Cullen vetoes Chief Electoral Prosecutor

As blogged earlier, Chris Finlayon has proposed the excellent idea of a QC as Chief Electoral Prosecutor instead of the Police.  I’ve advocated the removal of the Police as prosecutors for over a year – since I read the OIA files on how badly they stuffed up the 2005 investigations.

Nicky Hager and the Coalition for Open Government should be supporting this – it would mean an agency with the will, the competence and powers to properly investigate breaches such as alleged by Hager.

But alas Dr Cullen has vetoed it.  This means it won’t even be debated or voted upon.  They were presumably worried that it might get minor party support and be passed.

Standing Order 319 gives the Minister of Finance to power to veto any amendment which has more than a minor impact on the Crown’s finances.  And Dr Cullen has stated he think it will.  But you will be amazed at his estimates?

He thinks over a three year electoral period it will cost up to almost $10 million.  Why?  The Government says it will probably need 15 to 30 fulltime staff.

So get this – they are passing a law which is so badly drafted and may catch so many people, 15 to 30 staff would be needed to properly investigate and prosecute everyone who breaks it.

Just more farce from the Government of farce.

Helen Clark on Erin Leigh

I think most people are aware of what has happened to date.  Erin Leigh revealed that a number of Environment Ministry staff were very unhappy with David Parker “suggesting” Claire Curran be hired, as they saw it as politicising the Ministry.

Trevor Mallard then got up in Parliament and labelled Leigh sad and incompetent.

This has been refuted by numerous neutral civil servants who have in fact raved about how good she is.  Mind you, even if someone is not that good at their job, how much money would the Employment Tribunal award for a boss who gets up in public and calls her incompetent in front of the nation’s media?  Trevor is off to a good start as Minister of Labour.

Anyway the 9th floor had been pushing stories about how Trevor went off on his own, and how Clark was not happy.  So we got to hear yesterday what she though of Trevor Mallard using parliamentary privilege to destroy the career of a young former public servant.

From Hansard:

John Key: Does she condone or approve of Trevor Mallard’s savage attack, using parliamentary privilege, on *Erin Leigh when she blew the whistle on political interference at the Ministry for* the Environment?

Rt Hon HELEN CLARK: My understanding is that the Minister spoke on advice. Having read the Hansard, I consider it rather mild by his standards.

The translation is:

“The bitch should be glad Trevor didn’t punch her little face in, like he did to Tau”

I mean, seriously, does anyone other than Helen really think what Mallard did is appropriate?

It just goes to show how fake she was over Mallard needing to get his anger under control, and how she was demoting him.

Also nice to know that our Prime Minister no longer holds Minister to a high set of standards.  What is the standard she now holds them to – “by his standards”. So its official Ministers are now to be judged against the standards of Trevor Mallard.  I can safely predict none will ever fail!!

The amendments

Okay let us look at some of the proposed amendments to the Electoral Finance Bill.

First SOP162 by Annette King.

  1. Deletes the “megaphone” paragraph which the Select Committee added on.  This is a 100% backdown, which is good.
  2. Moves the deadline for third party registrations from writ day to 21 days before the election.  A small improvement, but the Electoral Commission itself has said they have no problems with allowing registrations at any time, as other countries do.
  3. Plug a massive loophole with donations made via trusts. The current provisions could have been got around by donating a Trust A which donates to Trust B which donates to a party.  This is the problem with having inserted these clauses in just a couple of weeks ago – lots of loopholes.
  4. allows the electoral authorities to not report breaches to the Police if inconsequential.  This is similiar to the status quo when small breaches often were not reported.  However the EFB changed the requirement for notification to the Police from “shall” to “must” which effectively would have removed all discretion, hence the need for this further change.
  5. The requirement to have a name and address on “election advertisements” is changed from “persons” to promoters”.  This in fact changes very little, as any person who makes a statement advocating support for or against a party becomes a promoter.  If you post to Usenet “Don’t vote National as they hate workers”, then you are a promoter and need a name and address on the post.  If you make up a placard for a protest march which says “Don’t vote for parties against Kyoto”, then that still needs you to put your name and address on it.  The effect of the change is that if someone makes up ten placards for the march, and gives them to other marchers, then it is that person’s name and address which must go on the placards – not the person they have given it to.  So the change is sensible in that regard, but it doesn’t change the situation that posts to Usenet and placards are now election ads which require names and addresses. It’s a pity the Government didn’t use the amendment Dean Knight drafted for them, which would have solved almost all these problems.  One can only assume they did not, because they want to have this effect.

Then we have SOP163 by Annette King:

  1.  scores of apparently minor amendments.  I’ve yet to work through them all.  One of the problems of amendments at this stage is you need to work the amendment into the Bill to see the effect it has.  This is unlike the select committee changes which are marked up within the Bill itself.
  2. removes the ability for non cash anonymous donations to be made via the Electoral Commission.  The EC will be very pleased with this, especially as I know someone was planning to deliver to them $1,200 worth of logs as a donation to a party for use as wood for hoardings.  The poor EC would have been required to store the logs, and then pass them on 🙂

SOP164 just divided the Bill into three Acts, once passed.  They will be:

  1. Electoral Finance Act 2007
  2. Broadcasting Amendment Act 2007
  3. Electoral Amendment Act 2007

One of the good things a future Government can do is to bring all the electoral law back under one Electoral Act.  If you want parties, candidates and now even the public to obey the electoral laws, it will help a hell of a lot if there is only one Act of Parliament they have to read and understand.

Chris Finlayson proposed SOP 165. It proposes the creation of a Chief Electoral Prosecutor who shall be a QC or SC. This is a superb proposal (and should have been in the Bill from the beginning) as the Police incompetence with the 2005 breaches is well known and documented.  I’d almost say nothing is more important than having an authority which actually will prosecute clear breaches of the electoral laws – otherwise what is the point of having them.  The Police failure to prosecute in 2005 greatly undermined the authority of the electoral agencies who asked them to prosecute.  This would be a great step forward. I love the powers Finlayson has given it also.

The Greens and United Future should seriously look at supporting this SOP. It would be nice if Labour did also, but they were the prime beneficiaries of the Police incompetence or timidness last election, so may not be motivated to do so.

Finally we have SOP 166 from Chris Finlayson. This has several dozen substantive amendments – none of them are fillybusters.  They include:

  1. Change start date to 1 April 2008
  2. Rename third party to interest group
  3.  Make clear a periodical can not include a political party publication
  4. change the massively wide definition of publish back to close to the 1993 Electoral Act definition (would exempt placards, Usenet posts, etc)
  5. change the regulated period back to the traditional 90 days
  6. deletes the definition of election advertisement which includes advocating for or against a class of party or candidate, by just referring to policies (ie support parties which support Kyoto would now not be an ad)
  7. widens the exemption for blogs to all personal political views on the Internet
  8. changes the thresholds and limits for third party advertising to those recommended by the Electoral Commission
  9. corrects a drafting error which could be interpreted as accidentially reducing the limit for parties from $2.4 million to $1.4 million (it comes down to using “plus” instead of “and”)
  10. Brings in CPI indexing of various donation and spending limits (in a very well worded new Part)
  11. Allows political parties, not just individuals, to be sued under the Act

It will be very interesting to see how some of the minor parties vote on these amendments.  Are the Greens going to vote against extending the blog exemption to all personal political views on the Internet?
Each amendment is voted on one after another within each Part of the Bill, so it is hard to keep up with which amendments have been accepted.  Generally all the Government ones get accepted and none of the Opposition ones, but some of Finlayson’s may get through.

King backdowns on EFB interpretation

The Herald reports that Annette King has backed away from her own advice to the Electoral Commission on how the immunity for adveritsing by MPs in their capacity as MPs should apply.

I had suggested the acid test should be whether Labour’s 2005 pledge card would now be exempt.  And the good thing initiall is that the Minister gave an explanation that:

“MPs acting in their capacity as members of Parliament” excluded statements they made outside the House on policy that was intended to be enacted by a future Parliament.”

That sounded somewhat promising, as that would probably mean an election pledge card would not be exempt.

But last night in Parliament she backed down from her interpretation, and said her view was a personal one, not an official one.

So we’re now back to the situation where the Electoral Commission will have to just tell everyone to consult their lawyers.  Welcome to Florida.

Thanks Lord Ashcroft

Over 150 last second amendments!!

Annette King has just tabled the Government SOPs to the Electoral Finance Bill.  I’m amazed by the quantity of the amendments – there are over 150 further amendments to the Bill.

MPs in an hour or so will start voting on the details of the Bill, and the Government has just landed 150 amendements on them.

Now remember this is not just any law – this is part of the constitution of New Zealand – the Electoral Act is arguably our most important democratic act.  And it is being patched up at the last second with scores of amendments that cut out the public from meaningful scrutiny.

Do you remember Helen claiming the Bill was great now it is out of select committee?  So great, it needs 150 amendments.

Could you imagine the outcry in most countries if suddenly one has 150 amendments to the constitution, a couple of hours before they get voted on?  Mickey Mouse is too generous a term for it.

I’ll blog the substance of some of the changes as I work through them.

Why Australia is so much richer than New Zealand?

Phil Rennie from the Centre for Independent Studies has published an analysis on why Australia is so much richer than New Zealand.

Major points are:

  • Per capita GDP (adjusted for PPP) is NZ$48,000 in Australia and $36,400 in NZ
  • The major difference is labour productivity – Australian workers produce a
    third more wealth for every hour worked, largely because they have more capital (machinery and technology) to work with.
  • Tax is a major area of difference between the two countries. Australia is a much lower taxing country, especially in terms of income tax. This affects incentives to work, save, and invest.
  • Prosperity does not come by accident. Australia has a stronger political consensus around policies for growth, which contributes to investor confidence. In contrast, New Zealand halted most major reform in 1993, and has increased tax and regulation since 2000.

That last point is an important one.  Both the Coalition and Labor in Australia are very focused on increasing economic growth, and making necessary reforms to increase labour productivity etc.

The analysis includes some wage comparisons.  For example a dump truck operator in NZ earns $45K to $60K and in Australia $73K to $84K in NZ PPP $.

Going back to Australian Labor, the report quotes the new PM Kevin Rudd:

Kevin Rudd says he is ‘committed to keeping taxes as low as possible to attract investment and reward enterprise.’

Also a good quote:

A myth persists in some quarters that New Zealand is a laboratory for free-market reform, and that it has done all it can to create a level playing field. The reality is that our major reforms are now considered orthodox around the world. If we want to increase our growth, we need to do more, as Australia has consciously chosen to do.

Finally some recommendations:

  1. Lower income taxes.
  2. Cut the top rate of income tax.
  3. Improve the quality of government spending.
  4. Commit to light-handed regulation as much as possible.
  5. Regulatory responsibility law.

Now of course some people will decry all these things.  But here’s the irony – they’re the same people who probably complain wages in NZ are not high enough. You want higher wages – you need to keep improving the economic environment.

156 pages of comments

NZ Herald does final call to Kill the Bill

04front.jpg

The Herald does another front page editorial on the Electoral Finance Bill. This Bill is oppossed by almost every independent institution there is – almost universal media opposition.  The Human Rights Commission concerns have not been fully met.  The Law Society, the Institute of Accountants have both called it fundamentally flawed.  Even the Electoral Commission has said they can not interpret it, and the so called solution to their concerns hasn’t even yet been publicly published.  I’d even say the majority of left wing commentators like McCarten, Harre and Trotter are saying the status quo should prevail, or are at best very very luke warm on proceeding.

Anyway let’s quote from the Herald front page:

There will be no winners if the Electoral Finance Bill is passed into law this week. The Labour Party will have revised the electoral rules to suit itself, but that will be a pyrrhic victory if it loses the next election, as polls suggest it will. The National Party has promised to repeal the bill as soon as it gets the chance.

Thus our electoral law is reduced to a game of political ping-pong, a game that would not have started had the Government done the right thing from the beginning.

Even its friend the Green Party has been urging it to refer its concerns about election finance to an independent body that could recommend changes to the law if necessary from an impartial position.

Unless the Greens and United Future act on their reservations and withhold support for the bill this week it will pass. And they will be as guilty as Labour and New Zealand First for the offence to free speech.

The self-serving electoral fix is being done now in the hope it might be forgotten at an election 11 months hence.

Money does not win elections unless the message it is financing strikes a popular chord. Labour is legislating in fear of messages it might not like. At the same time, it has given parties in Parliament the right to use public funds for purposes the Auditor-General ruled improper at the last election.

The country should not stand for this. It is not unduly susceptible to paid campaigns. The bill is an insult to our intelligence as well as our rights. Even now, at the 11th hour, it can be stopped and sent to an impartial panel. Let’s hope the common sense outside Parliament can prevail.

Next year will be very difficult for the Government.  They will be trying to get their message across, but what will the media probably be reporting:

  • A hearing in April on whether or not the original EFB breached the Bill of Rights
  • People, like John Boscawen, deliberately spending over the limit campaigning against the parties that supported this bill, and ending up in court for daring to spend his own money criticising the parties that passed this law.   That court case will be a nightmare for Labour and allies.
  • Multiple electoral petitions on electorate expenditure interpretation
  • A year long focus on every piece of advertising paid for by the taxpayer through Parliament
  • Scores of people who will break the law in minor ways and get publicity for doing so
  • Hundreds of complaints to electoral authorities over unauthorised advertisements
  • Ridicule for the law as the massive loopholes in it get exploited

Labour needs to ask themselves one question.  Is it worth losing the election over?

Peter Dunne does not know what he is voting for

Peter Dunne has posted on the United Future website about the Electoral Finance Bill, and sadly it is apparent Peter is not conversant with what the EFB will do. He makes a number of quite wrong claims.

A Dave (not me) had said:

If the opinion can be seen as encouraging or persuading people to support or not support a party or a candidate or a class of party or candidate it will be limited. If you want to run a campaign which says �Support parties which support Kyoto� then that is captured.

Peter Dunne replied:

With respect, Dave, neiter of those claims are true. To be caught, a group has to be apending more than $120,000 in support of a particular party, from the period of registration through to the leection. That is from Writ Day onwards – about a month before the election.

Now let us look at what the Bill says – would it include a campaign which says support parties which support Kyoto, even if it does not name them?

Clause 5(1) is our key clause defining an election advertisement, and we want paragraph (a)(ii) which is:

encouraging or persuading voters to vote, or not to vote, for a type of party or for a type of candidate that is described or indicated by reference to views, positions, or policies that are or are not held, taken, or pursued (whether or not the name of a party or the name of a candidate is stated)

So it is crystal clear it does not have to be in support of a particular party. It can be in support or against parties which hold or do not hold particular policy positions. Peter Dunne is quite wrong in his assertion it has to be “in support of a particular party”. The example given by Dave about “Support parties which support Kyoto” is quite clearly within the gambit of 5(1)(a)(ii).

Peter is also confused about the dates which the spending limits apply for – it is all of election year. Here’s how it works:

  1. Any communication with the public by any means which says “Support parties which support Kyoto” is an election advertisement from 1 January 2008
  2. If one spends over $12,000 on that communication, you *must* register as a third party prior to spending over $12,000. So if you spend $3,000 a month from January then you must register before May.
  3. The latest you can enrol as a third party is writ day, but the spending limit applies for all expenditure from 1 January. You can not do what Dunne suggests and spend what you like until writ day, and then be restricted.

So the implication that the limit on spending is from writ day to election day is quite misleading.

Peter is also wrong on the t-shirts. T-shirts were not defined under the 1993 Electoral Act as an advertisement. The Electoral Finance Bill most definitely will include t-shirts as publishing an advertisement if it encourages or persuades people to vote for a party. But that is a trivial side issue compared to the fact that a Government Minister and the swing vote on the Select Committee has not fully understood the third party provisions of the Bill he is partly responsible for.

I have a hell of a lot of time for Peter Dunne, and I note he has not said he will definitely vote for the Electoral Finance Bill on the third reading. I urge him to re-read the Bill and decide to vote against it.

UPDATE: Graeme Edgeler (lawyer who has written a lot on this bill) has posted on the United Future blog correcting various statements made there. He points out that the Crazy Car campaign being run this year would be covered (and illegal due to its cost) next year.

Also Peter Dunne has admitted he is wrong about the period of time the $120,000 applies for. He has not yet conceded that his description of what sort of activities would be captured was also wrong.

Effing phone

I left my main cellphone at home yesterday and spent the day doing various things around town.  Left the polling team around 8 pm and went home.

Normally there may be a few missed calls.  But hell there were 33 missed calls and 14 voice mail messages.  That’s just ridicolous.  How on Earth can you be expected to get work done if you are getting called every 15 minutes.

The thought of clearing 14 voice mail messages last night was too depressing so I watched TV instead! Will clear them later this morning.

Telecom should really put me on commission for all the money they make from people ringing me!

Third Party Spending Limits

It is a timely day to look at the third party spending limits in the Electoral Finance Bill. I blogged a couple of weeks ago:

You see there are two levels of spending one should look at, in setting a limit.

  1. How much does a third party need to spend to be effective? You see if the limit is set below that level, then you defeat the entire purpose of having advocacy in a democratic society. How much money do you need to spend to be able to effectively communicate a message to the target of 2.7 million people.
  2. How much spending constitutes starting to drown out or dominate the debate? The limit at which the ad on TV is appearing every day for weeks on end, or in every newspaper repeatedly.

So the limit for third parties (there is an argument that there should be no limit, but this is accepting that you have a limit as political parties have a limit) should be between (1) and (2).

Now the Sensible Sentencing Trust and Family First put out a release yesterday giving a practical example of how the limit of $120,000 over 11 months is so low that it will prevent them from even sending a brochure to every household:

Both trusts had planned on sending a brochure to every household in NZ next year in a similar fashion to what political parties do. The brochures would have highlighted issues important to each of the trusts and shown how the political parties have each responded to those concerns. This would have been paid for through donations from members and supporters with no taxpayer funding.

However, Family First has gained a quote to do this and discovered that it would be banned under the Electoral Finance Bill.

“The cost of just the brochures and envelopes is quoted at $135,000, and then there is the cost of postage to add on,” says Bob McCoskrie, National Director of Family First NZ. “However, the proposed electoral law restricts 3rd party advertising to $120,000.”

“The Electoral Finance Bill will mean that this simple one-off activity of placing one brochure into the hands of NZ homes in 2008 to present our concerns will be illegal. This is perfect proof of just how restrictive this bill is.”

So if $120,000 is too low, what is the right level? Well the Electoral Commission which advocates a level of at least $250,000 actually did research on what one can purchase at five levels:

a Limit before registering as 3rd party, $5,000
b Spending cap in Bill – $60,000, which is 1.25% of $4.8 million;
c $120,000, which is 2.5% of $4.8 million
d $240,000, which is 5.0% of $4.8 million
e $480,000, which is 10.0% of $4.8 million

Note that the Government originally went for the 1.25% figure, but has now increased this to just 2.5% or $120,000.

Now if one looks at the information provided by their media agency, you’ll see that it takes $240,000 to even reach 60% of the NZ adult population. $480,000 will reach 75%.

The $120,000 is half of what was recommended. Why?  It is nothing to do with stopping people “buying” elections or drowning out the debate.  One can only conclude it is about stopping lobby groups from being able to effectively criticise the Government.

If it is not about that, then why did the Government and Select Committee ignore the advice of the Electoral Commission to have a higher limit?  The Commission provided factual research on what one can and can not purchase at various levels, and the level was set very low, knowing it would restrict lobby groups from being able to communicate in election year.

The Sensible Sentencing Trust wants to be able to put one pamphlet into every household next year – yes just one extra piece of junk mail. They want to be able to communicate what the policies are of all the parties on law & order issues which are of concern to them, and how they rate those policies. The Electoral Finance Bill will prevent them being able to even do this – yes it will stop a simple flyer going to every home.

And worse of all, this restriction on being able to even send a flyer to every home will apply for all of 2008, not just the election campaign itself.

Chavez loses

This is great news – Venezuela voters have rejected the constitution promoted by Hugo Chavez by 51% to 49%.

This new constitution would have removed the law requiring Chavez to step down in 2012, and give him greatly increased powers.

He is accepting the result for now, but we’ll see given time whether or not he does hand power over peacefully.

Another blow against Parker

Another former Environment Ministry staffer has spoken out and revealed what has really gone on in the Environment Ministry.

TV3 has the video here.

The summary is

  • Former communications manager, Keith Lyons (who now works for international aid agencies in Tibet) has said it seemed Mr Parker left the ministry no choice about hiring Ms Curran, that “It seemed like it was being imposed on the ministry,”
  • Parker “wanted to boost his own profile” and “It sounded like, from him, that the appointment was not negotiable. The minister wanted to ensure his own interests were promoted.”

  • Also Lyons defends Erin Leigh (who says Trevor Mallard has ruined her reputation and her business) saying he would “rate her one of the top communications professionals I have come across”

  • Lyons says that Trevor Mallard has made  untrue and unfounded claims and “he has misled the House and also the nation,”

The evidence against David Parker is mounting.  Two different employees have said he intervened to get Clare Curran hired for his own political interests.  The SSC inquiry better damn well be interviewing those former staff, and also looking at why no one stood up to the Minister.

Trevor Mallard comes close to deserving to join David Parker in being sacked from Cabinet. Mallard’s vicious slander of Erin Leigh has been refuted by two of her former bosses, plus a former Ministry CEO.  If he does not do a sincere apology in Parliament tomorrow, then he should be sacked.

Espiner on Mallard

And we get a double dose of Colin today – a blog post on Trevor as well as his column on the EFB.

I’m not sure about private prosecutions. Should someone who had nothing to do with an alleged crime be able to prosecute it, even if neither the victim nor the police believe such a prosecution is justified?

So the first question is this: Did police decide against prosecuting Mallard because he is a senior Cabinet minister, or because the offence was considered minor and the victim, Henare, declined to press charges? If it was the former, then McCready may have done us all a favour. If it was the latter, then Mallard is being held to a standard the rest of us are not required to meet.

In Mallard’s case it might well be a case of sauce for the duck, given what a goose the minister has been recently. Environment Ministry whistleblower Erin Leigh reckons her job prospects have been harmed by Mallard’s recent hatchet-job on her in Parliament. It wasn’t a pretty sight and coming so soon after his dust-up with Henare the senior Labour MP came across looking like a bully.

As the Dominion Post newspaper observed recently, it’s clear whatever anger management course Clark sent him on isn’t working. Perhaps a few days in the slammer would clear Mallard’s mind?

Colin probably speaks for a lot of people with his ambivalence.  We all have sympathy for MPs against spiteful prosecutions, but on the other hand seeing Trevor monster Erin Leigh in Parliament and appearing like a bully doesn’t exactly engender sympathy.

An Espiner column

Two pretty balanced pieces from Colin Espiner today.  First his column on the Electoral Finance Bill:

The Electoral Finance Bill will dominate this final sitting and it’s likely to be a grim fight to the death for both sides.

… but this year the Opposition is likely to put up more than its usual token resistance and will drag out the debate on the bill for as long as it possibly can.

And so it should. The bill has potentially far-reaching consequences for the democratic right of opponents of the government to have their say in election year.

Indeed.  I hope National fight the bill for as long as possible.

But despite attempts by Labour to patch up the worst of the bill’s flaws, it remains a shoddy piece of legislation that should be consigned to the dustbin. Even the kindest interpretation of its aims and objectives would still require, as the Electoral Commission itself says,”a law of common sense” to apply.

… There is also no doubt that the debate has been effectively hijacked by Right-wing supporters of National such as David Farrar and John Boscawen, who have even appeared in the media as “independent” commentators, despite one being National’s Wellington Central campaign manager and the other an Act Party fundraiser.

I wouldn’t say hijacked – no one is forced to quote me.  But glad to have been effective on such a good cause.  I actually had no plans at all to oppose the Bill on the basis of what was in the leaked Cabinet Paper.  It is only when it got changed into the monstrosity that got introduced into the House that I decided to oppose the Bill outright rather than just offer amendments.

Labour only has itself to blame, however. It missed a golden opportunity to hold National to an earlier pledge to support the end of secret trusts and Brethren-style campaign tactics by over-reaching itself in a bid to stamp out any anti-government expenditure in an election year.

Indeed.  National should have been on the back foot over the bill, and it is a sign of how incompetent the Government’s handling of this has been, that even the Sunday Star-Times is now saying Kill the Bill.

Regardless of whether this bill has any merit ramming any electoral law through Parliament on a bare majority weeks before it is due to come into force is bad government.

Incredibly bad Government.  Hell they had a four month period for spam laws to come into force, and we now have only 15 working days left this year and no-one has actully seen the final law.  It’s beyond Mickey Mouse.

Labour has already rolled over companion legislation dealing with the funding of parties’ office budgets until after the next election and it should do the same with the bill. Only in the relative calm post-election can these issues be properly debated. In the meantime, the entire lot should be farmed out to a properly constituted Royal Commission of Inquiry. Electoral law is too important to be decided by back-room deals and without the support of the major opposition party.

Indeed.  The electoral law is being written by Helen Clark and Winston Peters in private, plus the Greens.

A very dumb blonde

Progressives did it first!

You Paid For It

 I’m happy to pre-announce the formation of a new resource for election year – the You Paid For It blog.

It will be officially launched on 1 January 2008 to coincide with the start of the soon to be regulated election period.

The idea behind the blog is that we will be encouraging everyone to look out for anything they get sent which has the parliamentary crest on it.  If you see the crest, it means you paid for it.  And we want people to upload, or e-mail or even post in all the material they come across – pamphlets, newsletters, advertisements, pens, banners.  And this applies to all parties and all MPs.

We also will welcome any background details to the scans – how you got it, where it was published, estimated no of copies.

This material may become invaluable – both for public scrutiny of taxpayer funded advertising, but also for any electoral petitions or police prosecutions.

You see the Government has not succeeded in getting a total exemption for parliamentary expenditure under the Electoral Finance Bill.  As they are being forced to clarify Clause 81(2)(g) it means that even if it approved by the Parliamentary Service, it still will have an independent test under the Electoral Act of does it encourage or persuade people to support or not support a party or candidate or type of party or candidate.

Now combined with the extension of the regulated period to all of election year, it means that anything an MP spends on publicity next year *may* be able to be counted as party or candidate expenditure under the Act, even if approved by the Parliamentary Service.  It will have to be seen as encouraging or persuading people to vote, but that is not always clear cut as we saw with the pledge card.

So MPs had better be very careful with spending their $65,000 parliamentary budget.  If $5,000 of that $65,000 they spend ends up classified as election advertising, and they have spent $16,000 directly on the campaign, then bang they have overspent and they are out of Parliament.

Every letter, every advert, every newsletter will be scrutinised for electioneering.  There could be multiple election petitions to get rulings on what is or is not an election advertisement and does it qualify for the parliamentary purposes exemption. Where onece you could avoid this uncertainity by just not spending any of your parliamentary budget on advertising in the last 90 days, now you will have to second guess all your expenditure all year long.

And MPs should also remember the advice of the Solictor-General which is just having part of a publication as electioneering means the whole thing qualifies. So your electorate newsletter might be 95% okay, but just one paragraph can turn it into an election advertisement, and bang there goes your seat.

The sensible thing is to stay with the status quo – a 90 day regulated period where one stops spending your parliamentary budget on advertising and the cap kicks in from the same spot.  It allowed risk to be minimised.  But by extending the regulated period to the whole year, it means everything published by you next year will be open to electoral challenge.  And this new website is designed to record evidence of such taxpayer funded advertising so that anyone who does wish to do electoral challenges, or complaints to the electoral authorities and/or the Police will have the source material to do so.

National recalls DVD

National has put out a press release announcing it has “taken steps to recall and replace copies of a DVD produced and distributed by National, titled ‘Ambitious For New Zealand’.”

The move comes after the Party received a letter from lawyers acting on behalf of record company EMI, who have raised concerns about a musical track used on the DVD.

“Obviously, National relied on the expertise of the production company that put together the video and its soundtrack.

“However, National is now taking steps to recall and replace the DVD.

“We’ll take all available steps to retrieve copies of the DVD which have already been distributed to electorates, and we have replaced it on our website and National’s You Tube channel.

A new version of the DVD will be available shortly.

I blogged my views about this on Saturday. It’s very messy and not a good look. I suppose the bright side is it happened this year not with say the election campaign itself, but it’s an own goal that will hurt. I think I can safely predict it won’t happen again!

It also a testament to the role the blogosphere can play. I suspect EMI would have got around sooner or later to noticing and complaining, but left wing blogs (primarily The Standard) acted quite legitimately in raising the issue, and the fact it has been recalled suggests there was substance to the complaint.

The video has received over 10,000 visits on You Tube before the controversy, so it is a pity that the 20 seconds of music has overshadowed what appears to have been a pretty successful video.  But that’s the nature of it.

Mallard pleads not guilty

NZPA reports:

Trevor Mallard entered a not guilty plea when he appeared in the dock of Wellington District Court today to face a private assault prosecution

A status hearing has been set down for December 18. Also bail in the end was not opposed.

I’m surprised Mallard pleaded not guilty. I would have thought he wants it over and done with. On the other hand by pleading not guilty he forces the prosecution to prove their case, and if there are no first hand witnesses, then it may get thrown out.

As I have said before, I regard the private prosecution as a waste of court time. But citizens have the right to do these things.

mallarddock.JPG

This photo sent in by a reader.

UPDATE: The photo appears to in fact be taken by Kent Blechynden of the Dominion Post. It would be appreciated if in future people do not e-mail me photos taken from media websites, but just e-mail me the link. That way I know who to credit.

Fairbrother beats Nash for Napier nomination

Still in love with the Blackberry Curve

Well I’ve had one for four days now, and am still very much in love with my new toy.  I’ve discovered it has a 1 GB hard drive, so one can still thousands of photos in it before it even gets close to full. Also the camera can do up to a 5x zoom.

The GPS works fine, and is faster than the GPS in my car.  Unlike the car GPS though, no close up maps of NZ are yet available which is a small pain.  Hopefully they will become available before too long.

Getting the e-mail to work was very easy.  Just clicked onto the configure e-mail button, then logged into Blackberry with my existing username and password. It then recognises I have a different blackberry ID, and it asks whether e-mail should now be sent to this new one.  You say yes, and that’s all that is needed.

Yet to try out the video player on it – will try copying a TV show onto it and seeing how well it works.

The Shortland Street killer revealed – probably

Someone leaked onto You Tube three video clips, which are presumably the three versions of revealing  who is the Shortland Street killer.  It is possible it was done deliberately as a PR stunt or they are fakes to mislead.  But having said that, it has long been stated three endings have been filmed, and this is the week the identity is revealed.

I haven’t seen the clips, but they have been discussed at Street Talk, of course.

After the break I’ll link to the thread with the details and summarise the three options:

Continue reading »