Dr Ropata returns
Hilarious – Dr Ropata returns to Shortland Street.
Will Suzy Aiken return also? 🙂
The Herald reports on the well known news about Barack Obama distancing himself from his preacher who said Sept the 11th was retribution for US (and he said it just a few days afterwards), that the US Govt invented AIDS and said God should damn America, not praise it.
The media have been letting Obama off pretty lightly, because they all hate Hillary too much. But National Review’s Jonah Goldberg makes an astute comparison:
If John McCain had spent twenty years hanging with Pat Robertson, describing him as his mentor, attending Robertson’s church, having his kids baptized by Robertson, having Robertson officiate at his wedding, giving him the inspiration for the title of his career-making autobiography, collaborating with him in political organizing, and then tried to dismiss criticism by calling Robertson his lovable uncle who sometimes goes too far, there is no way on God’s green earth Yglesias or his crowd would call this “trumped up.”
People are wanting to know what lies behind Obama’s rhetoric. Is he just another Jesse Jackson or is he a candidate who can unite?
This issue will be around for a while. McCain won’t touch it as he doesn’t need to.
Hilarious – Dr Ropata returns to Shortland Street.
Will Suzy Aiken return also? 🙂
BERL have come out and said they disagree with the BNZ about NZ going into recession.
It reminds me of the three economists having an archery contest. The first one has an arrow hit a meter to the left of the bullseye, the second one then goes and hits a meter to the right of the bullseye and the third one yells out “Bullseye” 🙂
Less common is the different stances of the PM and Finance Minister. Helen was all “the economy is strong, no problems” while Cullen admitted NZ may have a small recession.
I’m happy to promote this very cool competition – where an IT “rock star” can win travel to an international IT conference up to $10,000 in value.
People can read more about it, and enter at the official website. You can nominate someone else or enter yourself in. The judging is as follows:
The winner will come from the shortlist of 10 finalists selected by Ninetwenty and the panel of judges. Public Voting will then be opened and the 10 finalists will be shortlisted to 3 by public vote and judge assessment. All finalists will be referenced. The top 3 will present at an evening with Unlimited Potential on the 21 May. A winner will be announced by the Judges on that evening.
This is a great way to celebrate excellence in the local industry. Hopefully lots of entries will be made.
Bernard Hickey blogs on what the latest Wall Street panic means for us, and it isn’t pretty.
JPMorgan Chase has moved to purchase Bear Sterns, but for only US$2 a share, which is a total value of just $236 million. On March the 14th the shares were trading for $30 a share, which valued the company at US$3.54 billion. A year ago they were worth $10 billion. Their annual turnover is $16.2 billion so $236 million is almost saying they are worthless.
I got e-mailed this graphic from a contact who got it from a staffer at the International Monetary Fund. I think it may have been in the Washington Post, and it is a useful guide to what happened.
Anyway back to Bernard:
The news coming out of Wall St this morning is simply shocking and is something every New Zealander should understand and care about.
Put simply, panic and fear rule in the world’s financial capitals right now and it will cost us all in one way or another and sooner or later. …
Translation: This is big, don’t think it won’t affect you.
In the last five years since our debt-fuelled consumption and housing boom started in January 2003, we have borrowed around NZ$39.6 billion from foreign investors.
Translation: We owe a lot of money overseas and are vulnerable to anything that may impact what those investors do.
The moment we lose the confidence of these housewives and dentists is the moment our interest rates rise and our currency collapses. This has been referred to as the Uridashi Tsunami. We know it’s coming. We just don’t know when.
Translation: Start getting off the beach now, not once you can see the tsunami about to hit.
All this means that wholesale interest rates are likely to keep rising. That means mortgage rates are likely to keep rising. Maybe not this week, but maybe next month and the month after that. Oil prices are likely to keep rising because they rise when the US dollar falls. The Fed’s desperate moves to pump money into the markets will simply increase inflationary pressures globally. Petrol and food prices are likely to rise further.
The squeeze on disposable incomes for anyone with a big mortgage will get tighter and tighter. Our economy will slow and may even fall into a recession. That is stagflation.
Translation: We may get the worse of both worlds. High interest rates, high prices and low economic growth.
The Dutch Parliament has changed the law, after two years of debate, to make sex with animals a crime.
Previously it was only a crime if the animal was mistreated. How the hell does a court determine that? Call the horse to the dock to testify? Forensic evidence of bruising? Or does it mean no flowers the next day?
I note with amusement that the “Party for the Animals” opposed the Bill. I think they are for the animals in exactly the same way that a country which calls itself a democratic people’s republic, never is.
My God. The January Crown Accounts had a $600 million error in them. IRD failed to update the provisional tax take, which is why tax revenue was around $700 million below forecast.
Vernon Small blogs that Cullen is furious. I would be also. This is not a minor error. And the fact that the tax figures were below forecast for the first time ever, is all the more reason why it should have been triple-checked.
There are numerous stories in the Hawke’s Bay District Health Board report.
First the main Herald story by Paula Oliver:
But it is what was missing from the report which will be the subject of ongoing argument.
The review did not canvas questions of whether former Health Minister Annette King should have appointed Mr Hausmann to the board.
The panel decided that topic was out of the scope of its report.
The report also did not delve into allegations that the board’s chief executive Chris Clarke colluded with Mr Hausmann over a contract.
The treatment of the whistleblower who drew attention to the conflict also was not canvassed in the report.
Yep, it all comes down to the terms of reference. This is how the Ingram Report found Field had done no wrong, yet the Police have laid dozens of charges against him. Ingram was only allowed to look into Field’s actions as a Minister. Likewise this report was not allowed to cover Annette King’s actions or the actions of management.
John Armstrong writes the report vindicates David Cunliffe’s decision to sack the Board:
Health Minister David Cunliffe professes to be satisfied with the damning findings of the independent review of Hawkes Bay’s troubled district health board.
Satisfied? Cunliffe should be satisfied – deliriously so. If his Beehive office were not so cramped he would have been excused performing cartwheels across it.
But he notes:
While Cunliffe can claim to have been vindicated, King, however, cannot claim to have been cleared by the report in terms of the wisdom of appointing Hausmann to the board.
Determining that it was outside the scope of its terms of reference, the panel rejected the board’s request to examine King’s role.
Marty Sharpe in the Dom Post focuses on the former Chair, KevinAtkinson, calling it a whitewash:
Kevin Atkinson, sacked with the rest of the board last month, says the “weasel word” report is a “whitewash in every sense of the word”. He urges the auditor-general to investigate.
But Health Minister David Cunliffe says the report, which criticises the board for failing to meet basic conflict of interest procedures and highlights major rifts with senior management, justifies his decision to sack it.
There certainly was a rift with senior management. But if I was a director and my senior management had been secretly taping conversations, improperly allowing a fellow director preferred access to RFP details, not implementing board decisions etc then I might have a rift also. Whose fault the rift is, is something that was out of bounds for the report as management were excluded. The Auditor-General is his report on one contract found much to criticise.
NZPA reports today that the Minister denies any political interference with the report, and that there is more information to come out.
Finally the Dom Post editorial says the report misses the big picture:
The report makes no comment on the wisdom of former health minister Annette King appointing Mr Hausmann, the managing director of a company with significant interests in the health sector to the board, no comment on the wisdom of board staff giving Mr Hausmann a tender document ahead of rival bidders for a district health board contract and no comment on the appropriateness of the board’s former chief operating officer Ray Lind, Mrs King’s husband and now an employee of Mr Hausmann’s company, secretly recording a meeting with the whistleblower who first questioned the appropriateness of an e-mail from Mr Hausmann to a staff member.
Mr Wilson says that is because the focus of the review was governance. But given the disquiet created by the sacking of the board just 72 days after it was elected, the existence of a substantially different draft report, the contents of which the National Party has begun dripfeeding in Parliament but which The Dominion Post has been prevented from reporting by lawyers acting on behalf of the director-general of health and Mr Hausmann, and the relatively narrow focus of the inquiry, the report will not be the end of the matter.
The board was clearly remiss in its handling of conflicts of interests. Quite possibly it deserved to be dismissed. But the wider question of whether or not Mr Hausmann should ever have been appointed to the board has not been addressed. Nor has management’s role in the debacle.
The region has been poorly served by the board, board staff and government ministers.The only beneficiaries are the National MPs campaigning to retain the Napier and Tukituki electorates later this year.
Indeed it is far from over. The number of unanswered questions remains high.
Boom Boom.
Gypsies have complained that Basil Brush is racist because his show showed a gypsy woman trying to sell the puppet fox wooden pegs and a bunch of heather.
Bad Basil.
The “u” is missing so it is Australian Labor of course.
Despite Australia living in what Clark calls a benign strategic environment, they have ordered 24 Lockheed Super Hornets.
Someone sent me the link. Pretty amusing.
Queensland has just had its local body elections, and they have seen a change of Mayor and Council in Cairns.
My mate, Michael Moore, has been an outspoken critic of the current long serving Mayor, and his blog played a not insignificant role in the election. He’s exposed some scandals, posted You Tube videos of people going to court, scrutinised various Mayoral trips and highlighted the conflicts of interests not declared by various people. It’s been a great example of the difference one person can make with a blog.
I blogged last week on the news that Air New Zealand pay only NZ$6,240 a year to flight attendants on its Shanghai route, who are Shanghai-based. This is massively lower than the NZ minimum wage.
NZPA reports on the PM’s response yesterday:
Miss Clark pointed to market rates at work, saying for instance that while Shanghai staff were paid less, those based in London would be paid more than those based in New Zealand.
Her understanding was that airlines who based crews in Shanghai did not directly employ them. They were employed through a local government agency.
Air NZ paid “substantial taxes” to the Chinese government over and above the wages paid to Chinese workers.
Could you imagine the outrage if a National PM dismissed the fact people employed by Air NZ on the flights were being paid at around one quarter the minimum wage, by referring to the “market rates”? Around 20 unions would have condemned the Government by now, and protest marches would be planned up and down the country.
This also shows one of the problems with state ownership. Because the Govt owns 80% of Air NZ, it feels it has to defend what they have done. If they were not state owned, I’d suspect the PM would be far more critical.
The PM relies on the fact they are not employed directly, but sub-contracted. Is this the same PM who pushed through a law specifically to stop sub-contracting leading to reduced terms and conditions?
I have no problems with market rates determining how much people get paid based on where they live. We already have this with salaries higher in Auckland for example. But the issue is having those “market rates” at massively below the NZ minimum wage.
Sure the NZ minimum wage does not apply to people working in China. But if someone from China works in NZ, then it most certainly does apply. And I am not convinced being employed by Air NZ on board an Air NZ flight is different to being employed in NZ.
Incidentially the Chinese former cabin crew member (Crystal Zeng) who gave the Herald the story, posted a comment on the former thread, pointing out that the salaries being paid by Air NZ are in fact even less than the Chinese airlines pay.
After days and weeks of the Minister and Peter Hausmann suggesting that the final MOH report would clear everything up, hey presto it is released today and by avoiding minor little issues such as why someone with such massive conflicts was appointed in the first place, it gives people a tick.
The report is on the MOH website and is a massive 190 pages. The report itself is very fine within its careful terms of reference (and has some very good recommendations). Things people should note are:
You see it all is like Yes Minister taught us. Frame the terms of reference correctly and you are guaranteed a report which will not cause problems. Clark did the same with the Ingram Report. This casts no aspersions on the report writers, but shows the limitations of the type of inquiry chosen.
Despite that the report by no means “clears” Hausmann. On numerous occassions it states he should have acted differently. But in the end I don’t think Hausmann is the main issue here. Other board members are also slated.
The report makes clear Hausmann had been working with the DHB since 2003 on possible public/private joint ventures. It is exceedingly clear Annette King should never ever have appointed him to the DHB. With all respect he was probably the most conflicted person in NZ with regard to that particular DHB. Her decision went on to cause almost all the problems. If she had left him off the board, his company might today be engaged in a happy partnership with the DHB.
Despite the criticism of Hausmann in the report, I’m prepared to give him some benefit of the doubt and say he did try to do the right thing most of the time. But his company was so involved with the DHB at so many levels, it was always going to be near impossible – you had DHB managers asking him for advice all the time. He probably should have been appointed CEO not a DHB member.
If one really needs to point fingers I think DHB management is a place to start. Numerous board decisions were not implemented, and it is the DHB CEO and senior staff who should have been providing the advice to DHB members on handling conflicts. The fact the CEO was tied up in the middle of all the problems made things worse.
Finally the report notes:
As such, the views contained in the draft reports were preliminary views expressed at the time that the drafts were provided. The Panel now considers that a number of these preliminary views were wrong.
That is an extraordinary change for a draft to final report. I will be very interested in seeing the draft report when it comes out.
And the question once again I would ask if why did Annette King appoint Hausmann? Officials in MOH and DPMC were concerned. She did not follow best practice with an interview panel. She ignored the concerns of the current Board Chair. His conflicts were probably bigger than any other person in NZ for that DHB. She claims it is all because she chatted to him at some cocktail function and was impressed by him.
News.com.au reports on claims the Transport Workers Union (TWU) extorted money from transport companies and used it to bolster Labor Party election campaigning:
The Nine Network’s Sunday program reported the TWU had been accused of extorting money from transport companies and double-crossing its own members.
It said the union had been accused of extracting funds from companies and funnelling the money into a slush fund used to help re-elect New South Wales Labor MPs. …
The NSW MPs allegedly involved included Paul McLeay, Noreen Hay, Ageing and Disability Minister Kristina Keneally and Di Beamer.
The MPs had reportedly declared the funds to the NSW Election Funding Authority as having come from the union, but the union had not.
Readers will also recall how the trade union movement spent $10 million “buying” the election. And if these allegations are correct, it wasn’t even their own money!
The Electoral Commission has released the full data from some research UMR did for them last year, including a section on online voting. It starts on page 43 of this pdf.
Pages and pages of interesting data. The 2010 local body elections provide a wonderful opportunity to trial online voting, and I hope necessary law and operational changes can be made so it can be used in a few areas.
Steve Pierson at The Standard proposes that MPs salary increases be linked to the median wage:
Every year the Remuneration Board, an independent body, reviews the pay of MPs. Whatever pay increase it recommends is always approved by Parliament unanimously and without debate, to keep the process from being politicised. Every year, our ever mature media gleefully portrays this process as politicians giving themselves a huge pay rise.
What if, instead, MPs pay increases were automatic and the same amount as the median income increase? The pay and annual increase methodology would be contained in legislation, so would not require annual approval. Any suggestion of impropriety would be eliminated and our journalists could get on with investigating real stories.
First of all a couple of minor corrections. It is the Remuneration Authority, not Board, and more importantly they do not recommend pay increases – they set salaries. Not only does Parliament not get to vote on them, they don’t even need an Order-in-Council.
I agree it would be good to avoid the annual outrage over MPs getting a payrise, which people think they have voted themselves. But linking to the median wage would over time have MPs salaries drift below the level they should be to attract suitable professionals. It would also provide an incentive for MPs to let inflation run rampant as wage increases of 15% and inflation of 15% hurts people on the median wage, but actually benefits people on higher incomes.
I do recall a Yes Prime Minister episode where Sir Humphrey gets a massive pay rise through Cabinet for the public service, by having MPs pay rises linked to public servants!
What I have long advocated is that MPs salaries and allowances should only be reviewed and set every three years, instead of annually. Inflation is low enough that this can be done.
What this would mean if no MP gets a pay increase during a term of Parliament. They keep the same salary for their term of office. So in 2008 the RA would set MP salaries for 2009 – 2011. And in 2011 for 2012 – 2014. They would only take effect for the new Parliament. So candidates can choose to stand knowing exactly what the salary will be, and voters will know the salary for the job they are electing people to.
Pablo, in the comments of The Standard, also endorses this and notes this is constitutional law in the US.
It would be a popular policy with the public, to have no pay increases for MPs during a parliamentary term, and it would save the MPs the annual bashing they get for something they don’t decide.
The Dom Post endorses National’s policy to freeze staffing levels in the non-operational areas of the public service.
National Leader John Key is right to target waste in the public service, and right to draw attention to the blossoming in numbers and wages that has taken place under Labour. The spend-up on mandarins has been large, the pay packets bloated and much of the work produced of, at best, dubious value, The Dominion Post writes.
However, it is also right to draw attention to his double standards, and to caution that he should use a scalpel, not an axe, in seeking savings.
The statistics highlighted by Mr Key underscore what has been apparent for some time: The Government, flush with cash from taxes that have been too high for too long, has spent that money with the insouciance that comes from having full pockets and an insufficient regard as to whether it is getting value for the spending.
Mr Key has been at pains to say that National will not be going to cut what he calls front-line staff – teachers, doctors, nurses, social work ers and so on. Instead those numbers on the front line will increase. But National will “pull hard on the handbrake” to stop any more growth in the bureaucracy.
That is a laudable goal, and one which deserves to gain public support.
The Dom Post also suggests less junkets for retiring MPs would equally save money!
The Parliamentary Library has just released their latest set of electorate profiles. These are invaluable documents for MPs, candidates and many others.
They are fully updated, being on the 2008 electoral boundaries, and using the latest 2006 census data.
There are many new features, including:
Each profile is around 20 pages, and it will have been a huge job for the Library to get them all done. One of the very very few things I miss about Parliament is the first class Library service.
One of the most useful aspects of all the data they have in the profiles, is they also give a rank for each statistic from 1 to 63. This means one can see some clear stuff, such as in Auckland Central:
It is stuff like that which allows you to really get to understand an electorate.
A couple of things to watch out for.
For those who love data, be warned – you can spend days with these profiles!
As NZ First rails against the evil Canadian pension fund, wanting to buy a minority stake in Auckland International Airport, it is useful to recall that the Airport has been in private ownership for around a decade – it is not Government owned.
And who sold it in July 1998? Well the Treasurer did. And who was the Treasurer? It was the Rt Hon Winston Peters. So let us enjoy some of his statements at the time:
“I’m pleased that high-profile New Zealanders like former All Black captain Sean Fitzpatrick are involved in promoting the float, which shows it is a float for the people.
“With the recent criticism of MMP in the past week, it is good to see such a positive event that would probably not have occurred under the old electoral system,” Mr Peters said.
and
Reports that phones were running hot with people seeking copies of the Auckland International Airport Investment Statement were pleasing, Treasurer Winston Peters said today.
“We have heard reports of some Post Offices running out of copies and of telephone operators being besieged by over 14,000 calls.
Several items re ACT.
Claire Trevett in the Herald talks to John Ansell:
He said right-wing parties internationally had difficulty portraying that they had “heart” – and his main job was to put heart into right-wing policies.
The strategy showed in a presentation he made to Act’s conference at the weekend, when he showed an ad depicting “the priorities of Labour.”
It said Labour could afford $25 million to save an endangered snail, but could not afford the same amount to fund Herceptin for women with breast cancer.
“We’ve got a default socialist country, but we are killing people with kindness.
“People think if you throw money at people, you’re caring for them. It’s not only incorrect, it’s immoral … ‘
I think people will be hearing more on the $25 million on snails instead of Herceptin.
Tracy Watkins says Sir Roger is being lined up for Cabinet. I think people should wait to see his list ranking before they get excited.
And finally Blair Mulholland gets so excited he wants to be ACT’s candidate in Mt Albert.
The Herald joins the campaign to ban cellphone use in cars. Never mind there are many more dangerous distractions when driving, this one is flavour of the month.
People have got excited that Vodafone and Telecom have said they support such a ban. This is not quite correct. They only want non-hands free use banned. This would not actually lead to a revenue drop for them, but a revenue gain as hundreds of thousands would have to buy a hands free kit.
And research has tended to show that cellphone use is almost equally distracting, whether or not it is hands free or not. So such a ban would be a claytons response.
The Herald says:
For the purposes of impact and clarity, there must be a ban. Education programmes go only so far.
But where is the evidence for this assertion. Has MOT ever run an education programme on cellphone use in cars? Would a rational response to the issue not be to first run an education programme, and only if it fails, then consider a ban?
So why not have a MOT road safety advertising campaign on the dangers of cellphone use (or even on wider distractions) in cars, and how to mitigate these. Points could be:
Justification for a ban often cites many other countries have done it. But has it had any effect? Are there stats showing a decline in accidents due to cellphone use? Or has it just resulted in thousands more tickets?
Euthanasia, like any issue to do with death, is a highly emotional issue. I used to be against it, but changed my mind after the death of Martin Hames in 2003.
The photo above is of Chantal Sebire who has appealed to French President Nicolas Sarkozy to allow her to die by euthanasia.
Sebire suffers from esthesioneuroblastoma, which attacks the nasal cavity. She has lived without a sense of smell and taste since 2000 and now the tumour has evolved and eaten into her jaws, and then eye sockets, leaving her blind since last year.
She suffers from “atrocious bouts of pain that can last up to four hours at a time”.
The Herald reports that the PSA has applied to register as a third party. Now they are not affiliated to a political party, so I can’t imagine there will be any issue about their eligibility.
What is interesting though, is why they are registering at all. The PSA goes to great lengths to claim political neutrality.
Ms Pilott said the union had understood that if it wanted to campaign on ideas, it had to register in order not to break the law.
“It is already the case in fact that public services and the extent to which they are going to be funded or the value of them is already an election issue so I think it vindicates our decision.” …
“But our understanding is that if we want to participate in the election campaign in pursuit of particular ideas out there, then we are required to register.”
So they wish to remain politically neutral, but they need to register in case their promotion of their ideas breach the Act. Annette King’s law of common sense doesn’t seem to be working that well.
I’m passionately in favour of a free trade agreement with China. But I’m even more passionately in favour of free speech and the right to protest. Now let us look at the different responses from Australia and NZ:
“We urge the Chinese Government to allow peaceful expression of dissent. We call on Chinese authorities to act with restraint and to deal with protesters peacefully.”
– Australian Foreign Minister Stephen Smith“The Government is concerned at the reports of violence and is trying to obtain more accurate information. It calls on all sides to exercise restraint.”
– Prime Minister Helen Clark
Yeah those damn protesters need to be more restrained as they get shot.
Photo from Al Jazeera.
It would be good to have the NZ Government also stress the right to peaceful protest.