Labour pressures Hinchcliffe not to stand

TVNZ reports Labour Party MPs and former MPs are pressuring Labour Party member John Hinchcliffe to pull out of the Auckland Mayoralty race as he may take support away from defacto Labour candidate Dick Hubbard.

Hinchcliffe has revealed that not only have current MPs been pressuring him, but that a former Labour MP e-mailed Hinchliffe to warn him not to stand as it “might be more pleasant for you if you discontinued with your Mayoralty campaign”.

Hinchcliffe should be careful.  When Labour gets desperate they can get very nasty.  The fact he is a long standing party member will not help him at all as he finds out what “less pleasant” means.

Sunday Caption Contest

The half a billion dollar coverup

The Herald on Sunday has the info the Auckland City Council has been trying to keep covered up.  Their liability for leaky homes may be as high as $500 million dollars.  Ratepayers I am sure will appreciate knowing this.

Hubbard still won’t confirm the amount, but will say he is seeking a taxpayer bailout for the Council from Helen Clark.

The Government’s accounts, thanks to the Fiscal Responsibility Act, publish an extremely detailed listing of contingent liabilities. Even so detailed as to reveal there are $37 million of old $1 and $2 notes not accounted for.

Aaron Bhatnagar makes the suggestion that an equivalent of the Fiscal Responsibility Act should apply to Councils.  That’s a fine idea and one National should look at.  Just as the central Govt has to do a special pre-election set of accounts, so should local authorities.

More Labour poll rigging

Good God this is the third or fourth time they have done this.

For a few days the NZ Herald has had a poll on who benefits more from Labour’s attacks on John Key.   Now I never checked the poll out myself but several people over a couple of days mentioned that it was consistently running at 87% saying National.

Then I got an e-mail alerting me to a huge number of votes for Labour being added on, obviously through some automated process. Previously activity of this sort has been linked back to Parliament.

So the Herald has now closed the poll, which within a couple of hours had Labour go from 13% to 53%.

I really wish the newspapers wouldn’t run these unscientific polls, or if they insist on doing so, restrict it to one vote per poll per IP address.

Local Body websites

Laws on local body elections

Few were surprised that Michael Laws has decided to stand again for the Wanganui Mayoralty.  Michael has never been one to give power up willingly.  I have no doubt he will get elected again – I suspect with a huge majority.

Michael writes in the SST about other elections:

Auckland is shaping, as ever, as a professional mud wrestling contest. The often peptic John Banks is back, declaring himself a changed man. And unlike Rodney Hide, he did not need to dance to be so. He will beat Dick Hubbard for one simple reason: Dick hasn’t done anything.

This isn’t really Hubbard’s fault. His naivete led him to believe that being mayor would be like being chairman of a board of directors managing a cereal company. Which, of course, it should be. Unfortunately, a team of liberals and left-wingers had won the majority of council seats and Dick thus had two choices. He could willingly become their puppet, or he could fight them all the way through until now and then throw himself on the electorate and demand they give him a team that he could work with.

He chose neither option. Splat. Run down by the traffic coming both ways.

Power and Phones

The SST has a story about how Telecom’s new IP based next generation network will require power to the gateway in each house, with fears that in a power cut one can’t call 111.

It is an issue, but not at all a show stopper.  For a start the number of households without at least one cellphone must be miniscule.  In fact I suspect there are more households without landlines than there are without cellphones.

Personal, vicious and negative

Matt McCarten predicts “politics in New Zealand is going to be personal, vicious and negative over the next 12 months”.

I am tempted to joke and that will just be the internal leadership battle within Labour 🙂

Matthew Hooton writes in the SST that John Key once told him that Phil Goff was the Labour politician he feared was most capable of stopping him becoming prime minister.

Goff is obviously starting to position himself with his antics on the Air New Zealand fiasco being clearly directed at shoring up support from the left of the party.

He would never ever challenge Clark for the leadership, but as with 1990 if a victory looks impossible, he might be promoted to help minimise the losses.  Nothing focuses MPs more than a risk to their personal seat.

Hooton looks at the past week:

On Tuesday, Clark was still defending her government’s attempt to stifle democracy with its Electoral Finance Bill. On Wednesday, she indicated she might be prepared to establish multi-party talks to develop a more sensible proposal, but only if Key would first agree not to criticise the original. On Thursday, Labour used its majority on a select committee over the objections of the opposition to appoint Sir Geoffrey Palmer to rewrite the bill.

Only people who are completely out of touch with reality could believe that a former Labour prime minister, a major party donor and the prime minister’s personal legal adviser is the right person for that particular job.

Elsewhere, Labour looked vindictive and mad, with Clark’s election strategist, Pete Hodgson, taking a week out from running the health system to dig around the Companies Office and Truth looking for dirt on Key. His allegations were all comical, but how long will it be before Clark, Cullen and Hodgson justify a search of Key’s rubbish bins or his emails and faxes, in their hunt for a decent smear?

My personal highlight this week was Cullen falsely accusing me in parliament of being the owner of Truth. Keep this up, and it’ll be time for the men in white coats.

Logan’s Run Movie

Martin Hirst

AUT Associate Professor Martin Hirst is going to be an adviser to the EPMU’s inquiry into the state of journalism in NZ.

Hirst writes in The Press that as a marxist he regards the USSR, Eastern Europe, China and Cuba not as communist states but as “totalitarian forms of state-capitalism”. This is a common view it seems from Marxists and Maoists.

My goodness, isn’t this a wonderful twisting of words. Even the nasty communist states are capitalists so hence capitalism is evil and communism is pure light and goodness.

And in the free market West we merely have a “charade of democracy”.

Funny how so many millions of people always want to escape the communist countries for the so called charade of democracy.

Associate Professor Hirst is in charge of the journalism curriculum at AUT incidentially.

So of course a man who can debate issues on the facts. He would never of course call someone a neo Nazi just because he disagrees with their political views.

Christchurch City Council Nominees

An interesting range of candidates for Christchurch City Council.

I don’t follow CCC as closely as Wellington and Auckland, but I’ll do a bit of speculation:

The three main candidates for Mayor are Bob Parker (centre), Megan Woods (left) and Jo Giles (right). Almost everyone is picking Parker to win. Hopefully Kyle Chapman will come last.

In Banks Peninsula probably Steve Lowndes to prevail

Burwood/Pegasus – Independent Gail Sheriff to be joined by 2021’s Chrissie Williams.

Fendalton/Waimairi – Mike Wall to join Sally Buck

Hagley/Ferrymead – 2021’s Linda Rutland to join David Cox

Riccarton/Wigram – Bob Shearing and Helen Broughton to keep their seats

Shirley/Papanui – no contest with Norm WIthers and Graham Condomn safe as

Spreydon/Heathcote – Sue Wells and Barry Corbett to also retain their seats

The $8 billion payout

Wow times are not great for some farmers, but if you are a dairy farmer, you have to be pretty happy.  The average payout to the 11,600 farms will be $689,000.

Sounds like a lot of it will be used to retire debt, rather than a splurge up.

The biggest winner of course will be Dr Cullen who will gain an extra billion or so in tax revenue.

How did they get the Electoral Finance Bill so wrong?

Tracy Watkins in the Dom Post has an article on the Electoral Finance Bill – basically asking how could the Government get the bill so wrong?

I’m one of those interviewed for the article.  Basically I point out two huge blunders:

1) Not including the clamp down on anonymous and trust donations, which had huge widespread support, while clamping down on third party spending.  It was a hypocritical double standard.

2) That no-one at all looked at how the third party spending aspects would work at a practical level.  They obviously looked at how do we devise a tight definition of advertising, a tight definition of publication, a tight definition of disclosure, and no-one at all then did the obvious and think about in a practical instead of theoretical sense.

There are two people to blame for these blunders.  The first is Helen Clark.  She personally instructed for the clampdown on anonymous donations to parties to be removed, as she needs that money for her re-election campaign.  Burton did recommend such a clampdown to the Cabinet.

The second is Mark Burton in relation to the third party regime.  It is incompetence even worse than George Hawkins to have not personally examined the bill in a political and practical sense.  That is why you have a Minister and political staff within a Minister’s office.

So Clark and Burton both blundered massively.  And it is the combination of their blunders which gave us this bill.  However despite their blunders they won’t publicly say what changes they will agree to.  We are expected to believe that Burton, the Greens and Winston (who represent a majority of MPs) will somehow make it workable or even desirable law through the select committee process.

More mud backfiring

Not that anyone except Sonic and Selma actually thought there was anything to Labour’s H-Fee attacks on Key, but a former SFO Director has come out and said:

Mr Key was simply one in a “vast array of innocent people, potential witnesses, in a massive fact-gathering exercise. I feel compelled to fully support the reported comments of John Key in relation to the H-Fee transaction. It should not need to be said that John Key was completely innocent of any wrongdoing whatsoever. For any politician to hint or suggest otherwise would be absolutely rubbish and pure mischief-making”.

This latest attempt has so backfired that Labour now denies they knew anything about it.  Oh except for the fact Trevor Mallard kept referring to it in the House.  And Mike Williams claims no knowledge at all – the same Mike Williams heard boasting on planes about dirt they had on John Key.

Fran O’Sullivan writes that Key has emerged unscathed from the smears:

If they are to ram home an allegation implicating Key in the H fee fraud, Labour will now need to produce cast-iron evidence – not simply a guilt by association smear. Right now the public sympathy is running with Key.

John Armstrong sees this as Labour self-destructing:

Is it a destructive mixture of fear and bravado coupled with blind panic which has driven Labour to turn what had been a slow-burning campaign to undermine John Key’s credibility into a full-blown and foolhardy character assassination job?

How else to explain the behaviour of Pete Hodgson, the kamikaze pilot who forgot to pack his aircraft with explosives?

His resorting to smear tactics without providing any substance to justify them reeked of the truly desperate.

Labour crossed a major threshold this week in switching its focus away from Key’s supposed policy inconsistencies and on to matters of personal character.

Like the junkie who is ever increasing the dose just to get the same hit, Labour’s failure to get any bounce in the polls out of its anti-Key onslaught is seeing it scrape the bottom of the barrel even harder to turn up something, anything, it can chuck in the direction of National’s leader.

Don’t expect it to stop though.

Wellington Region Mayoralty Contests

Starting in Wellington City , we have nine nominations, being:

  • Ray Ahipene-Mercer
  • Paul Bailey
  • Carl Gifford
  • Rob Goulden
  • Nick Kelly
  • John McGrath
  • Bryan Pepperell
  • Kerry Prendergast
  • Helene Ritchie
  • Jack Ruben
  • Nick Wang

Kerry is obviously the favourite, but it is an STV election so she will have to pick up some support from the minor candidates as they fall over.

Around a third of the Council are standing for Mayor – not because they have a realistic chance of winning, but I suspect because they know their profile helps them with their Council seat election.

I tend to favour a rule that one chooses to stand for Mayor or Council. A Mayor shouldn’t have to put up with a Council full of people who stood and lost to them.  No wonder you get so much infighting.  It would also make candidates for Mayor seriously think about whether they want to stand or not.

McGrath is the only candidate not on Council who has a chance of getting a respectable result.

In Lower Hutt we have:

  • Ross Jamieson
  • Ken Laban
  • David Ogden
  • Rose Thomas
  • Ray Wallace

Laban vs incumbent Ogden is probably the main show, but others could pick up quite a bit.

In Porirua Jenny Brash has four challengers:

  •  Jenny Brash
  • Selwyn Katene
  • Liz Kelly
  • Robert Shaw
  • Piripi Gray

Have not followed Porirua politics as much as I used to so not sure how secure Brash is.

And in Upper Hutt Wayne Guppy has no challengers. A happy man.

On ZB tonight

Hager on Electoral Finance Bill

Now Nicky Hager has spoken on radio about the Electoral Finance Bill.  Nicky is a member of the Coalition for Open Government and was no doubt expecting to be one of the biggest cheerleaders for the bill.

Phil U listened to Hager on radio today and what did he say about the bill:

He said it was legislation you would expect to see introduced by the Nazi Party!!

I’ve just listened to it myself and he does indeed make the Nazi analogy.  He also says National has good grounds for attacking the bill.
I say – Kill the Bill!

Now’s that’s a scary error!

Andrew Geddis on Electoral Reform Bill

Andrew Geddis is an associate professor at Otago University and has written a lot on the Electoral Act.  Now I don’t agree with Geddis on all things electoral, which is not surprising considering his background, but he is always worth reading and listening to.

I almost missed this article from last Friday by Geddis where he writes in The Press that one should not only be concerned with the EFB’s third party spending clauses, but also the failure to increase the transparency of political party funding.

Following the 2005 election, the Government promised to put a stop to the flow of secret funds to political parties and candidates.

However, the Government seems to have decided that both individual candidates and political parties should be allowed to continue their existing fundraising practices.

No doubt the early, knee-jerk rejection of any sort of public funding left it fearing that any greater disclosure measures might starve such contestants of the money they need to operate effectively.

This failure to really debate the pros and cons of public funding is regrettable. The public was never given the choice of whether it would rather politicians get their money from large, hidden, private donations or taxpayer grants. Instead, the status quo has been left in place, rather than the hard questions confronted.

At this last part, I disagree with Geddis that it is a binary choice.  That is quite misleading. And let us not pretend that Labour, who unilaterally killed the provisions, was in any way concerned for National’s ability to fundraise, or any other party’s ability.  Their sole concern was their own ability.

The amount of money received from anonymous sources is relatively modest, especially compared to the huge amounts Labour were proposing to have the taxpayer hand over to parties.

In this post back in April I calculated  that over the last four elections political parties would have received $40.5 million in taxpayer funding, and this to replace $6 million of anon donations over 12 years.  Labour would have had a likely $10.8 million funding boost from taxpayer funding.

One can end anonymous donations without needing state funding.

Geddis also covers how third party restrictions work in some overseas countries, but that the way they have been proposed in NZ leads to a conclusion that “the proposed limits on third-party spending simply are too low to allow third parties to meaningfully participate in the electoral proces”.

Latest Labour attack on Key

Labour’s latest press release on Key is below.  Not yet online, hence no link:

KEY IMPLICATED IN BRIDGECORP COLLAPSE, RESIGNATION SOUGHT

Senior Cabinet Minister Pete Hodgson has tabled in Parliament damning documents showing that John Key is responsible for the collapse of Bridgecorp, and has called for him to resign his seat in Parliament.

“It all goes back to his days at Merrill Lynch when he was head of currency dealing.  He was appointed to the Foreign Exchange Advisory Committee of the New York Federal Reserve”.

“In 1998, another member of that committee was a Cyril Nathanson.  Mr Nathanson is now dead, but he had a son – Fred Nathanson”

“We have conclusive proof that Fred Nathanson in 2001 invested in  Bridgecorp.  Not only did he invest in Bridgecorp, he also once had dinner with one of the Directors.  We have a photo from the respected National Inquirer newspaper in the United States”

“This is the smoking gun which ties John Key to the collapse of Bridgecorp.  It is disgraceful behaviour on the part of Mr Key and we believe he should personally reimburse every creditor of Bridgecorp’s and resign his seat in Parliament”

ENDS

Caption Contest

Herald Editorial slams Labour attacks

The NZ Herald editoralises:

The Labour Party’s latest campaign to dent John Key’s credibility has been described by some as an act of desperation to claw back lost support. Others see the oddest of spectacles, a governing party performing like an Opposition. Both were accurate perspectives on a small-minded assault that is more likely to buttress the National Party leader than undermine him.

That hardly seems likely to have been a matter of overriding importance in the electorate. Or to voters throughout the country. What probably interests them more is the fact that the Health Minister has found time to collate the product of what he described as some “digging” by the party. Pressing matters related to waiting lists, overcrowded accident and emergency departments, and threatened industrial action by senior doctors were pushed to one side as this petty line of inquiry was pursued.

Mr Hodgson’s exercise in futility is evidence of a seriously distracted administration. A Government, in fact, that should get back to governing.

I urge Labour to ignore this advice and carry on with Pete’s tactics.  The public don’t care about hospitals or prisons or schools.  They want more info on who once had lunch with whom.

Registration now needed

Aarrrgh. Despite the anti-spam test of typing in the words from a random graphic, the spammers are getting through. A dozen overnight.

Not sure if they have found out a way to scan the graphic, or they pay slaves in China 1c per hour to manually spam me.

As a trial, I have turned on a feature which will hold a comment for moderation unless you are registered and have successfully posted at least once previously. You can register at the bottom of the sidebar.

Let me know how much of a hassle this is. Most regulars are already registered. I don’t want to discourage the occassional posters but I do want to stop the spam appearing.

More Labour lies

NZPA reports that Labour is defending its reliance on the Truth story about John Key because according to Dr Cullen:

“the paper was partly owned by Matthew Hooton, well known for working with and for the National Party”

Now this got me excited that I could hit Matthew up for a free subscription.  But sadly Dr Cullen just made it up. Matthew is not a part owner.  Dr Cullen no doubt won’t apologise as he said it under parliamentary privilege.

But in a fit of irony, as the exact time Dr Cullen was smearing Matthew in the House, Matthew was hosting with Matt McCarten a campaign launch for former Alliance MP Willie Jackson and former Labour MP John Tamihere.  Classic.

Desperate and Dateless

My God this is so sad.  After having got laughed at over their two year old story about where John Key registered his address, today Labour tried to link him to leaky homes.  The best they can find is he went into business with a coupel of people, who four years *before* had had built a leaky home.

Colin Espiner I am sure is speaking for the entire press gallery when he says:

Oh, for heaven’s sake! Someone needs to tell Prime Minister Helen Clark to call off her attack dogs until they’ve got something decent to chew on.

The paltry fare served up on John Key by Labour’s research unit for the likes of Pete Hodgson and Clayton Cosgrove to growl over of late has been nothing short of a total embarrassment.

Colin turns to today’s attack:

Today Labour plumbed new depths, serving up a patsy on leaky buildings to Clayton Cosgrove so he could attack Key for once having an involvement with two businessmen who allegedly designed and built some leaky apartments in Auckland.

The story, which appeared in that reputable staple of the Government’s research unit – The Truth newspaper – goes that Key was a shareholder in a business, Earl of Auckland Ltd, along with two others involved in the city’s property market.

His business partners built the apartments now subject to leaky building claims in 1997. But Key says he had nothing to do with the buildings – which were completed four years before he even began a business relationship with the men.

Had Key been directly involved with building leaky homes, or shirked his responsibilities to clients once problems had become known, this might – might – be a story. But on the facts known at the moment, this smear attempt on Key is nothing short of totally pathetic.

You really have to wonder who is driving Labour’s strategy.  Colin outs it down to sheer panic:

It speaks volumes about the panic now gripping Labour, as National sits at 50 per cent in the polls, that it is prepared to stoop to grabbing stories out of a discredited scandal sheet like Truth and run them in Parliament without even checking all the facts.

What’s next? A breathless account about how Key failed to return his overdue books to the Christchurch Public Library in 1973? A thunderous denounciation of the National leader for failing to donate to a boy scout fundraising drive?

It’s such a pity we have to wait 15 months to get a chance to vote and show what we think.