DPF on Agenda

I’m one of the two guest panelists on Agenda this Saturday, which means I get to ask the interviewees some questions, and talk about the issues of the week.

The good news for me is I get to spend Friday evening in Auckland, having some drinks with friends. The bad news is I’ll need to be up by 7am šŸ™

Sea Lion Mums

sealions.JPG

Forest & Bird are are asking people to celebrate Mother’s Day by helping sea lion mums whose population has been declining.

MPs who are Mums will be accepting Mothers’ Day cards from Forest & Bird on Parliament’s front steps today. Katherine Rich, Heather Roy, Metiria Turei, Judy Turner, Barbara Stewart and Marian Hobbs are all taking part.

UPDATE: Photo from Parliament below:

sealionmps.JPG

Tony Blair’s greatest legacy?

Tony Blair’s legacy is at best a mixed one. But it is probably very fitting that in the week he is expected to announce his resignation, that Ian Paisley and Martin McGuinesss get sworn in as First Minister and Deputy First Minister of Northern Ireland.

It is inspiring, and makes me think maybe there is hope for the Middle East.

Tony Blair is only one of those responsible for the end of the civil war, but his role was not insignificant. It probably will be his greatest legacy.

Neil Finn defends his comments

Crowded House’s Neil Finn defends the comments he made about the PM seeking music glory. His article speaks for itself but some extracts for the lazy:

I just got back to town and discovered that the likes of Howard Morrison, Ray Columbus and Paul Holmes are upset about comments I made to Real Groove magazine. My first thoughts were hooray, I must be doing something right!

My comments about the PM stem from the 2005 Music Awards which resembled a Labour Party Conference, complete with red balloons. According to organisers, Helen, rather than being invited to speak, had insisted on addressing the assembly. Like other years, she undoubtedly enjoyed being cheered by a grateful music industry while Don Brash sitting in the front row was insulted from the stage. Despite this – and to his credit – Don stayed till the end of the night, unlike Helen who left soon after the applause had died down. Many people felt uncomfortable and I left feeling a bit sickened. I don’t believe it’s healthy that musicians and politicians should be so closely aligned.

Hey, I am quite enjoying the feeling of being unpopular. There is something liberating in it.

Those Music Awards were a disgrace, Even the organisers said so and apologised. Good on Neil Finn for not just backing down.

Obama does a Bushism

Goerge Bush is well known for his Bushisms or verbal gaffes such as the one this week when he said the Queen visited in 1776. But much worse than that one is Barack Obama’s who somehow managed to turn a tornado which killed 12 people into one which killed 10,000.

NZ vs Australia tax rates

The latest changes to the Australian tax rates now means that all Australians earning less than $250,000 pay less in tax than we do in NZ. And that’s before we even look at higher wages, and less indirect taxes.

taxrates.JPG

The table above shows how much tax Australians and NZers will be paying at each income level. Also what the effective average tax rate will be.

If you have an entry level job at $20K, Dr Cullen takes 18.2% off you, while Mr Costello will take only 6.8% giving you an extra $2,300 to spend.

At the average wage of $40K, Dr Cullen takes 20.2% and Mr Costello only 14.6%.

At $80K, Dr Cullen takes 28.1% to 22.3% for Costello. That’s an extra $4,000+.

Now let us look at what a Finance Minister who does not hate tax cuts can do over time.

taxcuts2.JPG

Now remember in looking at the above table, that Australia has had far smaller surpluses as a % of GDP than NZ, yet have managed to cut taxes consistently.

Low income Aussies have had a 40% reduction in the tax they pay. Those on our average wage of $40,000 have had a massive 28% reduction in tax.

In fact everyone earning under $150,000 had has a 20% or greater reduction in tax.

NZ has had a golden opportunity to lower taxes over the last few years – at times when it would not have been inflationary and we had the second best best fiscal position in the world.

Thanks to Dr Cullen we have lost the opportunity to stay competitive with Australia, and to give hard working Kiwis some of their own money back.

Fisking the NZ Herald Editorial

The NZ Herald Editorial makes a number of assertions regarding the operational separation of Telecom which are to be blunt quite wrong. Taking them in order:

If the Government is determined upon a three-way split it might have to buy back the wire network.

The Government has no choice about a three way split. It is the law of the land as set down in the Telecommunications Act, passed 199-2 by Parliament.

It might get that opportunity if Telecom went ahead with its preferred two-way separation, keeping wholesale and retail sales together and setting up a separate network company.

The law does not allow a two-way separation. Telecom proposed one last year and it was rejected in favour of a three-way one – a decision Telecom said at the time it accepts.

It is hard to see why the Government is hell-bent on a three-way split when the state’s experience with electricity suggests it is impractical.

Again the Government is not hell-bent. It’s original bill was for LLU, UBS and NDSL only. It was the Select Committee that near unamiously decided to include a three way operational separtion split.

And the op sep model has no relation to the way the electricty sector is structured.

Lessons can surely be taken from one line network for the other. There would seem no harm in Telecom retaining wholesale and retail interests if its network is open to all competitors and managed as a distinct business.

This statement ignores what is in the op sep plan. Telecom are allowed to retain both wholesale and retail interests under op sep. It just has to treat its retail arm the same as other retail customers. At present you have nonsense situations where Telecom retail prices are cheaper than the wholesale prices offered to other retailers. It’s about whether Telecom Retail can connect via Ethernet which is very cheap while other players have to buy very expensive ATM boxes.

If Telecom has underinvested in the wire network, it is probably farsighted. Rapid developments in wireless technology suggest the telephone lines could soon be the railway of telecommunications – carrying bulk cargo but not much human traffic.

Now this is just incredible – praising Telecom for underinvesting in the network. What planet was the leader writer on? Have they actually talked to anyone in industry about this?

First of all while wireless and mobile is going to be doing some amazing stuff, it is generally complementary to fixed line networks not a substitute for it. Plus ever with wireless and mobile, it still needs the fibre backhaul network to be robust enough to carry the traffic. Praising Telecom for its underinvestment is just madness.

Next I suppose the NZ Herald will praise the lack of roads in Auckland.

Sign the Subway Petition

Jeremy and I have set up an online petition where people can signify their support for:

Subway New Zealand and Subway George Street Dunedin to show compassion and common sense in the case of Jackie Lang, and for them to formally request the Police not to prosecute her for the alleged misappropriation of a $2 soda which she shared with a friend, and to resolve her employment status in a manner satisfactory to both Subway and Ms Lang.

If you think this would be a good outcome, please feel free to sign the petition and if you have a website to promote it on your site, and/or e-mail friends about it.

Exterminate the Jews

I saw this quote on PC’s blog:

This is Islam, that was ahead of its time with regards to human rights in the treatment of prisoners, but our people was afflicted by the cancerous lump, that is the Jews, in the heart of the Arab nation.

Be certain that America is on its way to disappear, America is wallowing [in blood] today in Iraq and Afghanistan, America is defeated and Israel is defeated, and was defeated in Lebanon and Palestine. Make us victorious over the infidel people.

Allah, take hold of the Jews and their allies, Allah, take hold of the Americans and their allies. Allah, count them and kill them to the last one and dont leave even one.

So who was this person? Was it a radical extremist Iman? A marginalised terrorist? No it is Dr. Ahmad Bahar, the acting Speaker of the Palestinian Legislative Council.

Better make that wall even higher!

1 million Amazon Harry Potter orders

Sir Geoffrey Palmer

Chris Finlayson has pointed out the inappropriateness of the President of the Law Commission also being a major Labour Party donor.

I’ve actually been concerned for sometime that Sir Geoffrey has expanded the traditional role of the Commission to become the PM’s personal law drafter such as on the Bradford Bill.

I’m a huge fan of the Law Commission for its traditional role. It is one of the few areas of Government which is proactive not reactive – looking at different areas of law and proposing how we can improve them. And their work on sedition is a good example of that.

But they seem to be often going beyond that, and almost like a law firm proposing specific amendments. That as far as I know is not their role. We have Parliamentary Counsel Office for that, plus Crown Law and Ministry of Justice can advise on such things. The Law Commission should be the big picture stuff IMO.

Busy Day

Very busy day today. Had gym at 8.00 am, quotes for clients through the morning, then a meeting at InternetNZ at 11.30 am, a conference call with ISPs on Telecom structural separation at 1.30 p.m., a meeting to discuss fibre to the home ideas at 3.00 p.m. and at 6 p.m. a meeting of the Parliamentary Internet Caucus where presentations and discussions on digital broadcasting will occur.

Somehow amongst all this I need to find time to work on an address I have to give in a fortnight to the Pacific Rim Policy Conference, which is in Hawaii. Over 100 leaders of US and other thinktanks will be there so very high powered audience.

I’m talking on Intellectual Property in an Internet age, and will be looking at problems and solutions ranging from market solutions to technological “solutions”. Richard Prebble and Don Brash are also guest speakers so will be a good Kiwi contingent there.

Turia on Gangs

80% of the time the Maori Party says sensible stuff that almost all parties and people can agree with. And then every so often, they (normally Turia) come out with absolute clangers. One was Tariana Turia’s call for more race based seats – for Pacific Islanders.

Another was yesterday when she said “But just like I’m not prepared to say that the police are all rapists, I am also not prepared to say that all gangs are criminals”.

The inability to differentiate between the Police and gangs is disturbing on many levels. First of all it really is insulting to ever talk about maybe not all Police are rapists as is even a significant proprotion are. While by no means overlooking the deplorable behaviour of some in Rotorua in the 1980s, there are almost 10,000 sworn Police. How would Turia like someone saying “I’m not prepared to say all Maori are rapists” which strongly suggests that it is a debatable proposition. Saying not all Police are rapists is not a debatable proposition. It is obviously true.

Now the proposition that not all gangs are criminal is highly debatable. Certainly the vast majority of gangs exist for the purpose of undertaking criminal activity. It is part of their initiation into membership. Now it may be there are some gangs which are not so much into criminal activity, but it is not a foregone conclusion.

And then Turia’s thinly veiled racism when she tries to blame the P problem on Asians is deplorable. I saw a story somewhere refuting her point – in fact it is mainly being done via non Asian gangs. And she is wrong she she suggests the Police ignore Asian crime – they have a dedicated unit for it.

How the Government is cracking down on gangs

In response to being asked what the Government was doing to crack down on gangs and organised crime, Justice Minister Mark Burton talked about his bold moves in updating the Secondhand Dealers and Pawnbrokers Act, and other laws.

As John Armstrong notes, it was not a sterling performance.

But I am sure all the gangs which operate second hand goods businesses will be quaking with fear.

America’s Cup

Is anyone actually following the America’s Cup? I watched every race the last few Cups but couldn’t even tell you the points board this time. No one I know is talking about it much. Perhaps it will change if we make the Challenger Finals?

Anyway I see we won a race.

Tax Cuts in Australia

Peter Costello has just announced A$31.5 billion of tax cuts, on a A$10.6 billion surplus. Now that surplus in nominal terms is around the same size as NZ’s last year. As a % of GDP it is around one fifth the size of our surplus.

Plus Australia is investing in its own super fund, $10 billion on water supply, $741 million for climate change, an $8,000 rebate for solar panel installation, $5 billion for higher education, $1.6 billion for aged care.

And what has the Australian Labor Party said regarding the tax cuts? They have come out saying they support them.

The NZ Labour Party’s hatred of tax cuts is almost unique around the world. Left wing parties in the UK, Australia, US, Germany have all supported tax cuts. I doubt you could find a party anywhere in the world which would not have cut taxes by now, given a crown surplus which is around 20% of it’s income. And no $1 billion of cuts after $30 billion of surpluses is not enough.

No hungry kids in my electorate

I am sure everyone remembers Phil Goff announcing that there were no hungry children in his electorate, in response to John Key announcing a scheme to supply food to a school in his electorate.

Well Red Cross has now launched a scheme to supply free breakfasts to kids at all 270 decile one schools around the country. Good on them, Countdown and Woolworths for the initiative.

The question has to be will Phil Goff angrily denounce this scheme and insist schools in his electorate be left out of it?

Oh and an evaluation of the pilot scheme found children involved were “better behaved, more alert and settled”, which was the whole point behind it. It’s not about welfare (free food) as much as minimising risks that kids will flunk out of school because they are inattentive and disruptive due to hunger.

Trust in Professions

Roy Morgan has a poll (taken in Australia) on which professions have ā€œhighā€ or ā€œvery highā€ standards of ethics and honesty. They asked about 29 professions.

Public Servants were in 15th place just ahead of us pollsters in 16th place. Four places lower are talkback radio announcers in 20th.Then MPs are in 21st and 22nd places just ahead of union leaders on 23rd. The bottom four places being to various sales persons, but the next bottom places go to newspaper journalists and TV reporters.

When journalists rank even lower than politicians for ethics and honesty, there should be some damn hard soul searching about why.

Genesis Pukeko Parody

Greenpeace have done an amusing parody of the Genesis Pukeko advert. Well worth a view. The voice over has been done very well. It’s great the Internet and You Tube have allowed such parodies to be not just easily created, but easily viewed.

Business Book Title Competition

Fronde CEO Jim Donovan blogged a few days ago about how almost anything, no matter how stupid, can be made into a business book title such as “Management secrets of the Carmelite Nuns”.

He started thinking about Kiwi variants and came up with:
* The Jerry Collins guide to ambush marketing
* Building a global brand on a limited budget, by Nicole Begg
And I contributed:
* How to build a business on belief by Brian Tamaki
* Climbing to the Top in Business by Ed Hillary
* The importance of working in unison by the Ever-Swindells

Anyway this has prompted Jim to start a competition for the best Kiwi business book title. Head over there with your suggested titles. The winner gets public acclaim and some beers with Jim. Entries close on Friday evening. Just keep it clean as his is a nice business blog!

Join the Subway Boycott

Subway bloggers

Go to Aucklander at Large to get your own boycott badge.

Subway may have had the legal right to get a staff member arrested for a $2 drink, but likewise customers have the right to show their disapproval. I feel sorry for the other Subway owners but am sure they can pressure the Dunedin branch to do the right thing.

Free Content!

Chris Bell, of NZBC fame, has put up on his website his stories and poems. He talks at length about why is allowing people to access it for free, even though he also commercially derives income from the content. Lots and lots of great reading there.

DPF on domains

A couple of weeks ago I was interview by TVNZ for an item on domain names and Domainz. It finally screened yesterday, and is linked here. Just under three minutes.

The decisions taken in 2000 – 2001 to introduce more competition into the .nz domain market have been justified over time, in my opinion. There are now over 60 registrars for people to choose from, the wholesale price has dropped (now $1.50 a month), the retail offerings include a healthy range of prices, terms and products, plus the former registry, Domainz, has survived despite losing the registry and just being one of many competitive registrars.

ACT on Campus Essay Competition

ACT on Campus have launched a 2007 Liberal Thinking essay competition.

The competition is open to all New Zealand Secondary students and the winning student will receive an all expenses paid trip to Wellington, to spend a day with Rodney Hide to experience political life first hand. Their school library will also receive a substantial book voucher.

Have to praise AOC for such a positive move. I can’t wait to see the winning entries.

Parole Changes

I suppose it is little surprise that the NZ Herald reports that families of crime victims support a toughening up of parole laws while defence lawyers do not, labelling them as akin to Guantanamo Bay.

The defence lawyers miss, or do not agree with me, on a key point. Parole is a privilege, not a right you get at one third or even two thirds of your sentence.

The onus of proof should be overwhelmingly against early release, unless the Parole Board is convinced they will not reoffend.

And as we saw with Burton taking a narrow legalistic approach to what evidence may be considered by the Parole Board has tragic consequences. Every prison officer who knew Burton thought he would reoffend. But they were unable to say so. Very little of a prisoner’s behaviour in prison goes to the Board.

Now if this was the primary judicial forum for sentencing, then I would say yes you must meet court rules of evidence. But it is not. They have been found guilty and sentenced to a full term in jail. Parole is a privilege, and to prevent dangerous criminals getting out early, a lesser standard of proof regarding their behaviour is fine. This is not about proving whether they committed a crime – it is about making a best risk assessment of their propensity to reoffend.

And yes there are some risks that a malicious guard could lie to keep someone in prison longer, but at the end of the day the only “harm” done by that is a prisoner serves their full term (for which they were found guilty beyond reasonable doubt), and that is a much lesser harm than a dangerous prisoner is released early to kill, rape, beat or steal from law abiding members of the community.

I do agree though with the criticism of having any money paid to prisoners for mistreatment, handed over to their victims. Two wrongs do not make a right. One does not want a perverse incentive for prison guards to beat up prisoners so then compensation will flow to the original victims of the prisoner.