Child Abuse

Many people are up in arms at the proposal from the Children’s Commissioner to have each family and child’s progress monitored by an authorised provider.

Yes it is a somewhat desperate proposal, but one motivated by how desperately bad our child abuse story is. They’re not online but the Dom Post had a two page spread on all our high profile child murders,what the promised response was each time, and how little has changed.  Some of the solutions have been implemented but having marginal effect, and others have slipped off the screen (Ministers have some accountability for this).

Seriously, I almost cried reading about all those deaths.  To say they are unacceptable is under-stating it by a magnitude.  And you know if it will help stop this barbaric toll, I’ll even consider Kiro’s proposal.

Not that I think her proposal is particularly sound.  I think the high risk factors which make a child more likely to be at risk of child abuse are well enough known, that there is little argument for universal interventions, rather than targeted interventions.  One argument might be that there would be less resistance to targeted interventions if they were universal and some families didn’t think they were being singled out.

But nevertheless universal interventions should be a last resort.  Almost all the cases of child murder we have had have not happened to families unknown to the state.  It doesn’t just happen out of the blue.

I would agree with Dr Kiro that home visitation is important.  I suspect that one will be able to quickly ascertain if a child is at risk, based on a home visit.  If the beer crates are still in the living room, that’s going to be a warning sign for example.

So universal interventions are not the answer, but before we reject that, we should come up with some workable ideas or solutions as alternatives.  Because the status quo of being the most unsafe country in the developed world for children can not continue.

76-14

A reasonable effort but still some way to go.  If Italy can score 14 points against us, how much will other teams score?

I’ve said this before, but hearing the National Anthem reminded me how much I love the Maori version of the National Anthem.  It sounds much better than the English version musically, and helps reflect better who we are, then merely the English version.

What I think should be a lesson to us all, is how the Maori version has become so popular. There has been no law passed making it official or even worse mandatory.  There has been no legion of bureaucrats promoting it.  There has been no Treaty claim insisting it be given equal status.  It has simply been picked up and adopted by more and more New Zealanders over the years.  Sure a lot of people don’t know all the words (despite John Campbell’s best efforts) but most support and enjoy its use.

Go the Pumas

Blogging controversy in Cairns

My friend Mike Moore has taken to this blogging lark so well, that the Mayor of Cairns has been trying to get his blog closed down, and has even threatened Mike’s employer about it.

Mike has responded by sending some chocolates to the Mayor.  Of course the attempts by the Mayor to close it down has led to many media stories and a massive increase in readership.

Keep up the good work Mike!

Fran on Nuclear Energy

Fran O’Sullivan gives a good overview of the nuclear energy debate:

Clark will be displaying a tin ear to the momentous problems faced by polluters such as China and the political sensibilities of the United States and Australia if she opposes the inclusion of nuclear energy among possible alternatives to power sources that arguably have a bigger impact on climate change.

But there is no clause stating that New Zealand should expand the legislation to promote an international stance against using nuclear power for electricity.

Clark says nuclear energy is not something New Zealand will ever tout. But there is a big difference between such touting and conceding that its use by countries such as China, which plans a string of nuclear power stations, can stop their people from choking on pollution from the coal-fired plants that power the world’s factories and also cook the planet.

It will be interesting to see what is agreed, and how it is spun.

You can still submit!

The online submission facility for the Electoral Finance Bill is still working and the good people in the Office of the Clerk traditionally will still process submissions that come in over a weekend, if there was a Friday deadline.

Go to this post for details of how to make your submission, and some issues you can mention in your submission. Go ahead and do it – you’ll feel better for it.  And ask to be heard by the Select Committee, unless that would freak you out.  The Select Committee can travel about so don’t worry if you live outside Wellington.

Mother now a suspect

Portugese Police have officially named Kate McCann as a suspect in the murder of her daughter Madeleine.  It will be fascinating to see how this ends up.  Has the entire world been hoaxed with appeals for sightings?  You’d have to be a first class liar to keep that up.

The pledge card revisited

The Electoral Finance Bill isn’t just about third parties.  It is primarily about Labour trying to get re-elected, and is merely part of a strategy.

Part One is to clamp down on the amounts everyone else can spend.  We see these with not only the draconian third party restrictions, but also the extending of the regulated period for political parties to 11 months.  This is simply because Labour has less money because it has lost so many supporters.

But Part Two is the killer.   As the Herald reports, H2 has been trying to get all the parliamentary parties to agree that items such as Labour’s pledge card can be funded out of their parliamentary budget.  Now under the current law, even if they did again fund their pledge card out of their parliamentary budget, it would still have to be accounted for as part of their spending limit.

But the Electoral Finance Bill exempts parliamentary spending from the spending caps.  This means that not only will Labour be able to get the taxpayer to pay for their pledge card again, they won’t have it count as part of their limit.

The naked self interest is disgusting. They want to prevent parties and third parties from spending their own money on their election campaigns, yet want to be able to use their parliamentary budgets for anythign bar explicit vote solicitations.

Consider the hypocrisy.  A third party is told that if they publish their views on any proposition associated with a party or candidate, then bang that is an election ad and must count towards their meagre total.

But a parliamentary party can actually publish a election pledge card, and not have that count towards their total.

John Armstrong writes on how Labour is still 100% committed to the passing of the Electoral Finance Bill.  Their concessions will be minor and only in areas where their interests are unaffected.

What Labour is trying to do borders on corruption.  And yes I use that word deliberately.  The Chief Electoral Officer, the Electoral Commission and the Auditor-Generall all found that they broke the law last election.  Labour have never shown a hint of contrition for this.  They have merely attacked the neutral officials who held them to account.   And they are now trying to legalise their previously illegal behaviour.

People may think the C word is too harsh.  But think what your reaction would be if you read how some small pacific country had the incumbent Government clearly breached the country’s electoral laws, and then using their narrow majority gained at the disputed election, they rewrote the election laws to legalise their illegal actions, and to restrict the ability of parties and groups to criticise them.

You’d probably be thinking it’s a typical corrupt Pacific country.  Now if you think that does not verge on the boundaries of corruption, then tell me how.

Court Orders no longer enforced, just discussed

You know I thought one of the ways our justice system works is that a Judge makes an order, and the Police enforce it.  A pretty simple concept.

But in the case of the stolen body, it seems not.  The wife of the deceased gained a court order that the body be exhumed and returned to Christchurch where she lives.  So one would think the Police would implement the court order.

But no. The Police will take no action until there is an amicable agreement.

This is a fascinating development where those who have broken the law have to now agree to how to remedy that breach.

Professor Ranginui Walker speaks some common sense:

“It’s time Maori learned they live with Pakeha law.

“Before they do such a thing as hi-jacking the body, they should check out the law. It was done in ignorance.”

While fighting over a body was honourable to Maori, it was clear that widows had the final say at burial, Professor Walker said.

Comments held for moderation

A comment is generally held for moderation for two reasons:

  1. Because it has three or more links in the text (likely spam)
  2. If you have not yet made a comment which has been accepted

So everyone has their first comment held.  Generally I’ll clear them within a couple of hours.

It does mean though that if you set up a fake hotmail account under my name and try and post as me, all your effort is wasted and your posts never appear on the blog, even for a split second.

Experts start the flaying of the Electoral Finance Bill

The first day of oral submissions was yesterday.  Professor Andrew Geddis, author of a textbook on electoral law, submitted.  Now just so no one accuses Geddis of being a nasty filthy right winger like me, he has a socialist background and is all for public funding of parties and clamping down on private money.  He was no doubt expecting to be a big supporter of the Government’s bill based on their rhetoric of the last year.

NZPA reports Geddis blasted the EFB as breaching the Bill of Rights Act and being a piecemeal reaction to problems:

The question of how third party spending has been defined under the Act, the width of that and the low limits that have been put on it, in my opinion, breach the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act.

The limits are so tight they don’t allow for real meaningful involvement, not just in election process, but legislative and social policy making process during that year.

He was especially concerned about a cause restricting the ability of youth to participate in political debate

Prof Geddis said the way the bill was written any advertisements relating to issues would come under its restrictions. That meant organisations could accidentally send out messages that would be considered electioneering and stop them expressing views shared by any political party.

Had the controversial anti-smacking law change been done in an election year debate may have been stifled.

Prof Geddis was also concerned the bill set high standards of disclosure for everyone but politicians and candidates and he said they should be included or the requirements dropped.

He said it was absurd that people had to sign a declaration before speaking out even if all they wanted to do was hold up a placard.

 Also the NZ Herald reports on Dr Claire Robinson’s submission:

Dr Claire Robinson said that under the proposed law, every political party logo published in election year would require the authorising signature of the party’s financial agent.

The bill was unworkable and unenforceable and did not reflect “the nature of political communication and electioneering in the modern MMP election campaign”.

The key word I am hearing from everyone is unworkable.  Not “needing minor clarification”.  This is why it must be rejected so a workable set of reforms (and reform is needed) can be developed.

Remember you have until the end of today to submit.

APEC Security Caption Contest

The APEC Nuclear Debate

It has been inevitable that the silliness of the NZ hysterical position on nuclear power would clash with the desire to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

To try and have a rational debate, let us not talk about NZ but China.  There are actually reasonable grounds on which to say nuclear power isn’t necessarily a viable option for NZ (which is very different to saying it should be banned).

Let us talk about China, and their impact on the world environment.

China is the biggest emitter of greenhouse gases in the world.  And a major factor in this is their coal mines, with a new one opening every week or so.

Now unless one wants to argue that China’s economy should not be allowed to grow and lift more people out of poverty, then you accept China needs more and more energy.

Now if it keeps building coal mines, then their greenhouse gas emissions will continue to skyrocket.  Plus around 5,000 Chinese citizens a year die in said mines.

If they build nuclear power plants, then there are basically no additional greenhouse gas emissions.

So does someone want to make a case that China should keep using coal instead of nuclear, that this will somehow be better for China and/or the world?

As Bush says:

“If you truly care about greenhouse gases, then you’ll support nuclear power. If you believe that greenhouse gases are a priority, like a lot of us, if you take the issue seriously, like I do and John [Howard] does, then you should be supportive of nuclear power.

“After all, nuclear power enables you to generate electricity without any greenhouse gases.”

Now the Greens would have us believe climate change is so bad we are faced with global extinction. So surely the relatively minor risks of a nuclear leak pale in comparison with
global extinction?

Now again I am not talking nuclear power in New Zealand.  I am talking about whether nuclear power should be endorsed generally as a preferable power source to coal.

Why would a Government with aspirations of carbon neutrality not endorse nuclear power as an option for other countries?

Satire ban looks set to stay

The parliamentary ban on use of parliamentary footage for satirical purposes looks set to stay, with most MPs very unsympathetic to a media proposal to merely ban misrepresentation.

MPs it seemed aired decades of pent up grievances such as how Bill Rowling in 1982 was misrepresented as laughing at a speech in TV footage.  They also objected to a soundtrack of “We’re in the money” being played in relation to an item on MP’s pay rises.

Why not just have a committee of MPs approve the news every day then. Then I am sure we will have no complaints!

A solution for Fiji?

The good Commodore has decided that martial law must be reimposed because deposed prime minister Laisenia Qarase is in Suva speaking out against the coup that toppled him, for his court case where he seeks to have the coup declared illegal.

So what exactly is it that the Commodore wants banned:

Commodore Bainimarama said yesterday that Mr Qarase was “acting irresponsibly by making statements and participating in activities which have political orientation”.

Oh wait, I have a much better solution that martial law.  Commodore Baininarama should simply pass the Electoral Finance Bill!!!

NZ First not happy

Wow.  Mark Burton has blundered again.  Now that is not so surprising.  What is surprising is how NZ First is treating it.

Burton announced the results of the Rates Inquiry this week.  He overlooked that it was set up at NZ First’s bequest and didn’t even give them an advance copy, let alone acknowledge their role.  Shabby.

But instead of a private note of complaint, NZ First attacked and humuliated the Minister in the House – as detailed in Audrey Young’s blog.  And this attack on a Government Minister would have been approved by Foreign Minister Winston Peters.  Not quite the recipe for stable Government.  Here are some of the questions asked:

“Has he or his staff been briefed on the details of the Confidence and Supply Agreement with New Zealand First, in particular the part that says: That the relationship between New Zealand First and the government will be based on good faith and no surprises, and does he believe that his failure to provide a timely pre-public release briefing to New Zealand First, his failure to inform New Zealand First of the press conference until the day it was to take place, the failure of his staff to send a copy of the report when they had promised to do so and his complete exclusion of any reference to New Zealand First’s role in securing the inquiry demonstrates acting in good faith with no surprises?”

“Does the Minister understand what the terms good faith and no surprises mean, and if his poor judgment in this matter jeopardises the otherwise constructive relationship between New Zealand First and the government, why does he not do the honourable thing and resign?”

Yes, NZ First did just call on Mark Burton to resign.  That is an unprecedented call from a party with Ministers in the Government.

The Falling Sky (Acorn) Prevention Bill

TVNZ and Freeview

Throng has an interview with TVNZ’s General Manager of Digital Services on why they won’t allow Sky to show their new free to air digital channels.

I remain unconvinced though.  If I have paid my share of the $80 million cost of the channels, I want them delivered to me through the one box I have already paid for like every other local free to air channel.

30 hours left to make your submission on the Electoral Finance Bill

Okay sorry this is late and abbreviated but you still have 30 hours left until end of Friday to have your say on the Electoral Finance Bill.

The bill in its current form will regulate almost all political discourse next year. Participation in the political process will be something you have to jump through hoops, not a given right.  Labour, Greens, NZ First are showing little signs of accepting how flawed the Bill is.  In fact the Government is blatantly lying about its effects.

So please please take 30 minutes out of your day or evening to make a submission.  It does not have to be long and you can do it online.  They should be in by the end of Friday.  Here is how:

  1.  Go to this page about the Bill.
  2. Click on “Make an online submission”
  3. Select Yes or no as to whether you wish to appear before the Select Committee to speak to your submission.  Unless the thought of doing so freaks you out I encourage people to say yes.  Your submission will have more relevance if they hear from you directly on why you do not want your rights interfered with.  It also makes it harder for them to rush it into law.
  4. Enter in your name, and contact details.  Also if you are appearing, list your name and number as a witness.
  5. Then click next page
  6. Now you can either import a word document with your submission in it, or type in your submission in the box provided.  Then click Submit.  It is as easy as that.  Just be aware the page times out after 20 minutes so write your submission first and then follow through the process.

Now comes the question – what do you say.  Well first of all you need to say what do you want them to do with the Bill.  There are broadly three choices.  To pass it unamended.  To pass it with amendment.  Or to reject it by recommending to the House it does not proceed.  I think people should say something like:

“I ask the Justice and Electoral Select Committee to reject the Electoral Finance Bill and recommend to the House it does not proceed because it seeks to impose draconian restrictions on political advocacy and speech for which there is no electoral or public mandate”

I would then expand on the point that there is no mandate for these third party restrictions in the Bill. Point out that there has been no public policy process around the Bill.  Point out that it has not been possible to even debate it until a few weeks ago and that one would expect sweeping changes of this nature to come at the end of a lengthy public debate, not at the beginning.

Also point out that why you don’t want the bill merely amended is because you will then have no chance to have meaningful input into the revised bill.  State that your preference is for a public policy process to be used to explore issues and develop options around electoral reform, and then for legislation to be advanced.

Then you may want to highlight some features you find undesirable. Below I give some examples you can incorporate.  But at the end do it in your own words.  Here’s a short list of undesirable features:

  • It extends the period of “regulated speech from 90 days to around 11 months, meaning New Zealanders will spend one third of their lives restricted as to their advocacy.
  • It defines as an election advertisement taking a position on any proposition that a party or candidate is associated with, which will elevate parties and MPs to first class citizens, as the moment they take a position on an issue, it becomes a restricted topic for all other New Zealanders
  • It covers not just traditional advertising, but is worded so that every e-mail and every website (except non commercial blogs) fall under the regulated speech regime
  • It has an almost unworkable bureaucratic system of sworn statutory declarations for any person or organisation spending even $1 expressing a view for or against a party in election year
  • It bans any unincorprated society with even one member under the age of 17 from spending more than $100 a week on political issues
  • It bans political parties from being able to run issue advertisements
  • It requires every organisation that spends more than $100 a week or $5,00 a year on “taking a position on any proposition that a party or candidate is associated with” as having to register with the Government and reveal all non trivial sources of income.  This will affect hundreds if not thousands of organisations
  • It requires third parties ot hand over anonymous donations over $500 to the Government yet allows political parties to accept anonymous donations of no limit at all.
  • It restricts an organisation to $60,000 expenditure in a year on so called election advertising, which barely covers two full page newspapers ads in our largest newspaper, over 11 months.  This is a ridiculously low limit to apply for such a long period of time.
  • It will legalise Labour’s illegal pledge card over-spending in 2005
  • It does not provide for significantly greater penalties for parties that deliberately breach the Electoral Act as happened in 2005
  • It prevents a wronged party, attacked by a politician, from defending itself during an election campaign by requiring third parties to register prior to the issuing of the election writs
  • It does not crack down on anonymous and trust donations to political parties despite there being a clear public consensus that it should.
  • The definition of advertising and publication is so wide that e-mailing a press release, stating your views on a website (other than a non commercial blog), or even making a placard for a protest march will be regulated by the Bill
  • That both third parties and political parties are greatly restricted for all of election year which will prevent them from being able to effectively respond to Government initiatives such as the Budget

That probably gives people some stuff to go on.  You can also mention that the Governments are set up to serve the people, not to take away their rights to criticise the Government.  That any restrictions on these rights should not be rushed into law but only be legislated into law after there has been significant public consultation and input, and widespread consensus.  Point out the only consensus amongst the public is that the Bill is anti-democratic.

So get to work people.  It sounds melodramatic to say if you don’t have your say on this law, you will lose your say on other laws.  But in fact sending in a submission to a Select Committee will actually be defined as a publication and an election advertisement and be illegal next year unless you sign a statutory declaration that you will not spend more than $5,000 on “advertising”.

Also next year if there is a proposed bill, and you are a registered third party and you have already spent your $60,000 on other activities, then you will be banned from spending even $1 on publishing your submission on a law.

Do not trust that Labour, Greens and NZ First will magically make this Bill less draconian.  The Government is blatantly lying about what this Bill does. The Greens will agree to almost anything so long as it stops the Brethren and National.  Winston I hope will show some sense on this, but I don’t want to rely on that.

I am in Heaven

Bliss – My Stats NZ Census Meshblock Dataset arrived last night.  If you don’t hear from me for a few weeks, blame all the nice data I am pouring over.

Already interesting stuff found like median family income being $87,000 in Wellington City, then $76,100 in North Shore, $72,900 in Auckland, $68,00 in Queenstown Lakes etc.  At the other end of the scale it is only $37,100 in Opotiki District and $41,200 in Horowhenua.

Net Greenhouse Gas Emission

netemissions.png

This graph, taken from No Right Turn, nicely shows how hollowHelen Clark’s rhetoric of carbon neutrality is.

The situation is even worse than the graph shows. John Howard gets pilloried for not ratifying Kyoto, but even if he had, their target was an increase of no more than 8% from 1990. They have actually achieved their target. Our target was a 0% increase and we are at over 20%. NZ not Australia deserves to be the target of attacks of climate change activists.

The anti-spam law

I’ve been very involved with the anti-spam law development for several years.  In 2004 InternetNZ had finally got over dealing with the issues of how to run .nz, had sold Domainz and was starting to look at wider Internet issues and spam was high up the list of issues most affecting good use of the Internet.

I personally loathe spammers with a passion.  They started by spamming Usenet, then went for e-mail spam and now do blog spam. I can’t even estimate how much of my time gets used up dealing with spam.   Seriously – give me a gun and a spammer and you’ll have one dead spammer, and best of all no jury would ever convict me.

I raised the issue of a law in June 2004 at a conference and recall the then Minister, Paul Swain, being unenthusiastic about such a law. His successor, David Cunliffe, was far more supportive of taking action.  He has in fact been great to work with on the issue.

As we researched more into the spam area, and talked to ISPs, to anti-spam technology companies, to other Governments, to international anti-spam groups, we found that there was close to universal consenus on the elements needed to effectively combat spam.  They are:

  • Education
  • Technology
  • Industry Self-Regulation
  • Legislation
  • International Co-operation

It was made very clear that there is no one easy solution. No one element works by itself. Education about never responding to spam is essential, but as spam can be profitable if just 1 in 10 million people reply, that will never stop it alone.

Technology is great, but Brightmail for example said they will never win the war by themselves as  it is like am arms race, where spammers always find ways around filters and filters have to adjust.  Also technology only blocks spam from consumer, does not stop spam, and the false positive rate is an issue with some products.

This is why legislation and international co-operation play a part.  And the two are very linked together. Firstly it is important to state that spam is illegal, so action can be taken against spammers.  It is a grievous breach of our property rights and a form of theft.

Secondly most spam is international in nature.  The sender can be in one country, the website in another.  The domain name registration in a third and  credit card processing in a 4th.  At an OECD workshop on spam I attended, the US Federal Trade Commission said that they sometimes need to file a dozen search warrants in four or five different countries, over a period of a week or so -in order to track down and prosecute a major spammer.

Our legislation is partly about us being able to  co-operate with overseas agencies when there is a NZ link.  And there is sometimes.  For example I had reported to me from Spamhaus earlier this year that the No 1 spammer in the world was using a NZer and NZ registered company to act as its domain name registrar to allow it to open and close spamming websites constantly.  If the law had been in force then, someone on the North Shore would have had a knock on their door from someone with a search warrant, and she may have been able to provide evidence to track down the No 1 spammer and prosecute him.

Again none of this will stop most spam, but just as child porn is not stopped by anti-child porn laws, that is not a reason not to have them. And as almost the last country in the OECD to have anti-spam laws, we won’t want to end up as a refuge for spammers driven out of every other OECD country.

I also don’t regard it as being at all a bad thing that NZ companies have to be more careful about checking they get consent before they add you to their mailing list.  I’ve had several companies or organisations add me to their weekly newsletter list simply because I dealt with them commercially on an unrelated issue.

Having said that, many companies are over-reacting to the new law by asking people to opt back in.  My polling company has a mailing list for our free public monthly newsletter on public polls. I have not e-mailed the subscribers asking them whether or not they wish to be on the list. Why?

Because I have already been following the new law by only having people on the list who have asked to go on it.  You can only get on there by using the website to double opt in.  And each message has a footer telling you how to unsubscribe.  So if you have been following best practice with your e-mail lists, the new law basically should not affect you.

The last three years for me has been chairing or attending several seminars on spam and spam laws, having visited the Australian anti-spam agency, having helped MED draft the law, having submitted desired changes to the Select Committee (all of which were taken up) and having also worked with DIA on setting up the new agency, I’m very pleased to see the law take effect.  Partly because I can now retire from active involvement in this issue, but mainly because in a very small modest way, it will help in the battle against spam.

I should also point out that while I have taken a lead role within InternetNZ in regards to the fight against spam, the true champion who provided so much time, expertise and credibility has been Dunedin’s David Harris, the inventor of Pegasus Mail.  My loathing for spammers is mild compared to the other David’s 🙂

The Law Commission

The Law Commission is one of my favourite bodies. I think they generally do great work as they proactively look at how to improve our laws, rather than just be reactive.

But one aspect of their work which is starting to raise more and more concerns with me, is their constant views on legislation before Parliament considering their President is a former Labour Party Leader and a major donor to Labour – lobbyist and lawyer Sir Geoffrey Palmer. People complain about the US style of politics, yet don’t complain when one of NZ’s most entrenched lobbyists gets appointed to an important constitutional role.

Reading this story on Rodney Hide’s Regulatory Responsibility Bill, I note once again the Minister is suddenly armed with an opinion from the Law Commission that there were “very serious concerns” about the quality of the bill.

I’m going off memory here but it seems everytime an opposition bill makes it to select committee, that the Law Commission pops up talking about how seriously flawed the bill is.

Well here will be a good test of the Law Commission. The Electoral Finance Bill is almost inarguably the most seriously flawed bill of a generation. Will the Law Commission (which has been appointed as an advisor on the Bill) label the EFB “seriously flawed” or will it merely talks of minor clarifying changes to be made?

Cheaper Jails

Corrections have had massive blow-outs in their budget for building new prisons. An independent review has found ways to build them cheaper:

  • Less pretty landscaping (I am amazed this has to even be stated)
  • Communal toilets
  • Allowing private sector management
  • No need to paint every cell
  • A less onerous RMA process
  • Reducing the size and quality of cultural facilities for inmates

Naturally I support all of these. We don’t need five star prisons.  We need functional prisons which comply with safety and health regulations.

A secret strike!

Following the advise of their union, a group of posties staged a secret strike in July last year.  Rather than deliver the mail, as they were being paid to, they reposted some of their letters.  This means that customers faced waiting twice as long or more for their mail if they were affected by the secret strike.

Now when your employees refuse to do their jobs, it is a partial strike and an employer is allowed to respond by locking them out.  In this case, where the union and employees, did not even tell the employer if their action – one could argue that the employer could treat the actions as misconduct.

But NZ Post did not move to formally sanction or dismiss the employees.  They merely locked them out, backdating it to the start of their secret strike.

But the Employment Relations Authority has ruled it is illegal to backdate a suspension notice. So it means the posties get full pay during all the time they were on a secret strike.

It does indeed appear to be a loophole in the law.  My view is that employees only get the protection of the law for striking, when they actually notify their employer they are striking.  Any sort of “secret strike” is simply misconduct.

Imagine if you discover your helpdesk staff were hanging up on every fifth call as part of a “secret strike”?  Or if your accounts receivable team decided not to invoice evey fifth customer without telling you.  Totally unacceptable.