I’m happy just being the MP for Mt Roskill

Clark breached confidentiality

The NZ Herald reports that Helen Clark broke a confidentiality agreement with Air New Zealand when she revealed details of other charters in an attack on Australian Foreign Minister Alexander Downer.

Also Clark is exposed as a liar.  She claimed she Downer never told her in advance about him speaking at the National Party conference.  Downer reveals he has had the High Commissione check the notes of the billateral meeting he had with Clark, and they confirm the conference was discussed.

Breaking promises even before they are in office

AUS-ASTE Merger

There have been some interesting debates on the AUS-Cantebury blog about the proposed merger of the university staff union with the polytechnic staff unions.

There is a considerable level of resistance in some quarters to the merger, with concern that the distinctive nature of universities face getting more watered down, just for the sake of a bigger union. One compelling post against is here.

I’d be interested to hear from affected staff on their views for or against.

Ali Reza Panah

I take a hardline view on illegal immigrants, fake refugee claims. I supported the expulsion of Danny Butler in the 1990s, that German couple in the same period, the Australian hardline stance on “economic refuguees” (which as actually worked – far far less attempts now), the expulsion of Ahmed Zaoui (on the grounds of the amnesty now in place in Algeria) etc etc.

The trouble with giving in to the emotional sight of a family on the TV news begging to stay, is that it provides the wrong incentives. It penalises those genuine refugees and asylum seekers who follow the correct procedure and provides incentives for people to game the system.

In the case of Ali Reza Panah, my view has been that his conversion to Christianity was fake and he should be deported.

But my God, 60 days on a hunger strike taking him to near death is enough. As Michael Ellis says, it is time to give him the benefit of the doubt and let him stay.

Surviving the Rugby World Cup

A very amusing article by NZPA on how partners of rugby supporters can survive the Rigby World Cup season.  Has ten survivial tips including:

2. Three minutes to fulltime, the score tied, with a drop-kick all that’s standing between the All Blacks winning … it’s not the time to ask whether you should go to his parents for Christmas or yours.

9. Accept you will attend social gatherings, which do not revolve around rugby, by yourself until the tournament is over. This includes anything involving births, deaths and marriages. And do not invite your rugby-hating friends around to the house while the games are on, especially if they have children.

What I find most amusing is that the author of the article is in fact a huge “rugby nut” herself.

Hat Tip: PM of NZ

bank.nz is approved

The InternetNZ Council on Friday approved the creation of bank.nz as the 14th second level domain under the .nz top level domain.

I think this is a good thing.

I imagine all NZ banks will over the next year or so move to the bank.nz domain.  This will clearly identify which financial institutes are registered banks and which are not.

And while not a total solution, it will be useful with phishing scams that one can educate people to ignore any URL which is not a bank.nz address.  Of course people can still be fooled, but it will help.

I wonder which bank will be first to register, once it is created?

Solictor Trust Funds

NewstalkZB has an item on how $62,000 was donated to the National Party from a Bell Gully Trust account in 2005, linking it to their criticism of the Electoral Finance Bill.  This was noted by Tane in comments, which shows journalists read the comments also.

However it is a pity that they don’t realise how solicitor trust accounts work, and how ridiculous linking it to their criticism is.

Lawyers get  basically no say on how funds are spent from a trust fund.  They are merely a vehicle for their clients and the lawyer’s job is to execute the wishes of their client.  If you say Lawyer B, here is a cheque for $25,000, please put it in your trust find and pay it to Party A, they do so without question.  It is their job.  They get no say in who it goes to – could be Labour, National or Greens etc.

So linking their criticism of the EFB to their trust account activity is ridiculous.  It is like attacking the vews of say the BNZ Chief Economist because someone went into a BNZ branch and asked for a bank cheque to be made out to a political party.

We can make a difference

People out there can make a difference through this blog and others. Take for example the Bell Gully article in NZ Lawyer on the Electoral Finance Bill.

Now it actually was published last week. No stories appeared from it.

Late yesterday a friend mentioned it to me in an e-mail. I asked him to scan it in and e-mail me the pdf, which I got last night. It appeared on the blog at 9 am this morning.

At 11.40 am it was a news story on NewstalkZB.

At 2.00 p.m. it was a story on NZPA.

At 2.06 pm it was on the Herald website. Tomorrow it will be in various newspapers.

I say this not to claim any great feat on my part. Hell all I did was upload a file and summarise it.

The key thing was that someone sent it to me. Hence this post – I do encourage people to send in to me stuff like this, which they think might be useful. It might be a column like this, an academic article, an editorial in an obscure newspaper, a link to Jon Stewart making fun of NZ laws etc etc. I won’t always use them, but by e-mailing me you give me the ability to do so.

The reason blogs do well are that they are often a group effort. The sum is greater than the parts.

Bell Gully slays the Electoral Finance Bill

Belly Gully partner Roger Partridge and solicitor Jesse Wilson have published a stunningly good article in NZ Lawyer on the Electoral Finance Bill.

A pdf scan of the article is here –doc030907.pdf. Definitely read the whole thing, but here are some extracts or summaries:

  • The EFB imposes constraints on political advocacy that are  arguably unparalleled in modern NZ history
  •  Raises the issues that as one can not register as a third party once an election writ has been served, any person or organisation attacked by a party during a campaign will be banned from fighting back.
  • The EFB curtails opportunities for citizens to express their ideas on matters of public importance in an election year, when it matters most
  • A key part – “No evidence of the harm said to be caused by third-party advocacy has been provided to justify these heavy-handed proposals”
  • “It’s conceptual premise is fundamentally inconsistent with the principle that citizens do not require prior authorisation to to express their views about the Government on political issues of the day
  • “The Bill effectively creates a licensing regime for political speech”
  • “The Bill rations the amount of political speech by third parties in election year” and “the rations are meagre”
  • “The fact that advocacy may persuade the electorate is hardly a reason to suppress it”
  • “Far from being a corrupt practice, persuasion through speech is the lifeblood of the democratic society and the hallmark of civilised society
  • “The suggestion that free speech can “unduly influence” voters is misconceived. The foundation of the democratic system is that voters should be free to judge for themselves which ideas have merit
  • “If a group of private citizens consider the registered parties have failed to give due attention to an issue, and they wish to introduce their own ideas into the political discourse, this should not be constrained is the purpose of the Bill is to promote public participation in the electoral process”

A truly excellent article.  The part that stands out for me is:

“The fact that advocacy may persuade the electorate is hardly a reason to suppress it”

Indeed.

Hey Pete

I know you’ve been too busy to cope with the fact that emergency departments have been asking people not to turn up, but the fact that we may be about to start flying pregnant mothers (I’m sure that is not something recommended for late term mothers) to Australia as we have run out of beds here could be worth you looking into.

Only if you’re not too busy with your other duties though.

EFB changes

Helen Clark has said she knows nothing of any letter from the Government to the Justice and Electoral Select Committee proposing changes to the Electoral Finance Bill, before submissions even close on it.

This is strange as sources inform me the Government has finished drafting a Supplementary Order Paper setting out its proposed amendments.

As always, we the public, will be the last to know.

Do as I say, not as I do

Moore hits back

An extraordinary column by Mike Moore in the Herald today.  Extracts:

The idea of banning published dissent for election year, a third of a parliamentary term, is sinister, and as written, could ban books. Why ban them? Burn them.

 Ouch.  Not a subtle reference.

Just as I was feeling remorseful because some of my comments were giving comfort to the National Party where the shallow men have replaced the hollow men, the violent frenzy in response proved my point.

The attacks were Orwellian in their doublespeak, and Nixonian in their dark paranoia. One line spun that is about promoting Phil Goff, who I also sprayed in the article, was pure Nixon. I haven’t spoken to Phil in a year. Unfortunately. Documents have come to me instructing familiar names to ring talkbacks and write letters to the editors.

The message here is that if Labour had not responded with a campaign against Moore, he would not be firing back.

Jim Anderton is the designated driver in the attack plan. He’s loving the attention. Most people thought he was dead or, even more fatal in politics, retired. He has not voted Labour in 20 years, not many know that Norm Kirk kicked him out of the party when he was right-wing, anti-abortion, anti-gay, and with Roger Douglas, wanted to remove the unions from the party. Then he left again as a left-winger. I didn’t support Jim when he was far right or far left.

Ouch.  That’s what you call a counter volley.

To be fair, both Helen Clark and Michael Cullen said they would have lost their seats if I had not taken over. I raised money for Labour before the last election and since the election, to disagree is not automatically to be a traitor.

Oh it is in Helengrad.

Anderton opposed all the policies that now make New Zealand wealthy. Against closer economic relations with Australia, against universities getting paid students from overseas, now our fourth biggest export income earner. Opposed GST, waterfront reforms, an independent central bank.

He even opposed the Uruguay trade round and that has returned New Zealand more than a billion dollars a year.

All true.

Mind you, if you believe the media, National MP Tim Groser did all that. Groser’s modesty will be his downfall. He should remind people it was he who first climbed Everest, split the atom, produced Lord of the Rings, and invented rugby.

Ha ha ha.  Sound like some unresolved issues there between Mike and Tim.

But I do get upset when the leadership sneer and darkly mention my tax status. It’s an honour each week to pay more tax than a minister earns, I’ve discovered capitalism late in life. I think my record for New Zealand stands.

Good God.  Who referred to his tax status?

I’m writing this from Kuala Lumpur where I’m in a group that’s working on how a democratic, secular Islam can be a force for good.

Sounds very useful.

My last book was published in several languages and is in its third edition. I’ve written more books than Anderton’s read.

Ha ha ha.  Boy those two really do not get on.

“Uber apparatchiks, spinmeisters, paid friends, call the dogs off.” Remember to laugh at life’s absurdities. Talk about the good decision to get justice for Agent Orange victims, unbundling the communications system, how to get better results from the new money going to health and education, and expose the National Party’s policy that somehow less investment will improve things.

No no don’t listen to him.  Keep with the where did John Key live in 2002 issue.

Private Super Savings

Lindsay Mitchell blogs on the fact that:

The Social Development Ministry survey found the average private income of a single person aged over 65 had dropped 88 per cent from $2200 a year in 1989 to just $260 in 2004.

This is a concern and reinforces my scepticism about the bad messages sent out by universal publicly funded superannuation.It is far more efficient for people who can afford to save for their own retirement to do so, rather than to overtax them and then give it back to them as a pension.  It is silly people earning $100,000+ a year are getting a welfare benefit just because they have turned 65.  By restricting benefits to those who need them, we are better able to further assist those in genuine need.

And with our ageing population, it is very much the wrong signal to send that people don’t need to save for their retirement as the state will do it for you.   This is one reason why KiwiSaver isn’t a bad thing.

The Muppet Show

Red Confectionary has the text of an amusing pamphlet dropped around Vic over the weekend.  It’s called a year in the rear and covers all the antics of the VUWSA Executive.  As someone has noted, the Salient staff are spoilt by getting so many easy stories!

Some extracts:

Education Vice President Joel Cosgrove set the standard straight away this year, making a lone stand against Prime-minister Helen Clark and her Australian counterpart John Howard in the first week of class. After screaming angrily at the two Prime-ministers, Cosgrove had to be restrained by police. That wasn’t enough for the Education Vice-President however, who then proceeded to place the eighty-three year old University Games Shield on Trade Me with the help of former President Nick Kelly. At just one dollar it would’ve been the bargain of the year if the university management hadn’t stepped in.

By the end of March Clubs Officer Melissa Barnard was making a name for herself as well. In an interesting interview, Barnard expressed the view that the new student hostel was preferable to ‘students paying $130 to live in an arsef**k flat in f**ken arsef**kville.’ Later in the week she was again in trouble after screaming death threats at Activities Officer Bernard-Bernard Galaxy.

Victims of Crime

My first reaction upon reading the call for compensation from the Government to victims of crime, is that surely the criminals should be the ones who pay compensation, not the taxpayer.

But reading further down the story, I see the proposal is not to hit the taxpayer up, but to fund it with a 10% levy on existing fines.  That’s a proposal worth considering.

Steve Crow in court on gun charges

Totally Unacceptable TVNZ

As a taxpayer I am paying my share of the $79 million the Government has put into funding TVNZ’s two new free to air digital channels. But TVNZ is refusing to make them available over Sky decoders, despite being free to air like TVONE and TV2 which are also available on Sky.

This sticks it to consumers and taxpayers. I am forced to pay out money for a second decoder which according to many reports performs appallingly badly anyway.

But the money isn’t even the issue. It is convenience. Like most people on My Sky, I now use only one remote control to record and view. Having to use one decoder for 48 channels and another decoder for the other two would be a major pain in the butt.

If TVNZ were a private broadcaster I would not mind so much about whether they make their channels available over Sky (though I would still say it makes sense for them to do so to maximise their audience), but I am forced to fund these new channels through my taxes, so they have an obligation to make it available to me as cheaply as possible – and that is via the technology already in 55% of households.

If TVNZ were not gouging the taxpayer for the costs of the new channels, then it would beyond doubt provide them through Sky – they would need the subscriber numbers and it woudl be a straight forward commercial decision. But due to the taxpayer picking up the costs, they can crap on the viewer and force us to pay more, not caring if it means less subscribers because they get their money from the Government.

The Government talks about a commitment to public broadcasting. Well why then are they letting their public broadcaster screw over the public?

Brewer nears the century

Like most of the country I had never heard of the Newmarket Business Association until media whore Cameron Brewer was appointed its General Manager.  Cameron is infamous for managing to do a press release on any topic at any time, and is also master of the PR stunt.

Today Cameron is talking about how shoppers spend more on Mother’s Day than Father’s Day.

A quick search of the NZ Herald shows that Cameron has been mentioned 99 times.  So just one more time and he has scored his century. Talking of Cameron and scoring, oh the stories one could tell from his past … 🙂

Moore’s vision!

Some interesting sites

Colin James looks at five different Prime Ministers and what they have meant for an Independent New Zealand.  The five PMs are Kirk, Muldoon, Lange, Clark and Key!

A news story of little surprise.  A man who lived with 200 black widow spiders has died.  Yes one of them bit him.  he then got eaten by the spiders, pet snakes, lizards and termites until the neighbours noticed the smell.

Aussies 4 ANZUS in strong support of the US/Australia alliance.

Blog Idol

Stuff is almost halfway through its blog idol, with only six finalists left. I haven’t been checking it out much, but a couple of people have suggested I highlight it.

The remaining finalists are:

I have found Stephen covers the topics most of interest to me, while Julie has the easiest style to follow.  All of them quite readable.

464 commenters

Grey Power on Electoral Finance Bill

NewstalkZB reports:

Grey Power is slamming the legislation contained in the proposed Electoral Finance Bill. National president Graham Stairmand says the bill is fatally flawed and takes away the right of free speech.

Wonder if Winston is going to remain its number one supporter now?

I have many many many disagreements with Grey Power.  But you know if they take a dislike to a future National Government, they should be able to raise money and use it campaigning against National.  They should not be restricted in their advocacy for all of election year.   A sensible limit for the last six to 12 weeks is a debatable proposition, but this muzzling for all of election year must go.