An interesting defence for Field

The Herald has a story on the application to the High Court to lay bribery and corruption charges against Taito Phillip Field.

What I find fascinating is the defence offered by Field’s lawyer.

Mr Field’s lawyer Paul Dacre said the argument was over bribery and not corruption, and that the charges could only be allowed if both parties to the transaction were aware it was illegal.

Crown prosecutor Simon Moore said there was no need to establish whether the workers were willing parties

Now what I read from this is that Dacre concedes that the transactions were illegal and that Field knew they were illegal, but that if the immigrants didn’t realise that their working on his house for free was illegal, then Field is not guilty or has no case to answer.

I’d be worried if my lawyer offered a defence against bribery that I knew what I was doing was illegal, but that those paying me did not!

Very Nasty

So people are in no illusions about how creepish certain MPs are, this exchange comes from Hansard yesterday as National was questioning the Government over the Electoral Finance Bill.

Rt Hon Winston Peters: Are there fundamental principles in this bill such as a ban on political policy being bought by outsiders, or political promotion being facilitated by outsiders, or, worse still, unhealthy—

Hon Dr Nick Smith: Have you paid the money back yet?

Rt Hon Winston Peters: Listen, loony tune, take control of yourself. Take your pills before you come down to the House, not halfway through question time.

Hon Dr Nick Smith: Have you paid up?

Rt Hon Winston Peters: I am serious. I am not a medical doctor but I have seen those symptoms before, and far too frequently in your case.

As Whale Oil points out, this sort of behaviour is disgusting.  Mocking people who have had a mental illness, about it, is vile.  And it is not just Peters who does this, but many other Ministers also.

A huge proportion of the population have mental health issues at least once in their lifetime.  Mocking people for it is about as funny as if an MP publicly mocked someone for having cancer.

What galls me is that not all parties descend into the swamp.  I recall in the 1990s a high flying Labour MP had a mental health episode.  Some sort of incident actually occurred in the House itself I am told.  I was only a Young Nat then, but I remember being told that any reference to the episode publicly was considered taboo and heartless.  And this was the case for the best part of a decade.  The episode has been mentioned once (I think) in recent times, but only in the context of a National MP (unwisely) hitting back at taunting
like the above.

There’s nothing that can be done to stop some MPs behaving like this.  But next time the Government announces funding for mental health, just remember which Ministers make a habit of doing mental health taunts at the same target.  A quick search of Hansard finds:

  • Michael Cullen,  21 June 2005, 6 December 2005 x 2
  • David Benson-Pope, 4 March 2004
  • Annette King, 5 September 2006
  • Trevor Mallard, 21 March 2006

And they are just the ones which make Hansard.  Incidentially I don’t have a problem with yelling out “take your pills” as a general retort to someone interjecting.  Hell I’ve had Winston say it to me in the 1996 Leader’s Debate when I heckled from the audience.  All good fun.

But when it is deliberately and repeatedly targeted at an MP who had publicly been known to have had a mental health episode, it is very different.  Just as one might have a general retort of “Don’t have a heart attack” to someone doing a  huge rant, you wouldn’t say that if you knew the person opposite had (for example) almost died from a heart attack a few months ago.  All humour is situational.

What Peters said, with explicit labeling as a “loony tune” is a new low.

The distancing starts

Helen Clark is already distancing herself from the Electoral Finance Bill, as if it is nothing to do with her. I mean she only chaired the Cabinet which dictated the policy for the bill and also signed off on the Bill.

I don’t think one should take a shred of comfort in vague talk about we’ll amend it at select committee. That may mean cosmestic changes only. This bill was backed by Labour. Greens, United Future and NZ First. Unless they publicly declare their position on these free speech restrictions, one should assume they will not support meaningful changes.

What comes out of select committee will probably be just before Christmas and can be rushed into law with just a few hours debate.

Helen Clark also tried to justify her totally unprincipled u-turn regarding clamping down on anonymous and trust donations, saying:

“The problem is if you’re going to totally clamp down on anonymous donations – which I’d be very happy to see – you do need some quid pros quos,” the Prime Minister said.

“Because the Labour Party isn’t led by me with a $50 million bank account.”

She said the Labour Party had support from many people on low and modest incomes and “we are not in a position to just write large personal cheques”.

This confirms that Helen Clark writes electoral law to personally suit her and the Labour Party. It is nothing to do with a fair contest. As Colin Espiner blogs:

That last comment left me somewhat breathless. Is the Prime Minister really saying that Labour is now drafting legislation specifically tailored to the wealth of the Leader of the Opposition? Her comments appear to reinforce my earlier point (see previous postings on this subject) that Labour has designed this legislation to suit itself and no one else.

Personally, I think whether or not John Key has $50 million in the bank is immaterial. The most National can spend in an election campaign is $2.4 million. If Key wants to bankroll the campaign, so what? It’s his money. He would have to think very carefully before doing so, however, since the public’s reaction would likely be negative and a donation of that size would be very difficult to conceal, even with Labour’s loose campaign finance laws.

I don’t believe Labour will have any trouble in finding $2.4 million either. Again, it has tailored the new law to make sure its donors can continue to contribute virtually without restriction.

I’ve just informed the National Party General Manager that he no longer needs to worry about fund-raising as according to Helen, John Key is going to fund the entire party. Thanks John. I wonder who is going to tell John of his kind donation.

Clark talks about how Labour gets support from people on low and modest incomes and are not in a position to just write large personal cheques. But this is nonsense. A clamp down on anon and trust donations will only affect large donors who give over $10,000 a year.

Labour only received$300,000 of anon donations last election year. It is amazing they will sell out their principles so cheaply. They spent a year campaigning against anonymous donations, and are now clinging to them purely because Helen isn’t as wealthy as John Key. How absolutely pathethic.

Air NZ, Australia and Iraq

While I have enjoyed seeing the Government get so twisted about it, I have to say I don’t believe there was anything at all inappropriate about what Air New Zealand did.

Australia is our closest ally and friend.  Our troops are bonded together for eternity through the ANZAC traditions.  To suggest that Air NZ should refuse to take the Royal Australian Air Force as a client is almost offensive to our neighbours.  Hell we trade with China, sell meat to Iran, give aid to North Korea and somehow the Govt thinks Australia should be on our blacklist.

It doesn’t matter whether or not we agree with the Australian presence in Iraq (something which actually has a UN mandate).  Would anyone suggest Fonterra should refuse to sell milk to the Australian military?  Should we ban NZ lamb from being served to Australian soliders in Iraq.

The problem for Helen and Phil is Iraq has become a defining issue for the left.  It is such a symbol for them, that they can’t engage rationally on the issue.  Anything associated with Iraq is evil and must be stopped.

From all accounts Air New Zealand behaved impeccably by checking with MFAT, and at later dates giving them more precise details.

It has also transpired that security officials in the Dept of PM and Cabinet were aware of these flights.

MFAT Secretary Simon Murdoch has done the very honourable thing and has apologised for not informing Ministers.  And it is correct that enough alarm bells should have rung for a briefing note to go to the Minister.   My slightly more paranoid part of my brain wonders how Murdoch made such a basic mistake.  Murdoch is held in incredibly high esteem – some call him the most gifted civil servant of a generation. I almost wonder whether he did say something to Winston or his office, and he is just honourably taking the fall.  I could imagine Winston (who is not a member of the hysterical left when it comes to Iraq) shrugging it off as no big thing.  Having considered that theory though I reject it on the basis that Murdoch is too principled to lie, even for his Minister. He isn’t the sort of civil servant who would conveniently forget about a conversation.

I must give Peters some credit in this.  He has been the voice of calm and reason in wanting more facts before passing judgement, and in not putting the boot into his department just to score points.  And he was absolutely right to not throw Murdoch to the wolves – his loss would not be of benefit to anyone.

So 9/10 for Winston and 3/10 to Goff.  Very different to my normal ratings.

In trouble with the blog

There is an article in The Press today in which Christchurch Mayoral candidate Bob Parker has taken offence at what he labels a smear campaign against him, based on a comment on Tony Milne’s blog. Tony is standing for the City Council on the Christchurch 2021 whose mayoral candidate, Megan Woods, is standing against Bob Parker.

The Google cache of the particular post was archived by Whale Oil. I remember when reading it at the time that I thought it was very unwise for Tony to not only refer to “persistent rumours” about Bob Parker, but also express that he is baffled by the comments about the the challenges of his new wife Joanna (who for those visually impaired is drop dead gorgeous and somewhat younger than Bob) establishing a relationship with his adult children. Not sure what is baffling about that – pretty common in second marriages.

Now Tony got some flack on his blog for it, and then Insolent Prick and Whale Oil blogged about his comments highlighting the unsavoury comments re Parker. Tony then modified his post to remove the comments on Parker and also deleted the comments on the post complaining about the comments.

Tony claims that his comments on the “persistent rumours” were referring to a possible September wedding for Parker and his fiancée. I’m sorry, but as Tui says “Yeah Right”. That’s just too cute for words and while arguably plausible don’t fit the context.

The Canterbury Public Issues Forum has a thread on the whole issue, including posts from Tony, Parker and Megan Woods.

It’s an interesting trail of events. A post on one blog that was only up for a short period is cached on Google and then linked to by another blog, and then noticed by the subject of the post who raises it on an online forum, and some exchanges happen there, and then finally it becomes a story in the main newspaper.

While the damage done is self inflicted by Tony, he does actually have my sympathy. We have all posted stuff we shouldn’t have, and regretted it later. One reason I have no desire to ever be a candidate is because it does then make any such bad calls much more newsworthy.

The new Air New Zealand planes

Public Address on EFB

Graeme Edgeler from the Coalition for Open Government writes at Public Address on the Electoral Finance Bill.  He encourages people to submit and points out that not only does it over-reach the third party provisions, but it makes almost no progress on all the other areas of reform.  My summary of what Graeme said is:

  1. Anon Donations & Secret Trusts – no action
  2. Exclusive Brethren campaign – limit is too low, definitions are too broad, and many of the effects of the bill as currently written are perverse
  3. Misuse of  parliamentary funds – COG says it isn’t dealt with (and isn’t really an electoral issue)
  4. Labour’s breach of the spending cap – COG says no dealt with.  Some have a view that the EFB will legalise their overspend by explicitly exempting parliamentary spending.
  5. Foreign Donors – no action
  6. Broadcasting Limit Breach – no action
  7. Police Incompetence – no change in prosecuting authority
  8. Time for laying prosecutions – a useful change to clarify when six months begins
  9. Peters vs Clarkson – clarifies rules which were argued in that case

As Graeme says, it is not even a mixed bag.  I have another six or seven areas such as ability to pool advertising and broadcasting budgets which the EFB does not address.  Labour have ignored almost every single positive reform measure and gone totally over board on the third party restrictions.

I do not share the COG’s optimism that the bill can be suitably amended at select committee to turn it into good law.  In fact I have a massive concern that what will come out of select committee will be just before Christmas and rushed into law to take effect by 1 January.  There will be almost no chance for public debate on the revised bill.

And that would be bad enough at the best of times.  But even worse, the Government has never even engaged the public in debating the issues in the first place.  It has spent months cutting deals in secret, gutting the transparency provisions, and not once has it issued a public discussion document.

Below is what should be the process for matters such as electoral law:

  1. Release a public discussion paper (green paper) on issues and options
  2. Consult with public and parties on the paper
  3. Summarise and release feedback on the options
  4. With as much consultation as possible with all parties, release a public discussion paper (white paper) with specific recommendations
  5. Ask for feedback on recommendations from public and parties
  6. Summarise and release feedback on the recommendations
  7. Release final policy statement on desired changes
  8. Cabinet then instructs PCO to draft changes on basis of widely consulted on and known policy
  9. Minister introduces Bill and refers it to select committee
  10. Select Committee can then work on changes to the bill which do not dramatically alter it, but improve it to meet its intentions

Now someone may suggest that is over the top.  Well far from it that is close to normal process for almost any policy area.  Digital Copyright went through three or four public policy papers and consultation before legislation was introduced.

So why would we accept anything less for the Electoral Act – a keystone of our constitution.

The last time we embarked on major reform, we did so after a Royal Commission and a wide public debate and consulation.

This is why most reluctantly I do not think the Bill should proceed at all.  90% of the important issues are missing from it and the minor improvements do not come close to  making up for the draconian third party stuff.

The public deserve better than merely getting to make one submission on an incredibly flawed bill and then no say at all on what will inevitably still be a partially flawed bill in the days before Christmas.  It will result in bad law.

I am not saying throw the bill out because I do not want any changes to the Electoral Act.  To the contrary I want lots and lots of changes.  I want bigger fines, I want better enforcement, I want more flexibility with broadcasting, I want inflation adjustments, I want clearer rules, I want more transparency.  I was looking forward to having a halfway decent bill which could be turned into a good bill.

At the seminars I have attended on this issue, and the debates I have had with people from all over the political spectrum, I believe a proper public consultation process would lead to a high degree of consensus in many key areas.   There are some really sensible changes that need to be done – but again they have almost all been ignored.

Let us take just one example – the bill’s failure to clamp down on anon and trust donations.  Now I agree with COG that they should be in the bill.  But I would disgaree with them on at what level they should be disclosed.  I’m comfortable with the status quo of only disclosing above $10,000, while COG wants $250.  Now the problem is yes we may get the select committee to agree to ban anonymous donations but who knows what level they may set it at.  It might be $250 (which I think would be a hideous invasion of privacy) or they might even make it $20,000 to fit the continuous disclosure provision (which COG will scream at).  But the problem is what ever level they set it at, then we will not have a chance for a public debate or whether that is the right level.

We need to have the public debate up front and before the bill is drafted, so we can capture all the areas on which there is a consensus.  That way then  time can be spent on debating details such as the actual level of disclosure, rather than the fundamental principle of do you allow anon donations at all.

So sadly my position is that the bill should be thrown out entirely, and the Government told to go away and do a proper job of consultation and public debate.  It will be better to get a really good law in place for the 2011 election than a badly flawed law rushed through in the days before Christmas.

Lickspittles

Some people have a go at Whale Oil for his shall we say colourful language used regarding Government supporters, such as labelling them lickspittles.

Considering a Minister of the Crown has now labelled Air New Zealand a “lickspittle lackey of the Australian and American Governments”, let there be no more complaints about bloggers using the term.

Getting more action

On Newstalk ZB tomorrow

I’m on Newstalk ZB tomorrow for an hour from 11 am to midday Friday as part of the Face Off Panel.  This is broadcast to Wellington only.

Also on ZB every Tuesday at around 6.30 pm with Larry Williams to discuss the week.  That broadcast is nation-wide.

Hypocrisy on retirement savings

Business New Zealand has pointed out that the compulsory employer contributions to KiwiSaver was the worst political ambush of business in 20 years, with no consultation at all. To quote Phil O’Reilly:

Employers had been willing to support a workplace savings scheme if it had been “compliance light” and based on “no-surprise” consultation.

This had changed on Budget day when employers were lumbered with the compulsory contributions and the risk of administering the scheme.

“Clearly, ambush trumps consensus.”

Finance Minister Michael Cullen had called for consensus around retirement issues, but this clearly did not include employers.

O’Reilly also points out some of the practical issues:

Employers would have to negotiate different wage rises for different employees based on whether they were in the scheme or not.

Mr O’Reilly said this would cause tension in the workplace, especially if someone negotiated a pay rise on the basis they were not in KiwiSaver and then afterwards joined up.

This would mean that person had gained a larger wage rise than their colleagues.

The bill should be amended so that any required employer contribution should be recognised as part a total employment package whether or not the employee joined KiwiSaver.

The recommendation is sensible.  One might be able to achieve that with an explicit employment agreement, but it would be better to have specific legislative provision for it.

Easy up, easy down

An anti EFB You Tube

Someone emailed me the link to this new You Tube video on Labour’s free speech record. Covers the attempted billboard ban in Auckland, the kicking out of journalists when the Chinese Givernment asks, the restrictions on what charities can say to remain tax free, the parliamentary ban on satirical use of parliamentary photos or footage, and then finally the draconian Electoral Finance Bill.

There’s a great cameo of Gerry Brownlee as Eric Cartman from Southpark singing a popular song from the Southpark movie (the one about Kyle’s mum).

The last couple of seconds will lead to Godwin’s Law being cited. And while personally I wouldn’t do that comparison, it is not unexpected when you have such a massively wide reaching bill with huge implications on free speech where even an e-mail to a friend criticising the Government would need a statutory declaration filed.

Air NZ helping the war on terror

Oh this is delicious.  The Government has been making money from the War on Terror and Iraq by having its 90% owned airline, Air NZ, transport Australian troops there.

And while the Government claims to be unhappy about it, they are not going to force the airline to stop.  And MFAT has known about this since January and said they did not think it breached policy.

The Foreign and Defence Ministers are at odds on the issue with Goff saying he is against it, but Peters saying it depends on what the troops were doing.  Also Goff has attacked MFAT and Peters is refusing to agree with his criticism.  Dissension and chaos rules!

Congrats to Investigate who researched and broke this story.

The Press on Clark’s Politics of Envy

In less than a week The Press has devoted a second editorial to the draconian Electoral Finance Bill. Quotes:

Prime Minister Helen Clark is as good as admitting that her Government’s Electoral Finance Bill is in trouble – and it deserves to be. This legislation is flawed.

The curbs on third-party advertising are draconian and it has failed to crack down on anonymous political donations. As Clark struggled this week to defend the bill, her party’s agenda became clear, and it is the politics of envy.

Clark’s most revealing comment came as she pushed her stock line that the price of a crackdown on anonymous donors must be the state funding of parties. “The Labour Party isn’t led by me with a $50 million bank account,” she said. National leader John Key was the direct target of this jibe, but it was miscalculated. Outside Labour circles, most New Zealanders do not hold wealth and success in jealous disdain.

The Government is also rattled by the strong opposition to its electoral finance legislation, but it has only itself to blame. Clark now concedes that the bill cast too tight a net around third-party advertising, saying that this will be remedied by a select committee. This raises the question of why Labour introduced defective legislation in the first place.

I can answer that one.  Because they don’t see it as defective.  They are just trying to placate critics.

Congrats Miss English

Maria English, the 16 yar old daughter of Bill and Mary English was named top debater at the final of the New Zealand Schools’ Debating Championships, despite being only a fifth former.  Damn impressive.

Also congrats to the other finalists including Jaz Morris and Ella Edginton who if memory serves me correctly were Youth MPs for Sue Kedgeley and Trevor Mallard respectively.

I suspect being the only daughter and having five brothers has provided good incentive to Maria to hone her verbal skills!

Parking Warden chased by forklift

NZPA on Trade Me sale of Election

On-air gaffes

Labour against state house tenants being able to buy their homes

Living outside the electorate

The Baubles of Office

TV3 has a story that Foreign Minister and NZ First Leader Winston Peters is going to appoint as our next High Commissioner to the Cook Islands, a NZ First MP – Brian Donnelly.

Now that’s a mighty big bauble of office.

Brian is a hell of a decent guy, is actually of Cooks descent and will I am sure be a most conscientious High Commissioner.  But that isn’t the point.  The point is that he would not be appointed unless Winston was Foreign Minister.

And the point is that Winston before the last election made an explicit commitment that he was shunning the baubles of office.  And not only if he not shunning them for himself, he is now handing them out to his mates.

Harawira has a point

Hone Harawira has been told he must refund half his airfare as he only stayed for half the select committee business.

Harawira had a point though that NZ First MPs had a cheek in raising the issue, considering they have yet to pay back even a single cent of the $160,000 they owe the taxpayer.

Harawira should take the moral high ground and table a cheque in Parliament tomorrow and then ask for the Leave of the House to debate why NZ First has not yet paid back their $160,000.

Key on You Tube

John Key’s latest You Tube notes that National’s videos have now had over 20,000 plays and there have been over 100,000 visits to John Key’s video blog site. He welcomes Phil Goff to the game and notes it is good Labour have discovered You Tube 🙂

Bid on the 2008 General Election

Heh this is priceless.  As a protest against Helen Clark’s refusal to clamp down on anonymous and trust donations (her latest excuse is because John Key has more money than her) the Coalition for Open Government has listed the 2008 General Election on Trade Me.

Very smart idea.  I’ve just put in a bid of $100. I like the idea of owning the Government 🙂