Electoral Finance Amendment Act Details

Bill English has released his proposed amendment to the Electoral Finance Act. Both Labour and the Green parties have been breaching their own law by using their head office address rather than their financial agent’s home address.

I suspect all parties will support it, as I doubt any of them really want the home address of their financial agent displayed on every billboard, pamphlet and poster in the country.

Earliest Easter for 100 years

According to National Review, Easter will not be this early again until 2160. It can in theory be one day earlier than it is this year, but will not be until 2285, and last was in 1818.

Incidentially Easter is observed on the Sunday after the first full moon on or after the day of the vernal equinox which is normally 21 March.

National Review says the formula to work out the date for Easter is:

((19*t+u-w-(u-(u+8)\25)+1)\3)+15)mod30)+(32+2*x+2*y-(19*t+u-w- (u-(u+8)\25)+1)\3)+15)mod30)-z)mod7)-7*(t+11*(19*t+u-w(u- (u+8)\25)+1)\3)+15)mod30)+22*(32+2*x+2*y-(19*t+u-w-(u- (u+8)\25)+1)\3)+15)mod30)-g)mod7)+114)\31

Looks Greek to me. I prefer the Meeus/Jones/Butcher Gregorian algorithm:

  1. a = Y mod 19
  2. b = Y/100
  3. c = Y mod 100
  4. d = b/4
  5. e = b mod 4
  6. f = (b + 8) / 25
  7. g = (b – f + 1) / 3
  8. h = (19 × a + b – d – g + 15) mod 30
  9. i = c / 4
  10. k = c mod 4
  11. l = (32 + 2 × e + 2 × i – h – k) mod 7
  12. m = (a + 11 × h + 22 × L) / 451
  13. month = (h + L – 7 × m + 114) / 31
  14. day = ((h + L – 7 × m + 114) mod 31) + 1

Simple really. So let us try it for 2008 (you use integers only by truncating)

  1. a = 2008 mod 19 = 13
  2. b = 2008/100 = 20
  3. c = 2008 mod 100 = 8
  4. d = 20/4 = 5
  5. e = 20 mod 4 = 0
  6. f = (20 + 8 )/ 25 = 28/25 = 1
  7. g = (20 – 1 + 1) / 3 = 20/3 = 6
  8. h = (19 × 13 + 20 – 5 – 6 + 15) mod 30 = 271 mod 30 = 1
  9. i = 8 /4 = 2
  10. k = 8 mod 4 = 0
  11. l = (32 + 2 × 0 + 2 × 2 – 1 – 0) mod 7 = 35 mod 7 = 0
  12. m = (13 + 11 × 1 + 22 × 0) / 451 = 46/451 = 0
  13. month = (1 + 0 – 7 × 0 + 114) /31 = 115/31 = 3
  14. day = ((1 + 0 – 7 × 0 + 114) mod 31) + 1 = 22 +1 = 23

So in 2008 Easter Sunday is the 23rd day of the third month.

I’ve even been bored enough that I have set up a spreadsheet in Excel with the formula so I can now instantly calculate Easter for any year!

Obama vs the Internet

Before the Internet, Obama would have easily escaped the issue of his links to Rev Wright. No voter would have seen Wrights’s insanities and hate, and Obama’s ever changing lines would not be heavily scrutinised by the media who love him. And neither Clinton nor McCain could or would go near the issue.

But just as You Tube got the original videos seen, so we also see the first real attack video on Obama, and it is pretty effective. It make Obama look, well like an ordinary politician, and once he is reduced to that level, more focus comes onto his actual beliefs and policies.

The video isn’t done by any formal campaign, just by one of many of thousands of politically active people who have access to video editing technology. Now I am not saying the video is fair (it isn’t) but it is a reality that power has partly transferred from the formal campiagns to a wider array of activists. McCain has in fact sacked a staffer who merely forwarded on a link to the video.

Is it hurting Obama? Well look at the Gallup poll:

gallup1.JPG

Plus the National polls are showing McCain ahead of Obama. And more critically in the big swing states of Florida, Ohio and Pennsylvania McCain has an average lead of 11%, 7% and 2%. Now months to go and this will change but I am hearing the Republicans would now rather have Obama than Clinton as their opponent.

Susan Estrich has a useful column on this:

What the critics are saying, sometimes out loud but also in quiet whispers, is that they don’t understand how a man who gives speeches about moving past the racial divide would choose a racist minister to be a member of his family, about why, with all the churches in Chicago, Obama not only picked this one but remained true to it, about how he could not have known what others knew, could not have heard what others did.

The critics will tell you that blaming white America for spreading AIDS to blacks is not the same as an elderly white woman admitting that she is afraid of black men, and that there is a difference between standing by the grandmother who raised you and standing by a religious leader who preaches hate.

Personally I liked Obama’s speech on race, but I think the growing issue for him is his evasions. He at first claimed he had never heard Wright say the controversial stuff, and then it emerged he had. As with many scandals, it is how you react to them, rather than the original scandal, which proves lethal. Ask Bill Clinton.

The latest New York resignation

Media access tightened in Parliament

I think the Speaker has over reacted by banning media access to the ground floor of Parliament House where the select committees meet. Following Brian Connell to outside the toilet was probably unwise by TVNZ, but the media should have access to MPs when they are going into and out of the House and Select Committees.

While it is not a co-ordinated programme, the cumulative effect of growing media restrictions is a cause for concern. Steven Price blogged last week on a public forum (I was going to attend but got too busy) by the Chairs of the NZ and Australian Press Councils and a member fo the NZ Law Commission. The comments below come from retired High Court Judge Barry Paterson who chairs the NZ Press Council:

He is worried that statutes and regulations may be chipping away at freedom of expression. Examples: restrictions on reporting about suicide in the Coroners Act; the proposal to restrict access to births, deaths and marriages registers; the restrictions on policitcal speech in the Electoral Finance Act (he was surprised that the Crown Law Office vet deferred to the government’s political judgment, and that this “margin of appreciation” could tip a finely balanced freedom of expression issue in favour of allowing encroachment); the possibility of wide codes, and later regulations, aimed at non-communicable diseases, affecting the advertising, sponsorship and marketing of particular goods under the Public Health Bill; and the proposal to amalgamate regulation of various media platforms.

On numerous fronts, the right to know and the right to free speech get encroached.

Closing Businesses

I can’t be bothered doing the normal debate on the stupidity of laws which prevent willing employees from earning extra money on Good Friday or Easter Sunday. Those who believe it is their job to “force” people not to work will never be persaded I accept. They probably opposed Saturday shopping also.

But what I do want to touch on is this reported statement by Green MP Sue Bradford:

Meanwhile, Green Party industrial relations spokeswoman Sue Bradford said last week the party would like to see the Department of Labour given the power to close businesses for the day if they broke the law, rather than the current $1000 fine.

She wants the state to have the power to close businesses for the day, rather than just fine them.  Okay – how would this work when the Greens obtain power.

Will staff be arrested by Police if they refuse to stop serving customers? Will customers be tear gassed if they don’t stop buying goods at a store Sue has ordered closed? Or will Department of Labour inspectors just put up barbed wire fences around offending businesses?

Electoral Finance Act to be amended

Leave has just been granted by all parties in Parliament for Bill English to introduce a bill next members’ day to amend the Electoral Finance Act.

This will be around the issue I have highlighted requiring home addresses of party financial agents on advertising material.

Anderton annoyed at ACT on Campus

Heh heh. NZPA reports:

Wellington, March 20 NZPA – Moves by young ACT supporters to boost membership by selling cut-price party pills are “grossly irresponsible”, Associate Health Minister Jim Anderton says.

The group ACT on Campus sold the pills last month for $1 each to Auckland University students who joined their organisation.

Party pills will be illegal from April 1, after legislation classifying them as a class C1 drug was passed this month. ACT, the Green and Maori parties voted against the legislation.

But ACT on Campus Auckland president Ben Smith said the pills were still legal and there was nothing wrong with the successful promotion, which had signed up 500 people.

But Mr Anderton, who is the minister in charge of the Government’s drugs policy, told NZPA the promotion was grossly irresponsible and ACT needed to rein in its youth wing.

Very innovative thinking by ACT on Campus.

Fallow on Housing affordability

Brian Fallow says the following facts are sobering. They are indeed:

It uses data from Statistics New Zealand’s survey of family income and employment (affectionately known as Sofie) to estimate what proportion of couples and single people who rent could afford to buy.

To buy, that is, a house from among the cheapest 25 per cent available in their region while keeping their mortgage payments at no more than 30 per cent of their gross income.

They reckon that in 2000, 59 per cent of renting couples and 11 per cent of single people could have afforded a lowest quartile priced house.

By 2006, however, that had dropped to 29 per cent of couples and only 2 per cent of single renters.

It gets worse if you exclude those who could have afforded (based on their net worth) a 20 per cent deposit but who for whatever reason had decided not to.

Among the rest, the proportion of couples who could afford to buy dropped from 40 to 12 per cent since 2000.

“At current prices and interest rates, the gap between the income of those who cannot afford to buy a lower-quartile-priced house and the income needed to service a mortgage on such a house while keeping the payments at or below 30 per cent is large,” the report says.

“On average to bridge the gap, a couple would need a deposit of $122,000 and non-partnered individuals would need a deposit of around $177,000.”

For many people, the officials drily note, this would pose a considerable hurdle.

I am so glad I got in just in time in 2001, and purchased.

Yates retires

What sort of roof does the PM have?

The Herald reports on how the PM said:

A transcript of the interview shows she suggested plans by National would require big cuts to the public service and would see “your mortgage rate going through the roof because the system couldn’t stand it”.

The presenter responded: “It’s going through the roof with your lot.”

But the Prime Minister dismissed that: “Well no, no, it’s not going through the roof.”

Well first we have her economic illiteracy that a lower level of public spending would increase interest rates.

But the comical part is her insistence that interest rate are not high, or through the roof.

Floating mortgage rates are now at 10.70% and fixed terms vary from 9.30 to 9.95% at National Bank. The floating rate as recorded by the Reserve Bank has been at over 10% for 11 months.

In November 1999 floating mortgage rates were 6.69%.

The OECD has NZ with the highest interest rates in the developed world. Here’s just some of the latest data for countries.

  1. Japan 0.75%
  2. US 3.84%
  3. Canada 3.88%
  4. Europe 4.36%
  5. UK 5.61%
  6. Australia 7.18%
  7. NZ 8.82%

So how the hell the PM thinks she has any credibility warning against high interest rates, I don’t know.

The PM may not regard interest rates of close to 11% as going through the roof, but they are high enough to stop most people from being able to afford a roof.

Too good to resist

The Electoral Finance Act strikes again

I blogged last Friday on how the Electoral Finance Act’s extension of the regulated period to all of 2008, was causing huge problems in Parliament. MPs face the possibility of multiple electoral petitions after the election seeking court rulings on whether their taxpayer funded spending counts as an election expense or not.

I understand from the last electoral petition, that defending one costs somewhere between $100,000 to $200,000. Labour is going to have to get a mighty big loan from Owen Glenn to help them cover the costs of potentially up to 20 electoral petitions, unless they adopt an incredibly conservative approach to their parliamentary spending.

The Herald reports that taxpayer funded publications will also now be able to carry party political authorisation statements from party financial agents. So they will have a parliamentary crest on them which is meant to represent the fact the publication is not electioneering and taxpayer funded, but also have a party financial agent authorisation on them which is meant to represent they are electioneering.

Electoral Commission chief executive Helena Catt fuelled the caution of political parties, saying she would not exempt material as being advertising simply because it had a parliamentary crest.

What really surprised MPs was that she said if it was advertising, it should also be counted against a party or candidate as an election expense. MPs passing the law late last year believed the act gave their parliamentary material an exemption on the expenses ledger if it was produced in their capacity as an MP.

But Dr Catt said Parliament gave the commission virtually no guidance as to what that term meant and the commission was working towards producing its own guidance.

This should not be a huge surprise. Dr Catt went to the trouble of publicly warning last year that the Act was unclear with regards to the parliamentary exemption. She even went on radio to discuss it.

Now what happened after that is Annette King as Justice Minister came up with a definiton, which seemed to satisfy the Electoral Commission. But after beign squashed by the ninth floor (as Annette’s definition would have ruled out material such as Labour’s pledge card) she humiliated herself by publicly recanting on her definition and repeatedly declaring to Parliament that she was wrong.   So the poor Electoral Commission have ended up having to work out their own definition.

And I suspect it is almost inevitable that those definitions will be tested in court.

This is a timely reminder to people that if you receive at home or work any material at all with the parliamentary crest on it, submit it to the You Paid For It website. Submitting it to the website doesn’t mean that one is alleging the publication should not have been funded by Parliament and it doesn’t necessarily mean the publication should be included as an election advertisement and/or expense. But it will preserve a copy which can be scrutinised by legal experts for possible use in electoral petitions or prosecutions. It also provides transparency over what has been approved by The Parliamentary Service.

Peters will negotiate with largest party

Tim Donoghue reports in the Dom Post that Winston Peters has confirmed that NZ First will negotiate post-election with the largest party. Of course that depends on whether they make it back.

Now this does not mean that they will automatically support the largest party.  It means they will give them first preference to negotiate an acceptable deal. It won’t be like in 1996 when parallel negotiations occurred with both major parties.

It is interesting that Peters is signalling that the balance of power will be a choice between him and the Maori Party.  That’s quite a smart tactic which may appeal to his core support.

With friends like Dr Cullen, who needs enemies?

NZPA reports how Michael Cullen almost reduced Keith Locke to tears in Parliament yesterday.

It is worth noting that the Greens are Labour’s closest allies in Parliament in policy terms. They have helped keep Labour in office for almost nine years now, and were dumped from consideration for Ministerial roles this time in favour of Peters and Dunne. And amazingly Keith Locke refers to Michael Cullen as having been a family friend.

Without wanting to trivialise domestic violence, it seems to me the Greens sometimes exhibit the symptoms of battered wife syndrome.  They just keep staying faithful, no matter how bad the behaviour.

Rotorua Selection

National also selected its Rotorua candidate last night.  Rotorua is marginally a National majority on the new boundaries, so it was vigorously contested by five candidates.

The evening stretched out to the maximum four ballots, and Todd McClay won in the final round against Don Hammond.

Todd has had a fascinating career including many years as the Cook Islands Ambassador to the European Union. He is very respected for his advocacy work on behalf of many Pacific states. He also has a strong business background.

His father, Roger McClay, is a former MP for Taupo. Roger was (and is) a hugely likeable guy who said in his valedictory speech he was probably leaving without an enemy in Parliament – a rare feat. He later served as Children’s Commissioner.

As I have said previously Steve Chadwick will be no pushover, but I think Todd has a fine parliamentary career ahead of him.

Talking of selection meetings, there was a really good question asked at another candidates meeting I attended this week (not Wellington Central).  The candidates were asked “What question do you not want to be asked, and what would be your answer to it”.

That was a very cunning question.  I’m not sure what question I would least like to be asked if I ever sought a candidacy. Probably something about why I was one found underneath a hedge in Dunedin pretending to be a hedgehog!

More on Air New Zealand pay rates

The Herald has a story reporting Air New Zealand’s response to the story on pay rates for Shanghai based staff on Air New Zealand flights. The Herald also rebuts some of the responses, and provides further information such as the fact one of the Chinese air stewardesses put on the Chinese rates is in fact a NZ resident.

They keep saying they are subcontracted through Fasco, but I have been sent a copy of a pay slip, and it certainly looks like they are paid directly.

payslip_may_2007.JPG

The pay rate per hour seems to work out to Y25 which is NZ$4.41.

Groser to attend FTA signing

Praising Judy Turner twice in a week!

The Herald reports on a bill by United Future’s Judy Turner that will allow DNA testing of children for paternity tests. At present a parent can block such a test for a child under 16.

The Government doesn’t seem that keen on it, but the Law Commission backed such a move in 2005.

I would make the point that a court ordered DNA test should only be ordered, if agreement can not be obtained.  It is a last resort, not a first resort.  But it is important that they can be ordered when paternity is in doubt.

Wellington Central Results

Classy

Wellington Central

NZPA through Stuff report that Sue Kedgley will again be the Green Party candidate for Wellington Central.

WC is the highest party vote in NZ for The Greens. I thought they might stand Russel Norman there this time as he is a co-leader, and would attract even more attention.

National makes it selection tonight. I’ll blog it when known. I think it will be very close.

Arthur C Clarke is dead

Judy Turner on Tibet

Never thought I would be approvingly quoting from a Judy Turner speech, but hers was the highlight regarding China and Tibet. Turner is the second United Future MP. Some extracts:

However, it is sadly obvious that the Labour Government has bigger fish to fry than to uphold an oppressed people’s political freedoms and fundamental human rights. Worst still, it appears to the world New Zealand’s timid response has simply been bought by Chinese Yuan.

Ouch – and remember this is from a party which supports the Government.

The first response of the Government was to stall, saying more information is needed. Hopefully it will blow over, they are thinking – maybe if the People’s Liberation Army can crush the dissension quickly enough we might be able to sneak over to Beijing, sign on the dotted line and still gain the plaudits for being the first country to sign a bilateral free trade agreement with China.

The initial response was pretty appalling. To be fair the Government’s later position was much better as they talked about the right to peaceful protest.

As a proud New Zealander the very least I would expect is for the Prime Minister to summon the Chinese Ambassador and in no uncertain terms express our nation’s disappointment and disapproval. Or are we so subservient in this relationship that we cannot even do that?

Maybe we just emailed them a press release!

UnitedFuture leader Hon Peter Dunne hosted the Dalai Lama last year, an honour made strange by the fact that the Prime Minister refused to meet with the Tibetan leader. At the time, not a lot was really made of this.

Maybe now we are truly seeing which side of the fence this Labour Government sits on.

Again, this is from a Government ally whose Leader is a Minister.

I don’t go as far as the Greens in calling for there to be no FTA with China, because of what has happened.  Let’s be honest – the Greens are against an FTA with anyone – this is just an excuse to oppose the FTA.  But by that I don’t mean they are not sincere on the Tibet issue – they have a long and good record on that issue.

We should complete the FTA. But we shouldn’t let the desire for an FTA mean that we self-censor ourselves on fundamental issues such as the right to peaceful protest. Now again this doesn’t mean we get up and call the Chinese Government a bunch of bloody killers – rhetoric like that doesn’t tends to be counter-productive.  But we should communicate our views directly to the Chinese Government, and have public statements that clearly support the right of peaceful protest, and condemn the use of force to stop such protests.

China claims that the violence was caused by the protesters.  Well that is possible but the trouble is that there is no way to verify this, because of the media restrictions. If they allowed free movement of media, then one could judge independently what has happened.  Without that media freedom, it is dangerous to assume the Chinese Government is telling the truth.

UPDATE: John Armstrong also likes Turner’s speech.

King on Lind rumours

There is a somewhat bizarre story in the Dominion Post about Annette King allegedly writing a letter to a HB DHB employee regarding rumours her husband was having an affair.

I’m only covering this because it is in the media. A couple of people have made comments in the past on this blog alleging such an affair.  I immediately deleted them, and will do so to any comment on this thread which makes accusations of that nature. I don’t really care if it is true or not and don’t see it as relevant.

What I find bizarre is if a warning letter was written to Jacqueline Parisi, because according to the story she is the one who alerted Ray Lind to the rumours. Now normally one would be grateful if someone informs you of rumours you are having an affair.  So, why would you write a letter to that person? Let alone send it to the CEO to give to the employee.

And if you are Minister of Health at the time, it appears unwise to write to a DHB CEO on a personal issue, asking him to deliver a personal letter to an employee.
I know a couple of high profile people who have had to put up with malicious gossip allegaing affairs with a particular person, and their response is to have their lawyer write a letter to the person spreading the rumour – instead of them personally writing. That is the safer course of action. Or of course not to put anything in writing at all is an option.

By having written a letter while Minister of Health to a DHB CEO and employee, King has given the media the excuse to write about the issue.   The media never need much of an excuse to cover an issue like that – the Brash alleged affair went public based on a report of a discussion at a private Caucus meeting.

Like with Don Brash and Je-Lan, Annette King and Ray Lind have my sympathies for their private life becoming a media issue.  Despite my policy differences with her, I have always regarded Annette King in a positive light, and she was a very likeable opponent in 1996 when I was part of the National campaign team in Rongotai.

But the letter (if it exists – it seems even that is disputed) seems unwise. As I said, it gives the media an excuse to write stories about it.  I do have to say that personally I fail to see the relevance – I can’t see how any of this is relevant to the issues around the Board and conflicts of interest in contracts.