:
A year has obviously changed a lot. The broadband debate has stepped up a notch and National’s play here with a sizeable amount of funding shows how seriously it now considers broadband to improving our productivity and growing the economy.
“National’s medium to long-term vision is for a fibre connection to almost every home, supported by satellite and mobile solutions where it makes sense,” says Key.
Paula Oliver looks at the politics of it:
The broadband announcement is all about Key showing he has a wider plan – outside that old chestnut of tax cuts – to lift New Zealand’s future economic performance, productivity and wages. …
In New Zealand, the political positions are reversed, with Key on Rudd’s side of the argument and Labour sounding more like Howard. …
Communications Minister David Cunliffe says the Rudd/Key idea would put Telecom back into a monopoly position and pour taxpayer money into the pockets of that company’s shareholders.
But it was difficult yesterday to find too many people close to the issue willing to rip into Key’s move.
To avoid Key wrestling the issue away from Labour and in public minds making it his own, Labour needs to reveal – and soon – more of its big plan for broadband.
National is very aware of the need not to have a vertically integrated monopoly over fibre instead of copper. One of the key principles that industry people have noted is that any such network will need to be open access.
Jon Hoyle in the Dominion Post reviews the announcement also:
Business New Zealand chief executive Phil O’Reilly said such a network would especially help small to medium exporters gain a cost-effective global presence.
It would also be a plus for multi-national companies considering setting up in New Zealand, and a reason for those already here to invest further. But even with the right regulatory settings, it would be hard to get the private sector to invest several billion dollars, Mr O’Reilly said.
Tuanz, an advocacy group for business telecommunications customers, said the policy would receive strong support from its members. .
Tuanz chief executive Ernie Newman said the Labour-led Government’s strategy had been too short-sighted and National’s policy could prove cost-effective in the long run.
Finally Vernon Small also covers it in the Dom Post:
Mr Key said yesterday that the “fibre to the home” funding, spread over six years, would lift productivity and wages, and help deliver a “step-change” for the economy.
A week after ruling out asset sales under National in its next term, he said a National government would keep a stake in the joint venture, which would require up to $3.5 billion of private sector money.
It would not replace other planned investment, would increase broadband services and must not “line the pockets of incumbents”. …
The Government is likely to announce its own broadband investment plan in the May 22 Budget.
Telecom welcomed Mr Key’s plan, saying it saw a big role for public-private partnerships and that it would work with whoever was in government.
It is good to see Telecom supportive in principle. If fibre is laid down to 75% of homes, then the demand for both domestic and international backhaul will be massive, and there will be significant opportunities for bandwidth and service providers to offer competing products over the fibre network.
Obviously the details of how investment in and construction of the fibre network would occur will be a major issue. There is one proposal on the table at the moment from David Skilling for a Fibre Co, which would have government, local government, telco and other private capital shareholding. I personally regard that as a workable model, but not necessarily the best model. The challenge will be to see if people can put up superior models.
Winston may have given them free bus tickets at off-peak times (not a bad initiative actually), but he won’t be so happy with the fact they are taking his precious Electoral Finance Act to court. The Herald reports:
Grey Power has rejected a New Zealand First member’s bid to stop it challenging the controversial electoral finance legislation in court.
The older persons’ lobby group has joined the Sensible Sentencing Trust and Electoral Finance Act opponent John Boscawen in a High Court challenge made against the new law when it was in its “draconian” bill form.
New Zealand First supported the law change, which limits third party spending on election advertising.
At Grey Power’s national meeting in Christchurch this week, the federation’s involvement in the court action was tested by one of its own.
Jens Meder, a senior New Zealand First member and representative for the Auckland Grey Power Association, put forward a remit arguing it was wrong for the national federation to be a party to the court action.
His remit was “almost unanimously” rejected, said Grey Power federation secretary Bill Atkinson.
I can’t wait for the election campaign. Winston will be asked about the EFA at every meeting in Tauranga, and he will also be asked about the $158,000 his party has not repaid to the taxpayer. Add on the many baubles of office he said he would reject, and well his free bus fares policy may get lost in the noise.
Most people will have seen the furore in the US about Barack Obama comments on bitter small town Americans. We will find out later today if it has hurt him much in the Pennsylvania primary.
Pundits seem to say if Clinton wins by more than 10% she gets a significant boost. If she wins by less than 10% the stalemate continues (which would almost inevitably result in Obama eventually winning) and if by some chance Obama wins, then it is all over for Clinton.
The Herald has an interesting story from The Observer about how Obama’s comments were made to a private meeting in San Francisco. One of the invitees was a 61 year old housewive who also blogged. She was invited as she was a supporter and donor. But she put her role as a “reporter” first and blogged his comments, and the rest is history.
This neatly illustrates the power of the blog – politicians are less able to say one thing to a group of supporters and another thing publicly. As Mike Williams has also discovered!
The AA has called for GST to be removed on the excise portion of petrol, reports the Herald.
AA spokesman Mark Stockdale last night urged the Government to consider removing GST on petrol excise tax, a move it says could cut prices by more than 5c a litre. …
But a statement from Finance Minister Michael Cullen’s office last night said the Government would not change the GST system, “as creating exemptions would add extra compliance costs for businesses which would be passed on to consumers”.
A one-off change to GST would have had no effect against the “global forces” driving petrol prices.
“If the New Zealand Government had changed GST rules along these lines 12 months ago, no one would have even noticed as the benefits would have been wiped out almost immediately by the global rise in oil prices,” the statement said.
I’m with Dr Cullen on this one. First of all I think an absolute strength of GST is that is is near universal for all goods and services. The moment you start varying out a few exemptions, you then end up in an endless litany of moral judgements on what should or should not have GST on it. In Australia you have (or had) GST on your bread if it has sultanas in it, but no GST if no sultanas.
Cullen is also right that piddling about with stuff that will knock 5c a litre off only, when retail prices have almost doubled in the last few years, will not even be noticed.
A reader e-mailed me a video they put together of some of the best Labour moments. I thought it was worth sharing so asked Whale Oil to upload it to You Tube (I should learn how to do it myself!). Not a bad effort.
I have just returned from a Wellington Chamber of Commerce lunch at Te Papa where John Key announced the next National Government will invest $1.5 billion into extending our current fibre network, with the aim of having 75% of homes in NZ having fibre to the home by 2014. It got a very warm reception from the business audience
I am delighted, in fact beyond delighted. I’m thrilled. This is a stunning bold initiative, and one that I think is great wearing all my different hats.
Having served as the Public Policy Chair for InternetNZ (Internet Society of NZ) for the last five years, this is a massive step towards the vision we have of a high speed connected nation. And the level of funding and target timeframe is almost better than could be expected.
Fibre is to today’s economy what roads and rail were to us 100 years ago. One has to invest in the infrastructure before you get a return on it, from the services that can be delivered over it. This is why there is a legitimate role for the Government – there is a timing mismatch if you do not have the state invest capital in infrastructure development.
Especially pleasing was seeing a reference to the fact that the fibre network will need to be open access, and also done in such a way not to crowd out existing fibre plans. If implemented, this will be a public/private partnership with the public capital allowing the private sector to invest more.
As a National Party supporter, I’m also very pleased. I think it positions John Key and National as having an economic development plan which is focused on infrastructure investment. At a time when the Government has no real answers to the economic challenges facing NZ (except to say we can’t control petrol prices of food prices or house prices), and is mired in the repercussions from some silly stunts, National has seized the policy initiative.
What is good about today’s announcement is it is not in an area you normally expect National to lead. Everyone expects National to be tougher on law & order, and everyone expects National to cut taxes more than Labour. But this has been about showing a future looking vision of where New Zealand is heading.
Finally I’m just pleased as a New Zealander. The future of NZ does worry me. Seeing so many people leave for overseas, seeing our national income fail to keep up with Australia paints a gloomy picture for the future.
We have real challenges ahead of us – both economically, and environmentally. And the sad reality is that there are relatively few policies which are good for economic growth but also good for the environment. It can be a delicate balancing act.
But rollout of fibre to the home will, I believe, has significant benefits for us economically, environmentally, and in quality of life. What David Skilling calls the weightless economy, where our remoteness is less of an issue, will be a big part of our future. And having ultra-high speed broadband everyone will position us well to compete globally. No it is not guaranteed – few things are. But I think it is an investment very much worth taking – and for less than the cost of Dr Cullen’s cancelled chewing gum tax cuts.
The challenge now is for other parties to rise to the challenge set by John Key. For as much as it would be electorally advantageous to National for Labour not to make a similar commitment, I hope they do show similar ambition.
Hat Tip: Anti-Dismal.