Six drink driving convictions

The Dom Post reports on a Housing NZ manager who has just racked up his sixth drink driving conviction. Despite injuring people when driving drunk, and despite being given a 12 month jail sentence, he is keeping his job because he now has home detention, and will work from home.

The appalling thing is how many times this person has probably actually driven drunk, to have racked up six convictions.  In my experience you only get stopped by the Police every 200 – 300 trips in the evening.  So to have racked up six convictions, it is highly likely someone has driven drunk on many hundreds of occasions, maybe over a thousand.

Call for top tax rate of 30%

Four top business groups have called for a reduction in the top tax rate to 30% – matching the corporate rate.

They make the valuable point that tax cuts should not be a form of income redistribution. One has dozens of other programmes that do that.  Tax cuts should be about increasing economic growth and private savings.

They have also estimated one can deliver $2.5 billion of tax cuts (annually) without a serious impact on inflation.

General Debate 10 February 2008

One of the IT firms here has arranged a visit to the Taj Mahal today, so I’m away from 6 am until 11 pm Delhi time.  Normally can think of little worse than four hours each way in a bus, but the chance to see the Taj Mahal is too good to refuse.

Main conference starts tomorrow.

The Russell media empire grows

The Russell Brown media empire continues to grow.  On top of his blog, his print columns and his radio show, Russell is to be the presenter of Media 7, which will be on the new TVNZ 7 channel.

I’d like to say I’m looking forward to seeing it, because I think NZ needs more not less shows which focus and can be critical of the media. But I’ve really got no intention of paying hundreds of dollars to buy and install a receiver for the new TVNZ channels.  The 100+ channels I get on Sky are more than enough for me.  So I’ll have to rely on people to You Tube the show.

Griffin grades Telecom

Asha Ali Abdille

Well I’m glad Asha Ali Abdille wasn’t on my flight, but if she had been I suspect she would have not managed to do anything but injure herself.  The security measures on international flights are much stronger than on domestic flights and especially compared to small aircraft on domestic flights which don’t even use metal detectors.

Not that I advocate metal detectors on these small flights.  I think it was  a sensible decision that no sane terrorist would try to hijack such a small plane. Sadly in this case Asha Ali Abdille is obviously not particularly sane.

Apart from anything else, trying to hijack a Beechcraft 1900 to fly to Australia is pretty stupid.   Australia is around 1,500 miles from Blenheim. Generally the Beechcraft is used for flights under 500 miles. Now with full tanks it can just in theory do 1,500 miles (but I doubt 1,500) but very unlikely it has full tanks for a short flight as the extra weight costs a lot. So she hadn’t even picked a plane which could make the journey.

It goes without saying huge kudos to the pilots for getting everyone down safely, despite having been stabbed by her.

Actually it seems pretty clear from the reporting that she is either mad or bad (a court can determine which) and it does make you wonder whether NZ should have its own “Do Not Fly” list as even before this placing her on there seems like the reason you would have such a list.

Winston Peters has long campaigned about this woman.  And while he often gets it wrong (remember the innocent Iraqis he defamed last election) he has some valid points about why she was allowed to bring her family over here, after she had started criminal offending.  I don’t know the law off hand but as a refugee rather than a migrant, I doubt she personally can have her residency cancelled, even with criminal convictions. But she has tried to bring in 14 family members, which can be stopped.

Peters has asked many question in Parliament about this woman.  Some extracts:

On 3 November 2004:

But this story just gets worse. I wonder whether the journalists involved really knew just who it was they were putting on the front page of the Dominion Post. It turns out that the so-called sympathy case for bleeding-heart liberals has a background that Al Capone would have been proud of. She has, first, several convictions for violence and intimidation; second, a charge of conspiracy to kill, which did not proceed because the prosecution witnesses refused to testify; third, evidence of already bringing in several family members, some of whom were allegedly not true family members, which checks failed to identify; fourth, regular movement between the Somali communities of Hamilton, Hawke’s Bay, Christchurch, and Lower Hutt, using intimidatory tactics to get her way; and, fifth, a well-known reputation for carrying weapons and spitting in people’s faces, and then for telling them she has AIDS—clearly a true role model for our refugee programme. This story has a disturbing undercurrent that our soft policies allow to happen.

And 10 November 2004:

Can the Minister explain why we have a fistful of letters of complaint that have never been acted on by his department, and will his investigation of Asha Ali Abdille deal with her treatment of staff at the Red Cross in Wellington and Christchurch, which involved threatening to pour petrol on one person and spitting in another receptionist’s face, and the bizarre circumstances at the Hastings police station in which she threw a bucket of faeces over a constable.

As I said above, this is not about her right tolive here. The issue Peters has been on about is whether she should have been judged by Immigration Service as a sound person to sponsor family members.

I do wonder if NZ does have a “do not fly” list.  It is of course easier with the benefit of hindsight, but her previous activities do suggest she would be a prime candidate for inclusion.

People Power linked to CYFSWatch?

Whale Oil does some detective work and finds that the group claiming responsibility for the brick attacks on offices of MPs who supported the Electoral Finance Act, may also be the people who set up CYFSWatch.

As it was discovered that The Standard was being (temporarily) hosted on the same server and IP address range as various Labour Party sites, Whale Oil has posted how the IP address of people-powernz.org is shared with:

  1. buggerit.co.nz –
  2. cyfstalk.org
  3. cyfswatch.org
  4. pttp-hosting.com
  5. purebrednz.com

Now shared hosting doesn’t mean you are necessarily linked.  For example my blog shares an IP address with Stephen Franks – yet this is just coincidence – something arranged by our ISP.  Of course I had lunch with Stephen on Thursday, so one could manage a quite nice conspiracy theory if you wanted.

Anyway as CYFSWatch and People Power are both anonymous sites, it seems quite plausible.

I know the Police some months ago did track down at least one of the people involved in the CYFSWatch site, so they may not have much work to follow inquiries.

I note that People Power have done a third attack.  There are much better ways to protest than throwing bricks through windows, and they really should stop – all they do is harm the cause they are advocating for – a criticism which perhaps by no coincidence is also often said about the groups involved in advocacy for male parents with regard to CYFS and the Family Court.

Driving in Delhi

Well I’ve just checked into the hotel in Delhi, and the taxi experience from the airport was everything I had been led to expect.

There were no seatbelts at all in the backseat. Normally not a big issue, but with a driver who darts in and out of traffic (even at 1 am) was a missing security blanket.

I learnt two important road rules:

  1. Overtaking on the left is encouraged – especially if there isn’t enough room to do it safely
  2. You can ignore red lights so long as you honk your horn repeatedly as you go through them

Anyway sleep now.

Molesworth & Featherston predict the impossible

In their first newsletter of 2008, Molesworth and Featherston have made a fairly big blunder. They state on their first page:

The election this year will be on 29 November.

They don’t claim it is likely, possible or even probably – but as a dead cert.

Sadly for them it is impossible.

The current 48th Parliament commenced on 6 October 2005 when the writs were returned.

Under s17 of the Constitution Act 1986, the term of Parliament is set at 3 years, so this means that the 48th Parliament will expire and automatically dissolve on the 6th of October 2008 – if it hasn’t already done so voluntarily by then.

Then under s125 of the Electoral Act 1993, the Governor-General has a maximum of seven days to order the Chief Electoral Office to issue the election writs. This makes it 13 October 2008 at the latest.

Under s139, The election must then be held 20 – 27 days after nominations close, and on a Saturday. Also the final election writs (which includes time for counting special votes and any judicial recounts) must be returned no later than 50 days after they are issued which is 25 November 2008.

The 25th of November is a Tuesday and it is impossible to have the writs returned three days after polling day (it normally is at least two weeks and one needs a three day period alone for allowing recount applications under s180), so the last possible date is in fact Saturday 15 November 2008.

Even that date will only allow ten days for counting all the special votes and allowing for any recounts, which would be tight. So while 15 November is legally possible, I doubt it will be beyond 8 November.

The $1 million iYomu competition

The iYomu $1 million competition is in the final stages, with just five finalists left competing to win the money.

I’m backing chiaradina.  Why?

  • She lives in Wellington
  • Her story of moving to NZ and the breakup with her partner sounds like she needs a good break.  To quote her: “From one day to the next I had lost everything: my marriage, my house, my future, my dog”
  •  She will donate $100,000 of the prize to animal welfare
  • Her accent is gorgeous

The eventual winner will be known around 13 March.

Romney is out

In a surprise move Mitt Romney has suspended his presidential campaign.  While Huckabee is going to stay in the contest, there can be little doubt that John McCain has just become the presumptive Republican nominee.

Good.

I’m glad there will be a Republican candidate whom one can be enthusiastic about.

Kiwiblog Jan 2008 Stats

A few interesting aspects in the Jan stats.

Top Visitors

pspc18-241.parliament.govt.nz 7532
node5.moh.govt.nz 2182
inetgate.msd.govt.nz 1975
gate1.ird.govt.nz 1824
zeus.tvnz.co.nz 1300
apngw6.apn.co.nz 1043
mswfb1.parliament.govt.nz 1021

Top Pages Viewed

/2008/01/the_standard_hosted_by_the_labour_party.html 9387
/2008/01/clayton_weatherston.html 4826
/2008/01/a_new_website.html 3135
/2008/01/six_police_officers_for_smacking_complaint.html 2671

Top Search Terms

kiwiblog 5438
clayton weatherston 2443
david farrar 2013
computers internet blog 1912
liz shaw 367
nicole begg 274
hutt valley high school 160

and further down ….

miss coromandel 85
estonian women 61
shortland street killer 49
how to score a girl 35
gourmet food store 35
did you expense the lap dance 12
islam bdsm 3

A very insightful Espiner piece

Colin Espiner has a very insightful piece on yesterday’s speech by Cullen.  First he points out the the hype over the tax policy was greater than the substance, which was only two lines:

”We will lay out a programme in relation to the next three year term in office and the longer term direction of change beyond that.”

Colin then astutely sense the contradiction between what Dr Cullen says, and what he is being forced to do:

I do wonder about his commitment to tax cuts, however. In a strangely schizophrenic speech at times, Cullen also says this: “Most people here today know that I am not convinced by the tax cut evangelism of my political opponents. They may talk up the transformative power of tax cuts, but underneath that spin what you will really find is a long-term goal of undermining the role of government in society and winning elections.” 

Um. So does this apply to Labour too? Or are its tax cuts aimed at increasing the role of government and losing elections? And if he is so opposed to them, why is he cutting taxes at all? (Answer: Because Helen Clark’s told him to.)

The hypocrisy of Cullen claiming National promises tax cuts to win elections is quite massive.  Because that is exactly what Clark and Cullen is doing. And trust me National’s desire for tax cuts has little to do with its electoral popularity.  That is just an added bonus.

But then Colin explores another contradiction:

Of more interest to me was another little announcement, on the funding proposals for a major new Auckland motorway project, the Waterview Connection. Cullen revealed that the Government’s preferred option is a massive tunnel, because it would be the least disruptive option. Oh, and because it goes straight through the Prime Minister’s electorate of Mt Albert.

It comes at a massive cost, around $2.3 billion, and Cullen announced that a steering group has been formed to examine whether to undertake the venture as a public-private partnership. (Given that most of those on the steering group are rabid fans of PPPs, I think I know what the answer will be.)

This is somewhat strange, given that just three months ago the Government was beating National around the ears for suggesting the use of public-private partnerships in infrastructure funding. Indeed, the now-departed Steve Maharey told me last October that this Government wouldn’t have a bar of PPPs because they were a discredited and unviable form of funding such projects in this country.

Indeed, just three months ago Labour was hysterically attacking PPPs as evil (despite passing a special law to allow them), and now they are embracing them again.

Consistency isn’t exactly a core value of this Government. And they don’t even have an election loss to blame it on!

The most sucessful Foreign Minister?

The Hive is choking badly on the assertion in Trans-Tasman that Winston Peters could be the most successful foreign minister since Brian Talboys.

First of all I will acknowledge Peters has done better than I expected.  And certainly his policy instincts are relatively sound and middle of the road.   His weaknesses has been lack of attention to detail, the fixation with the media, and not even supporting his own Govt’s trade policy.  But his attention to the US relationship has been good, and he has done quite well on the personal relationships.

But I agree TT is getting carried away by elevating Peters after just two years to some sort of top ranking.  Let’s look at the recent Foreign Ministers post Talboys:

  1. Warren Cooper 81 – 84
  2. David Lange 84 – 87
  3. Russell Marshall 87 – 90
  4. Mike Moore 90
  5. Don McKinnon 90 – 99
  6. Phil Goff 99 – 05
  7. Winston Peters 05 –

Now I will exclude Moore as he was not in the job for long. So if I was to rank from top to bottom, it would probably be

  1. Don McKinnon
  2. Phil Goff
  3. David Lange
  4. Winston Peters
  5. Russell Marshall
  6. Warren Cooper

It is hard to argue against McKinnon as top.  Only Holyoake served longer, his Commonwealth appointment speaks for itself and Bougainville was a personal highlight.

Goff has done little wrong (except misuse confidential information to attack Brash), and was a very solid performer.

Lange is hard to rate as he was PM also, but he helped put NZ on the map.  High point was at the Oxford Union while lowlight was caving in to the French over the Rainbow Warrior.  Also did well with Africa and India.

Peters I have discussed above.

Marshall I am possibly too hard on, but my recollection is more rhetoric than action.  He was also on the loony left of Labour.

Cooper went on to be an entertaining Mayor of Queenstown, but never shined as Foreign Minister.  Muldoon was the de facto Minister.

Incidentally from 1957 to 1975  the Minister of Foreign Affairs was also the PM – for Nash, Holyoake, Marshall, Kirk and Rowling.

DPF to India

I’m now on a flight to India.  Well actually on a flight to Sydney, and then another to Mumbai and then finally one to Delhi.  Unless I connect at airports will be off the air for the next 24 hours or so.

I’ve got three or four posts on time delay, so there will be some fresh content during the day.

Another Electoral Finance Act problem

Bill English has raised another problem with the Electoral Finance Act – probably because it was rushed through so quickly.

It relates to the address one has to put on election advertisements.  The requirement for third parties is that their financial agent list their home address on all their adverts.  Now I have no problem with this (and in fact my home address is on the FSC billboards) as a third party can be hard to track down – we saw the Brethren being less than upfront with the addresses they listed.

But in a fit of stupidity they have also required every single candidate and party financial agent to list their home address on every advertisement.  Now this is ridicolous and serves no good purpose.  Parties and candidates are known accountable public figures.

In the last election the National Party adverts listed the office block the party HQ is in.  They have been there for around 20 years so are hardly a fly by night outfit.

Now instead of listing the party’s registered physical address, every advert has to list the home address of the party’s financial agent or party secretary if none appointed.

Not many would be overly keen to have their home address on every single newspaper ad, pamphlet, leaflet, TV ad, radio ad and billboard up and down the country.  And the sad experience of those of us in politics is people will ring or pop in without warning if your address is highly publicised.

As I said, there is absolutely no public policy reason why party advertisements should not be able to use the registered office of the party, instead of the financial agent’s home address. But the law as written doesn’t allow this.  It should be changed.

Tracy argues Clark made right call

Dom Post Political Editor Tracy Watkins is going against the consensus, and saying she believes it was the right call for Clark to stay away from most of Waitangi.

I’m not personally agreeing with Tracy, but she argues a sound case.  It is good also for there to be a difference of views amongst the gallery on this issue. There can sometimes be a bit of a “pack mentality” where people don’t want to go against the consensus.  I think it is always good to have a well reasoned argument the other way.

I don’t think Waitangi by itself was terribly important, but momentum is important and at the moment Key has it, and Clark is struggling. But there is no way that will continue to be the case all year – there will be good and not so good spells for both leaders.

Unemployment at record low

The Government’s record of employment and unemployment continues to be very strong, even excellent.  One can quibble over how much is due to Government policy or not, but nevertheless it has happened on their watch, and is a good achievement.

The December 2007 Household Labour Force Survey had 77,000 unemployed, which is just 3.4% of the labour force – a record low. It has been under 4% for over two years. The challenge in 2008 will be to keep it low in the face of a more uncertain economic environment.

The OECD average unemployment rate is 5.5%.  NZ is 5th lowest at 3.4%.Norway is 2.6%, Netherlands 2.9%.

There is also a measure known as jobless, which is different to unemployed.  To be counted as unemployed you need to be both out of work, available for work, and seeking work. On top of that there are 50,000 people not seeking work and 23,000 unavailable for work. That is a total jobless of 146,000, which is much the same as two years ago.  But unemployment is the more important figure as these are people really wanting to work and trying to work, but unable to find it.  There are different issues around those not seeking work.
The labour force participation rate has also risen to 68.8%.  This is also welcome, and one of the factors to sustainably lifting national earnings.

There is still some work to do with under 20 year olds – their unemployment rate has reduced, but is still 12.6%.

Bu ethnicity the unemployment rates are European 2.3%, Maori 7.3%, and Pacific 4.7%. All also well done on historic levels.  Still a concern Maori unemployment is three times European – but nevertheless this is a historically low level.

A whopper lie from the PM

Helen got all bitter on Tuesday and lashed out at the warm reception John Key got at Waitangi. She went on to say:

“I am waiting for the National Party to vote for a single treaty settlement negotiated by us.”

So has National been voting against all the treaty settlements this decade? Let’s look at the record:

  1. Pouakanui Claims Settlement Act – voted for in 2000
  2. Te Uri o Hau Claims Settlement Act – voted for in 2002
  3. Ngati Tama Claims Settlement Act – voted for in 2003
  4. Ngati Ruanui Claims Settlement Act – voted for in 2003
  5. Ngaa Rauru Kiitahi Claims Settlement Act – voted for first and second readings and against third reading in 2005
  6. Ngati Tuwharetoa (Bay of Plenty) Claims Settlement Act – voted for in 2005
  7. Ngati Awa Claims Settlement Act – voted for in 2005
  8. Te Arawa Lakes Settlement Act – voted against in 2005
  9. Ngati Mutunga Claims Settlement Act – voted for in 2006
  10. Te Roroa Claims Settlement Bill (second reading) – voted against in 2007

Incidentially National initiated and settled 10 claims in the 1990s. Of the ten claims settled since 2000, only the Ngaa Rauru Kiitahi settlement was initiated and settled by Labour. And that was voted for by National. So 19/20 settled claims were initiated by National.

So National has voted for eight seven out of ten claims negotiated and settled by Labour. For Clark to claim she is waiting for National to vote for a single settlement is a lie of mammoth proportions.

UPDATE: See correction.

Not a push poll

I got an e-mail on Monday, asking:

Does Labour use push-polling?

I had thought that push-polling wasn’t used by any of the political parties in NZ at the moment. But my partner just had a lengthy opinion poll telephone call with [named deleted by DPF] that involved a lot of what she thought were dodgy questions. Many of the questions involved the interviewer reading out statements by Key and asking if she felt less inclined to vote for National after hearing these. And by contrast there were lots of positive questions involving statements about the Labour Party.

This in fact though is not a push poll. Merely reciting negative statements on a politician is not a push poll – it can be legitimate testing of attack lines, messages etc.

So what is the difference between a push poll and research of attack lines? The American Association For Public Opinion Research has an FAQ on the issue:

Political telemarketing calls, when disguised as research, may sometimes be difficult to differentiate from a legitimate survey. Here are characteristics that will usually indicate that the call is not a legitimate survey.

  • One or only a few questions are asked, all about a single candidate or a single issue.
  • The questions are uniformly strongly negative (or sometimes uniformly positive) descriptions of the candidate or issue.
  • The organization conducting the calls is not named, or a phony name is used.
  • Evasive answers are given in response to requests for more information about the survey.
  • The number of people called is very large, sometimes many thousands.
  • The calls are not based on a random sample.
  • It is difficult to find out which organization conducted the interviews.

And they explain the difference between message testing and a push poll:

The fact that a poll contains negative information about one or more candidates does NOT in and of itself make it a ‘push poll.’ Political campaigns routinely sponsor legitimate “message-testing” surveys that are used by campaign consultants to test out the effectiveness of various possible campaign messages or campaign ad content, often including negative messages. Political message-testing surveys may sometimes be confused with fake polling, but they are very different.

So that poll, presumably on behalf of Labour, was entirely legitimate as a form of message testing.  They were trying to find out which attack lines on Key will have the most effect on reducing National’s support, and conversely which lines about Labour will be most effective at increasing support for them.

Not paid back yet

Just a reminder to everyone that Winston is still collecting interest on his unpaid $158,000 and Peter Dunne’s United Future party still owes around $50,000.

Media should be running a weekly story on the unpaid debts, until they are paid back or until a party states it is refusing to pay (which they legally can do).

TVNZ moves to ad model for digital content

TVNZ has announced they are going to both ditch copy protection software on their digital downloads, and also abolish the pay per download fee for premium content.  Instead they are focusing on an ad-supported model.

This isn’t a huge surprise.  Around a year ago Jason Parris, TVNZ’s head of emerging business, spoke to a meeting of the Parliamentary Internet Caucus and he said that he doubted pay per download model was one which would be sustainable, and that an ad supported model was the future.

I thought the statement at the time showed that TVNZ did understand the market and the technology well, and were realistic about it. So this is just part of an evolution of their strategy – not a major change.

Labour promises years and years of tax cuts

If National saying they will not reverse a policy already implemented is billed as a u-turn,what do you call the extraordinary statement from Labour that after oppossing personal tax cuts for the last eight years, they will now deliver tax cuts not just next year – but every year thereafter until the end of time.

Oh okay, not until the end of time, but past the next two elections.

Personally, I don’t believe them.  Cullen announced tax cuts in 2005 and cancelled them in 2007.  With the uncertain economic future, it isn’t hard to imagine a scenario where after the election they will find an excuse to cancel them again – on the grounds the economy is not resilient enough.

But it is good Labour has done a u-turn and has stolen National’s tax cut policy of progressive tax cuts every year. This shifts the debate to how to deliver ongoing reductions in taxation, and leaves behind the hysteria of the past about how tax cuts will results in slashes to core public services.

Isn’t it amazing how one poll comes out saying tax cuts are the biggest election issue, and Labour quickly comes up with a new tax cut policy of tax cuts every year.  If only they had adopted this policy when inflation was lower and the surpluses higher a few years ago.

But as I said, I welcome Labour joining the mainstream view that reductions in personal tax cuts are highly desirable.  Their sister party in Australia has been there for some time.

Zogby Polls

The Hive noted earlier today that I didn’t rate the Reuters/Zogby poll, but that they did.  Zogby in 1996 and 2000 was often seen as the most accurate pollster but since then they have many bad calls and considerable controversy.

With that in mind it is worth reviewing their polls for Super Tuesday for the most important state of California.

They said Obama was ahead by 13%. At this stage Clinton is leading by 16%

They said Romney was ahead by 7%. At this stage McCain is leading by 17%

No pollster gets it right all the time.  And they did call some other states correctly, but their reputation won’t have been helped by being so far out in California.

Super Tuesday Summary

The biggest states tend to be the ones at the beginning. The first number is the Dem delegates, with 2,025 needed for victory and the second number is Rep delegates with 1,191 for victory.

  1. California (370/170) – Clinton and McCain
  2. New York (232/87) – Clinton and McCain
  3. Illinois (153/87) – Obama and McCain
  4. Georgia (103/72) – Obama and Huckabee
  5. New Jersey (107/52) – Clinton and McCain
  6. Missouri (72/58) – Obama (leading) and McCain
  7. Tennessee (68/39) -Clinton and Huckabee
  8. Massachusetts (93/43) – Clinton and Romney
  9. Arizona (56/53) – Clinton and McCain
  10. Alabama (52/48) – Obama and Huckabee
  11. Connecticut (48/30) – Obama and McCain
  12. Oklahoma (38/41) – Clinton and McCain
  13. Arkansas (35/34) – Clinton and Huckabee
  14. Delaware (15/18) – Obama and McCain
  15. Utah (23/36) – Obama and Romney
  16. Colorado (71/46) – Obama and Romney
  17. Alaska (18/29) – Obama and no result yet
  18. North Dakota (21/26) – Obama and Romney
  19. Kansas (21/0) – Obama,
  20. New Mexico (26/0) – Clinton (leading)
  21. Montana (0/25) – Romney
  22. Idaho (12/0) – Obama
  23. West Virginia (0/30) – Huckabee
  24. Minnesota (72/0) – Obama and Romney

So the states for each candidate are:

  • Clinton –  Arizona, Arkansas, California, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York,  Oklahoma, Tennessee, plus leading in New Mexico
  • Obama – Alabama, Alaska, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Kansas, Minnesota, North Dakota, Utah plus leading in Missouri
  • McCain – Arizona, Arkansas, California, Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Missouri, New Jersey, New York, Oklahoma
  • Romney – Colorado, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Montana, North Dakota, Utah
  • Huckabee – Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Tennessee, West Virginia,

And delegate totals for each candidate are:

  • Clinton – 591
  • Obama – 476
  • Edwards – 26
  • McCain – 487
  • Romney – 176
  • Huckabee – 122
  • Paul -11

On the Republican side McCain is in pole position but neither Romney nor Huckabee is withdrawing. Hard to see how McCain can get stopped but if Romney wins California that will be a big boost.

The Democratic contest is going to carry on for some time. California will be important also but either can win from here.

UPDATE: California has closed. No results yet but the exit polls have Clinton ahead by 6.3% and McCain ahead by 1.5%.

UPDATE2: Tables above updated.  Clinton and McCain win California. While Clinton is 115 delegates ahead of Obama she is only 28 ahead amongst pledged delegates. This is the closest primary race in decades

And while McCain is a very clear front runner, again it is pretty historic that both parties have emerged from Super Tuesday without a nominee.

The next few Republican states are Louisiana, Washington and Kanasas on 9 Feb and then Virginia, Maryland and DC on 12 Feb.  Big states like Texas are not until March.

On the Democratic side they have Washington, Louisiana and Nebraska on the 9th, Maine on the 10th and also Virginia, Maryland and DC on the 12th.  Looking way out they have Texas on 4 March for 228 delegates and Pennsylvania on 22 April with 188.