Sedition Submissions

The Justice & Electoral Select Committee is hearing submissions on the repeal of sedition law on Thursday from 11.15 am to 11.40 am.

I’m on at 11.30 am.  Not sure who will be appearing apart from presumably Idiot/Savant. Sounds like very few submissions which is good – hopefully the bill will continue to have unamious support.

The hearings are in Select Committee Room One in Bowen House.

Relationships in the Civil Service

There is still a huge unresolved issue hanging over the civil service, in terms of will your relationship make you ineligible to keep your job or be promoted.  I have been amazed that the commentators seem to be split 50/50 on whether Setchell’s relationship should have meant she never got the job in the first place.

I very much tend to the point of view that you trust people’s professionalism unless they give you a reason not to. The most famous example of this is Mary Matalin and James Carville who were key strategists for Bush (41) and Clinton in 1992 despite being partners and then married to each other.

Obviously it is a potential conflict of interest for a civil servant if you have a partner who is say a journalist, or works for a political party, or if you yourself are involved in a political party.  That is not the issue.  The issue is how do you mitigate or manage the conflict of interest.

To actually refuse to employ someone because of their relationship is an incredibly extreme measure.  Normally you manage a conflict of interest by making sure it is known and recorded and that the staff member concerned is clearly advised what can and can not be shared with people outside the office.

As I blogged last month, there have been numerous examples in the past of civil servants with a much greater conflict of interest that Setchell had.

I just find it amazing this assumption that one can’t trust a professional not to act unethically.  It actually worries me if Wellington has become so tribal that professionalism is not trusted.

This doesn’t just apply to civil service jobs.  To use myself as an example, I worked for National Leaders for eight years, yet in various capacities I quite often deal with Labour Party Ministers or Green MPs.  Now on the odd occasions in the last two years I’ve been in a Minister’s office and sworn to secrecy over certain issues or thoughts.  And never in a thousand years would I even think of breaking that confidence.  I place great value on integrity and reputation and would never put partisan politics ahead of that.  And I hugely appreciate that certain Ministers have trusted me enough to have a professional relationship with me.

It would be a great pity if a culture of distrust became so prevalent that the civil service, and the wider Wellington networks became Americanised where political loyalty is more relevant than professional conduct.

The great problem the SSC has, apart from dealing with its own credibility, is to provide guidance as to what does or does not constitute a barrier to employment and/or promotion.  If the SSC fail to provide this guidance, then have no doubt that the line will be drawn at where Setchell was – relationships will prevent you from furthering your career, no matter how much personal integrity you have.

And if the line is drawn at being unable to hire someone as a third level manager because of their boyfriend, then I would expect the following classes of people will be unable to gain a senior role in the civil service:

  • Anyone who has ever been a candidate for a political party
  • Anyone who has ever been an office holder in a political party
  • Anyone who has worked in a Minister’s private office (except as a department secondee)
  • Anyone who has worked for a political party, a backbench MP, or a Research Unit
  • Anyone whose partner is employed by a political party

If the Government and the SSC can not clearly state that one’s relationship will not lose you your job in the public service, then the political neutrality will be permanently lessened and scores of not hundreds of civil servants will find their careers stalled or over.

Win US$1 million

The NZ based new social networking site, iYomu, is offering a prize of US$1 million, and the winner will be voted on by iYomu members.

How it works is you become a member and win points for completing puzzles and tasks.  The top ten points scorers will be interviewed by iYomu and thee grand finalists selected from them.  Then the entire iYomu membership will vote on who should win.

The challenge starts this week and runs until 31 December 2007.  You can gain points by referring friends, completing user profiles and solving 12 puzzles featuring different locations from around the world.

Read/WriteWeb has further details and some great screenshots from the site.

As it is a NZ based company, it would be great if a Kiwi won the US$1 million.  I know I’ll be aiming to win.

Poll on Media

Roy Morgan has done a poll in Australia on what people think of the media.  It isn’t pleasant:

  • 85% believe that Newspaper journalists are often biased
  • 74% believe TV reporters are often biased
  • 69% believe that Talk-back radio announcers are often biased.
  • 49% believe Internet sites are often biased.

Oh this is hilarious.   People think talkback hosts are less biased than newspaper journalists.  That is what they should be discussing at the EPMU conference! And Internet sites are seen as the least biased.  Now this is Australia, not NZ, but still very funny.

  • 62% say newspaper journalists often get facts wrong
  • 55% say TV reporters and journalists often get facts wrong
  • 51% say Talk-back radio announcers often get facts wrong
  • 77% say Television reporters and journalists invade people’s privacy unnecessarily
  • 69% say Newspaper journalists invade people’s privacy unnecessarily
  • 22% say Talk-back radio announcers invade people’s privacy unnecessarily.

And in terms of media bias, people were asked if groups were too left-wing leaning or right-wing leaning:

  •  Newspaper journalists 24% LW, 19% RW
  • TV Reporters 20% LW, 15% RW
  • Talk-back Radio 15% LW, 24% RW
  • Internet sites 7% LW, 5% RW

A mother writes

NZ Herald journalist and mother Karyn Scherer writes in the Herald how Police visited her on Saturday Night:

There were three burly policemen on my doorstep, who shone a torch in my face and aggressively informed me that someone in my neighbourhood was concerned that I might be abusing my children.

It turns out that the alleged abuse was Scherer making her two year old have a bath and go to bed.  While the Police accepted this explanation, Scherer ponders:

So they left, but without so much as a smile or a “sorry to bother you”, and now I am the talk of the neighbourhood.

I can only suppose my name is on a blacklist somewhere, and if they get another call then Child Youth and Family will be notified.

And then she reconsiders a previous position:

I have written editorials in favour of the anti-smacking law and I have been asked to appear on TV to present my arguments. I have bored my colleagues with my views on the matter, and I must admit I am now wondering if those who argued that the anti-smacking law would come back to bite good parents on the bum might have been right.

PM on You Tube

So who will run the world now?

Karl Rove has announced that he will resign his White House post at the end of August.

So who will run the world now? Cheney can only do so much by himself 🙂

In some way no surprise Rove is going.  His speciality is elections and this frees him up for various 2008 campaigns.

Hat Tip: No Right Turn

Shortland Street

Madness in Britain

Paul at The Fundy Post alerts me to the story of a documentary on Channel 4 called “Undercover Mosque“.  The Guardian explains how this documentary showed stuff such as a “moderate” Iman preaching “We love the people of Islam and we hate the people of kuffaar. We hate the kuffaar!'” (Kuffaar’ is a derogatory term for non-Muslims).

Now the good news is the Police have investigated and have asked the Crown Prosecution Service to prosecute for stirring up racial hatred.

So that’s fine then.  Well, not quite.

You see the Police are not demanding that the Iman spreading the message of hate be charged.  No it is the makers of the documentary who they want charged for distorting the message of love that the Iman intended.

Go read the full article at The Guardian and weep.

The photoshop proof

This won’t surprise anyone but Whale Oil has tracked down proof that the official Prime Ministerial photo is photoshopped.

He checked out the metadata on the photo supplied by the PMs Office to Wikipedia, and it reveals the software used is Photoshop 7.0, yet has no info on the camera used.

I’m sure the PM is not the only politician to have photo shopped, but normally it is minor editing rather than transformation.  I’d love to know who they use for the editing as I reckon they might even be able to make me look presentable!

Sigh – so petty

I knew someone would be petty enough to get worked up about it, and yep No Right Turn has.

He blogged about my statement that Consilium was bloody expensive to attend and hence only serious people attended, and labels it economic snobbery.

First of all CIS gets no government funding.  It survives by donations and by attendance fess at events like this.  Otherwise there is no money to pay for guest speakers and the like.

Secondly CIS put on many events for free.  They in fact run an annual liberty and society conference in Australia and pay all the costs of the attendees who tend to be students from NZ and Australia.  They also put on a number of free lectures in NZ and Australia.

Third of all my statement that a high fee meant only serious people attended does not imply people who can’t afford it are not serious about policy.  I could not afford to go normally and I am very serious about policy. No Right Turn should know the difference between “All Betans are rich” and “All rich people are Betans” hence “All poor people are Thetans”.

The six million visit blog

Cue to sounds of Steve Austin jumping a fence …..

Over the weekend Kiwiblog registered its six millionth unique visit.  If I knew who it was I’d give them a prize but w’re now at 6,019,965 so anyone who was around 20,000 ago is a moral winner.

I might run a sweepstake next year for people to guess the date and time of Visitor Number 10,000,000.

Blame the one year old

Nothing sadder than someone too dump to even tell a plausible lie.

Chris Kahui is blaming the fatal injuries to his three month old twins on his then on year old son.

The injuries were similiar to those incurred in a high velocity car crash.

That must be one bloody big and bloody fast one year old.

Please note that just because Kahui is obviously lying about the source of the injuries, does not mean he is guilty.  Considering the Judge said:

The hearing began after Judge Roy Wade gave a strict warning to media on their responsibility to ensure fair and accurate reporting of the hearing.

Judge Wade said the court had strong powers to deal with media who were in contempt of court.

Please refrain from expressing an opinion on the guilt or innocence of Kahui.   Calling him a stupid liar is okay though, because he clearly is.

On Shine TV

Just done an interview with Shine TV regarding the Electoral Finance Bill – should play tonight. I do so enjoy explaining how the Bill will work to people – their disbelief grows and grows as the ramifications of it hit home.

Let the cartoons begin …

cartoon11.gif

The Guy Body cartoon in today’s Herald does the job nicely, along with the Editorial titled “Advocacy Free Speech Threatened” which indeed it is.  Some extracts:

A nine-month restriction of free speech is unnecessary and probably untenable.

This bill would curb the free speech of any individual or group who wants to promote any social interest that might favour a party or candidate at the election.

The definition of political advertising has been broadened by the bill from the usual one, material that seeks to persuade people to support a candidate or party, to anything “taking a position with which one or more parties or one or more candidates is associated”. This is fraught with dangers.

But you know the worst thing about this vile legislation?  Normally if a law is proposed that you think is appalling and you want to stop it, you’ll come out and say I’ll campaign against any party or MP which votes for this bill.  And this is how it is meant to be – MPs should be accountable for their votes.  So if for example Parliament voted to confiscate land from Maori tribes, one would want to be able to say any MP who votes for this confiscation will be targeted at the next election.

But the absolutely appalling thing about this law, is it will protect the MPs who vote for it, from being held accountable for their vote.  Yes one will only be able to spend $60,000 targeting MPs who vote away your right to criticise, because duh that criticism will now be regulated and restricted.

Now just think about what sorts of laws could be passed in future if the Electoral Finance Bill is passed.  A Muldoon type PM would love it.  Not only are your critics restricted to each spending no more than $60,000 (on all issues), if they try and work together on a co-ordinated campaign then they can go to jail for colluding against the Government.

Yates gone by Xmas

Just spotted that Labour List MP Di Yates has announced she will leave Parliament by the end of the year and is going to run for the Hamilton City Council.  I had to laugh at this sentence:

She told the Waikato Times she had not been pushed by Prime Minister Helen Clark, who had been “surprised” by her decision.

I suspect the Prime Minister was as surprised by this decision as an Eskimo is surprised by cold weather.

Louisa Wall will become an MP by the end of the year to replace Yates.  The next on the list after that is Su’a William Sio who may be the Labour candidate for Mangere to replace Field.

Mayoral Websites

Aaron Bhatnagar reviews the Auckland Mayoral Websites.  His scores are:

  • Dick Hubbard 0/10 (no site)
  • John Banks 8/10
  • John Hinchcliff 6/10
  • Steve Crow 2/10
  • Alex Swney 8.5/10
  • Lisa Prager 7/10
  • Coralie Van Camp 0/10
  • Ray Presland 0/10

Is there a site somewhere that has links to every mayoral campaign site in the country? That would be useful.

The US sub-prime tremors

It sounds like the title for a movie but the tremors in the US (and wider) sub-prime market could become something very nasty.

During the last few days a number of my fellow attendees have been checking market updates every hour or so.  Lots of directors of banks and other financial institutions, so when these guys look a bit worried, you know it is time to start taking notice.

Brian Fallow has a story in the Herald on some of what is happening.

Also a cause for nervousness is the fact central banks have had to inject US$323 billion into the money markets over the last 48 hours.  And yes that is billion – around three times the entire GDP of NZ.

It sounds like this episode won’t go pear shaped, but nothing is for certain. People are waiting for the US to open again on Monday morning.

Fran has the facts on the Downer visit

Nothing like a dose of facts.  A few people had got all worked up about Downer speaking at the National Party Conference last weekend.

Fran O’Sullivan reveals that:

Downer briefed Clark on the invitation well before the conference, going so far as to indicate the subject matter for what at that stage was supposed to be a public speech. He intended to affirm the importance of the bilateral relationship and focus on liberal values.

Clark was not opposed. Labour has, after all, extended invitations to high-ranking Labour politicians to attend its own mid-term annual conferences.

Then British Deputy Prime Minister John Prescott gave a great speech to Labour’s conference in December 2001, reaffirming the links between Britain and New Zealand in times of peace and war.

No one batted an eyelid either when Queensland Premier Peter Beattie spoke on environmental policies at last year’s Labour Party conference.

Clark, as much as any other politician, is aware of the brotherhood between politicians of similar hues. She makes a practice of attending Progressive Governance conferences where political leaders with democratic or Labour values discuss the big issues facing the world from their perspective.

She has gone so far as to form an alliance with the British Labour Government on policy formation.

If Clark had raised opposition to the Downer visit, the Australian Foreign Minister would simply have found a reason not to accept National Party president Judy Kirk’s invitation.

Incidentally was chatting to Downer last night and he was quite blown away by the standing ovation he got in NZ.  But he shouldn’t have been – it was a superb speech.  I got him to retell to the group we were with the story of him getting home to his young kids chanting anti-Downer songs at home.

KiwiSaver and Women

The SST reports that women may be disadvantaged by KiwiSaver, as they can get penalised by time spent out of the paid workforce such as child rearing.

A perusal of PQs last month, finds this exchange:

Jackie Blue: Was any gender analysis undertaken during the design of KiwiSaver; if so, what were the main findings?

Portfolio: Finance
Minister: Hon Dr Michael Cullen
Date Lodged:20/07/2007

Answer Text: Although no specific gender analysis was undertaken during the design of KiwiSaver, the scheme is designed to address many of the reasons why women are relatively disadvantaged in terms of superannuation savings at present – i.e. it is a flexible, voluntary and portable saving scheme. For example, KiwiSaver is not tied to the continued employment with one employer, allowing women to continue to contribute to their saving while they stay home to raise young children and continue to benefit from the member tax credit.

Even minor items of government policy tend to get a gender analysis done.  It’s pretty amazing that something as huge as KiwiSaver did not have a gender analysis done.

A danger to democracy

Matthew Hooton labels the Electoral Finance Bill and Mark Burton a danger to democracy:

The legislation -developed in secret by Justice Minister Mark Burton under the guidance of Labour’s election strategist Pete Hodgson – does nothing to stop a repeat of the 2005 pledge card rort or the anonymous donations and secret trusts that Helen Clark once said were so undemocratic. She’s now decided she needs them.Plunket would be caught if it published a pamphlet saying “Politicians Need To Act On Child Abuse”, or even “Child Abuse Is Wrong”. Press statements saying “National Does U-Turn” or “Labour Attacks Free Speech” would also be regulated by the state, as would placards at protest marches.

The legislation also goes well beyond the traditional three months of an election campaign. From New Year’s Day to mid-November – 10<<1/2 months – it would be illegal for anyone other than the government to spend more than $60,000 talking to the public about a policy issue.

Sixty thousand dollars may sound like a lot – it’s the income at which Michael Cullen says we’re rich – but it buys almost nothing in terms of mass communication.

Run just two full-page advertisements in section A of this newspaper, saying “Cut Taxes”, and Labour’s legislation would send you to jail.

Burton has set the threshold so low not because he thinks it is fair, but precisely because he knows it is not enough for Labour’s critics to get their message across to the public.

In the 12 months leading up to election 2005, the government spent $12 million – a million dollars a month – to remind us to check if we were eligible for Working for Families handouts. A group wanting to criticise Working for Families – disclosing exactly who they are -would now be restricted to just $6000 a month in election year.

There is not just a cap on spending. Burton’s legislation sets a threshold above which groups must first register with the state before saying anything.

At an electorate level, the limit is $500. Buy more than 10 rolls of 50c stamps, with the intention of sending a letter to Wigram or Epsom voters about something on which Jim Anderton or Rodney Hide has expressed an opinion, and you will need to register with the state. Don’t expect to keep your job in the public service if you do. But, if you don’t register, the police will be able to enter your home to search for the stamps.

It’s not clear whether our justice minister has a predilection for jackboots or is just incompetent and doesn’t understand his own legislation. Either way, he’s a danger to our democracy. His bill should be binned and he should be sacked.

Suspicious Burglaries

Diane Foreman has gone public with her suspicions that multiple break-ins at her apartment were politically motivated.

It seems her Parnell apartment was burgled twice in the six weeks leading up to the 2005 election, including a break-in on the night before polling day.  Nothing was stolen either time.

Incredibly when the Police investigated, they asked Foreman whether rumours in Wellington that she was a drug dealer were true.  Jesus Christ. Talk about offensive.

One of the intruders was identified by a friend staying with her as a private detective.

Personally I am very very reluctant to believe any sort of break in is politically motivated.  I think the stolen e-mails probably came about by someone illegally accessing a machine or server at Parliament, not through break ins.

On the other hand there were reports John Key’s rubbish was being searched at least twice.  And the Exclusive Brethren actually were mad enough to hire a private detective to spy on the Prime Minister, so can one totally rule it out – I guess not.  However I still consider it highly unlikely.

McCarten on dismissals

I find myself largely agreeing with Matt McCarten on the dismissals of both Paul Buchanan and TVNZ security guard Louis Rawnsley being over-reactions.

Both persons did act inappropriately, but I am sure both cases could have been solved with an apology and a warning.

The Herald on Sunday editorial also calls the Buchanan sacking an excessive penalty:

The earlier email exchange shows a student whose English is poor and who is plainly not keeping up with the course’s demands. Buchanan said so and although his style was unforgivable, the substance is fair.

International student fees, as a proportion of the university’s revenue, has almost halved since 2004 but the university should not, in the hunt for the fee dollar, expect its staff to tolerate, and even reward, mediocrity.

All things considered, sacking a fine teacher seems excessive and unwise.

Coddington on Groser

Deborah Coddington has a good article on the allegations against Tim Groser by his ex wife, stating:

Isn’t it becoming a trifle tiresome the way the media get into lathers over the slightest misdemeanour committed by public figures?

She later turns the column into MPs looking fashionable and wanting compulsory boxers for male MPs.  At one points she explains:

In Parliament I saw braless MPs walking around preceded by what looked like two ferrets fighting in a sack

Heh wonderful turn of phrase.

Consilium

I thought I would provide a bit more detail about Consilium.  If you’re into policy, ideas and issues then Consilium is a heavyweight event.  The quality of the attendees is amazing – top business and political leaders, former commerce commission chairs, orchestra CEOs, top academics, overseas speakers and some politicians.

Interestingly there are five Labor MPs here, and only two Coalition MPs.  While the Centre for Independent Studies is a classical liberal thinktank, it is very non partisan and is held in high regard by many in the Australian Labor Party.

Around 150 people attend plus partners.  The partners tend to attend all the sessions, as most have a keen interest in public policy issues.  The one thing which has struck me about the people here is the sheer intelligence and intellectual firepower.

This is possibly because it is generally not a cheap event to attend.  I am extremely lucky to have been invited to speak as a guest.  Not up to me to state what the normal attendance fee is, but let us say it is high enough to deter anyone who is not very serious  about policy issues.  And to my surprise I learnt that despite the high fee, there is a waiting list of people wanting to attend.  That’s because the quality of the event has given it such a good reputation.

I’ve been lucky this year to attend four thinktank type events.  The Pacific Rim Policy Forum in Hawaii, the Sounds Symposium in Blenheim, the Dunes Symposium on Waiheke Island and finally Consilium in Coolum, Queensland.

My interest in politics comes from an interest in policy.  Discussions about the best policy rather than the most popular policy are what motivate me.  Some of your best ideas come from a session where you actually disagreed with what was said, but it led you to think about the issue in a different way.

Anyway need to head back into a session now.  Will try and later today blog a summary of yesterday’s forums.