Iyomu $1 million challenge update

It’s only a couple of weeks until someone wins the $1 million Iyomu challenge.  A couple of interesting updates.

Nine of the top ten participants have been disqualified for cheating or not following the rules.  This opens the competition up significantly.

Also one smart player has appealed for help, and if he wins he will donate half the prize to charity. A nice move.

Help Protect Ayaan Hirsi Ali

I think most people know who Ayaan Hirsi Ali is.

She lives in real fear for her life.  Sam Harris has set up a way for people to donate to help with her protection.  That’s a good idea.  It would be a tragedy if she is killed, but it would also be tragic if she has to give up her freedom of speech just to stay alive.

NZ drops nine places in climate change index

This should be a major story that exposes the lack of credibility the Government has on climate change.

An annual index of high emitting countries is published, ranking how well they do on the issue of climate change performance. 50% is weighted on the trend of emissions, 30% on their overall level, and 20% on their policies.

In 2007 NZ was in 22nd place out of 56.

In 2008, NZ has plummeted to 31st place out of 56.

NZ has fallen into the bottom half in the last year. In the same year that Helen Clark declared her vision of being the best country in the world – the first carbon neutral country. The Environment Ministry is all pumped up to spend our money next year promoting these fine words.

Except the substance behind the words is a myth.

Falling nine places is the reality.

Hat Tip: Kiwiblogblog

Nine for Christchurch Central

The Press reports there are nine candidates seeking the candidacy for Labour for Christchurch Central.  They probably see it as a seat for life – hence the interest.  The nine are:

  1. Brendon Burns – Former journalist for The Press and former candidate in Kaikoura.
  2. James Caygill – Former political adviser to Prime Minister Helen Clark.
  3. Hine Conner – Labour official.
  4. Eamon Daly – Tetraplegic academic and government adviser.  Stood in 2002 and 2005 also. Also failed to get elected to local community board in 2007.
  5. Erin Ebborn-Gillespie – Christchurch family lawyer. List candidate 2005.
  6. Wayne Hawker – Night-shift baker and Labour fundraiser. Also failed to get elected to local community board in 2007.
  7. Tina Lomax – Community board member and school principal.
  8. Ingrid Stonhill – Former Christchurch City councillor.
  9. Megan Woods – Unsuccessful Christchurch mayoral candidate.

Now remember that unlike National’s selections where 60 local members solely decide the outcome, only seven votes count in Labour selections.

Under their Rule 246 the NZ Council appoints three members of the selection committee, of whom at least one must be a women.

The local LEC elects just two members, of whom again one must be a woman.

Those present at the selection meeting elect one final member to the selection committee.

And then finally after the speeches, those present vote preferentially on their preferred candidate, and this counts as a seventh vote.

Caygill and Burns would both add some obvious talent to the Labour Caucus.

Hopkins on Electoral Finance Bill

Jim Hopkins makes an excellent observation about the Electoral Finance Bill.

Because what our politicians are doing this week is not preventing people from buying an election. They’re actually determining who can buy it. And they’ve very sensibly decided it should be them. While deftly wrapping a gag of red tape around everyone else’s tongue, their bill specifically exempts parliamentarians from its provisions.

Indeed.  It is the hypocrisy which most grates.

In a strange way, the restrictions our glorious leaders are imposing on their surly populace are really quite flattering. They demonstrate that the gummint’s more scared of us than we are of them!

It’s true! They’re terrified. The big people are really just frightened little people, so haunted by the unthinkable thought that the great unwashed will be seduced by the tawdry blandishments of hucksters and ne’er do wells that they’ve built themselves a Maginot Line of regulations heedless of what happened to the last one.

Of course they are scared – scared bullies as we saw with Trevor Mallard attacking Erin Leigh.

So we’re heading for our first Eastern Bloc campaign, only made possible because it’s as easy to steal a national treasure from Parliament as it is from Waiouru’s museum. In different ways, the security in each is equally lax. And the consequences equally sad.

This is the point I made in my post on why I support republicanism.  We need a written constitution to protect our Electoral Act from such partisan hijacking.

Rich as an insult

John Roughan asks a good question:

We are in the last, cantankerous, pre-Christmas weeks of the year. “Scumbag,” Michael Cullen calls across the House to John Key. “Rich prick.”

Rich? What sort of mind regards “rich” as a term of abuse?

The answer seems self evident.

Anderton and Dunne get it wrong on Electoral Finance Bill

The NZ Herald has asked party leaders to explain their positions on the Electoral Finance Bill.

Now Jim Anderton recounts how

“anonymous people bought full-page newspaper advertisements in my electorate, printing lies about me on the day before the election.”

He concludes:

Anyone who opposes the Electoral Finance Bill needs to explain why unfair, anonymous, full-page lies on election eve should be allowed.

Jim obviously has not read the Electoral Finance Bill.  For if he had, he would know the above practice is a corrupt practice in the existing Electoral Act 1993, and will only be a less serious illegal practice in the Electoral Finance Act 2007.

The relevant clauses are s 199A in the Electoral Act and clauses 53 and54 in the Electoral Finance Bill.  Under the current law someone doing the above risked prison and listing on the corrupt practices list.  This law change downgrades to that a maximum $10,000 fine.

Peter Dunne also gets it wrong, again.  He says:

The EFB places similar limits [on how much political parties and individual candidates can spend on election campaigns] on lobby groups promoting a political party during an election campaign.

The limit under the Electoral Act 1993 is $0. The limit under the Electoral Finance Act 2007 will be the same.

Dom Post says Kill the Bill

Thursday’s editorial had a good suggestion:

The purposes of the bill – to provide more transparency and accountability in the democratic process, prevent the undue influence of wealth and promote public participation in parliamentary democracy – are admirable, but the legislation is a dog’s breakfast.

The Government should concede defeat, pull the bill and establish an independent body to overhaul not only the electoral finance laws but the parliamentary spending rules that were the subject of Auditor-General Kevin Brady’s damning inquiry last year.

Such a body would almost certainly conclude that the fairest and simplest solution is to make the system more transparent. Voters are not stupid. If they know where the money is coming from, they know the purposes for which it is being spent.

An independent body would also almost certainly conclude that MPs should not be able to use public funds to subsidise their campaigns, something the recently passed Appropriation (Continuation of Interim Meaning of Funding for Parliamentary Purposes) Act gives them the ability to do.

Contrary to Labour and its allies, most people do not believe the appropriate response to Mr Brady’s inquiry was to make legal, practices that were previously illegal. Rather, it was for MPs to comply with the law as it stood.

The last line is especially true.  Most people who break the law, then have to comply with it in future.  Labour however not only retrospectively changes the law to wipe out their previously illegal behaviour, but also changes it for the next election so they can repeat their illegal acts, legally.

A second wikipedia vandal

A confused lobby group

So what does the Sensible Sentencing Trust think of the proposed Commission of Inquiry into the Justice System?

At 9.51 am their spokesperson Garth McVicar said:

The Royal Commission of Inquiry recommended by the Ombudsman is doomed to failure before it begins

At 9.52 am their other spokesperson Marc Alexander said:

The call by the Ombudsman for a Royal Commission into the criminal justice system is long overdue

So it is a long overdue doomed to failure inquiry that is needed 🙂

I suspect Mr Right Hand and Mr Left Hand are now in talks!

Responsible Drinking

The video is from 42 below about drinking responsibly over the holiday season. To do their part for safe drinking, 42 below are providing chauffeur driven cars from 7 pm to 11 pm to groups of 2 – 3 who between them collect six stamps (one stamp per 42 below drink). So a great way to get home if you’ve been enjoying their product.

Russell Brown and Muldoon

Had a very fun night last night. I had rsvp’d to the Wellingtonista Award Night. The Wellingtonista is a great read – excellent example of a community blog, and always fun. So I figured their awards would be fun, plus Public Address were having a celebrity quiz night set in when Muldoon was Prime Minister era.

I had a incredibly frantic day and was 75% keen to just go home and sleep, but felt guilty that as I had rsvped, that would be impolite. So I went along at 7 pm.

Around five minutes after I got there, Russell Brown comes up to me and says something along the lines of “Sean Plunket can’t be located, so how would you feel about filling in for him”. Now this had a bad case of deja vu. I initially appeared about as enthusiastic as one would be for fire walking, but did ask exactly what role was Sean meant to be playing, and upon learning it was just to be a member of one of the teams, I happily agreed.

The other team, labelled the left team due to their position on the stage, was led by Marion Hobbs. Our team captain was Graham Reid, plus myself and Stephanie.

Russell has the actual questions in the quiz over at Hard News. Go give them a go.

We won the quiz. One section was naming songs from the 1970s played backwards. I couldn’t even get them played forwards but my teammates could. However I did do quite well on the politics section despite being eight when Muldoon took office. It was great fun.

I turned the trophy, a Muldoon toby jug, into my personal drinking vessel for the night. It is truly a hideous thing, and I am going to proudly show it off before returning it 🙂

Was lots of good people at the function I enjoyed catching up with. My only regret is I spent so little time actually talking to the Wellingtonista crew myself – I really do love their blog.

Well done to Public Address, Wellingtonista and sponsors for a good night.

muldoonmug.JPG

Graham and myself with the winning trophy.  It is almost scary!

General Debate 7 December 2007

Pansy for Botany

NZPA reported yesterday that Pansy Wong is seeking the National nomination for Botany.  This is no real secret, and has been fairly widely known for a while.

I am amused by the combination of having a candidate called Pansy for a seat called Botany.

Dim-Post: Capital Coast Health Set to Outsource Healthcare

The Dim-Post returns, from a recent comment in the CCDHB thread:

Capital Coast Health Set to Outsource Healthcare

In a move he promises will ‘revolutionize’ public medicine in New Zealand interim Capital Coast Health Chief Executive Derek Milne has announced that Wellington Hospital will no longer be providing any form of health care services to Wellington residences. Instead the DHB will focus on what Mr Milne referred to as ‘core competencies’.

‘This health board needs to focus on what we can do in areas like construction and facilities management and move away from our negatives such as curing diseases and saving lives,’ Milne told the Dim-Post. ‘This will also allow us to expand into other activities of interest such as m-commerce.’

‘Hiring a team of programmers to build Web 2.0 sites is going to cost a lot less than keeping all these surgeons and specialists on payroll.’

Others have applauded the proposed solution to the problems that plagued the troubled DHB. ‘It’s hard to think of a downside to this,’ said Ministry of Health Director General Stephen McKernan speaking from a conference on Lithuanian sculpture in Mirabel-aux-Baronnies. ‘This will certainly make the Wellington health board easier to administer and budget for so everybody wins.’

Capital Coast board Chairwoman Judith Aitken was doubtful that the famous hospital grounds would continue to be used for medicine or health-care. ‘We will almost certainly outsource those tasks to service providers in South East Asia,’ she said. ‘This will free up the physical assets of the hospital to be converted to apartments and will ensure that when one of your children swallows a bottle of drain-cleaner you’ll enjoy the same high standard of support you receive when your internet connection fails.’

November Kiwiblog Stats

A few observations:

Traffic used to drop away at 5 pm. But now it stays strong until around 10 pm. Midday to 1 pm is marginally busiest with over 50,000 page views. But by 9 pm it is still running at 70% of peak time. Slowest time is 3am to 6 am with only 10,000 page views per hour (being the total for the month). So that is still 300 page views an hour at 3 am! Must be the foreigners.

Now we come to most frequent visitors. And I did something extra this month. I did IP searches with APNIC, RIPE and on the comments database to see who are the most frequent types of visitors. In the past I have published the ones whose servers carry their own name (like most Govt Depts) but people may enjoy who makes up the current top ten:

  1. Parliament (1,000 people) – 7,731 visits
  2. A large computer firm (hundreds of staff) – 4,296 visits
  3. A large PR/Consulting firm (150+ staff) – 3,786 visits
  4. A tertiary institute (5,000+ students) – 3,651 visits
  5. A non profit organisation – 3,479 visits
  6. A US university – 2,678 visits
  7. A Govt Dept – 1,847 visits

Most visited pages:

  1.  /2007/07/preferring_blondes.html
  2. /2007/11/police_terror_evidence_online.html
  3. /2007/11/the_best-laid_plans_of_mice_and_men_often_go_awry.html
  4. /2007/11/herald_exposes_website_poll_hacker.html
  5. /2007/11/legalising_the_pledge_card.html

Most common search terms:

  1. kiwiblog – 5,939
  2. david farrar – 2,103
  3. farrar
  4. kiwi blog
  5. kiwiblog.co.nz
  6. david p farrar
  7. www.kiwiblog.co.nz
  8. electoral finance bill
  9. reasons to stay in iraq
  10. all black jokes
  11. we re here to help
  12. scott watson
  13. nicole begg
  14. cactus kate
  15. australian election results

The Govt’s solution to Capital Coast Health woes – cut 50 doctors

The Government’s Health Ministry has been working with Capital Coast Health to solve those minor problems like mothers new borns dying, and mothers being bribed to go home early.

As anyone reading the Dom Post would know, the proposed solution is to get rid of 50 doctors.

Yes, that will do it.

It reminds me of an episode of Yes Minister.

$40 million and …

Okay the Corrections Department under this Government has spent a whopping $40 million on a new database to help stop prisoners reoffending.

The “integrated offender management” (IOM) system was described by the Corrections Department in 2000 as “the biggest single initiative the department has undertaken to reduce reoffending”.

How has it worked?

  • number of released prisoners being re-imprisoned within two years has increased, from 34.0 per cent when the system started in 2000-01 to 38.8 per cent in the year to June
  • has failed to move the two-year reconviction rate of released prisoners from 55.1% (now at 55.4%) – the rate when the system started.

So why has it failed.  Well Greg Newbold, who has been a prisoner, says why:

“It’s another wreck on the scrapheap of abandoned fads of criminal rehabilitation,” he said.

“They predicted up to a 25 per cent reduction in annual inmate intakes.”

But Dr Newbold, who served seven and a half years in Paremoremo Prison in the 1970s, said he predicted in 2002 that the system would not work because most prisoners, unlike patients, did not want to be “cured”.

“They like the way they are. They want to give up going to jail. They don’t want to give up offending.”

Newbold says that the small minority of prisoners who want to change should be targeted and helped, but that such measures are ineffective for many prisoners.

Relative Spends

NZ First in trouble

NZ First has three traditional areas of support.  They are:

  1. Elderly grey power type voters
  2. Provincial and rural conservatives
  3. Maori

The Herald reports today that their support for the Electoral Finance Bill is going to lose them support from two core groups which have supported them previously – Grey Power and the Sensible Sentencing Trust.

First Grey Power:

Grey Power national vice-president Don Chapman said the organisation was apolitical but he would not be surprised if NZ First loyalists within the organisation’s 95,000 members turned away from the party too.

“I would be very, very surprised if [Mr Peters] was supported, because we are very anti that bill, and the implications that the bill would have on us as an organisation.”

Then the Sensible Sentencing Trust:

Garth McVicar – national spokesman for the Sensible Sentencing Trust … said yesterday: “Our stance will certainly be that we don’t see much point in supporting NZ First any further. I would imagine we’ve got thousands more members than [NZ First] have throughout New Zealand, so I think they’re dead in the water, realistically. I think Winston’s just totally lost the plot.”

And this was in response to Winston saying:

Mr Peters responded that [law and order spokesman] Ron Mark and he had worked closely with Mr McVicar for many years and would continue to do so.

NZ First are killed off if they do not make 5% next election, or win Tauranga back (much harder).  They’ve just pissed off their two biggest supporters which will make their job all the harder.

Dom Post on Erin Leigh

The Dom Post has two good items on the Erin Leigh affair. A blog post written before the Environment Ministry apologised, and an article this morning. First the blog by Dom Post Political Editor Tracy Watkins:

It is easy for those of us who have been here a while to forget just how brutal the political arena can be. Which may explain why Trevor Mallard thought it was okay to set out to destroy the career of a young woman who previously worked at the Environment Ministry and who blew the whistle on alleged political meddling.

… there is a serious imbalance here. Mallard is a minister of the state with huge powers at his disposal to investigate and rebut the allegations made by Leigh. Leigh, on the other hand, has few such resources at her disposal -she is just a young woman, whose most important asset is a career and a professional reputation on which she relies for her livelihood.

… Mallard’s sole intention can only have been to leave Leigh’s reputation and credibility in tatters. How else could you justify labelling someone incompetent and sad? Previous employers have rebutted Mallard claims, defending Leigh as a great worker. But it shouldn’t matter. Maybe she was right; maybe she was wrong. The trick with power sometimes is knowing when to just turn the other cheek.Prime Minister Helen Clark passed up the opportunity yesterday to say sorry to Leigh, defending Mallard’s attack as “mild by his standards”.

Mild by a politician’s standards, maybe – but for a young woman like Leigh, far more brutal than anything she is capable of dishing up.

Even worse, was the PM laughing about it. The sisterhood only extends so far.

Then we have today’s article by Martin Kay. Note the harsh (but justified) language used by the Dom Post, describing what Mallard did as smearing:

Environment Minister Trevor Mallard will not apologise for smearing former ministry worker Erin Leigh after he misread advice about her performance.

Mr Mallard said yesterday he would not say sorry after he used parliamentary privilege to wrongly brand Ms Leigh as incompetent – despite Environment Ministry boss Hugh Logan saying that a briefing on her work was not meant to reflect poorly on her.

This is a classic example of third termitis. Of course Mallard should apologise, but the Government is at the stage where it is obsessed with proving itself “right” on an issue, rather than simply apologising.

UPDATE: Also read John Armstrong on this topic:

So why not say you’re sorry, Mr Mallard? The Minister for the Environment should have issued a unqualified apology for wrongly maligning whistle-blower Erin Leigh the instant he was given the highly embarrassing news yesterday that his questioning of her competence had been based on inappropriate advice from his ministry.

Mr Mallard should have apologised to set the record straight in Parliament and avoid a potential breach of privilege case. He should have done so to silence the National Party. And he should have done so for his own sake.

That he has not done so – and that his Beehive colleagues are not insisting he do so – suggests he and they have lost grip of their senses.

… Mr Logan might be on the way out. Mr Mallard might go the same way if he is not careful.

As a minimum, he needs to set the record straight in Parliament. He did so when previously supplied with wrong information. What is so different this time?

His unwillingness to say “sorry” may reflect advice that he concede nothing in case Ms Leigh seeks damages for defamation. But the ministry has already admitted fault by saying the briefing note could be interpreted in an adverse way.

Mr Mallard might be looking for a way out of politics. That analysis might be completely wrong. But his behaviour has more than a touch of the political death-wish about it – his refusal to apologise seemingly just another example of that syndrome.

If Trevor has a political death-wish, who are we to stop him?

National Caucus Party

The annual year end National Caucus Party was last night, and it was a great night.  Somehow I was again one of the last to leave but it was at a fairly respectable bit before 2 am.

They had a band instead of the traditional karaoke, which might be why things didn’t drag on quite so late as some years. But I enjoyed the change to the band.

I was surprised by the number of former senior Beehive staffers (who worked for the current Government) who were there – I think they can sniff the wind.  In fact everyone there was in a pretty buoyant mood.

Had good attendances from the minor parties – lots there from the Maori Party,NZ First, United Future, Act and the Greens.  It’s actually one of the things I love most about these events – you have really great discussions with people even though you disagree with them on lots of things – it’s much more fun than talking to people who agree with you.  For that reason I always enjoy chatting to the Green MPs and staff.

I’ve noted you can almost classify people into two groups when it comes to drinking.  There’s that very small minority who get aggressive and become arseholes and try to pick arguments.  But there’s the vast majority who just get relaxed, happy, friendly and you just have a great time talking to them.

For reasons of self preservation (and manners), I don’t go into detail about what people say, or what happened.  But I will make the observation that some of Labour’s support parties are very very unhappy with them over how they have handled the Electoral Finance Bill.

One funny event was when some of the MPs were trying to persuade a former MP to come into the House and seek the call on the Electoral Finance Bill, and see if the Speaker/Chairman actually twigged on.  The plan wasn’t executed but it would have been hilarious to see it attempted.

It was a pretty large turnout.  As well as the MPs and staff, you have press gallery and other journalists. a few former staff like me, some former MPs, lots of people from various industry groups, some lobbyists, MPs and staff from other parties which are not deemed to be enemies (ie all parties except Labour and Progressive) and a few others.  Again it is part of what makes it such a good night – so many people to talk to – you end up having conversations on every topic from Shortland Street to Treasury fiscal projections of revenue, to media gossip, to republicanism, to the Electoral Finance Bill.

Greens admit law is an abortion

The Greens have just released their amendments, being a Supplementary Order Paper setting up a review of the law, just two months after it comes into force!!!!

What a total admission that this law is a bad bad flawed law.  You normally review laws three to five years after they come into force, or at least after the election.  But the Greens are implicitly admitting the law is so bad we need to start writing the new one in two months time.

Haven’t critics always said this law is designed for one election only – to get Helen Clark her 4th term.

Also very disappointing to see the Greens have failed to put up an amendment to abolish anonymous donations.  They’ve done a dirty deal with Labour to allow Labour to keep its anonymous donations.

The Green SOP is here.  The review panel and the citizen’s jury have to report back by December 2008 – what a farce – to report back on the law before you’ve even had time to run an election under it.

What the Greens are proposing should have been done in 2006 or early 2007. I personally fully support the idea of an independent review panel and also a citizen’s assembly to help with public participation.  In fact I have been an advocate of this since before the EFB was even tabled in Parliament.

But’s it’s insane to launch a review 60 days after the law is passed. 

Also I have to say I do not think Labour can be trusted one iota with setting up a true independent review.  It should not be appointed by the Minister of Justice.  Can you imagine who Mark Burton would have appointed – himself, Pete Hodsgon and Mike Williams probably.  You need to do it properly with full multi-party support.

The independent review panel needs to be appointed by Parliament as a whole – probably using the old formula of over 50% of the parties and 75% of the MPs as a minimum level of agreement.  The same applies to setting up the processes around a Citizen’s Jury.  There are massively important questions around who advises them, who sets the agenda.  It can’t be a partisan Minister, who is part of a Government which has lied and lied repeatedly about the Electoral Finance Bill.

Any panel appointed unilaterally by Annette King and her helpers will have no credibility.  It must have multi-party agreement on its composition and related issues.  And it should not and can not properly do its job in the middle of an election campaign.

What I’d like to see is after the election, National work with the Greens and other parties to indeed appoint an independent panel or even royal commission, and have a citizen’s jury as part of that. 

Environment Ministry apologies to Erin Leigh

Trevor Mallard and Helen Clark won’t apologise to Erin Leigh, but the Environment Ministry has.  Just been e-mailed a PR from them which says:

I am concerned that written material provided to the Minister in preparation for a question in the House led to a reflection on the work of Ms Erin Leigh in 2005/06 that was not intended by the Ministry.

Ms Leigh, a professional communications consultant, was contracted in 2005 by the Ministry. Her contract was renewed three times. In May 2006 she notified the Ministry that she was ending her contract and ceased work. At the time the Ministry accepted this without seeking any further explanation, and paid all contract fees billed to it.

Ms Leigh had completed a number of projects under the four contracts. Her media work was professional and of good quality, especially work that she did in respect of the Waitaki Water Allocation Board of Inquiry.

The climate change work on which she was engaged, with other Ministry personnel, was not yet concluded and was subsequently completed by others.

Two weeks ago the Ministry was asked to provide the Minister with information on her work and her departure. Under time limitations, a briefing note was prepared from internal records and provided to the Minister.

As Chief Executive, I was responsible for that briefing. I did not take it or intend it to reflect on Ms Leigh’s professional ability or her performance under contract to the Ministry.

The events which have followed show that the note could be, and was, interpreted in this adverse way. In particular, the Minister understood it in that way, with public and personal consequences for Ms Leigh and for the Ministry.

Because these events were connected with an investigation that had already been initiated by the State Services Commissioner, I initially considered that there should not be a separate public response.

I now consider that there should have been a Ministry response and so I am releasing this statement. Because Ms Leigh has not agreed to the public release of the briefing note, the Ministry will not be releasing it with this statement.

Both personally and on behalf of the Ministry I apologise for what has occurred, and I regret the public attention which has been generated.

Hugh Logan
Chief Executive

I suspect Logan has had furious staff demanding the Ministry now stay silent.  They know that if Mallard got away with it, any of them could be professionally destroyed in the same way. 

Greens vote to outlaw anonymous advocacy on the Internet

The Electoral Finance Bill defines an election advertisement as pretty much anything in written (and electronic) form which advocates for or against a party.  There is an exemption in Clause 5(2)(g) for blogs which reads:

The publication by an individual, on a non-commercial basis, on the Internet of his or her personal political
views (being the kind of publication commonly known as a blog).

The problem is, it only excludes blogs.  If they had said “(for example the kind of …) then it wouldn’t.  Anyway Chris Finlayson put up an amendment to change the exemption to simply say: 

The publication by an individual, on a non-commercial basis, on the Internet of his or her personal political views.

Surely no one would object to that?  Do we really want personal political views on the Internet made into election advertisements which need a name and address attached to them.

But alas, the amendment was defeated.  Those great champions of human rights overseas – the Greens and United Future, voted against the amendment.