John Dewar

Copyright (New Technologies) Bill

The Herald has an article on the Copyright (New Technologies) Bill which will soon be passed into law. I’m quoted lamenting that format shifting only applies to sound and it will still be illegal to copy a movie onto say your video Ipod, even though you have legally purchased the DVD.

I also ping the provision that says it is illegal to keep a copy of a TV show you have recorded for longer than the time necessary to watch it at a more convenient time.  In theory everyone will have to wipe over their VCR tapes every week.

As Peter Griffin says most people will ignore the law anyway.  Just a pity when Parliament passes laws that they know people will ignore because it undermines overall respect for the law.

More on Buchanan

The Herald reports:

Palestinian activists at Auckland University appear to have helped – unwittingly or deliberately – to bring down one of their strongest champions in this country, sacked political scientist Paul Buchanan.

Cactus Kate also blogged on Buchanan:

Underlying the principle of free speech is to defend the rights of people you do not necessarily agree with or like.

Dr Paul Buchanan supported alleged terrorist Ahmed Zaoui, is obviously an anti-Bush pedaling American apologist with weak leanings and terrible typing skills, but I defend his right to grumpily tell students who are obviously rubbish that they are rubbish. It’s possibly the first time this pampered little Daddy’s girl has ever been told she is not good at something. That in itself would have been shock enough. I doubt anyone in the Emirates has ever fronted up with the truth.

If I rolled up at Hong Kong University and enrolled in an Engineering class taught in Cantonese, I would fail unless I had an adequate understanding of both Engineering and Cantonese. Which I don’t. Not a bit. I would not expect to pass or be given special tuition or privileges because I was an English speaker.

Auckland University is ranked in the top 50 Universities in the World. I expect it to maintain this reputation to maintain the reputation of my degrees and it does not help sacking a specialist senior lecturer for in effect demanding higher standards from a student accepted to go there who is not up to the task, based on how much money she was prepared to pay. That won’t uphold the reputation of anything in New Zealand.

You know if I was Vice-Chancellor of Victoria, I’d be chatting to Dr Buchanan right now about opportunities in Wellington.

Herald on Electoral Finance Bill

I had been concerned at the lack of coverage in the NZ Herald on the Electoral Finance Bill.  Aucklanders I know, including a former party president, had told me they would have had no idea of what was in the Bill and how bad it was, if they hadn’t heard me on NewstalkZB discussing it with Larry Williams.

Anyway today the  Herald comes to the party big time with no less than three articles on it.

First of all this article by Audrey Young which labels it an “electoral bill no one wants”.  Yes the bill is so appallingly bad that even the Government has stopped trying to defend it. Not that they don’t want it passed, they just realise there would be a public revolution if it got passed unchanged.

The Herald uses my phrase (well I’ve not seen it elsewhere) of “regulated criticism” and that is exactly what it is.  A bill which defines how one can criticise the Government, and by how much.

They quote Forest & Bird who say having the restrictions stretch out for a whole year is “absolutely unreasonable”. The Sensible Sentencing Trust label it “a corrupt piece of legislation”.

Forest & Bird is also upset that if anyone gives them over $500 anonymously, they have to hand it over to the Government.  Yes Dr Cullen will confiscate your donations.

Even Jeanette Fitzsimons concedes “that while she did not agree with Roger Dickie of the Kyoto Forestry Association on the allocation of forest Kyoto credits, I will stand up for their right to put that view publicly.”

I even get a mention as having “lampooned in Stalinist style by David Farrar on Kiwiblog”.  This is technically incorrect as I was lampooning it in Maoist style, but the differences aren’t great 🙂

In a second article Audrey Young reports that National is alerting about 500 interest groups to make submission on the bills.  Good. I’m half tempted to try and form a “Free Speech  Coalition” of interested groups to co-ordinate opposition to these provisions.

And finally John Armstrong lets loose:

Wake up to what Labour is doing with its shabby, self-serving Electoral Finance Bill. Or let it be on your conscience that you stood back and watched your right to free speech being flushed down the drain.

While not being quite that direct, National’s Bill English has effectively thrown down that challenge to trade unions, left-of-centre lobby groups, and politicians and individuals of the same ideological ilk.

I have absolutely no doubt that if this bill was passed into law, and National still won the next election, then the Electoral Finance Act would become the most hated and despised law amongst the left. The advantages it gives to an incumbent Government is massive.  A National Government could arrange for all state sector pay rounds to be in election year.  This would muzzle the unions from doing a public campaign is support of their claims.

If National was totally unprincipled and very cunning it would let this bill pass, betting on the probability their poll lead is great enough that even the taxpayer funded  Govt advertising campaigns next year won’t save the Govt.  And then in Govt this bill would be their best protection, and Labour and the Greens having forced it through wouldn’t be able to complaining about it.

Armstrong covers this in his article also, that National in 2011 could be hugely advantaged by this bill.Luckily for us all National is putting principle first:

English says standing back is not an option. The legislation is so draconian, so pernicious, so unsatisfactory and so unworkable, National is morally obliged to fight it, even though the bill’s failure to ban anonymous donations is very much to National’s advantage.

One has to give kudos to the Herald for covering this issue, because it is against their own self-interest also.  By shutting down almost all paid advocacy in election year, the media are made incredibly more powerful.  If lobby groups and parties can’t spend much money on promoting their issues, then editorial discretion as to what gets covered becomes massively more powerful.

This aspect gets noticed by Michelle Boag, who on her blog labels the bill as great news for the PR or public relations industry. Because if one can’t pay to advertise your view, you then need PR people to try and influence editorial coverage.

So in summary the bill is great for the incumbent Government, the media and the PR industry and bad for everyone else!

Whale Oil on Vodafone

Coolum

coo1.JPG

Had a great drive up to Coolum on Thursday.  The rental car had built in GPS which really should be compulsory in all rental cars.  It just makes driving in an unfamiliar location a breeze.  No gawking at maps, no worry about missing a turn off, no problems if you detour to see some scenery.

coo2.JPG

Was a pleasure to drive on decent roads – two or three lane roads almost the entire way.  And one notices even that extra 10 km/hr with the max being 110.  And yes they have even named a highway after him.

coo3.JPG

The Hyatt Regency in Coolum is a huge resort with several dozen hectares of land, a couple of hundred villas and a golf course.  You can see above a typical block of villas.

coo4.JPG

Most of the Consilium sessions are in the Pavilion.   There are over 100 attendees plus partners.  I love the way it is set up with one big round table.  And they have one of those systems where the camera automatically focuses on your seat if you push the mike button to speak.

coo5.JPG

And this is where we have lunch – as expected warm weather.

New Immigration Act

I’ve yet to go through the detail of it, but generally I think the Government and David Cunliffe should be congratulated for their proposed new Immigration Act.

Governments have been looking to reduce the massive delays and loopholes in the Act for over a decade.  Shysters like Irishman Danny Butler exploited every avenue to try and stay in NZ, and it took far too long to get rid of him.  Likewise the Zaoui case should be able to be determined within a year, not a decade.  Thd trouble is the longer it takes to resolve the more people think “oh let them stay, they’ve been here so long now anyway”.

The NZ Herald editorial also supports the proposed new law as a good balance.  I don’t know anyone who can justify having four seperate appeal bodies – the Residence Review Board, the Refugee Status Appeals Authority, the Removal Review Authority and the Deportation Review Tribunal.  One new Immigration and Protection Tribunal is a vast improvement.

Not surprisingly No Right Turn disagrees. Mind you his concerns over secret evidence may be well founded – I’ve yet to do a full clause by clause read of the Bill.  But it is generally headed in the right direction and I suspect after it is passed people will refer to the bad old days of 5+ year delays in resolcing immigration issues.

A good suggestion

The idiotic parent who were not allowed to name their kid “4Real” are now planning to register him as “Superman”.

I liked the suggestion:

Parents – if you think 4real is such a cool name, why don’t you change your own name by deed poll and wander round introducing yourself as 4Real for a month before deciding whether it is a good idea for your kid. Your kid is not you! And you don’t own him. Imagine being him – how hurt he’ll feel when he gets to school and discovers the name he identifies himself by has a totally different meaning for everyone else, and is generally considered a ridiculous one. He’ll be hurt his parents hadn’t thought of his feelings, hadn’t empathised with their own child’s situation. If the kid really wants to be called 4Real, he can choose it himself later on. And so what if you realised your kid was ‘4Real’. Later on he will make you ‘tired’ or maybe you’ll be ‘blown away’ by him, but do any of those make good names? They are just one of thousands of words to do with your child. No one doubts you love him, but think of him why don’t you.

In the end the state can’t and shouldn’t stop stupid names being registered for kids.  But really how selfish those parents are.

100 pages of comments

The Herald has over 100 pages of comments on the Paul Buchanan sacking.  That’s an amazing amount.  I can’t think too many lecturers would attract anywhere near that amount of comment.

Further development today was that he originally was very supportive to the student concerned, and only later went ballistic at her.

Wage Increases

The Council of Trade Unions has called for wage increase to keep up with house prices.

Yes, that will keep inflation down.  Massive wage rises with no increase in productivity.  And then interest rates will go up making home ownership even more difficult.

The CTU used to have an economist.  Is he or she on leave?

The People’s Mayor

Dick Hubbard is branding himself “The People’s Mayor”.

Presumably he means this in the sense of those trashy TV shows where someone is labelled “The People’s Judge”.

Actually the last three years have been a bit like a strange reality TV show!

Hone goes walkabout

Hone Harawira should become an Australian MP if he wants to use his NZ taxpayer funded time to campaign over there.

There’s no shortage of aboriginal leaders to give their views on what Howard has done.  In fact I’ll be hearing from some of those leaders this afternoon, including Warren Mundine a former Labor Party President.  Not all leaders are oppossed to the intervention.

Direct Democracy

A poster made this comment in the anarchism thread about direct democracy:

With direct democracy we would have never had the legalisation of homosexuality, the immigration of Asians, the teaching of Maori, Islam would be banned, liquor licences would run till midnight at most, concerts would be held in soundproof rooms – basically imagine if the whole country was run under the auspices of the RMA with input open to everyone.

Discuss!

Brisbane

I have been to Brisbane only twice before.  Once when I was around 14 with my family and once when I was around 25 with the NZ contingent attending the Australian/Asia-Pacific Venture in Queensland.  Both times we went to the amusement parks.

This time somewhat more sedate.  Caught up with an ex on Tuesday and on Wednesday just shopped and looked around Brisbane.  Thursday I pick up the rental car so will be more mobile.

qld4.JPG

A major mall on Queen Street. I love the open air nature of the shops and cafes.

qld5.JPG

The lake at the botanical gardens.

qld6.JPG

This is the State Parliament.

qld7.JPG

Another shot from the botanical gardens.

qld8.JPG

The Brisbane River.

Facelift’s John Key song

Facelift is in good form at the moment. For those who missed it here is the John Key song with Bill on drums and Gerry on the guitar.

One part I especially liked was:

Voters may worry that choosing me is a big punt
But I’m a good joker even though I’m quite a rich …..

Hat Tip: Whale Oil

July 2007 Public Polls

jul07polls.JPG

As one can see the average of the public polls in July 2007 sees National remain well ahead, but with a shrinking margin.

The latest Curia monthly newsletter has the following info in it:

  • Details of all five polls in the month
  • The weighted average of all the public polls and associated graphs
  • Summaries of other public polls on issues such as
    • Auckland Super City
    • Auckland Airport
    • Auckland Mayoralty
    •  Parliamentary Satire ban
    • KiwiSaver
    • America’s Cup Funding
    • Business and Consumer Confidence
  • Average results for public political polls in
    • United States
    • United Kingdom
    • Australia
    • Canada

You can subscribe to the free polling newsletter at this link.

A question

Health Targets

The Government has poured a huge amount of extra money into Vote Health since 1999, yet health outcomes have only marginally improved, or in some cases even got worse.

A CIS report found:

  •  Public health spending doubled in the last ten years, and has increased in real terms by 49% since 2000.
  • Since 2000 the increase in life expectancy has slowed right down. From 2000 to 2004 (the latest available year) the average has only moved from 78.7 to 79.4 years.
  • The rate of decrease in the infant mortality rate has slowed since 1997
  • hospital efficiency would appear to have fallen by 7.7% over the last three years.’
  • The number of elective surgery operations has actually declined since 2000, from 107,366 operations to 105,437 in 2006.
  • Hospital readmission rates—a key indicator of the quality of care—are unchanged from 2000.
  • Hospital mortality rates are unchanged from 2000.

Yesterday the Government finally, after eight years, announced a focus on outcomes rather than inputs or outputs.  This is a good thing as one can then judge the value of any extra spending.  The ten targets are:

  1. To increase immunisation rates of two year olds from 77% to 95%
  2. Increase from 54% to 85% the proportion of adolescents utilising oral health services
  3. An undefined increase for each DHB in elective service discharges
  4. Cancer patients to wait less than eight weeks for treatment to commence after assessment
  5. Reduce the number of avoidable hospital admissions
  6. Increase the percentage of diabates sufferers who have annual checks, and retinal screening
  7. 90% of mental health patients have up-to-date  relapse prevention plans
  8. Increase  proportion of infants breastfed to 74%, from 67%, at six weeks
  9. Increase the proportion of “never smokers” in year ten students by 2% from 54% to 56%
  10. Reduce the budget spent on the Ministry of Health from 1.85% to 1.65% by 2009/10

Now these are a good step forward.  However a few criticisms:

  • Most have no date associated with them
  • Three of them have no hard target for improvement
  •  Some go for an easy outcome but not the best outcome such as targeting the rate of diabetes checking rather than actually aiming to lower the rate of diabates.
    Same also aiming to have more mental health plans in place rather than a more ambitious target of fewer occurrences of mental health problems
  • The Ministry spending target is not very ambitious considering the total health spend is known to be budgeted to increase greatly by 2010 anyway.

It’s just a pity the Government has introduced these outcome targets at such a late stage we may never get to judge them on how well they do in implementing them.

Hopefully though future focus from the Government will be on these outcomes, not just on inputs and outputs as Pete Hodgsosn did in the very release announcing these where he claims:

  • 150,000 New Zealand women get free mammograms each year
  • an additional $2.2 billion has gone into primary healthcare
  • an extra 4000 nurses and 1200 doctors have been employed

All true and maybe all good, but the point of health spending isn’t for money spent, more doctors and more nurses, or even more cancer checks.  It is to have a lower mortality rate from cancer, a healthier population, less illness etc etc.

Stamford Plaza

I’ve been staying at the Stamford Plaza in Brisbane for a couple of days before driving north to Coolum where I’ll be attending the Consilium retreat organised by the Centre for Independent Studies.

qld1.JPG

This is the view from my room.  We’re next to the river and get all the morning sun. Not a bad view to wake up to.

qld2.JPG

The hotel is a pretty nice one.  They even have a TV in the bathroom!

qld3.JPG

And this is a view of the hotel from the next door botanical gardens.

The TVNZ dismissal

Was TVNZ wrong to dismiss a security guard for haranguing Christine Rankin over her views on Maori and child abuse?

First of all EPMU national secretary Andrew Little is wrong to claim or imply that  the security guard did nothing wrong and was just expressing his rights as a citizen.  As a citizen Mr Rawnsley can write a letter to the editor, run a blog etc.  His rights don’t extend to confronting guests of his employer especially when as TVNZ CEO Rick Ellis says, his job is to “be the welcoming and safe face of TVNZ”.

However while Rawnsley was wrong, that doesn’t mean TVNZ was right to dismiss him outright for his actions.  Considering his length of service, 24 years, I am pretty appalled they didn’t just give him a warning.

Having said that, we don’t know the full details such as whether his language was more colourful than he claimed, or whether he was asked to apologise and refused.

But on the basis of the facts known at this stage, the sacking is an over reaction, just as Paul Buchanan’s was.

Dewar found guilty

John Dewar has been found guilty on four charges of attempting to obstruct or defeat the course of justice

This does not come as any surprise to anyone who has been following the case.

There is an irony that the people he tried to cover up for got found not guilty, while he is now going to go to jail.

Impact of the Holocaust

Interesting reading of a Wikipedia article comparing the Jewish population in 1900 and 2005. During that time global population increased from 1.65 billion to 6.00 billion or by 264%.

The Jewish population in 1900 was 11.2 million. At 264% increase it would have been 29.5 million. Instead it is 14.6 million.

More striking is looking on a country basis how even today – 60 years after WWII, the Jewish populations are a fraction of what they were. Examples:

  • Algeria – from 51,000 to 100
  • Austria/Hungary/Poland – from 3.4 million to 93,000
  • Germany – from 586,000 to 107,000
  • Netherlands – from 104,000 to 33,000
  • Morocco – from 110,000 to 5,000
  • Romania – from 269,000 to 6,000
  • Russia – from 3.9 million to 717,000

We shall never forget.

Best Excuses

A lively thread in the post about the sacking of Paul Buchanan who told a student he did not believe her father had died (and we are yet to have confirmed if said father is indeed dead) as an excuse for a late essay.

So what are the best excuses you have made or had made to you for a late assisgnment or essay. My best excuse was in 1996 for one of quant papers.  It went like this:

I won’t be able to get my essay to you today but I have a really good excuse.

It all started a couple of weeks ago when the Prime Minister did really badly in the first leader’s debate.  We decided we needed to have our supporters more fired up, so I got assigned to training up around 30 – 40 of them in how to heckle.

The lecturer looks at me and realises this is a fairly original and possibly lengthy explanation.

So anyway I put together a sheet on good heckle lines, and how to time your heckle etc.  Had some very good lines such as reminding Jim Anderton who campaigned against cheap Japanese imports that his campaign bus was a cheap Japanese import nickname Sooty due to the masses of exhaust it exhaled.  Also lines to Winston Peters such as “Michael Laws told you to say that” no matter what the topic is.

Anyway we had the meeting and it went very well.  That was two days ago. Then yesterday it transpired that some prick had photocopied the heckle lines and went and stuck a copy of them underneath every door in the press gallery.

Hence yesterday at around 9.30 am my phone started to go crazy.  It was the day of the second and final Leader’s debate and all the press had a copy of my heckling memo and lines for supporters.   I got hauled into McCully’s office and told that I was to flee the premises, avoiding any press, and not turn up for a few days until it had died down.

So I immediately went from McCully’s office down in the private Ministerial lift the press can’t get to, and out through the basement, avoiding the horde of journalists in the corridor looking for me.

Now the problem sir is that my text books and my notes were in my Beehive office.  I couldn’t get past the media to retrieve them so I had to leave them there.  But I should be able to go in at the weekend and get them, so could I hand my assignment in on next Monday.

 The lecturer then responded with words along the lines of:

I’m going to give you the extension for two reasons.

  1. Even if you are lying, you deserve an extension for the originality of the excuse.  I doubt I will hear such a convoluted story again.
  2. You were the lead item on the TV3 news last night

🙂

Incinerate the Electoral Finance Bill

People should listen to this interview on National Radio Nine to Noon with Steven Price. Steven isn’t a dirty rightie like me. Steven is a respected media law commentator, a spokesperson of the Coalition for Open Government and Nicky Hager’s lawyer. I say this just to make the point that the language used to describe the bill comes from someone who thought he would be the chief supporter of the bill.

Steven starts by saying:

Let’s rip the flesh off this Electoral Finance Bill and incinerate it

Then on the 3rd party restrictions:

They’re also shut down an awful lot of political speech, almost everybody’s political speech

Kathryn Ryan upon learning that these restrictions will not just be the traditional 90 days but all of election year commented:

That’s crazy

Steven goes on to explain the definition of election advertising is so wide

It captures almost all political discourse in that year

Submissions on this draconian bill can now be made, and close on 7 September.

If ever there was a bill you should do a submission on, it is this. It will affect the rights of almost all NZers to have their say on political issues. Do not assume that the MPs will magically fix it.

Under this bill it will be illegal to upload a video to You Tube attacking the Government unless you sign a statutory declaration.

It will be illegal to promote an online petition against a Government policy without a statutory declaration or registering.

Have you say, while you still can. Details of how to submit are here.

I will provide some ideas and suggestions for people to help with their submissions closer to the deadline. So don’t worry if you are not an expert on the bill. But please take the time to make a submission.

A verdict before the inquiry

Well why bother with the inquiry, as Annette King has already declared that it was all just a case of forgetful memory and that this is not a hanging offence.

Let us be very clear about this.  Only three people knew that David Benson-Pope had indeed expressed an opinion to Hugh Logan that is Setchell wasn’t removed he would not be able to be free and frank with the Ministry.  They are DBP, Hugh Logan and Mark Prebble.

And we are expected to believe that all three of them simply forgot.   The only three people who knew, all had identical memory failure.

Hugh Logan somehow remembered to tell Prebble, but forgot to tell Rennie.

Benson-Pope forgot to tell anyone at all.

Mark Prebble actually wrote an article on the Setchell issue, and as he typed out the words declaring there had been no Ministerial involvement, he forgot that he knew there had been.

Hugh Logan who saw the article before it was printed, also forgot that he had had this conversation, and didn’t remind Dr Prebble again.

An inquiry reporting to Dr Prebble, about Dr Prebble, is totally inappropriate.  Especially as Annette King has already signalled the desired outcome.

There should be a judicial inquiry by a Judge with powers to take testimony under oath.