Caught by “his own people”

One of the TV bulletins (can’t recall which) reported how Nai Yin Xue was caught by “his own people”.

This got me wondering.  Was he caught be a family member of his?

If not, then what did TV news mean?

And what is so unusual about being caught by people of your own race?  Is there some reason viewers should think it is unusual for Chinese people to turn in a Chinese murderer?

James Allan on Clark

Former Otago Law Professor James Allan writes in The Australian about Helen Clark:

Prime Minister Helen Clark is in big trouble with an election a little more than six months away.

Her Labour Government came into office in 1999, winning that election and the next two. But, unless something drastic happens soon, it will lose office to the right-of-centre National Party later this year. Indeed, it will suffer a noticeably worse defeat than John Howard did in this country.

The Coalition only had 1.5% less than Labor on primary vote and 5.4% less on two-party preferred.  But with FPP even a fairly small margin can lead to a large majority – 18 seats in Australia’s case.

One of the big problems for the Clark Government has to do with comparative economic performance. Soon after coming into office it said one of its main goals was to lift NZ back into the top half of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development league tables in terms of per capita gross domestic product. It hasn’t. Indeed, NZ has dropped a place or two down to 20th or 21st. Little mention is made of this pledge by the Government these days.

One of many goals dropped.  You don’t hear much about Closing the Gaps either anymore.

And taxes are relatively high. The OECD estimates that NZ’s general government receipts are running at 45 per cent of GDP. Australia’s run at about 35 per cent. NZ is even above the OECD average, one that includes the high-taxing Europeans. So despite a lower top marginal tax rate there, it is a high-tax economy.

Yep. NZers pay more tax in pretty much every income bracket up to around $220,000.

In a decade, that would widen the gap from 30 per cent to 40 per cent. Who knows how many Kiwis might then see Australia as an attractive place to live? The brutal truth seems to be that the Clark Government’s emphasis on wealth distribution over wealth creation is seeing the country as a whole do no better than stand still in comparative terms, while Australia is surging ahead, and a few other countries are doing even better.

And Kevin Rudd is very very focused on wealth creation.  Plus he is delivering $31 billion of tax cuts.

Of late, the Government has also indulged in some forays into illiberal lawmaking. The new Electoral Finance Act, passed at the end of last year, was strongly condemned by a surprising range of viewpoints, even by the Human Rights Commission, as putting unacceptable limits on free speech. Then there was the parental anti-smacking law of last year, another of the government-knows-best laws that eventually started to grate on otherwise sympathetic voters.

Indeed.

All in all, there is a tough year ahead for Clark.

Her odds at present look even worse than Hillary Clinton’s, and that’s saying quite a bit.

Actually I think Clark’s odd are better than Clinton’s.

Ralston connects the dots

Bill Ralston thinks National hasn’t done a good enough job with the Hawke’s Bay District Health Board sacking, and that what happened there is a bigger scandal than anything to do with Owen Glenn.  He paints a nice succinct picture:

A wee while back, Annette King was Minister of Health. Her husband, Ray Lind, was the chief operating officer of the Hawke’s Bay District Health Board.

Against the wishes of many on the health board, King appoints Peter Hausmann to the board. Hausmann runs a company called Healthcare New Zealand and many on the board fretted that he, as a supplier to health boards, would have a conflict of interest as a board member. King appointed him anyway.

It is still a mystery to many why King insisted on appointing someone who would be so conflicted.  Was there no one else?

In a very short time, the chairman of the board discovered Hausmann was involved in email discussions over a tender for a multi-million-dollar contract from the board he was a member of.

Which he had promised he would not do.

A woman whistleblower in the board’s administration brings this to the chairman’s attention.

She alleges Annette King’s husband, Ray Lind, as a senior manager put pressure on her because she blew the whistle. She ends up being restructured out of her job and an employment dispute ensues.

And don’t forget the secret taping on conversations. Also do not forget the DHB CEO is a former staffer for Helen Clark.

Meanwhile, Ray Lind quits and goes to work for Hausmann.

And as the inquiry goes on, Hausmann I think tried to bill the Board $500,000 or so for his legal fees.

Flak flies, King is reshuffled out of the portfolio, her successor dithers about sorting out the rolling brawl between the board and its managers over various contracts being awarded, and the people of Hawke’s Bay respond by backing the chairman and his board supporters by resoundingly re-electing them.

Normally the good people of Hawke’s Bay will disagree on whether the week starts on a Saturday or a Monday, plus every other issue known to man.  One should not under-estimate how rare it is to be able to unite every local body in the region against you (for sacking the board).

An inquiry into the murky goings on at the DHB rumbles away while there is yet another cabinet reshuffle and two-gun David Cunliffe takes over the job and refuses to confirm the chairman in his job.

Then, just 72 days after the re-elected board takes office, Cunliffe sacks them. He says the organisation is “dysfunctional” and it has a “rapidly deteriorating” financial situation. Actually, it’s only $7.7 million in the red, within its target range of coming out plus or minus 1 per cent of its revenue. David Cunliffe might not have noticed, but there is not a DHB in the country that hasn’t had financial problems and the Hawke’s Bay board’s problem is minor.

Indeed it is not clear at all why this Board was sacked when there are other boards who deserve sacking more.  There was no intermediate step taken such as a Crown Monitor. And also unknown is how many of the problems were caused by the Government’s own review taking so long to resolve, and the failure to confirm the Chair.

Cunliffe whinged to me that the board had publicly criticised him and the Health Ministry. Diddums. When you are in politics sometimes people have a go at you.

And he had attacked them publicly.  It must be a new rule that criticism can only be made public in one direction.

He accused the board of having a dysfunctional relationship with its management. Hell, if the management had been getting up to half the shenanigans the board alleges, no wonder the place was dysfunctional.

The concept of allowing staff to choose their governors is a new one for me.

Cunliffe added another reason for sacking the board was that hospital clinicians were critical of it. When are doctors ever happy with their DHB? Besides, only two out of 120 clinicians at the DHB have ever publicly had a go at the board and one of those has since quit.

And the local head of the doctor’s union publicly backed the Board Chair.  This is very unusual for a union head.

Sorry, David Cunliffe sacked the democratically elected Hawke’s Bay DHB because it was causing his Government grief and the board was exposing something rotten that began with the disastrous mistakes of Annette King.

One has to ask once again, why appoint someone to a board who you know is about to have a major conflict of interest with that board?

HoS on Tired Labour

The HoS Editorial is on a tired looking Labour Party:

It remains to be seen whether New Zealand First, currently polling well below the five-per-cent threshold, will be rescued by its leader’s recapture of Tauranga. But it is tempting to wonder whether Prime Minister Helen Clark, sensing approaching electoral oblivion, is engaging in the time-honoured political strategy of getting her retaliation in first.

Facing opinion polls that put Labour as much as 20 points behind National – which could, on the numbers, easily govern alone – Clark launched an extraordinary attack on the New Zealand Herald, accusing it of being “a Tory paper” that had “shown no charity to Labour in the party’s 91 years of existence”. She singled out for special mention the newspaper’s long-serving cartoonist Minhinnick for “flaying” Labour Governments.

The argument that Minhinnick’s political leanings were conservative is not a difficult one to sustain, but the PM deserves all the ink a cartoonist might throw at her if she seeks to blame Min for her troubles. He retired in 1976 – five years before Helen Elizabeth Clark was elected MP for Mt Albert. …

Yes blaming a cartoonist who has been dead for 16 years is never a good look.

Labour’s problems are of a very different provenance and a much more recent vintage – and the Herald’s well-reasoned opposition to the Electoral Finance Act (in which it was scarcely a lone voice) has nothing to do with it.

Labour activists who are on a jihad against the Herald should take note. The HoS (editorially independent) has labelled the Herald’s campaign against the EFA as well-reasoned.

In an online poll at nzherald.co.nz on the day of the PM’s outburst, 80 per cent of 3000 respondents believed Labour was to blame for its own polling troubles and four per cent blamed National. Unpalatable though Clark may find the fact, the “blame the media” approach is not going to cut much ice on polling day.

The plain fact is that Labour, limbering up for an election at which it seems certain to take a hammering, is looking tired. Steve Maharey has gone, Michael Cullen – who has attracted the nickname Michael Sullen in some quarters – has lost the sparkle in his eye and, apparently, the fire in his belly as well.

Actually Dr Sullen is the approved nickname 🙂

Davis’ suggestion that the Herald’s coverage of the Owen Glenn loan affair was driven by a desire to “foment happy mischief” and that the newspaper was “having great fun at [Labour’s] expense” would have seemed quaintly chivalrous if it had not been so ill-judged. It cannot but create the impression that the PM needs all the help she can get.

But hey it has given me a tagline for the blog 🙂

New NZ First President

Obama pulls ahead in Texas

America moves closer to its first African-American candidate for President, with the latest polls in Texas.

Five polls are out in the two days and only one Shows Clinton ahead (by 4%).  The other four have Obama ahead 1% to 6%.  So polls are not conclusive but her lead has gone from 12% ahead to narrowly behind which is a bad trend.

Why Family First do so well

Rarely does a day go by, without Family First in the news. This is because Bob McCoskrie is a very very smart media operator. Not only does he do a press release a day, but he thinks outside the square.

Sure they do still sometimes do dumb stuff like trying to get Californication off the air through an advertiser boycott. Probably sent ratings soaring. But they are very smart when they do releases like this one in my inbox:

Family First NZ has offered to pay for a child to join their family on a dream holiday to Disneyland if they win the ‘nightmare’ trip in More FM’s current radio competition.

First prize in the competition is a family trip (worth $20,000) to Disneyland in both LA and Florida for 10 days. However, if the winning family tosses a coin and it is ‘tails’, one of the children has to stay behind.

“The competition has been ill-conceived and is potentially traumatic for a young family,” says Bob McCoskrie, National Director of Family First NZ, “and our understanding is that More FM has received a number of complaints about it, and that even some staff have concerns.” …

Family First hopes that the winner gets ‘heads’ on the coin, but in the event that it is ‘tails’, they are offering to fund the extra airfare so that the whole family enjoys a brilliant family trip together.

“Who wants to be at the departure lounge when little Jeremy waves goodbye to the rest of his family as they embark on their dream trip to Disneyland?”

This is seriously brilliant PR.  Instead of just complaining about the More FM competition, they front up with the $2K or so for the extra child, in case the family flips tails.

Today they have launched a ‘Have dinner with your family” campaign on billboards and in newspapers.  Not at all political – just pushing a families message.

If all they did was go on about smacking and rude shows on TV, they would be marginalised.  But Bob M manages to find a family angle to almost every issue, and get in the news on it.  A quick check of NZPA finds around 40 references to Family First – just in February.

Now don’t take this to mean I agree with all of Family First’s aims. Of their four current action alerts, I oppose them on three of the four – Californication, Hell’s Pizza, and Boobs on Bikes. I do agree on the anti-smacking law.

But one doesn’t have to agree with a group on something, to admire their media skills.  Likewise I don’t agree with the EPMU and Andrew Little on a lot of things – but I do admire his media operation.

Voice Spammed

Just received an automated voice spam call on my voicemail.  From Roger Douglas, promoting his speech at the ACT Party Conference.  Presumably is being done by ACT.  I have serious doubts that the annoyance it causes to so many people is worth the number of positive responses they get.

General Debate 1 March 2008

Dom Post Editorial on Trade Me Consulship auction

Superb. The Trade Me auction of honorary consulships, done by Whale Oil, has gained its own dedicated editorial in the Dominion Post. Some extracts:

Alas, the online auction for an honorary consulship has been revealed to be the work of an inventive blogger rather than a Foreign Affairs and Trade Ministry initiative, The Dominion Post says.

The bidders who offered half a million dollars, Holden utes and assignations with supermodels in exchange for the position will instead have to earn the good opinion of Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters if they wish to add the title honorary consul to their letterheads. The auction was pulled by Trade Me after receiving “a number of complaints” and because the seller was unable to deliver the item listed.

But this is an idea whose time has come. And it is one that should be applied to a wider range of positions than just honorary consulships. Instead of assigning plum diplomatic posts to politicians who fancy a spot of OE before heading off to tend the flower beds and write indignant letters to the local newspaper, they should be auctioned off to the highest bidder. Surplus cabinet positions should also be put under the hammer. Everybody knows there is barely enough work for 15 ministers. The remaining ones should be flogged off, and so should national honours …

But a formal auction would be manifestly superior. Not only would it widen the pool of bidders and direct funds to the consolidated account rather than party coffers, it would also avoid the sort of confusion that now hovers over the most recent Officer of the New Zealand Order of Merit, expatriate billionaire Owen Glenn. Did he get the honour because he gave $7.5 million to Auckland University’s new business school or because he gave the Labour Party $500,000 and loaned it a further $100,000?

An auction would also avoid the speculation that now surrounds Mr Glenn’s interest in being appointed honorary consul to Monaco. Was he responsible for the large anonymous donation NZ First president Dail Jones says appeared in the party’s bank account late last year but that Mr Peters says was never made? He’s not saying. In an open, transparent system there would be no need for confusion or obfuscation. Bidders could make known their identities and would receive the heartfelt thanks of the populace, spared the cost of footing at least part of the Government’s bill.

Let the bidding commence.

The only way this story can get better is if Winston now goes ahead and actually appoints Glenn.

Key’s Secret Weapon

Fran O’Sullivan writes on John Key’s secret weapon, or greatest ally, and declares it is Helen Clark.

I agree on this.  Look up until mid 2006 Clark’s political skills were superb. But since then she has made mistake after mistake after mistake. On almost every major issue she has made the wrong call, and then finally making the right call so late in the piece she gets no credit for it.  Now she is still very smart, very determined and only a fool counts her out. But she is not a bystander to Labour’s problems – she has caused many of them.

It was Clark’s inner circle, particularly her chief of staff Heather Simpson, who combined with the party central to plunder some $800,000 of taxpayers’ funds to help Labour win in 2005. Labour was ultimately forced to pay the funds back after a damning auditor-general’s report. The party has been on the back foot ever since.

She pilloried the Auditor-General and only agreed to pay it back as public opinion reached a crescendo.

But Clark didn’t learn. Her kitchen cabinet then put up the hapless former minister Mark Burton to introduce the obnoxious Electoral Finance Act which the Herald rightly labels “an assault on democracy”. It was another politically inept step which will continue to dog Labour right through this election year.

The Bill, as introduced, was that most incompetent law, arguably since WWII. How Burton and the Cabinet approved it is a mystery.  It was, as Nicky Hager said, something the Nazis could have come up with.  If the final version of the EFA was the version they introduced, then there would have been far less fuss.

Last week’s surreal run of events illustrated just how far she has become detached from the bedrock common sense which characterised her earlier years as prime minister. The events included Clark publicly shunning Labour’s major financial donor Owen Glenn at the opening of the University of Auckland’s new business school and subsequent labelling the Herald as a “Tory paper which had shown no charity to Labour during its 91 years of existence”.

Indeed.  I found it interesting that I don’t think even a single Govt supporter tried to defend her on the 91 years smear against the Herald. It really was pathetic and desperate.

Fran then suggests that if Clark doesn’t regain her mojo, maybe Cullen could be an interim Leader. He is more and more sorting out her messes, and was furious with her for suggesting in the Listener he may retire. She also highlights the recent exchange on wages:

Importantly, Cullen has Key’s measure. This was evident in Parliament where Key sat like a stunned mullet when Cullen took him to task over a newspaper report that quoted the National leader saying “we would love to see wages drop” during a conversation he held in Northland about the gaping wage differences between New Zealand and Australia.

Key’s comment does not make logical sense. But his propensity to mangle his syntax or wrong word himself gets him into trouble. This was evidenced at last year’s National Party conference with his embarrassing reference to a “Labour Government that I lead”.

She concludes:

Cullen will continue to ruthlessly mine Key’s lapses of brain-mouth co-ordination. These won’t matter too much if and when Key gets to be prime minister. Political journalists will just laugh with and at him, as they did with former National Prime Minister Jim Bolger when he came back from each foreign tour with a new accent. But in the crucible of an election year the stakes are much higher.

It will not have escaped Key’s notice that Cullen will also try to snooker National by unveiling costly but popular policies in his forthcoming budget.

Key needs a gameplan to deal with Labour’s dirt agenda and much more discipline on the verbal front. If he can get on top of his weaknesses the election is his. If not, Labour may yet have a chance.

To some degree the election is National’s to lose.  That is over simplifying, but National’s discipline will be key.

The Leader in Waiting

Audrey Young profiles the leader in waiting for Labour, and also looks at the far more interesting issue of who would be Goff’s Deputy.

First she look at if Labour loses:

Being Opposition leader is one of the worst jobs in politics, especially up against a new Government enjoying a honeymoon with the public.

The leader has to have the skills to prevent the defeated party tearing itself apart – and this is where Goff would be weakest – be the toughest opponent to a Government that has just been given a mandate to do what it is doing, and have public appeal.

It is a job for the toughest. Few in Labour ranks could handle it well.

Clark could but there’s no satisfaction in going backwards. Michael Cullen could but he would be yesterday’s man. Annette King could but does not want it. Mallard would have been a rival to Goff had he not played fast and loose with his own reputation.

Lianne Dalziel revels more in backroom work than public profile these days.

Clark would indeed be a formidable Opposition Leader.  But I can’t see her wanting to have that job for long unless someone like Little was in Caucus who given time could beat Goff.  Cullen and King don’t want it.  Mallard does but has struck himself out literally. Maharey has gone and Dalziel’s sacking from Cabinet for lying would be recalled too often.

If Labour wins, the situation is a bit different:

A return to power by Labour at the next election reduces the alternatives.

Clark could then hand over to a new leader (and Prime Minister) before the 2011 election. Again that could still be Goff if none of the new generation have scrubbed up well enough.

But by then Shane Jones, now in his first term, may have acquired some of the necessary communication skills and party political experience necessary to lead Labour.

Indeed if Labour do win again, some alternatives to Goff will have time to prove themselves.

And then the deputies:

The best the next generation could hope for under a Goff leadership would be as deputy.

David Cunliffe has ambition, is handling the front bench well, and has definite public appeal but his perceived arrogance makes him unpopular in his own caucus.

Maryan Street has ability but, with less than one term, very little political experience. However she may have a rapid rise owing to the thinning ranks of capable women in a party where gender balance is important.

Street fighter Clayton Cosgrove would be invaluable to the party in Opposition but does not have broad enough appeal to make it to the top two.

King it seems does not want Leader but maybe could be persuaded to be Deputy. If Cunliffe survives Health I could well see him moving into Finance – but that may be seperate to Deputy. Street has been effective behind the scenes but too early to know if she move into a public leadership role.  She has been Party President though. Jones as Deputy is a possibility also.

Audrey then sums up all the candidates:

THE NEXT LABOUR LEADER

PHIL GOFF
Best bet since Maharey announced he was quitting and Mallard wrestled Henare in the corridors of Parliament.

ANNETTE KING
More respected in the caucus and as able as Goff, but colleagues know better than to ask. She would refuse. She has found love and will do nothing to compromise it.

AND THE NEXT GENERATION…

SHANE JONES
The perfect candidate on paper, expert in Maoritanga and Harvard-educated, but the first-termer is not experienced enough and not steeped in party culture.

DAVID CUNLIFFE
Has won over the public for his strong leadership in health but has still not won over his caucus, who have as little regard for him as they do for his ego. Could be deputy material.

CLAYTON COSGROVE
The Mike Moore acolyte has won respect from the Left of the party for his ability to put differences aside – but not that much respect.

DARREN HUGHES
Clever, witty and able but needs another six years under his belt to shake off the kid-brother image and show his serious side.

MARYAN STREET
A classic modern Labour MP – policy-driven feminist with a strong human rights bent – not as scary as she sounds. Could be an a contender for deputy to Goff.

DAVID PARKER
Bright, methodical, a details man but has too much of an academic approach to the job.

ANDREW LITTLE
Ruled himself out of Parliament next term but could do a Bob Hawke after 2011 if other leadership combinations have failed.

Armstrong on Cunliffe

A very perceptive and balanced article from John Armstrong on Cunliffe in health. Extracts:

Sure, Annette King must take some of the blame as a former Health Minister for the appointment of the board member whose alleged conflict of interest sparked the ructions that have seen the board at war with that member and the DHB’s chief executive.

Indeed.  And it was known at the time he would probably be tendering for a major contract.  Why on earth would you appoint somone about to be so conflicted?

Cunliffe knew what was expected of him: neutralise health as a political issue in election year.

He is also smart enough to know that being effective required a radical change in style in the way the portfolio was handled.

Cunliffe’s approach has been in vivid contrast to that of his predecessor, Pete Hodgson. And presumably deliberately so.

In a portfolio where a political irritant at lunchtime can become a political headache by dinnertime, Hodgson had a tendency to stand back and wait for the relevant DHB to do something.

Cunliffe is far more hands-on and in-your-face. He is a new broom. He conveys a sense of urgency.

Just as well for Labour. For the floodgates opened after his appointment.

This is a fair point.  Cunliffe is at least attempting to manage his portfolio, unlike Hodgson. I do think the conflict of interest issues which tie back to Annette King both professionally and personally, should have made him hold off sacking the entire Board as it looks like protecting King (even if it is not).  I would have just removed the board member with the conflict of interest and then given the Board say three months to gets it shit together.

Cunliffe has not pretended the catalogue of mishaps and errors contained in those reports never happened. But they did not happen under his watch. He is painting himself as a break from the past rather than someone who got the job just because he was next in the queue.

And he is doing things differently, for example, breaking the unwritten rule that ministers keep well away from wage negotiations.

Again I am not absolutely convinced that was a sensible thing to do (sets a precedent) but again at least it is a Minister not drifting along.

The strong community backing for the board and the accompanying backlash against the Government have obliterated any faint hope that Labour might have had of recapturing the Napier and Tukituki seats.

And having local Labour MP Russell Fairbrother come out proclaiming that the only local people complaining about the decision are those with private health insurance is a contender for most stupid statement of the year.

The main worry now for the party is what Cunliffe’s wielding of the axe in Hawkes Bay will do to Labour’s party vote not just in that province, but in provincial New Zealand as a whole.

However, rather than being Cunliffe’s fault, the backlash springs from a fundamental weakness in the DHB model. DHBs are accountable to the Minister of Health for a simple reason. They are funded by central Government. Their assets are owned by the Crown. Yet they are supposed to be responsive to their local communities. At some stage the board of a DHB was bound to end up torn between having to be accountable to the minister but preferring to be accountable to its local community.

This is why I do not support elections for DHBs.  The dual accountability actually means no accountability.  Minister gets to blame the DHB.  The Minister should appoint the entire DHB (but consult widely on the appointments) and in turn be held accountable for how they DHBs do.

Fran fact checks Winston

Winston challenged journalists to report the facts, so Fran O’Sullivan has done just that.  First she makes the point:

Let’s concede here that Peters is right on one point: journalists have not uncovered any evidence that Glenn contributed to his party.

But we’d hardly be doing our jobs if we didn’t ask pertinent questions after Peters’ own party president admitted to Herald political editor Audrey Young that despite help from NZ First’s bank, he couldn’t track down the source of a donation put towards a $158,000 sum outstanding from the 2005 election.

Then she reports Winston’s challenge:

I took Peters up on his challenge and did some digging after he told Paul Henry on TVNZ’s Close Up programme about his expectations for a professional journalist – “It’s [about] getting the facts first and presenting a story that will stand up.” Here’s what I found in relation to some of his own statements.

And what did she find:

Peters: “We have not made a decision with respect to even having a consul in Monaco … It’s an ongoing matter for consideration and has been for 12 long years.” (Parliament press conference on Thursday).

Fact: In June 2004, former foreign minister Phil Goff categorically ruled against appointing a consul to Monaco saying there was “no proven need” for one.

Indeed.  It was case closed.  Winston re-opened it.

Peters: “Since the formation of New Zealand First, we have assiduously at all times complied with the electoral law of this country.” (Parliament press conference on Thursday).

Fact: Auditor-General Kevin Brady believed NZ First was responsible for $158,000 of a total $1.17 million in unlawful spending of parliamentary funds by political parties at the 2005 election.

Peters contests this saying its expenditure was pre-approved by Parliamentary Services and the Chief Electoral Office.

This was a breach of the Public Finance Act rather than the Electoral Act, to be fair.

Peters: NZ First has “had no big business backing since its inception”. (Close Up on Thursday).

Fact: NZ First’s electoral donations returns indeed show the party has not come within cooee of attracting the big business backing which has swelled the campaign coffers of the main parties.

But Contact Energy – surely a big business – did give $10,000 to the party in 2003 and again in 2005.

Absolutely. Peters was wrong.

Peters: “This is a party (NZ First) that has spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on a great case to do with tax evasion in this country and we don’t recall any journalist or any media group joining us in these battles.” (Parliament press conference on Thursday).

Fact: New Zealand news media companies – particularly the National Business Review, Independent and Television New Zealand – between them spent hundreds of thousands of dollars fighting injunctions during the 1990s to get the big wine box tax avoidance issue in front of the public.

It is true that NZ First paid for a subsequent challenge to the wine box inquiry commissioner’s findings right through to the Privy Council.

Yes, not quite a solo effort as portrayed.

And I am still waiting for Owen Glenn to tell us which political party he did donate to, if it was not NZ First?

Cunliffe rejects Telecom separation plan

DC may be facing the pressure in health, but I am very pleased to see he is still makin good calls in the Comms/IT area.

He has not accepted Telecom’s proposed separation plan. The proposed plan was a lot better than the draft plan, but still had aspects which would have left incentives in place which would increase the chance of failure.

InternetNZ, whose submission was to not accept the plan, is relieved and happy:

InternetNZ Executive Director Keith Davidson says it is very good to see Government has recognised the issues, and is committed to ensuring a robust operational separation plan that correctly incents the relevant divisions within Telecom. “Ideally the wholesale manager should have little or no group incentive and InternetNZ is pleased to see that a limit will be put in place.”

The changes needed are not huge, but of great significance potentially.  Telecom today is a very different beast to a few years ago and are generally working well towards a structure where there will be greater competition and investment.  The Minister deserves credit for not rushing the final plan by sacrificing quality for speed.

Friday Photos

A couple of fun photos people have pointed out to me. First do you remember how hard Helen worked not to be seen with Owen Glenn last week. I don’t think the media managed to get a photo of them together. But good old Owen has put the photo below on his website.

UPDATE: The photo it appears is from 2005 when he first announced the donation. Still it’s a photo the PM doesn’t want seen I bet 🙂

oghc.JPG

She still doesn’t look happy though!

And then we have (hat tip: mccully.co) this photo from the Hero Debate.

rblabour.JPG

I hope they are on commission for any membership money they raised. And hey as Winston says you can get up to $158,000 from lots of small donations.

A decent cobber

One of the pleasures of attending the NZBR Retreat was meeting Andrew Bolt, who gave a superb talk about Kevin Rudd. Andrew is a former Labor staffer (and still good friends with several Labor Ministers), and now a columnist and blogger. His last book was “Still Not Sorry” which gives a clue as to his current views.

Andrew gives me a small plug on his blog.

His talk on Rudd was fascinating, as it was flavoured with a lot of inside info from within Labor.  Also discussed the current Liberal Party which is looking very very dismal. I predict they will allow Nelson to lose the next election then Turnbull will roll him.

The funniest thing was when I first met Andrew.  He was furiously trying to calculate something on a large pad, and was down to around line 30.

Upon enquiry I found out he was trying to work out how big China’s economy will be in 100 years time if it keeps growing at 10%.  So he was calculating it manually line by line over 100 years.  The look of relief on his face was palpable when I said I had a laptop with excel on it – took around 30 seconds.  I think he had spent 20 minutes already on it! Still good to see someone who knows how to do maths the old fashioned way.

Councils vote to challenge DHB sacking

NZPA reports:

Hawke’s Bay Regional Council voted on Wednesday to seek a judicial review of the ministers decision and yesterday three more councils — Napier, Hastings and Wairoa — voted to join the action.

Central Hawke’s Bay District Council will vote on the matter today …

National’s health spokesman, Tony Ryall has described the move as “appalling political manipulation” designed to get rid of the board so it could not put its case in a conflict of interest inquiry.

“One conclusion is that there’s a wider political agenda,” Mr Ryall said.

“He kept the Capital and Coast District Health Board despite widespread public opposition, yet he has sacked the Hawke’s Bay board in spite of community support.”

Green Party MP Sue Kedgley said she had “grave concerns” about Mr Cunliffe’s action.

“It appears to be a politically motivated act driven by the minister’s irritation at a chairman of a district health board who was prepared to speak his mind,” she said.

Also read this editorial in HB Today:

Sacking the district health board is a disgraceful betrayal: It abuses the confidence the people of Hawke’s Bay placed in the board, which is only three months old, and it reveals the principle of public participation in health governance to be a sham and at the whim of political convenience …

The region’s mayors plan a legal challenge. The minister says he has been advised it will not succeed. He may well have the whip hand … until November. In the meantime questions need to be answered and in the open. If there are issues then let’s put them on the table. No more smoke and mirrors.

Mr Cunliffe has shown contempt for Hawke’s Bay people. In nine months’ time we will be able to return the favour.

Goodness me, that almost looks like an advertisement under the Electoral Finance Act.

Nai Yin Xue caught

Stuff reports:

Commander Tom Hession of the US Marshals confirmed to Radio New Zealand’s Nine to Noon programme that he was apprehended at approximately 8.30am.

Nai Yin Xue, 54, is wanted in connection with the death of his wife, Anan Liu, 27, whose body was found in the boot of a car outside their Mount Roskill home on 18 September. He took their three-year-old child from Auckland to Melbourne on 13 September then abandoned Qian Xun Xue – known as ‘Pumpkin’ – at the Southern Cross railway station in Melbourne on 15 September.

That’s great news.

Frog Blog celebrates Leap Year

Frog Blog has declared Leap Day today as the Day of the Frog. And with some very good humour, they preview what other blogs might say:

And of course I’m sure other blogs will be writing about Leap Day too. Kiwiblog will be uncovering the story of a frog advocacy group that has been silenced by the Electoral Finance Act, the Standard will discuss how John Key pulls the legs off frogs when no one is looking. I expect No Right Turn to have detailed policy analysis on possible legislative action relating to the Maud Island Frog. Hard News will report on the cultural impact that Archey’s Frogs had by releasing a song of their mating call exclusively to iTunes. Whale Oil will continue to amuse his readers by photoshopping Jeanette’s head onto a frog (guffaw).

Heh, I like it.  It gets Whale Oil and The Standard perfectly 🙂

General Debate 29 Feb 2009

Hawke’s Bay District Health Board

I’ve not had time to do as detailed a post as I would like to on this, and the media have covered the issues well.  So I’ll just ask a few questions:

  1. Why would the Minister not sack the Capital Coast DHB (which would probably be met with universal support) but instead sack the HB DHB – something the local community is dead set against?
  2. Isn’t it rather perverse to go public with anonymous criticisms of the Board by anonymous surgeons, and then complain when the DHB Chair responds in the media also?
  3. Will the majorities of local National MPs Chris Tremain and Craig Foss increase by 25%, 50% or 100%?
  4. The Govt is trying to suppress the draft report and the former DHB members the final report.  Why not release both the draft and final and let the public form their own views.  Plus lets face it – they will both end up on the Internet anyway I suspect.
  5. Why is the Government apparently punishing the DHB for acting to prevent a conflict of interest in a contract, when the Auckland DHB got lambasted by the High Court for not being diligent enough in dealing with conflicts of interests?
  6. Why did Annette King appoint someone to the HB DHB when it was known he was likely to bid for a major contract off them?
  7. How bad is it for the Government to have the local Councils taking the Minister to health over the sacking?
  8. Has a doctors union ever before praised a DHB Chairman? Don’t they normally refer to all Chairs as cheap bastards who won’t pay us enough.

I look forward to seeing both the final report and hopefully the draft report.

The answer is NO

Winston Peters has said the answer is No, with his comical NO sign as a prop yesterday.  I did enjoy Guyon Espiner’s wit in stealing said sign after the press conference and holding it up on One News when asked if Peters had really answered all the questions satisfactorily.

Let us look at what Winston did and did not say.  Please note I am not suggesting in any way that Peters has said anything which is not literally true. But it comes down to what one has not said.

First of all Peters insisted he would not provide any more information than required to by electoral laws.  Now this “donation” was made prior to the passing of the Electoral Finance Ac, so will be governed by the provisions of the 1993 Electoral Act.

Now I suspect (for example) National has a similar policy – they will only release the information required to by electoral law. So what is the difference.  Two things:

  1. Peters’ own party president has suggested there was a large anonymous donation
  2. Peters spent much of 2007 railing against such donations, and the need to change the law to prevent them.  It would be sheer hypocrisy to rail against them, and also pocket one just a few hours before the law changes

Now the Herald reports:

Asked if he was saying he had never received one dollar from Owen Glenn or any associate of Mr Glenn, he hauls a sign out from under his table.

“NO”, it read.

Now again on face value, one accepts what Peters has said.  However does this rule out Glenn having donated to say a local Tauranga trust, and that trust having donated to NZ First? This could be sorted out by having NZ First release their donations return to the Electoral Commission (due 30 April) early, so people can see if the auditors have signed off that there were *no* donations over $10K. If they were over $10K, then those who donated them can be asked if they were acting as an agent for anyone else.

Because you still have the statement from Owen Glenn that he has donated to parties in NZ other than Labour.  And combine that with his refusal to deny a donation to NZ First, but his quick denial of offering a donation to the Maori Party, and the puzzle grows. Owen Glenn could solve all this speculation by just confirming on the record that he has never donated directly or indirectly to NZ First.

I also found it interesting that when asked if NZ First had ever asked Owen Glenn for money, he did not say no, but instead said “Oh, get lost Barry”.  Possibly a more specific question could have been asked – did he ever meet with Owen Glenn in Sydney, and did they discuss donations at that meeting? Peters later says they never ask anyone for donations – now this can be true but doesn’t mean donations were not discussed.

But the part I find most amusing, is the denial that there was any large donations at all, let alone a large anonymous one in December. It seems Dail Jones is so stupid (according to Peters) that he could not tell the difference between money being transferred into their account from other party accounts, and an anonymous deposit. How very strange though that the bank could not trace the deposit, because if it is a transfer from another NZ First account – that should be simple to verify.

So if there was no large close to $100,000 donation as Dail Jones has said, where did all the money come from:

Where the $158,000 came from to “repay” NZ First’s unlawful spend at the last election:

“We’ve had anonymous donations at $10, and $20, and $50 for a long, long time because some people used to think – and it’s an attitude that still permeates New Zealand as a democracy – that one day the communists might take over and they will be all in the firing line.”

Oh I see.  It’s all just a series of $20 and $50 donations from people worried about the communists.  Hell I never knew Trevor Loudon donated to NZ First 🙂

Fiji looks grim

The NZ Herald editorial on Fiji is grim reading:

The Fiji Sun had run a series of articles accusing Fiji’s Finance Minister, Mahendra Chaudhry, of tax evasion. The junta’s response was a blatant act of intimidation against a newspaper trying to do its job. It made a mockery of Commodore Bainimarama’s assurances that his Administration would uphold media freedom …

 The attempt to tighten control does not stop there. This month, Commodore Bainimarama appointed himself head of the Great Council of Chiefs. This powerful group has sometimes been the voice of reason as Fiji stumbled through a succession of military coups. It can serve that role no longer. In addition, Police Commissioner Esala Teleni has warned Fijians not to speak out against the Administration. All this points to a determination to stifle debate, rather than a broadening of the regime’s tolerance to a wide range of viewpoints, the necessary precursor if a return to democracy is seriously contemplated.

Increasingly, it appears that any concessions Commodore Bainimarama makes are merely a response to aid-related ultimatums, especially from the European Union. There is nothing to suggest that he is genuinely intent on creating a united Fiji or that he is benignly shepherding it back to democracy.

The Commodore I suspect will never give up power.

Flexible Land Use Alliance gets support

The Flexible Land Use Alliance launched itself yesterday, and seems to have won support for one of its proposals from parties ranging from The Greens to National.

The Flexible Land Use Alliance consists of Blakely Pacific Ltd, Carter Holt Harvey Ltd, Fonterra Co-operate Group Ltd, Forest Enterprises Ltd, Landcorp Farming Ltd, the New Zealand Forest Owners Association Inc., PF Olsen Ltd and Wairakei Pastoral Ltd. I found it very interesting that an SOE is amongst the members – but that is good – they should be able to advocate for sensible policy, so long as they do so openly.

The issue is the deforestation liability on pre-1990 forests.  It has already led to massive deforestation prior to its implementation, and the group has pointed out that it may lock up to 200,000 hectares of land into forestry when it would be more economic to use it for other purposes.

Their preferred position is to exempt pre-1990 forests, but that has been dismissed by the Government (and National) as viable. However their backup option appears to have gathered remarkable support – the Greens, NZ First, United Future and ACT have all backed the backup option of offsetting – which will allow owners to convert a pre-1990 forest to other uses, so long as they plant an equivalent amount of forest elsewhere.

This means that the environmental benefits are much the same, yet the locking up of land in a potentially economically inefficient manner is minimised.

Jim Anderton appears to be taking a sensibly pragmatic approach to the proposal:

Forestry Minister Jim Anderton said the concept had been considered already and the conclusion was that the disadvantages outweighed the benefits.

But the Government was happy to look at it again, have the proposal evaluated and discuss it with stakeholders, he said.

One of the things which third term Governments often do, is dismiss any proposal on the grounds they know best, and have already considered it. Anderton’s response could be a template for other Ministers – don’t dismiss out of hand, say you’ll evaluate it again and are open to discussions.

Of course with National appearing to also favour the proposal (“the idea … has merit), it may already have 61 votes in the House, regardless of the Government. But if Labour/Progressive also back it, then one may have near total support for it.  Maori Party are not quoted as to their position, but Maori interests are amongst the Alliance members and they cite the current policy as being a Treaty breach, so I suspect the Maori Party will also be supportive.