NZ Law Journal Editorial
I see in the Dom Post there is a NZ Law Journal editorial on the Electoral Finance Act.
Could a friendly lawyer please e-mail me a text or pdf of the editorial.
Watch this video of American actress Amy Walker talking in 21 different accents, including New Zealand. She’s better than Bolger was at accents đ
Hat Tip: Spare Room (who have a great video everyday)
I see in the Dom Post there is a NZ Law Journal editorial on the Electoral Finance Act.
Could a friendly lawyer please e-mail me a text or pdf of the editorial.
The Southland Times has a story about a page on Bebo purporting to be from former or current McDonalds staff there.
I chatted to the reporter for quite a while about what alternatives were open to the McDonalds. They quote:
Technology commentator David Farrar, of Wellington, said McDonald’s could ask the site’s makers to remove its logos and intellectual property, but not order it to be removed in New Zealand, he said.
He suggested the best tact for McDonald’s would be to not over-react.
McDonalds seem to sensibly be avoiding an over-reaction:
Invercargill McDonald’s owner Trevor Rogan, who was unaware of the site when approached by The Southland Times said he was concerned about the content on the site.
However, neither he nor McDonald’s national headquarters would be trying to shut down the site, saying it was “freedom of speech”.
Mr Rogan’s concerns centred on the language used, the official McDonald’s logo being used on the site, and the 20 drive-through rules.
The site is obviously tongue in cheek and I doubt anyone would take a Bebo page as being an official McDonalds site. Especially one that advocates if there are drunk people in your car you shoudl tell them to shut the f**k up đ
The Government’s decision to change overnight without warning the rules around overseas investment into NZ is surely a sign of poll panic leading to a desperate attempt at populism.
This is not just about Auckland Airport. That deal was looking shaky anyway. It is about having consistent rules that are not changed halfway through a process. And it is also about having a degree of objectivity about over investment decisions.
Financial journalist Bernard Hickey blogs:
The governmentâs decision overnight to invent a new rule that allows it to block the sale of Auckland Airport is a stunning turnaround of decades of official policy. It will hurt our ability to encourage foreign investors to come here and help us pay for our current account deficit. It is also another sign that the government is on its last legs. Fearing it may not be in power for too much longer, it is showing its true colours and is embedding its naturally anti-foreign-investment instincts into law.Â
Suddenly the government has decided that selling the Auckland Airport is a bad idea. It has invented a rule that says it can block any sale of âstrategically important infrastructure on sensitive landâ …
I believe there could be a lot of sensitive land out there that needs to be protected from foreign investors. After all, this land could be insulted or bruised in many ways. Are you confident that a minister of the crown can decide this for the nation without reference to Parliament or voters in an election? And will foreign investors give our government the benefit of the doubt whenever theyâre considering buying an asset here on âsensitive landâ? Â
There are a hundred of these types of assets on this type of land. What about our banking system? There is no more strategic asset. Should the buildings with the servers hosting all our accounts be seized back by the government? I jest just a little here, but it shows the absurdity of this decision and how it could be extrapolated by an even more insensitive and insane government. For example, what about the assets of Fletcher Building. It is held in large part by foreign investors and is responsible for a good chunk of New Zealandâs public and private infrastructure building. Sounds a good enough reason to stop foreigners from owning it.
Read Bernard’s full column. It is justifiably scathing. This is a kneejerk abandonment of a decades old policy. And it is not a reversal after public consultation, and careful policy analysis. It is poll driven panic politics. Bernard goes on:
And finally, what was the government of a debtor nation with a current account deficit of around 8% of GDP thinking? That it doesnât matter if we discourage foreign investment? That the foreign institutional investors will understand if we change our minds about the fundamental rules of the game right at the end of a bidding war? That they wonât mind? This is a plainly dumb thing to do when we need foreign investors to keep funding our way of life and building up our infrastructure. We spend more than we earn. We need to borrow from foreigners to do that or we need to encourage foreign investment.
What will turning off foreign investors mean for voters? It will mean higher interest rates on mortgages. When foreign investors believe we are a riskier proposition, they will increase the risk premium they demand for the money they lend us. That will increase wholesale interest rates and that will be passed on (as weâve found in recent weeks) to us in the form of higher mortgage rates.
What on earth was the government thinking? Clearly, it was not thinking clearly at all.
And NBR Editor Nevil Gibson writes:
The simple take from the governmentâs decision to tighten overseas investment rules is that the countryâs ports and airports will be run more by political whim than business strategy.
In a sudden move, taken a year after the first move by overseas interests to take control of Auckland International Airport, the new rules extend the âimportance of local controlâ to the approval process.
Under the Overseas Investment Act regime, two cabinet ministers have to approve changes of ownership of âsensitive land.â In other words, political imperatives are paramount to business ones.
Even if one agrees with the rule change, the way the Government has gone about it is atrocious. The Canadian Pension Fund could have saved millions of dollars if it was told a year ago, the Government will not allow the airport to be sold. They could have announced an intention a year ago to change to the rules and consult on them. Investors – both domestic and foreign – will be very wary of a Government which acts so capriciously. And as Bernard Hickey says – the price may come in higher interest rates.
Phil Goff makes short shift of Russel Norman’s scare mongering over the free trade agreement with China:
Comments by Greens co-leader Russel Norman that: âParliament has no say over this (China Trade) agreementâ, is absolutely incorrect, says Trade Minister Phil Goff.
âThe China trade agreement cannot come into effect without parliamentary scrutiny and support. Dr Norman should acquaint himself better with New Zealandâs parliamentary system,â Mr Goff said.
âThe full agreement and a National Impact Analysis will be tabled in Parliament at the time the Agreement is signed, and will be posted on the Web.
âThis process will allow parliamentary and public scrutiny of the agreement, with the Foreign Affairs, Trade and Defence Committee likely to call for public submissions on it.
âLegislation then has to be introduced for the agreement to be given effect in domestic law, and must be passed by Parliament for that to happen.
That’s a great serving by Goff. Especially where he suggests that Norman, not yet an MP, doesn’t even know how Parliament works.
âIt is likely that this legislation will receive overwhelming support in the House, though of course this remains to be tested.
I’d be appalled if National doesn’t support it. The Greens will of course be against – as they seem to be against all trade agreements. What will be very interesting is how NZ First votes. Their previous voting record and rhetoric means they should vote against. But Winston will be aware of how bad it will look for the Foreign Minister to vote against a trade agreement. As his party has no decision making capability excluding him, I suspect he will make them vote for it.
âWhile I cannot comment on the detail of the agreement while it is still going through final technical discussions and has yet to be submitted to Cabinet for final approval, I can say that the sort of suggestions made by Dr Norman are nonsense.
âFree movement of labour, for example, has never been considered by anyone as part of the negotiation. To even make that suggestion is absurd.
Sounds like a scare-mongering tactic worthy of Winston – beware the hoards moving here to take your job!
âThe Greens appear to have already made up their minds to oppose a trade agreement with China, New Zealandâs third largest trading partner and fastest growing export market.
âHowever, it would be more sensible for them to first examine what the agreement actually involved, which all parties in parliament will soon have the opportunity to do,â Mr Goff said.
I’m going to take a punt and predict that no matter what the details are of it, the Greens will be against it.
This is one area where I am very supportive of the Government – depending of course on the final details.
Russel Norman has responded on Frog Blog.
For those who haven’t followed it, Australian conservative commentator Andrew Bolt blogged how he met me at the NZBR retreat. I then returned the favour.
In my comments George Darroch posted a long list of awful things Andrew has said, saying his views “border on insanity”.
The only problem, as Andrew pointed out back on both my blog and on his blog is that not a single one of the 16 comments Darroch attributed to Andrew, were made by Andrew. They were simply comments by others on his blog. Most people can tell the difference between a comment and a post.
Anyway after the publicity of being called to account on Australia’s most widely read blog, George has apologised to Andrew. Oh and then made it a Claytons apology by demanding Andrew state his opinion on the 16 statements he falsely ascribed to him. Darroch has now also blogged on the issue.
Who needs underarm bowling for a good Trans-Tasman clash đ
Aaron Bhatnagar is having fun,
Cathy Casey from City Vision accused C&R of making diversity a dirty word at the Auckland City Council.
Aaron reveals that what she is complaining about is the decision not to fund a $12,000 cocktail party to celebrate diversity. And just to really have fun, he points out that C&R have five Crs and Community Board members who are ethnically diverse – two Chinese, one Samoan, Aaron (half Indian) and one Maori, while City Vision he labels monochromatic as they don’t have any non Europeans.
And for good measure he posts photos also.
Personally I think City Vision have a political death watch. They’ve spent three months whining about C&R cutting funding to various politically correct causes. C&R will just slaughter them in 2011 (if all other things stay even) by publishing the list of all the things they have saved the ratepayer from funding and how City Vision would have rates skyrocketing for their pet projects.
Following the Herald and TV3 polls both out today, Curia’s monthly newsletter summarising the public polls in NZ and abroad will be published tomorrow.
The graph above shows the average of all the public polls since the election. February 2008 includes all six polls in February.
It also includes the normal round-up from Australia, the US, the UK and Canada. In Australia Kevin Rudd has a massive 29% lead over the Coalition.
This newsletter is only available by e-mail. If you would like to receive future issues go to http://listserver.actrix.co.nz/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/polling-newsletter to subscribe yourself.
Marc Ambinder at The Atlantic blogs on the numbers showing how tough it will be for Hillary Clinton to pull back Obama’s lead. He finds that even a rosy scenario has Clinton only reducing Obama’s lead by 60 – 80 delegates.
Colin Espiner blogs on the latest polls.
Keeping Stock blogs a quote from Helen Clark on the sacking of the Hawke’s Bay District Health Board:
“But my view is that I don’t really care what the rights and wrongs of what was going on within the board are – I don’t believe that you can run a decent health service for the people of Hawke’s Bay while that is going on.”
I should think the PM should deeply care about the rights and wrongs. The members of the DHB whose reputations are affected by this sacking certainly care.
Russell Brown comments on his blog on the context around the photo of him at the Hero Debate.
Whale Oil has a video on Labour’s health problems.
Paul Walker has a hilarious video on economics. Yes seriously it is funny.
Nice of the taxpayer to provide free meeting space for worthy groups. See below e-mail:
Date: Sun, 2 Mar 2008 22:50:23 +1300
From:
To:
Subject: Reminder: Harbour Branch AGM – Monday 3 MarchDear Harbour Branch members,
This email is to remind you of the Harbour Branch AGM, which will take place on Monday 3 March from 6.30pm-7.30pm at Marian Hobbs’ Electorate Office on Willis St. We will follow the AGM with drinks – at a place to be decided on the night!
If you are interested in any of the Officer or Delegate positions listed below, please let me know in advance, or attend the meeting.
The Agenda is as follows:
1. Apologies
2. Confirmation of Minutes of previous AGM
3. Matters Arising
4. Correspondence
5. Election of Officers – Chair, Vice Chair, Secretary, Treasurer, Women’s Liaison Officer
6. Election of delegates to the Labour Electorate Committee
7. Election of delegates to Region 4 (Wellington) List Conference
Note: The Regional List selection is being held on Saturday 15 March
8. General Business – Election year campaigning and fundraising
I look forward to seeing you there.
Best wishes,
—
Secretary | Harbour Branch
Not that I think it is a big deal. I am sure that is not the only office to host a party meeting, but in Wellington especially I would have thought the presence of Labour’s own head office would be a better location.
Powerline came to fame as the blog which played the biggest role in exposing the the documents used by CBS 60 minutes regarding Bush’s Air Guard service as likely fakes. Dan rather and others lost their jobs over their part in a story where their desire to get someone they didn’t like over-rode all the normal checking of facts and authenticity.
Well Power Line may have just done it again. Read this masterful dissection of another 60 Minutes programme.
The CBS programme allaged that Karl Rove requested an Alabama lawyer to follow (now jailed) Democratic Alabama Governor Don Siegelman around and try to get photos on him in bed with a female aide.
Read the Power Line post which powerfully raises huge questions over the credibility of the woman making the allegations. CBS better hope for their own sake they have improved their standards since the last time.
All the media are full of the news that the latest Marae DigiPoll had the Maori Party ahead in all seven Maori seats. But people should be aware of the very small sample sizes when you break it down into each electorate.
A helpful journalist has passed on the full data released by Marae/DigiPoll so I’m able to go into some detail on the results.
Party Vote
First let us look at the consolidated results for the sample of 1,003 Maori with 665 on the Maori roll and 338 on the general roll. This has a margin of error of 3.1%:
On the party vote, the Maori Party is 38% and Labour 37%, followed by National on 15%.
Breaking into the two rolls, the margin of error is 3.9% for the Maori roll and 5.4% for the General Roll.
On the Maori Roll the party vote is 49% Maori Party, 33% Labour and 9% National. On the General Roll the vote is 11% Maori Party, 46% Labour and 29% National.
Now note that the proportions of Maori on the Maori and General roll are not actually 2/3 to 1/3. The last Maori Option found 58% of Maori chose to be on the Maori roll and 42% on the General roll. If you apply those percentages to the separate party vote for the general and Maori rolls, then the weighted party vote for all adult Maori would be Maori Party 33%, Labour 38% and National 17%.
Electorate Vote
Those on the Maori Roll were asked their electorate vote preference, in terms of party affiliation. 56% chose Maori Party over 28% Labour.
But it gets less clear when you break it down into the seven seats. 665 respondents over seven seats is an average of 95 per seat which is a whopping margin of error of 10.3%.
But that is not to say one can’t take some indications from the results. You can calculate for each electorate what the probability is that the leading candidate is in fact ahead of the other candidate. Going through the seven electorates, we have the Maori Party result followed by the Labour Party result:
The Maori Party, beyond doubt, is leading in the four seats it currently holds. There is a greater than 95% chance that it is leading in Ikaroa-Rawhiti and Te Tai Tonga – and hence well placed to pick them up.
The one which is less certain is Tainui. There is a significant 20% probability that Labour actually leads in that seat. You really need a larger poll sample when the result is that close.
However one factor which may help the Maori Party is that the boundaries for Tainui have changed and are now less favourable for Labour in the new seat of Hauraki-Waikato. So that makes it a bit harder for Nanaia Mahuta to hold her seat.
My overall conclusion is that the Maori Party look well placed to win six out of seven seats, and the seventh seat is too close to call but leans Maori Party.
Other Issues
Satisfaction ratings for all respondents:
The most important issues for Maori on the Maori roll are Education 16%, Treaty Issues 14%, Health 11%, Tax Cuts 9% and Law & Order 8%.
For Maori on the general roll, is is Health 18%, Tax Cuts 16%, Law & Order 12%, Education 9% and Treaty Issues 3%.
Last week a commenter, Bogus News, has seemingly been busy doing some research. He produced this list, which was reproduced and added to by Keeping Stock:
Removing the $1,890 cap on charitable donations. Donations of any amount, up to an individualâs total net income, will be eligible for the 33.3% rebate. Removing the 5% cap on the level of donations that can be deducted by companies and Maori Authorities.
National announced on 27 February 2007
Government announced in 2007 Budget
Full-cost funding for community groups that better covers the true costs of service delivery. Less bureaucracy and fewer compliance costs.
National announced on 16 May 2007
Government announced in 2008 Prime Ministerâs Statement
All payments which reimburse volunteers for actual and reasonable expenses will be tax free, regardless of the amount of the payment. Honoraria payments will be tax free up to an amount of $500 per year per person.
National announced on 16 May 2007
Government released a discussion document on 1 November 2007
A greater emphasis on trades training in schools. Giving schools more flexibility to offer their students trades and industry training opportunities outside their school-gates. Expanding school-based apprenticeship training.
National announced on 18 June 2007
Government announced on 30 January 2008
Giving the police the ability to issue time-bound, on-the-spot protection orders to protect families.
National announced on 1 November 2007
Government issued discussion document in mid-December 2007
Committing all fuel tax revenues to the National Land Transport Fund.
National had in 2005 election policy;
Labour announced on 25 July 2007
Serious consideration of Public Private Partnerships for roading projects.
National policy for many years â most recently confirmed on 17 Sep 2007;
Government announced on 7 February 2008
Allowing lines companies to invest in generation, especially from renewable energy sources.
National had in 2005 election policy;
Government introduced with Electricity Industry Reform Amendment Bill, first reading 11 Dec 2007.
Devolving carbon credits to post-1990 forest owners
National announced on 6 March 2007;
Government announced on 20 September 2007
An emissions trading scheme to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
National proposed on 6 October 2006;
Labour announced on 20 September 2007
A multi-year programme of personal tax cuts
National policy for many years;
Government announced on 7 February 2008
Reducing the rate of business tax from 33% to 30%
National had in 2005 election policy;
Labour announced in 2007 Budget
Promoting housing affordability by freeing up the supply of land and cutting building compliance costs
National announced on 5 Aug 2007;
Government announced in 2008 Prime Ministerâs Statement
As to be expected under MMP, most focus in on the party vote. But electorates are also important to parties. It hurt Labour badly to lose 10 seats to National in 2005.
Currently National and Labour have 31 seats each. And they got almost the same share of the electorate vote in 2005 – 40.38% for National and 40.35% for Labour.
Now seats never quite fall in a linear way, but one can apply a linear swing to majorities, to get some idea of what seats may fall to National if the current polls continue.
The last Colmar Brunton poll has the electorate vote for National at 48% and for Labour at 35%. This is a relative increase in National’s EV of 19% and a relative drop for Labour of 13%.
So which seats (new boundaries have been taken into account) would on paper go to National, if that was the linear swing on the electorate vote?
That would reduce Labour to 23 seats. But a Marae Digi-poll out on Sunday had the Maori Party ahead in all seven Maori seats. If they pick up the other three, then Labour would be down to just 20 electorate seats out of 70.
So is that the worse case scenario? Well no. This is based on a poll which has National ahead of Labour by just 13% in the EV. The previous CB poll had Nat 55% EV and Lab 33%. If that (unlikely) result had a linear application, how many more seats would fall:
Also Rimutaka and Waitakere (Pillay) get reduced to under 500 vote majorities for Labour. If they also got taken on a bad swing, Labour would be reduced to 13 electorate seats.
Now these are not predictions by any means – it is just a linear application of poll results. There is no way anyone will be winning Otaki by 5,000 votes. I expect Nathan Guy and Darren Hughes to have a very close contest. They are both good MPs. The retirement of Steve Maharey might make Palmerston North very interesting.
Labour will have an interesting challenge with their list rankings. They want to rejuvenate and have some new MPs after the election. So one might expect they won’t automatically put sitting MPs at the top of the list. However if they do not protect sitting MPs, then quite a few of them could end up out of Parliament.
Not PC brings us this look-alike image of Dr Cullen and Mr Mackie from South Park.
And Whale Oils adds a new title to a well known brand.
The Herald’s editorial today refers to my questioning of the EPMU’s eligibility to be listed as a third party under the Electoral Finance Act:
There is delicious irony in the fact that one of the first victims of the Electoral Finance Act is a labour union. The Engineering, Printing and Manufacturing Union has been muzzled for two months while the Electoral Commission considers an objection to the union’s application for a right to advertise its views in election year.
The irony is no coincidence, of course; the objection has been filed by an opponent of the detestable act, website “blogger” David Farrar. He has no real objection to the union’s running political advertisements this year just as it has done in many previous election years. In fact, like all opponents of the act, he would probably say the union should have every right to exercise the same freedom it had before …
Mr Farrar has set out to make fun of the legislation and his objection has succeeded in that aim, whatever the commission’s ultimate ruling. It is ridiculous that there should need to be a regulatory assessment of the union’s ties to the Labour Party before it can do exactly as it has done in the months before previous elections …
But where, then, should the commission draw the line on who might be allowed to register as a “third party” under the act and advertise in a way that might tend to support a party or candidate standing at the election? Pity the commission; it has been handed this pointless, pin-pricking exercise only because the Labour Party lives in excessive fear of private money in politics …
It is entirely healthy that any organisation – industry association, trade union or religious sect – caring enough for a principle or policy to promote it to the electorate should be allowed to do so. Voters are not fools; money cannot speak louder than the merits of the message it is paying for.
We hope the EPMU receives permission to speak this year and we dare hope the challenge to its political rights has given the architects of the act cause to regret. The gag stands to earn considerably more ridicule before it ends at the election.
The Herald is quite correct that my motivation is not to prevent the EPMU from having a voice in election year. However the issues I raised with the Electoral Commission are not frivolous or done just to delay the EPMU’s application. I have a genuine belief that they are clearly not eligible to register under the law. I would not have written to the Electoral Commission if I did not believe that the law as written means they are ineligible to be registered.
Donna Chisholm in the SST quotes from an Audit Office report on the Hawke’s Bay District Health Board. Now I can’t find the Audit Office report online, but it doesn’t look great for the Government which has effectively sided with Peter Hausmann and the management, by dismissing the entire Board.
Chisholm states the Audit Office reports finds the following:
Now bear in mind this is only a report into the $1.1 million contract. We are yet to see the report into the $50 million contract.
UPDATE: Local MP Craig Foss has several relevant blog posts on this issue, citing board minutes and written questions about the fact the contract was not tendered, and how the CEO told the Board initially it had been.
I now fully back Owen Glenn’s application to be Honorary Consul in Monaco. And no I haven’t suddenly had $90,000 appear inmy bank account I know nothing about!
In an ODT article in the Herald, Simon Cunliffe interviews Glenn who reveals he planned beach volleyball competitions in Monaco if he becomes Honorary Consul. Now anything which promotes beach volleyball around the world is a worthwhile endeavour in my eyes đ
An article on frivolous 111 calls lists the following calls made:
This got me thinking. How exactly do two hedgehogs fight? Answers anyone?
The Government is looking to add an extra year of on-the-job training as a requirement for teacher trainees.
This looks to be a sensible reaction to the problems reported of many trainees not up to scratch. The ERO found:
Almost half of beginner secondary teachers and a third of novice primary teachers did not reach the required level of competence.
That is an appalling situation. The move for an extra year training is a good step in the right direction – but I doubt it is a full solution by itself.
The Herald has a new column (I think just online but not sure) called “Just the facts” by Keith Ng.
Now I’m very supportive of any attempt by the media to fact check claims by politicians – or even to put them into context. And I think Keith generally has a good track record with checking the facts out.
But there is a danger on having just one person set up as “the fact checker”. Factcheck.org in the US had around a dozen staff. Because one’s personal political views can influence what facts you find relevant, what story you tell with facts. There is a reason people refer to “lies, damned lies and statistics”.
As an example, I’ll criticise below one of Keith’s fact checks – not to say I am right and Keith is wrong, but how the use or non use of certain facts can give different impressions:
“Violent youth crime is at an all-time high”.
JOHN KEY (STATE OF THE NATION SPEECH, JAN 29)That’s true, but
Okay the insignificant little detail that John Key is correct is given just two words. Wouldn’t it have been useful to provide the actual statistics on violent youth offending. Then people could judge how significant the increase is. Just two words supporting the fact he is correct, and several hundred words on trying to undermine his assertion.
violent old-people crime is at an all-time high, too. Violent crime for every age group over 13 is, technically, “at an all-time high”, and the fastest growing group of violent offenders is in the 51-99 category.
So the defence to the rise in violent youth crime, is that violent crime is up for all age groups. Okay well why not give us offending rates in say 2000 and 2007 for all age groups so people can see the absolute rates and the growth for each age group.
Boot camp for old people, anyone? Young people commit more violent crimes than people over 30, but the increase is happening across the board.
That looks like sarcasm, not facts. One can have an entire separate debate about “boot camps” – something along the lines of better to turn people away from crime when they are younger. And also the overwhelming support for the policy from experts in the youth offending area. But hey I’m getting away from the facts.
And again why not provide the facts for violent offending of under 30s and over 30s.
Youth crime as a whole is actually decreasing:
Could have been useful to mention that the overall reported crime figures are generally held to be relatively meaningless as they treat murdering someone the same as having a joint on you. One could do an entire article on why the overall crime rate is such a flawed measure – instead of using it as rebuttal to a true statement about violent youth crime offending.
As an alternative why not point out what areas of youth crime are increasing (violent and sexual I think)Â and what areas are decreasing?
2006 saw the lowest number of arrests for youth offending since 1995.
Now the context of the statement is a speech by the National Leader, criticising the current Govt’s policies. Why not compare 2006 to 1999 instead of the previous high of 1995?
When the change in population is taken into account, that’s a 17 per cent decrease over 10 years.
And how much took place from 1995 to 1999, and how much from 2000 to 2006? All facts which would be useful.
I could go through and apply a similar analysis to the other “Just the Facts” articles, but I won’t. The purpose isn’t to attack Keith (who I think is an excellent journalist), but to show that there are dangers in labelling any article as “Just the facts”. It all comes down to what is subjective choices as to which facts to include, whether or not to use absolute or relative data, what time frames to choose etc etc.
I almost overlooked this – Chris Trotter’s column on Friday in the Dominion Post. Trotter advocates more stringly than his previous hints that Labour should make Goff Leader if they want a chance of a fourth term:
Prime Minister Helen Clark’s fast-dwindling coterie of media allies tell us it would be madness. The throng of political journalists hanging around John Key agree. But what, exactly, is mad about the idea of replacing Helen Clark with Phil Goff?
According to the latest Fairfax-Nielsen poll, Labour is now more popular than its leader. That suggests the Government’s catastrophic numbers are being driven by Miss Clark’s unpopularity not the party’s.
This marks an important shift in the electorate’s response. For most of the past eight years the prime minister has consistently outperformed her party in popularity. She was Labour’s greatest asset, the wind beneath its wings. She has now become the lump of lead on its back.
A lump of lead. Trotter is not going for a subtle approach.
In that respect, at least, Peter Dunne is right about New Zealand’s race for the Beehive being similar to the Democratic Party’s race in the United States for the White House.
In their affinity for political managerialism, Helen and Hillary are alike. But, do Mr Key’s speeches echo our own electorate’s hunger for “Hope” and “Change” in the way Barack Obama’s echo America’s?
Yes, in a strange way they do. Mr Key may not be as effective a speaker as Mr Obama, but his personal political narrative (poor boy raised by a solo mum, who transcends his humble origins to achieve remarkable success) is strikingly similar â and so is the way voters have loaded their deep longing for fresh explanations and new beginnings on to the young challenger’s shoulders.
While I think a direct comparison to Obama is silly, Trotter may be right in terms of the analysis of voters looking for a new beginning.
Labour’s caucus needs to get its head around this â and soon. Because the longer it delays replacing Miss Clark as leader, the more time it is allowing for the voters to convince themselves (if they have not already done so) that Mr Key is the prime minister they are looking for.
Ever since the moment a panicked Clark agreed to the compromise on the smacking bill, Key has looked like a prime minister in waiting.
But the electorate does not need to turn to National for “Hope” and “Change”. Indeed, history suggests that the Right is incapable of delivering change or hope in ways remotely beneficial to working people.
But “Hope” and “Change” are Labour’s stock-in-trade: it’s what the party does, has always done.
Miss Clark admirably fulfilled the hopes, and proudly delivered the changes demanded by the zeitgeist of 1999.
If Mr Goff has the wit and the courage to embrace the zeitgeist of 2008, there is no reason why Labour shouldn’t win its fourth term.
Well I can think of a few reasons, and am not convinced that Goff would do better than Clark. The danger for Clark is if any MPs start to think probable disaster is preferable to guaranteed disaster.
No Rught Turn as usual beats the media to reporting that the new Assistant Speaker will be Marian Hobbs.
I guest she must be bored, to volunteer to do the job for just six months.
Michael Laws in his column (and he is on a DHB) describes the true nature of DHBs:
Every piece of legislation that governs DHBs essentially says the same thing.
Your arse is mine. The minister drives policy and everybody else, whether elected or not, is simply there for show. Kevin Atkinson and his Hawke’s Bay DHB forgot that simple truth. They were never in charge; they were elected/appointed to do the minister’s bidding.
But by having some of them elected, it gives the illusion of local control, and gives the Minister scapegoats.
Expecting Cunliffe to “sort out” health would be like asking Winston Peters to sort out the Middle East. It’s not a case of where you would start so much as a case of the complete system is stuffed. Just like the Middle East. You would need a neutron bomb and the sure knowledge that only starting all over again would have any impact.
That’s a fair call. The demand for health is unlimited, so there will never be a truly sorted out health system.
Ministers don’t have that luxury. Instead they get the dubious privilege of managing all the major and mini crises until some other poor bugger gets allocated the portfolio. So they don’t need stroppy DHBs who think that their primary aim is to expose health contract corruption, run deficits and generally deliver way more health services than they are funded for.
Ouch he used the c word.
The truth is that until New Zealand has just four or five DHBs, with the necessary economies of scale and integrated services, and until the public health sector starts paying internationally competitive salaries, then no remedy will be possible. Health ministers know this. But one of their sacred cows is letting the locals labour under the illusion that they are really running their own health services. Reducing, combining or even co-ordinating the current DHBs is essential but too politically difficult.
Illusion is the right word.