Murray’s new project

Expiring Demerits

Generally I have been pretty happy with how the demerits scheme has worked.  Ultimately everyone comments here at my pleasure, but the scheme has given some transparency around what sort of comments I regard as unacceptable. It also generally seems to work in providing an incentive for people to be less trollish once they have some demerits.

Not that I wish it to be an expect replica of the traffic demerits scheme, but I do wonder whether I should allow demerits to disappear after a period of time, so that someone doesn’t end up suspended one day for say five comments spread over four years which attracted demerits.

There seem to me to be two ways I could let demerits expire.  They are:

  1. x months after a demerit was given, it expires
  2. y months after the last demerit was given, all current demerits expire

My thinking is along the lines of x=12 if I implement (1) and probably y=6 if I implement (2). Feedback on these are welcome. I note most people who end up suspended do so for comments over one to two months.

Another issue is whether I should should ever reset people’s suspension histories, say after an election. So if someone had been suspended for two months prior to an election, and then after the election they were suspended again, it would be back to just one week instead of four months. In theory as I plan to keep this blog going for many years, some people could end up with year long bans etc. On the other hand I don’t see much merit in helping recidivist offenders 🙂

Auckland vs Wellington arts funding

Saturday’s Herald had two articles on the issue of arts funding for Auckland vs Wellington. I have some comments on comments in the articles:

The Auckland War Memorial Museum, he says, receives virtually no operational funding, while its capital counterpart, Te Papa, scores millions a year from the Government.

Aucklanders are asked to pay to visit their museum; Te Papa is free.

First of all, both have the same charging policy – free admission but donations encouraged.

Secondly one needs to ask how come Te Papa gets two to three times as many visitors as the Auckland War Memorial Museum, despite a population base one quarter of Auckland’s.

Wellington gets many of the national cultural facilities because we support them so strongly.  Now to be fair to Aucklanders, they are not all cultural philistines. The spread out nature of Auckland means that any facility is harder to get to for most residents than a facility in Wellington. Wellington CBD is just so trivially easy to get into, that it is easier to use the local facilities.

Auckland’s Philharmonia Orchestra often finds itself playing second fiddle to the Wellington-based New Zealand Symphony Orchestra, says APO board chairwoman Rosanne Meo. APO figures show it earns $2.56 million a year in government funding – barely a fifth of the NZSO’s $12.34 million.

The NZSO visits Auckland about six times yearly, playing about 12 concerts. The APO plays about 40 mainstage concerts a year in Auckland, she says.

Now reading this you might think those greedy Wellingtonians get to have the taxpayer pay for around 40 concerts a year in Wellington.  But as the NZSO tells us:

All its main symphonic programmes are presented in Auckland and Wellington, and as well as this, the orchestra visits some 30 New Zealand towns and cities annually.

Wellington get 12 main concerts – just the same as in Auckland. And 30 towns and cities get to hear the NZSO. Hence that is why it gets national funding. It is not a Wellington orchestra.

Auckland City Council arts, culture and recreation chairman Greg Moyle said Auckland is “desperately short of theatres. It seems only fair that some funding should come out of the central pot to help fund these sorts of infrastructure facilities that we would expect to find in a world-class city like Auckland.”

I would have thought that was something for Aucklanders to fund. As far as I know Bats Theatre, Circa Theatre, St James Downstage etc are all funded by sponsors, local Councils and lottery money.

Auckland City Mayor John Banks said there was “much inequity” between Wellington and Auckland.

It was unfair that Auckland City ratepayers alone funded Auckland’s art culture and the Regional Amenities Bill would hopefully fix that.

I agree that it has been unfair Auckland City rather than Auckland Region has had to fund many regional amenities.

As I said above, the geographic nature of Wellington means cultural amenities get far more visitors.  Stick Te Papa in Auckland and I predict it would get less visitors than in Wellington, despite four times as large a population and most international visitors.

Nick Smith’s financial battles

The SST reports on how an American multinational timber company, Osmose,  is suing Nick Smith and a local scientist for $15 million each. Nick has already had $300,000 in legal costs and it is likely his bills will reach $500,000.  It is worth remembering this is costs to be met from after tax income. On an MPs salary, take home pay is only around $71,000 a year, so the cost is more than the entire take home pay for seven years.

The company of course has the right to take legal action if it thinks comments made were defamatory and hurt their business.  They have to prove actual lost income to succeed (so I understand). But if as reported, the company is refusing any offer to settle, you wonder if the motivation is to destroy Nick and Dr Wakeling rather than have the record set straight and receive compensation.

Nick has been sued before – ironically for the first time by the Exclusive Brethren. But all the other cases have been won or settled.

Telecom to set up ISP for business customers

This looks to be a smart move by Telecom – a dedicated ISP for business customers. Business needs are different to home user needs, and the Xtra brand is more focused in the consumer retail market.

The key deciders will be their pricing plans and their service levels, but it is a good idea in terms of meeting customer needs.

No sympathy from the Minister

Housing Minister Marian Street is quoted in the Dom Post:

But Ms Street despairs at some of the “hard luck” stories.

The latest target of her ire is a weekend newspaper article about a young professional couple who turned up their noses at $400,000 do-ups in Grey Lynn and starter houses in “dodgy” outer suburbs. They were distressed when they found a two-bedroom townhouse in Herne Bay, one of Auckland’s most exclusive suburbs, was on the market at $900,000. …

“I’m really sick of reading stories about nice young couples who have got hugely high earning potential stretching out in front of them complaining about how awful the housing market is because they can’t get a house in Herne Bay.”

The couple in last Sunday’s article had dismissed $400,000 do-ups in Grey Lynn because they said they couldn’t afford to renovate – an argument that holds little truck with Ms Street.

So what are the details of this rich prick couple in the weekend media? Looks like a reference to this SST article:

Van der Stoep, a Sunday Star-Times journalist, and her partner, a fifth-year medical student, rent a one-bedroom apartment in Herne Bay, but are desperate for more space and a small garden they can call their own.

They won’t be in a position to buy until next year but they have already begun scouting the market to find a house at $385,000, the limit of what they can afford by spending 48% of their income a level which experts say causes “mortgage stress”.

Van der Stoep says the couple, who will have a combined income next year of about $76,000, have discussed pushing their budget up to $400,000 but even at $385,000 their finances will be stretched so they are reluctant to take on any more debt. They hope to save a 10% deposit.

“It actually makes a massive difference to your weekly payments. You don’t want to go at the end of the week `Oh my God, how am I going to afford the groceries?”‘

Van der Stoep says they looked at a small two-bedroom townhouse in Herne Bay which they thought might be within their reach only to discover it had a $900,000 pricetag.

So a couple earning $76,000 are now rich pricks. How dare they complain about spending 50% of their income on mortgage payments.

I don’t read the SST article as them complaining they can’t live in Herne Bay. It is complaining that even a modest house in a modest area is almost unaffordable for them.

And I am not sure about their “hugely high  earning potential”. A 5th year medical student may be a long way off “high earning” and medicine doesn’t pay anywhere as well as it used to.  Hell policy analysts earn more than some doctors. Likewise journalism isn’t known for its riches either.

Roger Douglas on his proposals

Roger Douglas defends his proposals in the NZ Herald and rejects the “hard right” label.

Now most people know my personal economic views. If I was designing a country from scratch, I would adopt many of Sir Roger’s policies. But that is not the same as putting forward a policy platform which reflects NZ today, yet moves in the right direction.

What is interesting is that Sir Roger mentions his proposals on health and education and taxation, but doesn’t cover the aspect which I suspect most set off glee in the Beehive – namely to cut current spending by $3 to $5 billion. That is what made his proscription somewhat toxic to many. The fact he does not repeat this in his article, suggests to me he knows it.

It is one thing to say we will not increase spending as fast as Labour (which does reduce it as a % of GDP).  But it is quite another to start talking about a 10% reduction in current spending.  NZers will equate that with a huge cut in education, health and other public services.

The proposal to tax exempt the 1st $20K of income is a desirable end goal, to minimise the deadweight cost of tax churning.  But suggesting one can end up there in just a few years is not credible. Peter Costello and now Kevin Rudd are heading towards that goal, but only by having a small reduction every year consistently year after year – not a big bang solution. It will take Australia 15 years of tax cutting to get to that situation.
In fact one thing which I have wondered,  is how much less revenue would occur under the proposed tax policy.  Let’s take them one by one:

  1. Reduce top tax rate to 33c = $900 million according to Treasury budget documents
  2. No tax on 1st $20K of income. This is a bit harder to work out as you need to go to the tax tables showing income in each band.  I calculate there is $26.2 billion at the 15% rate which is $3.9 billion and $22.6 billion between $9,500 and $20,000 which at 21% is $4.7 billion.  That is a total of $8.7 billion.  However Treasury advise to offset this by 17.31% to allow for extra GST etc so net change is $7.2 billion
  3. Adjusting tax brackets to 1999 levels takes a bit of calculation also.  The CPI increased 24% since Dec 1999. But we have already got rid of the bottom rate and the top rate. Hence the only threshold we need to adjust is the 21c/33c threshold at $38,000. It would move to $47,000 with CPI adjustment ad would cost $1.1 billion

So the total annual revenue reduction would be $9.2 billion.

Is there a problem?

Like many, I have absolutely no problem with the proposition that employees working a full eight hours should have a meal break and a couple of (paid) rest breaks.  And the same goes for allowing breastfeeding at work.

What I am not sure about is whether there is enough of a problem, that legislation is needed, as announced by the Government.

I can’t recall an employment contract for FT staff which does not include meal breaks and rest breaks. Whether employees take them is another matter. At Wellington Newspapers the “tea lady” literally would come around and everyone would have a break. At Red Cross we actually gathered in the staff room and our ten minute breaks sometimes stretched on to half an hour as the conversation was always so good.

At Parliament though, there was no communal tea breaks, and even the meal breaks would often end up as 10 minutes at your desk with sandwiches as you continued to work.  However that was by choice, and generally you were treated as an adult to manage your own time so if one disappeared for a two hour lunch or a 45 minute coffee at Astoria, no one complained so long as you got the job done.

I’d be interested in knowing how many complaints have employment authorities had over an employer not allowing meal or tea breaks? Also is there any case law so to speak from employment tribunals that such breaks must be provided even if not in an employment contract?

Like I said, I have no problem with making it explicit in law, but is this a problem that needs solving?

As for breast feeding at work, I ask the same question? Has there ever been a complaint filed with an employment authority that an employer told an employee she can’t take a few minutes off to express, or to feed their babies if they are brought into work?

The employers I know tend to be like most people in society, and go ga-ga when someone has their babies in at work, and they’ll happily queue up for the right to hold the baby, and talk baby talk to it.

So again I just ask is there a problem which needs solving.  Certainly not all employers are good employers, but has there been reported problems in this area?

The one area I have some concern over the announced requirement to set aside breastfeeding facilities. Big corporates will have no problems doing this, and probably already are. But what about the dairy owner or the small business owner with just four staff. The cost of putting in place a facility that may never be used could be considerable. Will all 100,000+ employers in NZ be audited over the adequacy of their breast feeding facilities by a new inspection unit?

The proposed law should certainly be sent through to select committee for scrutiny. But it would be worth MPs asking for proof of the extent of the problem that this law is “solving”, and most of all with regard to the breast feeding facilities, a caution that a legislated requirement doesn’t end up with costs well in excess of any benefits.

I have a suspicion that if there was a widespread problem with employees not getting meal breaks and being banned from breast feeding, we would have seen action before Labour’s ninth year of office, hence this may be about a sound good solution looking for a problem. Having said that, that doesn’t mean the legislation is necessarily without merit.

Councils reject Government housing affordability bill

Every Council that has submitted on the Government’s Affordable Housing bill is against it, and Local Government NZ has said it does not know of a single Council who would use it, if passed.

Here are some quotes:

Auckland said the bill would require it to analyse who qualified as needing an affordable home.

“This bill requires [councils] to take an interventionist role in social policy and the domestic arrangements of residents that Auckland City Council does not consider appropriate for local government.”

Indeed.  It means big rates rises for everyone, including oh yeah home owners.

Manukau City’s submission called for the bill to be withdrawn, saying it left councils and ratepayers effectively subsidising cheaper houses.

This is all the Government seems to know sometimes. Instead of focusing on fundamentals such as how to improve the overall wealth of NZ, their instinctive response to every issue is merely for rich pricks to subsidise everyone else.

We’ll see this later this year when all taxpayers will be asked to have more of their tax dollars go towards extending paid parental leave.  That won’t stop people fleeing to Australia.

The North Shore City Council said it would need two years and up to $250,000 to establish a policy on implementing the changes.

The bill’s provisions would push up the overall cost of housing, leaving “middle-income New Zealanders” paying more for their homes.

Yep affordable housing for Labour means having “rich pricks” or as NSCC calls them “middle-income NZers” paying more for their housing.

The Hive on Tibet

The Hive has some advice for China.  And it is pretty good advice. Queen Bee is not a huge fan it seems of the Dalai Lama and the former feudal Tibet, but the Chinese response is so over the top, it damages them greatly. So the Hive suggests:

  • fire the Editor of The People’s Daily;
  • fire who ever it was who led the response on the ground to the demonstrations in Tibet;
  • make all those arrested and who were guilty of property damage do some community service to make amends;
  • release those who protested but did not damage property;
  • don’t execute anyone, but feel free to otherwise throw the book at anyone guilty of physical assault;
  • ask the Dalai Lama to show a bit more restraint and offer to send an envoy to meet him in a neutral location to ensure his concerns are discussed;
  • allow tourists to return to Tibet immediately;
  • ask your Embassies and Consulates abroad to write Op Eds to all local newspapers reminding people what life in feudal Tibet was like (particularly for the slaves) before Deng Xiaoping moved in from Sichuan to liberate Tibet;
  • invite any Foreign Minister who wants to, to visit Tibet this year;
  • allow the foreign media (not just Hong Kong media) immediate access to Tibet.

Not bad advice.

Will rejoins ACT

Thoughts on the abortion debate

I was impressed that we have a semi-sane debate on abortion law a week ago.

A few other bloggers contributed to the debate also. One which I found very moving was a female blogger talking first hand about an abortion she had, and the immense physical and emotional trauma it was. It nicely brought the debate down to a personal level.

I also thought Matt Flannagan’s post is worth a wider readership. Now I disagree with Matt (his post is specifically rebutting me) but he makes an argument for his view point and as his PhD was on the “ethics of killing a fetus”, he has spent a lot of time on this issue.

Anyway no comments on this post. I just thought I would mention the contributions on the other blogs. I don’t intend to generate another debate.

Ma elected President of Taiwan

The KMT have won the presidential election in Taiwan, and Ma Ying-jeou is now the President-Elect of Taiwan. He takes office on 20 May 2008.

It was a crushing victory, with a 17% margin for Ma over the the DPP candidate. I met Ma last July and he is an extremely charismatic politician. I am not surprised he won.

Politics in Taiwan is passionate and people really love or hate one of the parties.  KMT allege the DPP won last time with a fake assassiniation attempt, and DPP supporters have a long list of grievances against the KMT going all the way back to invading Taiwan.

Generally the KMT supports a more conciliatory relationship with the PRC and I imagine tensions in that part of the world should be somewhat reduced:

Ma based his campaign on promises to reverse the pro-independence direction of outgoing President Chen Shui-bian and leverage China’s white-hot economic boom to re-energize Taiwan’s ailing high-tech economy.

He has proposed a formal peace treaty with Beijing that would demilitarize the Taiwan Strait, the 160-kilometer-wide (100-mile-wide) waterway that separates the two heavily armed sides. But he has drawn the line at unification, promising it would not be discussed during his presidency.

Economically, he wants to lower barriers to Taiwanese investment on the mainland — it already amounts to more than US$100 billion (euro65 billion) — and to begin direct air and maritime links between the sides.

The referenda to apply for UN entry also failed as less than six million (36% of eleigible voters) voted in them, under the level required by law. By comparison 13 million voted in the Presidential election. That also will have people sighing in relief around the world, as it had been criticised by everyone from the US to Russia as inflammatory.

Krauthammer on Obama

Conservative commentator Charles Krauthammer pull no punches. First he asks which controversial statements did Obama sit through without a word of protest. Did they include:

  • Wright’s assertion from the pulpit that the U.S. government invented the HIV virus “as a means of genocide against people of color”?
  • Wright’s claim that America was morally responsible for 9/11 — “chickens coming home to roost” — because of, among other crimes, Hiroshima and Nagasaki?
  • the charge that the U.S. government (of Franklin Roosevelt, mind you) knew about Pearl Harbor, but lied about it?
  • the government gives drugs to black people, presumably to enslave and imprison them?

He then attacks the comparison of Rev Wright to his white grandmother who said she was scared of black men who passed her on the street:

“I can no more disown (Wright) than I can my white grandmother.” What exactly was grandma’s offense? Jesse Jackson himself once admitted to the fear he feels from the footsteps of black men on the street. And Harry Truman was known to use epithets for blacks and Jews in private, yet is revered for desegregating the armed forces and recognizing the first Jewish state since Jesus’ time. He never spread racial hatred. Nor did grandma.

Yet Obama compares her to Wright. Does he not see the moral difference between the occasional private expression of the prejudices of one’s time and the use of a public stage to spread racial lies and race hatred?

Krauthammer does get to a key point. There is no comparison between the two. And I wonder how many people listened to those sermons and believed that the US Government invented AIDS to use against black people.

Finally he asks:

If Wright is a man of the past, why would you expose your children to his vitriolic divisiveness? This is a man who curses America and who proclaimed moral satisfaction in the deaths of 3,000 innocents at a time when their bodies were still being sought at Ground Zero. It is not just the older congregants who stand and cheer and roar in wild approval of Wright’s rants, but young people as well. Why did you give $22,500 just two years ago to a church run by a man of the past who infects the younger generation with precisely the racial attitudes and animus you say you have come unto us to transcend?

To balance things up, here’s an article on how Hillary Clinton is a active participant in conservative Bible study and prayer circles which is known as “The Family”. The article alleges The Family has Nazi and fascist links over many decades. I don’t think the allegations are credible somehow.

And to add to woes for the Democrats, 25% of Florida Democrats have said in a poll they are less likely to support their party’s nominee if their state is not seated at the Democratic Convention.

Naked News on Alt TV

The Herald on Sunday reports that Alt TV will be introducing Naked News in May. Family First have said people will be horrified.

My stance on the issue will be determined by whether Bomber Bradbury is the news presenter! 🙂

Sunday News has a longer article on the Naked News show.

Alt TV’s creative director and former Shortland Street actor Oliver Driver told Sunday News mainstream TV news had become a “farce”. “So we thought we might as well join them,” Driver said.

“There was more coverage of Gin the otter going missing when in the same week a Korean boy was also gone.”

Will Alt TV apply for press gallery accreditation and will their reporters have the same dress code standards? Could make things interesting!

Bill and Fran on Hawke’s Bay DHB

Bill Ralston and Fran O’Sullivan both write in the HoS on the Hawke’s Bay DHB. We’ll let ladies go first, and quote Fran first:

Atkinson believes the inquiry should have addressed other issues that the former board recently uncovered. These include the secret emails between Hausmann and the executive, which Ryall told Parliament showed Hausmann changed tender documents to his advantage. Ryall said both parties withheld these and they came to light only after independent forensic analysis of the back-up tapes.

This also highlights why independent external inquiries with powers to compel evidence are preferable, to inquiries like Ingram and this one which are limited in what they can do.

And now Bill speaks:

When neither you nor your spouse is having an affair it is probably best that you do not write letters and make public statements denying any shagging is going on.

This is political common sense 101, yet former Health Minister Annette King has done exactly that in a breathtaking act of stupidity, neatly adding the missing ingredient of sex to the scandal surrounding the Hawkes Bay District Health Board.

I said much the same. An MP or spouse having or not having affairs is not a matter for the media, but by having written the letter (while Minister of Health), it has meant the issue does hit the public domain.

After the board was controversially sacked by new Health Minister David Cunliffe, King went public, alerting media to the sex rumours. Now, when confronted by reporters with questions about the letter, she accuses the media of being part of a “dirty tricks campaign” and refuses to confirm the letter exists, saying she cannot find it on the ministerial database, avoiding the question of whether she wrote it privately to the board employee.

Heh, I am trying to imagine the look on the face of the Ministerial Secretary if it had been done through the office and entered into the database. First of all how do you classify a letter which threatens someone over alleged affairs by the Minister’s spouse. I doubt it would fit in any of the standard categories!

The report is more interesting for what is not in it than what is. It doesn’t cover whether King should have appointed Hausman; it doesn’t comment on the fact that board staff gave Hausman tender documents ahead of rival bidders; it doesn’t look at Lind’s involvement with the whistleblower or Hausman’s company.

Yes, once again anything like the above was ruled out of the terms of reference.

Perhaps most of all, the report failed to acknowledge that the DHB became a “culture of mistrust and dysfunctional” only after King appointed Hausman.

And it was all predictable.  Appointing a board member against the advice of the Chair flies in the face of good governance. If you are going to do that, you should replace the Chair.

Meanwhile, Cunliffe continues to threaten the sacked board with further investigations of what it may have been up to, King burbles on about a dirty tricks campaign against her and the combined local bodies, and the sacked board prepares for legal action against the Government.

It is a mess that won’t go away until there is a full, transparent, independent inquiry into what happened.

Indeed. And if we don’t get one in 2008, maybe a new Government can order one in 2009?

Views galore on Easter Trading

Where do I start. How about with the CTU:

“The current Easter Sunday trading restrictions ensure that retail workers have at least some ability to participate in the huge range of family, community and religious activities that take place around New Zealand over Easter,” said CTU secretary Carol Beaumont.

I find it interesting that given a choice between being pro-worker or anti-employer they go for anti-employer.

I would expect unions to strongly advocate for penal rates on public holidays, and to advocate that no employee should be forced to work on a public holiday, but why do unions campaign to make their own members poorer by removing the right for low paid workers to earn extra money by working? They claim they support higher wages for workers, yet support a law which prevents them from earning higher wages.

If a couple both on $15 an hour had the ability to volunteer to work on Good Friday, and they were not normally rostered on those days, then they could earn the equivalent of $37.50 a hour which for one day’s work would be $600 of extra earnings for their family.

They could then take the family away on holiday the following weekend when things are less crowded, because they were able to earn that extra $600.

The Press attacks the Government for not changing the status quo:

What this shows is that the Government is gun-shy about taking leadership in election year over an issue which is highly sensitive for many Christians and trade unions.

Religious opponents of allowing general trading on Easter Sunday believe that commercialism would somehow undermine the spiritual meaning of Easter, while trade unions argue that trading-hour liberalisation would expose employees to the risk of exploitation. Yet neither of these arguments is convincing.

Better by far that the Government had acted to at least ensure that the trading regime was consistent and logical, rather than allow the law to continue to make an ass of itself during future Easter weekends.

The Dominion Post is more pointed:

Going to a brothel yesterday was fine by the Government. Going to a garden centre wasn’t, The Dominion Post writes.

That – presumably – is not because the Government believes a dalliance with a prostitute is a more appropriate way to mark Good Friday than sowing some sweetpeas, but because New Zealand’s Easter shopping laws remain a hotch-potch of anomalies and absurdities.

Queenstown and Taupo shop owners could happily open their doors without fear of fines because they are deemed to be tourist areas. Their near neighbours in Wanaka and Rotorua could not. Dairies and service stations were allowed to open. Garden centres were not – but many did anyway.

It is small wonder that the laws and the fines that go along with breaking them are regarded as a final remnant of the days New Zealand was run, as former prime minister David Lange put it, like a Gdansk shipyard.

The best reform suggestion comes from Jim Donovan:

The usual arguments are trotted out by the pro-restriction lobby: it’s one day families can all rely on to get together, it’s a mark of respect to our religious and cultural heritage, it’s one day that sporting and cultural festival organisers can rely on  … That’s fine for those people who want to put aside those particular days for the things they want to do; but why … should everyone else be captive to those special interest groups’ demands, especially when the vast majority actually take no part in the special events on those holidays? The pro-restriction lobby then trots out pieties against crass commercialism and abuse of workers’ rights.

Jim sums up the usual arguments from the statists who want to force their views on everyone else. He then makes a proposal:

Get rid of public holidays altogether, and in return increase annual leave entitlements by the same number of days. Say you currently get 20 days annual leave and 10 public holidays; instead you’d get 30 days annual leave, to take whenever you like.

To cater for the people who want to fix certain dates for religious or cultural activities, you could allow them to nominate up to, say, 5 days a year where they can definitely take time off (i.e. the employer has no choice). To avoid gaming, once nominated those days MUST be taken, unless the employer and employee otherwise both agree. Of course you’d have to allow for essential services, but I’d keep it a very short list.

I like it.  Those who want to have Easter together can do so.  In fact under the current law they can’t as they could be forced to work Easter Saturday and/or Easter Monday. Jim’s proposal would give certainty to families who want some guaranteed time together, but allow freedom to choose for everyone else.

The economy, businesses and consumers would effectively gain several days trading a year. And here’s the greatest advantage – ordinary workers would be free to take more days off when they and their employer agree, not when someone else outside the relationship says they should. For example, families could organise get-togethers when it suited them – and avoid the peak fares and traffic jams of the most popular days.

Indeed. Why let a stupid Gregorian calendar formula dictate when you must take a day off.

I’d bet that most people and businesses would prefer the latter. And think of the administrative simplicity. Unfortunately, too many vested interests love the petty power, anti-competitiveness and big-noting associated with public holidays.

It would be great for religious diversity also.  Jews and Muslims could nominate as of right five of their religious holidays as days they get to take off. As could Buddhists, Hindus. And Americans here could take the 4th of July off.  At present no employee gets to decide as of right a single day they take off. This proposal would give them an inalienable right to take five days off that they nominate and choose, plus another 25 days by mutual consent.

Jim Donovan for Minister of Labour I say.

Easter Sunday ban on comments

Seeing that the powers that be have declared Easter Sunday so sacred, that shops can’t open on it (despite not even being a public holiday), then it is only fair I aso impose my personal wishes on everyone else and ban comments from appearing on Easter Sunday, so people will spend more time with their families.

However l’ll let comments start up again early afternoon, once everyone is back from church.

Now that’s a hospital error

You think NZ hospitals have a problem with medical errors. Have pity for this German woman. Fox News reports:

A German retiree is taking a hospital to court after she went in for a leg operation and got a new anus instead, the Daily Telegraph is reporting.

The woman woke up to find she had been mixed up with another patient suffering from incontinence who was to have surgery on her sphincter.

What can one say.

Hat Tip: Scott Adams

South Park Season 12

Season 11 of South Park has just finished on NZ TV, and with perfect timing Season 12 has started in the US.

In s12e01, Cartman gets HIV from donor blood during a tonsillitis operation. It’s actually got a bit of a serious theme – about how AIDs has declined in profile and fundraising despite the fact it is still killing so many people.  Basically it is a call to donate more money for research. The sick humour is there also though – Cartman injects Kyle with his blood so Kyle is motivated to help look for a cure.

In s12e02 it is far funnier, but still with a serious theme. They interrupt an Obama/Clinton debate with the latest Britney Watch bulletin showing her taking a leak in a forest.  It eviscerates the way the media have covered her breakdown as a commodity. Britney then blows off most of her head with a shotgun. The media just treat this as a new fashion look and keep up the coverage. Finally it ends with a pack of photographers hunting her down with satanic ritual overtones. She dies.

This is one of the reasons I like South Park.  Not just the gross humour, but that it can use humour so effectively to make an important point.

Battlestar Galactica Top Ten

David Letterman has the cast of Battlestar Galactica on his show to read out the top ten reasons to watch the fourth and final season of Battlestar Galactica.

It starts in a couple of weeks. I can’t wait. Unlike Lost, which has started to lose the plot, BSG have been smart in doing just four seasons so it will hopefully go out on a high.

Free to speak again

Stephen Franks is back blogging after National’s internal rules prevented him from doing so during the candidate selection process. The rules are to prevent what he calls “Clinton/Obama style fraticide” which is a great way of illustrating it.

Stephen hits back at distortions of his position on issues such as the Prostitution Reform and Civil Union Bills, and defends classicial liberals against what he labels collectivists who has stolen liberal clothing 🙂

Grant Robertson has also welcomed Stephen to the contest, and says he is looking forward to debating values, issues and policies. He says it would be good to hear Stephen’s views on National’s policy to keep core public service numbers constant for the next three years.

This might be the first ever contest where both major candidates blog. It will be great if we do get some useful discussions going between blogs.

Blog Links

I’ve got the links to other blogs working again. They are at https://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/blogroll.

There is a permament link to the blogroll on the top left under Pages.

The big blogroll button at the top will also point there eventually.  I just can’t make that change myself.

The importance of questions

Almost nothing is more important in polling than setting the questions.  And two recent reports of polls reminds me of this:

The first on cellphone use is reported as:

A new Research New Zealand (RNZ) poll showed 86 per cent of New Zealanders believed that phoning/texting and driving should be illegal.

Now they don’t state the actual question asked, but my first reaction is that by including texting and phoning together could lead to very different results to asking separately. Also talking about “phoning” rather than “using a phone” could get different results as one conjures up dialling out on a phone, rather than merely answering a call. I think texting someone while driving is pretty reckless, but answering a phone call is far less of a distraction.

A second is on Easter Trading:

Research New Zealand surveyed 500 people to find out whether they thought shops should be open on Good Friday and Easter Sunday.

Director Emanuel Kalafatelis says only 32 per cent of those polled want the law to change.

Now if you asked “Should shops have the option of opening” as opposed to “Should shops be open”, you may get different results. For example I don’t think shops should open on ANZAC Day morning, but I don’t think the law should prohibit them.

Now I am not saying in either of these cases, that a differently worded question would change the majority support into majority opposition. But that the questions, as reported, may make people more likely to respond a certain way.

This is not a criticism of Research New Zealand, a very good company.  Apart from anything else I have not seen the actual questions asked – only a media summary. The reason for the post is to highlight how important the wording of questions are, and how media reports which do not include the actual question used need to be treated with some caution.

Armstrong on Douglas

John Armstrong is puzzled by ACT:

Thursday morning’s press briefing was designed to garner more publicity for Act off the back of Sir Roger’s high-profile return to the party’s inner sanctum.

It sure did that. But it was sloppy tactical thinking on Act’s part.

When the party is on 1%, and it presents a programme as if it is the party on 50%, then no wonder it got short shift. It would be like Jim Anderton demanding that the Government abolish the armed forces, increase all benefits by 20%, and hike taxes.

Key was immediately put on the spot. Would he be torn between loyalty to a centre-right ally or preserving his party’s support? It was no contest.

Key was forthright. National would not sell voters down the river by presenting itself as a pragmatic, moderate conservative party before the election only to run an Act-instigated far right agenda in Government afterwards. And no, Sir Roger would not be a member of his Cabinet.

It was a faultless display from the new “decisive” Key – but one once again made on the defensive.

High praise – a faultless display. I’m actually fairly annoyed that the media demanded that what was an incredibly hypothetical question – having Douglas in Cabinet – be ruled out.  As Bill English had said earlier, the party is at 1% (2% in latest Morgan pollI note though) so it is far from certain Douglas would even be an MP.

Act may need Sir Roger’s agenda for re-branding purposes. His ideas are a lot more exciting than Hide’s endless mention of his red-tape cutting Regulatory Responsibility Bill. But there is a consequent risk Sir Roger could overshadow Act’s leader.

I must say as Sir Roger outlined his prescription, I did wonder if he had been given the power to unilaterally set ACT policy.

The other question is how Sir Roger’s broad-brush reforms would square with Hide’s strategy of developing bottom-line positions on just two or three issues from which Act hopes to extract policy concessions from National. The lesson from Thursday is that parties on the same side of the political spectrum are mutually obliged not to do things which end up disadvantaging both.

Exactly. Hide’s strategy is sound – a modest number of bottom-line positions which will give ACT some wins, but not make it look like the tail is wagging the dog. Obviously the more seats a party gains, the more influence they get.

If Act can win three or four seats, it will make it easier for National to form a Government. It is win-win for both parties.

However, Thursday’s behaviour was lose-lose by jeopardising National’s grip on centre-ground voters and in the process Act’s big chance of being in Government.

Act cannot afford to upset National by overplaying its limited hand. Its bargaining power is weak. Hide has to vote with National or feel the wrath of Epsom voters.

If Douglas is seen as the de facto leader or policy setter, and is proposing too radical an agenda, then Epsom voters may get nervous.

NZ First is the obvious candidate. Ignored this week was Winston Peters’ reinforcement of his earlier declaration that NZ First will negotiate first with the party that wins the most seats. He has now added the following: “We will work with the party the voters tell us to.” It is a signal he is willing to enter serious negotiations with National.

It was highly significant. NZ First did not say they will give first priority to the biggest bloc, but the biggest party. So even if Labour/Greens combined get more seats that National, National still gets first negotiation.