Greens attack BMWs

The Dom Post reports that the new Ministerial BMWs do not meet the targets set by the Energy Efficiency and Conservation Strategy issued in October.  The target is 6.5 litres per 100 kilometres travelled and the BMW 730Ld uses 8.01 litres. That more than 20% greater.

You really have to question the political judgement skills at the Beehive currently.  Regardless of arguments over whole-of-life costs and slightly improved energy efficiency, you don’t have to be a political genius to work out that replacing $70,000 cars with $170,000 cars is going to go down like cold sick with the public.  Throw in the fact that they are a BMW which in NZ (unlike Australia) has a luxury perception to it, and you really have to wonder why Internal Affairs were not told “Whatever you fucking do, don’t buy the $170K BMWs – we’ll get crucified”.

I once gave similiar advice, but on a larger scale, to a Minister in the late 90s as Cabinet was about to decide whether to buy a third frigate – something which was desirable and could be justified – yet was hugely unpopular with the public.  My words were along the lines of “Whatever you fucking do, don’t buy the effing frigate.  You can buy anything else, but not a frigate.  Probably even an aircraft carrier would be okay, just not the bloody frigate”.

A second e-mail from the Gourmet Food Store

The Southland Times has a story on the e-mail from Margaret McHugh of the Gourmet Food Company to a staffer at Ray White.

Well a second e-mail has just hit the inboxes – involving a different customer, back in mid September.

This one starts with an e-mail of complaint from a staffer at Trust Investments Management Limited.

Hello Margaret

Thank you for catering the breakfast for us on Thursday 6 September 2007.

We ordered this breakfast from you based on the very good quality and presentation of the first breakfast and lunch you supplied.

Unfortunately, we were disappointed with both the quality and presentation of the breakfast supplied, and we wish to comment as follows:

· Baps filled – We received filled Muffins instead. These were too big and unattractive with minimal filling.

· Filled Pockets – Supplied as requested but were not fresh and the fillings were messy; some pockets had strips of bacon which consisted of fat and rind.

· The Savory and Sweet Mini Muffins were a little tough.

· The Muesli slices were very nice.

· The Fresh Fruit platter which was ordered later, was also disappointing, for example the ends of the orange were included which consisted mainly of the white plinth.

We would appreciate if, in future our request cannot be met, you contact us to discuss alternatives/options.

Thank you

Then the first reply, which as per the other e-mail attacks rather than acts on the complaint:

I am sorry you were not happy with your clients breakfast, I am rather confused to say the least that you waited 4 1/2 days to inform me you were disappointed in the consumed breakfast food, it is rather unbelievable. If I was so unhappy I would have been on the telephone immediately and had the food replace forthwith. Of which I would have been more than pleased to do after having seen it again for myself.

Re fruit platter what is white Plinth. The only Plinth I know of is a square slab at the base of a column or pedestal. If you wish to discuss this further I am on the numbers below please don’t send an email it is so time consuming and impersonal . Regards Margaret

Then a reply back:

Hello Margaret

Thanks for your reply. The breakfast on Thursday 6 September commenced 7.30, the food was delivered at 7.20. Many of our guests had already arrived.

Could you have provided a replacement breakfast in 10 minutes?

The 4 ½ days to inform you of our disappointment included a 2-day weekend.

All in all we are surprised with the unprofessional response to our complaint.

Thank you

Now we get the flamer.  Note the pattern with both employees – threatening to get them in trouble with their bosses. Also I love the suggestion the food should have been preserved in case it had been tampered with!

I guess because I am the boss I can speak truthfully and not be afraid for my job, Does your boss know you are wasting their time emailing petty nonsense. In my 30 yrs as a successfully trained professional caterer I have never had to respond to such nonsense.

Please don’t use Gourmet Food Store again we are not used to part timers who have to much time on their hands,have no understanding, good manners and common sense in dealing with a complaint there and then. You never gave us an opportunity to amend what you said was wrong, we or course were never given the food to make an assessment of our own just some nicely typed out letter fully or criticism with no proof, not good enough !!!!!! The food could have been tampered with for all we know.

May I suggest in closing you spend a little more time in finding the word your were looking for in English relating to the orange so I can ask my supplier to remove it before he sends them to me in future.

I’ve also heard from a friend that she has had a similar e-mail in the past also. Looks like a pattern here!

A pissed off NZ Herald

Good God the Herald is not happy and not shy at showing it.  I only picked up yesterday’s edition last night as I flew home.  The front page story was expected, but on Page Three they have done a half page montage of all the MPs who voted for the Electoral Finance Act and have said they will be republishing the montage *every* month until the general election.

All praise the Herald.  It is vitally important that MPs understand that what they have done is so bad, that there will be consequences.  Destroying the constitutional conventions around the Electoral Act is not a minor escapade.

Also have to enjoy their sense of humour as the montage is headed up “In order to Inform, Enlighten and Entertain”, with a note that this is the only things the media are allowed to do from 1 January under the Act.

Their editorial pulls no punches:

The Electoral Finance Bill’s passage through Parliament late yesterday corrodes democracy and shames those whose names stand beside it as it enters the statutes. From January 1, political discourse will be less free, except for political parties – those private organisations that happen to provide the incumbent members of Parliament.

Today’s Herald has a story on the billboards and also Tim Shadbolt’s plans.

Audrey Young also blogs the Best of the Electoral Finance Bill Awards.  Best Speech gone to Maori Party MP and longtime protester Hone Harewira.  You must read this speech:

Yes folks money talks, but nothing talks quite like the truth, and the truth about this Bill is that it’s nothing but an arrogant dismissal by this Labour-led government to deny the citizens of Aotearoa / New Zealand the right to participate in one of the fundamental rights of any so-called “democratic society”  how you elect your government.

It’s about the sweet scent of power, and the lust for control. It’s about the decadence of corruption, the stench of deceit, and the refusal to accept the reality of impending defeat.

Yes, there have been amendments, hell we even voted for one of them, but given the constitutional importance of legislation that will play a critical role in determining how the next election will be fought  stitching up this deal behind closed doors, and then adding a veneer of democracy through a select committee process, is nothing but a sick joke.

We will not be party to this desperate attempt by Labour to stay in power at the expense of the fundamental human rights of the citizens of this country.

We will not be party to a bill designed to put fear into those who would speak their mind, by forcing them to run the gauntlet of registration, audit, notification, financial agency, monitoring, reporting, scrutiny, and penalty.

Madam Speaker, money is not what drives people to vote, it is truth …

And I sincerely hope and pray, that those who have sacrificed the truth for the delusion of power, that overwhelms this decadent and depraved piece of legislation, will come to see the folly of their ways when the people reject this sham, come Election 2008.

Again what a great speech.  Now for the other awards from Audrey:

Worst speech went to Winston Peters and no one could disagree.  A bizarre rambling speech.

Best quote went to John Key:

“If you are in favour of free speech then you are in favour of freedom of speech precisely for the views you despise. Otherwise you are not in favour of free speech.” They are not the word of a random right winger. They are not the words of a former treasurer of the Act Party… They are the words of Noam Chomsky, a man who is not from the left but from the far left.

Indeed.

Relaxing at the Viaduct

Well I’m stuck up in Auckland for a few hours with nothing to do, so a dozen of us are having an early Christmas break and having drinks for a few hours viaduct.JPGat a mate’s apartment at the Viaduct.  A nice relaxing day.  Don’t expect any more blogging today!

Some Billboards to enjoy

Free Speech Coalition saddened by passage of Electoral Finance Bill

The FSC put out this press release this afternoon:

The Free Speech Coalition, set up to campaign against the Electoral Finance Bill, is sad that MPs from Labour, NZ First, and the Greens have ignored the massive public sentiment against the bill.

The Act discourages individuals and groups from participating in the electoral process and spending their own money, while at the same time allows MPs and parliamentary parties to far more easily use taxpayer funds on their election campaigns and not even have it count towards their spending limits. It is the ultimate act in hypocrisy.

The MPs have

• Ignored the Law Society’s advice that the Bill should be scrapped
• Ignored the Human Rights Commission opposition to the regulated period, and their request to allow the public to submit on the amended Bill
• Ignored the NZ Institute of Charted Accountant’s advice that the Bill is unworkable
• Ignored the Electoral Commission’s advice on spending limits
• Failed to provide legislative certainty around the exemptions for MPs
• Protected anonymous donations with massive loopholes which may result in less, not more, disclosure
• Continually misrepresented key clauses of the Bill

“New Zealand has no written constitution. At the end of the day 61 MPs in Parliament can pass any law they like, no matter how repugnant. Previously constitutional conventions have protected Acts like the Electoral Act, but the passage of the Electoral Finance Bill sees the demise of that convention.” said spokesperson David Farrar.

“We hoped the parties supporting this Bill would listen to the near universal opposition from the media, from the legal profession, and from the public and do the right thing. Sadly they have chosen not to.

“We do not believe there should be no consequences for those parties which passed the Electoral Finance Act into law. The NZ Herald correctly labeled it as an “Attack on Democracy” and we believe it is time for Democracy to attack back.

“The Free Speech Coalition will commence an advertising campaign tomorrow against parties and MPs which voted for the Electoral Finance Act. This campaign will continue into 2008. A media advisory with details of the campaign will be released tomorrow.

ENDS

Electoral Finance Act now law

Sounds like United Future is voting against

Peter Dunne is saying the perception it is anti-democratic has become the reality and they no longer think it should be pushed through.

UPDATE: Yes Dunne has confirmed he is voting against.

UPDATE 2: I have very mixed feelings about the sincerity of what Peter Dunne has done.  I am glad he has voted against, but at every stage where his vote was actually important he has gone with the Government.  He never once protested the 11 month regulated period.  He voted against many amendments which would have improved the Bill.  I am not sure one vote flipflop at the last possible moment, knowing it will make no difference to the outcome, really means he does not continue to share liability for the law.

Mallard apologises to Erin Leigh

Better late than never.  This is what you call a poll inspired apology.  Very half hearted.

Mallard got up and merely said:

I made comment about  Erin Leigh on two occasions.  On reflection it ws not wise of me to make those comments. I apologise to her.

I think it is too late to repair the damage.

Mallard pleads guilty

From NZPA:

Cabinet Minister Trevor Mallard has pleaded guilty to a charge of fighting in a public place.

The plea in Wellington District Court this afternoon followed a hearing of the private prosecution taken by Wellington account Graham McCready over Mallard’s alleged assault of National MP Tau Henare in Parliament.

The offence carried no sentence with it and Mallard agreed to donate $500 to a Salvation Army drug and alcohol rehabilitation course.

Mr McCready withdrew a second charge against Mallard over an incident last year with another National MP.

Not a bad compromise.  Mallard will be glad it is over.

King comes clean with her interpretation

As I blogged last week, Annette King was due to reveal today a new interpretation of the parliamentary exemption, so that Labour’s pledge card.  She has been forced into this humiliating backdown because her original intepretation excluded statements made outside the House on policy to be enacted by a future Parliament, and the 9th floor realised this ruled out Labour’s pledge card and related campaign activities.

You see Labour is broke and needs to both have the taxpayer pay for its campaign, but also in case they do raise some money, not have the taxpayer spend count towards the limit.

So King has to back down.  And she did so today in the third reading.  She said:

My original view was too narrow.

She went onto to say that the exemption for MPs should include

provision of policy options and analysis to the electorate

A 180 degree flip-flop from her earlier view.  Sounds much like an election campaign to me – providing policy options and analysis to the electorate.

And then finally she referred to how

MPs behaviour governed by Appropriations Act 2007 and Speaker’s Guidelines

In other words having amended one law to over-ride the Auditor-General, they now want the other law (the Electoral Finance Act) to exempt from spending limits anything approved by The Parliamentary Service.

This final act of Annette King’s is the final proof that the motivations of those voting for the Bill is entirely self seeking – it is to allow them to run taxpayer funded election campaigns, and not even have them count as part of the limits they place on everyone else.

The Gourmet Food Store

Go over to Spare Room and read this e-mail exchange involving the Gourmet Food Store.

I, like many, have also been forwarded the original e-mails and reading them in order is even more painful than the extract Ana has put on Spare Room.  I think that store is going to lose a lot of business, like the marquee company last year.

BMWs for the Cabinet

The nice Government is very concerned about the environment and as part of this sincere belief, have decided to sacrifice their Ford Fairlaines for a more environmentally friendly car.

Yes the poor wee souls are going to downgrade their Ministerial cars from Ford Fairlaines to  BMW 730Lds.

How will they cope.  The sacrifices they are willing to make for the sake of the Environment.

So 34 BMWs are on the way.  And how much do they cost?  Well the Government will get a bulk discount but the shelf price in the UK (they are not sold in NZ) is NZ$146,400.  And a Ford Fairlaine 4.0 litre is $72,000.

A quiz from Audrey

Audrey Young blogs:

It is hard to decide what the worst feature of the Electoral Finance Bill is:

a) that it was pursued with such self-interest by Labour without the bipartisan approach associated with something as important as electoral law;

b) extending the regulated period for electioneering almost all of election year; or

c) that it gives incumbent MPs an even greater unfair advantage over outside rival candidates and groups that oppose them or their policies.

Audrey goes on to talk about how it will legalise Labour’s pledge card.

The Kiwiblog 2007 Awards Winners

Over 600 votes cast in just 24 hours.  And we have some winners.  Now remember this is not a scientific poll but a survey of whom Kiwiblog readers have rated the best.

MP of the Year

[14%] Helen Clark
[5%] Michael Cullen
[40%] Bill English
[41%] John Key

A not surprising clear preference to National here, with John Key narrowly ahead (just 5 votes in it) of his deputy for MP of the Year.  Their combination seems a winning one to date.

Labour MP of the Year

[23%] Helen Clark
[7%] Michael Cullen
[11%] David Cunliffe
[38%] Phil Goff
[8%] Steve Maharey
[13%] Trevor Mallard

Phil Goff a clear winner as Labour MP of the Year.  Widely regarded as having had an error free year and with the retirement of Maharey and sin binning of Mallard is now the heir apparent.

National MP of the Year

[49%] Bill English
[20%] Chris Finlayson
[31%] John Key

And a landslide win for Bill English as National MP of the Year.  English has impressed many with his dissection of the Electoral Finance Bill.

Minor Party MP of the Year

[25%] Sue Bradford (Green)
[12%] Ron Mark (NZ First)
[35%] Heather Roy (ACT)
[29%] Pita Sharples (Maori)

Heather Roy obviously has won the hearts and minds of many on the right.  However Maori Party co-leader Pita Sharples has almost as many fans, and Sue Bradford also gained an impressive number of votes.
Press Gallery Journalist of the Year

[16%] Jane Clifton
[30%] Colin Espiner
[34%] Fran O’Sullivan
[20%] Audrey Young

Associate press gallery member Fran O’Sullivan’s blunt no nonsense style sees her pip blogging political editor Colin Espiner for 1st place.
Public Servant of the Year

[38%] Kevin Brady
[32%] Erin Leigh
[6%] Hugh Logan
[15%] David McGee
[9%] Ros Noonan

Auditor-General Kevin Brady wins the award for public servant of the year, with whistle-blower Erin Leigh a close second.  Highly respected retiring Clerk of the House David McGee gets a creditable third place.

Kiwiblog will write to the winners informing them of their cyber-awards.

General Debate 18 December 2007

Today’s Tom Scott

The end of the battle

I started blogging on the proposed changes to the Electoral Act on 6 December 2006.  Ironically it was a post about how National had agreed to lend bi-partisan support to Helen Clark’s moves to reform the Electoral Act.

And this really highlights the magnitude of Labour’s incompetence on this issue.  National was nervous about being seen to defend secret trusts, anonymous donations and parallel campaigns by the Brethren. They did not want electoral reform to be a controversial issue.

All Labour had to do a year ago was sit down with National, and other parties, and agree on some basic principles, publish them for public comment, and then introduce a law based on that.  It would have flown through.

My 2nd post in March was to express concern at secret negotiations on the EFB and that changes should only be made with bipartisan support or an election commitment.  My concern was truly justified.

Then in April I commented on the leaked Cabinet paper.  And while I took issue with a couple of self serving aspects (protecting Owen Glenn’s donation) I blogged support for most of the proposals.

Then the Herald got hold of further details such as state funding of parties and extending the 90 day period and I started to go negative.

Then there was nothing for three months as Labour continued with secret negotiations instead of having a public policy process.  They are the only ones to blame for the law being passed a week before Christmas.

And then we saw in July their desire to screw maximum advantage for themselves and the outright incompetence of Mark Burton combined to create the horror known as the original Electoral Finance Bill. And that is why opposition rose up to it.  I certainly was planning to support the Electoral Finance Bill initially, and just seek improvements.  I never imagined it would be so draconian and unprecedented that one could get the Human Rights Commission and the Law Society agreeing it should be thrown out rather than amended.

Anyway since December 2006, I have made a total of 192 posts on the subject of the changes to the Electoral Act.  There are also 26 posts from early 2006 detailing Labour’s corrupt behaviour in the 2005 election where they defied the Chief Electoral Office and over-spent deliberately, bring the category total to 218.  This will be No 219.

The word count is somewhat horrific but I have published over 91,000 words on the Electoral Finance Bill. Now some of that is cut and paste but still a scary amount of words.

But it has been worth it.  Sadly the bill is about to pass, but those who support it have suffered for it, and hopefully will suffer next year for it.  And also many of the improvements to the EFB are due to the strength of the opposition.

I believe the blogs have played a pretty significant role.  Just one example is the submission of the Human Rights Commission.  This was not picked up by any media outlet as the media traditionally only cover submitters when they appear orally.  It was blogs which went through the 700 or so submissions, started writing about them, and then had the media follow through with stories. 

The same happened with some articles on the bill.  A couple of legal opinions strongly attacking the EFB were scanned in and placed on blogs.  Now these opinions had been public for several days already but not reported.  But once they got published on blogs, the media within hours had stories about them.

So it has been a battle well worth waging, and while today’s third reading marks the end of that battle as a loss for those against the Electoral Finance Bill, there is an old saying about winning a battle and losing the war, and those parties voting for the Electoral Finance Bill may yet discover that.

Final chance: Vote in the Kiwiblog 2007 Awards

Voting closes at 2 pm Tuesday 18 December, and results will be announced later that day. Only vote once please. If you remove the cookie and vote multiple times, a complaint will be laid with the ISP your IP address belongs to.

There are six questions to vote on. Just use the scroll bar to see them all. And they are meant to be positive awards for the best in each category. The most popular nominees in each category have been short-listed.

Have fun!

Less is more

Bryce Edwards makes the case for less, not more, state intervention in the democratic process.

It is not commonly realised that the US political system is one of the most highly regulated in the western world. Considerable regulations have been developed in order, ostensibly, to ensure a level playing field in elections. Of course, no such level playing field can be created from the huge restrictions on political activity that these state interventions impose.

By contrast, the New Zealand electoral system has historically been relatively laissez faire, with few state impediments to political activity. New Zealand political parties have been generally regarded as private organisations, and hence have had little obligation to report upon their internal affairs. Unfortunately, New Zealand has recently been shifting towards the American system of intense political regulation.

… The 1986 New Zealand Royal Commission on the Electoral System (RCES) anticipated the problems of the state-party relationship: ‘we recognise that there are dangers inherent in excessive State intervention in the democratic process. If taken too far, controls may represent an unjustifiable intrusion on the freedom of individuals, groups, political parties and candidates’ (RCES, 1986: p.185). Arguably, the regulation of politics has now been taken too far in New Zealand. And the consequences are not just a reduction in political liberty, but also many other apparently unintended consequences, including the creation of barriers to new political parties entering Parliament, and a reduction in the ability of the public to participate in politics.

In a perverse way, modern reforms actually exacerbate many of the problems they were intended to solve, as well as creating new problems along the way. Primarily, state intervention simply distorts political behaviour. As elsewhere, the reforms may be well intended but essentially, the cure of political regulation ends up being worse than the disease of financial scandal.

Read the full article.  It’s very good.

ACC set to sue Affco for gang shooting in car park

NZPA reports that ACC won’t back down with Affco:

ACC and Affco became involved in a long-running battle after Joel Storey, 23, was left paralysed from the waist down from what appeared to be a gang shooting in the carpark of Affco’s Wairoa plant in April 2003.

State-owned workplace insurer ACC said the incident came under the umbrella of a workplace accident and billed the company for $1 million in compensation.

If a gang shooting after hours in a car park is now a workplace accident, then I guess employers are now responsible for all crime related injuries.  Let’s sue the car park buildings for any violence that happens within their premises.

Also let’s think about the responsibility of employers to minimise workplace accidents.  Now if this includes minimising the chance of a gang shooting in the car park, how can the employer  help prevent this?  I guess we need to allow Affco to have its own armed security guards.  Or maybe a guard tower with some snipers.

KiwiSaver vs Universal Superannuation

I’m a fan of Kiwisaver, partly because from the day Cullen make it de facto compulsory through mandatory employer contributions I realised one day this will become the major source of income for people in retirement.

I’ve always thought at some future date, when say 75% of employees are in KiwiSaver, such as 2025 a Government will probably transfer the Cullen Fund into KiwiSaver and make it compulsory for all.  Logically NZ Superannuation will start to be means tested and only there for those who don’t have sufficient funds in KiwiSaver.

Now the Retirement Commission has looked at this, and come to a similiar conclusion:

“The incentives are now a significant cost that future governments will have to consider.

“The danger is that these costs become too high, and something has to change.”

The commission said that in a worst-case scenario, New Zealand’s universal superannuation would have to be cut to fund KiwiSaver.

It is the near ultimate irony is that Dr Cullen’s crowning achievement with be the effective privatisation of NZ Superannuation.  Now in the next few years or even the next decade, but at some stage in the future KiwiSaver will become the major source of income for retirees, and NZ Superannuation will become just a top up for some.

Growing confusion over Electoral Finance Bill

The Herald reports Steven Price from the Coalition for Open Government saying that despite the regulated period being all of 2008, an advertisement might start off the year legal, yet end up illegal at some unspecified time closer to the election.

This just goes to show what a mess things will be.  The true impact of the Bill will not be how many people get prosecuted, but how many people don’t speak out because they don’t know if doing so will be legal or not.

As Bill English says:

Mr English said under the current law there was a “bright line” at three months before the election and there was nothing in the bill to steer the Electoral Commission towards having a different rule on January 7 than a week before the election.

The bright line gives certainity.  Now advertisers have to face that their advertisements may become illegal on some unspecified date.  Good law is meant to have as little uncertainty as possible.

And this is not the only area of confusion.  The Electoral Commission still has no definition of how the exemption for MPs in their role as MPs is meant to work.  Instead they will have to rely on whatever partisan interpretation Annette King invents during her third reading speech today.  And no one really knows how a Court will interpret this area.

The Electoral Suicide Bill

 bosefbad.JPG

The latest advertisement from John Boscawen is above as an image.  The link below takes you to an 800KB pdf of it.  It ran in the Sunday Star-Times.

Electoral Suicide Bill Ad

Do Labour, the Greens, United Future and NZ First really want to be explaining next year why Tim Shadbolt has gone to jail for sticking up for his constituents in Southland by running advertisement ten months before the election.  Do they think there is any way they can overcome the symbolism of that? Sure there are grounds to disagree about whether the ads he ran in December would infringe, but there is no doubt his ads planned for early next year will run afoul as they will call for the Government to be brought down.

It is no coincidence that those parties supporting the Electoral Finance Bill are well down in the polls.  Now they can gamble that the issue will fade, but that is a very risky gamble.

The Innocence Project

Poneke (who is becoming a must read) has a very informative post about how Phil Goff’s promised inquiry into the Peter Ellis case was nobbled.  And yes the Val Sim he refers to is the same one who said the original Electoral Finance bill did not breach the Bill of Rights and is now on the Law Commission.

But more interesting for me is the blog post on The Innocence Project being set up by academics and others at Vic and Otago Unis.

I think the Peter Ellis case is a stain on our justice system, and am fully supportive of The Innocence Project.  This could even be a good cause for blogs from all sides of poltics to combine forces on to support.

How about a concerted campaign to set up a Criminal Cases Review Commission as proposed by Sir Thomas Thorp. In election year blogs could run a campaign to pressure all parliamentary parties to make it a policy commitment?