An unproportional result

Keith Ng blogs on an issue I planned to cover in more detail. What would happen if an overhang in seats for the Maori Party resulted in a Government being elected that got less votes than the Opposition?  Keith gives an example:

Anderton, Dunne and Hide gets <2% party vote between them. Maori Party gets all 7 Maori seats, with 3% of the party vote. We get a Parliament of 125 MPs. National + Hide + Dunne have 62 seats. Labour + Greens + Anderton have 56 seats.

In this scenario, the Maori Party could reverse a 6-seat gap with 3% of party votes.

That would be a fundamental slap in the face of proportional representation, and the scale of it would be made possible because of the Maori seats.

In this scenario, I would predict one of two likely responses.

The first is that MMP would be swept aside as its main virtue (and I support MMP over FPP) would be undermined.

The second is that the major parties would respond to this overhang situation by creating their own overhangs by creating party vote only parties and electorate seat only parties. Then all electorate seats would be overhangs (and we would ironically have a Supplementary Member style electoral  system) and the House would have 190 MPs!

NZ First policies being pinched

Audrey Young writes:

Labour is moving towards the more populist policies of New Zealand First but New Zealand First leader Winston Peters says he is not worried and has got many more it can pinch.

Indeed they are going down the NZ First route.  How long until they start attacking immigration?

DHB Members strike back

Government Expenditure

Bernard Hickey looks behind the headlines in the Crown accounts. Forget the investment write-downs he says:

Government spending is growing at a rate of 9.8%, which was more than twice as fast as revenue growth at 4.5% and twice as fast as estimated nominal GDP growth at around 5%. The government is eating the economy.

Watch the OBEGAL. It is barking that the government is spending too much and taxing too much and employing too many bureaucrats. It is biting us with low productivity growth because our best and brightest are becoming highly paid bureaucrats who now call themselves senior policy analysts. We’re all paying for this with higher wages costs, higher inflation and lower GDP growth.

Ignore this month’s deficit. Pay attention to a government eating the economy.

Eating the economy. A very nice way of putting it.

Hat Tip: The Hive

The return of Muldoon

Two separate columnists in two separate papers have used the “Muldoonist” tag in relation to Dr Cullen’s overnight secret law change regarding overseas investment in private companies.

Brian Gaynor in the Herald writes:

Finance Minister Dr Michael Cullen’s decision to effectively stymie the partial takeover offer for Auckland International Airport (AIA) is an unwanted reminder of the meddling policies of former Prime Minister Robert Muldoon.

Dr Cullen’s edict was so appalling, and so inconsistent with his policies of the previous eight years, that one can only conclude it was strongly influenced by political considerations ahead of this year’s general election. …

Cullen’s decision was announced nearly a decade after the Crown sold its 51.6 per cent controlling interest in the airport and more than seven months after the first offer for AIA was revealed. As a result the offer has been a terrible waste of resources – the airport had already spent $5.8 million on the process by the end of December.

Meanwhile Garry Sheeran in the SST says:

The crudely political nature of the government’s late-night move to block the Canadian bid for 40% of Auckland International Airport is highlighted by a barely cold, two-year review of the Overseas Investment Act.

That review, enacted into law in August 2005, was supported by a government “committed to maintaining a liberal investment regime”.

The legislation’s sponsor, Finance Minister Michael Cullen, said at the time that New Zealand needed foreign capital to develop the economy.

No surprise, then, at the collective gasp which greeted the same minister’s announcement late on Monday that the same act would be amended to send the Canadians packing, once and for all.

Political commentator Chris Trotter said the use of an order-in-council to rewrite the law harked back to the 1980s. “It would have been just another day under Rob Muldoon,” he said, “but using the governor-general and most of the cabinet to rewrite the rules is not something we are used to any more.

Also the NZ Herald Editorial calls on Cullen to name the assets covered by this new law:

Dr Cullen suggests the infrastructure he has in mind comprises only a “narrow” group. The inclusion of Auckland airport means it could be narrower. But, hopefully, dams and ports are the other ingredients. Certainly, there is no need for the likes of Television New Zealand, which can, in an emergency, be easily replicated.

The other factor in this equation is xenophobia. That is the unspoken reason for the obstacles installed by many overseas jurisdictions. It should not be an issue here. Dr Cullen must list what the Government considers strategically important infrastructure. That should be the prelude to a reasoned debate. From that, it should not be difficult to reach bipartisan agreement on strategic assets, and the degree of protection they should be afforded.

Indeed Dr Cullen has resorted to Winston’s old trick of xenophobia. And it is quite unacceptable for people not to know which assets or companies the Government now deems strategic. Why would people spend money investing in a company when the Govt by overnight whim can declare it is strategic and off limits.

And tonight mussels

The snapper made a good lunch, so this afternoon we went swimming and hunting for mussels and pipis. Another gorgeous day up north – as much as I love Wellington one thing you can’t do there is actually go into the water.

Have taken a few great photos but forgot the cord to transfer them so can’t blog them until I am home on Tuesday.

Fox to be Maori Party Candidate

Labour MP lashes out at political corectness

Retiring Labour MP Dover Samuels has lashed out at political corectness:

“We’ve got to learn to laugh at each other. This PC, culturally correct brigade will actually destroy our New Zealand lifestyle. There’s this inherent part of our country that is being destroyed because we’re becoming so PC.

“You’ve got these culturally correct loony tunes who think everything’s offensive come on, it’s time to wake up.

and

“The Treaty of Waitangi seems to be the antidote for everything from tagging to wagging school and colonisation which is absolute cultural bullshit.

“Frankly, I think a vast majority of Maori have had a gutsful of it, just like the average New Zealander that’s why I’m going to Australia.”

Samuels lashes the Maori Party for their part in it, but as they have been in Parliament only two years it is hard to resist the conclusion that he is also sending a message to his own colleagues.

Roughan on US Presidential Election

NZ Herald Assistant Editor John Roughan discusses the US elections:

This is more than a fascinating election, it’s a joy to observe because all the serious candidates left in the race seem admirable in their own way. That may change now that Hillary has survived and will play rough to win. But the politics of mutual respect has been a rare treat.

I wonder if we could do it this year. We have two very respectable candidates for Prime Minister.

This is the one part when I think Roughan is in fantasyland. There is not even a small sliver of probability that Labour and Clark will not try and demonise Key.  I mean when Clark was asked on TV if she could name one positive thing about John Key, she couldn’t even manage that.

I watched John McCain on television when he clinched the nomination in Texas this week and it struck me that he offers something Clinton and Obama do not.

They promise “change”, by which they mean more than a change of party in power but possibly not much more than a change of the race or gender of the President.

Ignore their faces, listen to their rhetoric, and you hear fairly standard policy speak from Clinton and great oratory – but only oratory – from Obama.

Listen to McCain and you might wonder whether he is a politician at all. Open your eyes and the impression is confirmed. He fails all the superficial tests of US politics. He looks old, sounds soft, dresses badly, grins like a chump. And his speeches are modest, reasonable, almost self-effacing but firm and clear in commitments that are not necessarily popular.

Indeed McCain avoids the populist route.

In Michigan where the depressed car industry has left high unemployment, McCain alone had the courage to tell audiences, “the old jobs are not coming back”.

He believes in free trade which is reason alone to pray for his victory, especially when Clinton and Obama are playing up fears and suspicion of foreign competition and corporate behaviour.

They don’t mean it; trade fear is standard feed for the Democrat Party base who vote in primaries. Obama and Clinton have shown themselves to be conventional politicians in that sense, while McCain has stood up to a pounding from his party’s conservative core.

I think the pundits who claim McCain have no chance at all in the general election will be surprised.  I am not predicting a winner, but I think it will be a very competitive race.

John and Fran double-tag Key

John Armstrong and Fran O’Sullivan both wrote yesterday on the messy week for John Key.  First here’s Armstrong:

As the latest TV3 poll indicated this week, an overwhelming majority of voters _ including a fair chunk of Labour ones _ expect National to win this year’s election. Key has transitted from new boy on the block to Prime Minister-in-waiting.

That is the standard by which his performance will increasingly be judged by voters from now on.

If one was to be generous to Key, you would say hey he is only in his second term of Parliament. But as Armstrong says when you are poised to become Prime Minister in eight months times, the expectations are that you perform up at that level, despite five years in Parliament against Clark’s 26.

While Key answered some questions directly, he fudged on the crucial ones. The more he prevaricated, the worse it looked.

He should have worked out some suitably firm-sounding lines in advance. Having spouted them, he should have cut the questioning off on the grounds he would otherwise be late for the start of Parliament.

Yes, one you have a position, stick to it.

Fran chips in:

Memo: John Key. Get on top of policy quickly or you may follow Don Brash into oblivion.

And stop blaming journalists for your verbal gaffes _ they’re not employed to be your mind-readers.

Fran’s never going to win a prize for sensitive use of language 🙂

Cullen should have been easy prey for National this week. His blatant interference in the Canadian Pension Plan’s partial takeover of Auckland Airport stank of political opportunism.

Agreed. The issue should have been the hypocrisy of Cullen’s move and the fact that he changed an important law overnight, by way of regulation, with no consultation with anyone at all.  A growing number of commentators have used the Muldoonist tag for that action and it is one which should stick.

Cullen has isolated another Key weakness _ a lack of institutional memory caused through his absence from New Zealand for much of the reform period.

This plays into why Key sometimes fails to turn journalistic questions to his advantage. It should have been easy enough to challenge the TVNZ report which (initially) made it seem as if a state asset had been on the block, rather than a publicly listed company owned 75 per cent by private shareholders.

But Key found himself drawn into a situation where it seemed as if he was in favour of asset sales rather than an open capital market. A political leader on top of their game would have quickly turned this to advantage by reminding journalists the airport was privatised years ago by then Treasurer Winston Peters.

Yeah So much of the media coverage would have you think the Government still owned the airport, let alone Winnie sold it 🙂

More Labour ignorance

The Herald has an item over election material by Labour without authorisation.  Justice Minister Annette King still seems unaware of parts of her own law.  They quote:

Justice Minister Annette King told Parliament the booklet was produced in October and paid for in November, before the Electoral Finance Act took effect on January 1.

It is a well known and long standing principle of electoral that it does not matter when something was produced or when something was paid for.  It is all about when it is used, when it is published or distributed to the public.

Fishing

A beautiful afternoon out fishing in Waitamata Harbour.  Went out on a friend’s boat and it was one of those boats with retractable wheels so we actually drove the boat on the road until the beach and then just drove it on the beach into the water and once it was deep enough the wheels retracted up.  Much easier than launching and trailers.

There were three of us and we caught around ten snapper and one kawhai.  I landed the kawhai after letting another one escape earlier.  The buggers jump into the air to try and unhook themselves.  I haven’t gone fishing for years and years so was a great relaxing afternoon.  It was perfect weather too.

On the way back we also lowered a very small environmentally friendly (doesn’t crush anything) dredge and after a couple of runs ended up with a great collection of scallops (but under the legal limit).

So dinner tonight was firstly lovely raw kawhai, and then home made fresh mornay scallops.  That was so filling we didn’t even move onto the snapper, which we may start at lunch tomorrow.

I am starting to become very favourably inclined towards the idea of owning a boat!

Recording Text Messages

The Government is looking at a law change requiring telcos to record and store text messages so Police can access them with a warrant.

I have some nervousness over this.  It is one thing to have a law which requires telcos to record the content of text messages *after they receive a search warrant targetted at a particular individual. But this is about having the telcos store every single text message we send or receive, so it can then be accessed.

The precedent this would set is that ISPs should also keep a copy of every e-mail message you ever send or receive, in case the Police should ever want it.  And then how about also requiring them to keep track of every website you have ever visited.

Telcos and ISPs should co-operate with the Police *after* a warrant has been served requiring interception or recording of data which a Judge/JP has authorised as necessary for a criminal investigation. But that is very different to having them forced to store personal communications on every NZer, so that law enforcement authorities can access them at some later date if they wish. Why not also have the teclso record every voice call, just in case they are also needed?

Sea Shepherd’s Watson claims Japanese Whalers shot him

DPF on Holiday

Chamber of Commerce Talk on Blogging and the Election

Very much enjoyed giving a presentation to the Wellington Chamber of Commerce on Friday about the impact of blogging on politics overseas and in New Zealand.

The Hive has a summary of what I said, from John Bishop’s newsletter.  I actually gave The Hive a plug as a new must read blog.  I also gave the Greens the overall prize for the best use of blogging and overall use of online technologies to communicate. I’ll let people guess which party was in 8th place 🙂

I might have got a bit too enthusiastic when I floated the concept of term limits on the press gallery so journalists focus more on the policy issues behind political debates, rather than the politics of the politics.  WRCC CEO Charles Finney said with a smile he would be sure to let Ian Templeton know 🙂

What really did surprise me (but less so with hindsight) was when Charles introduced me and said that since it had been public they had invited me, the Chamber had received abusive phone calls and e-mails from a few disgruntled individuals. Charming as always the “fan club”.

2% growth

The Dom Post reports that there it is forecast that there will be 2% annual growth over the next three years. This is labelled as good news.  It isn’t.

To start closing the gap with Australia we really need to put in place policies which will get a 4% average growth rate. A 2% growth rate will see fall further in relative terms.

People don’t get very excited about 2% vs 4% so what does that mean in real dollars.

GDP as at September 2007 was $171 billion.  At 2% growth it would be $181 billion in three years. If 2% growth continued for say nine years (three terms) then GDP would hit $204 billion.

And what if one managed 4% growth.  Well in three years  GDP would hit $192 billion. And in nine years it would be $243 billion.

So NZ would be $10.9 billion better off in three years if it could get 4% growth instead of 2%. And over nine years it would be $39 billion wealthier if it could make 4% instead of 2%.

And what does that mean for the average family? Well while GDP growth doesn’t automatically translate into cash in the hand, the extra national wealth per household (just under 1.5 million in the last census) would be $7,300 after three years and $26,000 after nine years.

Now even if one says hey we can never make and maintain 4%, even the gap between our usual 3% and 2% is significant.  An average $3,600 per household after three years and $12,500 after nine years.

So the only person who should be saying

There was some good news – the economy is expected to keep growing by around 2 per cent a year for the next three years.

Should be the Australian Minister of Immigration as he welcomes people in.

Labour does not know their own law

The Dom Post has an article on Labour’s breaches of the Electoral Finance Act.  Labour General Secretary Mike Smith is quoted as saying:

But Mr Smith said the act allowed financial agents to list the address of their party

Really.  Why didn’t Mr Smith cite a clause.  Maybe because he made it up. Let’s look at the Act.  First of all we have s7(1):

The secretary of a party must appoint a financial agent to be responsible for administering the party’s finances.

If none is appointed, the secretary is deemed to be appointed. Then Clause 63(2) says:

No promoter may, during a regulated period, publish, or cause or permit to be published, any election advertisement unless—(a) the advertisement contains a statement that sets out the name and address of the promoter of the advertisement; 

And s63(3) paragraph (a) states who maybe a promoter:

the financial agent of a party, but only if the advertisement is a party advertisement promoted by, or on behalf of, that party;

Okay so for all party advertisements, the promoter is the party’s financial agent. And the advertisement must have the name and address of the promoter, ie the financial agent.

So which address can one use. We turn to s5(1)

address means,— (a) in relation to an individual, the full address of the place where that person usually lives:

So the address must be the full address of where the financial agent usually lives. No wriggle room there. So on what basis does Mr Smith argue he can list the party’s address?

Smith also claims:

and the chief electoral officer had given an indication that view was acceptable.

Well this is possible, but beware people purporting to speak on behalf of others. I prefer to go off their direct words to the media:

Electoral Commission chief executive Helena Catt said no concerns had been raised with them from parties about the requirement for a personal address. She said the commission would be unable to change the situation because it was written in the law.

People should note though that the Chief Electoral Officer is a different person to Dr Catt.

Clark compared unfavourably to Bush

A blog has compared Helen Clark to George W Bush. Their headline:

Bush leads fight against climate change, Clark following fast

It goes on to compare Bush’s rhetoric to Clark’s and find some comparisons.

So which awful blog has done this? Is it Whale Oil? Insolent Prick? Cactus Kate? Ian Wishart? No Minister?

It’s the Greens’ Frog Blog!

So jubiliant over a $4 billion writedown

It was fascinating to observe Dr Cullen on the news last night. He seemed jubilant and happy. Could almost not restrain his glee.

And what was he celebrating? A drop in the Government’s surplus of $4.2 billion from a $3.8 billion surplus to a $0.4 billion deficit. The $4.2 billion drop being made up of decline in the value of financial assets by $2.5 billion, an addition $1 billion liability for ACC claimants and a $700 million drop in tax revenue.

Now while this isn’t end of the world stuff (as the underlying OBEGAL surplus is only down by $600 million) it isn’t what you would expect a Finance Minister to celebrate.  So why was he?  Because Dr Cullen thinks economic bad news is political good news, as a smaller surplus makes it harder for National to promise larger tax cuts.

When you combine his glee over a $4.2 billion surplus with the economic vandalism caused by a xenophobic last minute change to the overseas investment rules, one has to wonder has the 20% deficit in the polls pushed Dr Cullen into a scorched earth policy? Where any amount of damage and destruction to the economy is justified, if it might help close the poll gap?

It’s too early to tell, but when a Finance Minister gleefully celebrates the government’s net worth dropping by $4.2 billion,  it’s a fair question to ask.

Audrey Young on dropping wages

Anyone visiting certain blogs on the left in the last few weeks may have noticed one of their 17,628 posts on their insistence that John Key has a secret master plan to lower wages in NZ. This is all based on a reporter’s notes of a conversation in a cafe (not a speech to a business audience as they stated) between Key and a Kerikeri business woman.

Now the newspaper in question has come out and said that if what Key had said left the impression he wanted to lower wages, that would be incorrect.

This of course has led to even more fanatical claims that this statement by the newspaper is something sinister – as if MPs have never ever complained before to a media outlet about a story which they think left the wrong impression.

Audrey Young blogs some perspective on the issue:

There is a certain amount of rubbish being pedalled by the Engineering Printing and Manufacturing Union about the Herald’s involvement in the saga over whether or not John Key told the Bay Report in Northland he wanted wages to drop.

What a surprise.

The Herald was actually first to cover the claims about the John Key and lower wages story after Labour had been on the case for a few days, and that was at the suggestion of the Herald editor.

Oh no there goes the conspiracy theory. Or perhaps the Editor was just trying to make up for 91 years of no charity 🙂

Something else to keep a little perspective on this saga – what was run today in the Bay Report itself was a “clarification”,not a correction or a retraction.

It would suit National, Labour and the EPMU if it were a correction, but any fair reading of the “Point of clarification” would see that the paper is not disowning the reporter’s transcript. It is is saying that if what Key had said left the impression he wanted to lower wages, that would be incorrect.

There is quite a difference.

“From an examination of the interview, and the context of the comments made by Mr Key in relaitons to the loss of skilled workers from New Zealand to Australia, the Bay Report now accepts that was not intended and that impression would be incorrect.”

It all comes down to an unclear context for the comments.

There wouldn’t be a journalist or news outlet in the country that has not been lobbied by politicians about a story they have taken exception to. Labour does it too.

I have it on very good authority that Broadcasting Minister Steve Maharey rang the chief executive of Radio New Zealand (yes, management) last year because he was so pissed off at an interview conducted by Sean Plunket.

And that really was naughty. And MP can complain to any media organisation about coverage they don’t like. Except the Broadcasting Minister should never be the person who personally rings the CEO of a public broadcaster the Minister is responsible for- if it deals with content of a news story.

UPDATE: The Dom Post covers the story. An extract:

“The approach was not in the form of a demand and no other requests were made. Following an examination of the transcript of the interview and the context of the comments made by Mr Key during the interview, the editor agreed readers may have gained an incorrect impression and a clarification was warranted,” Mr Simons said.

He said the wording of the clarification, published by the Bay Report, was edited in the normal manner by the editor of the newspaper.

“The wording was discussed and agreed prior to publication by the journalist who wrote the original piece and the subeditor who edited the story,” Mr Simons said.

An anonymous spokesperson for The Standard said that they would be issuing an apology for their 11,879 posts attacking Mr Key, now it is clear everyone agrees John Key does not want wages in NZ to drop.  However they said all the editors are out today skiing on Mt Hell skifield today, after an unusual freezing over the entire Hell region, so the apology will have to wait until they finish skiing.

Yay – columns are back

Yay, all the columns and op-eds are back in the Herald’s opinion section.

Also good to see their dedicated blog section.  Their blogs now look like blogs rather than merely columns called blogs. And they have a proper comment section now with registration.  There is still a delay in them appearing but I guess the lawyers force them to do that!

March on Sunday at 2 pm

marchakl.JPG

Above is a shrunken version of the ad (pdf) by John Boscawen for a march in Auckland on Sunday (gather Queen Street at 2pm) to continue the protest over the Electoral Finance Act.

It is important to keep up activities like this to keep the Act in the news.  In the first two months of the year there has been a plethora of negative stories about the Act. And the Owen Glenn affair would have had far less potency if it were not for the hypocrisy of Labour and NZ First contrasting their rhetoric with the EFA with their actions.

And again on the hypocrisy, yesterday Bill English revealed that Labour has been breaking its own Act, by listing a work address instead of a home address on their campaign material. The Greens have also broken this aspect of the law with their “Date Green” t-shirts.  I previously blogged on this issue of needing home address of financial agents for parties. Labour’s response to this problem was to scoff – and now it appears they are breaching it themselves.

Where has the surplus gone?

Despite the headlines, the latest set of crown accounts are not as bad as some are saying.

This is because the important figure is the one called OBEGAL, formerly OBERAC.  This is the measure of the underlying structural surplus. Dr Cullen uses to refer to this one all the time until it got embarrassingly large and he then tried to revert to 1970s accounting standards by focusing on merely the cash surplus.

The OBEGAL to Jan 2008 was $3.1 billion against a forecast of $3.7 billion.  Now that’s somewhat disturbing as normally actual comes in way above forecast, but some of the difference may just be timing issues.

The full year OBEGAL forecast was $6.6 billion.   We’ll find out in May what that has been revised to – could possibly drop to the $5 to $6 billion range.  This is still definitely high enough to afford tax cuts but ironically quite a bit less than previous years when Cullen said they were not affordable.

Should WCC keep STV?

Poneke blogs that Wellington City Council should ditch STV – an issue they are going to consult on. I agree.

Now I actually support STV in many types of elections. In fact I introduced constitutional changes to InternetNZ so that candidates are elected by what is effectively STV, not FPP. National uses a form of STV for its internal elections for candidates and the board. I like and support STV in situations where it works well.
STV works well when the voter has a relatively small number of candidates to choose from, and they know most or all of the candidates. When you know the candidates you can quite easily make an intelligent choice about ranking X No 1, Y No 2 etc.

However STV is an unmitigated disaster for DHBs and a partial disaster for Councils.

Even the most politically active geek has no idea who 80% of the candidates for the DHB are. Trying to rank 30 of them in order based on who wrote the best 200 word bio is just insane, and it is no surprise turnouts are so low.

If one insisted on keeping STV for DHBs, then you would need very very small wards with one vacancy per ward.  That way you may end up just raking say four or five people for one local spot – something which might be possible if they are fairly well known locals.  Of course whether you want to have geographical segmentation like that for DHBs is another issue.

With regard to Councils, it is not quite as bad.  I actually like STV for voting for the Mayor. There is only one position to fill and it is possible to fairly sensibly rank say half a dozen candidates for Mayor. I like being able to express a second and third preference should my first preference fail to be elected.

But then when you come to wards, it becomes near useless again because again not even the political geeks can sensibly rank say 15 people competing for three Council positions. And so we have a 10% fall in turnout over two elections.  If you want to keep STV then you need small one person wards.

I could advocate STV for the Mayor, and FPP for Council but that may be too confusing.  So if WCC is to have one electoral system only, then FPP is best.