The work side in India

I tend to blog more on the fun and scenic parts of India, rather than post photos of dozens of people stuck in meeting rooms.  That doesn’t mean the meetings and work hasn’t happened.

ICANN is the body which co-ordinates and sets policy for the global domain name and addressing system for the Internet.  It is a unique private sector led initiative, and there have been some battles in the past with the UN’s ITU wanting to take over and have governments set the policy.

Normally when I attend one of these meetings, on behalf of InternetNZ, I am dealing with country code issues.  What that means is discussions between all those who set policy for and manage registries of country code domain names such as .uk, .nz, .au, .aq etc.

This time I am here in a slightly different role.  InternetNZ is also a member of the Asia-Pacific Regional At Large Organisation (I am signing the deed of incorportation today) which aims to represent all users on issues dealt with by ICANN.  Many of these tend to be issues around generic domain names such as .com, .org, .info, .asia.

These meetings are not one big meeting, but a series of meetings – the full schedule is here. Over the last four days I’ve attended over a dozen meetings.  Some are dealing with process, and some with policy.  I though I’d highlight two current policy issues to give people an idea of what we try to resolve at these meetings.

I blogged on the 4th of Feb about domain name tasting. This is where people use the five day grace period (during which you can cancel a .com domain name without paying for it) to register say a million names, see which ones gain enough money off Google Ads to keep, and then cancel 999,000 of them.  Now the five day grace period was intended for accidental registrations, not this.

The effects are very anti-registrant as many names get locked up indefinitely as one person after another registers it for the five day period, cancels it, and then someone else does the same. So you get less choice of names, and greater costs due to registries only being paid for 0.1% of the registrations made.

Now these is widespread agreement the practice should be stopped, but there is disagreement on how to do it.  Many, like myself, just want the five day grace period abolished.  It has almost no public policy virtue, and just leads to massive gaming.

Others though say the registries and registrars will not agree to this, as they like having the grace period for certain business practices, and suggest instead a ratio be set – something like cancellations can not exceed 10% of registrations for a registrar.

So we have a debate about whether to got for the optimal solution, which might be harder to achieve, or whether to go for a solution which will fix 99% of the current problems, is more achievable, but may cause issues in future.

Now remember these decisions have big financial consequences.  The domain name industry is easily multi-billion.  There are now 150 million domain name and if teh average retail value is US$35 then that alone is US$5 billion a year bfoer you even look at flow on effects.  So if you make a decision that does not follow good process, or is discriminatory, you will get lawsuits. Big lawsuits.

The other issue is that of internationalised domain names. This is about letting people register domain names in their native languages or scripts, rather than just in ASCII characters.  Now in many top level domains you can now use IDNs, so for example one could have a domain name of bücher.ch. Or in mandarin you could have 官話.cn.

But do you see the problem?  The top level domain is still in ASCII.  It means people can’t have their entire domain name in their native language (and this is desirable for a global resource).  So the answer is one sets up some new top level domains, which use an IDN.  So then one might have a domain name of m

But here the policy issues get interesting.  There is a fast track procedure planned for countries to be able to get an IDN TLD.  But questions to be resolved are:

  • Should each country just be limited to one IDN TLD initially, or more?
  • Should the number of IDN TLDs per country be limited to the number of official languages?  Who decides what is official?
  •  Who will run the new IDN TLD? Will it be the existing ccTLD Manager or someone else?
  • Should the IDN TLD be an abbreviation (like all current country codes are) or can they be names in full?

India has 12 official languages so they want 12 IDN TLDs. Sri Lanka has said that if they have only one IDN TLD they would choose to have none, as it would cause ethnic conflict to choose one language ahead of another to get an IDN established.

Now one might say let every country have whatever they want.  Well, that’s a legitimate viewpoint.  But also remember that there are generic top level domain registries who also want to apply for IDN TLDs.  They get very unhappy if country code managers get an unlimited number of new TLDs, shutting them out of the market.

Now none of these issues are unsolvable with goodwill, and there is a lot of that.  But with so many competing interests, it can be complex.

Some may think issues like IDNs are very academic and not particularly important.  Well to English users, no they are not. But let me tell you that the desire to be able to have domain names in their native language and scripts is something which many Governments are pushing for, at the highest levels.  Heads of Government and Ministers write in demanding quicker action.  If they don’t get that action, then they start to think hey maybe someone else should be in charge of the Internet’s naming and addressing systems.  So the balancing of interests is always very interesting.

Glenn says Brethren campaign prompted his $500,000 donation to Labour

The Dominion Post quotes expat billionaire Owen Glenn as citing the Exclusive Brethren’s “sneaky” campaign against Labour as what prompted him to donate $500,000 to the Labour Party. To quote the article:

He made the decision to give $500,000 to the New Zealand Labour Party while on his yacht in the Caribbean.

“There was a little bit of controversy to do with some church that had done something.”

That controversy was a $1 million campaign by the Exclusive Brethren to get National elected, a move that sparked the Government’s race to bring in new electoral finance laws before this year’s election.

What really riled Mr Glenn was the “sneaky” way in which the Brethren had reportedly tried to hide the fact it was behind the campaign.

“I thought, `Poor old Labour; let’s make this a little more interesting.’ There’s a little bit of imp in me.”

Now there is a serious credibility issue here. Very very serious. You see the Brethren campaign only became public in September 2005. And when did Owen Glenn make his donations? Well according to the Electoral Commission he gave $199,960 to Labour in 2004 – yes in 2004. And he gave a further $300,000 in 2005.

And as further proof we have this story in May 2005 with Labour President Mike Williams announcing the $500,000 donation by Owen Glenn, and confirming they had already received the $500,000 – with the first payment appearing to be on 9 November 2004 and the last on 9 March 2005.

So how does one reconcile these conflicting facts. There seem to be only three possibilities

  1. Owen Glenn knew about the Brethren’s plans a year before anyone else in NZ did
  2. The Dominion Post has grossly misrepresented what Owen Glenn has said
  3. Owen Glenn has lied

I am surpised the Dominion Post themselves didn’t pick up the inconsistency with the dates. They now need to confirm whether or not they have accurately reported the words of Mr Glenn. I will refrain from further comment on the implications until it is clear whether or not the story is correct.

There are also two other items of interest in the Dom Post Story:

  • Helen Clark offered him a seat in Parliament and the role of Transport Minister. It is unclear whether or not this was before or after his $500,000 donation
  • Owen Glenn made a further contribution to Labour after the election by loaning them money. If the loan was not at a commercial rate of interest I would argue it is a donation (for the amount of interest not charged) under the then s214F(b) of the Electoral Act 1993, and if this is the case Labour needs to clarify whether or not it has recognised that donation on its books and disclosed it to the Electoral Commission (if over the threshold). There have been huge scandals in the UK about UK Labour receiving interest free loans from donors.

Blog Bits

Poneke has had Wellington Mayor Kerry Predergast comment on on of his posts regarding public transport.  Excellent to see Kerry being responsive.

The Hive has a leaked confidential e-mail from the CEO to the Chair of the  NZ Business Council for Sustainable Development regarding potential conflicts of interest.

Not PC disapproves of my lack of purity on wanting free to air TV delivered on all platforms, or to specifically quote him:

Jawohl, Herr Farrar! 

Sheesh.  At least when Jim Neanderton insists on a “right” to free-to-air TV he’s honest enough to call himself a socialist.

Whale Oil’s family gets bigger.

EPMU’s third party eligibility

I blogged back on the 5th of February about the application from the EPMU to register as a third party.

In that post I mused about whether a future review of electoral law should look at whether an affiliated union’s election spending should be counted as part of a party’s, as they are so linked together. I didn’t at the time consider the issue of whether the EPMU was ineligible to be a third party under the Electoral Finance Act’s s13(2)(f)(i) which list sas ineligible “a person involved in the administration of the affairs of a party” as I was thinking of that applying to individuals who hold office within a party.

But that day a lawyer pointed out to me that the term “person” in law includes corporates, as it is only the term “natural person” which is restricted to individuals. Hence there was a real issue about the EPMU’s eligibility.

A reading of the Labour Party constitution found that the EPMU is eligible for representation on close to 100 Labour Party committees, and that every member of the EPMU automatically is a Labour Party member should they chose to exercise the right. To me this clearly made the EPMU a person involved in the administration of the affairs of a party.

Hence I wrote to the Electoral Commission setting out the arguments for why the EPMU is not eligible to be a third party (and remember i did not write the law – Labour did). They said they would consider the arguments and any response from the EPMU.

I was somewhat surprised to see an article quoting from my letter in the Dominion Post today. I haven’t spoken to the Dominion Post on the issue, and presume the EPMU leaked the letter and story.

I wasn’t planning to release my letter publicly until after there was a decision, but as it is the public domain, the letter is after the break. I think there is a compelling case under the law. The reported rebuttal from the EPMU seems fairly weak – arguing they are not a dominant force in Labour. Putting aside whether or not that characterisation is correct, the test in the law is not whether they are dominant. It is whether they are involved which is to my mind a much lower threshold.

It sounds like the Electoral Commission may not be able to make an immediate decision on the issue, as the new law has no precedent to go by and this is a test case.

Again I point out the obvious – if the EPMU is deemed ineligible to be a third party, and unable to campaign in the general election – it will be because of the way the law is drafted and because of the nature of their relationship with Labour as an affiliated member. A union which does not join a political party as an affiliate member would not have a problem being a registered third party.

Continue reading »

My first crash!

Forgot to mention I had my first crash here on Wednesday.  It was a wee head on between the taxi I was in and a tuk tuk. The tuk tuk swerved onto our side of the road to overtake a double parked car and went straight into the taxi. We braked so the impact wasn’t huge and no injuries, but a hell of a shock.  The tuk tuk toppled onto the side, but was okay.

Frankly the way people drive here, I’m surprised there’s been only one crash. As I said earlier, seat belts would be nice!

.Asia launch

On Monday night we were all invited to a party to celebrate the launch of a new top level domain – dot asia or .asia more formally.

asia1.JPG

The main singer is quite well known in Bollywood. She has also appeared in a couple of films.

asia3.JPG

To the left of the presenter are the CEO of .asia – Edmon Chung, ICANN Chair Peter Dengate-Thrush, ICANN CEO Paul Twomey and Indian cricket legend Kapil Dev.  Sorry for low quality of photos but they were done on blackberry instead of normal camera.

asia4.JPG

asia5.JPG

A couple more photos of the entertainment. They put on an excellent show.

It was a damn good night and a fun way to launch a new top level domain.  I quipped that it was definitely more fun that the launch of .museum 🙂

Go Chester

I don’t normally repeat stories in full, but this NZPA story by Peter Wilson is too good to edit:

Wellington, Feb 14 NZPA – It isn’t often anyone gets the last word when they tangle with Winston Peters, but National’s Chester Borrows managed to in Parliament today.

It started when the Whanganui MP offered ministers some advice, by way of interjection, during question time.

It wasn’t audible beyond the benches at the back of the chamber but Mr Peters heard it.

He was on his feet with a point of order for Speaker Margaret Wilson.

“In the interests of certain standards in this House, I would ask you to ask the National Party member at the back who used the phrase `tell the minister to get of his’… and I won’t say what else he said, and apologise to the House for that very intemperate language.”

Ms Wilson said she hadn’t heard what Mr Borrows said, but ordered him to withdraw and apologise anyway.

That done, Mr Borrows scribbled a note which was carried by messenger to Mr Peters.

It brought him to his feet again.

“You asked that member to apologise…he has now written to me using the same phrase and I don’t think he should. He should again apologise to the House.”

Ms Wilson didn’t go that far, although she advised members that if they wanted to send offensive notes to each other it would be better to do it outside the chamber.

Mr Peters stood up again, clutching the offensive note, and sought permission to table it.

Permission was granted and the note became an official document of Parliament, available for public scrutiny and then to be archived.

Written under parliamentary letterhead, it was addressed to the Rt Hon Winston Peters.

“Got you off your arse though, didn’t I?” it said.

 Heh heh heh. Now that is funny.

Caption Contest Time

Telecom Roaming

As a frequent traveller, I know to always check the Telecom website to see if my 027 phone will work in the countries I am going to.

Now the Telecom website clearly states my CDMA phone will roam in India. Except it doesn’t.  Dead as a dodo with no signal.

Luckily I also have my blackberry, but most people call me on my 027 phone, so is a hassle having it dead. More to the point information on a website should be correct!

More on Green sex for votes plan

Frog has responded to my post on their cunning sex for votes plan. Frog claims:

Here at Frog though there’s a long distance between going on a date with someone, which the original post discussed, and having sex. In fact it’s a traverse that I often fail to cross.

What is not clear is whether this long distance often not traversed is voluntary on Frog’s part, or due to rebuffs from other frogs. This may be making a virtue out of necessity 🙂

Frog also defends the reputation of Greenies:

I do need to assure readers that you can tell the difference when/if you eventually get to sleep with a Green – only Greens believe in true sustainability and making things last.

I am tempted to put this down to skiting, but then consider than a well known Greenie is animal rights activist and vegan Heather Mills. And what is in the news today about Heather:

“Heather was insatiable, she demanded sex six times a night.

“I’d come home to find her waiting naked in bed. She had a hoard of vibrators for when she was home alone. Her favourite was a huge back massager that she plugged into the mains.

Well a mains power supply will certainly make things last. I just hope it was windmill powered not coal powered.

Anyway returning to the main issue of the t-shirts saying “I only date girls/boys who vote Green”, it has occured to me that this may be an illegal advertisement under the Electoral Finance Act. Let’s look at what the law says:

S5(1) para (a)(i) says :

“election advertisement means any form of words or graphics, or both, that can reasonably be regarded as … encouraging or persuading voters to vote, or not to vote, for 1 or more specified parties or for 1 or more candidates or for any combination of such parties and candidates”

Now a t-shirt slogan is a form of words or graphics. Can it be reasonably regarded as encouraging people to vote Green? Well most definitively – it refers to vote Green and a reasonable person would regard the enhanced prospect of a date as encouragement. If those wearing the shirts were hideously ugly you might be able to argue it doesn’t, but the t-shirt wearers all semmed pleasantly attractive.

So next we ask has this advertisement been published?

For this we look at S4(1):

publish, in relation to an advertisement, means to—
(b) issue, hand out, or display, to the public; or

Well clearly the t-shirts are on display, so they have been published.

And what sort of election advertisement are they. Again S4(1) says:

party advertisement means any form of words or graphics, or both, that can reasonably be regarded as encouraging or persuading voters … to vote for the party (whether or not the name of the party is stated):

So it is not just an election advertisement, but a party advertisement. So in what way is it breaking the law?

s63(2) states:

No promoter may, during a regulated period, publish, or cause or permit to be published, any election advertisement unless—
(a) the advertisement contains a statement that sets out the name and address of the promoter of the advertisement; and
(b) the promoter is entitled to promote the advertisement.

There is no name and address on the t-shirt, so the t-shirts clearly are breaking the law. That is an illegal practice under S63(4).

But as it is a party advertisement, further laws have been broken probably:

S65(1) says “A promoter must not publish, or cause or permit to be published, an election advertisement that encourages or persuades, or appears to encourage or persuade, voters to vote for a party unless the publication of the advertisement … is authorised in writing by the financial agent of the party”

Has the Green Party financial agent approved the t-shirts in writing? If not that is another law broken.

And finally, do the Greens need to include the cost of those t-shirts as part of their election expenses? Yes, if they approved the t-shirts. S94(1) defines it as an election expense.

Now the London Greens have real issues if they have incurred this election expense without permission (in writing) of the Financial Agent as required by s96 para (a). You see under s97(i) this is automatically at least an illegal practice and if done wilfully it is a corrupt practice.

And no this would not have been an issue under the old Electoral Act 1993, as the definition of a party’s election activity in S214B(1) was not “any form of words or graphics” but publishing of notices, posters, pamphlets, handbills, billboards and cards, plus newspaper, TV and radio advertising.

And the authorisation requirement in the old S221(1) is even more narrow:

“… no person shall publish or cause or permit to be published in any newspaper, periodical, poster, or handbill, or broadcast or cause or permit to be broadcast over any radio or television station, any advertisement which … encourages or persuades or appears to encourage or persuade voters to vote for a party registered under Part 4 of this Act.”

So that clearly is not a t-shirt. The t-shirts would have been fine before the passing of the Electoral Finance Act. Now they appear to have committed two or three illegal acts and potentially one corrupt act.

Isn’t it somewhat sad that those Green supporters can’t wear a fun t-shirt that promotes their party, without breaking the law?

UPDATE: A reader has found a more detailed photo of the shirts on Facebook, and it seems the Greens are aware they are an election ad and have authorised them.  Full marks to the Greens for realising the extent of the law they voted for.  It does make the shirts look a bit silly though:

They may still have a problem though. If my memory is correct 16 Cambridge Terrace is the office of the Green Party.  And the law requires financial agents to use their home residential address, not their work address. So time to get the twink out.

Too delicious for words

This NZ Herald story on the House yesterday has a wonderful quote in defence of Annette’s King blaming the high murder rate on the moon and the sun:

Ms King, the Justice Minister, wasn’t there to defend herself against National’s Simon Power but Associate Justice Minister Rick Barker said her comments did not represent her own views.

Okay is that clear. The Minister’s comments do not represent her own views. This must be a previously unknown feature of Helen’s 1999 pledge for new standards of accountability.

It was a hoax

If you think your Valentine’s Day is sad …

How sad is this?  At drinks last night, Jordan Carter commented to me “Do you realise tomorrow will be the third Valentine’s Day in a row we have spent together”.

To protect Jordan’s reputation, as much as my own, I should clarify he means we have both been overseas on InternetNZ business, on the 14th of February.

Once was an ICANN meeting, once for the APRICOT conference and once was for meeting with Australian anti-spam agencies. It is just a coincidence, but a sad one.  Next year my pledge is to be home for Valentine’s Day!

Government letting TV viewers get screwed

Chris Barton nails the issue perfectly in the Herald on the ridicolous situation of consumers being forced to buy multiple devices just to view all the free to air channels.

There are simple things the Government could do right now to dramatically improve the lot of broadcast consumers. “Must carry” rules could stop the nonsense that’s going on between Sky and TVNZ and give both consumers and the Government immediate benefit. If Sky was required to carry Freeview TV6, the soon-to-be launched TV7 and Sports Extra (a simple channel tuning exercise on the Sky box) and Freeview was required to carry Sky’s Prime channel, consumers would get a much fairer deal.

Hear hear.

How else to explain the ridiculous situation many consumers face right now – that if they want to get all the free-to-air digital channels in New Zealand, they have to buy two set top boxes when one would do?

The Government needs to intervene also in setting open access standards for set top boxes to stop further anti-competitive tactics through the use of incompatible electronic programme guides and other lock-out mechanisms. Even Freeview is guilty of this anti-diversity behaviour.

Some of its accredited set top boxes – the Zinwell and re-badged Dick Smith box – are locked down to prevent customers tuning in other free-to-air satellite channels as they become available. It shouldn’t be allowed. Or, at the very least, prospective buyers should be told: “This box will not allow you to pick up other freely available satellite channels in New Zealand.”

Yes I bet that isn’t in the marketing campaign.  If a channel is free to air, one should be able to tune your device to receive it.

Cullen’s bad timing

Dr Cullen has refused to provide tax cuts over the last few years when surpluses have been the second highest in the world – close to $10 billion. He has claimed they were unaffordable.

Now suddenly in election year they are affordable, despite weakening economic growth leading to a fall in the six month surplus of around $1.7 billion.

So Dr Cullen says tax cuts are unaffordable when the surplus is $10 billion but are affordable when the surplus is far lower. No wonder he looks so unhappy every time he has to talk about them.

Fallow on Deforestation policy

Brian Fallow looks at the dilemmas facing the Government over their retrospective deforestation tax, and concludes that the best solution for NZ would be to scrap it.  And this comes from a columnist who generally has been supportive of the Government’s initiatives in the greenhouse gas area.  He writes:

Well here’s a suggestion: Forget the whole thing.

Not just the free allocation of 55 million tradable credits but the policy for which it is a partial offset, the retrospective deforestation tax.

The fundamental question to ask is what the object of the policy is. Is it to reduce New Zealand’s net greenhouse gas emissions, or to limit the financial risk to the taxpayer?

If it is the former – as it should be – there is a real danger that the policy of penalising deforestation will prove counterproductive.

And if so it will also be an own goal from a narrow fiscal point of view in the long run.

The policy is intended to discourage a switch in land use from trees, which store lots of carbon as they grow, to grass whose carbon is quickly returned to the atmosphere.

Increasing the proportion of New Zealand that is covered by plantation forest from 7 per cent would buy time, decades, in which the economy could adjust to a low-carbon future.

But if the policy effectively locks some forested land into a second-best use there is an opportunity cost. Export receipts, incomes, jobs, profits and taxes will all be lower than they might otherwise be.

The importance of land-based industries to the economy argues powerfully against reducing flexibility of land use.

And even from an environmental point of view there is a risk that erecting a barrier to exit from forestry will deter people from getting into it in the first place.

If the decision to change a block of land from grass to trees is seen as effectively irreversible, people may think twice about doing it.

Policy makers are liable to think a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.

They can see how much land is deforested but they cannot measure how much afforestation that might have taken place does not because landowners fear lock-in.

And they cannot measure the broader chilling effects on investment that might flow from imposing what amounts to a retrospective tax.

The Government might see devolving a deforestation liability as incentivising future behaviour (replanting) but those affected by it are likely to see it as penalising past behaviour (planting the forests in the first place) which cannot be changed and which indeed was actively encouraged at the time.

Retrospective tax changes are generally regarded as odious. They are also a bad look for a country which needs to attract investment capital…

Fallow suggests as an alternative:

In the meantime, while we wait and see what international rules emerge, it would seem to make sense for the Government to shelve plans to devolve the deforestation liability, and avoid the complications around the associated allocation of free units.

It should focus more on what will encourage the afforestation of a millon hectares of bare, erosion-prone land and less on locking in what may be a sub-optimal use of country already forested.

The Government rarely gets the balance of stick and carrot right, and it seems this area is no difference.

Vector to lay 300 kms of fibre in Auckland

Very pleased to see Vector announce plans for 300 kms of high speed fibre to be laid in Auckland.

What their strategy appears to be is not to compete at the retail level, but to offer ISPs a regional backhaul service to compete with Telecom, and faster than Telecom’s.

If I have interpreted their intentions correctly, that is a good thing as backhaul has little competition at the moment and is the major speed limitation at present.  Of course backhaul includes national and international but everything has to start somewhere.

There is no doubt NZ’s future is to have fibre to almost every premise.  It is where the OECD is going.  The question for us is whether we want to be last or one of the leaders.

The Press fails Clark

Today’s Press editorial:

Prime Minister Helen Clark has had two opportunities so far this year for big, stage-managed and headline-grabbing pronouncements on her Government’s election-year agenda, …

Twice, she has let down those voters hoping for imaginative and robust proposals to attend to the nation’s needs. She seems more preoccupied for now with simply pressing voters’ buttons, while side-stepping the inevitable questions that seek the substance behind these set-piece speeches…

Perhaps the only real clarity that can be taken from Clark’s speech is the signal that, if returned to office, she intends her Government to redouble its Wellington-knows-best efforts and continue to attempt to rescue suffering taxpayers by spending their money for them on ill-conceived pipe dreams.

The reactive nature of the housing policy carries some uncanny echoes of Clark’s state-of-the-nation speech a couple of weeks earlier, when she vowed to raise the school or training leaving age to 18, but with none of the detail in place to provide answers to the many questions immediately prompted…

Considering one of the “new”policies announced is actually 14 years old, there really is no excuse for the lack of detail.

Getting our news from China

McCain and Obama win

As expected McCain and Obama won Virginia, Maryland and DC.  Let’s look at scenarios now.

McCain has 797 delegates, with Romney on 285 and Huckabee on 240.  Also Paul on 14.  He needs 1,191 to win on another 394. Huckabee may withdraw at some stage (or Romney may endorse – less likely), but how long might it take for McCain to get 394 extra.

It is impossible to be precise as only Vermont is winner take all.  But the earliest McCain can win, if Huckabee stays in is at Pennsylvania on 22 April – their 74 delegates could push him over 1,200.

On the 4th of March you have Texas (140), Ohio (88), Rhode Island (20) and Vermont (17).  If McCain wins all of those then Huckabee might throw it in.

The Democat side is more fascinating. Obama has 1,259 to 1,210 for Clinton.  Remove the super delegates who can defect and it is  Obama 1,103 to 968 Clinton.

Now they need 2,025 to win so Obama needs 766 to win and Clinton needs 815.  However the remaining primaries and caucuses have only 1,078 delegates assigned to them.  It is almost impossible for Obama to win 766/1078 due to their method of allocating delegates not being winner takes all.

So the way it will be resolved is either by one candidate withdrawing, or failing that the party leadership (or John Edwards endorsing) urging super delegates to pledge themselves to the front runner to get a result.  There are still 398 super delegates yet to declare.

The Democrats have Democrats Abroad today (7 delegates) and on the 19th Wisconsin and Hawaii.  Obama is likely to win both those so if hw wins Democrats Abraod also that will be 11 in a row.

It may also all turn on the 4th of March – Texas, Ohio, Rhode Island and Vermont are up for a total of 370 delegates.  Clinton really needs to win both Texas and Ohio or the pressure will really go on to withdraw.

More blog goodness

Jordan Carter has a photo on the “chocolate” dish I tried to eat.

The Hive has details of what MFAT has done with regards to the jailed Saudi blogger. People will be delighted to know “the New Zealand embassy in Riyadh is monitoring closely”. Does this mean they have actually said a single word to the Saudi Government, let alone said anything publicly? Alas no.

At least the Goverment is consistent in not supporting free speech in both NZ and Saudi Arabia.

Poneke has a post up to his usual standards of quality and thoroughness – on former chief air accidents investigator Ron Chippindale.  He revisits Erebus and reveals that Chippindale told him in 1989 that he knew Air New Zealand had lied.

Goonix at The Visible Hand in Economics compares working for families payments to the Aryan scheme of giving out medals in 1939 to mothers who have four or more children. Whoever knew economists could be so provocative.

Bernard Hickey blogs at interest.co.nz on why a shared equity scheme won’t work. He states:

This policy is a headline in search of some sustainable detail.

The affordability problem is not a demand or a financing problem. Most people have no trouble getting a 90% or a 100% loan these days. The real problem is a supply problem. There simply aren’t enough new houses being built to keep prices from rising.

Mike Moore at Cairns Blog has been digging up scandals and actually held a press conference revealing doings of a local Mayor. His blog has become a real player.

Standing up for those you dislike

I never thought I would be quoting a Waikato Law Professor, but one can’t help but agree with Andrew Gillespie‘s column in the NZ Herald. Extracts:

Welcome to the increasingly intolerant society. A society where free speech, the liberty from which all other freedoms spring, has been under systematic siege on three fronts for the past year.

The first attack on free speech was when Parliament decided to remove the right of the public to satirise, ridicule or denigrate any Parliamentarian while at work in the chamber.

… The second area where free speech is under attack is with the new Electoral Finance Act.

…The third attack on free speech has been over gang insignia. At the moment, there is a move in some regions to restrict what gang members may wear in certain public spaces.

…Freedom of speech encompasses all aspects of our lives. The test of how sincere we are about freedom of speech is in how much we are willing to tolerate those we disagree with.

Gillespie is basically saying what Noam Chomsky once said:

If we don’t believe in free expression for people we despise, we don’t believe in it at all.

Talking of the Electoral Finance Act, well done to those who got front page media coverage for their anti-EFA protest at Parliament on Tuesday.

Peter McC has a good roundup of stories and links.

What are they famous for?

The Australian apology

I was a fan of John Howard but I could never work out why he didn’t arrange for a formal apology to Aboriginals for the past treatment they suffered.

In New Zealand, the Crown has already done 20 formal apologies (and settlements) for past behaviour.  It is am important part of the process of moving forward.

So it is good to see Australia catching up to NZ, in terms of formally recognising the wrongs of the past, with the apology by Prime Minister Kevin Rudd.

The full text is here.  It is very eloquent.

Sex for Votes?