Party Pill ban passed

It will be illegal to sell party pills from April, and illegal to possess any from October, under the law passed last night.

I predict some great parties on the 30th of September!

Well done to the Greens, ACT and the Maori Party for rejecting this silly ban. It will be just as successful as prohibition was in the US in the 1930s and will criminalise thousands of young party goers. If the party pill supply dries up, then they’ll just use other, much worse, drugs.
Top quotes:

Maori MP Hone Harawira said Mr Anderton was a killjoy and he thought it ridiculous to ban the pills when tobacco and alcohol remained legal.

Ms Turei described Mr Anderton as a “Muldoon Mini Me” for deciding to change the law but not allowing time to adjust. She said it was “utterly irrational” to think outlawing the pills would eliminate their use.

Next I await Parliament banning easter eggs due to their moderate risk of harm.

Canadians thank Government

A massive 63% of shareholders (close to 90% when you exclude the Council stakes) have agreed to sell their Auckland Airport shares to the Canadian pension fund.

Why so many?

Simple.  The Government’s actions have driven the current share price down so much, that it has made the Canadian offer much more attractive.

The next step, assuming over 50% have also voted for the bid, is for David Parker and Clayton Cosgrove to pretend to impartially consider the bid.  They will go through the farce of asking for reports, and taking time to make a decision, and then shock horror they will turn it down.

And then the Canadian pension fund will haul their little behinds into court, and point to massive and compelling evidence they predetermined the matter because persons no less than the Prime Minister (who can sack them) and the Finance Minister (who controls their budgets) has made it very clear they are expected to turn the bid down.

And so the Canadians will get their 24.9% voting share – which is less than the current level of overseas voting strength I suspect.

The growing bureaucracy

John Key’s speech on the bureaucracy yesterday is here.  Some key points:

  • Labour has had education bureaucrats grow in number by 40% compared to 12% growth of teacher numbers
  •  Central Health bureaucrats up 51% while medical professionals up 28%
  • MSD policy staff have increased 109% while MSD service staff only 23%
  • Overall an increase in bureaucrats by 37%, and 1 in 50 employees in NZ is now a bureaucrat
  • Salary costs for policy departments have increased 142%
  • Government Administration has been the fastest growing sector of the economy

Key also made these pledges:

  • No reduction in front-line staff. The numbers of doctors, nurses, teachers, social workers, police and other front-line staff will grow.
  • In the first term of a National government no growth in the size of the core bureaucracy.
  • $500 million estimated savings over three years

John Armstrong comments:

The freeze, however, is archetypal Key. It will strike a chord outside Wellington. But it is a moderate policy, rather than a radical initiative, and consequently much more difficult for Labour to criticise.

It left Labour torn between wanting to say the policy was too weak to be effective yet strong enough to force cutbacks in services.

He also comments on the PM’s bizarre attempts to suggest National will not hold costs, because Christine Rankin is rumoured to be seeking a candidacy:

The Prime Minister’s response was to raise the spectre of Rankin past followed by mention of Rankin present.

She noted Rankin was a National Party member and hinted the Auckland regional councillor might even be in the running to make it on to National’s candidate list. …

Yesterday’s attempted haymaker from Clark was so off target it risked knocking her out instead.

I hope National will keep a focus on the state sector.  Personally I would push for them to be more adventurous – not in terms of the number of public servants, but in the area of structural reform.  A recent remuneration survey not only discovered public sector CEOs are paid more than private sector ones, but that there are around 210 of them.

I would be keen to see what sort of savings one could make with a rationalisation so there are not 210 CEOs, 210 payroll systems, 210 IT systems, 210 HR systems. I’m not proposing that the functions performed by those agencies be dispensed with, but that amalgamations could result in not just cost savings, but enhanced performance. I’ll blog more one day in detail on this.

House Prices

DPMC have published a very good report on house prices. I quote one section:

Like other businesses, a rental property investor can combine their net rental income with income from other sources. An investor’s total deductions for interest, rates, repairs and insurance may exceed the gross income from rent, creating a loss that can be applied to reduce the taxpayer’s liability on other sources of income. The value of this aspect of the tax system is directly related to marginal tax rates. Therefore, the increase in 2000 to a top marginal tax rate of 39% may have encouraged some additional investment in rental housing.

So Labour increasing the top marginal tax rate increased demand for investment properties, pushing house prices up. And one presumes that a reduction in marginal tax rates would make investment properties less desirable and lead to a drop (or less of an increase) in house prices.

The travellers grow in number

Press gallery reporters, who never look happier than when they are perk busting, have managed to find out seven retiring MPs have overseas travel this year.

It is a bad look. There are reasons you want to attend events such as IPU or CPU meetings, and it could well be the case that MPs restanding don’t want to be out of town in election year. But someone should have realised the perception problem would be significant.  It is hardly a new thing, that the media scrutinise such travel closely.

The Speaker ultimately was in the best place to see the composition of the trips, and should have suggested to parties they rethink their choices.  But to be fair to Margaret Wilson I understand she doesn’t particularly enjoy these trips herself and is probably pretty peeved she has to deal with it.  I hear rumours that she may announce later today that the Speaker’s tour trip will be cancelled.

As someone who has worked in Government, I also have a small degree of professional sympathy for the Government whose big Fast Forward research funding announcement was pushed to second segment status on all the news shows, with the overseas travel perks as the lead items.  Sometimes crap just happens to the best laid plans.

Orcon’s Net and Phone package

NZPA reports on Orcon’s new package, only made possible thanks to local loop unbundling.

For $99 a month, people who live in range of their initial Auckland exchanges can for $100 a month get line rental, free national toll calls and Internet at up to 24 Mb/s download and 1 Mb/s upload.

Good call by Cunliffe

A good Minister will sometimes step in when regulations strange common sense.

This was very much the case when Kataraina Pewhairangi was ruled ineligible to donate part of her liver to save her 10 month old baby,  because she was not 21.

David Cunliffe made a very good call. Let us hope the operation is successful.

Makeup of Islam

Certain idiots on the left respond to any criticism of Islam or of Islamism with howls and cries of racism.  Some of them define a racist as anyone who disagrees with them.

 But the same people who will happily denounce Christians as stupid and mad, have a belief that criticism of Islam is somehow it a proxy for race.

The Sydney Morning Herald helpfully reports that in the United States, which has around two million Muslims living there, that American Muslims are 37% white, 24% black, 20% Asian and 19% other.

Hat Tip: Tim Blair

DPF busy

Had meetings in town yesterday at 11 am, 12 pm, 2 pm, 3.30 pm and 4.30 p.m. with the 4.30 pm. turning into drinks which lasted until 11 pm or so.  Hence no updates for the last 24 hours or so, except for a couple of time delayed posts.

Today not much better as just had gym, and then have a 9.15 meeting, an 11 am (dentist), and a 12.30 p.m. And after that around two days of e-mails to catch up on.  So little new content today until late afternoon probably.

But can use this as a general debate thread.

The Listener on Hawke’s Bay DHB

David Fisher puts his investigative skills to good use in the latest issue of The Listener. The article will not be online for a week or so, so I really recommend people interested buy a copy.  Some key points I noted:

  • The e-mail between Hausmann and CEO Chris Clarke in January 2006, discussing details of the contract Hausmann was tendering for, was only accessed by Board Administrator Deborah Houston as she was filling in for his PA. Hence there may have been many more e-mails like that.
  • King’s appointment of Peter Hausmann was at whim, and while legal (she can appoint anyone she wants) failed to follow best practice by having the potential appointee go before an interview panel.
  • The Cabinet Appointments and Honours Committee staff alerted King’s office to the extent of Hausmann’s conflicts of interest
  • A senior Ministry of Health staffer wrote a letter describing Hausmann’s appointment as posing a “huge risk”.
  • Peter Hausmann asked for an inquiry not just into his own actions, but for a full review of the Board’s performance and governance. The Ministry of Health advised there was no need for this, and that it should be into Hausmann’s conflicts only as they believe “these are prima facie serious matters”.
  • Pete Hodgson ignored the Ministry advice, and by making the review so much wider, meant the review took much much longer to complete, which in itself led to greater dysfunction.
  • Ray Lind recorded several conversations with staff and board members, without telling them at the time.
  • These secret recordings were only discovered when PWC audited the e-mail system and found Lind had e-mailed himself a copy – the e-mail had been deleted but was on the backup tape.
  • Hausmann had access to the RFP months before his ten competitors did, and at least one of them complained about the lack of time to respond when it went public
  • The e-mails to and from Hausmann regarding the RFP were deleted from the DHB’s e-mail system. This is arguably illegal under the Official Information Act.
  • The only backup tape which had the e-mails was May 2005, and of the 12 backup tapes given to PWC, it was the only one damaged.
  • DHB Management were severely criticised by the Audit Office for another (Wellcare Education) contract they gave to Hausmann’s company.
  • An e-mail from Hausmann, after he was appointed to the Board, was sent to a senior manager extensively advocated on behalf of Wellcare Education, which Hausmann’s company’s owned.

The failings of both King and Hodgson, but also Lind and Clarke seem numerous. Deleted e-mails, official advice ignored, preferential treatment, secret recordings, appointments without interviews, to name a few.

What Annette King has yet to answer is why she appointed Hausmann? She says she just met him and as impressed with him.  But why did she ffail to follow best practice? She says she was not legally obliged to do so.  Fine, we know that.  But the question is why did she not have an interview panel as normal?

And has Pete Hodgson explained why he ignored the advice from Ministry officials who had no political interest in the outcome? Did he talk to King before making that decision? Did he talk to Hausmann, Clarke or Ray Lind?

And why did DHB management not once, but twice, fall over themselves to give preferential treatment to Hausmann?

National Party Selections

National Party selections are in full swing, as they try to get them all finished by early to mid April. Last Thursday there was a Meet the Candidates Meeting upstairs in the Backbencher at 5.30 pm. I popped in seeing it was on my way home.

The three Wellington Central candidates are Paul Quinn, Stephen Franks and David Broome.  They all spoke and answered questions well.  Obviously only one of them can be candidate for Wellington Central,but I hope more than one of them can make their way into Parliament. It’s great to see all over the country so many good candidates stepping forward.

These meetings are not public, so I can’t go into details, but I can reveal that I asked a question stolen from Grant Robertson’s blog – which was to ask all the candidates to name a policy they think would be good for NZ, but which would be unpopular.

Most people probably don’t realise how gruelling a National Party selection contest can be.  So I thought I would use this post to explain.

First of all the selection meeting is made up of at least 60 delegates, based on a delegate  for every 15 members in the electorate, plus a top-up if that doesn’t make 60 by the local Region .  You have to have been a party member for at least six months to be a delegate.  The largest electorates can have around 150 delegates at the selection meeting. The Head Office gets no say at all except they can veto unsuitable candidates at the pre-selection stages.

Now once nominations close, candidates get told who the delegates are. Because it is a defined group of people (unlike Labour where any member or affiliated union member can turn up on the night), there is intensive lobbying.

In a serious contest, each candidate will have one on one meetings with all 60+ delegates – lasting about an hour each. On top of that there may be half a dozen “cottage meetings” where a dozen or so delegates are invited to hear a candidate talk and ask questions informally.

Then you have the three formal Meet The Candidates meetings. All delegates must attend at least one of these, and  they consist of 6 – 8 minute speeches from each candidate (with them all staying in the room for each other’s) and then questions from the floor which can be to one or all of the candidates. This can go on for some hours, and you can get some aggressive or tough questions.

Then you have the selection night, where each candidate has a ten minute speech, and then they have to answer two questions – one from the Leader and one from the President.  The same questions go to all candidates, so they don’t stay in the room for each other’s speeches. Then you finally have the vote.

So a candidate for the nomination may end up doing 60+ one on one meetings, half a dozen cottage meetings, three meet the candidate meetings plus the actual selection meeting.  It is no small commitment.

The nasty cartoonists

Auckland University senior political studies lecturer Dr Joe Atkinson is quoted in the HoS as saying cartoonists are being too nasty to Helen Clark.

He should try reading Doonesbury.

And I recall a Trace Hodgson cartoon that portrayed Muldoon as some sort of savage flesh eating beast – far far worse than anything in today’s cartoons.

Political Travellers

By coincidence, Jordan Carter was seated next to me on the flight up to Auckland on Saturday morning. I was heading on holiday, while Jordan was off to his selection meeting for Hunua for Labour, where he was selected unopposed. Congratulations Jordan.

I offered to help Jordan write his acceptance speech, but he declined!

On the way back on Monday night, Russel Norman and Jeanette Fitzsimons were on the flight (which was delayed 50 minutes).  Russel chatted to me for a bit and I told him that I had actually praised the Greens online communications, and his blogging specifically, at the Chamber of Commerce meeting on Friday. I’m not sure if he believed me 🙂 but Adam Smith has blogged that I did speak well of those, who are less charitable towards me.

Cullen’s Deputy

The Hive has been running a series of posts suggesting Cullen will roll Clark.  I offer no opinion on that probability of that scenario, but they have asked me for my thoughts on who would be the best Deputy to a PM Cullen.

It would have to be a woman, to keep the gender balance happy.  Labour’s rules are full of gender balance requirements. If an electorate turns up to their national conference with more men than women, they get hauled before some sort of Spanish inquisition where they have to justify their lack of gender balance, and if they can’t do so thhey lose most of their voting rights.

Annette King has always been the logical choice, but recent events are damaging her star. And the rumour is that she plans to resign in late 2009 or eary 2010 to bring Andrew Little in through a by-election.

Lianne Dalziel has been a very solid performer, but Deputy would be a stretch. Maryan Street is a possibility one day, but has not been in Cabinet long enough. However if one wanted a dark horse to bet on, it would be Street. Dyson is too polarising, even though she is on top of her portfolios.

Another good US sex scandal

New York Governor Eliot Splitzer, has been named in a federal prosecution of a prostitution ring.

Now personally I don’t think the fact he paid up to $5,500 a time to bonk some high class hooker means he is unfit for office. But because he has prosecuted prostitution rings in the past and campaigned on ethics, the hypocrisy is notable.

Most pundits are picking he will resign. Time will tell.

The Eastern European “Junket”

I’ve defended parliamentary overseas trips in the past.  In fact I advocate them quite strongly as desirable because many of the best ideas in relation to national issues, come from other countries and governments. MPs become better legislators and Ministers by having regular international perspectives.

But the trip detailed by Colin Espiner this morning is a bad look, and hard to defend. Having four out of five attendees retiring this year, and the fifth likely not to survive, significantly reduces the benefits of the trip – the MPs will not be around to use the experience and ideas they gain.

It is true that most other MPs may not want to go, as they will be campaigning.  But in that case serious consideration should have been given to cancelling the trip, and instead having an extra one in 2007 or 2009 instead. It really is hard to defend (as Helen Clark is doing) when 80% of them will retire in November. And Clark is wrong to say it is just diplomacy – it has always been about broadening the horizons and experiences of MPs just as much. If it is just diplomacy, the Speaker can attend by herself.

Marian Hobbs doesn’t help the case with this comment:

Hobbs said she was looking forward to the trip.

“I don’t know too much about the purpose. I think it’s about MMP. I’m not sure.”

Like I said, I am normally the last one to “perk bust” MPs – in fact I normally defend them. But again this is hard to defend as value for NZ.

Talking of perk busting, Audrey Young asks where is Rodney Hide when we need him!

Pastoral and Food Research Fund

NZPA has a story on the research fund announcement. The amount has been confirmed as $700 million but this is a capital injection which at 7% cost of interest is effectively $49 million annual in terms of expenditure. Still significant but around 0.1% of Government expenditure.

The funding is expected to be matched by industry contributions which is sensible.

I’ve heard on the grapevine that official advice to the Government was not to put the money into a dedicated capital fund, as this sort of jam jar approach removes the ability of Governments to consider quality of investment in future. Some OIAs will be revealing.

Also the rather unusual references to food and pastoral is because the Greens are campaigning against the Dairy Industry as being polluters, so they left Dairy off the propoganda.

Also worth noting that a ballpark estimate of *current* research and development industry funding is $130 million – via DairyNZ, Meat & Wool NZ, Fonterra etc. So this package, while very welcome, should be seen in context of current investment.

As I said this morning – greater R&D can make a real difference to NZ’s productivity and economic growth.  So the announcement is a good one, even though it should have been done ages ago, rather than wait for the election campaign.

Seven more sins

The BBC reports on seven new sins proclaimed by the Catholic Church.  I would have thought they were doing badly enough the the original sins, they really didn’t have to invent some more.  But here they are:

  1. Environmental pollution

  2. Genetic manipulation

  3. Accumulating excessive wealth

  4. Inflicting poverty

  5. Drug trafficking and consumption

  6. Morally debatable experiments

  7. Violation of fundamental rights of human nature

Now they are all quite interesting.

If one includes carbon emissions as pollution, then we are all sinners and should ask God every week to forgive our carbon footprint. A lot cheaper than carbon credits also.

And if GM food results in millions of people not starving, or cures for fatal illnesses, well sorry you scientists – it is still a sin.

And Bill Gates is obviously going to burn in hell. No not for Windows ME but for being rich. Never mind that he donates more to charity and helping people in poverty than anyone else alive.

Inflicting poverty being a sin is also interesting.  Does this make Dr Cullen a sinner as NZ still has poverty? And does this make the Chinese Government non-evil for lifting so many out of poverty?

Consuming drugs is a sin.  Does this include party pills? How about coffee?

And what Vatican spin doctor came up with morally debatable experiments.  What does that even mean?

I might even agree with the one about violating fundamental rights of human nature if they could list what these rights are.

Now The Times lists the seven original sins, and their respective punishments:

  1. Pride Broken on the wheel
  2. Envy Put in freezing water
  3. Gluttony Forced to eat rats, toads, and snakes
  4. Lust Smothered in fire and brimstone
  5. Anger Dismembered alive
  6. Greed Put in cauldrons of boiling oil
  7. Sloth Thrown in snake pits

So what might be appropriate punishments for the new sins? My guesses are:

  1. Environmental pollution – Drowned in acid rain

  2. Genetic manipulation – Stoned to death with organic pumpkins

  3. Accumulating excessive wealth – death by gerbils with $2 coins tied to them

  4. Inflicting poverty – covered with honey and tied and staked out near an anthill

  5. Drug trafficking and consumption – water boarding with Diet Coke

  6. Morally debatable experiments – Dissection with no anaesthetic

  7. Violation of fundamental rights of human nature – forced to listen to circular tape of Al Gore speeches until natural death occurs

In case the Kiwi Party, Sensible Sentencing or Family First read this post, please note the above suggested punishments are satire and should not be included in any manifesto 🙂

Armstrong on Auckland Airport

John Armstrong reviews the latest move by the Canadians:

An unadulterated shareholding of 40 per cent is widely considered to amount to control. However, the act’s criteria refer to “control” – not “ownership”. The distinction is important because the ministers’ decision is open to judicial review.

I am sure the Canadians were aware of this point.

The Prime Minister, who declined to comment on CPP’s move, yesterday suggested a 25 per cent stake fell within the definition of control if the remaining shareholding was widely dispersed, as it is in Auckland Airport’s case.

However, limiting CPP’s voting rights to 24.9 per cent would give the pension fund less influence than that of the Auckland and Manukau City Councils when their two holdings are combined – arguably not control.

The PM’s knowledge and experience of commercial law is limited, to say the least. As Armstrong points out two local Councils will have a combined greater controlling stake.

What is interesting is that her comments strongly suggest it is purely about politics, and not about any actual concern about control of strategic assets.

The law requires the two ministers to decide on the basis of Overseas Investment Act criteria – not political factors. Yesterday’s move by CPP effectively makes it that much harder for Parker and Cosgrove to say “no” without sounding political and ending up in the courts.

I have little doubt it will go to court, if turned down. The comments by all the other Ministers, the off the record briefings, and the decisions by Cabinet to keep changing the rules will make it almost impossible for the Ministers to argue they were not affected by political factors.

The Food and Pastoral Research Fund

The Herald previews today’s announcement of a new research fund for the pastoral and food industries.

Details are not yet known, but on the face of it investing in research is a good thing to do. That is potentially a useful contributor to increasing productivity and economic growth.

One beneficial outcome would be research which leads the way to have less methane emissions in the diary industry, as this would reduce out Kyoto liability.  One has to ask of course why didn’t the Government establish this research oh around seven or eight years ago when it confirmed Kyoto, instead of a few months before its third term ends.

The other thing which isn’t clear to me, is why it needs to be a dedicated fund, rather than merely an increase in annual funding.  The simple answer is the political one – because $500 million into a capital fund sounds far more sexy than announcing and extra $35 million a year in research funding. So when you hear the big numbers, remember that is capital, not expenditure.

Cullen also is probably desperately trying to reduce the cash surplus, so he can attack National’s tax cuts as unaffordable, while his own tax cuts will magically be affordable and non-inflationary

Crafty Canadians

The Canadians have today said they will reduce their voting strength in Auckland International Airport to 24.9%, even if they get 40% of the shares.  This is definitely below the level regarded as having “control” and makes it very difficult for the Government to turn the bid down, unless they want to be exposed as total xenophobes.

The Hive reports:

CPPIB intends to voluntarily reduce its voting power for all shareholder resolutions, with the exception of resolutions that affect the rights attaching to CPPIB’s shares, to 24.9% of all AIAL voting shares on issue. CPPIB will also provide that the limitation to 24.9% can only be relaxed or revoked by CPPIB if it is permitted by a New Zealand overseas investment law or regulatory approval to vote more than 24.9% of the voting shares in AIAL on issue. The voluntary restrictions that CPPIB will put in place in relation to its voting rights reinforce the fact that CPPIB will not have control over AIAL in any respect.

The Government’s response will be most interesting.  If they still send out signals saying no, then it will be clear they have done a full 180 degree flip and are now against overseas investment in New Zealand, regardless of control of assets.

Ralston gets it

A great quote from Bill Ralston which gets to the heart of the matter:

Am I the only person who finds it slightly hypocritical that we move to stymie the Canadian Pension Plan buying one of our “strategic assets” when Dr Cullen’s New Zealand Superannuation Fund is prowling the planet, merrily buying up other people’s strategic assets?

The NZ Super Fund already has assets of $13.2 billion – making it larger than almost any NZ company. And in just another 15 years it will be a staggering $100 billion in size and will own strategic assets in dozens of countries I suggest.

It already own assets in Argentina, Australia, Austria, Belgium, Bermuda, Brazil, Canada (that nasty country which can’t be trusted to own 30% of an airport), Cayman Islands, Chile, China, Colombia, Czech Republic,  Denmark, Egypt, Finland, France, Germany,Greece, Guernsey, Hong Kong, Hungary, India, Indonesia, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Japan, Liberia, Luxembourg, Malaysia, Marshall Islands, Mexico, Netherlands Antilles, Netherlands, Norway, Pakistan, Panama, Philippines, Poland, Portugal, Puerto Rico, Russia, Singapore, South Africa, South Korea, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Taiwan, Thailand, Turkey, UK, and the USA.

And amongst those investments in around 50 different countries are a couple of airports!

The dangers of blogging

This is very amusing.

Poneke blogged on the 25th of February about how the era of females occupying almost every top job in NZ seems to be coming to an end, and worried about the lack of role models for young women.

I have two daughters, and since their births I have told them them time and again to look at the country’s political, institutional and business leadership for the proof that “girls really can do anything” in New Zealand. During the last decade, and sometimes for much of the same time, we have had a woman prime minister, a woman leader of the opposition (they even swapped jobs in 1999), a woman governor-general, a woman chief justice, the chief executives of the country’s biggest listed company and one of the biggest banks were women, and latterly so has been the Speaker of Parliament. …

What does concern me is the growing shortage of highly visible top role models for my daughters and other girls and young women. Helen Clark will not be prime minister for much longer – at most till 2011 if she wins the election this year, and only till the coming election if she loses it. …

Then a couple of weeks later on the 9th, Aquilifer commented on the post:

Personally I find being told again and again “girls can do anything” to be demeaning, as is having every woman who has reached success of some degree or another shoved in my face as a role model. I’m not so stupid I can’t work out for myself my own abilities and potential.

It seems sexist to me that we have to gasp in delight and point out every successful woman, as if they have beaten insurmountable odds to get where they are. Now no societal barrier stops woman doing what they want, and we know that women can do every bit as well as men. Do we really need to point it out every time a woman gets into power?

We all reach our positions in life by our personal skills and attributes. The best woman or man will always win. If it’s a woman, that’s great, but if the best happens to be a man, there’s no need to be mournful- they’re still the best, and that’s all that should matter.

— Signed, your daughter

Classic. Poneke has a further thread on his (15 year old) daughter’s correcting of him.

Coalition in trouble in Australia

Brendan Nelson may end up with the shortest reign ever as Liberal Party Leader.

Four months into the job, and a poll shows:

  • 51% of voters want him replaced
  • 24% wants Malcolm Turnbull, 19% Peter Costello (who is leaving Parliament), 11% Julie Bishop (Deputy Leader) and only 9% pick Nelson
  • Amongst Coalition voters even worse with 61% wanting Nelson gone and 31% preferring Turnbull over 7% for Nelson

The Auckland EFA protest

The Herald reports on an anti-EFA protest march in Auckland. Helen shows her empathy:

But Prime Minister Helen Clark dismissed yesterday’s march, saying: “The problem with silent protests is that no one listens to them.”

The issue is that Helen didn’t listen to anyone at all in ramming this through.

March co-organiser Jim Bagnall estimated about 500 people marched from the Auckland Town Hall to QE Square at the bottom of Queen St where Auckland University law lecturer Bill Hodge spoke.

“Essentially what the act will deny voters is the freedom to be informed, so that they vote intelligently,” Dr Hodge told the protesters.

This is a very key point. They have deliberately set the spending limits so low that the effect is to actually deny candidates and third parties the ability to effectively communicate.

“The law is just bad legislation, and I feel Dr [Michael] Cullen has failed in his role as Attorney-General and should not continue in that office.”

Dr Hodge, a constitutional law expert who had not participated in any protests in Queen St since 1977, said he felt compelled to this time because he didn’t want New Zealand to have elections that were won in court rather than the ballot box – like American President George W. Bush did in his victory over Al Gore in 2000.

It is worth recalling that Dr Cullen told Parliament that the original EFB (the one which would have regulated people who took a position on any issue a party had a position on) was not a breach of the Bill of Rights. It defied both common sense and the opinion of almost every lawyer in NZ.

Protester Ramesh Kunagaran, an immigrant from Malaysia, said waking up to the news that the Malaysian Government had had its worst result since independence at the country’s general elections last Saturday made him come to the march.

“I am a Labour supporter and I am worried that if they do not repeal this law, it could be the single issue that would bring them down,” he said.

“I come from a country where free speech and even the media are controlled, and I don’t want the same thing to happen in my new country – and from the Malaysian election results, I hope Labour can see that gagging is not the way to win elections.”

Clark still thinks that opposition to the EFA is just from the right, when in fact it has been condemned and opposed by people from all over the spectrum.

The protest march was organiser John Boscawen’s fifth against the legislation, but his first since it took effect on January 1.

“Free speech is an issue that concerns all New Zealanders and the Electoral Finance Act is a profound betrayal of trust by the people whom we have voted to represent us,” he said. “I intend to continue protesting throughout this year until such time as the act is repealed.”

John has devoted an amazing amount of his time to this issue, and it is great to see he is going to carry on.  It is no coincidence that the massive gap in the polls has happened since the public started to be informed about the EFB and now EFA.
Personally I would have rather the EFB had been defeated, even if it meant the gap in the polls was less.  The main reason for that is the damage to the constitution conventions of having had such a major electoral change pushed through without even an attempt at bipartisan consultation.  It is one of those genies that when is let out, is very hard to get back in.