The wonders of genetic modification
A picture is worth 1,000 words thanks to Stuff.
Like an ageing Rocky, Jim Anderton has jumped into the fray to defend Helen against Mike Moore. Anderton, who obviously still has unresolved issues from the 80s, exhaled:
“One reason Labour failed so badly in the Moore era was that they were poll-driven fruitcakes who believed coups were some sort of management plan for a political party. Now he wants to start another coup.”
Mr Anderton said all Mr Moore every wanted was the limelight and he was a bitter failure.
Yes Helen of course is famous for taking no interest in the polls. And Helen has never been involved in coups, except the last two. What Anderton is actually referring to is the Lange/Rowling coup – he still isn’t over it 25 years later.
Moore responds with:
He said Mr Anderton was the failure and cited his own achievements including heading the World Trade Organisation, getting closer economic relations with Australia and exporting education.
Mr Anderton was creating a diversion; “as for failing how many seats has he got in Parliament? I took us within a couple of seats of Government once.”
He wrote a book that went to three editions; “when was the last time Jim Anderton had an idea that wasn’t forgotten in 1950?… there is one thing I do envy him and that’s his hair.”
Mr Moore said he was a more staunch supporter of Labour than Mr Anderton every was and had always voted for the party.
Meanwhile in a break from the fun, Audrey Young looks at why Moore spoke out after so many years of diplomatic silence. One theory is:
It is possible he was sickened by the recent Labour attacks on John Key – and Clark’s “plausible denability” over them.
Indeed. Or:
Moore’s breach of his own rigidly enforced discipline is not a joke gone wrong. It is part of a longer-term game.
It makes the Opposition’s criticism of Clark more credible and it makes internal criticism of Clark a little easier to raise – when Goff’s time comes.
So Moore spoke out either because (a) he was genuinely disgusted with Clark’s behaviour, or because (b) he is trying to help Phil Goff roll Clark. My God, what a choice.
I choose (c) – both of the above!
A picture is worth 1,000 words thanks to Stuff.
Lest anyone think I am saying that only Labour attacks MPs from other parties, on non parliamentary issues, let me be clear that of course most parties do this from time to time.
But a significant difference with what happened last week, is the lack of any “aggrieved parties”. I’ll explain what I mean.
Take David Benson-Pope and tennis balls. Neither National nor ACT got their staff to trawl through DBP’s background, interview former students and try and actively dig up dirt on him. What happened is a couple of his former students approached MPs after they thought he was being hypocritical on bullying. Sure the MPs then raised the issue in Parliament, but it was after being approached. And then the real reason it became such a huge issue was DBP denied it all and literally a dozen people came forward to contradict what he said.
Or take the case of David Parker. Parker incidentally resigned before there was even a single question time on his actions. Investigate ran their story – and it was based on there being a very aggrieved party who came forward.
Dover Samuels was sacked from Cabinet when a relative alleged inappropriate behaviour in the past. His corridor urinating antics also became an issue because the guy he pissed on, told people and it made the media.
So in all these cases the issues originated with a disgruntled person who felt the MP had behaved inappropriately. Certainly MPs made decisions as to whether or not they would follow the issue up, and ask questions on it (and that judgement has not always been sound) but these were scandals that came to MPs, rather than the MPs went out digging dirt, trying specifically to invent a scandal.
The attacks on Key have been missing this previously obligatory factor. There is no leaky home owner saying they hold Key responsible for their leaky home. There is no former Equiticorp employee alleging Key devised the H Fee and left him to take the blame for it. The only person writing letters about where Key lived in 2002 is Labour President Mike Williams.
What we apparently have is the Labour Party Cabinet actively going out there and trying to dig up dirt on John Key. They are no passive recipients of allegations from members of the public. They are the manufacturers, the wholesalers and the retailers in this supply chain.
Now that is something we have not had before. It is quite unprecedented.
So when Richard Long writes in the Dom Post:
This desperation for any scrap of information, any document that can be flourished against him, seems to put into context the burglary of Mr Key’s home while he was on a well-publicised overseas holiday, and the mysterious raids on his home garbage bins, detected by neighbours on several occasions. These were not homeless people, looking for discarded Parnell food portions. They were well-dressed operatives who took off swiftly when their activities were detected.
It does make you wonder. Now Long himself goes on to say he thinks Clark would have nothing to do with this, but certainly Labour would not refuse to use the fruits of such activities as they did with the Brash e-mails. And again you wonder how exactly is Labour trying to dig up dirt, now it has obviously decided to do so. It it merely doing Google searches? I suspect not.
I’ve not yet had time to read the full report. I intend to do so.
Stuff reports an average 8% per year increase is predicted. To be fair to local Govt, central Govt grows far more than this. But they get extra revenue from bracket creep, while Councils actually have to put the rates level up.
One area I plan to cover more is all the land which does not get rated, ranging from churches to Govt land to some Maori land.For some Councils this is a major issue, as it means all the other land has to be rated even higher.
The notion of local referenda for any increases beyond population and inflation growth is worty of support in my opinion.
There are times when the term “Labour lite” is not 100% inaccurate. Oh there will be plenty of differences between National and Labour in policy areas such as education, tax, ACC, housing, industrial relations, law & order (to name a few) but I have to say I am disappointed to see National uncritically welcome the proposal to throw half a billion a year at extending paid parental leave.
I understand the politics that no party wants to appear unsupportive to parents and families, but I have to say I do believe families first call should be on themselves, and only those genuinely in need should fall back on the state. There are dangers in having a huge proportion of the population reliant on taxpayer money.
Quite frankly if two lawyers decide to breed, I’m not convinced that people who earn far less than both the father and mother, should have to pay more tax, so they don’t have to survive on only $250,000 for a year.
I’m all for family support, so long as it is targeted.
It’s good to see Air NZ making a good profit. I always chuckle at it, because for years Air NZ have predicted doom and gloom for the airline unless the Commerce Commission caves in and allows them to do a deal with Qantas (which would almost kill competition). I’m glad the bluff has been played, and we still have competition and a profitable Air NZ.
Fran O’Sullivan also makes the valid point that the EPMU deserves some plaudits for reaching an agreement with Air NZ which has allowed it to increase productivity and gain more engineering work for other airlines.
This is the way of the future. Viacom has agreed to make South Park available legitimately online for no charge, but will be profit sharing on advertising from the websites you download them from.
They have correctly worked out that we are now in a global market and the moment an episode comes out in the US, people all around the world want to view it. And the only way to do that has been illegal file sharing, so of course people do that rather than wait six months.
And talking of downloads Peter Griffin blogs on how DRM may be in its dying days, with Walmart now offering DRM free music. And the irony is that the NZ Parliament is about to pass a law giving special legal protection to DRM technology.
A number of commentators over the years have suggested that the tactics and style of government practised by Helen Clark has started to resemble Muldoonism at its worse.
This view is now shared by former Labour Party Leader Mike Moore. And this is an unprecedented attack on Clark by her predecessor. While Clark and Moore have never been friendly since she rolled him in 1993, they made up in 1996, he had her support to become WTO Director-General, and since he has been back in NZ, he has not criticised her directly, he has more commented on policy. One can only conclude the mud smearing of the last week was too much for him to stomach, having endured it himself from Muldoon.
Moore writes:
In the 1980s, a cruelly funny cartoon appeared of David Lange. It had four panels – the first displayed a smiling picture of David, then slowly, over the next two panels, David’s face morphed into a picture of Roger Douglas.
I’m expecting a cartoon of Helen Clark to appear, morphing into an angry Robert Muldoon. He used SIS files on opponents, perfected the nasty technique of personally destroying opponents, intimidating the media (not that you have to muzzle sheep), and used the levers of Government to create stunts, diversions, and buy votes in marginal seats.
This politics of personal destruction is fearful. Why is Labour so good at it? Because we practise on each other.
Helen Clark is superb at it, she’s destroyed more National leaders than any other Labour leader. Come to think about it, she’s dispatched more Labour leaders than anyone else too.
Muldoon’s circle of close mates got smaller and weaker as he got older too. Exactly what does the “consort” Judith Tizard and the legion of Ministers outside Cabinet actually do?
Perhaps it’s good they don’t do much. They manage the remarkable feat of being self-important, expensive, trivial and irrelevant at the same time.
In case one thinks Moore only bags Labour:
John Key just has to keep his head down, and is happy to campaign as “Labour with tax cuts”, sort of like playing a vacuous political air guitar. As for Winston Peters, our Foreign Minister still seems to hate foreigners.
He can’t speak about hospitals without talking of Third World diseases and Third World people, the Central Bank policies are about, he claims, promoting speculation and money-lenders (code word), Dubai investment in New Zealand is naturally bad, but at least the anti-Asian and Muslim stuff has been shelved for a while.
Rodney Hide seems to have rejected capitalism for narcissism and is destined to be a talk-back celebrity. The Greens and the Maori Party have locked up their small market niche and go unquestioned by the media.
The major political parties don’t scrutinise them or test them in Parliament because they will decide who forms the Government. Labour could still form the next Government, even if we get fewer votes than National. Under MMP, a silver and a bronze trumps a gold medal.
A Foreign Minister who hates foreigners!!
Xtra is giving one week’s free Internet, estimated to be worth $6 million, as compensation for its e-mail problems, plus a $1 million donation to charity.
That’s a significant gesture, and good on them for doing it. But as Consumers’ say it was a big problem – e-mail outages if they occur must be minutes or hours at the worst, not days. And from all accounts the “false positive” rate for e-mails incorrectly marked as spam has skyrocketed which is also a serious problem.
Having said that, the new package of services such as virtual backup of files looks to be pretty damn good, and will set a welcome challenge to others.
Having in the last couple of years the motivation to discover more about how protection and harrassment orders work, I am extremely supportive of the review which slams the current system – and it is a shame Judges have rushed out to defend it.
Far too many women (yes I know it is not only women) especially live in fear of ex partners who routinely ignore protection orders, and face little or no sanction for it. And some fo them are dead.
Putting aside for now, the situation where there are children involved (as I am aware false accusations can and do get made), I think the process should be much easier for someone to get a protection order, but most of all breaches of them should have near automatic penalties.
If someone breaches a protection order the Police should have it an assigned priority to go find the person, and lock them up overnight until they go before a Judge first thing.
And if they breach it a second time they should be given a custodial sentence to protect the protectee.
Now if kids are involved, one does need a different regime, because such orders can mean they block a parent from their kids – which should be a last resort. But if there are no kids involved, then I would be very hard line.
The sad reality is so called protection orders rarely do protect, as this case study in the Herald shows. The Herald editorial is not too far from my own views.
The Advertising Standards Complaints Board has upheld a complaint [3 MB rtf file] against Labour’s online advertising for Kiwisaver.
The complaint was about the advertisement saying “Kiwisaver + New Zealand Super’ ‘Labours Guarantee for your retirement” when KiwiSaver is not guaranteed by the Government.
The finding:
It [The Board majority] stated that the use of the word “guarantee” without further qualification in reference to a scheme that dealt with the financial security of consumers contained a level of ambiguity that was likely to mislead. The linkage of KiwiSaver with New Zealand Super was, in the opinion of the majority likely to convey an overall impression of guaranteed financial security.
Accordingly, the majority of the Complaints Board considered that it was not clear in the advertisement that the “guarantee” reference was to a policy only, not the security of KiwiSaver as an investment scheme. Therefore a majority of the Complaints Board ruled that the advertisement was in breach of Rule 2 of the Code of Ethics.
Now these false misleading advertisements were not funded by the Labour Party. It was in fact an advertisement funded by the taxpayer for the Parliamentary Labour Party. Now I have no problems with parliamentary parties spending some of their budget on advertising (so long as it is not electioneering) but it would be nice if the ads we fund were at least truthful.
The Rule the ads are deemed to have broken is:
Rule 2: Truthful Presentation – Advertisements should not contain any statement or visual presentation or create an overall impression which directly or by implication, omission, ambiguity or exaggerated claim is misleading or deceptive, is likely to deceive or mislead the consumer, makes false and misleading representation, abuses the trust of the consumer or exploits his/her lack of experience or knowledge. (Obvious hyperbole, identifiable as such, is not considered to be misleading).
Is it just me or is the PM doing a good imitation of Sgt Schultz?
She claims to know nothing about the multiple Labour attacks on John Key.
Is her hearing so bad she can’t hear Trevor Mallard going on about H-Fees? Did she never wonder what that was about?
Does she not read the newspapers where her party president writes letters about where John Key lived in 2002?
Is she not listening when her Building Issues Minister is trying to link John Key to leaky homes on the basis of a Truth article?
Most of all is she unaware her own chief press secretary is going around the press gallery pushing the spin on these issues?
And does she think the public are so stupid that she denies any knowledge on the one hand, yet in the same article encourages the media to follow these issues up?
She also denies any knowledge of Labour Party involvement in the Auckland Mayoralty race.
She’s almost as bad a liar as Dick Hubbard who claims “he had received no strategic or campaign advice in any “shape or form” from members of the Labour Party or Labour MP” yet admits that he has met three times with Mike Williams to discuss polling and focus groups. On what universe is that not campaign advice?
On the 6.50 am flight to
A reader e-mailed me about a North Shore poll which is on the Shore Can website.
Now the poll doesn’t say who conducted it, so I presume it was done internally. Now generally I am very sceptical of any publicly released poll conducted by the organisation it is done for (as its publication may be designed to become a sell fulfilling prophecy) but in this case none of the questions are about the Shore Can ticket, so I wil put aside my scepticism to note some interesting results:
Personally I like the idea of ratepayers having to approve any increase in rates above inflation and population.
Mystery Pollster in the US blogs about how the order of questions has a significant effect on how people in the US view civil unions:
Public views on giving legal rights to gay and lesbian couples depend a good deal on the context in which the question is asked. On the survey, half of respondents were asked their views on civil unions after being asked about gay marriage, and half were asked the questions in the reverse order. When respondents have already had the opportunity to express their opposition to gay marriage on the survey, more feel comfortable with allowing some legal rights as an alternative. But when respondents are asked about legal rights without this context, they draw a firmer line.
Opponents of gay marriage are much more willing to accept the idea of some legal rights after they have had the opportunity to express their opposition to gay marriage. The percent favoring legal rights rises to 45% in this context, while just 37% favor the idea alone. Put in other words, opponents of gay marriage are much more likely to accept allowing some legal rights when they have already had the opportunity to express their opposition to gay marriage itself.
This is a great example of the importance of order when it comes to setting a poll question. One of the areas where a polling expert can add value is not just in helping frame the questions, but in working out the logical order to ask them, so that you get the most accurate data.
For example in political polls, I always recommend asking questions on how people will vote, before asking questions about issues. The reason for that is because generally questions on issues will remind people of the things they don’t like that the incumbent is doing. So asking someone to spell out what they think is the biggest issue facing the country and then asking them who they will vote for, may disadvantage the incumbent Government.
Student leaders have vowed to crucify those responsible for the Dunedin rioting.
I’m pretty sure that isn’t a punishment under the Sentencing Act.
However I am pretty sure that if the student associations did a Crassus and lined SH1 between Christchurch and Otago with a crucified student every 100 metres or so, then it would be a very effective deterrent for next year’s Undie 500.
I’ve been debating on this blog with Paul Williams whether Murray McCully’s statement on Agenda that National is extremely unlikely to to re-instate the RNZAF strike wing abolished in 2000 by Labour, is a major shift in policy.
I don’t think such a statement is a major revelation, but to be fair to Paul, Press Political Editor Colin Espiner has blogged that this is:
“a major U-turn from National’s previous position and a ringing endorsement for Helen Clark’s defence policies from her political enemies.”
Now when I read this I still wasn’t convinced this is a major u-turn, as it had been my impression that National had given up on restoring the strike wing since it lost the 2002 election. Mainly because the longer you go without one, the much much harder it is to reinstate one – especially as all the pilots have got jobs overseas.
But one of the hazards of being a former “insider” is that what you think is common knowledge, is not. When you work in Parliament you often have discussions on policy and soon work out what way the wind is blowing. Hence I don’t think I have heard anyone seriously advocate it should be reinstated since 2003 or so, but that doesn’t mean that was the public perception.
But did National still publicly hold out in 2005 that such a reinstatement is likely? Well I went to National’s 2005 Defence Policy. And you know there is not a single word in that policy about the Air Force Strike Wing. Nope, not even a word.
So bearing in mind the 2005 election policy was silent on the strike wing, I still have to disagree with both Colin and Paul that this is a major change.
And if we go back into the Herald archives (bless them for keeping them all searchable), we find an August 2005 story which says “Mr Carter confirmed that any prospect of re-establishing the Air Force strike wing was remote”.
I rest my case.
I also disagree that this is a vindication for the decision. It isn’t vindication, except for Father Time. It’s just a reality that the longer time goes on, the harder it is to reverse something.
If you asked all 48 National MPs, do they think the decision to get rid of the F16s was a bad decision, I’d guess 40 – 45 of them would say yes. But if you also asked them do they think National in 2009 should try and reinstate the strike wing, then I’d predict 47 out of 48 would say no.
The same goes for Labour. Ask the 50 Labour MPs if they agree with National’s 1991 benefit cuts and all 50 of them will say no. And again ask all 50 if they think Labour should reverse those benefit cuts, and 40 or so will say no.
A friend in SAFE tells me that TV3 will show on 60 Minutes tonight details of a New Zealand animal breeding facility that is one of the largest animal-testing facilities in the Southern Hemisphere.
The facility is thought to have up to 200 beagles being used for research.
SAFE have set up a an online petition, a public forum and a website at www.banbeagleexperiments.org.nz, available immediately after the screening of 60 Minutes. The site is partially available now and looks very slick.
I’m not opposed to all animal use in research, but I think it is a very valid debate about what the extents should be, and how necessary each individual research case is.
After the great response to the help us pick a name post, we’ve now got ten finalists for the official name, and unlike the parties behind the Electoral Finance Bill we believe in democracy, so you can get to vote on the best name for us all to use in referring to this bill.
Many thanks to Survey.Net.NZ for the facilities.
UPDATE: Previous poll had a coding error so vote again if you have already voted.
Today’s Press editorial is unimpressed with Labour
Labour’s efforts to demonise National leader John Key are a measure of its own desperation and panic
These shrill attacks have thus far failed to dent Key’s credibility and each time the National leader bats away an allegation it is the Government which looks ridiculous and rattled.
The political acumen Labour exhibited on taking office eight years ago has been replaced by the tired misjudgments of a third-term administration, including its Key-bashing.
Bereft of fresh faces and ideas to address the real issues of concern to New Zealanders, Labour has instead rounded on Key personally. There is a strong sense of political reversal in this, as an attack strategy is normally the weapon of an Opposition, not a Government. Most members of the public will see through and disdain this negative brand of politics. They will regard it as an admission by Labour that it can not handle Key and is desperate to destroy him by any means before the next election campaign. Far from doing this, all the attacks have achieved is to give Key even more publicity and possibly public sympathy.
Key does have question marks over his leadership strength. He is still politically inexperienced, as shown by his occasional gaffes and hints of flip-flops, and he has yet to show that he has the policy substance to go with his undoubted personal style. Ministers can legitimately scrutinise Key on these grounds, but its smear campaign belongs in the rubbish bin, not in the political arena.
Exactly. The attacks on him over the lack of clarity on the Complementary Medicines Bill were valid and what one expects. Likewise contrasting his views on Iraq five years ago and today is valid (if overdone and not the killer blow Labour thinks it is). But trying to smear him not on the basis of what he has done, but what some people he knows did four years before he went into business with them is not valid. Likewise in the House suggesting he is of bad or malign character because he helped the SFO with an inquiry into a business he once worked at, is also not valid.
But the smears will not stop. Helen Clark, who is normally the first to whine loudly whenever anything negative is said about her, says on NZPA this morning that “personal scrutiny is part of politics and National’s leader John Key should stop “bleating” about Labour’s attacks on him”.
Now one could say the PM is being a hypocrite, but really her position is consistent and clear. Do as she says, not as she does.
Some of the old RSS feeds do not work anymore. The only working feed for posts is:
https://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/feed
One can also do an RSS feed for comments from:
It is worth remembering as one considers the Electoral Finance Bill that while Labour drafted it, the Greens have bene unashamed cheerleaders for it. Like Labour, at most they’ll just concede some minor tweaking may be needed.
Now in the latest post from Russel Norman he attacks National for attacking the Bill and calls on them to be constructive and help make this a beter bill.
Now this would almost be laughable if it were not so sad. Labour, Winston and the Greens negotiate in secret this incredibly flawed bill. They refuse to take up the many months of requests from National to be consulted on the bill. They refuse to allow multi-party discussions on the bill, and then in a tone of pious indignation they complain that National is not being constructive.
National was in fact planning to vote for the bill if it had been a workable bill that did what it promised it would do. But as it became apparent what a travesty the bill is, they did the principled thing and refused to support it.
The Greens should be ashamed for their role to date. Labour could not have introduced this bill without their support. They could have insisted on a multi-party approach to the legislation. More importantly they could have insisted on a public policy process instead of a secret one. But they sold their votes out for almost nothing.
Perhaps the Greens should listen to one of their Youth MPs, Jaz Morris. Here is his take on the Electoral Finance Bill:
The Labour party, the so-called workers’ party, has really become a power hungry club for sold-out Fabian socialists – instead of leading on the basis of democracy and freedom. The status quo surrounding election spending clearly has problems. But to go from this to a law of minimal public involvement and red tape seems a bit of a leap. If Labour really wanted the most democratic elections possible, firstly it would throw out the EFB and secondly it might deal with the exact problems it seeks to ‘solve.’
The EFB needs to be destroyed, not just because it is dangerously anti-democratic but because doing so sends Labour a clear message – back to the drawing board on policy, ethos and political aim.
Jaz is right. Labour should not be helped out and saved for having introduced such a draconian bill. They should have every party in Parliament turn around, whack them around the head a couple of times, and told to come back and do it properly.
The effective deadline of Christmas 2007 for changes to the Electoral Act should not be used by the Greens and others as an excuse to pass unto law a bill which is not only so badly flawed, but has also not been part of any public policy process in terms of its underlying principles.
If the Greens continue to push the Electoral Finance Bill down such a flawed path, simply because of their desire to have law changes done before Christmas, then they are doing the classic case of the ends justify the means.
Worst of all they are doing it to one of the cornerstones of our constitution.
The Dom Post reports on National saying it is unlikely to reinstate the air combat wing of the RNZAF if it wins office.
This has been a near certainty since National failed to win office in 2002. The longer one is from a decision, the harder it is to over-turn it. In the case of the air combat wing you have real personnel problems as many have gone off to work overseas, and are most unlikely want to come back to NZ if their job tenure may only be six or nine years until Labour gains office again.
This is why parties are so keen to avoid being one term Governments. Most of your policies can be over-turned if you have only been in for three years. It is much much harder once they have been in for six or nine years.
For example Labour removed choice and competition for accident compensation insurance in 2000 after National introduced it in 1998/99. Now if National had done it in 1995, then there is no way in hell Labour would have been able to remove the choice that people had got used to.
In an NZ Herald article where Pete Hodgson defends his obsession with John Key instead of minor stuff like waiting lists, A&E Departments etc, Pete says:
“there was no orchestrated rollout of attacks”
Oh wait I have heard this line before I think. Around 20 years ago maybe. Back then it was:
“there was no orchestrated litany of lies”
Both statements are about as believable as each other.
NZPA Political Editor Peter Wilson has done his weekly column (not online) on how the lessons of the past are lost on Labour. Some extracts:
Day after day, cabinet ministers have been standing up in Parliament and making fools of themselves.
They should cut their losses and give it up, because it isn’t working.
None of the vague allegations have been substantiated and Key, for a relatively inexperienced politician, is showing a remarkable survival instinct.
Labour is giving National the opportunity to say the Government should pay some attention to running the country.
It has taken its eye off the ball, English told Parliament last week. People are worried about mortgage rates, not about where John Key lived in 2002, he said.
English is probably right too. Ministers have allowed real issues to appear to be eclipsed by their obsession with Key.
They are also looking desperate, even though that is the last thing they want people to think.
Labour has reason to be worried but they need to go to plan B, if there is one, to get out of the plight they are in.
I’m not sure there is much of a Plan A.