Labour style tax cuts

Gordon Brown is showing Michael Cullen how to cut taxes Labour style. He has abolished the 10% tax rate on low income earners.

Well that sounds good.

Only until you realise he has not abolished it so the first few thousand are not taxed. He has abolished it and replaced it with the standard 20% tax rate.

Many Labour MPs are unhappy.

So we need to be careful here if Dr Cullen talks of abolishing tax rates, and ask what will he be replacing them with?

Nandor blogs from the IPU

Nandor blogs from the IPU (International Parliamentary Union) meeting in Cape Town. He has some interesting observations on Zimbabwe and whether South Africa will step in if Mugabe starts massacring opponents. The IPU has also got involved:

The IPU did put out a strong statement last week. As well as being instrumental in putting it on the agenda, the NZ delegation also played a key role in getting the wording strengthened. John Carter and I worked together on amendments to the drafts, and I was impressed with what he got the drafting committee to support.

Well done John and Nandor. But who else is there:

Pressure also neeeds to be put on China to not sell arms under the circumstances. Zimbabwe is totally skint, so they can’t even pay their current bills. Any credit advanced for arms is even more unethical than normal. I had intended to mention it during the plenary debate. NZ had 8 minutes, split between Dover Samuels and me, but Dover spoke first and used up the whole allocation, so I had no opportunity to speak.

(I wouldn’t have minded so much if he hadn’t spent the whole time saying what a waste of time the IPU is before swanning off on a sight seeing tour with the delegates’ spouses!)

Oh dear.

Blog Bits

Poneke has blogged a copy of his 2004 presentation to the Sceptics Society Conference, showing that the media generally are not sceptical of “alternative medicine” claims. It is an excellent read.

Stephen Franks points out that “that” ghastly song written by his rival Grant Robertson was intended for a fund-raiser at the Beehive for the Mary Potter Hospice, and that the Hospice has got damaged by the furore with donors threatening to pull funding if the song was used at the fundraiser. It was pulled, but really how on Earth did they ever think something like that would be suitable for a charity fundraiser.

To balance things up, I’ll link to Grant Robertson responding to Stephen on the issues of midwives and maternity care.  The response, missed the point to me. Women have basically lost the choice of having a GP deliver their children, as GPs have been driven out of the profession.

No Minister has this wonderful quote:

“Prince William landed his chopper in Kate Middleton’s back paddock.”

Heh Heh. Originally picked up by Iain Dale.

Whale Oil has discovered a new Helen Clark site. It gives a different message everytime. Just click reload.

The BBC has a homage of Donald Rumsfield’s best quotes.

Confused or Lying?

Helen Clark has been defending Mike Williams on the basis he was confused. The Press reports:

Following an all-day Cabinet meeting yesterday, Clark refused to say if Williams had her full confidence.

Asked by a journalist if she still trusted him to tell the truth, she would not answer directly.

“Well, I’ve known him for a long time, but he can be a little loose and confused,” she said.

But does this sound like a confused man. From Agenda:

MIKE  There was a seminar between 8.30 and 9.30 in the morning which I conducted.  The hall was set up so I was right at the back of the stage on a lecturn almost behind the proscenial arch in the Wellington Town Hall, I’ve got 400 witnesses who’d tell you the first thing I said when I took the lecturn was that I could neither see nor hear them, the acoustics were terrible and the lighting was such I couldn’t even see the audience, okay.  I gave my address, it lasted about 50 minutes.  There was then discussion.  Now what I heard the delegate say and I wasn’t hearing him clearly was that if somebody asks you for a Kiwisaver brochure the IRD’s got good ones.  Now according to people there I did not respond that is a good idea, I simply moved on to the next question which was the last one.  So the whole thing is an incredible media beat up, it arguably never happened.

Funny that for someone who could not see or hear the audience, he referred to the delegate (and fellow NZ Council member) by name. Anyway he labels the whole thing an incredible media beat up and denies outright that he praised the suggestion as a damn good idea.

GUYON  So why did Helen Clark accuse you of poor judgement then?

MIKE  Well she hadn’t spoken to me.

Now this part is crucial. This is where Williams is not just “confused” about what happened, but starts to directly lie about his conversations with Clark. He has just asserted he did not respond “That’s a damn good idea”, and the only reason Clark said he exercised poor judgement was that she had not yet spoken to him.

GUYON  So does the Prime Minister accept your…?

MIKE  Absolutely, I’ve spoken to her after the event, she did the right thing.  Now look make it clear it was my session and I take absolute responsibility to anything that was said there, but I do not believe anything like that was said and I certainly did not hear anything like that said and neither did I endorse it.

While Guyon did not finish his sentence, it is clear he is referring to Williams version of events, and Williams very clearly implies on nationwide TV that the PM has accepted he did not endorse the idea of handing out Government pamphlets while campaigning.

But what does Helen say. The Dom Post reports:

But Miss Clark said yesterday that Mr Williams had informed her last week that was what he said.

“The first thing he told me was the right one. That was, he’d reacted along the lines of `what a good idea’ and he should have continued to repeat that. For whatever reason, he didn’t.

Now if one was very gullible or generous one could almost believe Williams was confused about what was said and what he said at the conference. But are we really meant to believe that he was also confused about his conversation with the Prime Minister?

I mean Clark is quite clear about what he said to her.  The Herald reports:

She said she was baffled at Mr Williams’ denial on Agenda, because he had confirmed it to her when she first spoke to him after the Herald revealed it last week.

This is not confusion. How can you be confused about what you told the PM? Having worked with a PM or two, you tend to remember in great detail your conversations with them – especially those only a few days old.

And do you know what is the weird thing. There was no need for Williams to lie. He wasn’t some cornered rat like Benson-Pope desperately lying because the truth would force him out of office. The truth had already come out, and Williams had been gently reprimanded by the PM. There was no suggestion his job was at risk up until the Agenda interview. By trying to rewrite history, he resurrected what had been an almost dead issue. One can only assume he made a calculated decision that no-one could contradict him if he started to spin what happened. But he went well well beyond spinning. He lied nine times in one interview.  He was in no way confused when he says the whole thing is a media beatup and never happened.

Press on West Coast Spying

The Press Editorial:

Senior Government figures made it clear that Solid Energy, which is a State-owned Enterprise, must not itself stoop to such tactics nor countenance its so-called security consultant, Thompson and Clark Investigations, doing so. But TCIL director Gavin Clark has again attempted to hire a paid informer. Even if Solid Energy had no knowledge of this, its continued commercial relationship with the security firm places its own credibility on the line. It is time that Solid Energy cut TCIL adrift.

They really have no choice. It just does not survive the credibility test that TCIL’s activities were not motivated by having Solid Energy as a client, even if not explicitly mandated in this episode.

Can I suggest that if TCIL are gong to continue as amateur spymasters, they get better at it. You don;t try and turn an existing greenie – no wonder they keep getting exposed.

If I was TCIL, and wanting to infiltrate the Save Happy Valley Coalition I would go along to Act on Campus, and hire their scruffiest new member and give him or her a two to three year mission. Now your typical AoC member will do anything for enough money, so you probably need to be thinking $1,000+ a month to supplement their student allowance.

You need to pick someone who has not been publicly identified as an AoC member, and have them join up. But the key is not to have them start spying too soon.  You need to be prepared to invest in just having them spy for a year or so, and then start having them produce the bacon.

Now after a while they may develop a conscience. More money will help with this problem, but a good spymaster will also start giving them some perks they’ll miss. You see they are probably investing all their spy money on the stockmarket. So every six months or so you send them and their boy/girlfriend to Queensland for a holiday – that will keep them motivated to keep spying.

Anyway back to The Press:

On the face of it, the Government’s unambiguous directive to Solid Power last year had been breached. This might explain the speed with which the SOE chief executive Don Elder specifically ruled out his organisation having any involvement in or knowledge of the second effort to hire a paid informer.

For Solid Energy this latest spying row is hugely counterproductive. A coal company in this age of heightened environmental awareness is always going to struggle to get good publicity. But the SOE does have some positive stories to tell, such as its entry into the biodiesel market and its involvement in the first Southern Hemisphere carbon storage project.

Instead, it has become mired in accusations about a private espionage operation, an activity which was last year shown to be distasteful to most New Zealanders. Compounding the perception problem, the accusations could also create sympathy and publicity for the targeted protest groups which they do not necessarily deserve.

All true.

A Helen joke

The Dom Post reports how a joke told by Hillary Clinton about Helen Clark. She is slightly ahead of her time though by calling Helen the Former PM of NZ:

In what the Labour Party would hope is more ignorance than prophecy, Mrs Clinton described Helen Clark as “former prime minister of New Zealand”.

The gaffe came in a chummy interview with American magazine Newsweek, when journalist Karen Breslau asked Mrs Clinton for a joke: “Here’s a good one. Helen Clark, former prime minister of New Zealand: her opponents have observed that in the event of a nuclear war, the two things that will emerge from the rubble are the cockroaches and Helen Clark.

Interesting science investments

From last week’s McCcully newsletter:

The Government’s gimmicky “Fast Forward Fund” science announcement has placed the Election Year spotlight on the whole area of science research and development.  There will now be greater interest in the National Party’s response closer to the election.  But what a pity that more focus has not been given to ensuring that we get value for money out of the existing budget.

The word ‘science’ will no doubt conjure up pictures of pasty-looking individuals in white coats shuffling around laboratories with Bunsen burners and test tubes. But a quick look at some of the projects currently being funded out of the Science/Research budget suggests that such is not the case.

Take, for example, a $96,000 grant for a study of Boganology.  No, this is apparently not a poorly selected term for some exciting new microbial organism. It’s exactly what it sounds like: a study of bogans. That will really get our export industries humming.

Then there’s the interesting little number entitled “More than Bricks and Mortar,” a study of social networks amongst homeless people.  All of that for a modest $795,000 (no, no typographical error – $795,000 out of the SCIENCE fund).

And how about a study of “The impact of economic shocks on the well-being of New Zealanders”.  A snip at $600,000.  All to ascertain the previously unknown and obviously elusive truth that economic shocks are bad for people’s well-being.

But for studies into the blindingly obvious the prize would have to be awarded to the report “How do positive events lead to greater happiness and wellbeing?” A modest $600,000 experiment that clearly involved giving someone a $600,000 grant and checking that he or she was very very happy indeed.

There is, of course, the usual display of rampant political correctness: a $427,000 grant for a “Dictionary of Loanwords in the Maori Language Newspapers”.  A $495,000 study of “The Impact of Sound Change on the Rhythm of Maori”.  And a $955,000 study “Ecosystem Services Benefits in Terrestrial Ecosystems for Iwi”, a report that will obviously shoot New Zealand immediately to the international forefront in this critical area of scientific endeavour.

That’s right folks. This is cash out of the SCIENCE budget we are talking about here.  Cash that has been confiscated from taxpayers under the pretence of investing it in maintaining world leadership in our primary industries.  Makes you yearn for a few more test tubes and Bunsen burners, doesn’t it?

I hope the good farmers of NZ check carefully what the Fast Forward Fund will actually be spent on!

Who was the delegate?

We have heard a lot from Labour about how the suggestion to use taxpayer funded Government information pamphlets while out campaigning just came from a delegate at the conference, and Mike Williams just agreed with him that it was a damn good idea (before WIlliams then denied everything).

Now as someone who has attended a lot of party conferences, I can sympathise that sometimes you get very naive and inexperienced members at these conferences who say stupid things.

So when the proposal to use the taxpayer funded advertising for campaigning is dismissed as just being from a delegate, you do wonder what sort of delegate?

Was it someone just active at branch level? Was it someone active at electorate level? Or was it someone who held office at regional level? Or was it someone even more senior than that.

Well thanks to a Kiwiblog reader, we have an answer.  A female Mainlander e-mailed in to identify the voice as Martin Ward. Mr Ward is (or at least was until recently) a member of the Labour Party’s ruling NZ Council.  So this delegate the President was responding to, was one of his colleagues on the Party’s top board.

And according to reports Mr Ward suggested the use of both KiwiSaver and Working for Families brochures. WFF is one of the Government’s key welfare benefits (by way of family tax credits). And who is the Minister of Social Welfare, sorry Social Development and Employment. Well by coincidence Mr Ward’s wife – Ruth Dyson.

So this suggestion to use taxpayer funded material for campaigning did not come from some junior lackey. It came from a member of the Labour Party’s Council and the spouse of a senior Cabinet Minister.

More EFA Fun

A reader writes in:

For a while now I have noticed when passing major road improvement projects on State Highways that at the beginning of each project there is a large Transit sign stating what the improvement is.

Underneath the main text is a short statement saying: A New Zealand Government Initiative.

What are your thoughts on whether these would count as an election advertisement and should they carry an authorisation statement and count toward election costs for the Labour Party.

I know its perhaps drawing a long bow, but they only seemed to appear in the last year or so and it irks me every time I see it.  I can’t actually see any reason for it to be on the Transit sign apart from to make people think positively of the government in relation to fixing roads.

There is an arguable case. Let us look at Section 5(1)(a)(ii)

In this Act, election advertisement—

  • (a) means any form of words or graphics, or both, that can reasonably be regarded as doing 1 or more of the following:

    • (ii) encouraging or persuading voters to vote, or not to vote, for a type of party or for a type of candidate that is described or indicated by reference to views, positions, or policies that are or are not held, taken, or pursued (whether or not the name of a party or the name of a candidate is stated); and

Now as the EFA says the name of the party does not need to be stated and a “The Government” is a description of the parties which form the Government – Labour, Progressive, NZ First and United Future.

Now does the signs saying “A NZ Government initiative” encourage people to vote for Government parties?  Probably not – it would be a stretch. On the other hand you might ask why the signs now include the statement – does anyone think that state highway upgrades are a private initiative? Maybe the suggestion came from that independent Transit board member Mike Williams?

Meanwhile Peter McC has photos of the Palmerston North Labour Party candidate, Iain Lees-Galloway, with an illegal election advertisement.  After he noticed photos being taken, he stuck on an authorisation statement but sadly as it did not include a home address (just the Labour Head Office) it is still illegal!

Mike Williams – the video

A shorter list of blogs

I was having a look at my blogroll today and noted it was now around 400 blogs. Now I am actually subscribed to the RSS feeds for all those blogs (if I subscribe to an RSS feed  in Bloglines, it is automatically added to my blogroll), but don’t read every post on every blog.

Bloglines allows me to skim the first paragraphs of any entries, and then decide whether to read in full.

Anyway I thought it might be useful for me to put together a separate listing of the blogs I tend to always read in full.  This does not mean I endorse them, just that I read them more often than not. Please do not be offended if you are not on this list. I still read your blog, I just had to draw the line somewhere.

So there is now a new permanent page called “Must Read Blogs“. It lists 20 NZ political blogs and 36 other blogs. Correspondence will not be entered into but bribes will always be considered.

Law Journal article on Electoral Finance Act

The latest NZ Law Journal has a very scholarly and lengthy five page article on the Electoral Finance Act by Roger Partridge and Jesse Wilson of Belly Gully.

This article is what Crown Law should have published to Parliament. They quote extensively from Australian, Canadian, UK and US court judgements and opinions. Their summary is worth repeating:

The full article is viewable as this pdf. I suggest people read the whole thing rather than make snide references to quoting Justice Scalia.

Further analysis of Williams on Agenda

The scandal over Williams lies re the Labour Party Congress have been the main focus of the last 24 hours. But there are plenty of other statements which are worth looking at. From the transcript:

GUYON  Your own poll Mike Williams UMR, I saw it this week, 51-36, 15 points behind, how do you pull that back?

MIKE  Well again I think UMR is the subject of this problem that – let me tell you virtually all polls are conducted by landlines I don’t know one that isn’t.  Now I was the first person in New Zealand ever to put the electronic white pages together with the electoral roll.  Okay that was in 1986 I think, and I got an 82% match in the general seats.  Right, what we got in January of this year was a 50% match.  What this means Guyon is that half the population is statistically invisible.  Now what I trust is our canvassing data and our canvassing data shows the Labour vote about where it was last time, about 40%.  Now at that point it’s winnable.

I find it amusing that Williams works so hard to discredit polls, when his party spends so much money on them! And I have never known someone to claim canvassing data on behalf of a party is more representative than a random scientific poll.

Now look I am the last person to deny there are some challenges for the polling industry, but people over state the problem of landlines. Labour’s Coromandel candidate Hugh Kininmonth for example claimed yesterday:

I’ve never been a fan of the polls. They’re incredibly irrelevant and unrepresentative. For one they seldom report the number of respondents who are ‘undecided’. Around 37% of electors don’t have a landline – they are therefore exempt from participating in the polls.

The 2006 census found only 8% of households said they had no landline, with only 2% having no telecommunication services at all.  I have no idea where 37% comes from.

Williams stuff on matching the electoral roll to the white pages is also somewhat of a red herring. That affects the party’s abilities to match voters to phone numbers, but does not affect polling for media organisations as they do not use the electoral roll, but just call random numbers from the ranges Telecom have advised are available for allocation.

GUYON  Alright, some people say that Andrew Little is lining himself up for the job of Labour Party President.

MIKE  I’d welcome that in the fullness of time yes I would.

GUYON  Is that going to happen?

MIKE  I wouldn’t be surprised, I think he’d have good support

Now Andrew would be a very capable Labour Party President, and on present form he may get a promotion sooner than he wants!

I note on that issue the Herald states:

Mr Little said he would be able to keep his role with the EPMU if he gained the Labour Party presidency.

Now imagine if Little ascends to the presidency before the election. He would be running the Labour Party campaign, and at the same time also running the independent third party EPMU campaign, which will in no way of course be aligned to help Labour’s campaign. That will be a serious case of hat shuffling.

MIKE  There was general agreement I mean it passed with a majority in the parliament and I do think it needs to shake down.  What I’d say to you Fran is that this is what it’s about, it’s about the influence of big money in election campaigns and I think in New Zealand we do not want the kind of American politics transplanted here.  I mean this book (The Hollow Men) really shows an outrage, it’s a conspiracy to overspend and that’s what the Electoral Finance Act’s all about.

Mike’s idea of general agreement is a fascinating one. He means Labour, NZ First and the Greens.

But the prize for hypocrisy is for the line “it’s a conspiracy to overspend”. Mike Williams’ own party overspent by $400,000 to $800,000. They lied to the Chief Electoral Officer about it. They stated they woudl include the pledge card as an expense at a time when they knew that was impossible to do and stay within the limit. They lied merely to keep the issue out of the media until after the election. So for Williams to go on about conspiracies to overspend is just laughable.

MIKE  Well that’s like we had in the past I mean if you’ve got a long memory you’ll realise Muldoon called an election under a National passed law that said you couldn’t enrol after the writs were down, in other words enrolments in that election that Muldoon actually lost cut off in 48 hours and we had to run round, parties change laws, that’s the prerogative of government is it not?

Williams is citing Muldoon as constitutional precedent! God help us.

MIKE  The sort of feedback we get is that yes people are definitely and something has to be done about that, and I think that will be at least partly addressed in the budget, but I do think there’s an understanding that the government cannot legislate for food prices, cannot legislate for petrol prices, there are some things that governments cannot do.

Well if you are going to cite Muldoon as a precedent for constitutional law, why not also follow him as a model for the economy and do a price freeze like he did.  After all his economic management was on a par with his constitutional law probity.

BERNARD  And we don’t have a government list if you like of what are other strategic assets, so we have to wait and hope or guess at what the government’s view on this is, this is the danger of politically driven decisions on foreign investment isn’t it?

MIKE  I’d agree with you, I think we probably do need a list and I think that’s an oversight, but Helen said you know we’re not perfect and these things don’t arise very often, I mean we haven’t had major strategic assets that I’m aware of the people trying to take them over before.

Here I agree with Mr Williams. We do need a list of what assets the Government now deems strategic. Even the Labour Party President says we need a list. So hopefully someone will ask Dr Cullen when he will be producing one.

MIKE  Well I think this government has been very constrained in its use of government advertising I mean if you go to New South Wales in advance of an election you’ll see wall to wall government advertising you know we’ve got advertised for nurses doctors and that sort of thing, I can’t anticipate that but obviously you’ve gotta tell people about what’s going on.

Cough, splutter. Constrained? Well constrained when the Auditor-General knocks some of the more outraegous plans back, but $100 million of government advertising spend is not constrained.

Air NZ pay not illegal

The Herald have reported that the Labour Department says Air NZ is not breaking the law by paying Shanghai based staff less than the minimum wage on international flights.

The legal minimum wage is $12 an hour but the Labour department report said it was not applicable to Air NZ as “it would appear Chinese employment law applied to the agreement between Air New Zealand and the Chinese Air crew”.

But not quite that clear:

However, in a statement last night the Department of Labour corrected “an assertion” in a media release from Air New Zealand on the issue.

The statement was in response to a release from the airline that stated that the department had found that Chinese law applied to the agreement between Air New Zealand and the Chinese cabin crew.

“What we said in our briefing to Labour Minister Trevor Mallard was that “it would appear that Chinese employment law applied”, workplace deputy secretary Andrew Annakin said.

“This is an important point of difference, as the department cannot definitively determine what employment law applies in a particular factual situation, particularly outside New Zealand.”

It would be a very interesting test case if taken to court. If the staff worked in China, there would be no doubt Chinese law applied. But when on an international flight, the law of the air generally tends to point to the law of the country the aircraft is registered in. However I know that flights into the US also have US Federal Law apply, so definitely not clear cut.

Absolute Power

I have not yet read the whole book, but on Friday I got hold of an electronic version of Absolute Power by Ian Wishart and have read a couple of hundred pages.

He tells the story of Helen Clark’s use and abuse of power, starting with her first weeks in office when she undermined then Police Commissioner Doone by not just leaking confidential information to the Sunday Star-Times, but by leaking false fabricated information and claiming it was in official reports, when it wasn’t. Some of this info has been covered previously but Wishart has done a service by putting it all together.

He contrasts the hounding from office of Peter Doone, with the treatment of allegations against Howard Broad for a similar but allegedly far more serious offence. The Dom Post reports:

The police watchdog has been asked to intervene after the State Services Commission cleared Police Commissioner Howard Broad of any wrongdoing in a 1992 drink-driving incident.

Journalist Ian Wishart claims Mr Broad “pulled rank” to get out of a breath test in Christchurch, saying something like “Don’t you know who I am” to a junior officer.

Mr Broad admitted he had been drinking, and a SSC investigation found he was told to park his car and refrain from driving for several hours.

Wishart has complained to the Independent Police Conduct Authority.

“The SSC claims the junior cop had a discretion not to breath-test despite seeing Mr Broad swerve across a lane, and despite an admission of drinking.

Now on the face of it, there is a gross double standard here. Doone was investigated by both the PCA and the Deputy Commissioner for merely getting out of his car when his partner was pulled over for no headlights on.

Broad allegedly had himself been drinking and driving, was swerving across the road, pulled rank on the officer (using swear words allegedly) and was told to stop driving and park his car. And somehow this is merely an issue for the State Services Commission!!!

Now Broad was not Commissioner when this incident happened, but anyone can see the double standard involved.

Clark distances herself from Williams

Helen Clark has distanced herself from Mike Williams and basically called him a liar for his performance on Agenda, yet says he will remain President as the Party conference elects him and has confidence in him.

Some quotes from Clark on Breakfast on TV One:

Clark: “I certainly can’t understand why he made the comment on Agenda yesterday Paul. I watched it with some disbelief because of course after I spoke to you last Monday I did when I got to Wellington speak to Mr Williams and established the facts of the matter both from him and in the course of the day and that led me to go to my press conference and say there had clearly been a misjudgement. That was only compounded by what was said yesterday.”

Henry: Did he tell you the truth, because it appears he has not been telling us the truth.

Clark: He told me the truth, and that’s why when the tape was run on TV last night I knew that was what I had been told six and a half days before. Really what possessed him on Agenda I do not know, I can only put it down to confusion.

Clark has all but called Williams a liar with her comments that she has no idea what possessed him to deny what happened on Agenda, and watched it with disbelief.

Clark generously puts it down to confusion but she knows he was not confused on Agenda. He didn’t like the fact he had been reprimanded and tried to rewrite history on the basis no-one could prove otherwise. He claimed it was all a media beat-up and grossly misrepresented what the delegate said, and what he said.

Differing Polls

I usually leave comment on polls, and differences between them, to the end of month newsletter, but it may be useful to reflect on the difference between the One News/Colmar Brunton poll and the TV Three/TNS poll.

Both were published tonight, and the former had a 19% gap and the latter a smaller 10% gap. Both show National able to form a Government, but that is a significant 9% difference between them.

The first thing to note is that despite being both published today, they may be over different time periods. One News informs me that their poll was from Sat 12 April to Thursday 17 April. I have not been able to get hold of Three News yet, but generally in the past they have had a longer gap between end of polling and publication.

So one factor in their difference might be the days they polled over. The last week has had a lot happening, and it is quite likely this got reflected in polling done later in the week.

I understand there is likely to be a Fairfax poll out in the near future, so that may help provide some clarity once it is published.

UPDATE: TV Three tells me their dates were from 10 to 16 April, so not a huge difference in time periods.

Mike Williams caught lying – again

Once again the Labour Party President has been caught lying. He denied repeatedly on camera that he had said something, and TVNZ have produced a tape recording of him saying the exact words he denied.

Let us look at what he said on Agenda this morning:

GUYON  A delegate at the Congress last weekend suggested using public information campaigns like Kiwisaver and information from government departments as an electioneering tool, why did you think that was a quote “damn good idea”?

MIKE  I didn’t think that was quote a “damn good idea” and let me…

GUYON  But that’s what you told them though isn’t it?

MIKE  No it’s not what I told them and let me get this clear.

Okay note here that Guyon said he was quoting what Williams said.  And note Williams absolutely denies he said it. Lie No 1.

MIKE  There was a seminar between 8.30 and 9.30 in the morning which I conducted.  The hall was set up so I was right at the back of the stage on a lecturn almost behind the proscenial arch in the Wellington Town Hall, I’ve got 400 witnesses who’d tell you the first thing I said when I took the lecturn was that I could neither see nor hear them, the acoustics were terrible and the lighting was such I couldn’t even see the audience, okay.  I gave my address, it lasted about 50 minutes.  There was then discussion.  Now what I heard the delegate say and I wasn’t hearing him clearly was that if somebody asks you for a Kiwisaver brochure the IRD’s got good ones.  Now according to people there I did not respond that is a good idea, I simply moved on to the next question which was the last one.  So the whole thing is an incredible media beat up, it arguably never happened.

Lie No 2 is his claim that the delegate merely said if people ask for a KiwiSaver brochure the IRD has got good ones. Lie No 3 is that he did not respond and simply moved onto the next question. And then he has the temerity to state the whole thing is a media beat up.

MIKE  Well she hadn’t spoken to me.  It was a surreal experience and something you’d tell your grandparents about.  At five o’clock on Monday morning I went to Tauranga, I didn’t see a Herald and I got a text from Helen when I got there saying what did this person say, and I responded as I remembered it that if somebody wants a Kiwisaver brochure send them to the IRD, I certainly did not hear anybody say go down and get some, and I’m in good company because Annette King, Phil Goff never heard that either.  I then went to a meeting in Tauranga which went till about three o’clock when I went on a tour of the Port of Tauranga and that turned into…

Lie No 4 is that the comment by the delegate (it gets watered down each time) wasn’t even that one should hand out IRD pamphlets, but that if someone wants one, you should refer them to the IRD.

Lie No 5 is claiming that King and Goff never heard it either. Annette King had already used the Helen Clark No 2 excuse and had previously said she didn’t hear anything at all as she was engrossed in conversation with someone. Now Williams is citing her in his defence.

MIKE  Absolutely, I’ve spoken to her after the event, she did the right thing.  Now look make it clear it was my session and I take absolute responsibility to anything that was said there, but I do not believe anything like that was said and I certainly did not hear anything like that said and neither did I endorse it.

Lie No 6 is his claim that nothing like that was said. Lie No 7 is that he did not hear anything (unless you believe he endorses something he never heard as a damn good idea) and Lie No 8 is his claim he did not endorse it.

MIKE  Absolutely, and the idea is a bad idea not for the reason you gave, you can’t hand out government information but it’s also a damn silly idea, if you’re going canvassing you don’t hand out IRD pamphlets that’s just dumb, but that’s also not what I heard him say.

And that is Lie No 9.

Now let us look at what TVNZ revealed on One News tonight. Williams never though a Labour Party delegate would tape what he said, so he thought he was safe lying repeatedly about what happened:

Delegate: “hand those out when you’re going around and you can say this is what the Labour Government broguht in and by the way the National Party voted against it … In fact they’re better than having Labour Party material because they’re informing people about things they may not already be getting.”

Williams: “Well that’s a damn good idea” … applause

Williams lied to TVNZ and to the public of New Zealand, not once, not twice, but nine times. He lied about what was said, he lied about what he said, he pretty much lied about everything.

This is of course not the first time Mike Williams has been caught out lying. He lied in January when he denied any donations from Owen Glenn since the last election. Also he would have signed off on the letter last election to the Chief Electoral Officer in which they agreed to include the pledge card in their expense return, and then weeks later lied and reneged on their word.

Now normally one would raise the question of whether Mike Williams could continue as Labour Party President after having been caught out lying nine times in the one interview. But I predict this will in no way make Helen Clark reconsider his position. After all she will conclude, his only sin was getting caught. They will not be angry at Williams for lying. They will be angry at the Labour Party delegate who recorded what he said, and exposed his lies.

An Aussie praises the All Black uniform

This small 15 second audio file is of the unimaginable – an Australian radio host saying how they love the All Black uniform.

The comments are from Australian Dancing With The Stars co-host, Sonia Kruger who does Mix Mornings with Sonia & Todd on Mix 160.5 in Sydney.

Sonia is on the right. I commented to her producer that she was wasted on radio and he assured me she was also one of the most popular television personalities. I thank Mix1065 for bringing Sonia’s comments to the attention of Kiwiblog readers, and am sure the All Blacks appreciate her support for their dress sense anyway!

Blog Outage Today

A City Council with 250 Councillors!

Ralston on the outer

Bill Ralston writes that he seems to have offended she who rules:

The Prime Minister has gone off me. I keep hearing from colleagues that she has been complaining loudly about these columns and my work on Radio Live’s drive show in the afternoons, when I often interview politicians. Apparently she believes I have “gone Tory”.

We’ve known each other since university days and I’ve always been moderately liberal in outlook, so she is puzzled by my criticism of the Government.

I have not had a road to Damascus experience and decided National is the way, the truth and the light.

It is simply that this Government has been in power for nine years and after that length of time it is inevitable it will have done things that provoke criticism.

Bill, Bill, Bill. If you criticise the Government, then of course you are a golf playing Tory. Either that or a chinless scarf wearer. You can’t be a friendly critic – friendly criticism is seen in the same light as friendly fire – a target to be fired back at.

Ralston then goes on to state all the current economic problems, and then observes:

Some of these factors are outside the control of the Government but it would be nice to see it concentrating on the issues that concern us.

Instead, Labour whinges about John Key. The National Party leader had a point last week when he accused the Government of fiddling while the economy burned. He asked what was the cost of the Government using countless bureaucrats to endlessly scour records in an attempt to discover inconsistencies in any utterance he made.

Helen Clark’s response was to yell “Diddums”, and Michael Cullen told Key to “get used to the fact he is playing with the big boys now”.

Displaying a sad and pathetic chip on his shoulder, Cullen went on to sneer that Key was the “MP for King’s College”. As a child, Cullen attended Christ’s College on a scholarship, an experience that obviously scarred him and left him with some kind of weird class hatred of those he terms “rich pricks”.

Hence his envy tax in 1999 to take an extra 6% off those earning more than $60,000. There was and is no fiscal need for it.

Can I suggest to Dr Cullen that the rest of us “poor pricks” would prefer he concentrated on delivering a budget that took the pressure off our diminishing disposable incomes rather than making infantile personal attacks?

Labour has become obsessed by John Key. The Government launched a campaign of ridicule to try to dent his credibility and at every opportunity it seeks to portray him as some kind of evil mastermind plotting to sell the family silver and deliver us into some kind of globalised bondage.

For many of us these attacks don’t ring true. Key is a quietly spoken, thoughtful sort of guy, obviously bright but somewhat colourless.

He is not Hannibal Lecter and all attempts to convince us that he is are doomed to fail.

That’s a visual association I could do without!

Fran on F&P

Fran O’Sullivan looks at the decision by F&P to shift its Dunedin production line overseas.

Chairman Gary Paykel has had plenty to say, largely behind scenes, about the difficulty of running internationally competitive manufacturing export businesses from countries that pay First World labour costs, are distant from the world’s major consumer markets, have outrageously uncompetitive transport costs and, in particular, are slammed by a crazy monetary policy which, in New Zealand’s case has had our dollar rubbing up at US80c for far too long.

There seems a degree of inevitability.

But despite his warnings and those of other manufacturers the Government did nothing major to offset the situation, despite labelling 2007 Export Year. It could have explored a special tax rate, as suggested by New Zealand First and United Future, to gear business towards increasing its export footprint offshore from manufacturing bases here. But didn’t.

It could also have cut Government spending, as the OECD suggested, to take the pressure off monetary policy. But didn’t.

The New Zealand dollar has appreciated 27 per cent against the greenback in the past two years. Investors are sucked in by interest rates that dwarf those in other OECD countries as the Reserve Bank tries to squeeze out inflationary pressure.

The Government can not stop individual manufacturers making decisions as to what is best for them. But they can play a significant role in setting an environment which is friendly for businesses to prosper.

New Zealand manufacturing is not dead – far from it. Statistics New Zealand’s manufacturing survey for the December quarter showed total manufacturing sales increased 8.3 per cent and manufacturing volumes rose 3.4 per cent.

But the ability of manufacturers to withstand higher compliance costs, such as the KiwiSaver superannuation phase-in, will get tougher if the exchange rate persists at current levels.

Every extra cost is what may push an employer and manufacturer past the tipping point.

But the reality is that Fisher & Paykel’s move is also a consequence of globalisation. The New Zealand Institute’s David Skilling has promoted the necessity for more businesses to go offshore and relocate closer to markets.

Skilling’s weightless economy is predicated on the notion that if New Zealand keeps the brains trust here – the designers and engineers who create the products and the company headquarters – New Zealand will benefit.

That is the likely best future for us. China is becoming or has become the world’s manufacturer. We need to specialise in areas where we have a comparative advantage.

Usenet

Bruce Simpson writes on Aardvark about Usenet:

Usenet newsgroups used to be one of the cornerstone parts of the internet.

What started out as a relatively small collection of NNTP-based message exchange groups quickly grew into a massive list numbering over 100,000 separate areas of special interest.

Back in the early to mid 1990s, when usenet was at its peak, I used to spend at least an hour a day trawling through my favourite newsgroups discussing things such as guns, engineering, science and other subjects.

Indeed, I made many very long-lasting friendships through usenet and the information I gathered there was invaluable.

But I’ve been awfully busy for the last few years and hadn’t really spent any time in the newsgroups until last week when I decided to revisit my old haunts.

What a horrible shock I got.

Gone is the wealth of friendly discussion, gone are many of the old faces, gone is the useful information that used to proliferate. All of this wonderful stuff seems to have been totally eclipsed by an incredible tide of spam. So much spam in fact, that I doubt I’ll ever use usenet again.

It used to be that anyone posting spam to a usenet newsgroup would immediately be pounced on by system admins and dealt with in a very short space of time.

Now it appears as if nobody really cares.

Usenet looks to have become a ghost-town.

The occasional on-topic post appears, like a ball of tumbleweed rolling through a sea of decaying infrastructure and snake-oil salesmen.

I was also a Usenet regular from 1996 to 2004. More than a regular. I helped set up some new nz.* groups, took part in efforts to fight against spammers and other Usenet vandals, and even helped newbies by answering questions in the new users group. And met some very fine people through Usenet. I used to spend almost as much time on Usenet as I now spend blogging.

But once I found blogs, I started to use Usenet less and less as the signal to noise ration was so much higher on blogs than in Usenet.  And one day I suddenly realised I had not been into Usenet for over a month.  Today I only check it out a couple of times a year.

Clark’s hollow record on climate change

It is now just six months before the election, and Helen Clark’s record on climate change is more hollow than anyone could have imagined.

The last set of greenhouse gas figures, before the election, was released this week, and NZ is 26% over its Kyoto target. By comparison Australia and the UK are on target to meet their target.

Now Labour in defence says that okay we may have an appaling actual record, but we do have some good policy. But what is the record:

  • Biofuels legislation slammed by Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment
  • Tradeable Emissions scheme legislation slammed as near useless by Greenpeace
  • The deforestation disaster
  • The Fart tax debacle (the issue wasn’t that it was a tax so much as the hypocrisy of taxing for carbon debits and not letting farmers share in carbon credits)

So as we get subjected to a barrage of taxpayer funded propaganda telling us about our wonderful carbon neutral aspiring Government, just remember than not only has the Government failed to reduce emissions, it has not even managed to stop them growing year after year.