Key’s speech in response
Key’s speech in response to Clark is quite fun to view. It’s 18 minutes long.
“Jane” has a blog detailing her last 90 days alive, before she kills herself.
Personally I think it is a hoax, and will be revealed to be some sort of experiment. But in the meantime it will achieve greater and greater awareness as the time gets closer. Currently 83 days to go.
Key’s speech in response to Clark is quite fun to view. It’s 18 minutes long.
The Dom Post reports:
A Palmerston North man who punched a woman in the face at the Wellington Cup race meeting later told police: “That’s what we do in Palmy.”
The police prosecutor said Parker had made a derogatory comment about the friend of a woman who was walking in front of him as they were leaving the course.
The woman turned around and asked him to explain. Parker pushed her in the chest, she pushed back and Parker then punched her in the face with a closed fist. The punch was hard enough to knock her backwards and cut the left side of her nose.
When spoken to by police, Parker admitted punching her and said “that’s what we do in Palmy”.
This reminds me of when John Cleese visited Palmy and said afterwards if you ever needed motivation to kill yourself, one should move to Palmy.
The Herald editorial gets to the nub of the problem:
The perverse thing about the Government’s attempt to tackle housing affordability is that it has accurately pinpointed the reason for young house-hunters’ gloom. “Fundamentally, the problem is the under-supply of affordable homes,” said Helen Clark in her statement to Parliament. This suggests an understanding of the fact that house prices rise when demand runs ahead of supply. Any rational response would, therefore, seek to increase supply while, at the same time, reduce demand. Sadly, the Government’s response tinkers around the edges of supply while stimulating demand, thereby underpinning prices.
Yes there could be a very interesting reaction to what the Government says it will do. Giving some people interest free loans will increase demand for houses, which will push prices up for everyone. Those who do not qualify for interest free loans could be very very pissed off.
After we visited the Taj Mahal, we then visited Agra Fort. Now calling it a fort is an under statement. It is almost a city within the walls, and India used to be ruled from there. Parts of it are over 1,000 years old.
Again some wonderful architecture.
As I said, it is almost a city inside the fort. One could have a great game of cricket there.
This is the view you get from Agra Fort of the Taj Mahal a couple of kms away. Magnificent.
Have just caught up with Katherine’s decision to retire. While I’m pleased that Katherine is going to have more time with her family, I am very sad that National is losing her as an MP and future Minister.
This is a pretty major blow. Not only was Katherine a front bencher, she was one of only two front-bench women. And she would have been an incredibly good Education Minister.
I can recall Katherine before she was an MP. It was at the Southern Regional Conference in 1999 and someone pointed Katherine out to me, and said they were hoping she would become a candidate, and was a real star. And I soon decided they were right. There was a small group of us who travelled to all five Regional Conferences (President, Leader, General Manager and a couple of others) and all of us were excited over the prospect of being able to get Katherine to become an MP. She stood out.
Her husband Andy is a first class guy also, and as sad as I am about us losing Katherine, I’m pleased they’ll be getting more time together. Four kids is no small task to look after.
On the political side Anne Tolley has been appointed Education Spokesperson. Anne has been very successful as Chief Whip, so it is a deserved step up. This moves Nathan Guy up to Chief Whip which is a rapid promotion as Nathan has been in Parliament for two years only. People will see more of Nathan in years to come – have no doubt. Chris Tremain takes Nathan’s old job as Junior Whip, and he will relish the challenge.
One of the useful requirements for being a Whip is to be able to work well with MPs and Whips from the other parties as they do the work agreeing on time allocations for committee stages debates etc. Nathan and Chris are both very genial guys who will have no problems in that regard.
The Taj Mahal is commonly judged one of the seven wonders of the world, so the opportunity to go see it was not one I planned to miss.
Those who don’t know the history of it, can check out Wikipedia. It took 20,000 people 22 years to create and is a monument to love – created by Shah Jahan to the memory of his third wife Mumtaz Mahal after she died in 16xx.
The guys in the party were a bit worried that a romatic present on this scale, just lifts the barrier a bit high for Valentine’s Day. But then we heard how Mumtaz Mahal gave Shah Jahan 14 children. A couple of the girls exclaimed that they’d want more than a bloody palace for 14 children, and one of them said she’d rather kill herself than have 14 kids. I wanted to ask the tour guide what the Shah got his 1st and 2nd wives!
This is a photo of the gateway. It’s damn impressive by itself. The 11 domes on the front at the top are replicated on the back, and represent the 22 years it took to build.
This is the view of the Taj Mahal from the gateway. It is perfectly symmetrical. And remember this built was 400 years ago.
Just to prove I was actually there, and didn’t just download photos off the Internet.
A close up of one of the marble blocks. Stunning work.
This is a passage from the Koran (well so I am told). There are almost 100 of these on the buildings.
Only as you get closer to the entrance to the tomb itself, do you realise how massive the structure is. You are not allowed to take photos inside.
One of the other structures making up the complex.
Definitely a highlight of the time in India. Well worth the journey.
First we have Colin Espiner before the speech:
There’s talk of more social spending and more money for infrastructure. I’m sure she’ll also touch on the environment.
In the wake of yesterday’s Salvation Army report, the Government should be a little more careful about simply increasing social spending without improving performance, though. The Sallies embarrassed Clark on the eve of her big day by revealing she’s spent an extra $16 billion on social services without – according to the Sallies – improving the lot of the underclass one little bit.
This is precisely the sort of wasteful spending National ought to be getting its teeth into, and I’d imagine John Key will use it in his retaliatory speech today.
Colin also touches on the likely new NZ First MP:
I read with amazement in the Dom this morning that the party is likely to re-select aged ultra-conservative former NZ First and former National MP Dail Jones as its replacement for Brian Donnelly …
To do this it would need to overlook the next two on the list – Susan Baragwanath and Jim Peters. No problem with ignoring Winston’s brother – he was a complete waste of space last time he was in Parliament. But if NZ First is serious about gaining 5% in the next election, does it honestly think that putting a man who served in the Muldoon government back in office is going to help?
… The man makes Gordon Copeland look like a rabid Left-winger.
I find it interesting the love fest Labour supporters now have for Winston, and wonder if they may regret it when Jones is an MP again.
Vernon Small detects a theme of Labout still cares:
She has linked the promised programme of tax cuts in the May Budget together with extra funding for non-government organisations, affordable housing, and a range of programmes to target youth crime and skill improvements.
The message seems to be that “Labour still cares” when it comes to household budgets, under pressure from rising prices, and giving children the best start in life.
Politically it is obviously an attempt to counter the compassionate conservatism that is becoming a hallmark of John Key’s leadership – and reassuring the party faithful that a big spend-up on tax cuts does not mean Labour has abandoned its social policy roots.
It will be very interesting how the left goes about denouncing tax cuts, as they usually do, with Clark now so wedded to them.
John Armstrong puts the champagne on hold:
You wouldn’t be cracking open the champagne tonight if you were a Labour MP sitting on a narrow majority.
Any backbencher hoping the Prime Minister was going to announce one or two juicy initiatives in her annual statement to Parliament which would capture the public’s imagination will have been disappointed.
Plans for some publicly-owned land to be freed up for new housing – a further step in the Government’s efforts to make housing more affordable – is about as exciting as it gets.
Armstrong has caught on that there is little new in the speech – mainly repackaging.
And then we return to Espiner Junior who calls it a solid start:
No fireworks, but a solid start, I thought.
The Opposition already know every word that she will utter, having been given the speech four hours in advance. The Leader of the Opposition can then stand up and rip her to shreds.
Except, he didn’t. Not today, anyway. Probably because while there was no “big idea” or startlingly new programmes, it was an extremely difficult speech to rip to shreds.
In fact much of what
Clark said could have come from Key’s mouth. He would hardly disagree with moves to make housing more affordable. Using more state funding for the private sector NGOs was actually National’s idea in the first place. Tax cuts? National’s idea was well. Further education and training for youth? Key agrees. Crack down on youth crime? Ditto.Perhaps that’s why the opening was a bit of a damp squib, which lacked its usual fireworks.
I thought Key’s reply was funny and entertaining, and he remembered to pose the usual vote of no-confidence in the Government.
But I would have liked a bit more of a rebuttal of
Clark ’s speech and a bit more about what National would do in return. If he wants to be the prime minister, he’s got to start acting like one.
From those reactions, I don’t think there is much of a winner or a loser (unlike the earlier speeches). Maybe you give Clark some brownie points for making an effort this year to put something fresh in.
Scoop has a series of photos of costumes for the Sevens, which is even better than the Dom Post collection. Check it out if you like admiring the variety of costumes.
My two favourites:
A great Fred Dagg collection.
Not sure the costumes comply 100% with sharia law!
People may recall the PM falsely claimed that National had not voted voted for a single treaty settlement negotiated by Labour, and I blogged that in fact they had voted for eight out of ten settlement acts.
The Standard has found I made a mistake and National only voted for seven out of ten settlements (still a world removed from Clark’s zero).
I had National down as voting for the Ngaa Rauru Kiitahi Settlement Act. National voted for it as first and second reading, but voted against at third reading after failing to get a schedule amended which dealt with placing certain spiritual beliefs into law. This wasn’t picked up as under urgency the commitee stage and third reading were done together, and it was only at the last minute National changed how it was voting, so by going off the early votes it appeared National was supporting.
Unlike Helen, I am happy to correct my mistakes, and certainly it is a strength of the blogosphere that mistakes can be highlighted and corrected.
On Sunday around 100 of us went from Delhi to Agra, courtesy of three of the local sponsors. We were going primarily to see the Taj Mahal, but also visit the local markets and see the Agra Fort.
Departure time was 6 am. A very red sun was coming up as we left. Superman would be powerless until it turned yellow!
It is only 250 kms to Agra but just getting through Delhi and through Agra adds a couple of hours on at each end – we didn’t get there until 11 am. The bus was very comfortable though and spent most of the trip learning about the Isle of Man, as Phil, the guy next to me, is the country code manager for .im. Jeremy Clarkson lives on the Isle and they have almost no taxes there so that’s two great things about it.
They had a fridge on the bus with soft drinks and beer so that made the trip over pretty good.
Whenever the bus slowed down, you would get surrounded by people trying to sell things. They would even pull the window open and throw things on your lap, and then ask for payment. Or in this case place their monkey on a stick close to the window. And if you take a photo of it, you have to pay them.
You can just see here a snake charmer performing. The snake did actually respond to the music but also got tired after a while and went to sleep – so the charmer poked it a couple of times to get it performing again. Personally I’d not poke any snakes myself!
Cristin from the Registrar Constituency making friends with the elephant and its owner.
Everywhere you go in India it seems you see cows, steers, monkeys, donkeys and elephants on the roads.
From 11 am to 5 pm we toured the Taj Mahal and Agra Fort (separate posts on them) and then headed back home. The trip up was great as we were all raring to go, but on the way home we just wanted to get to bed and we didn’t get in until 11 pm.
The worst thing was trying to sleep on the bus. You see the convention in India is to honk your horn if you want a vehicle to get out of your way. This isn’t seen as a rude thing (as in NZ where someone might bash you for it) but is common courtesy.
The problem is this meant the driver honked his horn – oh around every 45 seconds or so. So you’re trying to nod off, and then HOOONNNKKKK and your head snaps up alert, and then just as you relax again, then HOOONNNKKKK again. Now imagine that for five hours and you get the idea. Don’t get me wrong – to was worth it to get to see the Taj etc but it was tiring. Big thanks to Logix Boxes and the other sponsors for the trip.
Blair Mulholland has found a nice clothing designer to stalk. He likes Miriam Clements’ statement:
I studied economics at university and I subscribe to right wing economic theory – ie. the less government interference the better
as much as her gorgeous photo.
No Right Turn looks at the censored environmental report and concludes:
My immediate reaction is that Trevor Mallard is lying when he claims that the material was cut because it was not supported by the facts. The final section accurately reflects the content of previous chapters …
NRT does state he accepts no Minister saw the early draft (I wonder if that includes though the Minister’s staff) and agrees with the Greens and National that the Environment Ministry is to blame and should lose the responsibility of preparing the report to the more independent Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment.
Whale Oil is getting nasty threats from certain anonymous people who objected to his detective work on the People Power website and the CYFSWatch website:
What you display is a complete and utter recklessness for your personal safety, which is fine, but as a parent, you don’t have that luxury anymore.
If something did happen to you – where would that leave him?
You don’t seem to realise how vulnerable you are Cameron – or worse, you maybe just don’t care.
You might as well have painted a great big target on yourself which reads “aim here please”.
Deathwish, perhaps?
If I was Cameron, I’d send that one to the Police. Especially now that Cameron has stated the anonymous threat makers are madder than Tom Cruise – bound to provoke them further!
Cactus Kate blogs about Bernard Hickey’s balls. Sadly for Bernard only in the symbolic sense of his ballsy statement:
Prices here are currently at least 30 per cent over-valued and it’s now a question of how much and how fast they fall rather than if they will fall.
Kate also enjoys an exchange in Bernard’s comment section.
Frog Blog wants the PM to set an election date well in advance of the normal six weeks notice. I agree with him/her/it.
In fact I like the idea of a fixed election date, with an early election only if a no confidence vote is lost and no alternative government can be formed.
Yay, the US Writer’s strike is almost over. If there was no full Season Four of Battlestar Galactica I would have been madder than a vegan at McDonalds.
As there has been more time to investigate these bright new policies of Helen’s, it is looking more and more they are just old or stolen policies repackaged.
First the shared equity scheme – has been announced a dozen times already it seems, and was pledged to be in place by 2006.
Then we have the Charter of Victims’ Rights which is actually 14 years old. Helen first pledged this in 1994.
The new NGO policy is relatively new – to Labour anyway. It seems to be very close to the policy National announced last May.
Sounds like National Research have been working overtime today!
I saw yesterday that Michael Laws’ daughter, Lucy, was sick. Today the media clarify that the three year old has leukaemia.
I doubt any parent could have more scary or sad news than that, and Michael and family I am sure have the well wishes and prayers of everyone. There are no words adequate enough to convey how deeply one wants Lucy to get better.
As report after report has shown NZ is one of the worst countries in the world for housing affordability, the Government has announced. Or in fact the Herald has announced for them via a leaked copy of the speech.
There are no details yet, apart from the fact some people will be able to qualify for interest-free loans. It is hard to say how much of an impact it will have until you know how much one can borrow from the state, and who will be eligible.
It doesn’t really address any of the core underlying issues of housing affordability such as NZ incomes or supply of land or high inflation causing high interest rates or even tax treatment of property. It is just a targeted form of welfare – having people on higher incomes pay the interest on behalf of those on lower incomes. Now that may be popular with some, and be of assistance to some, but I don’t think it will change any of the fundamentals.
Looking further on in the speech, there is a promise to look at the supply of land issues. This is a positive step, after months of decrying calls to do exactly that from Don Brash and Owen McShane etc. Having said that, I am sceptical the reviews will lead to policy changes.
And in the real big news, the Government has devised a brand name of “School Plus” for its January announcement, after the reaction to it wasn’t as positive as hoped.
Maybe we can refer to Cullen’s fiscal policies as “Tax Plus”!
Andrew Sullivan sees the future:
It’s November 2008. A young Pakistani Muslim is watching television and sees that this man—Barack Hussein Obama—is the new face of America. In one simple image, America’s soft power has been ratcheted up not a notch, but a logarithm. A brown-skinned man whose father was an African, who grew up in Indonesia and Hawaii, who attended a majority-Muslim school as a boy, is now the alleged enemy. If you wanted the crudest but most effective weapon against the demonization of America that fuels Islamist ideology, Obama’s face gets close. It proves them wrong about what America is in ways no words can.
A President Obama (heh I accidentally typed President Osama at first) would be a powerful symbol against the hatred of the US in many countries. The”Great Satan” would be harder to demonise by the radical Islamists. It’s not reason enough to vote for him by itself, but it is a powerful factor.
Well it is 2.30 am here in Delhi so I am off to sleep. By the time I’m up I guess the speeches in Parliament will be over. All things considered, I’m pretty happy sleeping through them 🙂
The Dom Post reports that Dail Jones is set to return to the House for a third time, once Brian Donnelly resigns to become High Commissioner to the Cook Islands.
I have to say that I think it goes against the spirit of MMP to go into the election with a party list, on which people vote, and then after the election to “fix” things so people lower down the list leapfrog their way into Parliament. The Greens are planning to do that with Russel Norman and now NZ First with Dail Jones.
Jones is on the record as having said:
‘Custard is more dangerous than second-hand smoke. …[and] milk …is worse than second-hand smoke.’
So obviously a high flyer who will become Health Minister the next time Winston hands out baubles.
The appointment of Brian Donnelly as High Commissioner gives me mixed feelings. On a personal level I am delighted for Brian and he will do a fine job I am sure – better than most MPs given diplomatic posts. But it is the reality that there is no way at all he would have got the job unless Winston was Foreign Affairs Minister – and for a party which actively campaigned against the baubles of office – it is a major and hypocritical bauble Winston has dished out.
My spies in the Cook Islands tell me Donnelly’s impending appointment was the front page story of Cook Islands News yesterday. The word “bauble” is used in that article also!
The same issue also reports that as Donnelly goes from politics to diplomacy, Todd McClay may be doing the reverse.
Todd is the Cook Islands Ambassador to the European Union, and is reported as considering standing for the NZ Parliament this year. His father, Roger McClay, was MP for Taupo for many years. Roger also worked for Winston in more recent times as an advisor, so it is a very small world. The Cook Islands story says:
Todd McClay , the Cook Islands ambassador to the European Union, based in Brussels, is contemplating his future with the embassy and whether to contest the New Zealand general elections.
Speaking to Cook Islands News from New Zealand, McClay said that he has been asked to consider standing for parliament in New Zealand and has received nothing but support and encouragement both in New Zealand and the Cook Islands to do so.
McClay, whose father was a former NZ minister of Pacific island affairs and children’s commissioner, Roger McClay, has New Zealand, Irish and Cook Islands heritage.
He holds a politics degree and is completing a masters in international public law. McClay speaks French with a practical understanding of the Spanish and Italian languages.
I know who I would want in Parliament given a choice between Todd McClay and Dail Jones!
Helen Clark has now become the longest serving leader the NZ Labour Party has had. That’s a not inconsiderable achievement, and an indication of how dominant her leadership has been in the last decade.
She has been leader for around 14 years, three months, and has overtaken their 1st leader – Harry Holland.
In National the longest serving leader was Sid Holland who did 17 years and Holyoake who did almost 15 years.
Just read this, and laugh.
I should have taken a photo. It definitely looked like chocolate to me.
Long-time blog readers will know that DPF and friends enjoy the odd bottle of red wine at our regular gatherings at the Cork King’s house. And every year on 10 February, we try to guess how many bottles we have drunk.
The trend over the past few years has been clear:
So will we make 500 for the year to 10 Feb 2008? Let’s look at the photo?
Now just to make it harder the number of stelvins is increasing, making it harder to estimate. In 2006 there were 81 stelvins making up 18% of the total. In 2007 there were 109 stelvins, making up 22% of the total. 2008 looks to have a hell of a lot of stelvins. Generally they take up less room, so I think it is definitely over 500.
For historical comparison purposes, here are the corks from the first three years. Over six years that has been over 2,500 bottles of wine drunk 🙂
As usual, make your guesses below.
Getting to Delhi was some mission. One tends to think of Asia as being in our backyard, but Delhi is a lot closer to London than Wellington.
Started with a four hour flight to Sydney or Air NZ. Then had a few hours at Sydney Airport.
As proof of how small the world is, I ran into a couple of friends at the airport – Sonia and Brett. I met Sonia a few years ago at a cokctail function in Sydney when I was pretending to be the deposed prime minister of a former communist state. Brett served on the Executive of the IYDU with me and is a former President of the Australian Young Liberals.
The next flight was Qantas to Mumbai – 13 hours. I wasn’t looking forward to it as I was cattle class and it was packed full. Normally I regard this as akin to water boarding. But the fact they had personalised entertainment systems made all the difference. I got to Level 80 on Tetris and watched Atonement which was a great movie – about two sisters, and the younger one gets the boyfriend of the older one falsely convicted of rape just before WWII.
Mumbai Airport turned into a bit of a nightmare. It should have been simple as I already had a boarding pass, but I had to go through customs and check my bag back in. I asked where to go, to check in for my flight and was told by the armed soldiers who seem to also be the helpdesk to go out the door, along the road, up a floor and back in there.
I did that, and after queueing up at Jet Airways, got told this was international only, and I needed to go back to the other terminal for domestic transit. I went back there and then got sent somewhere else which was wrong, and finally after over an hour of being jerked about, I started to get fairly stroppy. Now raising your voice in a pissed off manner isn’t probably advisable to soldiers with sub machine guns, but my refusing to budget until someone personally walked me to the right location actually worked. And Murphy’s law it was around 20 metres away from where I started.
Got taken by bus away to the right departure gate (the airport is absolutely huge – took over 10 minutes driving over the runways), and then onto the two hour flight to Delhi.
Despite leaving at 11 pm the flight to Delhi was also packed full. By coincidence I was seated next to ICANN CEO Paul Twomey, so we chatted various ICANN issues. When we landed at 1 am, dozens of people switched their cellphones on and were chatting within seconds of the wheels touching down (some minutes before we actually stopped). I was amused both by the speed at which people started phoning, but also that it was 1 am in the morning, so God knows who the calls were to.
ICANN had a travel desk at the airport, but it turned out only at the international airport. So I had to negotiate a taxi fare into the hotel. After we negotiated what was still a rip-off price (but less so) they then tried to convince me there was also a US$10 car park exit fee. I pointed out they invented this as there was no fee paid. They then also tried to get me to pay for a petrol fillup on the way (I refused) and then at the end also asked for a tip for the good service. I finally gave over another US$5 just for the sheer gall.
I blogged previously on the interesting approach to red lights, the driver had.
So finally got to the hotel at around 2 am. I have to say I was kind of glad the other hotel burnt down as the replacement hotel is very nice – the Taj Mahal Hotel Delhi.
The rack rate here is incredibly expensive, but thankfully ICANN is paying.
I’ll blog later on about the issues at this meeting – a lot are about the issue of allowing top level domains in non-English scripts.
Audrey Young detects some positioning by Shane Jones. She comments:
Labour Maori MP Shane Jones immodestly compared himself to Winston Peters in Michele Hewitson’s interview in the Weekend Herald and he is wasting no time in attempting to live up to the comparison.
… The comparisons might be more valid with Phil Goff, than Peters.
Labour has not had a vocal hardliner since John Tamihere lost his seat in 2005 and since Goff handed over the Justice portfolio to Mark Burton in 2005.
[It is also worth noting that Jones twice referred to Annette King in a mother-hen type of capacity. Even if King won’t admit it – and she doesn’t – King plays a critical leadership role of the party’s right which is where Jones put himself, no doubt to the annoyance of Helen Clark who prefers to pretend no such thing exists.]
I can’t work out whether Jones is angling to be Goff’s Deputy or if he wants Goff to be his Deputy 🙂
Obama now had a miniscule but symbolically important lead over Clinton in the delegate race. He has 1137 to her 1134.
The next states up are Virginia, Maryland and DC. He leads the polls in the first two by over 15% and I can’t imagine he won’t win DC. So the pressure will go on Clinton to withdraw but she won’t until at least after Texas and Ohio on 4 March.