Venezuela now most corrupt
Tim Blair reports that Transparency International has found Venezuela to now be the most corrupt country in Latin America.
At the Auckland Koru Club yesterday, I ran into Michael Laws. Now this was actually the first time we had met since Michael got me arrested around 13 or 14 years ago. And by coincidence my company had also just done a poll for his local newspaper on the Wanganui Mayoralty.
Ended up having a lively and enjoyable chat for half an hour or so on everything from polls to Young Nationals to the Laws Watch blog to the arrest. Michael was very amused that I did not in fact know I had broken the law yet alone was the subject of a Police manhunt until I turned on the 6pm news in a ski lodge. He’s actually seen the faxes commemorating it at the Backbencher and offered to be the guest of honour at the 15 year anniversary. We had the arresting officer (who happened to be Michael’s neighbour) as the guest of honour at the first anniversary.
Tim Blair reports that Transparency International has found Venezuela to now be the most corrupt country in Latin America.
Eleanor Bishop in Salient has a good review of the Hollow Men play.
I’ve been meaning to go myself but someone told me its all sold out. Anyone know if this is the case and when the season closes?
As I know most of the people the play is about, I’m intrigued by how they are being portrayed and whether it is close to reality.
Auckland Mayor Dick Hubbard and Newmarket Business Association Head Cameron Brewer can’t agree on the relative lengths of Queen Street to Broadway, so Cameron has challenged the Mayor to a $1 million wager on the issue.
Dean Knight blogs that having local body advertising such as Wellington City’s IntensCITY week celebration should not happen so close to the local body elections, as it can advantage the incumbents.
Dean is right, and also (perhaps unwittingly) provides the rationale for the old 90 day period for central Government elections.
Traditionally, in the last 90 days, you:
If you get rid of the 90 day period, then you are in a weaker position to say hey that government advertising campaign shouldn’t be happening. Because it is silly to suggest there can be no govt advertising all election year, but it is quite reasonable to restrict it in the lead up to an election.
I’ve been flat out this week so only now got to clear the moderation queue. 185 comments held of which 173 are spam and 12 genuine comments which have now appeared.
I now just need to find the time to sort through the moderator applications!
The Herald reports that Labour has extended the deadline for MPs to declare if they are standing again, after few of them took the hints and announced their retirements. They’er now going to try again after the Ministerial reshuffle.
Hawkins and Robertson can hold on to their seats for near life I suspect. But Barker and Fairbrother may struggle as they need a winnable list place. Labour in the past has protected all its MPs – will they do it again this time?
The boundary changes have shifted the paper majorities for National and Labour from 31-31 to 34-29 for National. Other seats like Otaki are very vulnerable – Labour could drop down to 25 seats if effective local campaigns are held. On the plus side that will give more spots on the list!
Half Done has a nice quote from the submission from Matthew Hooton:
The Committee may also like to note that the Bill’s proposed spending limits of $60,000 in 2007 dollars would be just $18,024.71 in 1981 dollars. It would be extraordinary for the Committee to argue that the anti-apartheid movement should have been limited to this amount in 1981. It is noteworthy that not even the Government of Sir Robert Muldoon sought to clamp down on the anti-apartheid movement to this degree.
Indeed. The Clark bill will be admired by authoritarians around the world as something theymight try and do, if she gets away with it.
The Dom Post reports on the resignation and then un-resignation of the Chairman of the Monarchist League.
Goodness knows how a group can get so worked up about just taking part in a debate.
Hat Tip: Lewis Holden
The Dominion Post has joined the trend of press gallery bloggers and set up a group blog for their four gallery staff. It’s called Inside the Beltway.
Their latest entry reviews how John Key and Winston Peters did on Game of 2 Halves. They did both do well, even though Winston at first looked uncomfortable, but he warmed up, doing best in the head to head. John’s team won by one point though so it was a good close game.
Big News notes that Madeleine Setchell has been hired as a Communications Manager for Victoria University. Hopefully this is the last time her career will be a matter of public interest.
We are of course all still awaiting the Hunn report into how both the State Services Commissioner and the Environment Ministry CEO “forgot” that David Benson-Pope had told the CEO that if she remained a staff member he could not have free and frank discussions with the Ministry.
No one should be surprised that National sees a bigger role for the private sector in some areas. The differing views on the role of the private sector lie at the heart of the differences between left and right.
I certainly don’t see the private sector as the enemy. The hysterical cries of profiteering and privatisation are no substitute for analysis.
Even in the most core state areas such as Defence, one has private sector involvement. The Navy don’t build their own ships, the army don’t make their own guns.
As Colin Espiner reports in The Press, Labour itself trumpeted with great fanfare legislation to enable public-private partnerships. Of course the rhetoric hasn’t been matched by substance.
In any area of public involvement, there are a number of sub-areas. Such as:
Now the state almost always set the policy. There are some exceptions – industry self-regulation happens in some areas, but under an overall public policy framework and/or laws.
Who funds it tends to be the state also. The differences between right and left in terms of funding are not huge. The right tends to favour targetted funding much more (which I think is incredibly more sensible) while the left favour universal funding, but only in the more libertarian corners do you get arguments for no state funding at al.
Skipping over the issue of who delivers the primary services, I’ll note that in terms of sub-contractors, they are almost always private sector. Private medical labs often do hospital work. Community trusts often do work on behalf of MSD etc etc.
As for the primary services, I think a mixture of public and private sector involvement is good for both. I think private schools help public schools. They also free up more public money for public schools. I think the privately managed prison was light years better than the most of its public counterparts, and could have led to quantum improvements in the public prison service. I think having patients waiting for operations, when there are public funds and private beds available, is obscene.
But that is not to say I think we should tender out the military to competitive tender.
What I want is a Government which will be open minded about where there is a role for the private sector, and make decisions based on empirical evidence and analysis. If using the private sector will produce a better outcome, then that’s the main thing I worry about. I sure as hell don’t get jealous that someone may shock horror make money from being a landlord.
The Government has said it will only impose economic sanctions on Burma, if the United Nations agrees to do so.
The Greens are urging the Government to ignore the UN and take unilateral action against Burma.
Is this the same Green Party which insists on UN mandates when it is the United States taking action on something?
I should save this post and repost it every six months.
The overall crime stats mean little for three reasons.
Hence for some years I have focused mainly on violent crimes, and to a lesser degree sexual crimes. Yes the overall crime rate has some psychological value, but the average NZer is not too worried about how many people got done for having some pot, but they are worried about being beaten up or worse.
Lindsay Mitchell notes sarcastically how the Police try to paint every single increase in crime as good news.
Now the stats to 30 June 2007 have violent crime up 4.4% and sexual crimes up 4.6%. This is not good news, and I wish the Police Commissioner’s Office would focus more on reducing the crime rate rather than spinning mroe crime as good news.
The spin is that the increase in violent crimes come from more work on domestic violence. Well domestic violence tends to be minor assaults, so how did assaults increase in the last year:
Speaks for itself.
A fairly eventual evening. I flew up to Auckland on the 3 pm flight, getting in at 4 pm. Now I had managed to lose my drivers licence which made picking up the rental car a small challenge. But I got the Police at the international terminal to issue me a temporary proof of licence so finally had the car by 5 pm.
However by that time I now needed to get the polling database to my office so they could start polling at 6 pm. So I ended up sitting in the backseat of the rental car in the airport car park working on the laptop and then e-mailing it to Wellington. Goodness knows what anyone walking past would have thought I was doing, especially as the windows steamed up.
Then heading over to Maratei where Judith Collins was hosting a “funeral” at her home for the Clevedon electorate. Now the Auckland map doesn’t extend out that far so I did a quick Google Maps lookup before I left and memorised the route. However as I got to the main road East there was major major roadworks with a multi block detour. It took me around 10 minutes to get back on a road I had memorised. I know Auckland CBD well but had never driven out this way before.
Thought I did rather well to get there by 6 pm. The “funeral’ was lots of fun (I wasn’t up specifically for it, just coincidence of timing). It’s lovely country out that way and great views even though it was pouring with rain.
On the way back to Auckland I followed Scott back to Auckland as I am staying at his place. Now remember I found my way out to the remote location with no map, no local knowledge and a huge detour.
Now Scott was driving back to Auckland City, in fact to his home, has lived there all his life, and even worse had Navman GPS. But we ended up not once but twice taking wrong turns followed by u-turns. Hence I promised Scott I would let everyone know about his navigational ability.
On the plus side Scott has now lent me his Navman so I’m mobile around Auckland for three days without having to map read and drive at the same time. GPS should be compulsory in all new cars!
One News tonight has a special report on the Electoral Finance Bill. Will probably be halfway through the hour or so.
When you get past the terrible headline of “Landlords owning schools“, the concept of whether new schools need to own their land and buildings, or might be better off leasing them is something one can at least seriously debate.
Many public sector institutions lease instead of own buildings. No better example than Parliament itself which for many years did not own Bowen House. It still may not, in fact. Likewise most Government Departments do not own their own buildings.
One can argue that schools need to stay where they are, and not move about like Departments do. Well firstly Parliament itself is sort of wedded to the one spot. And most Govt Departments do stay in one place.
What we should be having is a debate on the pros and cons of ownership vs rental for new infrastructure. Having private sector involvement will beyond doubt allow a quicker build in most cases. But National has done itself somewhat of a disservice by having policy come out through media interviews rather than through well researched policy discussion documents which will frame potentially contentious issues by identifying what benefits might occur from the policy, what the drawbacks might be – and making it clear feedback is sought on whether the benefits outweight the drawbacks.
Ralston in the HoS quotes members of the Parliamentary Rugby Team from Labour and National, who seem to be upset by the PM’s unilateral decision to investigate the team.
Shane Jones says:
“I haven’t heard any allegations currently of impropriety. I reject it utterly,” he says, suddenly very serious and wary. “Once you get on this slippery slope it can get dangerous,”
Ralston comments:
It is the kind of loony political row that could only occur in New Zealand. In the UK they have glorious sex scandals and “cash for questions” corruption, in the US they have senators ensnared by Washington madams and big corporates kicking millions into congressional campaign funds. In New Zealand we squabble over who paid for whom to go to a footy match.
So why is the PM ordering an investigation. Ralston has a theory:
The Prime Minister also distrusts the fraternisation that occurs because of the nature of the team. As Murray McCully says plaintively, “It’s the only non-partisan activity around Parliament where MPs treat each other like human beings”.
Most of all, the Prime Minister is a control freak. She hates things that she cannot exercise power over and the anarchic nature of the Parliamentary Rugby squad, with no formal structure or lines of accountability deeply offend her. It is also about the intensely male sport of rugby, something she has little feeling for. If it was a sponsored parliamentary theatre group or opera chorus she might have taken a different stance.
And finally Ralston asks:
Come to think of it, how ethical is it for the cultural sector to bombard the Minister of Culture with freebie tickets to plays and concerts?
Possible double standards indeed.
The Sunday Star-Times has a beat-up article on MPs superannuaton scheme but it fails to mention the most crucial fact.
The Remuneration Authority when setting MPs salaries, does so on the basis of taking into account the total cost of an MP – including superannuation subsidies.
So the superannuation scheme is not an additional cost. If there was not such a scheme, then MPs base salaries would be up around $150,000 intead of the $122,500 they are. The cost of the super scheme is now effectively deducted from their base salary (both employer and employee contribution).
Now one can debate whether or not a backbench MP is worth $150,000, and that is a legitimate debate (I would point out this is a pay drop for most National MPs), but the issue of how much goes into superannuation vs salary is a red herring as both are set as part of a total remuneration calculation (which is the only sensible way to do it).
I will be very disappointed if National does drop its policy of bulk funding for schools. All bulk funding is, is simply letting a school spend its entire budget as they see fit – rather than having central Government dictate how much must be spent on this area, how much on this area, needing permission for capital works etc.
Bulk funding is one of those things that you have hysterical scare-mongering against, but once it is in everyone would wonder what was all the fuss about. A bit like Homosexual Law Reform in the mid 1980s. Once it happens, no-one at all will want to go back to the old system as they discover how much better the new system is.
Katherine Rich has said they’re looking at other options to give schools more flexibility in their management locally. I hope these are significant.
The latest Police shooting appears to be a good example of where a Tazer may have saved a life.
Anyone who thinks that pepper spray would be effective enough in stopping a charging man with a hammer aimed at your head, should try offering their own head up to be made into scrambled eggs.
It’s amusing to read that the group “Campaign Against the Tazer” claims not to be against the Tazer in all circumstances. Greg O’Connor pointed out that makes their name look pretty silly then.
There is an argument against the Tazer. Because it is (almost always) non-lethal, there is a risk Police will use it when it isn’t necessary. We’ve seen this in the United States (mainly with private security though). And in NZ we have seen occasions when Police have used pepper spray without proper justification.
But it is a balancing act. Does the risk of tazers being used inappropriately outweigh the likelihood that lives will be saved (both Police and attackers) by having available a weapon between pepper spray and a pistol?
I don’t think it does, and that Tazers on balance will be a good thing. However the Police will need to clamp down ruthlessly on any use of them when not justified.
The ODT reports on two polls showing incumbent Mayor Peter Chin with a huge lead.
Most of the major races have now had polls published. Yet to see anything for Christchurch or Wellington though. Have I missed them or has there been nothing?
Michelle Hewitson interviews Pansy Wong in the Herald. I found it quite a charming interview as Pansy’s quirkiness comes through nicely in it.
The NZ Herald editorial is unimpressed with the PM’s move to have the have the Speaker investigate the Parliamentary Rugby Team.
So ends, probably, a harmless and charming tradition. What could be more in tune with this country than the pleasure that a few of its male MPs derive from an occasional game of rugby? What could be the harm in accepting sponsorship for their recent trip to France?
The sponsorship had been organised by a representative of Sky TV, as it has been for years. Sky TV has an obvious interest in rugby. So do some of the other sponsors: Air New Zealand, adidas, Lion Nathan, Visa, McDonald’s and AMP. The French Government provided internal travel and accommodation.
Lobbying is a long way from corruption. If this trip was unethical, we have become too sanctimonious for words, or play.
Hear hear.
Today’s Herald DigiPoll should deal to any complacency about the result of the next election. It is competitive.