Cairns Blog

The Bill of Wrongs

The Listener joins the chorus against the Electoral Finance Bill:

The new electoral spending proposals are anti-democratic.

When Justice Minister Mark Burton told Parliament that the government was “seeking to encourage full and open expression from a diverse range of interests in the run-up to a general election”, he must have known that he could hardly have been introducing a bill less likely to achieve that.

As drafted, the bill casts its net so widely that potentially something as innocuous as writing a personal letter saying “Don’t vote for so-and-so” would bring the writer under its auspices. It would be laughable if it were not so alarming.

If the bill is passed in this shoddy form, it would very likely result in hundreds and possibly thousands of New Zealanders inadvertently committing breaches of the law from January 1 next year. And it would be for no other reason than trying to do exactly what Burton, and most New Zealanders, would say is desirable, namely, having “full and open expression from a diverse range of interests in the run-up to a general election”.

The most grievous part of the proposals is the restrictions and impositions placed on “third parties”. Again, the government probably had in mind the Exclusive Brethren, but every group from Women’s Refuge to Federated Farmers would be affected. By the bill’s own definition, “election advertising” includes encouraging someone to vote or not to vote for one or more parties, and is also defined as “taking a position on a proposition with which one or more candidates, or one or more parties, is associated”.

So, other than political parties, no individual or group is allowed to spend more than $60,000, which is about the cost of one full-page ad in three metropolitan newspapers on a single day, in the entire calendar year up until the election, commenting on any subject on which any party has a policy. And the group will first have to register with the Electoral Commission. That is not fostering full and open expression. Rather, it gives the government a largely unfettered run in election year. It is an embarrassment that the bill in its present form has been put before Parliament.

But even that is not the end of it. If a group that is not an incorporated society happens to have even a single member who is not a registered voter – for example, because they might be only 17 – then that group is not allowed to become a registered third party and can spend no more than $5000 in election year.

And even those likely to spend less than $5000 are still caught in the net. As the Coalition for Open Government has pointed out, a student who writes in chalk on a footpath “Keep NZ GE Free” will have to sign a statutory declaration that their election expenses will not amount to more than $5000 and they will have to write alongside their slogan their full name and residential address. This restrictive and ridiculous bill will curb the vigorous and spontaneous debate that is desirable in a democracy in an election year.

The Electoral Finance Bill gives the strong impression that there has been a quantum shift in thinking about participation in public debate. Suddenly, it is as though any forms of communication to do with politics after January 1 – unless it is by the media, bloggers or the government itself (and possibly even some government communications will be caught) – are dangerous and need to be monitored and restricted. The proposition is absurd. There is no evidence to support it. It is not the public’s excess that needs curbing in this draconian proposal, it is the government’s.

Public submissions on this bill are now being sought. People should have their say. If they don’t, after January 1 they may find they cannot say much at all.

If a business meeting was run like a blog

Newspaper Readership

The latest Nielsen newspaper readership figures show a general decline, but some exceptions in comparing June 2007 to June 2006:

  • NZ Herald 558,000 +1.6%
  • Sunday Star-Times 544,000 -5.9%
  • Sunday News 354,000 – 10.6%
  • Herald on Sunday 317,000 -0.6%
  • Dominion Post 245,000 -3.9%
  • The Press 221,000 -5.6%
  • Otago Daily Times 111,000 +2.8%
  • Waikato Times 95,000 +4.4%

Fairfax has to be worried – both Sunday newspapers are plummeting, and both major dailies also declining significantly.

Looking at magazines, we find:

  • NZ Woman’s Weekly 916,000 -3.9%
  • Woman’s Day 880,000 -1.5%
  • New Idea 503,000 – 5.6%
  • The Listener 275,000 -12.1%
  • North & South 262,000 -13.5%
  • Time Magazine 229,000 +4.6%
  • FHM 201,000 -6.5%
  • Metro 129,000 -16.2%
  • Investigate 60,000 -4.8%

Metro, North & South and The Listener are also all plummeting.

The fight for Wellington Central begins

Air NZ fiasco players

Audrey Young does a roundup on her blog of the main players of the Air New Zealand fiasco.

Young provides a good analysis of why Murdoch concluded there was nothing wrong with Air NZ providing the transport (mainly based on UN Security Council resolutions), but correctly concludes he still should have notified Ministers so it was their decision, not his.

I’m described in the blog post as a “Peters-baiter”.  Heh I like that as a title.  As I said though it was good to have him avoid the hysterics of Goff.  Normally it has been Goff as the calm nuanced one.

There’s one aspect to this, which I am surprised business journalists have not picked up on, and it is whether Dr Cullen has become a deemed Director of Air New Zealand, and could be sued by minority shareholders.

The Companies Act makes it very very clear majority shareholders do not and can not direct the company.  Directors have a strict fidicuary duty to run the company in the best interests of the company (hence all shareholders) and not to favour one or more large shareholders.

Now here is a case where the majority shareholder has intervened to force Air New Zealand to give up highly profitable business.  This has led to a loss of future profitability for the company and hence a decline in value for minority shareholders.

UN report on New Zealand

The UN (in fact a couple of people who work for the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination) has published its latest report on New Zealand, summarised by the NZ Herald.

Looking around the UN site, I found a word document with a list of questions the Special Rapporteur put to the Government.  They include why there are no special hate speech laws  (which have had a chilling effect in some countries).

Anyway taking their points in turn:

* United Nations report calls for renewed dialogue between the Government and Maori over the Foreshore and Seabed Act.

Dialogue is almost always a good idea.

* Praises the reduction of socio-economic disparities between Maori and Pacific people and the rest of the population.

This is good.

* Expresses concern about a proposal to remove statutory references to the Treaty of Waitangi.

This shows up factual inaccuracies in the UN’s understanding.  The proposal is to remove references to the principles, not the Treaty itself.

* Is concerned that steps taken to target programmes and policies on the basis of need rather than ethnicity may have been adopted in a “political climate unfavourable to the rights of Maori”.

Is there a right for targeting on the basis of ethnicity?  I always regard targeting by ethnicity to be a second best option to targeting individuals at need.

* Recommends the Government consider granting the Waitangi Tribunal legally binding powers to adjudicate Treaty matters.

Never going to happen.  Cedes too much soveriginity from the elected Parliament.

* Raises concern that there are no explicit references to the Treaty of Waitangi in the draft school curriculum.

Aren’t there? I’m surprised.

* Calls for efforts to address the Maori prison population to be a high priority.

Takes two to tango!

Kill the Bill

Rudd’s strip club visit

I don’t expect it will have a big impact on how people vote, but the revelation that Kevin Rudd not just visited a strip club when he was on an official trip to the UN in New York in 2003, but allegedly was overly touchy with the staff won’t exactly be helpful (well maybe in Queensland it will be).

I have to say it was a bloody stupid thing to do when you are travelling on a diplomatic passport in an official capacity.  Voters not so much resent the strip club, as the taxpayer money going towards the trip.

Not that New Zealand MPs are immune from poor judgement.  I recall hearing in the 1990s how one Minister was due to speak at the UN, and on the day they were due to speak, still had not emerged from their room.  Finally one of the officials got a spare key, and entered the room to find not only the Minister much the worse for wear, but also a dancer from the nightclub they had been to the previous night!

Rudd’s defence that he doesn’t remember much of the night is one I can have some sympathy for.  I’ve only been to a strip club three times.  Once earlier this year at the insistence of some Young Labour girls et al (as the bars had all closed for Easter), and twice as part of a stag night for a mate getting married.  Now the two times that were on a stag night, I have no recollection of having been there.  If you asked me to describe the interior I would have no idea.  In fact I doubted I had even attended but for the testimony of others.

Life in Iran

Parliamentary Wikipedia edits

$50 a MB

I’ve pinged Vodafone for their $10 – $30/MB charges for data when roaming.  Well Rod Drury points out Telecom’s charges can be as much as $50/MB.  Outrageous.

Just reading Stuff’s frontpage would cost you $38.20.

A link shows that in the UK Vodafone mobile data charges are only 1 pound a day for up to 15MB a day.

McCarten on Auckland Elections

Matt McCarten reviews his earlier predictions re the four Auckland mayoralties.

In Auckland City he is no longer picking Hubbard to win over Banks, but he does say Banks could still lose is Swney picks up enough support.

In Manukau, he says that if Willie Jackson stands, it will be a three-way race between Jackson, Len Brown and Dick Quax.

McCarten also hints that Tamihere may stand for the Waitakere Mayoralty against Bob Harvey.  That will be a fascinating battle if he does.

UnitedFuture

I’ve been busy so forgot to have some fun with United Future who in a cunning rebrand are now UnitedFuture.

I hope they didn’t pay Saatchi’s $100,000 for that, let alone the new logo which Gonzo points out looks like a purple cup with avocado in it.

Anyway whatever they call themselves, they still owe the taxpayer over $20,000.

HoS on Electoral Finance Bill

The Herald on Sunday labels the Electoral Finance Bill an affront to freedom of speech.  Some extracts:

Legislation passed to address specific problems is almost invariably bad law. So it is with the Electoral Finance Bill, which is an egregious challenge to democracy and our freedom to express political opinions.

It is hard to imagine a piece of legislation more ill-conceived or repugnant to the New Zealand version of democracy. 

The HoS also understands the critical issue – the legislation is so flawed that it can not be made acceptable by a select committee.

Justice Minister Mark Burton – echoed by the Prime Minister – has responded to the chorus of disapproval from lobby groups, constitutional experts, media commentators and the Government’s political opponents by coughing and mumbling that the bill will undergo amendment after consideration by a select committee whose deliberations will, in turn, be informed by public submission. But that is somewhat worse than no answer at all. Select committees exist to make fine adjustments to legislation or – more often – to finesse their political management so as to ensure they have adequate support when they are reported back to the House. They can also ensure that laws have a decent burial when they are euthanased in the committee room. They do not exist to redesign, clause by clause, legislation as shoddy as this.

The bill must be killed.  Simple as that.

Boobs on Bikes is back

Hilarious. Last year Dick Hubbard declared Boobs on Bikes must be stopped and that he would “move heaven and Earth to prevent any repeat”.

It seems God and Gaia are not onside with him, as Hubbard’s own Council has given it a licence for this Wednesday.

From the photos I saw last year, all the boobs looked fake and obviously surgically enlarged. If they’re going to have a parade, they should only allow non enhanced entries, just as sports events ban steroids.

NZ Herald on mental health attacks

Yay.  The NZ Herald has done an article on the disgusting attacks by the Government and Peters on Nick Smith.

Cullen and Peters miss the point when they say it is in response to Smith interjecting. No one is saying don’t hit back.  They are saying don’t hit back in that way.

Anyway it’s great that several hundred thousand people have now read what Cullen, Peters, King, Goff and Mallard say.  Hopefully the article will act as a brake on future insults.  There are dozens of ways to insult someone without getting nasty.

Shooting blind

John Armstrong writes in the Herald about the Air NZ fuss:

Labour is clearly fed up with constantly being forced on to the defensive.

With electoral defeat looming ever closer, Labour is shifting into survival mode, with trigger-happy ministers shooting first and asking questions later.

This was typified on Wednesday by Defence Minister Phil Goff letting fire with both barrels, firstly at Air New Zealand for flying troops into Kuwait, and then the Ministry of Foreign Affairs for failing to alert ministers to a breach of Government policy forbidding any involvement with combat operations in Iraq.

Goff’s apology should be to Peters. Not for the first time, Goff has trampled all over Peters’ portfolio. Previously, it has been as the reflex of a former foreign minister. This time, his motives were purely political.

Peters seemed remarkably relaxed about the incursion, though he pointedly mentioned he would get all the facts before apportioning blame.

Peters stood by his chief executive, accepting his apology and declaring that there the matter should rest. It was a show of respect and loyalty to one of the country’s most senior, most diligent and normally most dependable of public servants. However, standing by your officials has gone out of fashion in the Beehive where the default setting for any crisis is to see how much blame can be attached to officials, rather than ministers accepting responsibility.

Fran O’Sullivan comes in also:

The flights carrying Australian troops to the Middle East did not breach any United Nations sanctions, nor did they infringe on Government policy. That was the judgment call made by the country’s top diplomat six months ago when he effectively approved the flights as falling within Government policy parameters.

Now, Ministry of Foreign Affairs boss Simon Murdoch is being castigated by senior cabinet ministers for what the Stalinists would recognise as a political crime: failing to pre-judge six months ago that senior cabinet ministers like Phil Goff (and others) would decide to use New Zealand’s position on the Iraq war as a wedge against their National opponents – particularly leader John Key – with a damn-the-consequences approach.

Fran notes what damage this has done to our relationship with Australia.

Australia has now issued a formal sanction forbidding its 50,000 strong defence force to use Air New Zealand under any circumstances, including scheduled commercial flight travel.

In Canberra, Downer dressed down New Zealand Ambassador John Larkindale and requested High Commissioner John Dauth to express Australia’s “extreme displeasure” to Murdoch in New Zealand. Downer also pointed out the Kiwis had sent troops to Iraq after the fall of Baghdad.

That was also the judgment call made by the senior officials from police, defence, the Security Intelligence Service, the Government Communications Security Bureau, Foreign Affairs and the Office of Prime Minister and Cabinet, who were also told the airline was taking Australian troops to Kuwait, and assessed whether that posed a security threat to New Zealand.

Not one of them (or so we are told) decided the issue warranted attention by their political masters. It’s a pity those political masters did not take the same approach and laugh it off as the “latest conspiracy story” instead of making themselves – and New Zealand – a laughing stock.

I mean it is ridiculous.  The same Government which sent 61 troops into Iraq is now saying a private company (with a majority govt owner) can’t transport our closest allies to Kuwait.  And we won’t even mention how we also were transporting the Tongans and that somehow a commercial rather than charter flight is different.  One could argue having troops on commercial flights is a far bigger risk.  Hypocrisy abounds.

What a surprise

Online Banking Fraud

Good story in the NZ Herald about the issues around the banking code of practice.  The Dom Post and Computerworld have been on this issue, as has InternetNZ and Consumer’s Institute.

I’ve been part of the group working on the issue. It’s an interesting challenge defining where you draw the line between customers not being liable just because they don’t have say the latest security update, and not having any obligation at all on customers to keep their PCs or Internet Banking accounts secure.

Cullen abandons monetary policy consensus

This is a big story.  A very very big story.  Since the 1980s the bipartisan position of the NZ Government has been that monetary policy (or keeping inflation low) does not impact on the long-term sustainable rate of growth of the economy.

In fact the premise accepted by almost every OECD country is that you simply can not get higher long-term growth by simply having more inflation.   It isn’t that easy, and there is plenty of empirical evidence against the pre-1970s view that you could.

Dr Cullen has said he no longer believes in this:

“The accepted consensus has been that … monetary policy helps keep the economy stable by moderating economic cycles, without impacting on the sustainable rate of growth of the economy.

“My overriding concern is that this view no longer holds,”

He later told The Dominion Post he and the Reserve Bank were at odds.

“Oh yes, I have doubts about that consensus. I think it is probably the view the Reserve Bank would still hold but it’s not a view that I would share.”

Again this is very big.

The Minister of Finance no longer supports the official monetary policy of the Government.   He does it seems believe one gets higher long term growth by having higher inflation.

How does poor Dr Bollard do his job, when his Minister is saying he disagrees with what the bank is trying to do.

As Dr Cullen no longer accepts the consensus view on monetary policy, maybe a journalist could get him to explain what his view now is.  Could he specify how high a rate of inflation he would support to boost long-term economic growth.  What level of inflation do we need to grow faster than Australia?

A question

Which two New Zealand politicians actually have sent more than 60 New Zealand military personnel into Iraq since the war began in 2003.  Was it?

(a) Don Brash and Simon Power

(b) Helen Clark and Mark Burton

(c) John Key and Bill English

(d) The Exclusive Brethren and Investigate Magazine

Additional questions are:

  • Did the NZ troops  travel there by plane or did they walk?
  • Was their original six month mission extended to 12 months by the same politicians?
  • Were over 60 NZers lives put at risk by that deployment?
  • Was the location they worked in dangerous with kidnappings and violence, forcing them to shelter in their base camp?

Sedition submissions

Very much enjoyed the hearing on the sedition repeal bill.

First up was the Human Rights Commission, whom it seemed didn’t put a written submission in and were explaining that they were short of resources. I didn’t hear all of their hearing.

I was second up, and started off by saying that as someone who specialises in exciting the odd bit of disaffection against the Government, I was quite pleased to see the bill.
They had my written submission so I then made just two points.

  1. There were 11 other sections of the Crimes Act which could be used more appropriately in relation to undesirable acts from treason to threatening to destroy property.
  2. It has never really been used for its intended purpose of basically someoen trying to overthrow the state, and I highlight that it was aolmost comical that a Dunedin pub owner was charged with sedition but given diversion as a first time offender, as this summoned up images of someone being told “You’re a naughty boy for trying to overthrow the country, but we’ll let you off with a warning”.

The questions were all pretty supportive. I got nervous at one point as Chris Finlaysosn said he did want to challenge one of my assertions (my para 2) but upon rereading it he was satisfied I hadn’t said that one should never be held criminally liable for what one says – just that generally one should not. As the rep from Maxim found out it is best not to be at the wrong end of Chris!

Nandor did ask if I could confirm whether or not I did want to overthrow the Government and I confirmed that yes I do, but only through democratic means 🙂 – this led to a slight diversion about how the ends do not justify the means with Fiji as an example.

Next up was Idiot/Savant (his post on the experience is there). I had alluded to him as being the historical expert on sedition cases and he laid out some of the ridiculous examples from the past. The MPs found nothing to disagree with and the only discussion really was around a related issue of promoting terrorism.

Maxim followed I/S and argued against the bill. They said the definition should be more narrow but there was a need to protect legitimate authority as an important symbolic value. Chris Finlayson was in very sharp form attacking their arguments (and Chris is someone who has argued before the Privy Council more than possibly any other NZer) and the point was made that anti-heresy laws didn’t do much to stop heresy. This got both I/S and me excited at the opportunity to have a go at getting rid of blasphemous libel at some future stage.

Finally we had the Police, with the main rep being the Detective Superintendant in charge of all Police Prosecutions. He referred to the three recent cases of sedition charges being laid and was very upfront with his view that in two of the cases it was inappropiate to have used the sedition charge. There was some debate over how justified it was in the case of Tim Selwyn.

Overall I got the impression that the Police would not be at all concerned if the bill passes.

So was a fun experience. I am glad both I/S and myself did bother to make submissions as one should not take for granted a bill will pass. I will be most surprised if it doesn’t proceed.

Afterwards I/S and Graeme E from the COG had an extended coffee session, mainly talking about the Electoral Finance Bill. Oh yes also met Nicholas O’Kane from Vic, whom I hadn’t met before.

NBR Rich List

NBR have their rich list out today.  The Herald has a preview:

  1. Graeme Hart $2.75b
  2. Todd family $2.6b
  3. Eamon Cleary $2.1b
  4. Christopher and Richard Chandler $2.0b each
  5. Goodman family $1.8b
  6. Stephen Jennings $1.0b
  7. Erceg family $700m
  8. Douglas Myers $700m
  9. Sir Michael Fay $660m
  10. David Richwhite $660m

The threshold for inclusion has doubled this year from $25m to $50m, with a note that almost anyone who owns a house in inner Auckland or Wellington is by definition a millionaire now.
Best success story is 38 year old Don Ha who moved here as an 11 year old penniless refugee in 1980 and is now worth $60 million.

More Electoral Finance Bill Humour

From Will at Gonzo:

A press release from the Prime Minister’s office today announced that menstrual cycles will be strictly regulated in future. Instead of the usual five to seven days out of 28, women will be considered to be having their period continually from January 1st 2008.

Women will also have to provide proof that they are entitled to FHPs, and will need to appoint a gynaecological agent who will responsible for keeping track of them.

Women seeking Feminine Hygiene Products (FHP) will have to register with the Ministry of Menses, and are limited to 60 FHPs per year. An FHP is defined as any rag or implement which encourages, or is perceived to encourage, retention of menses.

Women’s groups around the country are up in arms. Prude Brewer, of advocacy group Glad Rag, says “This is a gross invasion of our rights. It is an affront to the dignity of women everywhere. There is blood on the government’s hands.”