Parole Changes

I suppose it is little surprise that the NZ Herald reports that families of crime victims support a toughening up of parole laws while defence lawyers do not, labelling them as akin to Guantanamo Bay.

The defence lawyers miss, or do not agree with me, on a key point. Parole is a privilege, not a right you get at one third or even two thirds of your sentence.

The onus of proof should be overwhelmingly against early release, unless the Parole Board is convinced they will not reoffend.

And as we saw with Burton taking a narrow legalistic approach to what evidence may be considered by the Parole Board has tragic consequences. Every prison officer who knew Burton thought he would reoffend. But they were unable to say so. Very little of a prisoner’s behaviour in prison goes to the Board.

Now if this was the primary judicial forum for sentencing, then I would say yes you must meet court rules of evidence. But it is not. They have been found guilty and sentenced to a full term in jail. Parole is a privilege, and to prevent dangerous criminals getting out early, a lesser standard of proof regarding their behaviour is fine. This is not about proving whether they committed a crime – it is about making a best risk assessment of their propensity to reoffend.

And yes there are some risks that a malicious guard could lie to keep someone in prison longer, but at the end of the day the only “harm” done by that is a prisoner serves their full term (for which they were found guilty beyond reasonable doubt), and that is a much lesser harm than a dangerous prisoner is released early to kill, rape, beat or steal from law abiding members of the community.

I do agree though with the criticism of having any money paid to prisoners for mistreatment, handed over to their victims. Two wrongs do not make a right. One does not want a perverse incentive for prison guards to beat up prisoners so then compensation will flow to the original victims of the prisoner.

National on Climate Change

Colin James looks at National on climate change.

Former president Geoff Thompson delivered a decidedly greenish briefing to its lower North Island conference on Saturday. His text had been cleared as consistent with Key’s upcoming speech. No one, not even a farmer, challenged him from the floor.

Thompson told the conference: “It’s about taking a realistic attitude to the management of risk,” and likened it to insuring your house against the (unlikely) possibility of fire. “We will be judged as a member of the international community and as exporters on our response.”

Thompson went on to promote the sort of numerical target Helen Clark and David Parker (and Key) have so far avoided: “National is looking at a 50 per cent reduction [in greenhouse gas emissions] by 2050.”

Meanwhile, there is a Budget next week on which the Government is pinning much hope. Expect lofty climate change rhetoric. Six months ago that might have got the jump on National. Now the picture is much murkier.

It will be interesting to see what is in the Budget – will it be rhetoric, or substance? And more importantly will the substance stand up to a decent cost benefit analysis?

New Zealanders

I wasn’t a huge fan of the trend to write one’s nationality as “New Zealander” on the census, mainly because as such a big users of Stats NZ data, I didn’t want to contribute to making it less useful.

However sociology professor Charles Crother (never thought I would be agreeing with a sociology professor!) makes a strong case in the NZ Herald that ethnicity is not just about ancestry or race but cultural affiliation, and that especially for younger New Zealanders born in NZ, the tag of European is one they feel no affinity for. It is almost a rejection of European culture for NZ culture (and it is different).

I did tick NZ European/Caucasian in the Census. But who knows, next time I may join the 500,000 Kiwis who wrote in “New Zealander”. Because that certainly is my culture.

Banning Gangs

There are three issues around the call for the banning of gangs, for me. The first is whether it can be done without any “false positives”, the second would it be effective, and the third is it justified?

The issue of false positives is how do you define a gang without also including say a rotary club. The simple solution for me is to have it as a group where more than say 80% of the members have criminal convictions. The other approach is to let the Government proscribe as they do with terrorist groups, but that gives the Government some pretty wide powers.

The issue of effectiveness is the one hard to overcome. If one looks at authoritarian countries like China, they do not have any public patched gangs. But they do have extensive organised crimes through triads etc, so the PM may be correct that banning gangs just sends them underground.

I suspect there would be pros and cons of banning gangs. The pros would be less street violence, less gang forts, less public recruitment. But the cons might be a move to more serious behind the scenes crimes such as kidnapping and blackmail.

Finally the third issue is whether one can justify removing the right of free association, even for gang members and criminals. Now there are some gangs which do just exist for the purpose of planning and executing crimes to which the answer might be yes, but I am informed that there are some gangs which are not such fronts, even though their members still have a fair few convictions amongst them.

I am a moron

Sedition laws to go

NZPA is reporting that the Government has agreed with the Law Commission to scrap the sedition laws. This is excellent news.

Parties in favour of scrapping are:

Labour 48
Greens 6
Maori 4
United 3
ACT 2
Progressive 1

So an easy 64/121 votes. As far as I know National and NZ First have not yet declared a position. I won’t be surprised if it ends up being supported by all eight parties.

No Right Turn deserves kudos for his research and tireless blogging of this area. Tim Selwyn also for being the sacrificial lamb which reignited the debate.

Subway Management are morons

Subway Dunedin found one of their staff, Jackie Lang, poured two cups of Coke for her and a friend without paying for them. The retail value of the drinks is $4 and the wholesale value (actual cost) is probably 10c or so (drinks are here the big margins are in fast food).

Now while Ms Lang shouldn’t have done what she did, a reasonable employer would probably just give her a warning. Unless there were other issues with her employment, outright dismissal is somewhat over the top.

But even that pales into comparison with what they did, which is not just to sack her, but to have her arrested and charged with theft is just nuts. It reminds me of Otago University a few years ago who had a cleaner arrested for stealing university pens. Hell if taking a pen home makes you a thief, we’re all thieves.

Lang will I am sure get diversion, but it would be better of Subway asked the Police to drop the charges. The damage to their corporate reputation will be considerable. It certainly makes me less willing to go there, if that is how they behave.

Lang did do wrong, and Subway were justified in taking some action. But having someone arrested for sharing a drink with a friend is vast overkill.

Ten things in National’s first budget

(1) An ongoing programme of ‘real’ personal tax cuts

(2) A substantial investment in infrastructure across public transport, roading, telecommunications, water and energy.

(3) A Resource Management Act Amendment Bill that will reduce the costs, delays and uncertainties of the RMA

(4) Policies that deliver the right incentives for people to choose work rather than welfare.

(5)·Reintroduce competition to the ACC system.

(6) A 90-day trial for new employees that will mean those who are most vulnerable in the labour market can be given a chance.

(7) An ongoing programme to fix the fact that 1 in 5 New Zealand kids are not succeeding at school.

(8) A stop to the flood of new regulations and red tape.

(9) Immigration policies that ensure we attract the best and skilled migrants that our country needs.

(10)· A sensible spending track that recognises the value of our core public services but doesn’t think the government should do everything in our society.

I think this shoes the substantial differences one would have in a National budget and Labour budget.

From: National

Labour Maori MPs may be axed

Martin Kay in The Press reports that Labour MPs Mita Ririnui and Mahara Okeroa may fail to get selected. Ririnui lost Waiariki to Te Ururoa Flavell last election and Okeroa is trailling in the polls in Te Tai Tonga.

I think it will be very hard for Labour to win back any seats off the Maori Party, or indeed to hold onto Te Tai Tonga. Horomia and Mahuta seem safe at this stage though.

NZ places I have stayed in

When doing a meme on places I have lived, it got me thinking about places I have stayed in, within NZ. One of my jobs at Parliament had me do overnight visits to pretty much every MP’s electorate office, so I’ve stayed in a lot of places like Matamata which might not normally be a tourism highlight.

All up I’ve stayed in 101 separate towns, localities or cities. Might be a bit more than that – probably a couple over looked. Most fun probably has been Mt Maunganui and least fun Wanganui!

Akaroa
Arrowtown
Ashburton
Continue reading »

Sunday Stroll

Atheist Revolution blogs on the statement by Christopher Hitchens that Karl Rove is an athiest, and that Bush is less of an believer than say Jimmy Carter was. Of course some can’t accept it, as painting everyone as religious nutters is so much easier.

They pander to the religious right in the US, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they are of them.

Maramatanga has a very good summary of the boundary changes.

John Bishop writes in the Press on why political donations should not be restricted.

TUANZ blogs on why it criticised the Government’s decision not to regulate mobile termination rates, and how an open transparent decision of the Telco Commissioner was overturned on the back of a series of private meetings.

Half Done highlights the US Judge who is suing his dry cleaner for $67 million – just for a pair of lost pants!

Virtual Super 14 Final Round

Okay the final round was not too bad. I got 31 points in a low scoring round and with thatI cracked the 400 mark, specifically 405. My global ranking is 9,223 (up 6,112) of 155,708 which has me in the 6th percentile.

I picked 5/7 games correctly, but only two margins correctly. I did not pick the Hurricanes losing (sigh) or the Chiefs beating the Crusaders.

Of the 91 people on the NZ bloggers challenge, I am in 6th place. Those above me in order are Mark Montgomerie (431), Graeme T (414), Brian Burgess (410), Graeme Edgeler (406) and Whale Oil (406).

The global champion at this stage is on 474 points.

Semis next weekend. I suppose I have to support the Blues and Crusaders.

Party Infighting

Adolf at Sir H highlights the story of how blogger Phil U got expelled from the Greens on the basis of secret dossiers. What happened to making decisions openly by consensus 🙂

And Red Rasputin has details of a complaint to Labour’s governing body signed by 18 Princes Street Labour members.

NZ First is also having tensions between the parliamentary and organisational wing. United Future, I hear, is having the Christians depart unhappy with Dunne on smacking. ACT always has tensions and National no doubt has some robust debate on the smacking compromise.

Times like this Jim Anderton must like being sole dictator of his own party – I mean it is even named after him 🙂

45 days!

It was hilarious watching the US live cable coverage of Paris Hilton being sentenced to 45 days jail for a parole violation relating to a drink driving case.

I’ve never seen so many news anchors and journalists with huge grins on their faces. I mean one could have boiled an egg on the heat of the joy radiating from their bodies. None of them actually came out and said “There is karma after all” but they were thinking it.

Labor MP asks driver for sex

hoare.JPG

A Federal Labor MP, Kelly Hoare, is undergoing counselling after allegedly asked a government car driver whilst being chauffeured to her Sydney home, “Why don’t you come in and fuck me”.

0%2C%2C5472704%2C00.jpg

Ms Hoare, 43, has been an MP for almost nine years.

I hope the driver has had counselling for the hassles he will get from his colleagues for the next ten years.

Labour appoints convicted fraudster as local campaign manager

James Papali’i has just been appointed to be the Labour Party campaign manager for the Mangere campaign in Manukau City.

James Papali’i is a convicted criminal. And not decades ago but just nine months ago! He was found guilty on 29 charges of forgery, theft and dishonesty. He stole $40,000 from a trust set up to help at-risk youth.

Now I am not saying that a conviction should be a bar for ever for political involvement. But for Labour to have him as their local campaign manager within months of his conviction for theft, is highly inappropriate.

Hat Tip: Sir H

Fred Thompson

Fred Thompson is a former US Senator and a potential candidate for the Republican 2008 Presidential nomination. He is also an actor and most well known for his portrayal of Arthur Branch on the series Law & Order.

The Branch character is a former Yale Law Professor who becomes a popular tough as nails conservative New York District Attorney. The popularity of the character benefits Thompson as some people see his character as him (cf the Governorator).

With that in mind, I enjoyed receiving today this e-mail:

AWESOME FACTS ABOUT FRED THOMPSON

* Fred Thompson has on multiple occasions pronounced “nuclear” correctly.

* Fred Thompson has blasted more people in the face with a shotgun than even Dick Cheney.

* The masked executioner of Saddam Hussein: Fred Thompson.

* Not only does Fred Thompson cut taxes, he cuts tax collectors.

* Fred Thompson is the only person to have ever bested Miyamato Mushashi in a duel. The reason Musashi is so vague about the book of the void is because the fifth ring of combat is really Fred Thompson.

* The reason Fred Thompson didn’t want to stay in the Senate for long is because all the extra scrutiny kept him from doing his favorite hobby: Prowling the streets at night killing drug dealers.

* Every night before going to sleep, Osama bin Laden checks under his bed for Fred Thompson.
Continue reading »

Female cop on Lundy etc

The SST has a review of a book by Palmerston North detective Liz Williams called Does This Make My Gun Look Big?

Williams was liasion to the Lundy family after Christine and Amber were found dead. She talks of how she didn’t assume Lundy was guilty at first, but after observing his behaviour at the funeral parlour and crime scene, she thought he definitely was. She labels his behaviour as a B grade movie performance.

She also reveals that one in three rape complaints she has investigated are false or unsubstantiated, and how angry she is for the real victims, whose life is made more difficult by the false complaints.

Hooton on Smacking Compromise

Matthew Hooton backgrounds the smacking compromise, and what it means politically.

Panicked, the government spent March prancing about, trying to make it go away. It attacked parents who were concerned about the bill – the prime minister smeared them as thrashers and beaters, reminiscent of her vilifying the hikoi marchers as “haters and wreckers”. She considered adopting the bill as a government measure, or forcing it through under urgency, but she couldn’t get the support.

Faced with the inevitability that Clark would move, Key had two options. He could make the most of it, and position himself as the equal of the nation’s leader, or he could risk being associated with the bill’s more rabid opponents, who were advancing towards the steps of parliament. The latter was never a real option for National’s cosmopolitan new leader.

In allowing the compromise, Key threw away an opportunity for his backbenchers to have a field day against Labour and he’s given Cullen an opening to promote whatever inspiring initiatives are in his Budget – but it is doubtful he gave away much more. For all the heat they generate in the short run, conscience issues don’t dominate election campaigns.

What Clark has given up is much more important – the ability to ever again demonise Key as a wolf in sheep’s clothing, the son of Ruth Richardson, the pawn of the religious right.

Such charges – however dishonest, even ludicrous – were to have been the central theme of her re-election strategy next year. Smearing Key was essential to Clark to allow her to use the same crude fear tactics and “Don’t Put It All Risk” slogan with which she so successfully slayed Don Brash in the final week of the 2005 campaign.

Key has acted on his own conscience and judgement. He has done the right thing, and he has been politically smart at the same time, leaving Labour’s planned 2008 election strategy in tatters. He is on his way to the prime ministership. Those who can’t stomach the new, modern National Party he is building can always go and vote for Act.

SST reports on VUWSA

The SST has done a story on the excesses by some members of the VUWSA Exec, which have been reported in Salient and here.

AUSA used to have such excesses. I note they seem to have dramatically reduced under voluntary membership.

The full report of what the exec members did is meant to be on the VUWSA site but I can’t find it.

Fraser on TVNZ

The SST has an interview with Ian Fraser. Some of it is expected justifying his record, but what I found interesting was:

His belief that the “hybrid” model of public service and commercial television cannot work and should be abandoned.

Fraser also calls on the government to sell off TV2 and turn TV One into a non-commercial public service channel combined with Maori Television and Radio New Zealand.

Fraser has a lifetime of dedication to public broadcasting, so when he says the TVNZ model is fatally flawed as a hybrid, people should listen.

I have long advocated selling off a fully commercial TV2 and having TV One as a public service broadcaster. The idea of merging it with Radio NZ and Maori TV also has some merit – more so for Radio NZ than Maori TV.

Privay Act excuses

The Herald on Sunday editorial rightly lambasts NZ Post for hiding behind the Privacy Act to justify heir refusal to reveal the surname of a sacked staff member who harrassed a customer. By refusing to reveal his surname, she is unable to apply for a protection order against the man.

As the Privacy Commissioner herself states, NZ Post is placing the privacy of a former staff member who broke the law, over the customer whose privacy was appallingly breached by said staffer. Madness.

Another meme

For some reason when one has been out all night, and you finally get home, then doing a meme seems more of a good idea than normal. Anyway stolen from Andrew Falloon.

1. How old will you be in 12 months? 40 years, 7 months, 23 days.

2. Do you think you’ll be married by then? No, unless I get drunk at Vegas again.

3. What do you look forward to most in the next 3 months? Consilium

4. Who was the last person you called? Tim Grafton

5. Who was the last person to call you? Nicola Shepheard, Herald on Sunday at 7.11pm.

6. Do you prefer to call or text? Call, but I text heaps to save money.

7. Do you have any pets? No but am fond of my niece’s two kittens and Accident Girl’s two Griffons.

8. What were you doing at 12am last night? Dancing badly

9. Parents seperated/divorced/married? Married.

10. When is the last time you saw your mom? Last Sunday

11. What happened at 11:00a.m? I was blogging!

12. How many states have you lived in? Have stayed in California, Nevada, Arizona, Florida, DC, Virginia, New York

13. How many cities/towns have you lived in? In NZ I have lived in Dunedin and Wellington.

14. Do you prefer shoes, socks, or bare feet? bare feet at home

15. Are you a social person? Yeah

16. What was the last thing you ate? Lasagne

17. Favorite ice cream? Naepolitian

18. What is your favorite dessert? Pavlova

19. What is your favorite TV show? Southpark then Grey’s Anatomy. Was West Wing.

20. What kind of jelly do you like on your PB & J sandwich? Oh yuck.

21. Do you like coffee? Not much. I never drink it by myself but end up having half a dozen flat whites a week through meeting people.

22. How many glasses of water a day do you drink on average? Half a dozen, plus heaps of milk and diet coke.

23. What do you drink in the morning? Water

24. Would you rather kiss someone with or without a tongue ring? Prefer without. Is fun when someone does have one but novelty wears out.

25. Do you sleep on a certain side of the bed? The right side is mine – of course!

26. Do you know how to play poker? Yes, but not a regular player. Prefer Blackjack.

27. Do you like to cuddle? Generally yes.

28. Any plans for this weekend? This weekend went with five girls to Downstage (had free tickets for The Graduate).

29. Do you eat out or at home more often? At home but I do eat out a lot.

32. Would you ever get your nipples pierced? Never.

33. Have you ever been in an ambulance? No.

34. Do you prefer an ocean or a pool? Pool. The ocean – I love the surf.

35. Do you prefer a window seat or an aisle seat? Aisle. Hate being cramped in.

36. Do you know how to drive a stick shift? I do. Once, but no longer I would say. Cactus Kate can testify to that.

37. What is your favorite thing to spend money on? Books.

38. Do you wear any jewellery 24/7? Not even a watch.

39. Do you speak any other language? A but of Latin but that isn’t meant to be spoken anyway.

40. Can you roll your tongue? Nah.

41. Who is the funniest person you know? Chris S.

42. Do you sleep with stuffed animals? No but I still have the ones I used to sleep with.

43. Would you rather make out with a one armed Slovakian midget or run without a bra on? Depends how hot the midget is.

44. What is the main ring tone on your phone? The Simpsons!

45. Do you still have clothes from when you were little? No.

46. What is the color of your bedroom walls? Vanilla.

47. Do you shut off the water when you brush your teeth? No.

48. Have you been kissed by anyone this week? Yes.

49. Do you like overly sensitive people? Yes but they may not like my insensitivity 🙂

50. Do you talk to the person who posted this before you? Only if we are at the same pub, which has been once!

Final French polls

I’ve been quite disappointed with Segolene Royal in the last two weeks. She seems to have abandoned campaigning on her policies and strengths to a launch a series of character attacks and alarmist statements against her opponent. She really deserves to lose. She took a bold initiative early on with announcing 100 policies in one day (not that I agreed with them, but it was a good thing to do), but in desperation has gone down the usual leftish track of warning of of riots and violence if her opponent wins.

France bans polls in the last two days, but there were nine polls done in May. Sarokozy in April averaged a 53 to 37 lead. In May it has averaged 53.7% to 46.3% so Sarokozy seems to be fairly secure. I think he will win by a 5% to 8% margin.