Webby Awards

Inflation high and rising

The Dominion Post reports that economists are forecasting inflation to be close to 4% for the year to March, with the official figures out on Tuesday.

The target is 2% (it should be 1%) with the allowable range being 1%  to 3%. Bottom line is no drop in interest rates for a while.

A new super union

The Hive has an interesting piece on the proposed merger of United, the NDU and SFWU. They say it will be around the same size as the EPMU, and in a position to take the presidency of the CTU with Laila Harre as the candidate.

One big question is whether the combined union will join the Labour Party. Unite is not an affiliate member, but NDU and SFWU are I believe.

On a related issue, NZPA reports today:

Council of Trade Unions (CTU) president Helen Kelly told the party’s congress today it would run a major campaign, with its affiliate unions, to help the Government win a fourth term.

The Australian unions spent $10 million helping get Labor elected there. Who knows how much will be spent in NZ, but remember money in politics is only bad, if it is used to campaign against Labour, not for it.

Who doctored the Minutes?

Craig Foss has some fascinating information on the Hawke’s Bay District Health Board sacking. One justification for the sacking was an allegation board members doctored minutes of an audit committee meeting. But, who really did the doctoring? Read what Craig says:

In this case the minute taker, who is also the HBDHB Internal Auditor, took notes, wrote up the draft minutes and sent them to the Audit Committee Chair and CEO for review prior to the draft minutes being sent to the other Audit Committee members.

This is normal practice in most organisations – the meeting chair and CEO see the first draft.

Then began a series of email exchanges between the minute taker and senior management. Essentially senior management challenged the first draft of the minutes, suggesting they needed to have significant changes made to them. The minute taker, who is also the internal auditor, resisted this and said that the minutes should reflect a balanced record of the proceedings. The minute taker stood his ground, and in the end it was suggested that if management wanted to make significant changes they should raise these concerns at the next Audit Committee meeting when the minutes were to be approved.

Now here you get into a real area of concern. The internal auditor was correct to stand his ground, if he did not feel the changes management wanted would fairly reflect the meeting.

The correct course of action would be for the senior management to talk directly to the meeting chair (who is the officer who legally has to sign off minutes after ratification by the committee) and discuss with the Audit Committee Chair any concerns they had over the minutes.

Even more disturbing is the fact that this is the Audit Committee which has a special role in scrutinising how management perform, and that senior management are trying to change the minutes without discussing it with the Audit Committee Chair.

Independent to the above, the draft minutes with some changes but nothing major, made by the Audit Committee Chair, were sent to the other members of the Audit Committee and CEO. That should have been the end of the discussion. But, an additional set of minutes, never seen by the Audit Committee Chair, that included changes made by senior management were sent direct to Minister Cunliffe, who then used them as evidence to sack the HBDHB.

Management do not have the power to change minutes. It is grossly improper. And in this case it seems these doctored minutes were produced by senior management against the desire of the internal auditor who actually was the minute taker for the meeting.

It is not clear of the Audit Committee formally ratified the minutes at their next meeting, but that is what should happen – the committee itself testifies as to their accuracy.

The first the HBDHB members knew of these “new” minutes was when they were released as part of the Ministers HBDHB sacking media pack labelled as “Document H”.

This sound like juicy fodder for the judicial review. It also sounds like a strong reason why the Auditor-General must review the management of the District Health Board.

Labour’s plan to avoid the EFA

The NZ Herald has obtained confidential strategy notes from the Labour Party Congress, detailing how Labour plans to get around the spending limits they have foisted on everyone else.

It involves taxpayer money again of course – this time Government Departments:

In a private session on the election strategy, run by president Mike Williams, delegates were advised to distribute pamphlets on KiwiSaver produced by the Inland Revenue Department and on Working for Families produced by Work and Income.

They were also advised to tell voters when handing out the pamphlets that National voted against both measures.

Normally in an election a party in Government would pay a hundred thousand dollars or so to produce a party pamphlet which tells people about the good things they have done. But to both save Labour money, and keep them under the limit everyone else has, they plan to get hundreds of thousands of extra Government funded information pamphlets and then scare people into thinking they WFF and KiwiSaver will eb abolished if you dare not to vote Labour.

Now let us remember here that this is not a low level campaign worker thinking “Hey why don’t we grab a hundred KiwiSaver pamphlets in case we run into people interested in them. This is the Labour Party’s most senior campaign official telling every MP, candidate and campaign activist to use taxpayer funded material as part of their election campaign.

The Auditor-General actually saw this possibility back in 2005:

Auditor-General Kevin Brady raised concerns about the use of Government publicity as a political tool in a report he wrote in June 2005, three months before the election.

He said a non-political departmental publicity campaign for a policy such as Working for Families could still have value to the Government as a political tool if it were used in a wider, more politically driven campaign.

And that is exactly what they are doing.

Oh there are going to be so many lawsuits and electoral petitions after the election.

Labour lines on tax cuts

Too Right blogged that he was polled recently and asked the following:

Would you prefer either:
1. a small tax cut of $10-$15 per week with no cuts to public services and no borrowing or 2. a larger tax cut which meant cuts to public services and borrowing to fund them.

Now Too Right concludes that the client is Labour, and I am sure he is right. And the question shows that Labour plans to scare monger. The difference between National and Labour will be the rate of growth of future spending, which is vastly different to cutting existing funding for existing services. Likewise neither National nor Labour need to borrow for tax cuts, as we have huge surpluses. They will both borrow for various capital expenditure and investment programmes though.

But here is the irony – Dr Cullen himself is planning to increase borrowing and debt, and also to slow the rate of growth of future spending.

Incidentially Too Right labelled the poll, a “push poll”. It isn’t. A push poll is not simply a poll which asks a loaded question – that is the testing of future attack lines. It becomes a push poll only if you are conducting the poll not to gather data, but to get that message out to as many people as possible.

Asset Sales

National’s policy on state owned assets for the 2005 election was very mild.  It was for no full sales, and maybe one or two minor part-sales. Something that even Labour has done in Government – sell some minor state assets.

Labour of course would have you believe National plans to sell the roads, the seas, the air and the water, rather than have a rational debate over whether or not the NZ Government needs to own a chain of garages (Vehicle Testing NZ).

And having semi-sucessfully managed a fear campaign in 2005, they were all poised to do so again. For months on end they tried to talk up Auckland Airport as some sort of state asset sale they were stopping when the reality was it has been a privately owned company since Winston sold it in 1998.

So at the Labour Party Congress this weekend, they were all set to start their campaign of fear and loathing on asset sales. Yet quietly on Sunday morning on Agenda, John Key took their toys away:

GUYON Alright you rightly point out it was sold by the National government in 1998 now that brings us to this position.  What is your position now as a National Party on state asset sales?

JOHN Well National’s had some time to reflect on that and the position that we’ve decided to have is the following one.  That in the first term of the National government there will be no state assets that will be sold either partially or fully.

GUYON So no state assets, you’re completely firm on that?

JOHN That’s right.

Colin Espiner caught on to the wonderful timing:

COLIN ESPINER – Christchurch Press
Mr Key the Prime Minister addressed the Labour Party’s annual congress, the election congress yesterday and one of the things she said was that asset sales were a defining issue for Labour, and a defining issue for the election, you’ve just essentially inoculated that, was that your intention?

and again:

COLIN  Sure, but you’re also avoiding skirting around the issue of asset sales where you’re gonna get clobbered by Labour, and they were warming up, they’ve been warming up on this one for weeks and you’ve essentially ripped the rug from under them haven’t you?

Yes he has.

John Armstrong I think is 100% wrong on this being a fumble, because Key only ruled them out for the first term of office. Far from being a fumble, it was a move of brilliant timing and within a few weeks, the issue will have little resonance with anyone but those who are in no way swinging voters. No party ever gives a guarantee beyond one election, and no-one outside Helen Clark and a few commentators really get excited about what may or many not happen in two elections time.

Now my personal view on asset sales I blogged back in July 2005, and listed 13 SOEs I would happily sell.  But even National under Don Brash was talking at most a partial float of Solid Energy and maybe a few farms.

If you are not going to have a bold asset sale programme (such as I would do), then it is politically stupid to have a 5% programme where you attract all the scaremongering over asset sales, just to allow say a 20% share holding in some coal mines.

So despite personally favouring a bold programme of asset sales, I am delighted that National has shut down Labour’s ability to effectively scare-monger on this issue, because frankly you should either do a bold programme, or do no programme at all. The 2005 Brash policy was so modest, it wasn’t worth the hassle and distraction it would be.

So overall I thought Key did very well on Agenda – a very in depth and extended interview. And I say that having been pretty critical of how Key handled the Peters issue the week before.

While I am very relaxed about going from a 5% asset sale policy to a 0% asset sale policy, I am somewhat concerned over the dropping of bulk funding. Sure, I understand the politics around not provoking the PPTA and NZEI into a full-scale jihad, but if we are serious about lifting our economic game, we need to lift our educational game, and the current way we fund and staff our schools will not achieve that.  Having said no to bulk funding, the onus is on National to come up with some other ways to improve management and funding of our schools.

Raybon on Parekura

Raybon Kan uses humour as a weapon of mass destruction against Parekura Horomia:

By the way, here are the multichoice options for the NCEA question: Why do children go to school without breakfast?

A. They’re so poor there’s no food in the house.

B. They snoozed and losed.

C. The acting education minister dropped by and ate their breakfast.

D. They’re planning to steal lunch.

And it’s not like he didn’t have clues. The question he was being asked, was about child poverty. The answer was in the question. If this was Who Wants to be a Millionaire?, this was round one, about the level of What Is Your Name?

Indeed, it was a answer of immensely stupid proportions!

So, here’s what Parekura did.

Deny.

Don’t admit anything. Wait till your lawyer shows up. Oh God, they’re asking a question. It’s an accusation. An attack. Deny.

“There’s a host of reasons why…”

Think, think. Deny.

“…why students…”

Buy time.

“…and pupils…”

Nice, students and pupils.

And then, it came to him.

“They’re trying to stay trim.”

Doh.

Speaks for itself.

Labour Party Conference Protests

The fire alarm which went off just as Helen Clark was about to speak has turned out to be a genuine fire alarm, not something done by the protesters. In that case it was bloody unfortunate timing, as it forced all the delegates and MPs onto the street where the protesters heckled them.

The protesters were the normal suspects complaining about the Urewera arrests, snails, mines etc.

Earlier in the day John Boscawen and a dozen or so supporters handed our pamphlets highlighting the defects of the Electoral Finance Act.  They got radio coverage most of the morning.

I wasn’t there, but was interesting to hear from someone who was, the different reaction to the protest from two MPs who got promoted to Cabinet in the last reshuffle. One of the new Cabinet Ministers had a discussion over the human rights issues around the EFA, which was respectful and courteous and went on for around five minutes or so. Another of the new Cabinet Ministers ripped up the pamphlet in front of the EFA protesters.

I won’t say who was who, but found it an interesting contrast.

Ralston on NZ First

Ralston exclaims:

Indeed, the whole attack on the FTA is part of a carefully conceived ploy by a desperate Winston Peters to raise the popularity of the party in an election year.

It is no accident that last week New Zealand First deputy leader Peter Brown came out with his bumbling racist attack on Asian migrants.

It is no accident that Peters should then launch into his crusade against the trade agreement with China.

New Zealand First is so low in the polls it faces oblivion at the next election unless it can rally enough redneck support with its campaign against the Yellow Peril.

Indeed, while Labour focused on the Canadian peril to our already privately owned airport.

Chow

Wellington can be a very small place!

Headed into town on Saturday night with various friends who were down for a campaign planning day for National, and around 15 of us decided to head to Chow on Tory Street for dinner.

Had a few drinks at the bar, and then they showed us to our table. As we are moving around it, Auckland Girl points out to me that the person at the table next to us (and backed onto us) looks like Labour Party President Mike Williams. Sure enough it was the Labour President and Head Office staff. We quickly whisper around the table to be careful in the conversations. A few minutes later in an exchange with one of the HQ staff, she confirms that they had much the same conversation – along the lines of “Hell, looks who is being seated next to us, so watch what you say”.

Sadly we had too much of a fun time to actually listen in to any conversations, and ended up heading off around three hours later having enjoyed some great food and champagne.  Just after I left, I got texted to say EMPU Secretary Andrew Little had just arrived and was in conversation with the National Party lawyer who had served papers on the EPMU the day before.  I was tempted to head back, but by then was settled in at Mac’s Brewery, but always amuses me how Wellington is such a very small place.

HoS on smugness

The Herald on Sunday editorial labels Horomia’s assertion some kids are going without breakfast to stay trim, as symptomatic of smugness in the ranks:

Responding to such a serious and heartbreaking issue as child poverty with glibness is something Prime Minister Helen Clark should have stamped out well before election year. The sight of our most amply proportioned cabinet minister suggesting hungry children are simply dieting was reminiscent of a certain French consort’s exhortation to “let them eat cake”.

I think the TV footage would make an excellent political advertisement!

As subsequent reports revealed, recent surveys show half of Maori households are sometimes, or often, running out of food. One in five Maori families is sometimes or often using food banks. Forty per cent of Pacific children go to school without breakfast – and not for slimming purposes. Those figures will only increase in the current climate of rising food, mortgage and petrol prices.

Derek Fox will be happy Parekura is so out of touch.

The Minister’s gaffe, though, is symptomatic of Labour’s wider issues. The party of the left sounds increasingly smug or out of touch with its core constituents. During its three terms in power, a number of its MPs have forgotten who put them there.

No different to a year ago when they denied there was an underclass.

Jail Golf

The Herald on Sunday reveals the inhumane conditions in the NZ prison system:

The Corrections Department has confirmed “grass areas”, which double as putting greens, are available at two North Island prisons for inmates keen on maintaining their handicap.

But if golf isn’t your game, that’s okay – Corrections says a range of other leisure activities are available to inmates, including petanque, darts and touch rugby.

Amnesty International should be alerted that prisoners have a putting green only. A nine hole course is the minimum acceptable for prisoners.

Electoral Finance Act editorial and law suit

The Dominion Post Editorial shows they understand why Labour passed the EFA. Quotes:

In office buildings on The Terrace and Featherston St some of the country’s finest minds are grappling with the most pressing legal issue of the day, The Dominion Post writes. It may not be what they had in mind when they applied for jobs at the Crown Law Office and the Electoral Commission, but it could prove to be the defining moment of their careers. Does a balloon bearing a political party logo and website address constitute an election advertisement?

Yes the balloon law is defying the law of common sense.

To the Great Unwashed the answer is simple. Of course. What other purpose could it have? But the answer is clearly anything but straight-forward for the Government’s legal advisers and the agency responsible for maintaining the integrity of the electoral system.

The question that they should be asking, is would parties put their names and websites on balloons if they didn’t think they did help with attracting support.

There is a serious side to the affair, however. It illustrates the absurdity of the new rules Labour, the Greens and NZ First rammed through Parliament last year.

As was apparent then, and is still apparent now, no one knows what they mean or how to interpret them.

Even Mike Williams has conceded this point, and in fact Labour have expressed support for National’s lawsuit seeking the opinion of the High Court on some key provisions.

This is best illustrated by the attempts of Justice Minister Annette King and her ministerial colleagues to explain whether or not parliamentary funds spent on promotional material should be counted as election advertising.

Last November Ms King said they should, then said she could be wrong. Last week Deputy Prime Minister Michael Cullen said they should not because “matters that are properly authorised as being for parliamentary purposes do not count as election advertising for the return of expenses”.

Ms King disagreed. The cost of any of the Labour booklets distributed this year would be deducted from the amount Labour was allowed to spend campaigning, she said, but only because the party secretary had said it would be.

If all that seems like an argument about nothing, then think again because if the position advanced by Dr Cullen is accepted, it will mean politicians are free to spend the $17 million given to them each year to develop and explain policy on election advertising so long as they do not explicitly solicit votes.

Exactly. This is what Dr Cullen and Labour wants. They just don’t want the voters to understand it,which is they made the provisions in the EFA implicit instead of explicit.

But there is a catch. The slush fund will be available only to incumbent politicians. Not only will political newcomers be denied access to the fund, they will also be barred from making up the difference from their own pockets.

New candidates are finding the EFA a huge problem, as appealing to free media is the only way they can raise their profile unless they want to spend their entire campaign budget by March.

When governments overseas stack the odds in their own favour, our Government tends to label them anti-democratic, but here its principle concern appears to be to make the rules as opaque as possible.

Oh the changes are anti-democratic, and designed to tilt the field in their favour. The reason the rules are opaque is simply because they didn’t want people to catch on to what they were doing.

Its face should be as red as the balloon in question.

That only works for people who have a sense of shame.

Now National announced late yesterday that they are filing proceedings in the High Court, seeking ruling on three issues:

1 – What is a parliamentary purpose? This seeks to clarify what elected parliamentarians and parties can spend their taxpayer-funded budgets on.

2 – Third party registrations. Does the law really allow organisations which are intertwined with political parties to run separate attack campaigns that don’t count towards a political party’s total election-year spending cap?

3 – Enforcement. What is the basis for referring matters to the police?

Now the NZ Herald reports that Helen Clark herself has said the judicial review might be “useful” in relation to the first point.

Prime Minister Helen Clark told reporters it might be “useful” that National had sought a judicial review of Electoral Commission rulings in order to get clarity on what “parliamentary purpose” meant.

“I understand the Electoral Commission is taking a view of that which may be at variance with what members of Parliament understood the law to be,” she said at the Labour Party conference in Wellington.

Indeed, it will be most interesting to see how the Court rules. I am not the plaintiff in the second case (I would liked to have been but I just couldn’t afford the cost) but I have sworn an affidavit and tendered a number of documents into evidence. This does mean I need to be somewhat cautious in any comments in make in public on the case, I may not be able to say as much as I would like to, until it is concluded.

But it is nice we finally have bipartisan agreement on electoral law – that we don’t understand it, and want some judicial guidance!

The Hive

Two items of note from The Hive. First they now allow comments:

I like their rules:

  • Keep comments relevant to the post in question
  • No speculation about anyone’s sexuality
  • No personal attacks allowed unless they are about Winston Peters

They also have a theory to explain why Winston does so well with US Secretary of State Condi Rice.

The strongest argument Armstrong has in defence of Winston staying on as Foreign Minister is Winnie’s relationship with Condi Rice. Does he not realise that this relationship is nothing to do with Winston’s capability in the job. It is purely sexual – platonic we should stress. Winston has for years made women aged 45 and above go weak at the knees. He dresses immaculately and shines his shoes (maybe Armsstrong doesn’t know how women tick, next time we see him we will inspect his shoes). He is also charming. Totally without substance, but he is one of the most polite men left on the planet (his mother did a fantastic job in bringing Winston up). During his political career hundreds of thousands of New Zealand women have lusted after Winston. Condi is one of his newer converts. To make the relationship more complete all Winston has to do is stare a little too long at Condi’s well exposed legs and high heels and he has her as putty in his hands. Well done, Winston, you have pulled another one. But is this good reason for him to stay on as Foreign Minister? Couldn’t boy wonder and now poet extraordinaire David Cunliffe be equally charming?

I really really hope the US Embassy forward this analysis to the State Department, for Condi’s attention 🙂

Armstrong on Peters

John Armstrong defends Peters against calls to sack him:

Those demanding Peters’ resignation say his opposition to the NZ-China Free Trade Agreement makes his position untenable. The charge simply does not stack up. …

Nothing has changed in the interim. Suggestions that Peters has suddenly placed the Government in a constitutional quandary are laughable and his critics know it. However, they are using his opposition to the China FTA as a convenient tool to mask their real agenda – ridding Parliament of him and NZ First.

Heh my agenda with Peters has never been very hidden – getting rid of him will be a wonderful day – a day in which I will not remain sober for more than 15 minutes.

Peters had to come out against the deal. Not doing so would have run counter to his party’s fundamental planks. It would have meant he went into the election with one arm tied behind his back.

His party could have voted against, and he could have abstained though.

But rather than credit Peters with a measured response, his critics instead exploited public ignorance of NZ First’s confidence and supply arrangement with Labour to falsely portray him as redundant as Foreign Minister.

I disagree that the response was measured, just because Peters is not attacking Labour in Parliament over it.  That would just ensure he was sacked, so I don’t give credit for him doing just enough to undermine it, but not quite enough to get sacked.

It may be anomalous for the Foreign Minister not to support what, for Labour, is a major triumph in trade policy. But that anomaly has existed ever since Labour agreed to give him the foreign affairs portfolio. The anomaly is apparently now an absurdity. If so, Labour – not Peters – should be taking the rap.

Oh I agree. And what should be remembered if they did not have to agree to make him Foreign Minister. He had agreed to give confidence and supply without it, but they wanted a closer relationship where they could tie him in closer to the Government.

As foreign minister, he has hardly put a foot wrong. If he does nothing else, his success in speeding the normalising of relations with Washington and the rapport he has with Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice has more than justified his tenure of the foreign affairs portfolio.

But that, too, has been forgotten in the rush to condemn him.

I will admit his desire to improve the US relationship has been laudable, and he has done well there – especially the relationship with Rice.

Not all expenses are perks!!

An article in the NZ Herald on whether MPs expenses should be more public.  I tend to favour more transparency in this area.

But the area I want to take issue on is this:

OUR MPS’ PERKS

* Up to $24,000 accommodation allowance for MPs who live outside Wellington.

* Rebates on private international travel – ranging from 25 per cent for second-term MPs to 90 per cent for fourth-termers.

* $400 to have security system installed in home, and $600 a year for monitoring.

* Domestic air flights for both MPs and their spouses/ partners, as well as related taxi and accommodation costs.

* Children over the age of 5 get four return trips to Wellington each year. No limit on free trips for those under 5.

The first one listed is not a perk.  It is a necessary expense. If your job requires you to stay overnight away from home, they pay for your accommodation. Every employer I have had, does that.

The international travel subsidy is a fair call as a perk. Not 100% perk as it will be used somewhat for work purposes, but also definitely some private benefit.

Calling a home alarm system a perk, is pushing it.  A bit of a grey area, but it is hardly something MPs get enjoyment out of, and is sadly necessary as part of the job.  However as many may already have home alarm systems, there is some private benefit as they can save money from it.

Domestic airfares for MPs is around 95% work expense, not perk. MPs do not fly around the country for fun. They do it because they have to as part of their jobs. There can be some personal benefit but it is relatively small.

The travel for spouses and children is a bit of a grey area. Again you don’t tend to see MPs using this to fly the spouse and kids to a beach resort. It is mainly used so that MPs actually keep their families together. Spending over 150 days a year away from your home is not a great lifestyle for a family.

Roughan on Peters

Very good analysis from John Roughan:

Winston Peters says every Chinese leader understands his position. I believe him. Winston personifies everything they fear in elective democracy.

China’s leaders see free elections as an invitation to egocentric individuals to play politics for personal gratification rather than social improvement. They genuinely think that where multi-party competition is permitted it will only produce politicians like Winston.

Bingo. Dead on the money.

It must be hard for people with no experience of free elections to believe that in educated democracies such as ours the vast majority of voters in fact are not seduced by politicians like Winston. It is hard enough to convince some in this that all politicians are not like him.

This is important. The vast majority of MPs, from all parties, are sincerely dedicated to improving NZ, and believe their policies will do so.

A tiresome popular misconception, assiduously cultivated by himself over the years, holds that all politicians except him are unprincipled and self-serving. The truth is exactly the reverse. Winston is unique but not for the reasons his admirers think. Just about everybody else in our Parliament is there with a sense of the social good.

Again, Peters is near unique in his populism without conviction or belief in anything but that he should be in power.

That is what we all thought. But the reason he gave this week was quite different. The agreement was too soft, he said, the tariff reductions too slow. He was hoping for better.

Bullshit. Phil Goff’s word is the only apt description for Winston’s politics. Our tariff phase-downs might be faster than China’s in this deal but those China has agreed to are rapid by comparison with New Zealand’s voluntary reductions over the past 20 years, which Winston of course opposed. He has opposed every important economic step the country has taken during his time in Parliament. If he operates by a principle beyond personal survival it is simple conservatism: do nothing drastic, nothing much is wrong, leave us alone.

Peters reasons for not voting for the FTA are bizarre. The Greens have a sincere opposition to the FTA- to be blunt they don’t like trade as it is bad for the environment.

But Peters says the tariffs in China are not coming down fast enough. So his solution is to do nothing, as if that will be better for our exporters!! He complains that we reduced tariffs unilaterally in the 80s and 90s.  Well yes we did, and now have the lowest unemployment in the developed world because we have a modern competitive economy. But can no one see through the faulty logic of complaining we have already lowered our tariffs, yet refusing to vote for something which will lower barriers for our exporters?

Yet both major parties now plainly hope he will return. Since they have to deal with minor parties to govern under MMP, they both would sooner deal with personal egos than principled parties. It is easier to satisfy a Peters or a Dunne than Act or Maori or the Greens.

Oh I would not say they “hope” he will return. Personally I would take a principled party you can trust over a politician you can never trust, any day of the week. But parties don’t get much of a say in who they get to deal with – the voters do, and then you see how a Government can be formed.

Each side at different times has been able to finesse Winston with a sinecure. National made him Treasurer, a position that didn’t exist before or since. In that role he was an impeccable presenter of the monetarist principles he had damned up and down the country for the previous 10 years.

And he sold Auckland Aiport!!!

Now he is Foreign Minister for everything but trade, which seems rather like being admiral of everything except the ships.

Superb analogy.

But to give him his due, his flexible ego has made him a force for stability in our new system. He was genuinely upset when Jenny Shipley could not maintain a coalition with him, and timed his decision on Labour’s China deal this week to ensure he did not undermine it.

Here I disagree. People have short memories. Peters killed the Coalition by staging a walkout from Cabinet, six hours *after* the dispute over Wellington Airport had been solved. And running newspaper ads attacking the agreement the day after the PM has signed it looks like undermining it to me.

Nevertheless, our politics would be better without him. He has been a misleading voice in national debates, a negative influence on public confidence in the country and those who genuinely serve it, a mischievous, evasive, obnoxious muck-raker with the charm of an attention-seeking child.

Poetry, sheer poetry.

He has fooled his admirers for too long. May this be the year that voters wash him out of our public life.

Hear hear.

More on Auckland Airport

I’m delighted to see such a strong response from National to the poll driven economic vandalism over Auckland Airport.

Labour are spinning to the media how popular this decision will be, which confirms it was not a decision based on the law. One journalist joked on ZB that he would be surprised if the two Ministers even read the application!

Dr Cullen is quoted as saying:

“We’ve not had a good experience of selling strategic assets overseas,” Dr Cullen said.

Firstly Dr Cullen it isn’t your asset. It belongs to the tens of thousands of share holders, whose net worth you have lowered. Secondly you can’t actually take an airport overseas. Thirdly how do we know what is strategic when you won’t say so in advance. And fourtly it was for a puny 25% voting stake.

The Dom Post reports that business leaders want clearer rules about foreign investment. And this is really the big issue (not just one decision). The rules were changed retrospectively and have been changed in such a way few people can make investment decisions with a high degree of confidence about what the rules are.

At a minimum the Government should list what the so called strategic assets are. No one wins when it is a guessing game.

Clarks claims inspired by Rudd “come from behind” win

Newstalk ZB reports:

Miss Clark says Labour is looking closely at the victory by the Australian Labor Party last November, which come from behind for a comfortable win. The Prime Minister told delegates those elections show an incumbent Government does not have to be at a disadvantage going for a fourth term.

Come from behind? There was no come from behind. From almost the day Kevin Rudd became leader, he soared to a lead in the polls, and the incumbent Government never came close to closing it. Rudd had a 10%+ lead for over a year, and even overtook Howard as Preferred PM. Now who does that sound a better comparison to?

And even more weird she claims the Australian elections show a Government does not have to be at a disadvantage going for a 4th term. Umm, the incumbent Government lost!! Sure, going for a 5th term, but either ZB has reported her comments incorrectly or she is really clutching for straws.

aust07poll.JPG

UPDATE: The above graph from Oz Politics shows what total crap Clark is speaking, when she refers to Rudd coming from behind. On two party preferred vote, Labor led the Coalition for over two years, and by over 10% for the year since Rudd became Leader.

New Ministry announced

The Government has announced that they are moving the trade division of MFAT (Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade) to the Ministry of Economic Development, to make clear that trade has nothing to do with foreign policy.

MFAT will now be known as FOAM, the Foreign and Overseas Aid Ministry and the MED will become the Trade and Economic Department (TED).

Winston Peters will continue as the FOAM Minister while Phil Goff has been appointed the new TED Minister.

Copyright changes

Been meaning to blog on this since the changes to the Copyright Act were passed on Tuesday with all but the Greens and the Maori Party against. It would be a very very close call, but if I was a (non whipped) MP I would probably have voted against as the law is so inconsistent. The major points:

  • One can now legally format shift music (say from a CD you purchase to an Ipod), but music labels can opt out of allowing this in their sale conditions.
  • However you can not format shift other works, such as a movie from a DVD to your laptop or to a Video Ipod.
  • It is legal to record a TV programme to watch it later, but you can only legally keep it for as long as is reasonable to have viewed it at a more convenient time.
  • ISPs have been given an exemeption for their technical operations, such as caching files, which in theory can breach copyright.
  • Content Hosters though have only limited liability for material uploaded by their customers. If they receive a complaint alleging a copyright infringement, the ISP becomes liable unless they delete the material. This means in the case of disputes, the ISP has to act as Judge and Jury or risk being sued, and there is some evidnece from overseas that (for example) the Church of Scientology uses such copyright laws as a way to silence critics.
  • A “notice and notice” regime was rejected in favour of the US style “notice and takedown described above. The NaN regime would have meant that if a content hoster receives a complaint, they must pass it onto their customer. If the customer does not respond or agrees to remove the material, then it is taken down. However if the customer disputes they are infringing copyright, then the ISP is not held liable, but merely provides the customer’s details to the complainant so they can negotiate or sort it out in court directly.
  • The law enshrines special protection for technological protection devices, even though they can sometimes restrict people from legal actions such as making backup copies, or format shifting. TPMs are hugely unpopular and most of the music industry are dropping them.

Has been lots of comments in various areas. First of all Canadian Professor Michael Geist (a expert and advocate for fair use copyright laws) says the law isn’t great but a lot better than what was planned for Canada. He thinks the parts dealing with circumventing TPMs are pretty good.

Steven Price has an excellent post on the notice and takedown regime, its strengths and weaknesses.  I think the Minister, Judith Tizard, has also indicated they will look in future at stronger fair use provisions, which could help.

Russell Brown blogged on the law also.  InternetNZ (I chaired their working group on this issue) calls it a missed opportunity, which it is.

On the bright side, the MPAA is looking a movie download site in NZ, where people can purchase movies. This is a laudable idea, as it is important that people are given legal avenues to access material. We have had the situation in the past where one could not purchase music legally for your Ipod in NZ, and where popular TV shows are not available here for months and months after they show overseas.  The world is a global market, and making works available globally for legal purchase and download will help reduce illegal downloads.

MPs Register of Interests

After some searching (the Parliament website could do with a new content page), I’ve found the full return for MPs as at 31 January 2008, which has been in the media yesterday and today.

Items I found interesting:

  • Jim Anderton makes us invest our money in Kiwibank, while he puts his money into the Commonwealth Bank of Australia – one of those foreign banks he used to rail against
  • Steve Chadwick has a family trust called the “Gonzo Family Trust”
  • Helen Clark owns five houses. One of those “rich pricks” pushing up house prices.
  • John Key got tickets to the RWC Semi-Final
  • Winston owns no house in Tauranga (he now lives in Auckland)
  • Judith Tizard has shared ownership of a house in Coromandel. With whom?

Bullshit on Bullshit

Winston Peters demanded the media grovel and apologise for the report that Phil Goff had described Peters’ attack on the free trade deal as Bullshit.

The Government then conceded that Goff has used the term “bullshit” but only in relation to criticism of the FTA, but somehow mytically this excludes Winston’s criticism.

Today the NZ Herald reports a business leader on the record confirming that Goff did indeed use the word “bullshit” about Peters’ criticisms of the deal.

ICT Skills Shortage

One of the areas NZ faces a skill shortage in, is ICT. This is dangerous as so much of the ICT industry underpins the rest of the economy.

NZCS is reported as looking at how to reverse the industry’s skills shortage, declining student numbers in ICT courses and project failure rates, and has suggested a professional ICT certification programme.

They have a discussion paper on their website for those in the industry who have a view.

My view is that ICT does need to lift its game and be seen as just as much a profession as (for example) law or accountancy. That is not to say they are the same, but the results of unqualified advice from any of those sectors can be equally harmful to a business. The certification proposal looks a  worthy idea to me.