Zaoui “no longer a security risk”

At 3 pm the SIS announced Ahmed Zaoui is no longer considered a security risk, and they have removed the security risk certificate against him.  This means Zaoui is now a resident of New Zealand as a legal refugee.

I am not completely surprised by this.  It has been apparent for some time that the original certificate was done primarily or totally on the basis of the fact he had terrism related convictions in France and Belgium, and had been deported from Switzerland and excluded from the UK.  That sort of background is entirely appropriate to have the warning bells activated for.

But that is a slightly different issue to actually being a security risk to New Zealand itself, as opposed to merely undesirable (refugees must be accepted whether or not they are undesirable).   With no network for former GIS activists, like there was in Europe, no colonial ties to Algeria, and also the profile from his case, it is not an unreasonable conclusion that he is today not a threat in NZ.

The unfortunate thing is how long this has all taken.  Cases should be decided in months not years.  Hopefully the changes to the Immigration Act will stop there from being a repeat of this very expensive very time consuming process.

David McGee

The Independent Financial Review reported yesterday that Clerk of the House David McGee is to become an Ombudsman.  It is a sign of my political geekdom that as a fifth former I purchased (and still have) a copy of McGee’s book “Parliamentary Practice in NZ” when it was first published in 1983.  He wasn’t even the Clerk then, but just the Deputy Clerk – yet already the authoritative source.

Two years later he became Clerk and for over 20 years has advised Speakers and MPs. He’s held in extremely high regard by MPs for his constitutional expertise and impartiality.  There have been a few HR issues in his office, but probably inevitable with any moderately sized employer.

So an outstanding choice to become an Ombudsman.  His successor will have big shoes to fill.

I should do a post one day on how the Clerk’s office works.  They actually are quite powerful.  For example the Clerk (generally through his staff) will reject any oral question that isn’t worded to their demanding standards,  and also that doesn’t provide proof of an assertion.  They also effectively decide which amendments to a bill are permissible – sometimes an amendment can be outside the scope of the Bill etc.

It is a very dumb parliamentary staffer that gets offside with the Clerk’s Office. The closest I came was when I drafted over 500 amendments to the Employment Relations Bill to help fillibuster it.  I recall the Assistant Clerk muttering about abuse of process (which of course it was) and my only defence was I was acting under orders.

One of my proudest days was when the same person said that the technical quality of my amendments was as good as their own staff.  Again at some stage I’ll do an uber geeky post on how to write good amendments to a bill!

Wallys of the Week

No 1 Wally award goes to Gordon Copeland. NZPA reports on how he put out a press release criticising the response to a question, hours before he actually asked the question!!

Independent MP Gordon Copeland was mocked in Parliament today for putting out a response criticising an answer to a question, hours before the question was even asked.

The former United Future MP was due to ask Attorney-General Michael Cullen if the Government was going to support his Bill of Rights (Private Property Rights) Bill.

Before Parliament sat today, Mr Copeland put out a press release marking his “disappointment at Government’s stance on property rights”.

Dr Cullen complained to the Speaker Margaret Wilson saying Mr Copeland had already expressed disappointment at his answer.

The prize however is shared by No 2, Jacqui Dean, who like Sue Kedgley’s office a few years ago, fell for the dihydrogen monoxide hoax. Here’s a lesson for all MPs. If a constituent writes to you asking for you to ban a substance you have never heard of because “In many cases of drug/party pill overdoses reported in New Zealand and overseas, Dihydrogen Monoxide is considered to be one of the contributing factors”, then here’s some steps you should take before writing to the Minister (whose response is here) and asking him whether “the Expert Advisory Committee on Drugs have a view on the banning of this drug”:

  1. Check Wikipedia
  2. Or Google
  3. Ask your party’s research unit what info they have on banning dihydrogen monoxide and when they manage to pull themselves back up off the floor, conclude it is a bad idea
  4. Ask the font of all knowledge – the Parliamentary Library

The dihydrogen monoxide hoax has a serious point to it.  It shows how one can make anything sound bad, and lead to a reflex “should we ban this?” response.  Rodney Hide has up on his blog his comments from Hansard, where he agrees with Nandor Tanczos that prohibition is a bad idea,

The New Zealand Sopranos

Party Pill Ban passes first reading

NZPA reports that Parliament voted 113-8 (Greens and ACT against) for the legislation allowing party pills with BZP to be made illegal drugs with the same seriousness as cannabis.

The motivations of those supporting the ban are sincere I am sure.  But I really hope they consider at select committee a few things:

1) Will regulation and education be more effective than prohibition?

2) How do you justify banning party pills, and not alcohol or tobacco?

3) Why do you think prohibition will be any more effective than say it was for the US with alcohol in the 1930s

4)  Do you think it is a smart move to criminalise almost every party going under 25 year old?

Scum

Read about this lovely Hastings Father:

  • made his 11 and 13 year old daughters box each other
  • belted the loser with a studded belt
  • whacked, punched and slapped her
  • pulled her hair and split her lip
  • the other sister was whacked with a golf club
  • previously smacked with a piece of firewood

Oh yeah and after doing all this, he gave them a bible to read.  And worse of all the daughters forgive and want him home.  I want him in jail.  It is natural for daughters to love their father, even abusive violent pricks.  I would hope the mother would love them enough though to leave him.

TUANZ Business Internet Awards

Enterprising people out there might want to check out the 2007 TUANZ Business Internet Awards. These awards are open to any organisation or individual who produced an interactive media product within the last 12 months.

Award categories include:

  • Education
  • Advertising/Promotion
  • Entertainment
  • Information/Architecture
  • e-Commerce
  • Experimentation
  • User Generated Content
  • SaaS
  • Tertiary Student
  • Craft
  • Best of the Best

You can enter online at the link above. Will be interesting to see the range of entries.

A good night

Had a damn good 40th last night. It achieved its aim of keeping me so busy and having so much fun I never had a moment to sit back and actually reflect on the fact I am now 40.  Somewhat hungover – was doing okay until Francis turned up and insisted on tequila shots.

The birthday cake was superb – it was a giant Spider Pig – this will only make sense if you have seen the Simpsons Movie, but I have been singing the Spider Pig tune for the last few weeks, so most apt.

Had the party in the upstairs function room of the Backbencher and it was pretty perfect for 100 or so people.  Highly recommended for others looking to do a private function.

I’m out of Wellington, in the South Island for the next six days, so somewhat lighter blogging than normal.  Later this week taking a rental car from Nelson down the West Coast, and after a night there over Arthur’s Pass to Christchurch.  Looking forward to the drive.

NBR on SFO

Ben Thomas in the NBR covers the announcement that the Serious Fraud Office is being wound up and amalgamated into a new Organised Crime Agency. Ben notes:

The decision to disestablish the SFO appears to have been taken swiftly: only three months ago, advertisements appeared for a replacement for the SFO’s outgoing director, David Bradshaw, and it received a big funding boost in May’s budget.

But now the minister in charge of the SFO, Michael Cullen, is suggesting that the connection between organized crime and fraud is too complex for the SFO to handle.

This is the reverse of the usual argument that serious and complex fraud is too specialized for the police. 

Like Ben, I am skeptical of this move.  I think an Organised Crime Agency is a very good thing, but whether the SFO should be part of that is another matter.

A decade ago I would have been insistent you can’t touch the SFO – it had almost a 100% conviction rate.  But in recent years it has had several high profile failures and confidence in it has been lessened.

The first ever text message Ministerial resignation

First of all a thumbs up to Damien O’Connor for offering his resignation. The complete opposite to David Benson-Pope who had to be crowbared out of office. And I think Clark is right not to accept it at this stage.

But I am highly amused that a Minister of the Crown offers his resignation by text message. Can you imagine it?

sry 4 Fkng ^ hellN. twas realy lamo. DY wnt me 2 resign?

And what was Helen’s reply?

vry lamo idd Damien. bt nt as lamo as George on hs bst dy so I won’t sak u.

I can just see the Cabinet Secretary turning those into a formal minute!

Key on Sept 11

John Key has just delivered a very personal and very good speech to the US/NZ Partnership Forum.  I should have twigged with his former job, that 9/11 would have affected him:

This morning’s moving ceremony at Auckland Cathedral reminds us again that September 11, 2001 is an unforgettable and utterly defining day.

  

One of the characteristics of such rare days, whether they are days of tragedy or days of profound relief, is that they unite people. They unite people in their families and in their communities. They unite people of goodwill across countries and across political boundaries. 

 

On September 11, 2001 my thoughts were with the people of New York and, in particular, my former colleagues at Merrill Lynch. The Merrill offices in New York were just across the road from the World Trade Center, in what is known as the World Financial Center.

 

Not long before the attacks I had worked and lived there, on and off, for six years. Whenever I think of my time in New York, my mind is drawn to those two enormous towers across the street, now no longer standing.

 

My colleagues had experiences on September 11 that no person should have to suffer. Moreover, three Merrill employees died that day. Two were people I had personally hired, and one was my boss.

 

For New Zealanders as a whole, September 11 brought a surge of sympathy for and a sense of solidarity with the American people.

I remember even Yasser Arafat lining up to donate blood.

Today, hanging in a privileged position on the stairs of Parliament House is a battered New Zealand flag. This flag was found by some of the American heroes of September 11 in the rubble of the Twin Towers. It speaks to me of the deep friendship between the New Zealand and American people. This friendship, as National’s Foreign Affairs spokesperson Murray McCully once put it, is the basic default position of New Zealanders.

 

That is the big picture in the United States/New Zealand relationship. Yet, accompanying that big picture has been the rift between our two countries over the nuclear issue, starting almost a quarter of a century ago.

 

I do not intend to dissect the history of that rift. There are many people in this room far better placed than me to do that, including our joint New Zealand chairs, former Prime Ministers Jim Bolger and Mike Moore.

 

They lived through, and were deeply involved in, the twists and turns of this often painful debate. Their presence no doubt tells you where they stand today on the importance to New Zealand of the United States relationship.

 

Independence on nuclear matters has become hard-wired into the New Zealand DNA. It is profoundly symbolic, and national symbols can be difficult for other countries to comprehend. But it is part of our collective psyche.

 

The first important announcement I made when I became Leader of the National Party was to confirm that under a future National Government there would be no change to New Zealand’s nuclear legislation.

 

A small country like New Zealand, which is so dependent on good international relations, cannot afford to have its key foreign policy settings changing with the political cycle. It is in New Zealand’s interest, and in the interest of those countries with which we enjoy close relations, to have a stable and durable platform on which to manage our relationships going forward.

 

I want to look to the future. I have little interest in debates, either economic or political, that simply re-litigate events of a quarter of a century ago.

Everytime I am in Parliament I look at the battered flag and reflect on what it represented – those New Zealanders who were in the Twin Towers the day of the attack.

 

I also like how Key puts the nuclear issue into the past a a quarter century old event, which should not affect the future.

 

The speech isn’t yet online but I guess it will be on National’s site soon.

Late Show

PC gone mad

A fine example of political corectness gone mad by our friends at VUWSA.

Salient has an article on Helen Lowry Hall, and there certainly are some valid concerns about the hostel.  However, this is not one of them:

Upon arriving to Helen Lowry there is a Bible waiting in every person’s room, she says. A 2006 resident who is of a different faith felt this was presumptuous and described it as “an invasion greeting you at your bedside.”

VUWSA Welfare Vice President Paul Brown says he is “very surprised by this” because “if a student wants a Bible in their room they can bring their own.” Brown says “this could be particularly offensive”, given the diverse range of students who attend Vic.

Having a bible in your room, is “particularly offensive”.  Jesus Christ.

Personally I think the practice is silly and would use my copy to provide me with a year’s supply of paper darts.  But to claims it is “particularly offensive” is political correctness gone mad.

TVNZ makes a loss

I recall the days when people complained that TVNZ’s profit was far too high.  Well the Government has solved that problem – TVNZ now makes a loss.

But hey it’s worth it for all those great extra locally made programmes such as …..

Lies, damned lies

Matthew Hooton’s column in the SST was labelled “Lies, damned lies: ‘Nazi’ election bill”. Key points:

The government has resorted to outright lies to defend its Electoral Finance Bill, as it refuses to back away from its plans to restrict citizens from participating freely and transparently in our democracy.

In the last fortnight, Justice Minister Mark Burton a mere frontman for more sinister forces within the Beehive has used taxpayers’ money to write to community groups, saying his bill does not restrict the ability of “legitimate groups” to play an active role in public debate. He insists “organisations can raise any issue of concern to them at any stage leading up to an election”. Only “secret, big-budget campaigns” that seek to influence voters “unduly” are affected, says Burton.

These statements are entirely false. Burton’s bill, signed off by the prime minister, is crystal clear: it regulates all words or graphics that express a view on any issue with which any politician is associated during the period before an election.

Now what is interesting is to compare the letters from English and Burton to community groups on the Bill. The English letter (electoral-finance-letter-10-final-august-2007.doc) is to the point and factual. The attachment (electoral-finance-bill-summary-3rd-parties.pdf) sent with the letter, which Burton has called misleading, takes the unfair step of actually quoting clauses from the Bill. A very mean and misleading thing to do you will agree. How dare National actually quote from the Bill.

But the real contrast comes in Burton’s letter (scan of letter), compared to English. Burton doesn’t quote from a single clause of the Bill. His entire letter is a polemic against “opponents” and a giant “trust us”. Again, the Minister doesn’t even refer once to a single clause of his own Bill.

Now this is scary. It’s one thing to introduce to Parliament a draconian bill which will remove rights of free speech in election year. It is quite another to lie to community groups about what the Bill does and does not do.

I encourage people to look at the actual attachments and see for themselves the vast difference  One is factual and merely encourages community groups to make submissions.  The other fails to refer to a single specific clause of the Bill, and basically just attacks the usual “enemies”.

So would you buy a used car from Mark Burton?

40

Well I was born exactly 40 years ago – at 5 am on 11 September 1967.

I’m not sure if one celebrates any birthday after your 21st, especially one which ends your 30s.  However I am reminded on the great response from George Burns when he was asked what was it like to have turned 80,  He replied “Pretty good considering the alternative” 🙂

I’m looking forward to a good party tonight. Don’t expect too much blogging tomorrow 🙂

What Helen should do

If a major reshuffle wasn’t looming, Helen would have filled the vacancy caused by David Benson-Pope weeks ago, and given permanent homes to his portfolios.  Hence it is likely she is doing a full reshuffle.  Now she hasn’t been very bold with these in the past, but this is a time when she should be bold.  This is what I would do if I was Helen (and it is genuine advice):

Cullen – has to lose Finance as any 2008 tax cuts will not be credible coming from him. Give him Health as a replacement as the portfolio needs a good manager. Also give him Treaty to keep him busy.

Goff – give Goff Finance.  Goff can do tax cuts far more credibly than Cullen and he rarely puts a foot wrong.  He is under used in Trade.

King – King is under used and could pick up Defence from Goff.

Hodgson – has to lose Health.   Give him Social Development from the former Benson-Pope. Frees him up mroe for election year also.

Burton – goneburger for multiple reasons

Barker – goneburger, better candidates waiting in teh wings

Cunliffe -a former diplomat would be ideal to pick up Trade, gives him a deserved promotion.  Also keep overview of Immigration until law changes through

O’Connor – keep in Cabinet but Corrections too demanding for him. Maybe Associate Immigration again and Associate Economic Development ot go with Rural Affairs

Cunliffe – picks up Trade, loses Communications, IT and  Associate Econ Dev

Cosgrove –  also promote and give Justice to

Shane Jones – promote to Cabinet and give him Comms/IT (he did a good job as Chair of Select Cmte considering the reforms), Associate Finance and a couple of minor Associates

Maryan Street – promote to Cabinet and give her Local Govt

Charles Chauvel – promote to Cabinet and give him Attorney General and Deputy Leader of the House.

That would keep numbers the same, bring in three new faces, and get a fresh look in Finance and Health. I think it would give them a reasonable poll boost and enable them to start setting the agenda again.

Bin Ladin is a leftie!

Andrew Bolt looks at Bin Laden’s latest video:

  • rails against capitalism
  • rails against multinational corporates
  • blames global warming on corporations
  • embraces Noam Chomsky

And he concludes Bin Laden is a leftie. Now before people flame, this doesn’t mean lefties support Bin Laden anymore than righties support David Duke.

My submission on the Electoral Finance Bill

My submission is below, with most of it over the break. Also note the paragraph numbering is mucked up with the cut and paste. Also some tables are not showing as they are graphics – will reinsert them in later today.

The submission is now available also as a pdf – efb-submission.pdf

 

SUBMISSION OF DAVID FARRAR
TO THE JUSTICE AND ELECTORAL SELECT COMMITTEE
ON THE ELECTORAL FINANCE BILL

Table of Contents

  • About the Submitter 1
  • Executive Summary 1 – 2
  • Major Criticisms 2 – 4
  • Money and Elections 4 – 6
  • State Funding 6 – 7
  • Definition of a Publication 7 – 8
  • Regulated Period 8 – 9
  • Definition of Election Advertisement 9 – 10
  • Financial Agents 10
  • Third Party Eligibility 10
  • Specified Amount 11
  • Continuous Disclosure 11 – 12
  • Anonymous Donations 12
  • Election Advertisements 12 – 13
  • Candidate Expenses 13
  • Party Expenses 14 – 15
  • Third Party Expenditure 15 – 16
  • Enforcement 16 – 17
  • General Provisions 17 – 18

About the Submitter

  1. This submission is made by David Farrar in a personal capacity. I would like to appear before the Committee to speak to my submission.
  2. I have over 15 years experience with the Electoral Act. As a former parliamentary staffer I advised National Prime Ministers and Opposition Leaders on the Act. I have been an electorate campaign manager and a national campaign staffer, requiring intimate knowledge of the Act. I have also done original research on the Police investigations relating to breaches of the Act in the 2005 election – research which led to full page stories in major newspapers.

Executive Summary

  1. The Electoral Finance Bill is the worst legislation I have ever come across. It is so badly drafted that it is quite simply unworkable. Even if the unintentional mistakes are fixed, it is still a repugnant law which promotes MPs and Candidates to a political elite, and requires all other New Zealanders to jump through hoops to express a view on any issues an MP or candidate has already associated themselves with.
  2. The Electoral Act does need changing in many areas. The blatant breaches of the Act in the 2005 election showed us this. Sadly the Electoral Finance Bill ignores almost all the areas where change is most badly needed, and goes totally overboard in areas such as third party campaigning. Even worse it seeks to legalise the illegal behaviour of certain parties in 2005, and seeks to criminalize the legal behaviour of other parties.
  3. I ask the Justice and Select Committee to vote to recommend to the House that this bill not proceed, so changes to the Electoral Act can be done in a way which involves the public from the beginning, rather than just allowing them one chance to be heard.
  4. The Bill as it currently stands fails in almost every single purpose listed in Clause 3. It will undermine public confidence in the electoral process, it discourages the public from participation, it fails to bring in greater transparency for parties and candidates and it is so badly drafted the controls will be neither clear nor effective.
  5. It needs to be recognized that MPs have a much vested outcome in the provisions of the Electoral Act, as this lays down the rules for how they get elected. This is arguably our most important constitutional Act, and major changes to it should have maximum public input.
  6. A sensible policy process would be as follows
    1. MOJ or some independent body releases an issues paper (or green paper) for discussion and feedback
    2. Submissions are sought on the paper from the public and parties
    3. Submissions are published and cross-submissions called for
    4. A series of public forums also held to discuss issues
    5. Then a white paper is released with specific proposals for change.
    6. Submissions and cross-submissions sought on the white paper
    7. A final policy paper setting out Government policy is published, and then legislation reflecting this known position is introduced
  7. It is entirely unacceptable for MPs to consider such wide ranging restrictions on third parties, when there has been no consultation or engagement with third parties on the proposed law. Transparency International pointed out in April that MPs are conflicted in deciding such issues, and recommended use of an independent panel. I would support this, whether a Commission or a Citizen’s Jury.
  8. The other reason that I submit the bill should be rejected in its entirety is that the changes that would be needed to make it workable, let alone desirable, law would be so great it would almost be a new Bill. The current Bill is simply too flawed to be used as a template. It treats third parties (ie the public) as undesirable players in election year that will be heard only under sufferance.
  9. If, however the Select Committee is determined to press ahead with the Bill, my fallback recommendation is that you reopen submissions on the amended bill to allow members of the public an opportunity to have a say on the acceptability of the bill, as amended.
  10. In case the Select Committee does decide to try and pass the Bill in amended form, I provide a lengthy list of criticism and proposed improvements for their consideration. I do reiterate that my preference is to have a proper public debate and consultation on these issues.
    Continue reading »

Moderation

Two events last week have convinced me that I’m going to have to crack down on some of the comments being made, as much as I would prefer not to.

The first is that due to comments being made on the Shane Wenzel thread, somehow I have been summoned as a witness to a civil case in the Auckland District Court.  I now have to consult a lawyer and find out if I can avoid this, or just supply the info they want (details of who made certain comments) and who if anyone reimburses me for my time and expense of getting to Auckland.

The second was a phone call from someone who has never posted on my blog, yet has had one of the more excitable commenters (currently banned) call her all sorts of nasty names.  I hadn’t seen the comments myself (I now read probably less than 25% of comments made) but having had them pointed out, they were pretty bad and I empathised with her.

So I am going to clamp down on abusive comments.  And this will be subjective calls – abuse is like spam and porn – hard to define but you know it when you see it.  But I am going to ask for some volunteers to help with the job and protect people against arbitrary decisions.

I am after five volunteers who can moderate.  This won’t be a huge time consuming task.  You don’t need to be reading every comment.  Just someone who regularly reads the threads.  I’d ideally like volunteers with a politically diverse range of views.  E-mail me if you are willing to volunteer.

How the moderation will work is like this:

1) Moderators will gain editor access to the blog.

2) Any individual moderator may edit or delete a comment [other than by me or another moderator], noting in the comment what they have done and why.  They will also formally warn the commenter that their comment was abusive or disruptive.

3) Once someone has had two formal warnings, they are liable for suspension if they infringe for a third time. But all five moderators need to agree that a suspension is warranted.

4) A 1st suspension is for one week.  A 2nd one for two weeks, a 3rd one for four weeks and doubling everytime.

5) A decision of the moderators can be appealed to me.  But don’t get your hopes up.

6) Moderators will be rotated every so often, maybe every six months or so.

Now I don’t want this to suppress lively debate.  In fact my policy will be to be far more tolerant of shall we say strong language of people participating in a debate, than of similar language about someone who isn’t there to defend themselves.  And if it proves too stifling I will reconsider after a couple of months – think of this as a trial.  But the status quo is not acceptable when it means me having to worry about court action.

So again, if you are willing to help moderate then contact me.  I am sure I will have far more offers than I need, so don’t hold a grudge if not initially asked to help.

August Polling Newsletter

puppollaug07.JPG

After two months of gaining in the polls, Labour has fallen significantly in the three public polls which came out in August.

The latest Curia monthly newsletter has the following info in it:

  • Details of all three polls in the month
  • The weighted average of all the public polls and associated graphs
  • Summaries of other public polls on issues such as
    • Child Abuse
    • Christian Voters
    • Business and Consumer Confidence
  • Average results for public political polls in
    • United States
    • United Kingdom
    • Australia
    • Canada

You can subscribe to the free polling newsletter at this link.

A fatal blunder

John Key has called it “mind blowing stupidity” and he is possibly being generous. What on earth was Damien O’Connor thinking when he brought a suspended prison officer out on tour with the Parliamentary rugby team (who won the parliamentary world cup again – well done team).

O’Connor is not a stupid man. He has struggled with Corrections, but that portfolio needs a more experienced Minister. But how on earth did neither he nor his staff think there wouldn’t be an issue in having a suspended prison officer fly overseas with and play rugby with the Minister of Corrections.

It does not matter if Jim Morgan is finally cleared or not. I hope he is. But how can there be confidence in the investigation into him now. What would you think if you were a mid level manager in the Department of Corrections investigating Morgan, and you saw he was off playing rugby in France with the Minister. I mean, really.

O’Connor’s blunder is unfair to Morgan as well as his Department.

Clark is yet to permanently assign the portfolios of David Benson-Pope. Surely this makes a full reshuffle look more and more likely. O’Connor must now be very likely to be sacked, along with Burton and Barker.

More nuclear support

The Herald on Sunday editorial slams opposition to nuclear power:

The nuclear threat to the planet pales into insignificance beside the threat posed by climate change.

Among the Kiwi contingent, the suggestion was as appetising as a plutonium milkshake. Foreign Affairs Minister Winston Peters muttered darkly that we were not going to “abrogate our sovereignty”; Trade and Disarmament Minister Phil Goff cited “other concerns”, including waste disposal, safety issues and the creation of terrorist targets; and PM Helen Clark, who sees no role for nuclear power in the climate-change debate, dismissed it as “not something we are going to endorse”.

Such an unequivocal attitude flies in the face of shifting international and scientific opinion. Barely a year ago, Patrick Moore, a co-founder of Greenpeace (which now derides him as an apostate), wrote that “nuclear energy is the only large-scale, cost-effective energy source that can reduce [greenhouse gas] emissions while continuing to satisfy a growing demand for power”. James Lovelock, the author of the Gaia hypothesis, pronounced that “only nuclear power can now halt global warming” and wrote “I entreat my friends in the [Green] movement to drop their wrongheaded objection to nuclear energy”.

Most people think countless thousands, even millions, of people died as a result of the Chernobyl accident in 1986. The World Health Organisation’s count is 75 – and all of those were people involved in fighting the fire and the cleanup. What is more, Chernobyl was a shoddily built, poorly maintained Soviet-era station belonging to a collapsing oligarchy: more than 20 years later, with all the technical development that has occurred, it is a poor example of the supposed risk.

It may well be that nuclear power is not viable here on practical or political grounds, though the likelihood is that we will fail to meet our emissions-reduction targets without a change in energy strategy. But we do ourselves and the world no favours by refusing out of hand to endorse or explore the nuclear option. When the biosphere collapses, it won’t spare this country just because we remained philosophically pure.

It would be good to have a response from the Greens to this.  Or from Labour.

Gore travels by private jet

Ralston on TVNZ

Ian Fraser, who was and is a big champion of public broadcasting, has said that TVNZ has impossible conflicting objectives to be both a commercial and public broadcaster.  Now Bill Raltson has said much the same, but with damning detail.  You really should read the whole thing, but some extracts:

I spent nearly four years there and, yes, I made some dreadful mistakes. Apart, perhaps, from Helen Clark, we all must concede occasionally we make mistakes.

Probably the worst error I made was accepting the job in the first place because the fundamentally flawed nature of the company makes it almost impossible for anyone to succeed in a TVNZ management role.

TVNZ is a Croc. I am not being rude here, that’s what you call a Crown Owned Company. This means it has a shareholder that is schizophrenic. As a shareholder, the Government wants a 9 per cent return on capital invested but it also wants, through the charter, a non-commercial social dividend. The Government wants to have its cake and eat it too and that just doesn’t work.

Making a 9 per cent dividend is tough enough in the media market today but when the charter requires you to spend precious revenue on programmes that will never make a buck, it’s plain suicide, because it creates a backwash of financial pressure that undercuts the whole business.

TVNZ has a politically appointed board. I believe that means in the past the board was often more interested in sucking up to its political masters than running a business. Board members also turn over at an incredibly high rate, compared with the private sector. Those short-serving board members usually have little or no knowledge of the broadcasting business and, indeed, because they’re politically appointed sometimes have little knowledge of business itself.

In short, TVNZ is dysfunctional because it’s designed that way. Its management often talks about the TV One or TV2 “family”. If TVNZ was a family, CYF would have been called in long ago.

Heh, nice line.

You cannot run TVNZ as a purely commercial business because lunatic political considerations constantly intrude.

Take, for example, Helen Clark’s aversion to paying presenters large salaries. Her stand has cost the company tens of millions of dollars and has been a major factor in bringing the place almost to its knees.

We put together a business case showing if we lost Judy, the impact on ratings would be significant and we’d lose many millions of dollars in advertising revenue as our audience decreased. In comparison with the potential losses, her salary increase was insignificant. Rightly or wrongly, it was a straight commercial business decision. The outlay is worth it when balanced against the return and the potential cost of not doing it.

The board accepted the business case and approved the salary contract. I passed a signed copy to Judy. But then one board member dissented, threatened to resign and went to the minister.

The board panicked and instructed Ian Fraser and myself to kill the contract, physically retrieve it from Judy and hand her another contract for a lot less cash.

Judy, for the first time in her career, suffered huge public abuse and One News ratings began a nose-dive from which it never recovered.

Cue Susan Wood. The year before the board had approved her salary of $450,000. Now, after the Bailey debacle, I was told the board wanted to cut Susan’s salary by $100,000, presumably to reduce the risk of another beating from Helen.

Now, I’ve never seen people react well to a 22 per cent pay cut and Susan was no exception. She immediately engaged lawyer Mei Chen who went at TVNZ like a rabid chihuahua and within weeks the row went public and the effluent was again flying around the building.

This fiasco damaged poor Susan’s reputation, hit Close Up’s audience and, I think, was a big part in her sad decision to quit a year later, exhausted and discouraged.

The only real hope is for some kind of non-partisan agreement by the politicians on making TVNZ completely independent of government and they need to decide what they want the network to be: A public broadcaster or simply another commercial channel? It cannot do both. That much is clear from the calamities of the past seven years.

I do hope National comes out with a bold policy in this area. The status quo is not workable. I would like to see some sums around selling off TV2, and having the interest from the sale, the current charter money and most/all the NZ on Air money go towards TV One as a dedicated public broadcaster.