Bear Sterns

The Fed’s bailing out of Bear Sterns is a sign of how bad things could get. Bear Sterms is America’s 5th largest bank, and if they had gone under the consequences would have been massive. They still might be.

For now it probably just means higher mortgage rates in NZ.

The real problems will be if the US and Europe go into recession. NZ could be hit with the worse of both worlds – part of a global recession – but still having high interest rates due to inflationary pressures.

Blog Bits

Newzblog shows that some on the left do not think it is a mortal sin to post photos of attractive people – they have a photo spread of Eliot Spitzer’s hooker.

Aaron Bhatnagar exposes hypocrisy from City Vision on water charges.

Steven Price criticises a judgement where an “insulting language” conviction was upheld against a man who taunted two police officers.

The Hive notices how Dr Cullen tells the Speaker how to rule, and how she always does.

La Vie

Went to see La Vie at the Festival of the Arts last night.  It was quite simply superb.

The acrobatics, the singing, the personalities were all first class, and I loved the over-arching plot that everyone there (including the audience) was in purgatory – a plane trip to hell which never arrives!

I got nervous when I found out on the day there is audience interaction, but luckily Auckland Girl and I were in a booth at the back, and those picked on tended to be in the front row. One guy ended up on stage with a cup on his head surrounded by the entire crew dancing around him.

My favourite female character was the crazy girl. She was just delightfully mad as she sang and swung about in her straitjacket.  Her facial expressions were golden.

The males were damn strong and incredibly flexible, as they twisted and twirled themselves about while balancing on arm arm. And one of them ever goes the full monty to female audience delight.

The venue was the Pacific Blue Festival Club on Frank Kitts Park – a tent with a stage floor and bar. It was a cosy intimate venue which worked so well.

The Festival finishes today so too late for others to see it, but you missed out big time if you haven’t.   It was the highlight of the Festival according to many.
You can read other reviews on Scoop, the Dom Post and Natalie at Texture.

The Dom Post says:

The performers are amazing – dive-rolling across the stage, balancing with one hand on the shoulders of fellow performers, suspended from the ceiling, twirling in chains, juggling diabolo and swapping tricks in the middle of an act – there is so much to take in and it is constantly spellbinding.

It really is hard to describe how good it was.

Oram on Fast Forward

Rod Oram writes with scepticism on Fast Forward:

Instead, the government shelved the report, and has now unveiled Fast Forward, the latest in its many, shifting, inadequately executed attempts at economic transformation. It is a big slug of money with no under-pinning strategic plan.

Given the primary sector’s lack of strategic vision, there is every danger that users of the Fast Forward fund will keep dragging it back to incremental projects that play to the sector’s historic focus on commodities.

And there are plenty of other risks too, such as a dominance of the government funding by dairying in general and Fonterra specifically, of tensions between competing companies and of political uncertainty.

I’ve also heard from industry sources, that dairy will be a dominant funder, and that there is no way in hell they will be paying for research in non dairy areas, as the Government has been suggesting.

HoS supports Public Health Bill

The HoS has come out in support of the Public Health Bill, and says people should not refer to it as nanny state.

I disagree.

Health authorities already have widespread powers – including the power to detain people and require them to take medication – to contain the spread of communicable disease. The cheap argument against extending it to non-communicable disease is that it is not the business of the state to protect people from themselves.

I despair at such an attitude. An inability to see a significance difference between a communicable disease and something which isn’t even a disease at all. Communicable disease management requires regulation and management because it can travel from person to person. That is massively different to issues such as obesity which is caused as much by lack of exercise as by food.

The Government says relax, no codes will be binding – well until three years are up. After that you may have a legion of inspectors going from dairy to dairy. Oh sorry Madam,  you are within 500 metres of a school so you can’t sell that. Sorry Sir, but you need to hide those items and put your healthier items up the front.

You think it won’t happen? Look at the explosion in health bureaucrats in the last few years?

Rather than try to regulate unhealthy foods out of existence, why not have an extra hours PE every day at school, or have DHBs provide free or subsidised gym memberships.  Because if they really think making shop keepers move certain foods to the back of the store will have any effect, they are dreaming.

Bill Ralston writes on the same issue:

The Public Health Bill is the latest example. … considering giving the Government power to control where and how supermarkets display unhealthy food.

It is a small clause in the bill and the Greens’ healthy food campaigner Sue Kedgley is adamant it would be unlikely to be used. Much.

In my experience, however, if you give Governments an inch they tend to take a mile.

Absolutely, and all our experience of Government backs this up.

People know the ugly truth of what unhealthy foods can do but some choose to gobble that Moro bar anyway. They have made a reasonably informed choice. It may not be the right choice or one that Matron Kedgley would advocate, but it is their choice.

The Government can try to control the sale of foods it dislikes but people will go on eating it. All this bill will do is create still more bureaucrats to administer it.

Yep, watch for a massive increase in public health officials.

Abortion Law

Matt McCarten writes in the HoS about a group called Voice for Life which ran adverts (which I did not see) a couple of weeks ago which said:

“We don’t want to change the [abortion] law – we want it to work as it was intended.”

Now my personal position on abortion is it should be legal, safe and preferably rare. As cessation of brain activity is what effectively marks death, I tend to regard life as the start of such brain activity (as measured by ECG, not just electrical activity) which is at around 20 weeks.

But the Voice for Life group do have a point.  In NZ we effectively have abortion on demand. Yet this has never been decided by way of legislation. The actual law basically restricts abortion to cases where there would be physical or psychological harm to the mother. Over the last 30 years or so, it has just been effectively ignored by way of an interpretation regime where all mothers qualify under the psychological harm criteria.

Voice for Life want our practice to reflect our law. Well I don’t agree with that – would be horrific to go back to a regime where women are forced into carrying unwanted pregnancies.

The issue for me, is should our law be updated to reflect our practice?

Part of me says let sleeping dogs lie. I love being able to tell friends in the US that our last major abortion debate was in the 1970s and that abortion hasn’t been a major issue in an election campaign in living memory.

But the purist part of me says it is wrong that we have never allowed the public through our representatives to have a say on whether or not the law should allow abortion on demand. I believe the majority of NZers and majority of MPs would vote for the current practice to become law. But it could be a fairly ugly debate. However do we do ourselves a dis-service by dodging the debate?

This is an issue which generates intense emotions on both sides. Some see abortion as incredibly evil and akin to murder. Others see restrictions on abortions as turning women into property who do not control their own bodies. It would be good if people could try and keep the rhetoric controlled.

Douglas for Hunua

Even the Cullen Fund has sold its airport shares

No Hilton for Wellington

The Environment Court has turned down the proposal for a 5 star Hilton to be built on the Wellington Waterfront.

I was generally supportive because the current location is occupied by an ugly warehouse used for indoor sports which just doesn’t make any use of the stunning views of its location.  There may have been features of the actual proposal which made it undesirable -but  I haven’t studied it in detail.

Wellington has no top class hotels at all. The Intercontinental (which fought the proposal as they don’t want competition) is closest, but we will struggle to attract certain conventions and conferences without a five star hotel.

Douglas to stand

To a standing ovation, Sir Roger Douglas has announced he will stand for ACT – as an electorate candidate, NZPA has reported.

This is smart politics.  The people who hate Roger Douglas will never vote ACT anyway, but it is a fairly strong symbolic gesture to those who supported the 80s reforms.

As far as I understand Douglas does not wish to actually win a seat, and is not after a high list ranking.

BNZ warns of recessions

The BNZ has made a gutsy call and says:

The BNZ says there is a greater than even chance that a recession will happen in the second half of the year.

“We have become victims of an almost perfect storm,” Mr Toplis said.

It has resulted in New Zealand businesses and consumers being pummelled by a combination of a global credit crisis, falling house prices, record fuel costs, a strong Kiwi dollar, high interest rates and the effects of the drought.

He warns that indicators such as the rapidly slowing housing market are just precursors and the credit crisis is only beginning to be felt by the wider economy.

Households are struggling under the weight of higher mortgage repayments and businesses are faced with rising debt-servicing costs as banks pay more to borrow overseas.

Household disposable income will be eroded by rising costs for food, electricity and rates, Mr Toplis says.

Transport companies and supermarkets say record fuel costs will have to be passed on to consumers.

“The economy is now very poorly and may well stay that way for some time to come,” Mr Toplis says.

Some of the factors are local, but the global economy isn’t looking too flash either.

Former NZ First candidate jailed for fraud

David Stevenson has been jailed for two years and three months for stealing over $210,000 from vulnerable clients.

Stevenson was one of those self appointed Elliot Splitzer types – holier than thou. He campaigned against higher salaries and pensions for Judges and MPs, and then stole money to increase his own salary. He stood for NZ First in 1993 I think.

Incidentally in looking through candidate lists, I notice another former NZ First candidate is a Chris Comeskey – presumably the same one who was involved in gettig the war medals returned.

Racism in Alice Springs

Deborah reports on a shocking story from Alice Springs where the Haven Backpackers Resort Hotel evicted a group of women and children, just because of their skin colour – they were Aboriginal. And a former staffer has said management told them not to allow Aboriginals to stay. Disgusting.

Bloggers are encouraged to blog on this issue, so the hotel will have its actions high up in Google when people search on them in future.

John Banks interview

A fairly amusing interview by Michelle Hewitson with the transmogrified (that term always makes me think of Calvin and Hobbes) John Banks. An extract:

To tell you the truth, I have been waiting for him to stuff up before going to see him in his second incarnation as mayor. He would not be offended by this: “You’re always remembered for your mistakes, not your achievements.”

But he seems to have been running along rather smoothly. He says he learned from his “three years in the wilderness” that his leadership style had to change and, amazingly, he seems to have managed it. I did ask around a bit and heard “obliging, transparent, inclusive”. He says, “It is still important to disagree but it is not necessary to be disagreeable”. Which suggests that he does now agree that he was disagreeable. “Of course.”

The interview also touches on how well he is working with ARC Chairman Mike Lee, despite their different political outlooks.

Bailey Kurariki

The Herald reports that Bailey Kurariki has found God and Maori culture and has turned his life around in prison.

I sincerely hope so, but have a real dread that this is not the case. As the Herald reports:

This week, the Parole Board said Bailey Kurariki was an articulate, intelligent and mature young man who was determined to turn his life around.

That was in stark contrast to its report last year, when it said he was at “high risk” of reoffending.

I get nervous at such dramatic changes which just happen to occur between parole hearings. But despite that I don’t think you can ignore the very strong advice of those who have been working to rehabilitate him:

But three years ago he began going to church and was baptised around May last year, which “has really helped him to mature”.

He was then transferred to the Maori focus unit in Hawkes Bay prison where he took an interest in kapa haka and tikanga Maori, and older Maori men took him in hand “in a positive way”.

He learned skills in the forestry industry and over a period of about two years, Kurariki grew up.

“By the end of last year we were hearing from prison officers that they were extremely impressed with him, and they are not fooled easily.

“They observed him in unguarded as well as guarded moments. There’s a lot of support for Bailey – they’ve seen him change.”

Prison Fellowship director Kim Workman said Kurariki had been rated by the Corrections Department “at the lowest possible level of risk”.

“Those who are close to him in the prison, and those from outside the prison who have supported him, are unanimous in their view that he is very unlikely to reoffend on release.”

I think he should be given a second chance. But that second chance (which is denied his victim Michael Choy) should not become a third or a fourth chance if he does offend on parole.  He should be made very aware that his sentence is for life and parole is a privilege not a right.

I hope he takes advantage of this opportunity to live a worthwhile life.

Air NZ pay rates

The Herald reveals that Shanghai-based flight attendants are paid just one quarter of the salary of their NZ colleagues on board Government-owned Air NZ.

For staff actually working in Shanghai at check-in desks etc, of course they will be paid at local rates. But it does seem inequitable that staff on board the actual flights, doing the exact same job, get paid such a massive difference purely based on where they live.

Of course the cost of living in China is much much less, and I suspect even NZ$6,240 a year is a top tier salary in China. But the flight attendants also spent much of their time in NZ and have NZ work permits.

The incentive this gives Air NZ must also be to use as few NZers as possible on the Shanghai routes.

It will be very interesting to see if the rhetoric of the Government translates into any action.

Polish argument against online voting

No wonder there are so many Polish jokes!

WARSAW – Poles should not be allowed to vote online because the internet attracts people who watch “pornography while sipping a bottle of beer”, a former prime minister told his party’s website.

Jaroslaw Kaczynski and other leaders of his conservative party have said they wanted to rejuvenate their ranks and reach out to internet users after losing power last October when younger voters flocked to their centre-right rivals.

Poland’s election commission is floating proposals such as allowing people to vote online to boost turnout.

“I am not an enthusiast of a young person sitting in front of a computer, watching video clips and pornography while sipping a bottle of beer and voting when he feels like it,” he was quoted as saying on his party’s revamped website.

He added that internet users are “the easiest group to manipulate, to suggest who to vote for.”

The Polish PM maybe onto something here. One could combine e-voting with pay per view porn – the porn covering the cost of the election.

NBR’s online plans

The Herald has an interesting article on the business newspapers. Most of it is about some sad layoffs at the IFR. But I was intrigued by this section on NBR:

Gibson said a new-look NBR would begin next week moving opinion pages on to newsprint which he said would allow more space for news and glossy adverts.

Meanwhile, the NBR website was being revamped and would be developed into what Gibson described as a right-wing answer to the Public Address website which had assembled left-wing commentators under its banner.

Technically one of the PAers is not left-wing. The token “rightie” I call him 🙂

Anyway good to see NBR planning to ramp up their online presence.

Name Supression

The Dom Post reports:

A fading pop star who admitted punching a Wellington City Council worker in a drunken scuffle on Courtenay Place has won a fight to keep her name secret after paying $300 and apologising.

The 26-year-old has also escaped conviction after being granted diversion …

She has previously recorded a hit single but has since struggled to make inroads into the industry.

Court documents show she was drinking on December 14 and was involved in a Courtenay Place confrontation about 4am.

Though a court attendant told The Dominion Post the case had been withdrawn and would not be called, her lawyer successfully sought permanent name suppression. Police consented.

Why on earth should she get name suppression? I have no problems with diversion. I’ve had it myself. But what on earth is the rationale for granting name suppression? Is she going to be massively harmed by people knowing she had a drunken scuffle? Justice should be open, not secret.

Only $20 milllion in year one

As I predicted the Government is using a capitalised fund to try and talk big figures like $2 billion of research spending. But John Key and Bill English have been calling for the actual details of projected capital flows, and spending.

NZPA this morning quote Jim Anderton:

He acknowledged that due to its gradual buildup the fund might only spend $20m in its first year, matched by $20m from industry.

Wow that is so less sexy than $2 billion. Hell it is 2% of it.

The Government should release the full capital and operating budgets for each of the 15 years it says it will exist for, rather than hide behind press releases.

On ZB 11 – 12

Doing one of my semi-regular spots on ZB’s Faceoff Panel from 11 – 12 today, for Wellington listeners.

Labour Minister Darren Hughes is on also. He’s a great guy, so I am sure we will have fun.

Topics include the Speaker’s Tours and Auckland Airport.

UPDATE: Was fun.  When Darren started going on about strategic assets, I asked him to provide a list.  He responded with “anything in my electorate” which was very witty. He kindly gave me a lift to near Lampton Quay afterwards.  When the driver asked where exactly he should let me off, Darren suggested where-ever the traffic is busiest 🙂

CIS wants a NZ policy analyst

The Centre for Independent Studies, of which I am a proud member, is seeking a Policy Analyst or Research Fellow for their NZ Policy Unit. The job is based in Sydney but you end up back in NZ a fair bit.

I would have loved a job like this when I was an employee, and the current staffer has described it as the best job he has ever had.

If you have the right skills, experience and background and want to join the brain-drain, then this may be for you.

I’m also running a (free) ad for them for the job.

Piss Off

I happened to be in Parliament on Wednesday when TV One showed their hilarious news item with Brian Connell telling Chris Faafoi to “piss off” as Faafoi asked Brian 18 times whether his wife was travellng with him to Europe.

A number of MPs inquired of assembled press secretaries whether this was now recommended response to media questions, and practised out loud this new form of parliamentary answer.

Faafoi deserves a prize for his tenacity, including waiting outside the toilet to carry on the questioning.  Mind you Duncan Garner would have probably followed inside 🙂

I’m a bit surprised that Brian didn’t say “Yes my wife is coming with me, as we already spend half the year apart. And it will actually save the taxpayer money as two economy class fares is a hell of a lot cheaper than one business class fare”.

Faafoi did have a right to ask the question, and that answer would have been more constructive I suggest!

Parliamentary Panic and Fear

There are a growing number of very very worried MPs, as the ramifications of the Electoral Finance Act become clearer – specifically the extension of the regulated period from 90 days to all of 2008.

You see the Government wanted to have a law which said if The Parliamentary Service approved some expenditure, it was automatically exempt from the Electoral Finance Act. But they realised the backlash if they stated it that baldly would be immense, so they tried to do it implicitly.

I blogged on this in December here and here. They key section for party expenses is s94(2), paragraph (g) which is:

election expense does not include the cost of any publications that relate to a member of Parliament in his or her capacity as a member of Parliament.

and for candidate expenses s 71 para (c)(i):

that relates to the campaign for the return of the candidate in the candidate’s capacity as a candidate for the district and not to the candidate in his or her capacity as a member of Parliament or as the holder of any other office

But the problem for the Government and for all MPs, is that the Electoral Commission and The Parliamentary Service have both said that just because something is approved by The Parliamentary Service doesn’t mean it will be exempt as an election expense. It will still be judged on its merits as to whether or not it is seen as an election advertisement (encourages or persuades people to vote for or against a party or type of party) and whether it qualifies as an exception to the election expense definition.

It is now dawning with a sense of dread on some MPs that all their taxpayer funded publications in 2008, run the risk of being deemed an election expense. If their newsletter advocates against other parties, then will that be an expense or not?

Causing even more fear, is the fact the Electoral Commission will not pre-approve material (which is not their role).  I am told by a (non National) MP that they will not rule in advance on whether a particular publication will be an election expense or not.  Instead they will keep a file of all complaints about publications, and after the election determine if they are expenses or not.

Now one sees why MPs are starting to panic. Almost every single MP spends more than $20,000 a year on taxpayer funded publications. In fact some MPs have *already* spent more than $20,000.  And if their publications are deemed election expenses, then they are facing either prosecution for over-spending, or much much worse – electoral petitions to over-turn their re-election.

You think Florida was bad. Imagine a scenario where say 50 of the 70 electorate MPs face an electoral petition, and the courts decide.

Now one might say, what is the probability that material approved by The Parliamentary Service could be found to be an election advertisement. Well the Solictor-General, Auditor-General, Chief Electoral Officer and Electoral Commission all found in different capacities that a massive amount of material last election, was electioneering.

When the regulated period was only 90 days, MPs could avoid the uncertainty by not spending any money on publications (except very basic stuff like electorate office ads) in the final weeks leading up to the election. But MPs don’t want to spend all of 2008 unable to publish anything, yet they don’t want to run the risk of finding out after an election they have over-spent because of their newsletter in February, and losing their seat.

But that isn’t even the end of the matter.  You see even if a publication qualifies as “in his or her capacity as an MP” and exempt as an election expense, it is not exempt as an election advertisement. Confused? I’ll try and explain.

The Act basically defines what is an election advertisement, and then defines an election expense as the cost of that advertisement. Now the exemption for parliamentary purposes only applies in terms of counting it as an expense, but not for whether or not it is an advertisement.

And here is the further problem causing some panic for MPs. Even if their publications do not count as an election expense, they may still be regarded as an election advertisement if for example they persuade or encourage you not to vote for another party.  So the MPs need to put “Authorised by Party Financial Agent, Home Address of PFA” on their publications or run the risk of breaching the Electoral Finance Act as an unauthorised advertisement.

But imagine how it looks to the public to have the parliamentary crest on a publication, but also an authorisation by the political party’s financial agent?

And MPs are worried that if they do put the authorisation on, then it is harder for them to argue it is not an election expense – even though it is quite logical under the Act that it can be one and not the other due to the exemption.

The potential for multiple electoral petitions is quite immense.  And it is worth recalling what happens if an electoral petition relating to over-spending is successful. The result is voided, and a by-election is called.  And if that seat is won by another party, that party which held that seat does not gain a List MP as compensation.

ACT conference

The ACT conference is this weekend. ACT are showing some promising signs of recovery, even though early days. Having Sir Roger Douglas back in the mainstream will send a strong message to core supporters that ACT is still needed, and should be supported.

John Key’s move to the centre has opened up ripe territory for ACT. They should be able to at least get a third MP if they position themselves smartly.

They’ve also recruited the very talented John Ansell to help with their campaign. John will now have the distinction of having worked on a Labour campaign (1993), National (2005) and ACT (2008).

UPDATE: A very good article was in Wednesday’s Herald on ACT, by Geoffrey Miller who wrote his honours dissertation on them.