Peters compared to Le Pen

Government turns down Auckland Airport investment

As predicted here for weeks, the “independent” Ministers has by pure coincidence turned down approval for the Canadian bid to buy a partial stake in Auckland International Airport.

The Canadians only wanted 40% of the shares, with a reduced 25% voting strength. Ironically many of the current shareholders who wanted to sell are foreign.

It is sad to see a Government so willing to do the right thing with the China FTA and ignore NZ First type xenophobia, yet succumb to it on this issue.

The Canadians have a pretty good chance of getting the Ministers’ decision over-turned in Court as it was obvious they pre-determined the matter before they even considered it. From what I can tell, reading the decision, the neutral officials in the OIO concluded allowing the investment would be beneficial to NZ, but the Ministers substituted their own political judgement.

Not such common sense

The Herald quotes Labour Party President Mike Williams:

Labour President Mike Williams is calling on the Electoral Commission to abandon its policy of not pre-approving party election advertisements to avoid confusion over what will or will not count.

Mike, Mike, Mike. There’s no need. Just apply the law of common sense as Annette King declared.

And Mike, have you thought that the reason the electoral authorities have not been so willing to declare what is permitted under the Electoral Finance Act is because even they have no fucking idea what parts of it mean?

Did it not even trigger a moment of concern Mike, when the CEO of the Electoral Commission took the unprecedented step of going on National Radio to publicly state how the then proposed law was unclear and confusing?

Did you not even pause for a second to consider that having Annette “common sense” King get up and declare one day what her view of “parliamentary purpose” is, and then the next day say how she got it wrong and you should just listen to what all the MPs views are in Hansard, might just possibly introduce some uncertainty in the law?

And Mike most of well why should the electoral authorities tell you in advance their view of material, when the last time they did it, your party lied to them, ignored them, broke the law and then attacked the electoral authorities as having got it wrong?

Darwin Award near miss

An in touch Minister

Parekura Horomia was asked yesterday about why 20,000 children a week are being fed at school, instead of home, for breakfast.

He replied that one of the “host of reasons” is because they are trying to stay trim.

Yes obviously five year olds are already into dieting to stay trim, so they are babe or dude magnets.

And just as obviously the proper way to diet as a five year old is to not have breakfast at home, but to have it at school instead. Because that helps you to stay trim.

State Houses being privatised

Sigh!

Back Benches

I am in danger of getting addicted to Back Benches, even though Tim Selwyn still isn’t a fan. I actually like the lighter side such as poking through an MP’s office.

I like being able to watch the show live while drinking and eating at the Backbencher. And this week the MPs didn’t interject so much, which made it better I though. The MPs on Wednesday were Moana Mackey, Chester Borrows, Ron Mark and Sue Bradford.

They encourage three audience questions to the MPs during the show, and when there seemed to be a lack of volunteers, I agreed to ask a question to Ron Mark.

Now I actually get on very well with Ron, having worked with him in Government in the 1990s,  and I admire his loyalty to his Leader even though I think it is misplaced. But that didn’t stop Ron immediately loudly exclaiming that I was a National plant as I got up to ask my question, and so it made good theatre.

I though I asked a very fair, not at all loaded question, just inquiring whether the MPs thought it was a good thing or a bad thing that NZ had a Foreign Minister who was against foreign trade deals, against foreign investment and against foreigners being able to come and live in NZ 🙂

Ron said they were not against any of those things, they just wanted smarter investment, smarter trade etc, Wallace (the host) then asked me the three questions from the NZ First ad.  I happily said yes I support the China FTA.  Then he asked if I supported selling the NZ dairy industry overseas.  I was a bit puzzled by that one because as I said, I wasn’t aware it was for sale, and if so who was selling it.  And how would a sale work – are we actually talking of moving all the cows to Japan or something? Finally I concluded that I think the cows are happier in NZ.

I thought Moana Mackey did very well- relaxed and on message.  I did hope though that when they asked her does she think the Diana inquest got it right, she would proclaim no, no Prince Philip really did murder her. Chester Borrows also good – supporting the FTA, and carefully tip-toeing through the issue of Winston. Ron Mark was on the receiving end of most of it, but as usual was the happy battler. Sue Bradford was fairly subdued, but got good cheers from the large contingent of Green supporters.

So was lots of fun, and was nice the MPs stayed around for a while to chat with the people in the BB.

Blog Bits

No Right Turn blogs that he believes the NZ First advertisements do breach the Electoral Finance Act as “a reasonable person would regard it as an encouragement to vote for NZ First”. I agree. As Idiot/Savant says it is not a survey, it lays out policy and encourages approval of it.

Poneke has more on the BBC story on climate change which got modified. The reporter denied he did it under pressure, but an activist has blogged she successfully pressured him to change it.

The visible hand in economics looks at fixed vs floating exchange rates.

The DAFT Party has a solution for China over Tibet. It is to rename China to Tibet, and declare they are all Tibetians. The PRC Government should see the sense of this now they are running a market economy – you replace a tarnished brand with a more positive brand!

Bernard Hickey has video and a blog post on Alan Bollard’s speech suggesting we are talking ourselves into a recession. Bernard says we’re not, and if we do have a recession, it is because we deserve it! Them’s fighting words! It’s a lengthy excellent post with many graphs.

Key on Foreign Policy

I missed in all the Peters excitement that John Key gave a foreign policy speech this week. Nor most foreign policy is bipartisan, so no major surprises, but a few things of note:

The past 20 years have seen a plethora of FTAs signed between countries and groups of countries. Their very nature is that they are exclusive. The greatest risk to our economy is that we are excluded.

Indeed. While NZ First and the Greens want us to be excluded!

There is much that New Zealand can do to improve our role in the Pacific, and the first thing is to ensure that our aid programme there is focused and targeted properly. While the National Party acknowledges that the main target of New Zealand’s aid effort is already the Pacific, we have stated that we believe a greater proportion of our budget should be targeted there.

I agree. It is our backyard, and the area in which we can have the most influence.

It is also important that this aid is properly focused. New Zealand’s aid in recent years has been targeted at “poverty elimination” – the focus should be on economic development.

Poverty elimination or reduction is necessary in the short term, but indeed economic development and growth is the only long-term solution to poverty.

Headline of the Week

Tumeke: “Liz gets fucked by Paul live on breakfast”

When I saw the headline in my RSS feed, my first thought was what about Diane. Then I realised that this was not some new ratings stunt from TVNZ, but a commentary on the performance of NZUSA co President Liz Hawes.

I didn’t see it myself, and no video online yet, so can’t comment on how fair or otherwise Bomber’s commentary is.

Welcome Registered Commenter No 2,000

This morning we had our 2,000th registered user, or commenter.  Their User Number is actually 2269, but I regularly delete accounts set up by spam bots so they are the 2,000th now in the system.

The lucky No 2,000 is ironically called “Deep Throat”, and they posted on the Public Health Bill.

I can’t recall when I turned registration on, but I think it was only a year or so ago. I was worried it might discourage people from commenting but it doesn’t seem to be, and most people find it easy to do.

The Parliamentary Purposes Exemption

I love it when I am proved right.

When I saw the new exemption (from party spending caps) for parliamentary purposes clause in the Electoral Finance Bill last year, I concluded and blogged that Labour were trying to change the law so that their private rules over parliamentary spending would over-ride the Electoral Act. Labour blatantly broke the law in 2005 with its $800,000 of over-spending and they argued to the Police that anything approved by The Parliamentary Service under Speaker’s Guidelines over-rode the Electoral Act.

Never mind that this was against the explicit advice of the electoral agencies, the Parliamentary Service itself and the clearly stated case law from the 1988 Wairarapa Electoral Petition.

But Labour did not want people to know what they were doing. If they didn’t mind, then the Electoral Finance Bill would simply have said:

Any material approved by The Parliamentary Service as an appropriate Party or MP’s parliamentary expense, will not be an election expense.

But what the EFA says in s94(2)(g):

does not include the cost of … any publications that relate to a member of Parliament in his or her capacity as a member of Parliament.

Now the Herald reports that Labour thinks the law is as it wanted it:

The view in Labour that all material with a parliamentary crest should not be attributed as an expense under a spending cap imposed on all parties is not shared by the Electoral Commission.

Acting Prime Minister Michael Cullen yesterday showed his frustration with the Electoral Commission when asked if its view was the same as his towards parliamentary-approved material and election expenses.

“I would advise them perhaps to take clear legal advice because the law is quite clear that where an MP is acting in accordance with their normal duties as a member of Parliament then, in fact, that [material] is not attributable.”

And at this point, I should remind people that they also changed the Public Finance Appropriations Act so all but the most explicit campaign advertisements could be funded by the taxpayer, and as an even better bonus exempt from spending limits. But they knew they could not state it as blatantly as this:

Labour dares not amend the act with a more explicit exemption for parliamentary material because of the potential voter backlash.

Now the Electoral Commission CEO warned publicly before the EFA was passed that the exemption was confusing and unclear. So Labour has no one to blame but itself for the fact that there is great confusion over what the exemption does or does not cover.

Colin Espiner also writes in The Press on the issue:

The law says publications and advertisements are not attributable to party campaign spending limits if they are produced by MPs in “his or her own capacity” as an MP.

The commission is understood to be worried that this could represent a loophole through which parties could use their multi-million-dollar Parliamentary Service budgets to run election advertisements and claim they were the work of individual MPs going about their parliamentary business.

The Commission should be worried, except that this is not a loophole, as in some sort of accidential consequence. It is in fact a very deliberate attempt by the parties who supported the EFA to have the taxpayer funded their campaign, and even better not have it count towards their expenditure limit.

Espiner also reports a useful reminder from Bill English:

English said that any assurances from Labour that it would attribute the money to its spending limit were worth little, as Labour assured the Electoral Commission just before the 2005 election that the $800,000 pledge card would be counted against its expenses and then, two days after the election, reneged.

“Why should we believe any undertaking the Labour Party makes about this?” English said.

Actually the pledge card was only $400,000 – the other $400,000 was other taxpayer funded expenditure. But sadly English is right – the Labour Party General Secretary wrote to the Chief Electoral Office a few days before the 2005 election and agreed the cost of the pledge card would be included as an election expense. Then after the election he wrote again to say he had changed his mind. In my eyes that was enough to move the over spending from an illegal practice to a corrupt practice. But thanks to the Police, we never got to find out if a Judge would have agreed.

Hodgson said the misunderstanding arose because the pledge card was similar to the 1999 and 2002 pledge cards, which had been determined to be within the rules.

Not totally. Yes the Parliamentary Service approved the earlier pledge cards as able to be paid for from their budget. They were wrong to do so, but they did approve them.

But they were never approved or cleared by the electoral authorities as not being a campaign expense. The simple reality is that the electoral authorities never knew that Labour had not been including them in their expense returns previously. The old return forms never asked for individual items to be listed, so there was no way they knew the previous pledge cards had illegally not been included.

Likewise the Auditor-General never was aware that the earlier pledge cards had been paid for out of parliamentary funds. If he had been aware, there is little doubt they too would have been ruled a breach of the Public Finance Act.

So in fact it is highly probable that Labour has broken both the law in every election since 1999. Hence their conclusion that the law had to be changed, rather than they simply start obeying it.

The Public Health Bill

I’ve yet to blog much on this, but the Public Health Bill before Parliament is unimaginably bad. It starts with an incredibly flawed premise – that conditions such as obesity should be treated the same as communicable diseases and health bureaucrats should have the same powers.  Now communicable disease such as SARS can spread throughout a population through normal every day contact, and kill hundreds and thousands in its wake. You need pretty draconian powers in reserve for such an eventuality.

But you do not, I repeat do not need those same powers because kids are exercising less, and obesity and diabetes are increasing.

The Commonwealth Press Union has opposed the Bill:

The Commonwealth Press Union’s media freedom committee (MFC) told Parliament’s health select committee it was alarmed about the broad powers the Director-General of Health would have under the Public Health Bill. …

“Editors fear that this bill as drafted will give the Director-General of Health the power to impose a code of practice on any matter deemed to be of interest to public healthcare policy makers.

“It could include the reporting of suicide, the issue of healthy foods, fatty foods, different lifestyles, alcohol and so on.”

He said if the director-general could not get agreement from all sectors of the media, he or she could ensure the code was enacted by legislation after the prescribed three-year review of how the code was working.

This is all true. The Director-General of Health will become the most powerful person in NZ.  He or she can just impose codes on any industry or sector. Big issues of the past such as advertising of alcohol have been decided by Parliament with (normally) consicence votes after six or more months of consideration of an issues. Under this Bill, the DG of Health can now simply impose a new law as a regulation without even a debate in Parliament.

And it gets truly scary for retailers. They could have health bureaucrats marching into their stores and instructing shop owners where to place any product they disapprove of.  They could even ban some foods from certain shops, because for example they are within say 500 metres of a school. Easter Eggs could have size restrictions placed on them or be banned totally.
Reducing obesity rates in New Zealand is a worthy goal. But if one was truly serious about it, then one would just extend school for an hour a day, and have one hour a day of PE and exercise – that would do far far more good than having the state take over the running of dairies and supermarkets. And for adults, you could allow doctors to prescribe free gym memberships for  poor overweight people. Our authorities seem obsessed with blaming everything on food choices, and nothing on exercise choices. I’m not saying the above suggestions are what should happen, but the powers in the Public Health Bill must be pared back or preferably removed.

Calls to sack Peters grow

The Herald reports that calls for Peters to be sacked as Foreign Minister (he could be moved to another portfolio) are growing. Business representatives who are still in China are said to be furious and Phil Goff has been trying to calm them down, agreeing it was a “bullshit” situation. Those effectively calling for him to go include:

  • Northern Employers and Manufacturers Association chief executive Alasdair Thompson
  • Bob Fenwick, a past president of the NZ Export Institute
  • Revenue Minister Peter Dunne

The fact Peters is not just quietly voting against (or abstaining) but has launched a high profile campaign  in NZ against it with newspaper ads is what has them fuming, plus his insistence he will state his views against it when overseas as Foreign Minister.

Martin Kay in the Dom Post covers in more detail the Revenue Minister’s views on Peters:

Mr Dunne, UnitedFuture’s leader and revenue minister, said Mr Peters would fly in the face of “all conventions about good government” if he spoke out against the FTA as a minister. “I can’t see how you stay on that basis.”

… Mr Dunne told Newstalk ZB the FTA was central to the Government’s foreign policy and Mr Peters had to represent that.

Kay also covers the issue of Labour’s about-face on this:

Dr Cullen’s insistence that it is all right for Mr Peters to speak against the deal contradicts comments he made soon after Mr Peters was appointed, when he said the FTA was one of the “highest foreign policy goals”.

His insistence that Mr Peters is free to criticise the deal overseas also appears at odds with a Cabinet circular that says he must speak for the Government “on all issues” when out of the country.

Colin Espiner in The Press also quotes Dr Cullen yesterday:

“I think that people understand very clearly that the confidence and supply agreement provides that Mr Peters is bound on matters purely of foreign policy …”

Now recall that in 2005, Dr Cullen stated in Parliament that the China FTA was one of the Government’s “highest foreign policy goals”.

Priceless

Labour agreed to increase the size of the Police by 1,000 officers as part of its deal with NZ First in 2005.

It has been obvious for some time they would not meet that target.

So they have come up with a solution – to import Asian police officers from Singapore.

Absolutely priceless!

Who gets to tell Peter Brown?

What I wish National had said

I was also on ZB today, and was asked about National’s position on Winston as Foreign Minister. I said that I was disappointed in the response in that it missed an opportunity to differentiate National from Labour in terms of how far one would compromise good Government just to keep the numbers together.

What I would have liked John Key to say in response to the question of whether one could have Peters as a future Foreign Minister is:

“Look no one is ruled in or out of a portfolio in advance, but what I will say is that in a Government I lead, you will not be able to be Minister of Foreign Affairs unless you support the Government’s foreign policy, which obviously includes trade agreements”

Key was not wrong to not rule Peters out. The sad reality of MMP is you can’t rule most things in or out until you have the elction results. But I do think he missed a real opportunity to make it clear that while he could not rule a person (Peters) out, he could rule out unacceptable behaviour (the Foreign Minister saying he will criticise a trade agreement while overseas, and campaigning against it in NZ before the ink is even dry).

This whole episode shows us the problem with the ever increasing removal of collective responsibility. It has gone too far.  I am not saying it needs to go back to the days of every member of the Executive having to support the Government on every issue. But when you are having a debate about whether or not it is okay for the Foreign Affairs Minister to be personally heading up a newspaper campaign against a major foreign policy achievement with China, then things have gone too far. There shouldn’t even be a debate.

I mean we have the Foreign Affairs Minister campaigning on his opposition to trade with foreigners, his opposition to Asian foreigners being able to live here, and his opposition to people being able to sell property or shares to foreigners. Does Helen not think this might slightly undermine his ability to be an effective and respected Foreign Minister?

Dunne calls for Peters to go

Just been listening to Larry Williams and Peter Dunne referred to Winston’s position as untenable and agreed he should resign.

I think it is very news worthy that one Minister of the Crown has called for another to be sacked.

NZIER tax cut tool

Hidden away on the NZIER site is a excel spreadsheet which allows you to design your own tax cuts.

You can do the following sorts of adjustments:

  • Change Thresholds
  • Change Rates
  • Change Thresholds and Rates
  • Introduce a tax-free threshold
  • Income Splitting

For each scenario, it will tell you have much less tax you will pay, and the approximate fiscal cost.

Four more candidates

National has announced a further four candidates, bringing them close to the end of their selections with 61 out of 63 electorate candidates selected. Only Dunedin North and Selwyn remain. The candidates list has been updated.

Dr Jackie Blue has been re-selected in Mt Roskill. Jackie has been high profile for a new MP, especially on the Herceptin issue.

Mita Harris is standing in Mangere. Mita is a Programme Manager for Community Relations and Biodiversity Asset.

Cam(pbell) Calder standing in Manurewa is is a Doctor and Clinical Research Director, and a past President of the French New Zealand Business Council.

In Manukau East, Kanwal JS Bakshi is the candidate. He is a graduate of Delhi University, the Secretary of the Auckland Sikh Society and Vice Chair of the Indian Trade Group and Hindu Heritage Management.

The selections are not quite complete, as there are up to five list only candidates to be nominated plus the two outstanding seats. However it is interesting that it is already one of the ethnically diverse slates of candidates with six Maori candidates, a PI candidate, a Chinese candidate and two Indian candidates. National isn’t into quotas at all, but does have an awareness that it is desirable for its candidates to represent the diversity that makes up NZ. Heh in some parties diversity probably means you have been a member of both the EPMU and the SWFU 🙂

I’ll wait until all candidates are confirmed before doing a full demographic breakdown. The occupational breakdowns are often interesting too – how many from business, how many farming, how many doctors, teachers, community sector employees etc.

Why Clark must sack Peters

The Government is, to be blunt, lying when it says there is no need for the Foreign Affairs Minister to support the China Free Trade Agreement because trade agreements are somehow seperate from foreign policy.

To rebut this preposterous claim, let me quote the Rt Hon Helen Clark who just six months ago addressed the Oxford Union on the topic of “New Zealand Foreign Policy“:

A successful WTO round is our top trade priority. For it to succeed it must deliver on opening up agricultural trade. That is also in the interests of the developing world. But New Zealand has strong interests in negotiations on industrials and services too, and is looking for an outcome which delivers more openness across the board.

Meantime in our own region we are forging new trade links with APEC partner economies. Our first free trade agreement was with Australia over 24 years ago. Now we have FTAs with Singapore and Thailand, and a sub regional FTA with Chile, Singapore, and Brunei. We have completed fourteen rounds of FTA negotiations with China. Negotiations for an FTA are also going on between ASEAN and Australia and New Zealand.

Clark makes it absolutely clear trade policy is a subset of foreign policy. It is not a separate issue as Clark now tries to claim. It is like arguing overseas aid is not part of foreign policy.

To quote Helen Clark some more, in 2000 she said “As I have indicated, multilateral trade policy will continue to be a key focus of our foreign policy.”

And Dr Cullen in 2005 in Hansard said:

Hon Dr MICHAEL CULLEN: Yes, the Minister of Foreign Affairs accepts that seeking a free-trade deal with China is one of our highest foreign policy goals.  …

Cullen points out that Goff is Trade Minister, not Peters. But he very clearly states that the China free-trade deal is “one of our highest foreign policy goals”.

Now Clark yesterday has tried to pretend it is not foreign policy, but trade policy only, as reported on TV3:

She did not believe that China or anyone else would find it strange for the foreign minister to attack trade policy.

But as Dr Cullen and herself and Goff have said on many occasions, it is a key foreign policy goal.

Now even worse, Peters has said he will criticise the deal when overseas as Foreign Minister.  So the NZ Government will pay for their Foreign Minister to fly to other countries, and if asked about the China FTA, to say it is a bad deal which does not deliver enough to NZ. He will even say this to the Chinese Foreign Minister he claims.

Peters is also running advertisements today in newspapers attacking the China FTA.  These ads were placed *before* his Caucus claimed to have decided their position yesterday. That tells you something.

So in summary, we have multiple statements from the Government that the China FTA has been and is one of their top foreign policy goals. And you have their Foreign Minister:

  • Stating he will criticise the FTA when overseas as Foreign Minister if asked
  • Attacking the deal while the PM is still in China
  • Basically attacking his own colleagues and MFAT staff as having failed to get a good enough deal
  • Claiming not to have made his mind up on the deal as he hadn’t seen details, yet drawing up advertisements in newspapers attacking the deal before it had even been signed!
  • also heading a party campaigning against Asian immigration to NZ

Now it is possible Peters is trying to get sacked.  Since he was re-elected to Parliament in 1984, he has never gone into an election backing the Government of the Day. He could have just announced his party will vote against but he will abstain in recognition of his responsibility to the Government he is Foreign Minister of.

But Clark’s credibility is one the line if she thinks it is not an issue that the NZ Foreign Affairs Minister is campaigning against the Government’s foreign policy, and allows him to do so.

What would we think if the US Secretary of State opposed the foreign and trade policy of the US Government? Or if any Foreign Minister anywhere in the world denounced and ran advertisements against their own Government’s foreign policy?

The “agree to disagree” clause in the agreements between Labour and NZ First can not and does not extend to the Foreign Minister able to campaign against and denounce overseas the foreign policy of the Government. It is the equivalent of the Finance Minister voting against tax cuts in the Budget (something Cullen probably wishes he could do) on the grounds tax is a matter for the Minister of Revenue, not the Minister of Finance.

Peters can not continue as Foreign Affairs Minister and be sent by the NZ taxpayer to countries around the world, where he will then criticise and attack the New Zealand Government foreign policy and achievements (by way of giving personal opinions on questions) rather than advocate on behalf of the Government he is the Foreign Minister for. That is a bauble too far.

China vs Canada

Ben Thomas in the NBR takes a look at the double standards when you look at the China FTA (which I support and Govt does) and the Canadian proposal to purchase some shares off existing private owners in Auckland International Airport, with a maximum 25% voting strength (which I support, but the Govt will turn down):

There’s one footnote to FTA. The two internationalists, Clark and Goff, know that back in New Zealand, there are politicians who are less expansive in their views on free trade and other cultures.

They are ready to stir up xenophobia to take advantage of the electorate’s insecurities, and boost their polling chances.

Your correspondent refers, of course, to Michael Cullen. The finance minister this week will be waiting with baited breath for the decision of his junior ministers (David Parker and Clayton Cosgrove) on whether the Canadian Pension Plan Investment Board can buy 39.5 per cent of Auckland International Airport shares.

Cullen was the driving force – or at least, the public face – of government opposition to the possibility of the Canadians acquiring a “strategic asset” like the airport.

He fronted the decision to amend the Overseas Investment Agency’s test to make the Canadians’ bid for 39.5 per cent of the airport (now only 24.9 per cent of votes) more difficult.

Why does Dr Cullen oppose the Canadian deal so vehemently?

Perhaps one concern is Canada’s poor record on human rights: the country only passed entrenched human rights legislation in the late 1970s.

Perhaps it is the Canadians continued oppression of their French-speaking minority, and refusal to grant the outlying province of Quebec greater autonomy.

Or perhaps, to paraphrase Enoch Powell and more latterly New Zealand First’s Peter Brown, Dr Cullen fears that opening the door to Canadian investment will lead to cultural disharmony and “rivers of maple syrup” in the street.

Very good points. The Govt gets full marks for the FTA, but their behaviour over a mere 25% voting strength in what is already a privately owned airport is petty political posturing.

Moore on China

Mike Moore makes some excellent arguments:

There are some who oppose New Zealand’s trade deal with China, and want a boycott of the Olympics. It’s precisely because China depends on the global trading system that world opinion on human rights now matters to the Chinese.

Thirty million people perished during the cultural revolution and Mao’s great leap backwards. World opinion didn’t matter to the Chinese then. Now it does, and that’s a good thing.

China is going through the same process as Japan, Singapore, and places like Taiwan. As living standards rise, a middle class emerges that seeks out better social outcomes. Wages in the Pearl River delta in China rose 13 per cent last year.

Seven thousand factories will close this year because wages have moved up and these jobs will head inland, or to Vietnam, even Africa. This is the virtue of free markets and globalisation.

For the first time the Chinese Government is answerable to its own laws – you can now sue the Government.

It’s no longer an atheist state; there are the beginnings of freedom of religion. Over 10,000 Chinese Muslims were allowed to go to the Haj in Mecca. Christians sued the Shanghai Government for wrongful arrest when they expressed their religious beliefs. This is an imperfect and uneven progress that should be celebrated.

All this is healthy and Prime Minister Helen Clark has hit the right note. …

The New Zealand /China trade deal is to be welcomed. Would our competitors turn it down? In fact, our advantage will last only a few years, if that, as others sign up.

All this exposes something else about New Zealand’s political process. Our Foreign Minister, Winston Peters, says he’s not a member of Government except when overseas and may not vote for it. How is this possible?

Peter Dunne has said he will vote for the deal but has the Chinese shaking in their boots by saying he won’t go to the reception. The Maori Party has taken different positions, but one MP said we shouldn’t trade with countries that pay lower wages than NZ. That means we can’t trade with Samoa, forcing them to pay more for goods from anywhere else.

At last the adults in the Labour and National Parties have taken control for a short time and done what is right for New Zealand. This deal is worth a few hundred million dollars to New Zealand, small compared to the Uruguay Trade round, and tiny compared to what this country will get from the Doha Trade round.

Why is it so small? Because the terms of China’s accession to the World Trade Organisation collapsed tariffs in agriculture by 90 per cent. Isn’t it a good thing that China is now inside the WTO and answerable to its rules, obligations, and binding legal disputes system? The WTO and the Doha Round is still the biggest global game.

But New Zealand can do a deal with China and advance the WTO. It’s a melancholy fact the best thing I ever did was leave New Zealand to run the World Trade Organisation. China joined the WTO and the Doha Trade round was launched in my time. Modesty prevents me from pointing this out.

Completing the Doha round would be a better achievement, but to be fair to Moore he can’t be held responsible for that not happening!

Labour concedes booklet to be an expense

This is very significant. Labour have done a u-turn on the cost of their booklet being an election expense.

The Electoral Commission had declared it an election advertisement (needing authorisation), but that does not mean it is automatically an election expense as there is an exemption for material which is for parliamentary purposes.  Dr Cullen had argued it was exempt.  He may possibly have been correct, but the problem is that no one at all knows what the parliamentary purposes exemption does and does not cover because they didn’t define it (despite the Electoral Commission CEO warning them prior to passing the law it was unclear),

Realising that there was a significant risk of being found after the election to have over-spent (again) if they relied on an undefined exemption, Labour have now said they will include the cost of any booklets distributed this year. This also saves them having to make the political argument that something can be “for parliamentary purposes” but also be “an election advertisement”. Even though it is legally possible, the public would not like such distinctions. Now they are claiming few have been distributed this year, but what is important is the precedent they have set – that anything deemed an advertisement will also be an expense, and the parliamentary purposes exemption will not be relied on (despite them working so very very hard to get it in place).

What this means is that people should watch out for  two things – crests and authorisation statements. If it has a crest on it (indicating taxpayer funded) and no authorisation statement that means the party publishing it does not think it is an election advertisement (something that can persuade or encourage people to support or oppose a party, parties, a candidate or candidates). If you think it does any of the above, then you can complain to the Electoral Commission about it. I would encourage you to only complain if you genuinely think it is can be construed as an election advertisement as defined by the EFA.  I am happy to give advice (as I have done many times already) on various material – but bare in mind I am not a lawyer and the Electoral Commission will make its own mind up. I’m just saying don’t flood them with material unless you genuinely believe it qualifies as an advertisement, so you may wish to check with someone.

If it does have an authorisation statement on it, then please please retain a copy. Because after the election parties and candidates have to account for their expenditure and list all their advertisements. If they do not include something which you received, then that copy you have could be vital evidence in electoral petitions and/or prosecutions. So do not throw away all your junk mail – keep it if it has a crest and/or authorisation statement on it.

Finally I note Labour have complained about policy statements on National’s website which are not authorised (even though the site itself is). The statements are the old 2005 policy statements which are there basically in an archival sense. It raises two interesting issues for the electoral authorities and parties. The first is whether old archived material (but still publicly available) that was authored before the EFA was passed needs to be removed from websites. The second is whether an authorisation statement for a website includes all content on the website, including pdfs which can be downloaded and printed.

Tibet

Helen Clark has said she did raise the issue of Tibet with the Chinese Premier. Good.

If you want to send a message to your Government to pressure China to enter into a dialogue over Tibet, you can do so at this website, which I found through the BNI Blog.