Muldoon Alert, Muldoon Alert

From the House yesterday:

Rt Hon HELEN CLARK: For obvious reasons, I seldom agree with Fran O’Sullivan. My job is to act in relation to Cabinet responsibility issues, not to initiate investigations into the actions of members of Parliament. However, if members opposite want to tempt me, there is always the possibility of investigations into Nick Smith’s contempt of court, Gerry Brownlee’s act of assault, or whether Mr Groser still uses cannabis.”

Oh come on Helen, next step is to threaten to release the SIS files and you’re there. BTW I think Nandor uses cannabis also!

Hat Tip: Keeping Stock

Net Debt

One of the more ridicolous arguments against reducing the level of over-taxation is that NZ needs to fund all of its capital expenditure out of operating income, and if we do not we will have a debt problem.  Let’s look at a history of debt in NZ.

netdebt.JPG

Okay, now this shows net core crown debt over the last 35 years.  First thing to note is that the debt has never been lower – even lower than early 70s.

We see the damage Muldoon did with his deficits, with net debt increasing to 30% of GDP.  So we owed one third the annual production of the entire economy. Then we had Labour, and they may have done some things right, but a balanced budget wasn’t one of them.  Net debt rose to around 50% of GDP.  Now that is a damn scary level.  If interest rates are 10%, then 5% of GDP goes just on interest.  And you don’t even want to think about what net debt as a proportion of Govt expenditure was.

Then we had National and National led Governments.  A failure to reduce the debt would have been a disaster, but they took the hard calls, and and in nine years achieved what once would have been thought impossible and cut net debt from 50% to 20% of GDP.

Now in eight years of Dr Cullen, debt has fallen further, though not as fast as under National. Now it is a lot easier to continue a trend already there, than reverse a trend, but Dr Cullen has certainly not let the side down. And today we basically are debt free.  As at 30 June a miniscule 2.1% of GDP, and if you take the money in the NZS Fund into account, we actually have negative debt of 5.9% of GDP.  We can all agree that NZ (Govt) does in no way at all have a debt problem.

Now this is not a licence to start running huge operating deficits and having debt blow up again.  But, if one has a large (in fact gigantic) operating surplus, basically zero debt, and a capital works programme that gets funded over time out of depreciation and interest, there is no sensible argument that one can not afford to reduce taxation.

Of course one will get many unsensible arguments.  I am sure someone could argue that we should actually build up a $500 billion cash stockpile in case we ever all get sick, or need to invade Australia, or want to pre-fund the next three generation’s worth of health care.  You can always, always find a reason not to give people their money back.

But arguing that NZ Govt has a debt problem is not one of them.

I would also remind people that National managed to reduce debt as a % of GDP by 30%, and reduce taxes.

Oh and before the usual suspects jump in and warn of the disasters that will occur if tax rates are reduced,  make sure you leave wriggle room to argue that tax cuts are in fact a good thing when Dr Cullen announces some next year.  Also be prepared to denounce tax cuts again if Labour wins in 2008 and then cancels the promised tax cuts in 2009.

In fact it would just be easier if you took the approach of arguing that whatever Dr Cullen says is the right level of taxation, is ipso facto, automatically the right level of taxation. Nice and simple that way.

Treasury Projections

An argument one often hears to try and convince people, that we shouldn’t get some of our taxes back, is that yes we had a big surplus this year, but hey look at the projections for future years – that surplus won’t be so large.

So let us review the history of Treasury projections of the Operating Balance or surplus.

The 2003/04 surplus was $7.4 billion. It was originally forecast to be $3.2 billion.

The 2004/05 surplus was $5.8 billion.  It was originally forecast to be $2.7 billion.

The 2005/06 surplus was $11.5 billion.  It was originally forecast to be $4.2 billion.

The 2006/07 surplus was $8.7 billion.  It was originally forecast to be $6.2 billion.

Now to be fair to Treasury, forecasting the income and expenditure for an entire country is damn hard.  Hell it can be hard to forecast earnings for a single company, let alone all of them.  Nevertheless their conservatism is starting to affect the credibility of the forecasts.

I’m more forgiving of a $6 billion change from an initial forecast four years out, to an actual than a smaller change over a smaller time period.  But let’s look at how the forecasts for 06/07 have changes over the years:

May 2003 = $6.2 billion
May 2004 = $5.1 billion
May 2005 = $5.3 billion
May 2006 = $5.8 billion
Dec 2006 = $6.3 billion
May 2007 = $6.6 billion
June 2007 = $8.7 billion (actual)

Yes the surplus to 30 June was $2.1 billion higher than when the Budget came out in May.

Now this year’s surplus was forecast in the BEFU to be $6.4 billion.  That means it could well be over $9 billion, which would make the surplus over five years  exceed $40 billion.

Dom Post on Tax Cuts

Some useful quotes from today’s editorial:

What it is proof of is that his Government is over-taxing New Zealanders, a bad practice that insulates ministers and officials from spending mistakes – because they can be written off without consequence – and makes individuals more dependent upon the state.

Treasury’s view that the state is on a “structurally higher” revenue track than previously believed makes some sort of announcement about tax cuts almost inevitable in next year’s Budget, which conveniently falls just a few months before the election. But, if past experience is anything to go by, the amounts involved will be small and the wait to receive them long. This is not a government that relishes relinquishing its grip on individuals’ wallets. Previously it has argued that returning surplus revenue to those who earned it would fuel inflation, a self-serving argument that has encouraged ministers and officials to bid opportunistically for the surplus cash.

Dr Cullen has previously argued that he does not need a tax cut. Given his $255,000 salary as deputy prime minister and the generous superannuation fund waiting for him in retirement it is difficult to disagree with him.

But there is a world of difference between earning $4900 a week and $1150 – the amount earned by someone on a $60,000 salary.

I would also observe that Dr Cullen doesn’t need taxpayer funded superannuation, yet he is happy enough to take that, yet not happy to give tax cuts, on the basis he personally doesn’t need them.  Somewhat inconsistent.

Peters cornered

That’s the headline in The Press.

It is very clear Peters misled Parliament.  He should admit he did so, and apologise.  To be fair to him, it wasn’t a deliberate lie, but a failing from his private office.  But the Minister is 100% responsible for their office.

Here is what Peters was asked in August:

Parliament’s records on August 16 show that McCully had asked Peters if he could assure Parliament that “at no stage did any ministry official communicate any information to him or his office about the planned Air New Zealand charters”.

And it is clear as daylight that a ministry official did communicate information to his office.

One does wonder what proportion of reports do not get read by anyone in the Minister’s office?  It is certainly not standard practice in most offices.

A victory for common sense

Well done to all the parties which have forced the Government to back down on the Births, Deaths, Marriages and Relationships Amendment Bill.

The Bill would have basically removed public access to the births, deaths and marriages registers.  While the motivation was stopping identity theft (which it would not stop), it would also have stopped journalists being able to verify claims from individuals, and massively affected historians, biographers etc.

This is not a minor change.  Barker had refused for months and months to make common sense changes.  But lacking the numbers to proceed, they have been forced to listen to the public.

It’s a very unsexy topic, but an important principle – public access to information.

Herald on Iraq

The Herald reports on how National quoted Mark Burton and Phil Goff back at Phil Goff who is still trying to muster fake outrage at John Key’s comment.

So Clark, Peters, Goff and Burton have all referred to the Iraq war as having concluded.  Which is just as well, because if it hadn’t concluded then Helen Clark would have been guilty of having participated in the Iraq War through the troops she sent to Iraq in 2003/2004.

Can’t even say their name

A reader has pointed out to me that Cullen’s irrational hatred of tax cuts is so intense that he can’t even refer to them directly.  Hence his statement:

“there is certainly fiscal headroom for the Government to engage in either further spending or revenue reduction”.

Revenue reduction.  Hmm.  You mean like cutting tax?  You mean like letting people keep more of their own money?

Che = Pinochet

I’m amused by the fact Che Guevara is idolised by many on the left, as he seems to be the equivalent of General Pinochet – someone who may have done some useful stuff initially, but whose human rights record at the end of the day made them an embarrassment.

Wikipedia reminds us he oversaw the extra-judicial executions of 156 to 550 people. He also praised North Korea as “a model to which revolutionary Cuba should aspire”.

Capital punishment

Some excitement and moral superiority feelings over the fact that we are backing a UN resolution asking for all countries to stop using the death penalty. This will have as much impact as most UN resolutions of course.

I don’t support use of the death penalty, but tend to think we have better things to do that tell other countries how to run their justice systems.  But anyway it is interesting to look at who does still use it, and how.

According to Wikipedia, 90 countries have totally abolished it, 11 only have it for incredibly rare stuff such as war time treason, 32 have it in theory but not in practice, and 64 still have it and use it. That’s around one third of the197 countries.

But six countries account for 91% of executions, and China alone accounts for 65%.  And if Amnesty is right the actual level in China might be a magnitude higher than officially reported.

NZ chalked up a fairly large 85 executions until they were abolished.  84 men and Minnie Dean. Also 84 of them were for murder.  Who knows what the other was for?

Also did you know one of the people executed in NZ murdered his pregnant girlfriend by burying her alive in the Mt Vic Tunnel site, where he was working?

Surpluses

I’ll do a more detailed analysis late tonight or tomorrow on the surpluses.  But what happens if we add today’s $8.7 billion surplus to those of the last three years.

Total surpluses = $33 billion, 807 million (source: Crown Financial Statements)

Total households = 1,393,707 (source: 2006 Census)

Surplus/Household = $24,256.89

So that is how much per household the Government has taken in taxation than it has spent on operating expenditure these last four years.

Now not all of that would be available in terms of tax relief. One does have to cover the Cullen Fund contributions (until Kiwisaver is big enough to replace it).  I’ll do an estimate later on how much tax could have been reduced by, if there wasn’t an ideological hatred of reducing the tax burden.

Connell retires

Few were surprised today when Brian Connell announced he would not contest the next election.  Putting aside his suspension from Caucus, his seat has basically disappeared.

That opens up one more spot for new candidates.  National has a reasonable chance of picking up ten or more new MPs, plus replacement for Blumsky and Connell.

September Public Poll

There were a record eight public polls in September.  TVNZ, TV3, Fairfax, NZ Herald and UMR all had a poll each, and there were three Morgan polls.

Curia’s monthly newsletter summarising the public polls in New Zealand, and overseas, will be out later today.  It’s a big edition.  You can subscribe to receive it by e-mail at this link.

sep07polls1.JPG

The average gap between National and Labour closed from 17% to 12%.  Still an election winning margin, but  less comfortable than in August.  Almost most polls were taken earlier in September.

Herald Scores

In an offline article, the Herald scores the exchanges yesterdays:

Rich 10 vs Maharey 1 (go Katherine!)

English 5 vs Cullen 5

Hodgson 7 vs Ryall 3

Key 3 vs Clark 3 (and Field 5)

Total: Nats 21 to Labour  16

They cover Clark’s defence of her statement that all Taito Phillip Field is probably guilty of, is trying to be helpful to someone.  She says:

“That statement was made very early in the piece and long before the Ingram report came out”

Now this may be true (which doesn’t let her off but putting that to one side), but the real damning thing is that Michael Cullen said almost exactly the same thing, and he said it after the Ingram Report came out.

Of course as Field himself said, he is innocent until proven guilty.  But if he is found guilty, Labour will be reminded of how they spent months and months defending him.

Was the Human Rights Commission censored?

I wondered why the Human Rights Commission did not make an oral submission on the Electoral Finance Bill, considering the strength of their written submission?

Well from this question in Parliament yesterday, it sounds like they did wish to appear but the Committee refused to hear from them!!

Christopher Finlayson: Does the chairperson agree with her colleague the Hon Steve Maharey, who said: “I am looking forward, of course, to the Human Rights Commission getting a chance to talk through its submission with the select committee.”; if so, why did she ensure that the members of the Human Rights Commission were not able to present oral evidence to the committee, where no doubt they would have voiced their strong opposition to the bill?

If this is correct, it is beyond outrageous. And can anyone think that the Committee is going to seriously consider the merits of the arguments, if it refuses to hear from the most important and damning critic – the Human Rights Commission. Hey let’s flush those human rights down the toilets without even hearing from them.

Up until very recently, the lack of an oral hearing would have meant the criticism from the Human Rights Commission would never ever have been public. Media tend to only report on oral submissions. But because all the written submissions were placed on the parliamentary website, and because bloggers took the time to go through all 575 submissions highlighting important ones, that their submission even became public.

I look forward to hearing defenders of the Government explain how it was a good thing that the Human Rights Commission were stopped from making an oral submission. Maybe it was so Mark Burton could continue to insist they are all wrong:

Christopher Finlayson: Does the Minister disagree with the submission of the *New Zealand Law Society when it said: “The bill seems to be inconsistent with the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 as it limits freedom of expression in a way that cannot be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.”; if so, on what grounds does he disagree with the Law Society?

Hon MARK BURTON: I do disagree with the Law Society.

Christopher Finlayson: Does the Minister disagree with the written submission of the Human Rights Commission, which states that “the inroads on freedom of expression which will result from the Bill are disproportionate and. in the Commission’s opinion, do not amount to reasonable justification under s.5 of the BoRA”; if he does, on what grounds does he disagree with the Human Rights Commission?

Hon MARK BURTON: … Secondly, I rely on Crown Law advice, which differs from that opinion.

So everyone is wrong, and just to make sure they are wrong we won’t allow them to be heard in public.

[UPDATE: It is possible that the HRC did not explicitly ask to make an oral submission, and that what happened is that a member of the Select Cmte moved that they be invited to appear, and this was refused by the Committee.  It is not unusual to have such invites extended – for example I understand the HRC was asked to appear on the sedition bill even though they did not even make a written submission]

Espiner on Labour hypocrisy

I was expecting yesterday in the House to be a bloodbath, but from the sounds of it Labour overplayed their hand, and National got some useful shots away on Field, Air New Zealand and the Electoral Finance Bill.  A draw is what one journalist called it.

In terms if private sector involvement, Colin Espiner makes some observations:

The way Labour’s senior ministers are beginning to sound, the involvement of any private enterprise whatsoever in the state sector is becoming as heretical as the Catholic Church embracing Islam.

Isn’t this the Government that … passed legislation specifically enabling the formation of PPPs in the transport sector?

Isn’t this the same Government that frequently enters into its own public-private arrangements with sponsors for big events?

It’s certainly the same Government, as National’s education spokeswoman Katherine Rich pointed out in the House today, that is quite happy to let private providers virtually run the early childhood sector, own the buildings of around 300 state schools and 100 private schools, and build and own the Ministry of Education’s headquarters in Wellington.

Rich also served Education Minister Steve Maharey’s pious whingeing about PPPs right back at him, with a lovely quote dredged up from Trevor Mallard speaking to the devil incarnate itself – the New Zealand Infrastructure Council – last November.

“We want to see more action,” Mallard enthused to the assembled developers and financiers that make up the council. “And there is a more important issue than whether new construction is privately or publicly funded. The Government is open-minded about the use of public-private partnerships.”

Oh really? Well, until it becomes politically expedient to say otherwise, anyway.

Another reminder of how two-faced Labour is becoming on the private sector came from National’s deputy Bill English in Parliament today, who reminded Finance Minister Michael Cullen that despite his new-found aversion to selling state assets, the Government appeared to need a process to protect the sale of sensitive Crown land.

“It may come as a shock to the member to know that the Crown has been selling and buying land since approximately 1840,” Cullen replied, before realising he’d effectively made English’s point.

Private contractors and companies work in every facet of government and the public sector, from the self-employed muffin lady at the Department of Work and Income to the private software developers working with the Ministry of Education to put computer-assisted learning programmes in schools.

The public education system pays private schools to educate thousands of New Zealanders and couldn’t cope if the network fell over tomorrow. Ditto the public health sector, which would be lost without the network of independent GPs, specialists, private hospitals, and surgeons that the state pays to meet the services that the public system is too stretched to provide.

Sure, there’s arguments over how far it should all go. But don’t let Labour fool you into thinking that somehow National wants to take the country in “a radical new direction” as Steve Maharey said in Parliament today. Most of National’s policies to date are actually incredibly mild, and certainly no different to what happens in the UK, or Australia, or Canada, or any other social-democratic Western country with which we like to compare ourselves.

I’v quoted so much of Colin’s article I probably owe him royalties.  Good to see him linking to source material such as oral questions also – a real feature of blogging.

Colins’ final words are also worth noting – for both National and Labour:

National’s big mistake has been doing such a lousy sales job on those policies, but there are signs that it is finally taking the argument back to Labour. It’ll be interesting to see just how far the Government wants to push this.

Besides risking accusations of scare-mongering, it’s probably seriously annoying the business community, which won’t take kindly to being portrayed as some sort of rapacious beast intent on asset-stripping the state sector. OK, sure, that has happened a couple of times in the past actually – the sale of Telecom springs to mind. But to argue that the private sector doesn’t have some expertise that can be used for the benefit of all is – well, socialist, I guess.

And that’s fine. It’s a legitimate political philosophy with a proud pedigree, if somewhat chequered in practice. But I doubt Labour in 2007 would accept such an epithet. Which is why I can detect a certain whiff of a word beginning with ”H” around the Beehive at the moment. It’s a word which you’re not allowed to use in Parliament but I can here – hypocrisy.

Indeed.  The same word applies to the fury over Key saying the war in Iraq was over – statements Clark has also made.

At the Mount

Flew in to Tauranga last night.  Near disaster when I discovered my rental car booking has disappeared into the ether, but managed to steal a car and got to try out the GPS.  It really is simple – just plug in and it works.

I’m staying at the end of Mt Maunganui, very close to the beach.   Is somewhat weird being here without the place overflowing – my previous visits have been over summer holidays. The last time I was here, I split my head open by accidentally head butting a tree.  Yes it was New Year’s Eve!

By coincidence, Lewis Holden was also in Tauranga, so we caught up for a drink on Maunganui Street and plotted the death of the Queen.  No, no, I mean we plotted what we would do once the Queen dies, not bring that date forward 🙂

All Black Jokes

Heard about the All Blacks new bra? All support but no cup.

What’s the difference between the All Blacks and an arsonist? An arsonist woouldn’t waste five matches.

What do you call 15 guys sitting around the T.V watching the Rugby World Cup final? The All Blacks

What’s the difference between Graham Henry and Viagra?
At least Viagra gives you a semi.

Graham Henry gets handed a mobile phone and is told “this is Wayne Barnes’s phone”, Henry says “how did you know”, the reply is “it had 15 missed calls”

What’s the difference between a tea-bag and the All Blacks?
A Tea Bag stays in the cup longer

Hat Tip: Red Confectionary

Add your own jokes in the comments.

Peter’s Office did know about Air NZ flight

Documents released under the OIA show that Winston Peter’s office was informed about the Air New Zealand flights to Kuwait.

It’s one thing when the Ministry has not informed the Minister’s Office.  Then the Department is at fault.

But I say some apologies are due to Simon Murdoch.  At least one if not two staff in the Minister’s office were informed as they signed for receipt of the information. Any failing on their part to inform the Minister reflects on the Minister (it is his office) not the Ministry.

New Toy

Yay, I am now the proud owner of a Street Pilot c320 GPS system.

I’m about to hit the road again for another five days, so will be a great investment.  Much easier than printing off Google Maps for all my destinations.

Tomorrow we find out how much we were over-taxed

The accounts for the last financial year (to 30 June) get released tomorrow.  The surplus is looking to be so embarrasingly large, that there is a lockup so that journalists can be educated as to why it isn’t really that large.

Remember this is the Government which cancelled the chewing gum tax cuts.

Treasury forecasts, once again, look to be incredibly conservative.  Plus of course Dr Cullen sticks in billions of contingencies.

Iy might not be practical, but wouldn’t it be great if at the end of the financial year, the Government just automatically refunded any surplus (above that needed for Cullen fund etc) to taxpayers.

Dear Taxpayer,

In the last financial year the Government received $4 billion more than it needed.  Rather than keep this money, we are returning it to those who were accidentally over-taxed.  

Hence please find attached a refund cheque for $1,800 as your share of the over-taxation.

Yours faithfully

 

David Farrar
Minister of Finance

Except the actual figure looks to be far more than $4 billion.  We will find out tomorrow.

Joschka Fischer on the Greens

Joschka Fischer was the German Foreign Minister for seven years, and Germany’s most popular politician during that time.

Like many Greens he started off as a communist.

Reason Magazine reports that his recent memoir he “has bitterly attacked the party, warning it would face collapse if it returned to its left-wing pacifist roots.

Since losing power in 2005, the Greens have become a minor opposition party. In an attempt to regain a higher profile, the party has shifted leftwards and begun a heated debate about the country’s military role in Afghanistan.

But Mr Fischer warned yesterday that the party would face “complete political collapse” if it continued on such a course. “If the Greens think they can restore their profile as a leftwing protest party without paying a heavy price, they are deluding themselves. Our support comes from the centre ground,” he said.

Fischer convinced the Greens to support NATO action in Kosovo to protect the locals from Serbia.

McGee confirmed as Ombudsman

The Speaker has confirmed that Clerk of the House David McGee, will take up an appointment as an Ombudsman on 19 November.  This has been supported by all parties in Parliament.

McGee has been Clerk for 22 years and served in the Office of the Clerk for over 33 years.

I blogged back on the 13th of September that he was an outstanding choice to be an Ombudsman.

Parliament on Live TV

Crime and Gun Laws

Blair Mulholland compares the NZ crime rate to Texas, and concludes that with the exception of homicides, other crimes are halved, due to the fact “victims” may be armed. Homicides are four times as high though.

Now putting aside for one moment the difference between correlation and causation, let’s assume that if had had no gun laws, we would have Texan levels of crime, instead of NZ levels.  We’ll also assume we use the same definition for a crime.

What this would mean for NZ, is 176 more people murdered each year, but 992 less rapes, and 28,832 less violent crimes.

Would this be an acceptable trade off?

Personally I don’t think so, unlike Blair.