Treaty signing moved due to angry mob

The NZ Herald reports:

Deputy Prime Minister Michael Cullen had to be protected from an angry mob of screaming protesters after being verbally abused and jostled before the signing of a historic Maori land claim agreement between the Crown and a small Far North iwi.

The event became so heated that the meeting was hastily transferred to another location.

This is disgraceful behaviour, and seriously undermines the goodwill necessary for historic grievances to be settled.  As Shane Jones say:

Mr Jones said the incident was bizarre. “Here we are trying to give back 3000ha to people. Anyone else would give their eye teeth for that and be green with envy.”

Now this is not to say that members of an Iwi or Hapu who do not agree with a proposed settlement can not protest against it.  But it seems obvious the nature of the protest went well beyond what is acceptable.

The deadline for filing historic claims is next year.  The good thing about this is that the number of unresolved claims can only then start to reduce.

Sydney Morning Herald on left vs right globally

The Sydney Morning Herald has an in depth article on the challenges facing the right in various countries, including New Zealand.

I chatted to the SMH political editor, Peter Hartcher, for up to an hour on the political situation here.  Always fun to chat politics with interested people.

I suggest people read the full article, but here is an extract about NZ:

In New Zealand, the story is similar. The conservative party, the Nationals, exiled from power since December 1999, have been huddling close in the lee of Labour’s Helen Clark.

More than Britain or the US – indeed, more than any other country – New Zealand was a zealous early adaptor of the Thatcherite market agenda. Per capita, it implemented the biggest privatisation agenda in the world. But the conservative revolution is long since passé and privatisation is a dirty word.

Labour has rolled back some of the early conservative accomplishments. The national system of railway tracks has been re-nationalised. The Post Office banking business, after being sold off, has been re-established. The privatisation of the three national energy companies, halted after the sale of only one, has been frozen. And the National Party is not proposing to change any of these policies.

The conservatives have a popular, young, self-made leader, John Key. “His strategy is ‘don’t rock the boat’,” says David Farrar, a popular conservative blogger who has worked for four Nationals prime ministers and opposition leaders.

“A year ago he tried to shut down traditional areas of controversy – nuclear ship visits and climate change, for example. The Nationals have been ahead in every poll this year and they are likely to win the next election” – due by next November – “but that’s because Labor is old and tired and not because of any upswelling of support for the Nationals’ agenda.”

As with any article, only some of what you say makes it.  Certainly it is true that Key has moved to shut down some areas of difference which could hurt National.  Likewise it is true that the mood is more to throw Labour out, than a popular revolution for National.  I did however give some examples of areas of difference such as allowing minority private shareholdings into some SOEs, the extent of tax cuts, competition for ACC, likely education policy etc.

Some interesting criticism of the Howard Government’s record also by CIS Director Greg Lindsay:

Howard increased the size of the state in Australian life and made it the biggest-taxing and biggest-spending government in the country’s history. Even his signature efforts at deregulation, such as Work Choices, were a confusion of detail rather than a clear retreat of the government, Lindsay argues.

“When you are as rich as Australia is now, you should be reducing the amount of money people receive from government, but Howard increased it. The Howard government forked out obscene amounts of money in Family Tax Benefit A and Family Tax Benefit B. They tried to nationalise the family.”

Sadly all Governments increase spending – the only debate nowadays is by how much. The debate in NZ will be about whether spending increases by $2.5 billion a year or $2.1 billion a year. Now that is what the public want – so they will get it.  But to really push NZ up the global league tables, we would need to be prepared to be a bit radical as to what should the state do and not do.

Trotter on Electoral Finance Bill Third Reading

I’m reading a column in the SST about Labour’s performance in the third reading of the Electoral Finance Bill:

It’s the little things that get you. Those dismissive, off-hand, arrogant little gestures that suddenly throw the bigger picture into sharp focus.

I’d tuned into the live-feed from parliament to watch the third reading debate of the Electoral Finance Bill. Here, at last, I thought, is Labour’s, New Zealand First’s and the Greens’ big chance to make their case. …  But, what did I see on the government side of the House? Row after row of empty seats. The contrast with the Opposition could hardly have been starker. Around the figure of Opposition leader John Key, I counted off practically all of National’s key spokespeople, and behind them sat most of the party’s backbenchers.

Where was Helen Clark? Where was Michael Cullen? Where was Phil Goff? Where were the serried ranks of the centre-left, proudly demonstrating their solidarity with the bill’s authors? For if ever there was an occasion for the whole of the house to be in attendance this was it.

How well I recall my old political studies professor, Tony Wood, lecturing his New Zealand politics class on matters constitutional. No, he said, this country does not have a written constitution, but it has something which is almost as good the Electoral Act. The clauses of that act, he told us, were entrenched meaning that they could not be repealed or amended except by referendum, or by a majority comprising three-quarters of the House of Representatives. The law pertaining to elections, he solemnly informed us, was the cornerstone of our democracy.

So where, on this day that vitally important aspects of “the law pertaining to elections” were about to be amended and repealed without the mandate of a referendum, and without anything approaching a three-quarters majority of the House of Representatives, were Helen Clark, Michael Cullen and Phil Goff?

Their seats were empty.

They should not have been. By their absence from this crucial debate, Labour’s leaders sent everyone their fellow MPs, their loyal supporters, the electorate as a whole a devastating (and some have said electorally suicidal) message.

They simply didn’t care.

Accused of holding New Zealand’s democratic traditions in utter contempt; charged with harbouring authoritarian, even dictatorial, ambitions; Labour’s leaders simply couldn’t be bothered to defend either themselves or their bill. They had other places to be; other people to see.

John Key knew where he had to be on Tuesday evening and he was there. The cameras captured the image for the whole of New Zealand to see. A young man, his eyes alight with passion, defending New Zealand’s democratic traditions and promising the nation that, should it repose its trust in his party: “We will repeal this bill.”

And as he sat down, all his colleagues rose to give him a standing ovation. The chamber rang with their applause.

He should have been answered by a prime minister. In response to Key’s charges we should have heard the thundering rebuttal of a Labour leader every bit as committed to upholding New Zealand’s democratic traditions as the National Party. We should have heard her prosecute the case against the malefactors of great wealth; against the economic royalists who would buy elections in the same way that they had bought everything else belonging to the people of New Zealand.

And when she sat down, all the government members, and with them all of those representing NZ First and the Greens, should have risen to their feet and cheered her to the echo.

And following the prime minister, Michael Cullen should have stood and eviscerated the Opposition with his rapier wit. And following him, Phil Goff should have bruised them with his wrath. It didn’t happen.

This unmandated, unloved, and probably unworkable bill was voted into law to the noisy condemnation of its enemies and the sullen silence of it friends.

It’s the little things that get you.

As you read about how the Government has broken the constitutional conventions around the “cornerstone of our democracy” you would be forgiven for thinking you were reading Matthew Hooton’s column.  But no, that was last week.  This was Chris Trotter’s column.

Clark’s 16 questions

A nice 16 questions and answers to and from Helen Clark in the SST.  All very normal yet interesting.

Clark was also on Paul Holmes radio last week and chatting to him about her impressions of various world leaders.  She was very good, and nicely sidestepped the question about whether Hugo Chavez is mad.  She repeated her admiration for Angela Merkel there.

Bill Ralston’s Report Card

Ralston gives out his report card:

  • Helen Clark: C
  • John Key: B
  • Winston Peters: C-
  • Jeanette Fitzsimons: D
  • Turia/Sharples: B+
  • Peter Dunne: B-
  • Jim Anderton: D
  • Rodney Hide: F
  • Michael Cullen: D
  • Bill English: B
  • Trevor Mallard: D
  • Gerry Brownlee: B-
  • Darren Hughes: A-
  • Hone Harawira: A-
  • Paula Bennett: B+
  • Field, Copeland and Benson-Pope: Overdue to be expelled

McCarten’s Awards

Matt McCarten hands out some awards:

  • Naughtiest Left-Winger: Chris Trotter for attacking John Minto.  Runner-up is Willie Jackson and Trevor Mallard ineligible for not being left-wing anymore!
  • Naughtiest Christian: Taito Phillip Field with Gordon Copeland as runner-up.
  • Naughtiest Playground Bully: Trevor Mallard followed bu Tau Henare
  • Naughtiest Cheat: Winston Peters

Margaret McHugh on the attack

Not only is Margaret McHugh unapologetic for her e-mails to customers, she has lodged 242 complaints with companies whose staff e-mailed her in response to the viral e-mail.

This fits the earlier patten of being a bully – she threatens what are obviously junior staff with going to their boss merely because they had the temerity to query her.

Not that people should have e-mailed her directly from a work address. That is unwise.

2008 Election Candidates

I’ve set up a permanent page (linked on top right) listing the major candidates for the 70 electorates for the 2008 election.

The Labour ones I have taken off Quest for Security. National’s are off memory for me so may be less than canonical.  I’ll do corrections and additions as they occur.

Most of the attention will be on the party vote contest, but I think there may be fun contests in  up to eight general electorate seats and three Maori seats.

Not just the Herald

The Herald has (rightly) been seen as the media outlet most oppossed to the Electoral Finance Act. But they have lots of allies.

The Dominion Post said:

When United Future MP Peter Dunne is prepared to jump ship, it’s a fair bet the vessel in question is the Titanic, The Dominion Post writes.

… The legislation is undemocratic, and the process by which Labour and its supporters have foisted it on the public has been an exercise in the arrogance of power.… The indefensibility of Labour’s position is only highlighted by the fact that at the same time it acted to restrict the role of those outside Parliament in political debate, it ensured that MPs are protected against challengers by extending a temporary regime that allows them to spend public money on their campaigns in a way the auditor-general had previously ruled was illegal.

And The Press says:

In any event, whatever happens next year, the legislation is thoroughly bad law and the process by which it was shoved through Parliament indefensible.

The Government has only itself to blame for the mess it has made of the matter. The bill was introduced with next to no consultation with anyone other than the cronies Labour needed to get it through the House. This was unforgivable for legislation of this kind. Consensus may be an unreachable goal on something as inherently as contentious as electoral finance, but some measure of consultation was called for. Labour did not make the slightest effort at it. The result was a bill that was a disaster that few but the party’s most uncritical followers could swallow. It was all too plainly designed not to deal honestly and fairly with an important problem but rather to shield an embattled government from any critical comment during an election year. The Government has since made multiple amendments in an attempt to remove some of the more offensive elements of the legislation, but the effort has not been sufficient. The Government was clearly prepared from the outset to ride roughshod over long-established principles. Trying to patch the matter up with all sorts of adjustments and fixes was never going to work. It should have gone back and started the process over.

The country is now left with a highly inadequate piece of legislation governing a central element of the democratic process. Parties and pressure groups will enter the election year with no clear idea of what sort of advertising is permissible. There is a clear risk that parties will engage in tit-for-tat complaints to try to shut down rivals by tying them up with expensive and time-consuming legal battles. Worse than that, from January 1, 11 months before any likely election, a firm engaged by the Electoral Commission will be conducting surveillance of political advertising to see that it complies with the law, something that will strike most fair-minded people as having the smack of Big Brother about it.

The Northern Advocate:

It’s a victory for shroud-waving, paranoia, envy and deceit. It gives power to the parties and to hell with the people. It says that if you can’t win by fair means, then make the foul lawful.

It has all been a telling illustration of how immune politicians can become to adverse public opinion that they can treat those to whom they should be answerable with such arrogance.

Having none themselves, they fail to recognise principles in others and scorn any who raise a voice in dissent as being driven by greed and self interest. By their definition it is not possible to defend democracy or to be capable of moral rectitude without agreeing implicitly with their own political ambitions.

I am told there is also an excellent ODT editorial, but I can’t locate a copy.

Greens not contesting Coromandel

Pretty sensible decision not to contest Coromandel.  National’s Goudie has built up a 10,000 vote majority and Fitzsimons time is better spent on the party vote.

The Greens should look at standing in a potentially winnable seat – one of those which has a strong party vote for them. If they continue to be close to the 5% threshold then Labour voters might vote strategically and elect a Green candidate to ensure the Greens remain in Parliament.  It worked for Prebble in 96 and Hide in 05.

Queen Elizabeth II

I may be a Republican but it doesn’t mean I don’t admire the superb service the Queen has given over her lifetime, and she is now Britain’s oldest monarch.

I was surprised to read that she is only the 40th monarch since William the Conquerer in 1066.  We’ve almost had more PMs in 150 years that the UK has had monarchs in 1,000 years.

Satire from Hopkins

Jim Hopkins yesterday:

“Hullo, little boy,” said the jovial figure, “What would you like for Christmas?”

“Ummmm,” his voice trembled. He knew he was being impertinent. “Mmmm, I’d like a BMW 730Ld, Santa.” ….

“No, no no,” Santa chuckled. “It’s all been done for you. By nice Ms Clark and her nice little elves, Jeanette and Winston. They’ve saved you the trouble. They’ve given you a nice little law for Christmas to make sure you won’t. Isn’t that nice?”

“I suppose so,” he mused. “I suppose I’m not really big enough to think for myself.”

“But you are lucky enough to have people who will do it for you!” beamed Santa. “And make sure no horrid rip-off rich person fills your head with … impure thoughts! Because we can’t have big money buying elections, can we?”

The battle for the Pacific

December Public Polls

As I don’t expect many polls between now and 31 December, I’ve published the monthly polling newsletter this morning. If you want to receive it next year.

If you would like to receive future issues, go to http://listserver.actrix.co.nz/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/polling-newsletter to subscribe yourself.

dec07polls1.JPG

The three polls this month all show a large and growing lead.  However I expect this will shrink over the summer break, as is traditional.

dec07minors.JPG

Looking at the minor parties, one can see 2007 has really been a disastrous year for the Greens.  A year ago there were almost at 10% and now they are at 5.1%. I would be very surprised if they do not pick up support next year as up is the only acceptable direction for them.

Fairfax and Pankhurst facing contempt proceedings

Fairfax Media and Dominion Post editor Tim Pankhurst have been told by the Solicitor-General they will face contempt proceedings for publishing the Police file on the Urewera 17.

Sadly for Fairfax and Tim it is probably an open and shut case. But they will argue public interest as a defence I am sure.

I wonder if the SG is trying to find out who posted the file on the Internet and also who leaked the file. That would be interesting.

Fijian scouts banned from Jamboree

Okay now this is getting silly.  Ten Fijian scouts have been banned from a jamboree in New Zealand because of their relatives.

Considering Winston made an exception for a Government Minister recently, he should make an exception for the Scouts.  I’m with Keith Locke on this one.

More on Curran

Some further thoughts.

First is that there is absolutely no suggestion Curran herself did anything wrong.  It is not her fault that Parker and the Ministry stuffed things up.

The second is how the report seems to have reached it conclusions at the beginning and then gone through and tried to explain away all the evidence that doesn’t fit the conclusion.

I mean there were written memos describing her as a Ministerial appointee.  Almost all the comms staff saw her as such.  The Minister’s Office described her as his right hand woman and set up job interview meetings for her.

Now the report explains away each of these circumstances on an individual basis, but what the report didn’t and probably couldn’t do is ask how likely it is that all these people had the wrong end of the stick  as opposed to the right end. It didn’t look at two scenarios and consider which was more likely.

Read the full report

The SSC has released its conclusions and the full report into Clare Curran.

Read the conclusions first about how there was nothing improper, and then read the full report.  Just amazing.  Here are some salient points:

  1. David Parker suggested Curran be hired at a meeting on 11 May
  2. Parker then called Curran to say he had put her name forward and that the Ministry would/might call her
  3. Then Parker’s private secretary e-mailed three senior Managers with Curran’s details and the Minister’s “suggestion” they meet her late that week and that they engage her “now” as someone else was leaving
  4. During her visit to Wellington Curran met with Parker as well as the Ministry
  5. The Minister’s private secretary e-mailed the CEO’s PA and referred to Curran as Parker’s “right-hand woman” and seeking a meeting for Curran with the CEO
  6. The Senior Media Advisor said he was told by both the Advisor and the Manager –
    Communications that Curran was going to be engaged by the Minister’s office and
    located within the Ministry where she would oversee the Ministry’s climate change
    communications work.
  7. The contract was uncontested, no formal interview was held, and no referee checks undertaken.
  8. There was widespread speculation in the Ministry that Curran’s connection to the
    Minister was the reason for her appointment, and this was never ever challenged by management.
  9. The communications team referred to the Curran as having been appointed by the Minister, including in a written report.
  10. One of her briefing notes to the Minister talked about how to minimise the risk of negative comment from the Greens.

The conclusions are straight from Yes Minister.

Just $70 will keep a billboard alive for another day

Okay the Free Speech Coalition has spent all its money. In fact slightly over-spent. So the billboards are only up for a month.

But just $70 will keep a billboard alive for another day. If you go and donate $70 at the Coalition’s website, we’ll keep a billboard up for another day. We can even proudly allocate a day to you, so you can claim the credit for a particular billboard on a particular day.

If you wish to donate more than $70, that of course is great. For those “rich pricks” as our Minister of Finance calls them, we have the following options:

  1. $70 for one non-Auckland billboard for one day
  2. $100 for one Auckland billboard for a day
  3. $150 for two non-Auckland billboards for a day
  4. $200 for one Auckland billboard for a weekend
  5. $500 for a billboard for a week
  6. $2,000 keeps a billboard up for an entire month. 11 of these and they are up until election day.
  7. $5,000 gets you an entirely new billboard with a new authoritarian and a new location for a month. You can pick to have it in your local town or suburb.
  8. $10,000 gets you your own personal billboard for three months

And if you are a “poor prick”, you are very welcome to donate less than $70.  Many supporters have given $20 and they are valued.

Send me your Gourmet Food Store viral e-mails

A computer scientist, Dean Pemberton, wants to do a study of how widespread the Gourmet Food Store viral e-mails travelled.

If you received either of the e-mails to and from Margaret from the Gourmet Food Store e-mails, can you please send them to [email protected]. By the way Dean doesn’t work for me – I control the domain so the address will forward to him.

Dean will not publish any of the names or organisations it has been sent to, or forwarded onto.  All results will be anonymised.  Do froward the whole e-mail if possible including all the cascading names it has been though as that will help measure the depth and breadth of it.

Feel free to bring this request to the notice of people you know who received or sent on the e-mail.

Russell Brown on Chch Spammer

Hugh Logan resigns

Hugh Logan has resigned as Chief Executive of the Ministry for the Environment reports Stuff.

Good on him for taking responsibility for the situation, especially as not all of it was of his making.

Tomorrow we expect to see the SSC report.

Mayoral Northern Club Membership

Aaron Bhatnagar blogs on how it turns out Dick Hubbard had ratepayers pay for his Northern Club Membership.

What is really stupid about this is that the Mayor is always given honorary membership of the Auckland Club, which automatically gives you reciprocal rights to the Northern Club.  So the perk wasn’t even needed.

Spammers beware

I’m delighted to see Internal Affairs raid offices in Christchurch, after a NZ link was discovered by the BBC to an international spam gang.

This is why I supported NZ joining the rest of the OECD in having an anti-spam law – so we can do our part working with other agencies in targeting the major spammers.  And from the sounds of it, this is a very large scale operation.

The maximum fine is $500,000.  Personally I would just settle for, if charges are laid and guilt established, with stamping “spammer” on their foreheads.  They’ll never be able to go out in public again 🙂