Super Tuesday Results

I’m just heading out for 90 minutes or so for a walk with Accident Girl and her dogs. I expect some results to start to flow through soon, so use this thread for updates.

Huckabee has beaten Romney in West Virginia, which was unexpected. McCain supporters may have voted tactically.

The polls in California range from Clinton ahead by 10% to Obama ahead by 13%.

It also looks very close for McCain and Romney in California. Most other places look good for McCain though.

UPDATE: Back now. For results below I will show after each state the number of delegates up for grabs for Democrats and then Republican, and then the results. Remember many Republican contests are winner take all, but no Democrats are.

Georgia (103/72): Obama by 23%, Huckabee over McCain by 23% so not call yet

Tennessee (68/39): Clinton by 1828%, McCain by 115% (but on 312% reporting only)

Massachusetts (93/43): Clinton by 16%, Romney by 12%

Connecticut (48/30): Obama by 34% (not final), McCain by 1821%

Oklahoma (38/41): Clinton by 25%, McCain by 105% (but only 2% in)

Arkansas (35/34): Clinton by 43%, Huackabee by 32%

Montana (25): McCain by 3% over Romney (9% counted)

UPDATE2: McCain is shooting ahead. He now has 309 delegates to 99 for Romney. Much closer with Democrats with Clinton 279 to Obama 210.

Illinois (153/57): Obama by 29%, McCain by 23%

New Jersey (107/52): Clinton by 32%, McCain by 30%

Missouri (72/58): Clinton by 18%, Huckabee by 7%

Alabama (52/48): Obama by 38%, McCain by 7% (only 23% counted)

Delaware (15/18): Clinton by 2%, McCain by 7% (only 29% counted)

Microsoft-Yahoo merger

Rod Drury has the best quote I have seen on the proposed Microsoft-Yahoo merger.

It’s like taking the two guys who finished second and third in a 100-yard dash and tying their legs together and asking for a rematch, believing that now they’ll run faster.

The quote is from the fake Steve Jobs.

Once again NRT makes it up

The sad decline of No Right Turn continues.  In a post on the climate change report he claims:

DPF regards this as proof positive that the costs of mitigation are too high, and that therefore we should not bother at all to do anything about emissions.

My post is here. The comments NRT attributes to me are invented.  In fact I said:

I have been saying for some months that we need more data on the benefits and costs of climate change and mitigation strategies, so that they can be weighed up. This report provides some of that data.

And later in the comments, I say:

I do have real problems with a Govt line of not acknowledging the trade offs between growth and carbon. If the cost of reduced carbon emissions is 1% less economic growth, well then that may be the price one has to pay.

Nowhere have I said or suggested we do nothing about emissions. As the comment makes clear, I accept that we may have to live with reduced economic growth to reduce carbon emissions.  I don’t think carbon neutrality is realistic (and let’s face it that is just an election slogan from Helen) but some stabilisation and reduction is possible.

Blog Bits on Waitangi Day

Not PC has a lengthy post on the Treaty of Waitangi, and how it is about property rights, not partnership. Well worth a read, even if you don’t agree.

Jimmy Jangles compares the positions of McCain, Clinton and Obama on free trade. My summary is McCain is a passionate supporter, Clinton is mildly supportive and fence sitting while Obama is against. It is a useful reminder that one can like Obama’s rhetoric but not like his policy positions. I love the quote from McCain:

“I don’t believe in walls. I believe in freedom. If I were President, I would negotiate a free trade agreement with almost any country willing to negotiate fairly with us. Only risks to the security of our vital interests or egregious offenses to our most cherished political values should disqualify a nation from entering into a free trade agreement with us.”

Poneke chats to Peter Ellis. I did laugh at Ellis’ sense of humour:

Every time I’ve met Ellis, he’s exhibited the sharp wit that has at times got him into trouble. This time was no exception. “When I started at the Civic in 1987, some parents were so PC that we had to call the girls little women, not little girls,” he said while reminiscing about his former workplace, which was regarded as the trendiest in Christchurch. Wealleans, whose wife worked at the Civic for years, mentioned putting a “don’t vote Labour” icon on the Peter Ellis website to protest at the Government’s lack of action on the case, such an icon likely breaching the Electoral Finance Act. “That’d be great, Winston,” Ellis said immediately. “You might find yourself sitting in jail with me having to visit you for a change.”

And on my suggestion of a blog campaign for a Royal Commission:

“I can’t even drive a car. Some people just aren’t mechanically minded. I’ve managed to wreck five lawnmowers and a washing machine. Imagine what I would do with a computer. Isn’t a blog like a bog with an ‘l’ in it? From what I’ve heard, some of these young girls today have blogs they use to flash their bits and pieces on. But yes, I don’t see why not. I have no objection to people supporting a royal commission with their blogs.”

Aaron Bhatnagar blogs on the Waiheke Island seccession movement.

Graeme Edgeler has a well timed post on the delegate count and how delegates are won in the US primaries.

A fascinating idea

Don Brash has floated a fascinating idea. To give the Reserve Bank Governor a second tool for fighting inflation, apart from raising interest rates.  It is to increase and decrease the petrol tax as a way to take the heat out of the economy without impacting exporters so much through high interest rates leading to a high dollar.

I’d love to see some economic modelling on this proposal – how much does a change in petrol prices affect consumption and spending etc.

Bhutto gifts party to husband in will

Benazir Bhutto has gifted her political party to her husband, in her will – saying she wants him to replace him.

I wonder if this idea could catch on.  Does Winston for example have a will in which he nominates his successor?  Jim Anderton probably doesn’t as Jim probably doesn’t accept he is mortal. And who would Peter Dunne leave his party to in his will?  It probably says “Anyone but Gordon”.

Clark blunders again

Watching TV3 News last night, it appears clear Clark has blundered again with her boycott of the full Waitangi programme.

John Key didn’t just look comfortable at Waitangi – he looked Prime Ministerial, and was almost greeted as such, while Clark was missing in action.

I did enjoy the only in NZ absurdity of Key being greeted by, and shaking hands with, Tame Iti who was arrested by the Police for allegedly being the leader of a group which aimed, amongst other things, to assassinate John Key.  However only once he had actually become PM! Could you imagine this in any other country.

And even more bizarrely the costs of the Iti family going to Waitangi are being paid for by Television New Zealand.

Colin Espiner blogged yesterday that Clark no-show was a risk

Key, too, is on to a winner whatever happens. While National leaders have not always been welcome at Te Tii, Key is so easy-going and charming that he is unlikely to cop a faceful of mud like his predecessor. But even if he was abused, it simply plays into his favour. It shows that he’s prepared to face up to criticism, while his counterpart is not.

… Being the Prime Minister is a little different, of course. One does have to keep one’s dignity. But I wonder whether this would have been the year to take the risk and return to Te Tii.

Audrey Young also blogged about Key at Waitangi:

It has been John Key’s Waitangi so far today, not Helen Clark’s who is just about to land in the Far North.

And the bizarre spectacle of the PM who refuses to turn up, criticising the warm reception John Key received. She just sounds bitter and small. And her lack of judgement comes through even more when she suggests that Key is not being honest about his agenda – because in fact the media have been reporting that Key has not been delivering a different message to a different audience, and despite the unpopularity has confirmed National policy is still to abolish the Maori seats and not abolish the Foreshore & Seabed Act.

Finally on radio this morning, I hear that John Key was asked to lead a prayer of his own at the dawn service, as the PM wasn’t there. Again this just makes him look like he is the PM, not just wanting to be.  Clark has surrendered her most important weapon – incumbency.

The result of the next election is by no means already determined.  But Labour needs a error-free year, and so far there have been two blunders barely one month in.

The cost of carbon mitigation

Adolf Stroombergen of Infometrics has done a study of the projected costs of carbon mitigation for NZ households. Dr Stroombergen is the chief economist at Infometrics and has done quite a bit of work in the climate change area – including for the Government’s Emissions Trading Group. In fact his work is quoted approvingly by David Parker just three months ago. This report was commissioned by the New Zealand Business Roundtable and the Petroleum Exploration and Production Association of New Zealand.

The Government has an aspirational goal of carbon neutrality by 2050. However this report doesn’t even try to measure what the cost of that would be. A very conservative target of restoring NZ’s emission levels to 1990 levels by 2025 is studied. And this is very conservative – NZ voted in Bali to reduce emission levels by 2020 to 25% – 40% below 1990 levels. Our Kyoto target is to be at 1990 levels by 2012.

The report looks at a business as usual scenario (based on growth of over 4% which is the Govt’s target], and then a scenario where a domestic price of carbon is $300/tonne. This reduces emissions by one third, but still leaves them 90% over 1990 levels. That shortfall has to be purchased on the international market at an estimated $100/tonne.

The impact on various industries is massive. Sheep farming would be 32% smaller than under business as usual. Dairy farming 28% smaller and petroleum 27% smaller.

A scenario C is also looked at, which assumes high economic growth itself leads to higher economic growth due to greater immigration and business confidence etc. You need to be an economist to follow it in detail, but the key thing for most is the figures. Under scenario C we reduce emissions by 40%, but they still exceed 1990 levels by 70% and and the cost of purchasing excess emissions on the world market is $7.2 billion.

The summary of the research is:

In summary, once the effects on aggregate investment, employment and productivity of investment uncertainty and transitional costs are taken into account, policy action to reduce New Zealand’s emissions could lead to a fall in private consumption of 14% relative to BAU. This is about $7,000 per person in current prices or $19,000 per household. It also implies a doubling of electricity prices relative to 2007/08 and increases in petrol prices of more than 50% Nevertheless, despite these adverse effects on households, New Zealand’s emission levels rise significantly rather than reduce relative to 1990 levels, calling into question the consistency of the government’s twin goals of growth and carbon neutrality.

I have been saying for some months that we need more data on the benefits and costs of climate change and mitigation strategies, so that they can be weighed up. This report provides some of that data.

The response from David Parker is very disappointing. In fact it could almost result in a prosecution under the Fair Trading Act. Parker claims:

There is no mismatch between the goal of raising New Zealanders’ standards of living and of becoming carbon neutral.

This is of course nonsense. Absolute nonsense. Of course there is a tradeoff between economic growth and carbon emissions. It is beyond dishonest for Parker to say there isn’t. The issue before us is how to make that trade off, and to what degree.

The Stroombergen report is not, of course, gospel. One can intelligently challenge the assumptions, the impact of technologies etc, and argue it will not be as bad as the $19,000 per household cost in the report. But to argue that there is absolutely no mismatch or tradeoff between economic growth and reducing carbon emissions is almost the equivalent of arguing the Earth is flat. It is an appalling response from the Climate Change Minister which just tries to con New Zealanders into thinking one can eliminate carbon emissions from our economy and not have it affect our standard of living.

Euphemism of the Year

This should win some sort of award for spin or euphemisms:

A baton may have been used to assist the man to the ground and with only one strike used, Mr Rutherford said.

Yes batons are well known for how they assist people to the ground.  Just in case you can’t make it all the way down there by yourself, then hey let a baton assist you.

Next we will read how the Police may have used a gun to assist a man in slowing down.

For the record I am not casting a view on whether the Police should have used a baton or not.  Just criticising the ridicolous way they described it as assisting him.

Congratulations Pansy

Congratulations to Pansy Wong who was selected tonight as National’s candidate for the new seat of Botany.

Pansy won on the first ballot, which is a considerable achievement with four people seeking the candidacy.

Based on the 2005 election results, Botany has a paper majority to National of 3,000 or so. Assuming Pansy wins at the election later this year, she will be the first Asian MP to win an electorate seat.

Well done Goff

Phil Goff has done well. A US-NZ free trade agreement is now a real possibility with the announcement that the US will begin negotiations with the P4 group of NZ, Brunei, Chile and Singapore.

This doesn’t mean a full free trade deal is guaranteed.  For now it only covers financial services and investments, but is has the potential to morph into a more comprehensive negotiation. A welcome step forward.

Backbencher closed

Get well Winnie

Cabinet Minister Winnie Laban has revealed she has breast cancer, and is having chemotherapy treatment.

While one would have sympathy any MP who has cancer (even the other Winnie!), it is worth noting that Laban is one of those MPs who is held in genuine affection by MPs from all parties.  She is a very pleasant and dedicated person.

Laban hopes publicity over her case will encourage other women to have regular checks. It was the sort of cancer than can’t be detected by self examination, but was picked up by a mammogram.

It’s just like voting – check early and check often!

Both party’s races get closer for Super Duper Tuesday

There are fascinating things happening with both parties for tomorrow’s primaries.

In the largest state – California, the last three polls (all completed yesterday) on Republicans have had a 38-38 tie, McCain ahead 39-36 and Romney ahead 40-32.  The Romney ahead poll is from Zogby which is not well regarded within the US polling industry, but regardless there is no doubt California is in play.

On the Democrat side, the last three polls are Obama 46-40, Obama 40-39, and Clinton 53-41. It could go either way.

The last two nationwide polls for the Democrats have Obama ahead 49-46 and 43-37.

A couple of people have suggested Wellingtonians copy the Aucklanders and find a nice bar (maybe the Backbencher) where one can follow the results and digest them over a few beers.  I’m not sure what bar would be good for this but if we did find one, how many people would be interested in coming along tomorrow afternoon?

Fox vs Horomia

Parekura Horomia will be worried at the news Derek Fox is seeking the Maori Party nomination for Ikaroa-Rawhiti.

In 1999 Derek Fox got 6,747 votes as an Independent – just 695 less than Parekura on 7,442.  And remember this was as an Independent.

In 2002, with no serious oppositon, Parekua got 11,192 and no one else over 1,000.

And last election in 2005, Horomia dropped to 9,502 and the Maori Party’s Atareta Poananga got 7,570.

A Marae-Digipoll in November 2007 had the Maori Party electorate support as 49% to 43% for Parekura.

The combination of Derek Fox and being the Maori Party candidate should combine to spell real trouble for Horomia. Of course nothing is certain and recent settlements in the area may help him survive.  The next poll there will be most interesting.

Jenny doing well

Karyn Scherer has a lengthy profile of my former boss, Jenny Shipley, in the NZ Herald.  Jenny has been very low profile since she retired from politics in 2002, and one can see why – she’s pretty damn busy in the commercial world.  While other former PMs generally pick up Government appointments, Jenny’s have all been in the business sector.  From what I can see she is:

  • Chair of Mainzeal (turnover NZ$400 million)
  • Director of Richina Pacific
  • Chair of Senior Money International
  • Director of Momentum
  • Director of China Construction Bank (turnover appears to be over US$20b, assets US$800b)

The China Construction Bank is the third largest in China with 300,000 employees and is rated by Asiaweek as the most profitable bank in China.  They are very demanding roles.
The whole article is quite fascinating – it sounds a great and varied life. Proof positive there can be a great life after politics.

NZ Herald on Civil Service neutrality

Some worthwhile points in the Herald editorial today:

A certain righteousness pervades the Labour Party that leads it to believe its policies and political interest are indivisible from the public interest. That assumption underlay the election-card spending controversy after the last election and was evident in the explanation for the political hirings and firings at the Environment Ministry in recent years.

One can not over-estimate how much this is true.

The ministry, it was said, had become politically important because “sustainability” was to be a central theme of Labour’s next election campaign. The implications of that explanation have been overshadowed by ministers’ problems.

Since when did a department became an instrument of an election campaign?

Indeed.

Our confidence in their tradition has been shaken but not shattered by the present Government. Public servants whose personal sympathies probably lie with Labour for the most part have had few problems serving National Governments. It must be a great deal harder to preserve their proper distance from a Labour programme. The Government needs to help them. Instead, it seems hardly aware of the damage it has done.

The next State Services Commissioner needs to implement a culture change starting with CEOs.  Maybe they could publish helpful booklets such as “How to say no to your Minister and still have them respect you in the morning” 🙂

The PM and Waitangi

The PM really needs to get over the fact that Harawira senior was rude to her a decade or so ago at Waitangi.  Life goes on, and it is regrettable that the PM has never gone to Waitangi for the full programme.

She is boycotting both the group of cross-party MPs that will be welcomed on to Te Tii Marae this morning and has not accepted an invitation to participate in a leaders debate with National Party leader John Key and others at the marae this afternoon.

Instead she is going to a meeting to confirm the Labour Party candidate for Te Tai Tokerau.  So putting party ahead of country.

Yes Waitangi Day can sometimes be rude. Yes like Don Brash you may get seated next to Tame Iti. But the head of the NZ Government should be at Waitangi for Waitangi Day.

I’ve no problem with temporary stay aways when things go too far, such as when the GG was spat on.  But her boycott of the full programme has been in place for something like a decade – in her own language it is time to move on.

EPMU to register as third party

Labour’s biggest affiliated union, the EPMU, has applied to be registered as a third party for the election.

By pure coincidence it plans to spend $120,000 – the same amount it spent on the 2005 election. And the amazing coincidence is that is the limit for third parties.

I mean I am sure it is a total coincidence. There is no way the Government set the limit by looking at how much its largest affiliated union wanted to spend. They would not be so self seeking I am sure.

Never mind that the independent Electoral Commission advised the limit should be around $300,000, and actually produced emperical research on how much advertising one can buy, justifying their recommendation.

I am confident that the Government had excellent reasons for setting the level at $120,000, and ignoring the official advice – even though they can’t tell us what these are. And again it is just a coincidence that is how much their largest affiliated union wants to spend, and spent last time.

The EPMU’s President and proposed Financial Agent is Andrew Little. This is the same Andrew Little who is a Vice-President of the Labour Party and is currently considering standing for Labour as a candidate. But let no one suggest the EPMU advertising spend will in any way be co-ordinated to align with Labour’s. Andrew will skillfully not listen to any discussions of campaign strategy at NZ Council meetings.

It may be an interesting issue for the next review of electoral law about whether an organisation that is formally affiliated to a political party, and whose members automatically are voting members of a political party should be seen as different from the political party for electoral spending purposes. The Young Nats activities get included as part of National’s, and Rainbow Labour would be included as part of Labour’s. The difference between a constituent group and an affiliated organisation might not be hugely different. For example both Rainbow Labour and affiliated unions have a representative on the Labour Party Ruling Council, and both have automatic membership eligibility – join them and you are automatically a member of Labour should you wish to exercise those rights.

Of course affiliated unions have a role and primary purpose related to industrial relations, not politics, and that should not be restricted. But it is a grey area when union membership is also de facto party membership and the union is affiliated.

This isn’t anti-union. If for example a farming lobby group was formally part of the National Party, and membership of the farming lobby group also gave you membership rights in National – then the same questions should arise.

UPDATE: I should make clear that the EPMU can not campaign for people to vote Labour without Labour’s authorisation and it counting as part of Labour’s limit.  They can campaign for people not to vote National or to campaign against parties wishing to introduce choice of provider into the ACC scheme for example]

Almost 550,000 left over last eight years

Over the last eight years, almost 550,000 NZ residents have left either permanently or long-term. That is over 13% of the population.Of course there has been migration into NZ also, but replacing NZers who leave is not the same as keeping NZers here, or having them return.

Of the 543,748 residents who have left, 391,334 were NZ citizens. And of those entering NZ only 193,557 were NZ citizens. That’s a net loss of almost 200,000 citizens.

Most focus is on the exodus to Australia.  This graph shows the flows for the last decade.

migration1.JPG

9/11 saw the numbers leaving fall off, and then stay constant through 2002 and 2003. But since 2003 the net migration to Australia has gone from 10,000 a year to over 25,000.

migration2.JPG

This graph shows the cumulative flows to and from Australia since Labour took office.

The equivalent of the total combined populations of Hamilton and Dunedin have moved to Australia.

All data from the External Migration series from Stats NZ.

Obama – Yes we can

Obama is 1% ahead of Clinton is the latest California polls. He has momentum and it is going to be a fascinating day on Wednesday when we get the results.

A kiwi living in the US has sent me the link to the below video. Quite a few famous faces in it, and it was put together at barely a day’s notice.

ACT supporting anti-smacking law referendum

ACT had a large half page ad in the SST yesterday, backing the petition calling for a referendum on whether a smack as part of good parental correction should be a criminal offence.

Quite smart move, as it is a hot issue with many and they can try and brand themselves as the one parliamentary party against the law change.

The ad I am told, was paid for out of private donations, not taxpayer funds.

It will be fascinating if they do get the numbers for a referendum, as it is not the issue the Government wants to be in everyone’s minds in the second half of this year.

The ad is below, the thumbnail going through to the full ad.

actpetition.JPG

Domain Name Tasting

In recent months and years there has been a phenomenon known as domain name tasting. It tends to happen in the .com top level domain, but not exclusively. It is a great example of how well intentioned policy can have dire consequences.

Most top level domains (including .nz) have what is commonly called a grace period where a registration can be cancelled without charge.  It is usually five days and the intention behind the policy is to protect registrants from paying a fee when they accidentally register the wrong name.

But what has happened is that domain name speculators register basically every name which becomes available in .com, and during the five day grace period place Google ads on a website at that domain name.  If the name was previously used it may have enough links and traffic to generate sufficient advertising revenue to cover the annual domain name fee (which can be under US$10).

If the first speculator decides to cancel within the five day period, a second one will register it, and so on with the net effect being that millions and millions of names are perpetually locked up. For example one registrar has reported that of 55.1 million names registered, 51.5 were cancelled during the five day grace period.

As domainspace reports, the ICANN board has passed a resolution indicating they intend to change the fees policy for generic top level domains so that one has to pay a registration fee, even if you cancel within five days.  This will probably kill off the domain tasting industry which was very anti-consumer as it both locked up millions of domain names, but also imposed extra costs on registrars and registries which ultimately get passed onto consumers.

As I said at the beginning it is a great example of a well intentioned policy backfiring.   The idea of a five day grace period was to help registrants, but as if often the case the lack of any fees creates incentives for people to game the system. It is worth considering how many government policies suffer from the same problem – well intentioned but ultimately counter-productive as they give people incentives to rort the system.

Record numbers leaving

The latest migration statistics highlight the exodus from New Zealand.

In 2007, a total of 77,081 Kiwis left permamently or long-term – at least a 10 year high.

Looking just as Australia there were 13,636 people moving from Australia to NZ, but a massive 41,634 went from NZ to Australia.  That is now 800 people a week or 114 people every day of the year.

The net migration to Australia has skyrocketed a massive 35% from 2006 to 2007. Up from 20,709 to 27,998, which is a 20 year high.

Bearish not Cherish