The change they should make to the EFA

The Herald reports that changes to the Electoral Finance Act are likely. I am not so sure, as any changes would need to be given leave to go up the order paper, and also need to go through a select committee. And making significant changes to the law in election year is risky.

But there is one change which could be made easily, and would not require all the advice and rule books to be thrown out. That is to change the length of the regulated period from 1 January to 90 days before the election (or a fixed date such as 1 September). That has led to all the uncertainty over normal activities being caught up as election expenses.

100 more diplomats

Winston Peters has had a $621 million increase for MFAT funding, over five years which will deliver 100 more diplomats.

Now this is a quirk of MMP. Ministers from parties not in Government can demand any amount of extra money from the Finance Minister, with the implicit threat of walking if they do not get it. This is no special skill.

We saw similiar last budget with a huge increase in funding for NZ Aid. But is an increase in quantity the same as an increase in quality? Well the Auditor-General reported that there were significant problems with how NZ Aid accounted in the field for its funding.

Now where does some of the funding go:

An increase in trade policy capacity, overseas and in Wellington, to push towards trade negotiations with key markets such as Korea, Japan, the United States, India and Mexico.

So Winston has managed to get more funding for trade policy staff, so he can then campaign against the trade agreements they negotiate. Is that not just a bit perverse?

Congratulations must go to MFAT though for taming their Minister so sucessfully. Ministries will forgive any manner of sins in a Minister so long as they bring home the bacon for them.

Hager’s spin

Nicky Hager claims the Police said the following:

“The Police had to address issues of ‘theft’ and ‘stealing’ because that is what Don Brash alleged. But in today’s finding the Police are saying they have no idea how the leaks occurred and that they have found no evidence of any crime being committed.”

 “This was always going to be the outcome because the information came from legitimate leaks. I believe the National Party used the allegations of theft, and thereby wasted Police resources, to try to distract attention away from the serious revelations in the book.”

Nicky would have you think hey the Police said no crime here, move along. But let us look at what they did say:

Police have closed their investigation into the theft of e-mails from former National Party leader Dr Don Brash and have announced that they have been unsuccessful in identifying those responsible for the thefts.

Hmmn, they called them thefts. Not leaks.

Detective Inspector Harry Quinn, the Officer in Charge of the investigation and Wellington Police District Crime Services Manager, said today that police had been unable to establish with certainty how the e-mails had actually been stolen.

And here they say the e-mails were stolen – they just don’t know how.

“How the thefts occurred still largely remains a mystery,” said Detective Inspector Quinn. “We have eliminated the suggestion that an external ‘computer hacker’ had breached the computer security within Parliament but there remains many other potential ways in which the crimes could have occurred.”

Again they repeat this was a theft, and all they rule out is an “external” hacker. This does not rule out numerous other scenarios such as a IT staffer with system access, an insecure password, or even someone taking advantage of a computer left logged in.

“There are strong indications that the e-mails were in printed form at the time of the theft, but with the thefts perhaps happening at any time over the two- year period it is very likely that they were stolen during several incidents,” Detective Inspector Quinn said.

I have no idea if the thefts were done of print outs, of electronic files or a mixture of both. But I would point out that someone sneaking into someone’s office, rummaging through their filing cabinet, and then taking papers from that filing cabinet is not a leak, but as the Police say – theft.

A leak is when you release information you legitimately have access to. Take for example the draft Green Party List that was leaked to me. A Green Party member who legitimately had a copy of the list, leaked it. Now that is massively different to a scenario where say only two people had a copy of the Green Party List and it was stored in Jeanette Fitzsimons’ office, and someone entered that office without authorisation, rummaged through her laptop or office files, and then stole a copy of the list, to give it to me.

E-mail Thieves got away with it

NZPA reports:

Police have given up hunt for the person behind the theft of former National Party leader Don Brash’s emails.

An investigation into the theft had closed, Wellington police district crime services manager Detective Inspector Harry Quinn said.

It had not identified those responsible.

“How the thefts occurred still largely remains a mystery,” Mr Quinn said.

“We have eliminated the suggestion that an external ‘computer hacker’ had breached the computer security within Parliament, but there remains many other potential ways in which the crimes could have occurred.”

The investigation established that emails created between October 2003 and November 2005 had been stolen from the ownership of Dr Brash, but found no evidence of thefts since November 2005.

Mr Quinn would not speculate on how he thought the emails had been taken from Dr Brash.

“There are strong indications that the emails were in printed form at the time of the theft, but with the thefts perhaps happening at any time over the two-year period it is very likely that they were stolen during several incidents,” he said.

Police interviewed parliamentary computer staff, parliamentary security staff, cleaners, Dr Brash’s staff, politicians, journalists and friends of Dr Brash.

“Many of them had their own theories on who was responsible and why the thefts had occurred,” said Mr Quinn.

“But in the end no firm evidence pointing to a potential perpetrator was uncovered. The file is closed until someone comes forward with some compelling evidence.”

Interesting that they think printed e-mails were stolen, rather than an electronic copy. If so then that is beyond doubt a criminal act.

Anonymous Donations 1st quarter 2008

Dunne calls for cross-party conference on EFA

NZPA reports:

United Future leader Peter Dunne today said a cross-party conference was needed to sort out problems with the Electoral Finance Act.

“No one, whether they were for the Act or against it, could have imagined the extent to which it is now intruding into every aspect of political life and the uncertainty it is causing for election officials, political parties, MPs and candidates.

On the contrary not only did I imagine this, I wrote extensively about it. I submitted to the Select Committee about it. And also amendments which would have helped make it better were voted down by Labour, Greens, NZ First and oh yes United Future.

“We cannot carry on with so much uncertainty and the flaws in the legislation need to be sorted out immediately in the interests of a fair election process this year.”

The easiest thing would to be change the regulated period back to 90 days.  Having it for all of election year has indeed played havoc with parties and others. Even asking people to renew a lapsed membership gets caught up. A party talking to supporters in February who have asked to hear from that party gets caught up.

He said the problems should be sorted out by MPs rather than the courts.

Why? The MPs are the ones who stuffed it up in the first place, and have a huge self interest.  Certainly it would be good to have a law with less uncertainty around it, but remember Annette King told us all how this was a good law and the law of common sense would sort it all out.

He said it should be made clear that taxpayer-funded party literature that did not solicit votes, money or membership was not attributable election expenditure.

No, no, no. The law has never ever exempted taxpayer-funded literature in the past. Giving MPs free rein to loot the taxpayer for their campaigns is not the answer. But moving the regulated period back to a more sensible time frame would mean that MPs could do their normals comms for most of the year, and then stop using taxpayer’s money for the last 12 weeks of the campaign.

Changes should also be made so the home address of a party’s financial agent was not required on advertising authorisations. 

There we are agreed. But Bill English’s bill to fix this is not going to be debated in time unless leave is granted for it to move up the order paper.

Poneke on Meningococcal B

Poneke has his usual trademark lengthy and well researched post on the Meningococcal B immunisation campaign and laments that the media treat actual doctors and scientists with more scepticism than the fantastic claims often made by alternative medicine promoters.

The comments are interesting with Russell Brown explaining his views and involvement, and also a supportive comment by David Cunliffe for the post. Excellent to see Ministers making comments on blogs.

Food prices

American Idol Judges the Labour Ministers

Elim College mourns

The death of six students and a teacher from Elim Christian College is a tragedy which will rest heavy on all those who knew them.

When I was 15, two of my classmates died in a car crash, along with the mother one one of them.  We were all stunned and and took months for life to get back to normal. And even to this day, I often think sadly of them, and the future they never got to have.

Havng seven die in one accident is almost unthinkable, and the sense of loss and sadness for their family and friends must be almost unbearable. I am reminded of some words of wisdom that death and loss only hurts so much because of our capacity for unselfish love and friendship.

Inevitably there will be a focus on how preventable was this. I don’t think today is the time to debate this, but I do note from Stuff:

Outdoor Pursuits Centre chief executive Grant Davidson told TV3 News the water flow in the gorge rose from 0.5 cubic metres per second (cumecs) at 3pm to 18 cumecs at 3.30pm – “the equivalent to the Tongariro River going down a small stream” – before dropping back to 0.5 cumecs by 6pm.

“When they entered the gorge the water was at very low level and there was no prediction for heavy rain,” he said.

That is a mighty big change for half an hour.

My thoughts and prayers are with the families and friends of the students and teacher, and the whole Elim College community.

You were warned

I warned people that the Electoral Finance Act covered e-mails and even press releases, and it is being proven right.

Heather Roy has been sending out a weekly e-mail newsletter for five years. It only goes to people who ask to receive it.  The Chief Electoral Office has advised it can be considered an election advertisement and now needs an authorisation statement.

And yes it may apply to press releases also:

Press releases, which are usually much more politically combative and seldom, if ever, carry authorisation, would be the obvious concern, potentially leaving scores of MPs in breach of the controversial new law.

But that question will not be resolved till Crown Law rules on whether a pamphlet handed to a journalist at an ACT conference could be deemed to have been published. Though material distributed to party members is exempt from the law, the journalist was not a party member.

E-mailing out a press release is probably an election advertisement. This would mean the party’s financial agent would need to authorise in writing all press releases before they go out, and they would have the financial agent’s home address on them.

More from Field depositions

More evidence yesterday from the depositions hearing against former Labour MP Taito Philip Field. While his colleagues were defending him in Parliament, what was Field allegedely up to?

Thai plasterer Phisimai Phothisarn yesterday told a Manukau District Court depositions hearing that Field had pre-approved what she would say about work carried out on one of his Wellington properties, before her meeting with independent investigator Noel Ingram, QC.

This is the inquiry which Labour trumpeted cleared Field? The inquiry set up by Clark with no power to force witnesses to testify under oath?

Ms Phothisarn – giving evidence for a second day – told prosecutor David Johnstone she and 11 other Thai immigrants had met Field twice before her interview with Mr Ingram.

It was at these meetings, it is alleged, Field agreed with them not to name the illegal workers, and to say they had gone to Wellington on three occasions.

Putting aside the alleged criminal behaviour, is it not a concern that a Labour Party Minister was hiding from the law so many illegal immigrants? Well hiding them until he could get his mate the Minister to make them legal, and then they could help repay the favour.

The court was also told Field had contacted her after her meeting with Mr Ingram and allegedly offered her money for work completed. …

She said she had a second meeting with Field – in a Burger King carpark in Auckland’s Mission Bay – where he again offered her money.

They eventually agreed he would pay her $2000. He arrived at her home later that evening with a cheque for $700.

He also asked her for a receipt.

Now some people out there might conclude that was a bribe for lying to the PM’s pet inquiry. Shame on you. It is perfectly normal to do business in the car park of Burger King. Hell I meet many clients in fast food car parks. There is nothing at all wrong with a MP meeting someone in a Burger King car park and insisting they accept money after they have just lied to a QC investigating that former Minister.

Rewriting History

It amazes me how much history has been rewritten over the collapse of the National – NZ First Government, and partisan assertions by NZ First are treated as fact today by journalists. Take Audrey Young today in the Herald:

That coalition was undermined by the lack of respect given to New Zealand First by National and eventually collapsed over the sale of Wellington Airport.

First of all it did not collapse over Wellington Airport. That was the excuse only. A deal was reached on Wellington Airport several hours before the walkout from Cabinet. I repeat, a deal was reached and agreed to by both parties. Despite this, Winston went ahead with a (pre-arranged) walkout from Cabinet to try and grandstand. His MPs were shocked and didn’t know whether to follow him, as the issue had been resolved prior to Cabinet. They had no choice, but to do so, and then things fell apart.

And likewise the assertion that the coalition was undermined by National is a very partisan view of things, and should not be reported as fact. My (partisan) view is that it was undermined by NZ First panicking at their poll ratings, low poll ratings caused primarily by NZ First and Tukugate.

Does the song require authorisation

The Herald touches on an exchange in Parliament yesterday:

The jury is out on whether this musically challenged attack on Key has backfired on Labour. With his tongue lodged firmly in his cheek, English wondered if the posting of the performance on YouTube made it an election advertisement backing Labour and thus requiring authorisation. Or was it an attack on Labour and therefore not requiring authorisation?

Heh, I don’t think the jury is out. I think they gave a verdict in five minutes. Labour supporters and even members tell me they are critically embarrassed and it was a hideous mistake.

But I did consult a lawyer yesterday morning about whether the song needed authorisation, and if so, whose?

On the face of it, it is an advertisement by the Labour Party urging people not to vote National and needs to be authorised by Labour.

But in reality it is so appalling, it probably “encourages” or “persuades” people not to vote Labour.

So you may have a situation when the effect of an advertisement is opposite to its intention.

Fran wants the list

Fran O’Sullivan wants the Government to list what is and is not a strategic asset. I agree this must be done, so people know which set of rules apply to them.  Regardless of your views on Auckland Airport, you probably agree it is not desirable for the rules to be changed halfway through a sale.

At the forum last night on how to “super-size” the economy, there was a lot of discussion on how we need more investment in NZ – in infrastructure, in businesses, in research & development etc. Investment helps us grow. But there will be less investment if the status of certain companies and/or assets are not known.

Hilarious

The Herald reports Helen Clark saying:

“Frankly swamping the shares of ownership in a SOE is exactly privatising it. So I think some hard questions need to be asked.”

The Government has also issued infrastructure bonds, most recently to help fund major roading projects, but Miss Clark said that did not qualify as privatisation.

I mean the Government should seriously get its own George Orwell TV show. First you have the special magical tax cuts which are non inflationary but all other tax cuts are inflationary.

Then you have the PM claim infrastructure bonds in an SOE are “exactly privatising it” but that roading infrastructure bonds are not privatisation.

They really are trying to fool all of the people all of the time.

Imagine if the last National Government had used infrastructure bonds for roading – Helen Clark would have been screaming in the 1990s that National was privatising the roads. Oh wait, she was!

A domestic violence register

Preventing Violence in the Home director Jane Drumm has advocated for a register of the most violent domestic violence offenders, to allow new partners to be warned.

Auckland’s domestic violence victim support agency wants a national register of the most violent offenders to be set up so new partners can be warned about dangerous men.

I’m all for such a register, but surely it should include all violent offenders, not just men?

Personally I don’t see why all convictions are not listed online in a searchable database. A criminal record is not a private matter. The clean slate law would wipe minor ones anyway eventually, but convictions should be a matter of public record.

The state doesn’t even have to set up such a database (but would be best to do so for accuracy purposes).  It could be done by any person or organisation.

Novel immigration assistance from a Labour MP

Very interesting depositions to date in the Taito Philip Field case, relating to his activities when a Labour MP.

Field asked Ministers to intervene more often than any other MP, and had a massively high sucess rate at getting Ministers to overturn decisions of the Immigration Service. So how did he advise immigrants?

The Herald reports:

A Thai immigrant says Mangere MP Taito Phillip Field told her to get married, then put her up in a rent-free home in the weeks after immigration authorities ordered her removal from New Zealand.

So we have the allegation a (then) Labour MP and Minister of the Crown advised illegal overstayers to get married, as a way to stop their deportation. Then he would house them for free (presumably so the Immigration Service would not find them), have them work for free on his house, and hey proesto his mate the Minister then gave them a work visa.

This is not yet proven in court, but my oh my it will be a fascinating case to follow. Hopefully they will also reports on how many of these people helped went on to join the Thai branch of the Labour Party.

And in a further NZPA story today, we heave of the alleged cover-up:

However, after Mr Siriwan went to Samoa on Field’s advice, the witness said he called her and told her not to talk to police about his finances or his accommodation in New Zealand in case there were problems.

So the former Minister was allegedly telling witnesses not to co-operate with the Police inquiry. Also fascinating.

Drowned

God it is pissing down with rain in Auckland, and I am thoroughly soaked taking refuge in a Starbucks on Queen Street.

I had a meeting yesterday morning with the NZ Institute over their broadband proposal and figured might as well stay here for an extra day and a bit, so I can make the CIS forum tonight on how to supersize the economy.

I figured that with most of the day spare, I could just stroll around Auckland, buy some books from Borders, and catch up for a few outdoor drinks later today.

Instead I’ve been running from cover to cover trying unsuccessfully not to get soaked as I get from one place to another. Bloody miserable.

The irony is Wellington was superb weather at the weekend. On Sunday had brunch at the Parade Cafe in Oriental Bay, followed by ice creams at the beach. Then we spent around six hours drinking champagne at Loaded Hog and Dockside (where by coincidence ran into Water Girl and a local Mayor who joined our table) and then Auckland Girl’s birthday dinner at Nicolini’s. Sunday was a superb day.

Wellington was still pretty good weather Monday morning when I flew out. But Auckland has been non stop rain for a day and a half. So much for being nearer the equator!

Who should America vote for?

The US presidential election is of course open to US citizens only. But as the President is the de facto leader of the world, people in almost every country follow the election, and have a view on it.

Link TV have set up a site where people can send a message to American voters. Lots of interesting voters there.

I would ask American voters to choose a US president who will tear down trade barriers, and who will pressure Europe to lift their trade barriers so that families in Africa get a better chance of lifting themselves out of poverty, by not having their exports blocked by EU and US protectionism.

Watch the Ministers sing

If you know of any swinging voters, please make sure they see this video of Labour Ministers Ruth Dyson, Maryan Street, Steve Chadwick (and MP Moana Mackey) singing their anti John Key song. I am trying to persuade National to get it made into a DVD and sent to every household!

Hat Tip: Whale Oil

Herald photo of Peters

No Right Turn on Labour

Idiot/Savant at No Right Turn is unimpressed with Labour’s plan to use the resources of the state to help them gain re-election:

Government advertising is supposed to inform people about government policy and how to access government services. It is not supposed to be used to support the government-of-the-day’s bid for re-election. By doing this Labour isn’t just displaying its cynicism, its moral bankruptcy, and its inability to distinguish between the party and the state (a disease more commonly known in one-party states like China; maybe it’s infectious?); they are also undermining the entire concept of government publicity, and in doing so, directly harming the interests of every New Zealander who may need to access government services.

Can’t add much to that. But wait we can:

But underlying it is the same basic contempt for the law we see in the US political system, the same desire to win at any cost no matter what it does to our democracy. And just by proposing it, they’re encouraging this attitude, and further undermining the very necessary controls we have on party election spending.

How long until we are all told it is just a misunderstanding?

Economic Freedom Benefits

Paul Walker blogs on the benefits of economic freedom, and mentions Hong Kong and Cuba:

An interesting point of comparison is that in 1958 Cuba’s per capita GDP was $3,170 while Hong Kong had a per capita GDP of $2,924. Since then these two countries have followed very different development paths in terms of economic freedom . Today Cuba is one of the poorest countries in Latin America, very different from today’s Hong Kong.

So in 1958 Cuba had a higher GDP per capita than Hong Kong. And today?

Hong Kong is US$41,944 (PPP) compared to around US$4,500 for Cuba.

Cuba has a state which is basically 100% of GDP. In Hong Kong it is under 20%. In NZ it is 42%.

Metro on Auckland MPs

A month or so ago, Metro Magazine got five (unnamed) press gallery members to rank the Auckland MPs. They now have a blog, so the article is now online.

Now I actually disagree with a fair few of their rankings (esp their love affair with the minor party MPs), but for those interested, here are their rankings:

  1. Helen Clark 8.5
  2. Phil Goff 8.2
  3. Sue Bradford 8.0
  4. John Key 7.8
  5. David Cunliffe 7.0
  6. Hone Harawira 6.8
  7. Pita Sharples 6.8
  8. Keith Locke 6.4
  9. Chris Carter 6.0
  10. Murray McCully 5.8
  11. Maryan Street 5.8
  12. Judith Collins 5.6
  13. Jackie Blue 5.2
  14. Nanaia Mahuta 5.2
  15. Jonathan Coleman 5.0
  16. Paula Bennett 4.6
  17. Tau Henare 4.6
  18. Mark Gosche 4.2
  19. Paul Hutchison 4.2
  20. Ross Robertson 4.2
  21. Lockwood Smith 4.0
  22. Pansy Wong 4.0
  23. Wayne Mapp 3.8
  24. Maurice Williamson 3.8
  25. Rodney Hide 3.6
  26. Clem Simich 3.6
  27. George Hawkins 3.2
  28. Lynne Pillay 3.0
  29. Richard Worth 3.0
  30. Darien Fenton 2.6
  31. Ann Hartley 2.4
  32. Allan Peachey 2.3
  33. Dave Heroera 1.7
  34. Ashraf Choudary 1.3
  35. Judith Tizard 1.0
  36. Taito Philip Field 0.6

The means and median scores are:

  • Labour, 4.1 mean, 3.7 median
  • National 4.5 mean, 4.2 median
  • Third Parties 6.3 mean, 6.8 median

As I said, I don’t agree with a fair number of the ratings.  Rodney Hide below Ross Robertson is just insane, for example.