Herald comments on where John Key lives

Do minor parties do better in the election campaign?

I noted in a NZ Herald discussion on how badly most minor parties were polling, it is taken as gospel that minor parties pick up support in an election campaign, and major parties lose support.

Now this is a pretty logical proposition, but what is the empirical evidence.  Let’s start with 1996.

In 1996 Labour averaged 17% in the CB poll before the campaign, and got 28%.  National averaged 39% and got 34%. NZ First averaged 22% and got 13%. Alliance averaged 12% and got 10%. ACT averaged 3% and got 6%.  Christian Coalition averaged 3% and got 4%.

Conclusion: Not true in 1996.  Labour got 11% more than it polled, and from the minors only ACT got significantly more than it polled.

In 1999 Labour averaged in all polls 42% and got 39%. National averaged 36% and got 31%. NZ First averaged 4% and got 4%.  Alliance averaged 7% and got 8%. ACT averaged 5% and got 7%.  Greens averaged 1% and got 5%.

Conclusion: Partly true in 1999.  Labour and National got a bit less than they had been polling, and some minors got a bit more.  Greens were the big improver but this is more because like ACT in 1996 they were a new party.

In 2002 National averaged 32% and got 21%. Labour averaged 51% and got 41%. ACT averaged 4% and got 7%. NZ First averaged 3% and got 10%. United averaged 0.4% and got 7%. Greens averaged 6% and got 7%.

Conclusion: True in 2002.  Labour and National each got around 10% less than they had been polling, and all minors got a lot more except for the Greens. 

In 2005 National averaged 36% and got 39%. Labour averaged 43% and got 41%. Maori averaged 2% and got 2%. ACT averaged 2% and got 1.5%.  NZ First averaged 7% and got
6%. United averaged 2% and got 3%. Greens averaged 5% and got 5%.

Conclusion: Not true in 2005.  Labour and National each got a higher vote than they had been polling. All minors were within 1% of their average polling level.
So the assertion that minor parties pick up support in the campaign period from major parties is far from a rule.  It has only conclusively been true once in 2002.  It was partly true in 1999 but false in 1996 and 2005.

Willie and John

Willie Jackson and John Tamihere have announced they are standing for the respective mayoralties of Manukau City and Waitakere City.

I think this is great, as big cities need big mayors.

I have long been a firm believer that party politics should not play a strong role in local body elections.  Certainly I have voted for Labour and Green candidates for Wellington City Council – not because they are Labour or Green but despite that.  I believe in the best people for the job.

Now Willie is a former Alliance MP and John a former Labour MP. But I would be voting for both those guys over Len Brown or Bob Harvey. I don’t know either of them really well, but had a bit to do with John when he was an MP, and gotten to know Wille a bit this year as we have both been on the Good Morning political panel on TV One.

The reason why I think their candidacies is a good thing is because the Mayoralty is about leadership.  A strong high profile Mayor can do wonders for a city.  It isn’t about who can chair a meeting well (even though that helps), or other administrative tasks.

Auckland City is a great example of what happens when you don’t have a strong Mayor. Hubbard has had a hellish three years because he can’t control his Council.  It doesn’t matter than you have only one vote – you have the pulpit and can use it.  A strong Mayor can generate public support for a vision and direction and get people behind them, and the Council will fall in behind.

For the first time in maybe a generation there are going to be very exciting and probably very close races in Auckland, Waitakere and Manukau.  Much more fun then in Wellington where Lower Hutt is probably the only competitive race for Mayor.

And this week’s decision is …

Desperation

Labour have been trying to push for months on end some sort of smoking gun (more a damp water pistol) about where John Key lives and how it compares to his electoral residence.

They have a nerve doing this as it was a Labour MP (and Alliance MP) who some years ago was found to be claiming a living out of Wellington allowance, despite being on the Wellington Central electoral roll.

In Key’s case, there is no pecuniary gain involved, but more to the point he actually went and got a written legal opinion from the Clerk of the House which advised how he could register a different electoral address to a company’s address.

The Herald has a story on this. John Armstrong also writes in his column that Labour risks sinking itself deeper into the electoral mire.  Also a Dom Post story on how this is going nowhere.

Of course when you have run out of ideas and policy, and you can’t even provide substance to the carbon neutral rhetoric, this is the only thing left.

Maybe it is okay to call it the Mugabe Bill

People get very upset if one compares the Government and its Electoral Finance Bill to overseas repressive regimes. But NZ Herald Political Editor Audrey Young blogs:

Great ironies at Parliament today.

Madam Zhu Lilan of the 10th National People’s Congress of the Republic of China was talking to the education committee about advances in opening up the Chinese education system, while National leader John Key was talking to the press club about the repressive, anti-democratic Electoral Finance Bill – that of which the Gang of Four would have been proud.

The simple fact is it is repressive and anti-democratic.

The Herald also reports that Labour has said it may negotiate on the bill with National, but only if National stops attacking it. Hilarious. National asked a dozen times before it got released to be consulted. It asked for a multi-party approach to it. Labour spat in National’s face and refused any dialogue. And now when they have f**ded themselves over with such a repressive bill, they want National to bail it out.

As a minor rebuke to the Herald, I should point out they have reported the EB’s campaign as $1.2 million. That is an alleged figure, and is disputed and should not be reported as fact.

Should Open XML become an international standard

Media on Tasman hostilities

A couple of editorials on the fighting between Clark/Goff and the Australian Government.

The Dom Post today notes:

Australia is New Zealand’s nearest neighbour, its closest ally and biggest trading partner.

For those reasons it beggars belief that any New Zealand government would allow a trivial domestic issue to damage the relationship.

Yet that is exactly what Prime Minister Helen Clark and her Labour colleagues have allowed to occur with their hysterical reaction to the news that Air New Zealand ferried about 600 Australian troops to the Middle East in June.

Miss Clark has accused Mr Downer of breaking an unspoken convention by addressing a National Party conference earlier this month. (The convention apparently does not exist between New Zealand and Britain. John Prescott twice addressed Labour conferences as Britain’s deputy prime minister.)

Today, thanks in no small part to the efforts of the public servant being pilloried for the troops debacle, the Foreign Affairs and Trade Ministry chief executive, and former high commissioner to Canberra, Simon Murdoch, Australia’s prime minister and his senior ministers meet at least annually with their New Zealand counterparts.

The Government should also consider the wisdom of publicly berating a public servant of Mr Murdoch’s standing. Mr Murdoch made a mistake, for which he has apologised, when he failed to alert ministers to the flights. But it was not the sort of mistake that warranted Deputy Prime Minister Michael Cullen’s veiled threat that it would be “taken into account at his next performance review”.

Mr Murdoch, a proud and, on occasions, prickly individual, is widely regarded as the outstanding public servant of his generation. If even he is going to be thrown to the wolves at the first hint of trouble, the future recruitment of high-quality public servants is only going to become more difficult.

And the Press also today:

 This mess was triggered a week ago, when it emerged that Air New Zealand had flown Australian troops to the Middle East, en route to Iraq. If it seemed of little consequence, the Government decided to treat it as a monumental scandal. As a result, it brought itself a squabble with the Australians, as well as damaging both Air New Zealand and the civil service.

That Clark is not managing this test of her temper well is illustrated by how, just as she complained about Australian interference in New Zealand’s politics, she ventured an opinion on the wisdom of Australian Labor leader Kevin Rudd’s drunken visit to a strip club.

There are other difficulties for Labour in the fallout of the troop-flights saga. Its heavy-handed treatment of Air New Zealand, a listed company, is cause for concern among investors. More alarming is the kicking it has given senior civil servants.

Labour seems to think it should treat the public service as a political wing, directing ministries over staff appointments and publicly berating chief executives if they fail to read the PM’s mind. It is laying the ground for a crisis in confidence between the public service and the Beehive. If it is allowed to take hold, it will only feed the sense of a Government which keeps finding corners to back itself into, and which is flailing as it looks for the way out.

You know I generally now believe that on current boundaries, National can’t win Wellington Central.  But if Labour keeps up its jihads against a neutral public service, then maybe on a good day the right candidate could win it.

The Shane Wenzel thread

I posted back in May on Shane Wenzel, and his reported activities.

It got a few dozen comments at the time.

However the thread will not die and it is now up to 321 comments.  Why?  Well Mr Wenzel himself and some of his critics  have been slamming each other backwards and forwards for weeks on end.

It may break the record for longest thread.  Also for most number of insults.  Read them all if you have the time.

John Key on Electoral Finance Bill

John Key is taking the opportunity of an address to the National Press Club to deal to the Electoral Finance Bill. I’m delighted to see the Leader of the Opposition take on this issue personally. There is no greater issue before us than this bill in my opinion.

The speech is superb, and I really encourage people to read it in full because it tells a story that a few extracts won’t do justice to. However as usual here are some quotes:

This is not just a poorly written bill, not just an ill-conceived bill, and not just a bad bill, although it is certainly all of those. Most of all, this is a dangerous bill. It is dangerous for all of us as individuals, it is dangerous for our democracy, and it is dangerous for New Zealand.

One of the key planks of democracy is that all citizens are free to express themselves on all political issues.

They are free to criticise the government. They are free to criticise the opposition. They are free to promote policies they like and protest against policies they abhor.

They march, they make placards, they deliver leaflets. They produce brochures, they send emails, they build websites. They take out advertisements in the paper, they call public meetings, they circulate petitions.

Two of the most powerful examples in recent years have been the debates over the foreshore and seabed, and over the smacking legislation. People had strong opinions, they were organised and they had their say, often loudly. A healthy democracy doesn’t just tolerate this – in fact, it requires it.

This is about the fundamentals of our democracy. I have said before that if I had to choose between losing my voice and losing my vote, I would go for the latter as I only get to vote once every three years but exercise my free speech rights every day.

 

English sportswriter Martin Johnson once said there were only three things wrong with the England cricket team – they can’t bat, they can’t bowl, and they can’t field.

In a similar vein, I think there are “only” three things wrong with the Electoral Finance Bill – the regulated election period is ludicrously long, the definition of publishing an election advertisement is ludicrously wide, and the hurdles that third parties have to jump are ludicrously high.

I love the analogy. The salient point is that these are not minor details to be tweaked at select committee. They are the core of the bill. I would also add on the limits are far far too low.

 

So next year, when you wake up on New Year’s Day, you will find that you are in an election period. It may not feel like that. You may think you’re on holiday at the beach or at a camping ground. Politicians and elections are likely to be the furthest things from your mind.

However, this bill makes it so that from 1 January on, and for up to 11 months, you are in an election period where free speech is tightly regulated and restricted. Because this period is so long, New Zealanders could spend up to 30% of their adult lives in a period of restricted speech. That is totally unacceptable.

Absolutely. Any period of restriction should be the minimum necessary. In Canada the restrictions only apply from the issuing of the writs – six weeks or so.

 

 

The bill also introduces a new type of election advertisement. The bill counts as an election advertisement any form of words or graphics that takes a position on a proposition with which a party or a candidate is associated.

On top of this, the definition of publishing an election advertisement covers buying advertising space in a newspaper – which you’d expect – but also includes handing out a leaflet, displaying a placard, issuing a press release, sending an email, posting on a website, and mailing a letter. The definition is so wide that it includes almost all forms of communication except for speaking to someone face to face.

The effect of this new definition is actually to put politicians in an incredibly privileged position in our society.

In an election year there are no restrictions on publicly discussing an issue until such a time as a party or candidate takes a position on that issue. Once a member of the “political elite” has taken a view, however, every other New Zealander is restricted in how they can advocate on that issue. In an election year, ordinary New Zealanders are relegated to being second-class citizens.

As I have said before, the Electoral Commission will need an RSS feed of banned topics so we can keep up to date with what issues are now off limits to the plebs. The moment an issue is associated with a party or candidate, we are restricted in what we can say about it.

 

This bill – this bill which the Government says will “help promote participation in parliamentary democracy” – says that no one, except political parties, can take out more than two full-page ads in a major newspaper over the course of an entire year about anything touching on politics.

How dare the Government propose a measure like that. Do we live in a democracy or don’t we? Are we free to express ourselves on all political issues?

In this country you have a right to have your say on Labour policy, on National policy, on Green policy, on any policy you like, and you have a right not be muzzled by the government.

 

Think about what would happen if the smacking debate or the debate about the foreshore and seabed occurred in an election year under the provisions of this bill. Discussion of these issues would have been restricted and debate would have been muted. And that would have suited the Government just fine.

 

It will also greatly disadvantage groups which comment on a wide range of policies. For the $60,000 is not per issue but per organisation for the year. So if Family First spends it $60,000 on the anti smacking debate, it then can’t advertise on any other issue. If the Automobile Association spends $60,000 campaigning for less congested roads in Auckland it can’t then spend any money advocating for Transmission Gully in Wellington.

 

But the biggest exemption is for MPs, who can publish whatever they like if they are doing it as an MP. That includes spending taxpayers’ money on a pledge card. If Labour puts out a pledge card in the next election, it will not count towards the Labour Party’s election spending cap.

They really have no shame. It is a blatant gerrymandering of our constitution to protect the current Government.

 

Also, government departments can continue to spend unlimited amounts of taxpayers’ money publicising policies, as we’ve seen with the millions of dollars of KiwiSaver and Working for Families ads – and they can do this right up to the day of the election.

Basically, this bill is saying: don’t you worry, citizens of New Zealand – leave all the politics to politicians, the media and bloggers. We’ll tell you want to think. You can trust us.

Hey I object to bloggers being tied in with media 🙂

 

This deeply flawed and anti-democratic bill needs to be ripped up and tossed in the bin.

The Prime Minister says there’s no need for that. She says any problems with the bill will be ironed out by the select committee, which contains representatives from all parties.

The problem is we are not talking about ironing out glitches, or correcting drafting errors, which is what select committees are good at. We are talking about a bill that is a total and utter mess. It is so heavy-handed it replaces 32 sections of the Electoral Act with 158 of its own. And we are talking about a bill that has been developed in completely the wrong way.

I agree. It can’t be fixed. It is far too important an Act to have last minute badly drafted law changes made to it.

 

Key then points out he is not oppossed to changes, but wants them developed, with consultation, based off the existing Act:

 

We would support a limit on third-party spending in an election period. Political parties and candidates are capped in their spending so it makes sense that third parties are as well. Organisations should not be allowed to spend unlimited sums of money trying to influence an election.

 

Also my position.

 

We are also prepared to see changes that make donations to parties more transparent. The fact there are no such proposals in the Electoral Finance Bill is because Labour chose not to include them. It is not due to National in any way whatsoever. We have consistently said we are open to changes in this area.

It is good to have the Opposition Leader himself reaffirm that National does support the change that almost everyone except Helen Clark wants. Her dropping of the sections dealing with this was disgraceful with the only justification being Labour needs the money.

 

In my view, political parties and other organisations need to know in advance when the election is to be held so they can comply with the law. I think serious consideration should be given to making the government give three months notice of the election date. When such notice is given, the regulated election period could then begin.

That would be a great move. Clark will never do it, but let’s hold National to that when they are in office. As a campaign manager last time I can tell you how bloody difficult it is to plan sensibly when you don’t even know if your expenditure is going to count or not until some weeks after you authorise it.

 

And then some ending words on the bill of rights:

 

Here in New Zealand we often take our democratic freedoms for granted. We think they will always be there. We have a Bill of Rights which is supposed to protect our right to freedom of expression. What on Earth could go wrong?

I have a different view. I believe what Thomas Jefferson said – that the price of freedom is eternal vigilance. We cannot and we must not take democratic freedoms for granted.

Because, in reality, it is not a Bill of Rights that protects our rights. It is not up to a solicitor in the Crown Law Office or an official in the Ministry of Justice. In the end, it is not up to the government at all.

The protection of rights lies with us, the citizens of New Zealand. There are times when we have to stand up for our rights, and the rights of our neighbours and friends, and indeed the rights of people we totally disagree with, or else these rights will begin to erode away.

We should count ourselves lucky that standing up for democracy in this country doesn’t involve marching through tear gas, or printing leaflets in a hidden cellar, or standing in front of a tank.

But little battles can be as important as big ones. And, though it is not as glamorous or as terrifying, you are just as much fighting for democracy by putting a submission on the Electoral Finance Bill.

You don’t have to agree with my analysis of what should change. You should make up your own mind and you should express it with the courage of your convictions.

That is what living in a democracy is all about.

Absolutely. This issue is too important to remain silent on. And yes I will be providing some guides to people for making submissions. It doesn’t take long to say “Kill the Bill” as it infringes on your rights to criticise the Government and other parties.

 

Incidentally here’s an ironic challenge for the lawyers. If this bill is passed, will sending in a submission to a bill, if done in election year, count as an election advertisement and be illegal unless you do a statutory declaration or register? I’d say it will be.

 

NZ Law Journal on Electoral Finance Bill

To see the NZ Law Journal editorial on the EFB, and also a review of electoral law publications by Richard Prebble, click on the link below:

NZ Law Journal on Electoral Finance Bill

I hope the NZLJ doesn’t object to me showing the articles to a wider audience.

The conclusion of the editorial is worth repeating:

It is possible that some of the more bizarre provisions are there to be negotiated away so that parties in the House will feel they have achieved something and vote for the amended Bill. That should not happen. This Bill is fundamentally obnoxious and should be scrapped.

The only person left defending the Bill is Winston Peters.  That should tell us a lot about why it must be defeated.

Better late than never

While the timing is unfortunate, nevertheless the Government has done the right thing in formally taking Australia to the World Trade Organisation over their 86-year blocking of our apple exports.

No-one could claim we have rushed into it!

The Australian Government will fight it of course, because they have to keep the locals back home happy.  But they will almost certainly lose, but then the WTO gets blamed instead of the Government.  This is the good thing about a rules based system – you have to follow them.

It will take a while though.  I’d pick around 2015 for the first NZ apple to make it to Australia.

Newspaper websites and blogs all closed down

Bill English has pointed out in Parliament that the Electoral Finance Bill only has an exemption for newspapers, but not for websites and blogs run by newspapers. And as they no doubt cost more than $60,000 a year to run, and certainly take positions on propositions associated with political parties, we can say goodbye to Herald online and Stuff next year if the bill is passed in its current form.

You see in the exceptions to what is an election advertisement in Clause 5(2), we have paragraph (c):

any content of a newspaper or periodical that has been selected by, or with the authority of, the editor of the newspaper or periodical solely for the purpose of informing or entertaining its readership

And a website is not a newspaper or periodical. And as Colin Espiner’s and Audrey Young’s blogs are not done on a non commercial basis (they are part of their paid jobs), their blogs will have to go also.

Yes, once again, the bill really is that bad.

The Government can’t even deny in the House it isn’t that bad. All Burton can say is:

Questions about the bill would be answered at select committee hearings, where MPs would receive expert advice about how key sections of the bill would be interpreted

Now this is crap. The Minister has tens time the number of expert advisers than the Select Committee has. It is a disgrace he can not get up in Parliament and answer questions on it.

This shows why the bill must be killed. The Government will just claim the interpretations are wrong, and then come election year it will be too late. Because the most nasty part of the bill is that once it is passed, you will not be able to spend more than $60,000 in election year criticising the bill itself.

Anyway this bill might be great for me. If Herald and Stuff and TVNZ have to close their websites down, I might get some of their advertising dollars 🙂

Air NZ and the “national interest”

I shouldn’t be surprised that it is top business and political journalist Fran O’Sullivan who covers the near illegal orders the Government has given Air New Zealand.  So many journalists wouldn’t know about the Companies Act. Fran writes:

Air NZ – in which the Government holds a 76 per cent stake – is not a state-owned enterprise.

But Cabinet ministers … now seem to believe they can order the publicly listed company to uphold non-specified “national interest” considerations.

Under the Companies Act it is clear that majority shareholders do not and cannot direct the company. Air NZ directors have fiduciary duties to run the company in the best interests of all shareholders – not to suck to the majority shareholder who appoints them.

Air NZ shareholders deserve to know a lot more about the Government’s definition of “national interest” and how any strictures will affect shareholder value.

But the NZX should be issuing “please explains” all round, given the huge number of uncertainties now on the table.

No shareholder – even a fabled “plaintiff of convenience” – has yet emerged to tackle the Government’s blatant interference in Air NZ’s business for what are really political ends. But if the Government continues down this capricious path, other Air NZ shareholders will get stroppy.At issue is, if the minister had known of the charter would he have advised Air NZ not to proceed? If so, what ramifications would this have for the company’s revenue? Would this have been a breach of Air NZ’s requirement to make continuous disclosure to all shareholders? And what ramifications would it have for the interests of other shareholders?

These are all good questions.  Air NZ is obliged by law and NZX to treat all shareholders equally.  If any market sensitive information is shared with Dr Cullen in their monthly meetings, then Air New Zealand Directors may be in the gun.

Waitemata Health

The Herald reports on the woman who had to wait for 30 hours in A&E at Waitemata before getting a bed.

She spent 13 hours on a drip in the waiting room, and then 17 hours on a trolley before getting a bed and then surgery the next day.

The Government claims it has increased doctor numbers at the hospital by 78%.  But the problem wasn’t doctors, but beds. How can health funding almost double and there not be enough beds in A&E?  Or at least capacity elsewhere.

MPs and Strip Clubs

The NZ Herald has a collection of MP responses to the strip club question.  Now I am as amused as anyone by the responses, but there is a serious question for the media in all this.  First the fun though:

Best story has to be Tim Barnett who took a bishop in his 80s to a gay strip club, as the bishop had always wanted to go.  How can onbe judge a man helping the church 🙂

Rodney Hide can recall some women taking their clothes off, so logically concludes they were probably strip clubs.  Either that, or just very friendly.

Sue Bradford discovered: “Gay male stripping is not necessarily that entertaining for women”.

And John Hayes had a great line: “”I used to work on the Cook Strait ferries. What do you think?”

Best metaphor goes to Jill Pettis:  She had been married for 36 years, so “Why go out for hamburger when you’ve got steak at home?”

But now to the serious issue.  Why are serious newspapers asking MPs this question?

The Kevin Rudd episode is legitimate news.  His strip club visit happened while he was an MP.  Worst it happened when he was travelling on taxpayer funded business.

But that doesn’t make it a legitimate question to be asking every MP about what they did before they were an MP.

There was a story in NZ (in Investigate Magazine) not so long ago about the private sexual escapades of an MP (and please do not name him in the comments – we all know who he is – I am just using the case as an example). That got almost totally ignored by the media, and certainly the NZ Herald did not go around all the other MPs asking them if they have ever done BDSM.

So why the double standard? How is asking MPs about whether they visited a strip club before they were MPs a legitimate question?

How to cut the dole numbers

Some headlines can’t be ignored

Online effects of the Electoral Finance Bill

Nathans Finance

Someone pointed out to me this PR on Scoop a year ago from Nathans Finace.  They announced:

  •  A 47% jump in net profit to $4.97 million
  • EBITDA of $17.7 million
  • Total assets up from $137 million to $172 million
  • An unblemished record of no bad debts

So what happened?

Rudd and Key

Heh, well if next year both Kevin Rudd and John Key are respective trans-Tasman Prime Ministers, they’ll have at least one thing in common – a visit to a New York strip club.

As it was long before politics, and not on a taxpayer funded trip, I doubt many people will be excited about it.

And I doubt anyone in Labour will try and make anything of it, considering the skeletons they may have. So basically quite amusing, but not significant.

UPDATE: Reliable sources inform me that the media story is somewhat inaccurate in that said visit did not take place while working in New York, but even longer ago – many many years ago.

Roy Morgan Poll

I don’t normally blog on individual polls as I prefer to just cover them all in Curia’s monthly newsletter.  However I am intrigued by the significant 4% drop to an all time low of 31% for Labour in the latest Roy Morgan poll.

roymorgan.JPG

The Morgan poll reports every fortnight and as the graph above shows, it has been pretty good at tracking the parties.  In 2005/2006 the TVNZ poll showed National ahead evrytime and the TV3 poll showed Labour ahead everytime.  I like Morgan because it correctly (in my opinion) showed the lead changing back and forwards several times. So Helen Clark may find it harder to dismiss this result as she did with the TVNZ poll.  Unless she is going to dismiss all results she doesn’t like.

I think Raymond Miller may be right – attacking John Key for his wealth, is a pretty dangerous strategy.  Maybe we are also starting to see some impact from the editorials and columns about the Electoral Finance Bill.

Hanging civil servants out to dry

I don’t think I can recall the last time a former State Services Commissioner or Deputy criticised the Government publicly, but Ross Tanner has spoken out regarding the tendency of Ministers to blame the Chief Executives, and hang them out to dry.

“There was a convention where in return for the loyalty and professionalism of the public service, ministers would actually answer in public and defend the actions, where they can, of their department,”

“What we’re seeing now is a tendency to pass the buck to the chief executive, and saying ‘you defend it’.”

Of course on top of this, civil servants are no longer trusted to be professional, if Ministers disapprove of their boyfriends.

Attacking success

The vast majority of New Zealanders think that people who do well, especially from humble beginnings, should be admired.  But Labour see John Key’s successful career in business (which of course can not match a career in lecturing in political science) as a bad thing.

The Herald reports how Labour has a deliberate strategy to attack Key’s wealth. Raymond Miller is quoted as saying he thinks the strategy is dangerous for Labour.  It is of course the politics of envy.  The best quote goes to Key himself:

“What we know is they don’t like people who are poor that become wealthy, and they don’t like people who are wealthy and stay wealthy – so the only conclusion can be that they want people who are wealthy to become poor and people who are poor to stay poor.”

Heh.

Pissing off our best friends

I have often praised Helen Clark for the way she has managed the trans-tasman relationship with John Howard, despite their political differences.  But she is trashing a lot of that good work with her petty attack on the Australian Foreign Minister.

First of all, the Australian Government has every right to be annoyed that their military are being treated like hostile insurgents insteaad of our closest ally. They have done nothing wrong except help the profitability of Air NZ.  Of course they are going to announce they will no longer use Air NZ, rather than go through the humiliation of the New Zealand Government defining when their money is good enough for us, as if they were Cuba.

A sensible Prime Minister would realise that Australia are the innocent party in the communication stuff up between MFAT and Ministers, and would send a quiet signal that no offence was intended, and we did not want to politicise their transport arrangements.

Instead Clark makes a personal attack on Downer, and brings up the red herring of his speech to a National Party conference.   Now the first thing to recall is that Helen Clark herself was informed of the speech in advance, and asked if she had any problems with it.  So for her to cry foul now, is cheap partisan tricks to avoid the issue of her Government’s hysterical over reaction to the Air NZ issue.

She then went on to say:

“It’s something we have refrained from doing over the 7½ years I’ve been in Government – I can tell you I have had numerous invitations from the Australian Labour Party to do the same.”

This is another red herring.  She is the Prime Minister and her counterpart is Howard, not Downer.

Furthermore her party has invited the Deputy Prime Minister of the UK and a state premier from Australia to their conferences.  She also accepts taxpayer funding to attend meetings of centre-left world leaders.

And finally I know several NZ Labour MPs, and in all probability Ministers, have attended Australian Labor Party conferences.

I also note that Clark talks about expecting Air NZ to be responsive to the national interest.  Air NZ is not an SOE.  It is a NZX listed company with private shareholders.

Oh just seen this story this morning,  where Clark now denies she had been briefed by Downer on the conference invitation.  So now she is calling Downer a liar.  Well of course we all know how bad her memory is, but perhaps they could release the official notes of that meeting.