The lawyers strike back

Hot Topic has done what looks to be a lawyer dictated apology and retraction to the Listener:

In fact Mr Hansford was not sacked by The Listener, and nor did The Listener seek to censor or suppress Mr Hansford’s views. Hot Topic and AUT Media Ltd accept that The Listener and its editor have a strong commitment to environmental issues, and that there was no basis for any of the criticisms expressed on this site of either The Listener or its editor, or of the editorial integrity and independence of The Listener. Hot Topic and AUT Media Ltd unreservedly withdraw those statements an apologise to The Listener and to Pamela Stirling for the distress caused by our publication.

While blogs, like any publication, are not immune from the responsibility of good faith and accuracy, it seems fairly heavy handed to sic the lawyers onto a blog rather than using the opportunities blogs provide to provide rebuttal and the other side of the story. I hope this isn’t the start of a trend.

Take the Green’s Candidate Test

It is good to see Frog is appreciating my efforts to highlight their candidates and candidate selection process. I do actually think it is not a bad idea to have some sort of test to see how well candidates do when confronted with an issue, and asked to formulate some lines.

Now in case the Greens need some more candidates, I thought I’d give people here the opportunity to enter their own responses. Today we will start with the A1 vs A2 milk issue.

The background story the candidates were given is after the break. Go read it and then complete the following in the comments below:

After reading the ‘A1 or A2’ article:

1. Pick out the main points, and summarise as three bullet points (one sentence each; the length of that sentence is up to you!) Time guide: 15mins, including reading the article.

2. As you cross the lobby of Parliament on the way to the House, a reporter from Radio New Zealand approaches you and asks for comment on the A1/A2 milk controversy.  You need to come up with a couple of “soundbites” which succinctly and compellingly give the Green perspective.  Time guide: 10 mins.
  Continue reading »

Immigration irregularities

TVNZ had a major story last night focusing on Mary-Anne Thompson, the head of the Immigration Service. They report:

Documents obtained by ONE News under the Official Information Act reveal the head of the Immigration Service organised visa waivers for her nephew Katekeimoa and another relative from Kiribati to come to NZ on holiday in 2004.

Visa waivers are usually only granted in emergencies. But emails obtained by ONE News show the waiver was granted to save the family the inconvenience of getting proper visas. …

But there were big problems with Katekeimoa and his family’s residency application. The quota from Kiribati was full and New Zealand was not accepting any more immigrants from there, and the application was lodged outside the allocated timeframe.

Despite all these issues, the head of immigration’s family were fast-tracked through and made New Zealand residents.

This is not a good look.  When you are the CEO of the Immigration Service you need to be cleaner than clean when it comes to any Immigration issues concerning your own family. I would have expected formally notifying your boss (Labour Dept CEO) that family members are making an application and ask your boss to ensure than decision making is done in such a way that you are not involved and no-one reporting to you feels any pressure, and most of all no deviation from normal practice happens.

I’m very surprised that someone as competent as Thompson would follow less than bess practice. Thompson is one of the top female civil servants. She was a high flyer at Treasury and then ended up helping manage Winston’s office when he was Treasurer (no mean task). After that she headed up the highly respected policy advisory group in the Dept of PM and Cabinet.
I didn’t know her well, being a very junior political flunkie in the PM’s Office, but Thompson was highly regarded as astute and professional.  Since then she has been a bit of a trouble-shooter, cleaning up after the lies in unison scandal in Immigration etc.

The allegations are pretty serious in that there appears to have been a serious lack of judgement involved, something which in Immigration especially can undermine confidence. I think this issue will not go away for a while.

Some cartoons don’t need comments

Door to Door spam

Just been watching (now it is available here) The Chaser’s War on Everything. A great Australian show, with the highlight being the time they asked Hillary Clinton what her policy on interms will be if she became President, and also when they drive through security up to George W Bush’s hotel dressed as Osama Bin Laden.

Anyway this episode had them trying to increase the sucess rate of spam, by doing it door to door instead of e-mail.

So they knock on someone’s front door claiming to be from Westpac and stating they are upgrading their website and need the person’s login and password. Then at the next house they claim to be the cousin of the former President of Nigeria etc. Very very funny, especially when they then start asking people door to door if people want to subscribe to a horny teen sluts website, and one of the home respondents actually says Yes.

The Elim deaths

It is quite moving to read in the Herald how teacher Tony McClean was found tied to student Tom Hsu who suffered from cerebral palsy. He obviously risked his own life to try and protect Hsu. A heroic act.

It is appropriate for investigations to try and determine what actually happened, was it preventable, and how can one minimise the risk of it happening again.

While it will take some time to know the answers to the above, it has been nice to observe that generally people have not been leaping into the blame game in the absence of known facts.

Views on Labour’s song

Denis Welch blogs his reaction to Labour’s song:

I do wish they wouldn’t sing at Labour Party conferences. Not in public, anyway. One glimpse on the television news of Ruth Dyson, Maryan Street and friends singing an anti-John-Key parody of “The Gambler” onstage at the latest conference was enough to have me hiding my head under the sofa cushions. Not only was it embarrassingly in-house, it exposed Labour as caring just a bit too much about Key. Boy, they must be scared of him. If they are so scared, they should find subtler ways of demonizing him.

Fran O’Sullivan gets musical in response:

“On a chilly autumn morning in a Government going nowhere, Helen met Michael the Gambler; caustic and grim.

“When Helen saw that people were suffering, stung by rising food prices and not able to pay their bills,

“The PM said, Michael, you’ll finally have to empty all your tills.

“Michael said, Helen, I’ve made a life out of gambling other people’s money, not caring where it came from, or who would lose their job.

“But this year I’ll let them keep back some of their taxes. I promise not to be churlish – I know there’s an election coming and I’ll be ready every day, to flip when you say flop.”

Chorus (sung by Fisher & Paykel choir):

“You’ve got to know not to trust them, not to believe them, know what they tell you, won’t be the truth,

“We can’t let them run the country, cos they’re just not able … “.

And if you think that is bad, you really don’t want to hear what was played on Classic Hits FM. Anyway Fran pulls no punches:

This bastardised Rogers’ ditty is not particularly nice.

But what else does the Government expect after the pathetic sight of three caterwauling female Cabinet ministers tunelessly hammering out their own bastard version of the Rogers hit to slag off John Key at the Labour Party congress?

The three ministers: Ruth Dyson (labour), Maryan Street (housing) and Steve Chadwick (conservation and women’s affairs) will be in the front-line as New Zealand families continue to be hit by the rising cost of living and the loss of more jobs overseas, while the persistently high New Zealand dollar robs most exporters of their profitability.

But instead of using their party congress to tackle major systemic issues like food security and New Zealand’s monetary policy regime, they burst into trivia.

A party’s election year congress is not a minor event. It is probably the third most important event for a party after the campaign opening and closing.  It is an opportunity to get you campaign messages away. Instead all people will now recall is the song and the fire alarm.

Armstrong on Arrogance

John Armstrong notes that Labour were talking humility at their weekend conference. He has a challenge though:

The real test, however, of whether this new humility is anything more than cosmetic is whether Labour is willing to ‘fess up to the complete and utter shambles that goes under the name of the Electoral Finance Act.

It would be hard to find another piece of legislation where Labour has not only got it so wrong, but also looked so arrogant in refusing to admit it.

Designed to stymie National booking an election-year splurge of advertising, the law has turned into the political equivalent of Frankenstein’s monster, paralysing parties’ communication with voters in ways that even the law’s biggest critics did not envisage.

Ahem, cough. With modesty I point out my blog post of 3 December 2007 where I said:

Now combined with the extension of the regulated period to all of election year, it means that anything an MP spends on publicity next year *may* be able to be counted as party or candidate expenditure under the Act, even if approved by the Parliamentary Service.  It will have to be seen as encouraging or persuading people to vote, but that is not always clear cut as we saw with the pledge card.

So MPs had better be very careful with spending their $65,000 parliamentary budget.  If $5,000 of that $65,000 they spend ends up classified as election advertising, and they have spent $16,000 directly on the campaign, then bang they have overspent and they are out of Parliament.

Every letter, every advert, every newsletter will be scrutinised for electioneering.  There could be multiple election petitions to get rulings on what is or is not an election advertisement and does it qualify for the parliamentary purposes exemption. Where onece you could avoid this uncertainity by just not spending any of your parliamentary budget on advertising in the last 90 days, now you will have to second guess all your expenditure all year long.

Armstrong continues:

Labour’s arrogance has started to wilt as it has become more and more difficult to ignore or explain away the ever-rising number of glaring faults and inconsistencies emerging in the legislation.

It is noticeable Labour is no longer defending the measure with any vigour or enthusiasm. It has instead resorted to hurling petty insults at Bill English for relentlessly highlighting the fact that the act is unworkable.

Yeah, eight years of hard work by Annette King to give herself one of the best reputations for competence, has disappeared in a few short months.

Armstrong concludes:

As much as can be ascertained, Labour is contemplating grasping this nettle one way or the other. When tackled on the subject, the Prime Minister has been choosing her words very carefully. She has ruled nothing in. But neither has she ruled anything out. Watch this space.

The only amendment Labour will be interested is is one which allows them to spend taxpayer money on advertising without restriction. But hey they can introduce such a law change, but I sure as hell look forward to select committee submission on it.

Such an ego

Oh it is hilarious reading the NZPA report on the challenge to National’s veto of Roger Payne as a candidate. Payne is quoted as saying:

“The people in the electorate of Selwyn deserve someone who is of immediate Cabinet material, I am able to offer that opportunity,” Mr Payne told the court.

Oh yes, Roger Payne is certainly going to go straight into Cabinet – around the time that Iran joins the European Union.

The decision (I expect it next week) will be interesting. If the Court finds that party boards do not have the right to veto unsuitable candidates, then it will affect most of the political parties in Parliament, as that is a very common power.

The material the SST pulled

A few people would have seen stories about pages being ripped out of the SST magazine Sunday, because of the editor’s letter from Emily Simpson. So what was it that is so bad?

All Emily did was quote a few lines from sex blogger – Always Aroused Girl. She even asterisked out the really naughty words, but did leave in scream, ecstasy and spit. Oh dear – the horrors.

The deleted editor’s letter is here.  Can’t say it seems too over the top for me, but I guess the SST were more worried about a commercial backlash.

Hat Tip: Editor’s Weblog

Kiwiblog Server upgrade

The Kiwiblog Server is being upgraded this weekend, which means Kiwiblog will be down between 10 am and 4 pm on Sunday 20 April.

Inspire Net, who are the very kind hosts, currently have me on a Hyperthreaded P4 3.0Ghz, with 4 Gbytes of ram, and a hardware raid 5 disk array.

Normally this would be more than enough for a blog. But due to the sheer volume of posts and comments on Kiwiblog, the new plugins that work well on a small site, struggle due to not being written to handle the sheer mass of data that Kiwiblog has accumulated over the years.

This has meant the blog performs very slowly during high load, due to a combination of sheer lack of horsepower in the current platform, and a memory leak in one of the new plugins that is being investigated at present.

So what are we moving to?

The new server is a Quad Core Xeon, 8Gbytes of Ram, and hardware Raid 10 disk array, and the server is capable of expanding out to 2 * Quad Core processors and 32 Gbytes of ram if the site continues to grow.

Once again many thanks to Inspire Net for their work on our behalf. And due to the upgrade you all have an excuse to get outdoors on Sunday!

Climate Change Censorship

A lot has been written about the Listener’s dumping of “Ecologic” columnist Dave Hansford and whether it was linked to a complaint by Bryan Leyland – a prominent sceptic.

John Drinnan covers it in the Herald.

But Listener editor Pamela Stirling is insisting that the two events are unconnected and that she is losing a staffer because of budget cuts.

Wellington freelance journalist Dave Hansford has been the ecological columnist since November.

He has had differences of opinion with Stirling during much of that time and on occasion was asked to changed the tone of the column.

Hansford would not be the only staffer who has had differences of opinion with the Editor.

Stirling says Hansford was only ever hired as a short-term position for two months and the column was now being written by a staffer.

But it’s clear that Stirling’s approach to the eco-column – like her approach to the Listener – has been a lot more right of centre than the line of the old days.

Stirling took over in 2004 and she says that for a long time the Listener had been the house journal of the Alliance Party.

Stirling says the magazine is more centrist and allows everyone to express a view.

It was indeed the Alliance house journal. not that I had a problem with that – if enough people want to buy the Listener as a left wing magazine, good on them. And if enough want to buy it as a centrist magazine also good on them.

Poneke blogs on the issue also. Likewise Russell Brown. And the issue was first raised on the very good Hot Topic blog.

Meanwhile in Australia they have the opposite issue with Earth Day. The Melbourne Age is known to be a very left wing paper. I doubt more than 5% of their journalists vote Liberal/National. But even they have protested about the editor forcing them to write supportive material for Earth Day. Read this story in The Australian:

In a statement accompanying the resolution, staff said the Earth Hour partnership placed basic journalistic principles in jeopardy: “Reporters were pressured not to write negative stories and story topics followed a schedule drafted by Earth Hour organisers.”

Andrew Bolt points out:

In a statement of protest last week, 235 Age journalists confirmed that their coverage of last month’s Earth Hour had been, in effect, propaganda.

“Reporters were pressured not to write ‘negative’ stories and story topics followed a schedule drafted by Earth Hour organisers,” they said. 

That confession came after the ABC’s Media Watch released an embarrassing email sent by the green group WWF to Age editor-in-chief Andrew Jaspan under the creepy header Re: Any last requests?.

In it, WWF staffer Fiona Poletti replied she indeed had more requests, and told Jaspan to run three more puff pieces for Earth Hour, a stunt in which readers were told to help save the planet from global warming by turning off lights for an hour.

Here’s one: “We would love the fashion story to get a good run. This has been given to Orietta and is about the fashion industry’s unified support for Earth Hour.”

WWF ordered, Jaspan obeyed. The Age dutifully ran that story, under the headline: “Fashionistas no dummies when it comes to be switching off.”

WWF’s request for a second story on businesses backing Earth Hour? Also obeyed. On cities around the world joining in? Obeyed. In each case Jaspan had journalists writing, albeit unwittingly, to a green group’s script.

Bolt also observes:

The joke is most Age journalists are so green they don’t need to be pushed to preach this gospel. But their bosses’ prodding changes everything.

What a reporter may freely write as news becomes propaganda if he or she is not free to report all the relevant facts. So all Age journalists writing about Earth Hour, or global warming, must for now be considered propagandists.

Too harsh? Then consider: after all that pushing of the green line by Age bosses, which staff writer would dare write that global warming in fact may have stalled, with oceans cooling and the planet not heating since 1998? Indeed, none has.

Which Age staffer would dare write that Earth Hour actually saved so little in greenhouse gases that just eight cars will make good those emissions in a year? Again, none has.

And finally Bolt uses his own situation as an example of how editorial independence should be preserved:

Responsible newspapers at least try to ensure their staff know they are still free to dissent and report inconvenient truths, which is why I’m still here, writing as I do, even after our boss Rupert Murdoch last year said it was time to “give the planet the benefit of the doubt” with global warming.

Yep, that is how it should be.

Congestion Charging for Wellington?

The Wellington Regional (not City) Council is pushing for a law change to allow congestion charging for motorists.

Generally I support congestion charging as a sensible user pays method. Implementation details and cost effectiveness are not minor issues though.

One model, developed by a council-contracted consultant, suggests charging motorists between $1.50 and $4.50 to drive into the city business district. The congestion charge would apply on weekdays between 7am and 9am. Motorists would also have to pay to leave the zone from 4pm to 6pm.

The costs talked about do not seem unduly high.

The council conceded the public could baulk at a congestion charge, with motorists already facing record petrol prices. But the proposal’s backers say it is designed to get people out of their cars and on to buses and trains.

I am a regular bus user, but would be concerned if any revenue from congestion charging went only on public transport. It should also be used to improve roads, such as the bypass. Public transport is a complement to roads, not a substitute.

Is the Hollow Men play illegal?

Stephen Franks has raised the issue of the Hollow Men play with the Electoral Commission. Nicky Hager was a strong supporter of the Electoral Finance Act, so it would be very ironic if the play based on his book was shut down as it is now an illegal election advertisement.

Let us look at how it may be an advertisement. First take s5(1)(a)(i)

election advertisement means any form of words or graphics, or both, that can reasonably be regarded as … encouraging or persuading voters to vote, or not to vote, for 1 or more specified parties…

Now a play is a form of words and The Hollow Men certainly encourages people not to vote for National. So is it exempt? What are the seven exemptions in s5(2)?

  1. electoral agency advertisements
  2. editorial material in a periodical
  3. radio or television programmes
  4. media Internet sites
  5. books
  6. documents published to members or shareholders
  7. blogs

So we have established that The Hollow Men play is almost certainly an election advertisement, and is not covered by any exemption. Next we ask is it “published” as defined in s4(1)?

publish, in relation to an advertisement, means to—

(a) print or insert in a periodical published or distributed in New Zealand; or
(b) issue, hand out, or display, to the public; or
(c) send to any member of the public by any means; or
(d) deliver to any member of the public, or leave at a place owned or occupied by a member of the public; or
(e) broadcast (for example, in the form of a radio or television broadcast); or
(f) include in a film or video displayed to the public; or
(g) disseminate to the public by means of the Internet or any other electronic medium; or
(h) store electronically in a way that is accessible to the public

We can rule out (a), (c), (g) and (h). But Stephen makes the case that a play can be considered to be displayed to the public, or delivered to any member of the public. Also if a PA system was used it could be caught up by (e) and if a promo clip for the play is put on You Tube, then that may breach (f).

One can’t say for sure that the Hollow Men play would or would not be illegal, but it shows how far reaching the law is.  It may escape the law only because it does not fit the definition of publish, even though it is defined as an election advertisement.

Now Nicky Hager should be very grateful to the anti-EFA lobbyists that we kicked up such a fuss about the select committee version of the EFB, that they deleted this clause in the definition for publish:

(i) bring to the notice of the public in any other manner

This was the infamous megaphone clause which the select committee added in. It got removed after protests.  But if that clause had remained in, then the case for The Hollow Men play being closed down by the Electoral Finance Act would have been greatly strengthened.

Press Council rules against Herald

The Press Council has ruled that two of the Herald’s editorials against the Electoral Finance Act were inaccurate due to omission of significant details. The Coalition for Open Government sucessfully laid the complaints, which means they have now won complaints against TV stations for initially reporting the EFB was better than it was (the TV stations made the mistake of believing the Minister’s spin in stead of reading the Bill) and against the Herald for making it sound worse than it was.

The basic issue was statements made in editorials that anyone wanting to promote and issue of concern would have to register as a third party, and that they did not mention this only applies if your spending is over $5,000 (in the original bill) or over $12,000 (in the revised bill). The Herald acknowledged that they probably should have, but stated the limit had been mentioned in other stories.

Incidentially if you wish to campaign for or against a candidate the limit is just $1,000 before you must register.

The Council summarises:

The council accepts that it is probably correct that any person or group wanting to promote an issue of concern would be required to spend more than $12,000.

However, this is not the point. The editorial suggested that anyone who wished to promote an issue of concern would need to register as a third party.

The failure to note the $12,000 threshold was a mis-statement of fact, which in the council’s view was not minimised by the words “to promote an issue of concern”.

Nor is it sufficient in the council’s view to say that the correct amount had been mentioned on other occasions.

Pretty difficult to disagree with the conclusion. The level at which you need to register is material and should have been in the editorials.

Incidentally it is well below the $40,000 recommended by electoral authorities.

Does KiwiSaver increase savings?

The Herald reports on a study done on KiwiSaver.

The research suggests that only 9% to 19% of money put into KiwiSaver is new savings, as most of the money being saved was just shuffled from other forms of savings.

If the correct figure is at the lower end of 9%, then that is less than the admin costs and fees, which would mean that KiwiSaver is actually lowering the overall savings rate.

Daft’s EFA Amendment

daftefa.JPG

The DAFT Party has agreed with Peter Dunne that the Electoral Finance Act needs amending, and they have proposed the above formula to simplify it in relation to party spending limits.

The formula may look complicated but it would mean there is greater certainty than with the current EFA!

Vector not strategic?

The Dom Post reports that the Government is not likely to block the sale of Wellington’s electricity network to a foreign party.

So the Government hysterically whips up opposition to a Canadian pension fund having a 25% voting stake in Auckland Airport, but has no problems with a Chinese, Hong Kong or Australian company buying 100% of Wellington’s power network.

Confused? Surely this is a Government of principle, and having proclaimed strategic asset sales to foreigners is bad, will not allow an asset as strategic as a power network to be sold?

I mean an airport is surely less strategic. Not all Aucklanders use Auckland Airport, there are substitutes to air travel, and competing airports can be built – as Waitakere Council wish to do.

But the power network in Wellington is used by 100% of Wellingtonians. No one goes without electricity. There is no way that someone could come along and put in a whole new set of power lines to every home. And there is no real alternative to electricity, as there is to air travel.

So why is the Government so inconsistent? I thought asset sales were the defining issue for this year? Why is the Government allowing this strategic asset to be flogged off?

Personally I would not be stopping private owners of either asset from selling them to other private owners. But as the Government has made asset sales a defining issue, their response is awaited.

ISP Performance

Homework for Green candidates

To help with the list ranking for the Green Party, all candidates are required to sit a test to see how good they are at spinning for the Greens. A helpful person has provided to me the “exercises” they were asked to do, and best of all the responses from all 42 candidates.

The exercises were commenting on the A1 vs A2 milk issue, and commenting on Auckland City Council’s draft annual plan. Interesting that they ask national politicians to interfere and comment on a local body’s plans.

So here are some of the responses:

Craig Carson:

One method to reduce the cost of water is to reduce consumption. There needs to be a system that ensures everyone has access to minimum requirements and charges rise as use rises.

Water Meters for everyone. An idea I support.

Kevin Hague though disagrees with water charges:

New Zealanders access to security of fresh , clean drinking water is a fundamental right, and it’s outrageous that ordinary kiwis are charged at all for this necessity of life. What’s next – a price for air?

And on the milk issue

Mikaere Curtis: 

Scientists reviewing studies made have concluded that milk containing the A1 protein could be linked to type 1 diabetes and heart disease.

Wow that is dangerous territory to talk about scientists “have concluded” and to talk about a link (causative) rather than just possible correlation.

But that is mild compared to Virginia Horrocks:

It would be relatively easy to change the whole NZ herd to A2 within 10 years so why not go ahead now. Like the tobacco industry and the lead industry before them, the milk industry is risking NZs health for profits

Yes the “milk” industry is just like the tobacco industry.

Keith Locke joins the label them killers meme:

“We can’t have people die of heart attacks and diabetes just because the government won’t give a few million dollars to research A1 milk”.

Now I could carry on, but that is enough for today. Tomorrow we’ll do some more quotes. And once I get bored, I’ll post the pdf of all the 42 answers.

Home Affordability Get Worse

Bernard Hickey blogs that home affordability got worse in March – to an all time low in the Fairfax Media home loan affordability series.

The median house price increased slightly in March, and interest rates crept up another 10 basis points to produce the worse ever result:

The proportion of median take home pay required to service the mortgage on a median house rose to 83.1% in March from 80.2% in February and surpassed the record 83.0% seen in November last year when house prices hit their peak.

This is also worse than the 77.8% seen in March last year and almost double the 44.2% seen in March 2003 when housing was seen as only just affordable. Most bankers believe anything more than 40% of after tax pay is unaffordable.

In Wellington it is even dimmer. One would need to spend 90.7% of your take home pay to service a mortgage on the median house. In Auckland 96.8%.

Nationally one needs an after tax income of $1,421.76 a week to have only 40% of your take-home pay go on the mortgage. That is $2,100.95 gross a week or $109,549.50 annually.

So if you earn less than $110,000 a year you can’t afford the median house unless you devote more than 40% of your net income to the mortgage.

Unintended consequences

The issue of biofuels is a great example of the law of unintended consequences. People insist that something is the answer, and that it must be supported, and they don’t realise what the flow on effects may be.

Biofuels have been touted as a partial solution to global warming, so governments passed laws mandating more biofuels must be used. I mean how could anyone object to more use of an energy source you can grow in the ground.

And so as the demand for biofuels increased by fiat, the supply was forced to increase. And hence farmers started growing more corn to produce ethanol for biofuels. Now again, who would object to that?

But wait. What did those farms use to produce? Oh minor stuff like wheat. So farms start producing less wheat. But people still want just as much wheat, so what happens? Oh yes the price of it goes up. And what does that mean? It means more people starve in the third world.

The Independent is a left of centre UK newspaper. Some useful quotes from this article:

Amid growing evidence that massive investment in biofuels by developed countries is helping to cause a food crisis for the world’s poor, the ecological cost of the push to produce billions of litres of petrol and diesel from plant sources will be highlighted today with protests across the country and growing political pressure to impose guarantees that the new technology reduces carbon emissions.

You see markets and incentives are very powerful things. The moment you tilt the field one way, it can have unimagined consequences.

The World Bank and the UN have, in recent days, expressed concern about the impact of biofuels on world food prices, sparking riots from Haiti to the Philippines. Gordon Brown, who has put the issue on the agenda at the forthcoming G8 summit, has also voiced concerns at EU level about deforestation and loss of habitats caused by biofuel production.

But who is to blame? Maybe those leaders who passed laws mandating biofuels?

But hey if a few extra hundred thousand people starve because of biofuels, isn’t that a price to pay for saving the planet from global warming?

Researchers at the University of Minnesota published a study in February this year which found that growing biofuel crops on converted rainforests, grasslands or peat bogs created up to 420 times more CO2 than it saved.

Whoops.

Hat Tip: Whoar

Sharples wants special seats for Maori in Auckland

It is no surprise that Pita Sharples wants reserved seats for Maori in Auckland local government. I disagree of course in implementing more Fiji style representation. Sharples said:

“Like most places, Auckland’s record of choosing Maori through the ballot box is abysmal,” he said. “I could name lists of Maori people, national figures in anyone’s eyes, sporting icons, former MPs, leading academics and jurists, people with all the requisite skills, who have stood for council and been rebuffed.

Sharples should go ahead and release that list. Then it could be debated in context.

At the last local body election two Maori candidates for Mayors were defeated – John Tamihere and Willie Jackson. Now I actually supported both Tamihere and Jackson, but I don’t think anyone has suggested they got rejected because they were Maori. Is this what Sharples is saying?

Banning gang patches a simplistic answer

Chester Borrows and Michael Laws will disagree with me, but I am unconvinced banning the public display of gang insignia will reduce violent crime, and is justified.

Gangs commit enough actual crimes, that there is no need to go and invent a new crime of wearing a patch, to get them on. I am all for a crack down on gangs.  Gangs exist primarily to arrange crime. But the solution to gangs is to arrest gang members when they break the law, and if they are a recividist offende, keep them inside for a very long time. Longer sentences and less parole would do a lot more than banning gang patches.

Having said that, I don’t think voting for the bill to go to select committee is a bad thing, as it will allow the issues of gangs to be considered. But personally I hope it doesn’t emerge out.

Are other Labour MPs hiding fugitives from the law?

The Herald reports on another case of a fugitive from authorities being hidden by Taito Philip Field when he was a Minister and a Labour MP.

Ms Phothisarn arrived in New Zealand on a visitor’s permit in May 1996, and had been living in Auckland illegally since August of that year.

She narrowly avoided capture during an Immigration Service raid on her Skipton Rd, Mangere, home in September 2002, but was caught when officers raided again in November.

By December, she had been issued a removal order and was shifting from house to house with her infant son to avoid the authorities.

It was at a meeting with Field in late December that the then-Labour MP offered her and her son, and new husband Sompong Srikaew, accommodation in a house in Prangley Ave, Mangere.

Now while MPs should be helping people with immigration problems, this absolutely does not extend to hiding and housing people who have been served a deportation order.

Did none of Field’s colleagues know he was doing this? Can Helen Clark confirm that none of her other MPs and Ministers were or are doing this? And did the Ministers of Immigration who fell over themselves to grant so many dispensations to people Field advocated for, know that Field was hiding people from their own Department?

Regardless of whether or not Field committed any crimes, the issue of Field’s political activities is something Clark can be questioned on. When Helen Clark defended Field as just helping his constituents, did she know of the fact he was hiding illegal immigrants? Is she happy for her Ministers of the Crown not to uphold the law, but to undermine it?