Espiner on Key

Has been a somewhat messy couple of days for John Key as he took a day to clarify National’s position on Auckland Airport and also gave a wrong impression on National’s treaty policy.

I’d guess that with such a huge lead in the polls, there has been a semi-natural inclination to try and avoid saying anything which might upset the pundits.  I don’t mean this to suggest that National will not have any policy which differs from Labour – I am sure it will. But that when Labour manufacture an issue, such as Auckland Airport, an inclination not to be forced into declaring whether or not one will reverse it is understandable. But a failure to clearly state what one will do in response can be worse than taking a position, even an unpopular one.

I’m pleased to see today that this has not happened with Labour’s attempts to buy Toll. Instead of fudging on their position, I am very glad to see NZPA report the following from National:

A National government would consider selling off a renationalised railway company, the party’s finance spokesman Bill English said today.

Finance Minister Michael Cullen confirmed today the Government had made an offer for Toll’s rail and ferry business, but the Crown and company remained poles apart about a fair price.

Mr English said the last thing New Zealand wanted was the Government to own the rail company.

“We certainly wouldn’t be buying Toll. The worst thing for our railway network would be for the Government to take it over using the OnTrack company, (the State-owned enterprise which runs the rail tracks) which is chaired by the Labour Party president Mike Williams,” Mr English said.

“We would be back to strikes in school holidays on the ferries and featherbedding in the system. We need to look after the taxpayers’ interests and the network and the best way to do that is to have a competent operator.”

Governments had a bad record on operating rail companies and he did not think Labour would be any better.

If the purchase was completed then a National government would get out of the business as quickly as possible.

Excellent.  A nice strong attack on the Government, a reminder of the bad old days, and a very clear response.

Now going back to Espiner, he writes:

The wonder, then, is that he did not say this loudly and clearly on Tuesday. There were certainly grounds for attacking Labour. The Government has intervened late in the piece, effectively shifting the goalposts. It has all but admitted it has done so for populist reasons. Allowing foreign investment in our companies has never bothered it in the past – indeed, Labour used to welcome it.

Labour remains responsible for selling some of New Zealand’s most strategic assets of all, such as Telecom, the railways, and more recently, the national electricity grid.

Nevertheless, Labour has snookered National over this one and both parties know it. I’d hate to think that Labour announced the new provisions purely to trap Key, because that would not only be the height of cynicism but terrible government. I’m sure it didn’t. But it would surely have crossed Labour’s mind.

I suspect they did actually. Not solely, but their decision was a terrible unprincipled act. That is why it should have been attacked strongly.

I understand Labour has a series of other traps for Key this year, and it’ll be interesting to see whether National’s leader is a little more careful where he stands.

As I said above, the response to a possible buy back of Toll looks much much better.

Will it make any difference to the polls? The short answer is I don’t believe it will. Not in the short term anyway. The average punter doesn’t watch Parliament with a clipboard keeping score of the exchanges (at least I hope they don’t or they’re as sad as the press gallery).

Heh so true 🙂

But it might hurt National during an election campaign.

That is the concern.  There’s only a few months to tighten things up.

8 overseas trips and 50% staff turnover

Dead Joey

Well the Shortland Street serial killer plotline is now dead with Joey.

Stuff reviews the end of the plotline.

I have to say that overall the producers did a pretty good job with it.  Viewer numbers went up, people started to talk about it more, and they didn’t ham it up too much.  I’m only an occassional viewer via My Sky but in the last few weeks have been watching regularly to see how it gets resolved.

DPF busy

Been in meeting all morning about digital broadcasting regulation (which I will blog on – well on the topic not the meeting, which was non-reportable) and am chairing an InternetNZ meeting this afternoon.

So not had time to cover stuff like the surplus now a deficit, “Slippery John”, verioud overhang scenarios, the Democratic race in the US or the latest Goff for Leader article by Chris Trotter.  May get to them tonight.

Treat this as a general debate thread though.

Where are all the columns?

Arrargh. The NZ Herald has modified its website and the very useful Opinion section has moved and changed.

It’s moved it to under News which is fine. Worked that out pretty easily.  But now it lists editorials only. It used to have all the columns and guest op-eds for the day together – was very very handy. But now it is just the editorials.

Please someone change it back. Or set up another section called Columns.

How many Labour MPs are fleeing overseas

I blogged yesterday about how Dover Samuels was heading overseas once he leaves Parliament.  Now I have been reminded that Marian Hobbs is off to the UK to teach, once she is off.  And it is widely rumoured Tim Barnett will also be heading to the UK.

So with around 12 Labour MPs retiring, as many as 25% of them will be fleeing NZ.  Is it any surprise so many other NZers are doing the same?

More climate change problems for Govt

There is no portfolio area where the difference between rhetoric and reality is greater – than environment – specifically climate change.  Clark talks about carbon neutrality while her growth in carbon emissions record is amongst the worse in the world compared to Kyoto targets.

Now a report by the NZ Institute reveals that the Government’s emissions trading scheme (already under fire by multiple groups) and other announced policies will have NZ miss our Kyoto target by 38 years!

Instead of getting back to our 1990 levels by 2012, they predict it won’t happen until 2050. Dr Skilling makes a valuable point:

Half of New Zealand’s emissions come from agriculture but it is harder to redesign a cow than a car.

The Government has voted in Bali to have a target of reducing emissions by 2020 to 25% to 40% below 1990 levels. To be blunt this is just not going to happen – it is almost a con. Even National’s goal of a 50% reduction by 2050 is looking overly optimistic according to NZI who suggest a 30% reduction by 2050 would be about as challenging as NZ could manage.

Related to this is a poll out by the NZ Business Council for Sustainable Development.  It’s a poll of those who take part within an online panel so not as robust as a truly random poll, but the Hive points out one interesting aspect:

When asked which of the two main parties would be best to manage climate change only 33% picked Labour and 32% picked National.

Also 35% of respondents ranked the Government’s management of climate change as below average and only 18% above average.  Not good when this is meant to be Labour’s biggest issue.

This strongly suggests that the public (or at least those who take part in NZBCSD surveys) are seeing through the Government’s rhetoric and realising how appalling their actual record has been.  I mean it is almost unthinkable that say a year ago just as many people would cite National being as good as Labour on climate change.

Candidates Updated

I’ve done another update of the 2008 candidates page. Thanks to those in both Labour and National who have sent through additions and corrections. At present it is an image of an excel sheet but I have 95% worked out how to convert it to HTML so have started hyperlinking candidates to their websites. The hyperlinks won’t work while it is just am image, but will eventually so feel free to e-mail me any candidate websites.

The latest addition the list is National’s Auckland Central candidate, Nikki Kaye. Nikki is one of my closest friends and an amazingly hard worker so I’m thrilled for her. She won a very tough selection battle tonight, which went all the way to a final third ballot.

Interest Rates

intratemar08.JPG

I’ve noticed in recent weeks that mortgage rates have been going up despite the official cash rate staying constant for the last six months. So I checked out the Reserve Bank data.

So on the graph you can see the OCR and the average floating first mortgage rate. And sure enough it has been starting to creep up.

The gap between the mortgage rate and the OCR in Feb 2008 was 2.40%. At times it has been as low as 2.00% and the average for the last four years is around 2.25%.

Now I’m not sure what this means, but could it be an expectation that the OCR may go up again? Or are the banks just increasing their margins?

Obama in the lead

Obama has picked up Vermont (as expected) and is ahead in Texas 54% to 45% with one million votes counted. The exit poll had then almost neck and neck and early returns are not always representative so Obama should hold off the champagne for a bit longer.

UPDATE: 1.3 million votes (14% of precincts) and narrowed to Obama 50%, Clinton 48%. Clinton well ahead in Ohio on 35% of precincts in.

UPDATE2: CNN has called Ohio For Clinton (she has 57% currently) and in Texas she is now ahead by 20,000 votes on 1.5 million votes counted.

UPDATE3: I don’t see Clinton conceding.  Her victory in Ohio is substantial 56% to 42%. And she is now 60,000 votes ahead in Texas with 58% of precincts in. Even if Obama gets more delegates (and there is a legal shit fight brewing over the Texas Caucuses) there is a feeling that just having a lead in the pledged delgates may not be enough to claim a moral victory and get the super delegates falling in behind you. The number of actual votes received seems to be getting more and more support (but not a consensus) as perhaps the best indicator of “moral victory”. But then you have issues like do you include Florida or even allow Florida to vote again?

McCain now the effective nominee

GPS may be driver hazard

The Sydney Morning Herald reports the GPS devices may be a driver hazard. Sigh everything is a potential driver hazard – passengers, radio, drinking water etc etc. In the future almost all cars will have GPS so people need to get used to having them.

My GPS is a particular hazard though. I was telling a friend of Noelle McCarthy’s last week that I have it programmed to speak to me in an female Irish accent so it will sound like Noelle. One has to resist the temptation not to drive down the wrong street just so the GPS will tell you in a strong yet lilting voice to do a u-turn immediately 🙂

Cute Knut

knut1.JPG

Readers will remember cute adorable Knut who made the news last year when animal rights activists said he would be better killed than raised in captivity. I even blogged about him in March 2007.

Anyway he has grown up a fair bit in the last year. Click to go over the break to see a photo of him today.

Continue reading »

Even Dover is fleeing to Australia

You know the exodus to Australia is getting bad when a sitting Labour MP announces he is off to Australia a few weeks after he gets out of Parliament.

When Samuels quits Parliament he will be replaced by Su’a William Sio. Sio, a trade unionist, is Deputy Mayor of Manukau City and Labour Candidate for Mangere. A profile says:

Su’a, who like Taito is Samoan and has strong links to the trade union movement, has endeared himself to a younger generation of Pacific Islanders by pushing strongly on youth issues and community initiatives. Politically he is thought to be conservative because of his strong church links. But he has also embraced the achievements of Pacific peoples in the arts, sports and music, and sharing a vision of a future where the impact of Pacific peoples in the wider communities will be felt at all levels, especially in business.

Di Yates is due to be pushed out in a few weeks also. Her replacement will be Brendon Burns – Labour’s Christchurch Central candidate.

Labour will be very pleased having two of their candidates able to access taxpayer funds to help with their campaigns legitimate parliamentary communications.

UPDATE: I thought Dover was one of those packing his bags early and resigning.  It seems he is staying put until the election.  In which case S’ua will be Yates replacement and Burns will have to wait for November or hope a List MP gets a really really bad cold 🙂

Gary Gygax dies

New MP Louisa Wall

The Herald covers the swearing in and maiden speech of new Labour MP Louisa Wall. She replaces Ann Hartley who has been “promoted” to the North Shore City Council.

I knew Louisa had been s Silver Fern but wasn’t aware she had also been a Black Fern. And even better she is keen to play rugby for the parliamentary rugby team. I love the idea of the team having a woman player in it – their opponents will probably stupidly under rate her and be left wondering what happened as Wall sprints away to score tries.

Dom Post on District Health Boards

A good thing may emerge from the sacking of the Hawke’s Bay District Health Board just a couple of months after they were elected. A questioning of the whole DHB structure.

Up until these events, people like myself who advocated DHBs should not be elected, were a very quiet minority. A month ago Matthew Hooton wouldn’t have been able to joke that he thinks Cunliffe should sack all 23 DHBs.

But by showing how DHBs are there to do as the Minister tells them, and that they have little control over important stuff such as funding, the Emperor’s new clothes are displayed.

So we see the Dom Post today saying:

Before Labour formed the government in 1999, health spokeswoman Annette King promised to return democracy to public healthcare, writes The Dominion Post. She argued people were agitating to get back around health board tables so they could have a say in what services their public hospital should provide.

Enter, in 2000, 21 district health boards, each with its own government-appointed chair.

The boards are a cruel hoax. Just how cruel was underlined last week when a King successor, David Cunliffe, sacked the board Hawkes’ Bay voters elected just months earlier and installed a “commissioner” instead. …

The need for a commissioner in the Bay reinforces the health management trick perpetrated on the public. Since DHBs were born, this Government has pretended that their seven-elected, four government-appointed members are those who decide local healthcare priorities. It has also deflected criticism of government funding and priorities their way.

What it has deliberately downplayed is the fact that it, via the Health Ministry, still pulls the strings by setting board budgets and circumscribing their activities. It has also glossed over the reality that, though communities go through a three-yearly charade of half-heartedly electing board members, they serve at the minister’s plea sure. That brutal fact has now come home to Hawke’s Bay voters. …

Mr Cunliffe’s strong faith in his own ability will be no more than self-aggrandisement unless he has the courage to tell the prime minister Labour’s fatally flawed health board model needs fundamental, albeit gradual, overhaul. He won’t. National, if it forms the next government, apparently plans no change, either. Because the electorate doesn’t trust it over public healthcare, it will tread lightly. …

They are indeed a charade and a hoax. The Minister should appoint the DHBs (and there should be less of them) and the Government should be accountable to the publci for their performance.

Hansard Quotes

Some quotes from Hansard relating to yesterday’s question time in the House:

Hon Tony Ryall: Is the Minister aware of the email that shows that chief executive Chris Clarke instructed staff to send draft tender documents to Mr Hausmann—who had indicated he would be a bidder—some weeks before the tender process opened, and before any other bidder saw the documents; and is this acceptable behaviour?

Surely this is a joke. No CEO would have draft tender documents sent weeks early to a potential bidder, and even more so if they are on your Board.

Hon Tony Ryall: Is he aware of this email that shows that Mr Hausmann, appointed by the Labour Government, having received this confidential draft tender document, proposed changes that would benefit his company, and is that what he would expect of someone being appointed to the board of that very district health board?

If I got inside information on a government tender, I wouldn’t suggest changes to it. I’d delete it unread.

Hon Tony Ryall: Is he aware from this email that the chief executive agreed to alter the tender documents in precisely the terms proposed by Mr Hausmann, at a time when no other bidder had such access, and is that a proper and ethical process?

Now Tony must be kidding again. Surely no CEO would actually let the party planning to put in a bid for the tender, rewrite the tender document to better suit them.

Hon Tony Ryall: Is he aware that the final document that went out to all tenderers incorporated the changes proposed by Mr Hausmann, whose company was the eventual successful party, and does he think that all potential bidders were fairly treated equally in this process?

Maybe he isn’t kidding.

Hon Tony Ryall: I seek leave to table the emails and documents mentioned in my questions.

Leave granted.

Well if the e-mails have been tabled, I guess we can judge for ourselves if Tony was just making this up or these e-mails do actually show what is claimed.

But wait that isn’t all. In the next question, we learn that these harmless e-mails (move on move on nothing to see here – read the official report when we are happy with it) may not quite have been voluntarily handed over the the inquiry team:

Hon Tony Ryall: Is the Minister aware that the material revealing secret emails between Hausmann and the executive, in which Hausmann changed the tender documents to his advantage, was withheld from the inquiry by both parties and came to light only after independent forensic analysis in London of the back-up tapes; and what does that say about the balance of truth in this inquiry?

Now this must be incorrect. Surely a DHB with obligations under the Official Information Act wouldn’t simply delete embarrassing e-mails.

Hon Tony Ryall: Would the Minister have confidence in the chief executive of the Hawke’s Bay District Health Board if it was confirmed to him that this information was withheld and came to light only because of specialised forensic analysis in Britain of the back-up tapes, which were mysteriously damaged?

The back-up tapes were damaged? What an unfortunate coincidence. Please do not connect the dots. The dots have nothing to do with each other.

Auckland Airport Roundup

Lots written on Auckland Airport today. I’ll divide it up into the legal, political, and economic. First of all look at this story by Audrey Young:

On Monday night, after the Australian sharemarket closed, the Government changed overseas investment rules ensuring that if even the Overseas Investment Commission approved the sale, the two ministers with the final say, Clayton Cosgrove and David Parker, would be able to say “no” and withstand judicial review.

I would not be so confident about it withstanding judicial review. Despite attempts to isolate the two decision making Ministers, it is obvious that the issue has been pre-determined for them. And as Chris Carter found out with the Whangamata marina, the Courts do not like Ministers pre-determining issues.

On the political side, Vernon Small blogs:

Labour is cock-a-hoop today over the Auckland Airport (we-won’t-let-it-be-bought-by-a-Canadian-pension-fund-but-don’t-want-to-say-it-that-blatantly) regulation change.

Just a day after Prime Minister Helen Clark predicted the ‘fun would begin’ once National started debating policy John Key has looked surprisingly leaden-footed in response to the change – a popular move with the electorate, I would imagine, but one which National would instinctively reject.

National’s response hasn’t been particularly well-targeted it seems to me. The issues I would focus on are:

  • One shouldn’t change the rules at the last second – moves like that destroy investment and jobs and push up interest rates
  • The rules should be clear as to what is and is not allowed, and this change means no one will be sure now what the ground rules are

Tracy Watkins has an article in the Dom Post, with the headline being “Nats will not ban airport sale”. Now please bear in mind Tracy does not write the headline even though it is her story. The headline though is a misleading one as it suggests Labour is banning the sale, and they are not. They are changing the rules, but they are not banning it.

On the economic front NZ Herald economic editor Brian Fallow looks at the dangers:

The Government is running risks with New Zealand’s reputation as an investment destination by suddenly turning Overseas Investment Office approval, long a rubber stamp, into a serious hurdle for the Canadian bid for Auckland Airport.

It has changed the rules in the closing minutes of the game.

And it does this reckless thing at the worst possible time.

The country has for 20 years enthusiastically taken advantage of the opportunities globalisation provides to access foreign capital.

Had we not, had we relied on what we ourselves are prepared to save and invest, the economy would be a lot smaller than it is.

Indeed.

Fran O’Sullivan counts the cost:

Helen Clark’s Government has wiped hundreds of millions of dollars off Auckland Airport’s value in a vainglorious move to exert “local control” over an asset that passed into majority private ownership more than a decade ago. …

The upshot is that New Zealand’s hard-won reputation as a “fair dealer” that welcomes foreign investment has now been carelessly hammered by a Government which is bent on milking the Auckland International Airport takeover for political advantage.

What Helen Clark and Finance Minister Michael Cullen forget as they blatantly ramp up the foreign investment bogey during election year is that the 50,000 retail shareholders in Auckland Airport also have votes.

The NZ Herald Editorial labels the move xenophobia:

This is populist politicking, pure and simple. An administration reeling in the polls has stooped to courting xenophobia. Only that explains the timing of the intervention. If the Government genuinely viewed this as the right policy, it could have acted when the airport first attracted overseas interest.

Andrew James in the Dom Post reports:

More than $300 million was wiped off Auckland International Airport’s market value after the Government introduced a late rule change …

$300 million wiped out.

And The Press editorial weighs things up:

… But it is doubtful if it is much more amenable to the national interest — whatever that is — under its present ownership than under Canadian ownership. Both owners would be subject to the same laws and regulations, and liable to the same pressures from governments local and national. Both owners would seek to maximise their profits and returns to shareholders. Materially, the only difference to occur under Canadian ownership would be a larger flow of profits offshore.

New Zealand does not have the capital or human resources to fuel its development, but it does not like the large foreign inflow of people and finance that development needs. The way to solve the conundrum is not to pass regulations but to upskill New Zealanders and make them more wealthy. Then they could own and manage their assets.

The Press gets it somewhat wrong with saying more profits would flow overseas. Because the domestic money freed up from any sale could well result in more money flowing to NZ from overseas.

The Visible Hand  in Economics deals with this and other economic issues. Gives a nice list of benefits and costs of foreign investment.

Most important issues facing students

Salient asked some MPs and candidates on campus some questions, including “In your opinion, what is the most important issue facing students at the moment?”

Here’s their initial responses:

Mark Blumsky (National): Student loans.

Heather Roy (ACT): Student loans …

Sue Kedgley (Greens): How to pay for the crippling debt.

Grant Robertson (Labour): Keeping Labour in Government …

Phil Howison (Libertarianz): Getting government out of students lives …

Hmmn, spot the answer which is most revealing.

Greenpeace attacks Govt emissions trading scheme

Greenpeace has commissioned a report on the proposed NZ Emissions Trading Scheme.

Now I blogged last Friday on how the Flexible Land Use Alliance warned that the proposed scheme would lock up land into uneconomic uses, and could cost billions of dollars. Almost every party in Parliament has backed their compromise option.

So what does Greenpeace have to say? Are they defending the proposed scheme? Let’s read the report and see what their summary is:

The current proposal for the structure of the ETS will deliver no significant reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, will act as an impediment to the rapid implementation of less carbon intensive production technologies in the manufacturing industry and will do nothing to slow the destruction of forests to make way for increasingly greenhouse gas intensive forms of dairy farming.

They then ask Will the NZ ETS deliver significant emission reductions?

The simple answer to this question is no.

Wow that’s a blunt answer.  The ETS simply won’t work in reducing emissions significantly.  And what will it cost?

If emissions growth is at the higher end of the Treasury forecasts then, at a world price of $25 per tonne, New Zealand would need to import at least $3.1 billion worth of emission permits.

So Greenpeace are saying the ETS will cost NZ $3.1 billion and it won’t actually significantly reduce emissions.  Ummm, doesn’t that mean if Greenpeace are correct, you’d have to be pretty crazy to implement such a scheme?

Five vie for Rotorua

The Rotorua Review lists the five candidates seeking the National Party candidacy for Rotorua. There were probably more than five originally, but pre-selection rules requires the selection meeting to have no more than five candidates. The five are:

  • Sandra Kai Fong – lawyer
  • Alan Hulton – property investor
  • Hamuera Mitchell – Ngati Whakaue Tribal Lands Trust chairman
  • Todd McClay – company manager (and former Cook Islands Ambassador to the EU)
  • Don Hammond – forestry consultant

The selection meeting is on 19 March. There are lots of selection meetings in March but I don’t know all the dates off hand.

On the new boundaries Rotorua has a paper majority to National of 366. Steve Chadwick is fairly well respected so will be no pushover but she will have to work hard to hold the seat against a likely big nationwide swing.

King on Hausmann

 There is a very useful article in the Dom Post with Annette King commenting on her appointment of Peter Hausmann to the Hawke’s Bay District Health Board:

Former health minister Annette King is standing by her decision to appoint Peter Hausmann to Hawke’s Bay District Health Board, and says she was not advised against doing so.

That is a peculiar thing to say when it is later reported:

Former board chairman Kevin Atkinson, who was sacked with the rest of the board last week, told The Dominion Post he advised Ms King on two occasions – in person and over the phone – to delay the appointment of Mr Hausmann till the tender process was completed.

and

An internal ministry e-mail from a senior analyst to the ministry’s DHB governance manager, Bruce Anderson, dated August 28, 2005, and obtained under the Official Information Act, identifies the ministry’s concerns.

The ministry advised that Mr Hausmann’s position on the board, even if he did not take part in discussions about the contract, would not address the public’s perception of fairness and might deter other companies from bidding for the tender.

King goes on to say:

Ms King said Mr Hausmann was appointed with the expectation that his conflicts of interests would be managed.

“Most potential board members do have potential conflicts of interest,” she said.

“That is not the issue. It is how they are managed and the disclosure of them.

“If handled at a governance level appropriately, these are not a problem.”

The issue of conflicts of interests is a vital one for DHBs. If they do not manage them well, then you can end up with what happened in Auckland with a massive laboratory testing contract cancelled by the High Court. So this is not a minor issue.

But Annette misses the major point. Yes many DHB members have conflicts of interests – but these are generally the result of DHB elections. Voters tend to vote for anyone with Dr in front of their name. The whole point of the Ministerial appointees is to balance the Board up with people not conflicted. And sure some Ministerial appointees may have minor conflicts but this was the largest possible conflict one could have – heading up a company which would tender for a $50 million contract.

Managing such a conflict is always going to be very very tough, even if everyone behaved perfectly (and there seems to be some evidence they did not). You see it is not just about having the DHB select the best company for the contract, but being able to manage that contract afterwards. If the contractor doesn’t perform as well as expected, it is a awful situation to manage if the contractor’s CEO sits on your own board.

I don’t subscribe any evil ulterior motives to Annette King in her appointment of Hausmann. I just can’t understand why she would have done it. The Board Chair was advising against it (and it is very very rare to appoint a Director against the wishes of a Chair), the Ministry of Health raised issues about it, and she knew he was going to be tendering for a major contract. Why create all these problems which could have been avoided by simply not appointing Hausmann or appointing him to another DHB where he wouldn’t have been conflicted?

Let me put it another way. If Annette King had not insisted on appointing Hausmann, does anyone think the DHB would have ended up sacked as has now happened?

This is not to say Hausmann himself is to blame (I do await the reports with interest though), for he was placed in a position by King where fallout like this was almost inevitable.

UPDATE: Tony Ryall has read in the House from some explosive e-mails, and has also alleged they were not given to the inquiry but recovered by forensic experts in London. I’ll blog the Hansard when it is available.

Nine to Noon politics

Just been listening to yesterday’s politics segment on Nine to Noon:

  •  Matthew Hooton spoke on how Maori Party may have overhang of six seats, and well placed to help choose the next Government
  • Laila Harre says Labour can not form Government without the Maori Party and without an overhang for the Maori Party. That will doom MMP in my opinion if a Government only gets a majority because of the overhang
  • Harre  says if there was a credible alternative to Clark her leadership would be under threat, but there is no credible alternative
  • Hooton points out Goff is 0% in preferred PM polls, and he will be grateful for that because if he was at 5% or so, then he might be pressured to stand.
  • Best lines were Hooton saying “I always support any sacking of any District Health Board” and “if he wants to be bold, he should sack them all” 🙂
  • But went on to say that sacking a board just 72 days after it was elected seems unwise, especially with allegations which involve another Government Minister.
  • Also funny was when Matthew asked Kathryn Ryan and Laile Harre who the voted for on their local DHB and let’s say there were no quick answers. Hell I doubt I can even recall who I voted for without checking.
  • Harre doesn’t support DHB amalgamations

Always my favourite Nine to Noon segment – but I am a politics junkie.

What I find interesting is I listen to half a dozen Nine to Noon items a week – but none of them live – all from their website.

Which way will the Maori Party go?

I find it very amusing to see so many on the left start to hug the Maori Party and claim that it is unthinkable for the Maori Party not to support Labour after the next election. Because some of them used to say the exact opposite.

Jordan Carter blogged in 2005 on how the Maori Party is *not* on the left:

It seems to me that the Maori Party’s ambition is to work back towards an illusory golden past of Maoridom, where individuality is subsumed under collective whanau, hapu and iwi identities. This is highlighted by the constant references to whanau, hapu and iwi in their speeches; by their hostility to the inevitable effects of modernity and the Enlightenment on Maori society; by their desire to see social services dominated by a Maori “Aristocracy” (also known as iwi-based service agencies) rather than the universal services provided by the welfare state.

A more conservative – in fact reactionary – approach to politics is hard to imagine. If a pakeha-based party was out campaigning for the restoration of the great landed estates as there were in England; supporting the putting of economic and social power back in the hands of the elites; undermining the national institutions of common citizenship that bind us together – that party would be laughed out of political existence within minutes.

And it gets better:

That party stands for the antithesis of left wing politics, and of liberal politics. It seeks to turn around Maori society and take it back to some non-existent glorious past, and in so doing create a new privileged elite that can exert the kind of social control of the past. These are not its policies – the policies are more middle of the road than this analysis allows; I am talking about the values and the direction they want to go.

It has nothing to do with the challenges that truly face Maori society in the 21st century. It has no answers to poverty or disadvantage or structural racism or the fight for social and economic equality. It has nothing to do with the left. On that basis, the miracle of Turia’s time in the Labour Party is that it lasted so long; not that she left. The stunning ineptitude of most of our media means that the party has been pained as Labour friendly, when it is the opposite.

And finally:

I know some wet urban liberals who are thinking of voting for the Maori Party. I just hope they realise that if they do, they are voting for a party of the conservative right, which would be much more comfortable in coalition with parties that shared its hostility to the State and to national collective institutions – National and ACT – than it would be dealing with the progressive elements in National and with the bulk of the Labour Party.

Sadly the realities of politics may mean that my party has to deal with these people post election, just as it may mean we have to deal with NZ First, but even NZ First is not as bad (from my point of view) as the Maori Party. At least they fall within a recognisably relevant set of issues – fear of cultural change, populism, economic and social nationalism and so on.

And more recently in 2007:

But when the rubber hits the road, in real hard edged policy debates, they always seem to end up siding with the right.

Anyone on the left who supports the party is simply making a National government more likely. I thank the Maori Party leadership for continuing to demonstrate that on a regular basis.

Now I’ve fairly consistently advocated the opposite – that in fact the Maori Party is more left leaning than right leaning. Their voting record backs up my assertion. Over time I believe the Maori Party will support Labour more often than National. But that is not to say they will back Labour every single time.

So having said that, I think anyone who states with certainty what the Maori Party will do post 2008 election is just jerking off. There will be multiple factors in play:

  • What policy agreements can be reached
  • How much vote each major party got (like NZF and UFNZ last time they may give first option to the largest party)
  • Personal relationships between MPs
  • What Cabinet positions are offered, if sought
  • How many seats the Maori Party wins
  • What they think their supporters will want
  • What deal they think will be best for the Maori Party and for Maori

John Armstrong in the Herald reports on a faux pax by Pita Sharples though:

Commenting on National Radio on Sunday’s Marae-DigiPoll survey, the Maori Party co-leader initially said the findings made it “easy” for his party to go into some kind of governing arrangement with National after the election.

No sooner had he uttered the word “easy” than he had modified it to the much safer and less definite “easier”.

Labour have used this to attack the Maori Party by saying a vote for them is a vote for National. Not the most sensible tactics I would have thought as on current polls the Maori Party is Labour’s only hope of a 4th term.