Domainz

Computerworld has an article on Domainz, and how it is promoting its expanded services. They mention that Domainz turns 10 this month.

I take a degree of personal pride in seeing Domainz celebrate its 10th birthday, as I was very involved with its sale.

Domainz was set up by my predecessors at InternetNZ to take over running the .nz registrer from Waikato University. Cutting a long story short, it was then decided in 2000 that the functions of Domainz should be split into two parts – one company running the .nz register as a shared registration system, and another to be a Registrar which would be opened to competition.

NZRS was set up to become the new registry, and it has operated the register since October 2002. I’m one of five Directors of NZRS.

ISPs and others were allowed to bulk transfer their customers away from Domainz over the next year, to reduce Domainz’s market share from 100% to a competitive level. Once the market was deemed competitive, InternetNZ wanted to sell Domainz as it would be a conflict of interest to be the market regulator, own the registry and also own one of the competitive registrars. If only the Govt would adopt the same principles!

Now selling a commercial companny isn’t something InternetNZ, or myself, had a lot of experience with. We were fortunate we managed to hire a first class expert in this area, and we eventually asked for bids from interested parties to buy Domainz.

Now we had seen some scenarios that said Domainz couldn’t possibly survive as a stand alone Registrar and would not attract any significant bids for it. So we had a background of a very uncertain future for Domainz, as it was unknown how many customers would leave it.

There were around 13 bids which was superb. Now those without a commercial background may think this is all simple. You just go for the highest bid. If only. You see each bid was for different things. One or two wanted to buy the company whole. Another wanted just the assets. Some wanted the residual cash, some did not. One just wanted the names in the database. Some wanted to merge with their business. Others wanted to keep it separate as a going concern. Some wanted the tax imputation credits preserved, others didn’t value these.

I couldn’t make a decision based on the 13 bids, as they were so different. So I spent many hours with spreadsheets trying to analyse each bid in terms of total gain to InternetNZ. It turned out that the expert liked my analysis so much, that it became the official basis for comparison and decision making. I was pretty thrilled with that, as this was a new area for me.

We decided on a preferred bidder. Now again as a novice you may think that’s the end of the process. You just accept their bid. The hard work was still to come. As due diligence continued the negotiations over the actual sale deed were ferocious and complex. Australian companies especially are quite ruthless in their approach, and while we ended up all on good terms, there were some very tense moments incuding negotiations at 4 am in the morning with myself and two others in the Domainz CEO’s office reviewing the latest accounts and final valuations. The approval meetings were scheduled for 10 am and we only decided at 5 am that we would recommend we proceed.

Even after the sale was formally agreed to, there was ongoing negotiations over certain values and valuations. I became one of around six people in NZ I suggest who is now an expert on how you value prepayments for domain names. The entire sale process ended up taking up around two years, as one can file against the funds held in trust for 18 months after sale.

So having been so involved in the decision to split from the registry, and so involved in its sale, I retain a certain pride that the company is still doing well today, especially as at one stage many thought it would not survive.

It also gave me some very valuable commercial experience. It’s not often you get involved with a company sale, unless you are a lawyer or accountant. It remains one of the most intellectually challenging things I have been involved with.

2007 Netguide Awards

wa07_votenow.jpg

I’m repeating a post from a month ago, as the Netguide Awards close on the 15th.

I want people to vote for Kiwiblog so I can have a reason to go up to Auckland for the Netguide Awards and drinks lots of champagne. Oh also because I’ve made around 2,500 posts in the last year to keep you all amused or enraged or both.

So here are the very simple voting instructions:

1) Register with Netguide here (takes ten seconds)

2) Login to Netguide here

3) Go to the awards page here

4) The very top category is Best Blog. Type or copy in “https://www.kiwiblog.co.nz”

5) Click Submit Vote, immediately below the comments box for that category

6) Vote in any other category you so wish

This takes you around 60 seconds all up. Simple.

Surplus keeps growing

We’re two thirds through the year and the surplus is already $6.5 billion.

I remain impressed that Treasury put our fully integrated accrued monthly crown accounts. It is no mean task. However as usual their surplus projections are well off.

The forecast last December was for a full year surplus of $6.26 billion. Already it is $6.51 billion with four months to go.

Net core crown debt is a minuscule 3.4% of GDP. This is laudable, but it shows it is ridiculous to suggest capital expenditure should be funded from surpluses rather than debt and depreciation which is standard commercial practice. You only differ from this if you have too high a level of debt.

Of course not all of the surplus is available for tax cuts. Here’s how you make the calculation.

Op Balance – revaluation & accounting changes – surplus from Super Fund – SOE retained surpluses – contributions to Super Fund. Cullen instructs Treasury to also include capital expenditure but that is just to avoid him ever having to give significant tax relief. If you buy a frigate which will last 30 years, you don’t fund it all out of a single year’s operating budget.

You borrow to cover the capital expenditure, and then the interest and the depreciation are charged over the full 30 years. It’s the only sane way to do it.

The law is the law

The Herald reports on Tyndale Park Christian School in Papatoetoe which for 15 years has refused to confirm or deny whether it still practises corporal punishment of students.

A leaked document suggests teachers do still strap pupils (and then pray for them!).

The law is the law. Regardless of one’s views, teachers lost this right 20 years ago. It is arguably legal for a school to have parents come in to apply corporal punishment, but it is clearly illegal for teachers to do so, even with permission.

The Ministry of Education should stop mucking around and enforce the law. I presume it can threaten deregistration if the school is unwilling to agree to operate under NZ law.

O’Sullivan on taxpayer funding moves by Labour

An excellent column by Fran O’Sullivan on all that is wrong with how Labour is planning to bring in taxpayer funding of political parties. Extracts:

If a major shareholder plundered company funds to maintain a jet-set lifestyle or fight off takeover attempts, someone would blow the whistle.

But somehow our ruling Labour Government seems to think it’s okay to try to square away private deals with minority parties, such as United Future and NZ First, so it can get control of $1.14 million of taxpayer funds to fight the next election. And rort some other election spending rules so it can more easily remain in power.

That’s what’s really going on at the Beehive this week as Labour’s “coalition managers” build the numbers so they can try and ram through legislation to get state funding of political parties in place for next year’s election.

Any forensic accountant – or Serious Fraud Office investigator – looking into this unseemly dealing would quickly do a double take.

They would question why Labour needs to rush through state funding without first asking all those taxpayers who are qualified to vote to give their mandate through a referendum at next year’s election.

Could it be that – despite Labour president Mike Williams’ denials – the party has found itself clean out of cash after it was forced to refund the $800,000 of taxpayers’ funds it unlawfully raided from the parliamentary purse to bolster its campaign for the 2005 election?

If so, the cosy deal that Labour is trying to stack up is nothing more than a taxpayer-funded money-go-round to bail out its finances.

But if Williams’ protests are true – and Labour does have sufficient fund-raising capacity for the next election – then he should urge the Government to take the right step and seek a proper political mandate.

For a Government which has made shareholders’ rights a motif for its own corporate law reforms, this all smacks of abuse of privilege.

… Labour is attempting a frank gerrymander by then trying to reserve a special position for the unions on third-party election funding. The $60,000 limit will not apply if they are “communicating directly” with their members.

The Herald has disclosed that Labour’s proposals fall into five major categories: transparency of donations; restricting third-party campaigns; clarifying election expenses; beefing up enforcement of the law; and state funding.

If it wants to be taken credibly, Labour should get Justice Minister Mark Burton to release a policy paper and form an all-party agreement on the options which can be taken to referendum.

The Electoral Act is one of our key constitutional documents, even though only parts of it are entrenched. Structural changes such as the move to MMP happened with the consent of the people. Taxpayer funding of political parties is a structural change. It will have a huge impact on parties, on members and the public. It will help entrench the current parties against challengers. There are pros and cons one can debate, but Labour negotiating 61 votes in favour in secret is a very bad look, as opposed to the bipartisan process advocated by Fran.

Electoral Act enforcement

The NZ Herald runs the headline that under new laws Police could raid party offices under new election laws. I believe they should have raided them (both National and Labour) last time, rather than just ask a few questions. As Labour staffers were being investigated for corrupt as well as illegal practices, they could have got a search warrant.

The proposed increases in fins for illegal practices are better than nothing but still provide little disincentive to parties and officers to comply. The fine goes from $3,000 to $10,000 for individuals.

What is more important however is the penalties for corrupt practices. Ideally these should be up to $1 million for parties, $100,000 and several years jail for individuals. The Herald doesn’t comment on these.

ACC advertising – unnecessary and false!

It’s bad enough that ACC is wasting $5 million on a branding type campaign (very different from safety focused advertising), but to make matters worse, their advertising has been found to be misleading. They should scrap the campaign, not amend it. We do not need a three year awareness campaign about how great ACC is, and how it is here for us. Monopolies do not need to spend millions of dollars on brand awareness.

Climate Change impact on NZ

NIWA has published extracts from the upcoming UN IPCC report, dealing with likely effects of climate change for NZ.

They note that since 1950 our mean temperature has increased by 0.4C which has led to 10 – 20 less days a year of cold nights and frost, an an increase in sea levels of seven cm.

Looking towards the future, they do not predict anything near massive calamity, but some desirable and some undesirable impacts:

* water security problems are projected to intensify by 2030 in Northland and some eastern regions.
* Sites at risk of loss of biodiversity include the alpine areas and sub Antarctic Islands.
* increases in the severity and frequency of storms and coastal flooding by 2050 in Northland an BoP.
* Production from agriculture and forestry is projected to decline by 2030 over parts of eastern New Zealand due to increased drought and fire.
* However, initial benefits to agriculture and forestry are projected in western and southern areas and close to major rivers due to a longer growing season, less frost, and increased rainfall.
* A southward shift in agricultural pests and diseases is likely with New Zealand becoming more susceptible to the establishment of new horticultural pests.
* Kiwifruit budbreak is likely to occur later, reducing flower numbers and yield in northern zones
* Apples: are very likely to flower and reach maturity earlier, with increased fruit size
* Earlier ripening and possible reductions in grape quality are likely by 2030

Overall the report is a nice change from some of the hysteria we see.

The report correctly notes that NZ should be spending more on adapting rather than mitigating. This is one of the huge debates globally. There has been little analysis of the costs of adapting to warmer temperatures compared to spending hundreds of billions on Kyoto which will only decrease by 2050 mean temperatures by 0.07C.

Nothing NZ does in the way of mitigation will have any effect at all in terms of global temperatures. We are just far too small. The case for investing in mitigation is to be a good global citizen, and help pressure other countries to do the same. But flagellating oneself to be carbon neutral, when other countries are not even close to meeting their Kyoto goals achieves little.

There is a case for both mitigation and adaptation strategies. But these strategies must be based on a comprehensive analysis of costs and benefits with the latter outweighing the former.

NRT has a short take on the report. Russel Norman posts a summary, without much comment.

The NZ Herald has a story also, focusing mainly on coastal properties. The Press focuses on refugees from Pacific Islands turning to NZ.

Come play with the toys

Bad Greens

A spy sent me the following e-mail from the Greens:

From: Green Party [mailto:[email protected]]
Sent: Wednesday, 4 April 2007 10:38
Subject: GREENTIMES

Hi there, we are about to print our next copy of GreenTimes, which will give an update on lots of the work the Green MPs are engaged with. At present our database only has your email address. We would like to send you GreenTimes but need a postal address to do so.

Please reply with your address and you will get a GreenTimes in the next few weeks.

Okay so the Greens already have an e-mail address for this person. They can send them a pdf of the Green newsletter by e-mail or even send them a link to a website version. But no they are encouraging the person to also receive a paper copy.

Now we all know paper comes from trees, and chopping trees down for newsletters increases greenhouse gases and leads to global warming.

So why are the Greens needlessly wasting paper on people they can communicate with electronically? Is carbon neutrality just something for everyone else to do, al la Al Gore?

No voting for idiots

The Bournemouth Borough Council has had to publicly apologise for its election pack which quoted a 1776 statute which declared “lunatics, idiots and deaf and dumb persons” could not vote.

Such a provision here would be grossly unfair to the Social Credit parties, and their successors.

Good radio

Political Alliances

We saw last week a couple of heated posts by pro smacking ban advocates, who instead of debating the issues, decided to demonise supporters based on who else was arguing against the bill. It was classic guilt by association.

I recall reading their fury at the Libertarianz being on the same side of the debate as Destiny Church. It was suggested this meant the Libertarianz had abandoned principle.

On the contrary the Libertarianz were staying true to their principles (say what you like about them, but flip flopping is not something you can accuse them of) and they were standing up for what they believe, regardless of whether they like those who agree with them on that issue. In fact it should make those who advocate the Bradford bill consider the merits of it, if it can unite everyone from Libertarianz to Destiny Church against it.

Now let us look at how incredibly stupid this guilt by association attempt is:

Ngai Tahu, the Greens and the Business Roundtable had much the same view on the Foreshore & Seabed legislation, being an unjust confiscation of property rights and legal process. Does this mean one demonises the Greens as being the nasty party in cahoots with the BRT?

Labour is currently supported in Government, by NZ First which has attacked Asian immigrants. Does this mean Labour is now judged by what NZ First stands for?

The religious right and the unions combine forces to stop shop trading on religious holidays. Does this mean the unions are tainted by this association? Or the religious groups?

Take myself. I’m happy to work with Keith Locke on republican issues, with Tim Barnett and most of Labour on civil unions, with Family First on Section 59, with Peter Dunne on sedition, with NZ First on free speech issues, with ACT on selling SOEs, with David Cunliffe and the Govt on telecommunication issues, with the Coalition for Open Government on the parts of electoral law reform we agree on, with the CTU in 1997 to defeat the compulsory savings referenda (despite my own PM backing it), with Heritage Foundation on defence issues, with the BRT on improving our economic performance, with student associations on improving accountability of tertiary institutes, with Cato on trade issues etc etc etc.

I regard this as the principled thing to do. I stand up for what I believe in, and work with any legitimate group to advance those beliefs. The suggestion made that one should not oppose the Bradford bill because Destiny, Maxim and Family First (and to be fair to FF they are nothing like Destiny) are also opposed is just unprincipled and unethical. Yes I will work with even Destiny on an issue, but I will also work with say Rainbow Labour to stop them ever getting into Parliament. I’ll work with Family First on the issues I agree with them on, and I’ll take the mickey out of them on the issues I disagree.

If being unwilling to only work with groups those on the left approve of, means I am a member of what was labelled “the nasty party”, then that is a badge I will wear with pride. I would rather work with the “wrong” people to get the “right” result than only work with the “approved” groups to get the wrong result.

I suspect I am not alone in this.

Not fully human

One can only be amused at the pseudo-research of submitters on the smacking ban bill, which found opponents are more likely to see children as not fully human.

No Virginia, they just see children as not fully adult. There is a difference.

But I love how they breathlessly find that some opponents have said some children can not be reasoned with. Have these people ever met a four year old???

You finally know you need to laugh or cry, when they manage to fit a reference to the evils of colonisation into their research – suggesting it is a parallel to those evil human denying advocates.

But hey here is a challenge for those who back the research that a child is fully rational and competent. Start demonstrating this in your own home. If you have three kids, turn over 60% of your income to them to spend as they wish. You and your partner get only 20% each. Please let us know how much money your four year old decides to spend on the mortgage and superannuation as opposed to ice cream.

Press on Labour

The Press had an editorial on Maharey’s “fuck you” moment, and how it is a symptom of greater problems. The last few paras are worth highlighting:

Maharey is not the only senior Labour minister to be showing the strains of office. David Benson-Pope, Mark Burton, Pete Hodgson and Trevor Mallard are all contributing to a jaded, stale and clumsy image of this Labour-led government.

There are still some solid performers within ministerial ranks. Annette King is showing the same safe pair of hands in her transport and police portfolios as she previously did in health. Phil Goff remains a respected and able Cabinet minister on trade and defence issues. Michael Cullen has his grumpy moments but he is still the shrewdest of political managers and finance ministers, although his future in politics must be limited. And Clark’s leadership continues to be her party’s greatest asset.

But overall Labour, now halfway into its third term and facing its most challenging MMP political environment to date, has a tired look. The party must now be regretting its failure in previous elections to bring forward the fresh and talented newcomers and pension off the time-servers. After all, if someone like Maharey, whose propensity to crack under pressure has been cruelly exposed, can be touted as leadership material, the case for political renewal really speaks for itself.

Tactics vs Strategy

An interesting article by John Armstrong on Helen Clark and John Key.

Armstrong makes the point that Clark is still performing very well on a tactical basis. She can react quickly and well when pressed.

But at a higher strategic level, she has made some extraordinary blunders:

1) Totally misjudged the public mood on the pledge card, reversing policy not to pay it back only at the last minute

2) Defended Taito Phillip Field for far too long

3) Fumbled the response to Key’s underclass speech by denying there was one

4) Making the anti-smacking law a whipped vote for Labour

5) And now about to try and ram through taxpayer funding of Labour and other political parties

One would actually expect them to be further behind in the polls, with all of the above having happened. The fact they haven’t suggests they have pretty strong core support which isn’t affected by most issues. National is certainly well on track to win more votes than Labour at the next election. But to beat Labour by a large enough margin so that it is untenable for Labour to form a Government is the tough challenge.

Why people are oppossed to the smacking ban law

I thought I would try and inject some rationality into the debate, after some serious ranting last week from some. Not that it has quite ended – Tony Milne is still referring to those 85% who disagree with him as the “pro-violence” campaign. This is about as rational as referring to those who support a women’s right to choose as being “pro-death”.

Something overlooked in this debate is the role of the law as a guide to society of what is right and wrong. At its most basic people see the law as how society says what is good and what is bad. I recall this when debating whether there should be a law against spam, even though its effectiveness would be limited. And the argument from a colleague was if we don’t state in our laws that this is an illegal act, how can we advocate as a country that it should not happen.

Now look at how this applies to Section 59 and the smacking issue. Put aside silly arguments over whether it legalises what you do, or just gives you a defence.

Most parents smack their children for correctional purposes at some stage. They may not know the exact law, but they are aware that what they do is allowed for in law, so long as it is reasonable force. So they see this as society having said we do not condemn you for smacking your child.

Now we have this bill to repeal Section 59. And they can understand that a very very small minority of parents who should be prosecuted have used too much force and not been held accountable. But they also know there is an amendment that lowers the amount of force you can use, but would clearly not criminalise smacking. And they cannot work out why any MP would want to vote against this amendment. They can only come up with two reasons:

(1) Some MPs want to ban smacking, and tell them how to raise their kids

(2) Some MPs do not want to ban smacking, but instead of trying to define reasonable force as legislators, they are going to leave interpretation solely to the Police and CYFS

Now neither of these reasons goes down well with the average parent or NZer.

The problem the MPs who refuse to vote for the Borrows amendment, is that their motives are mixed. Beyond doubt there are some who do want to ban smacking. And the more it is denied, the more it pisses the public off.

There are others who just want to abdicate their responsibility as legislators and leave it to the Police and CYFS to define. They honestly feel that the Police and CYFS will be responsible and only act on common sense, but parents of course seem to not welcome the uncertainty.

I doubt there is a single MP who wants parents who bash their kids to get away with it. Those who suggest otherwise are being dishonest. If the Borrows amendment was passed, I suspect the bill might pass close to 120-1.

Likewise I doubt there is a single MP who actually wants parents who lightly smack their children for correctional purposes to face legal proceedings for it. They believe such cases would not be prosecuted.

But the answer that parents are looking for, is why can’t Parliament just pass a law which clearly does not criminalise light smacking, but clamps down on actual harm to children. They ask isn’t that why we have a Parliament – to make such distinctions. They are not worried about being prosecuted, they just do not approve of having the law now “disapprove” of how they raise their children. They wonder why MPs don’t vote for the Borrows amendment, or if that wording isn’t quite adequate, why they don’t improve it, rather than vote it down.

No limits of planned funding

The leaks to soften up the public on taxpayer funding of political parties continues, with details in the NZ Herald.

Labour plans to ram through before the election this fundamental law change, which would see it get $1.14 million every year. Now note that this is not tied to campaign communications (like the broadcasting allocation) but is just a giant forced donation to the political party, which can be used for anything at all – recruiting members for example.

It is deeply ironic that having been found to have spent illegally $800,000 of taxpayer funds on their last election, Labour want to change the law to take more than that every year.

Whether the law proceeds may depend on Taito Phillip Field. I wonder how many inducements they will offer him to get his vote. I don’t mean illegal inducements, I mean stuff like funding for a new Pacific party.

Labour has no mandate for introducing such funding. It should campaign at the next election on the merits of its proposal, and if parties in favour get a majority, they can then implement it post 2008.

Easter Blog Roundup

Cactus Kate finds my analysis of the MP’s Register of Interest to be rather tabloid. Of course it is – unlike Kate I don’t orgasm at the thought of establishing a trust to avoid tax. Kate however devotes many pages to examining the various trusts MPs have. She also notes no less than 20 Labour MPs have trusts set up – presumably to minimise their tax obligations. Higher taxes are only for everyone else!

Kate also helpfully offers to help the IRD and SFO audit the MPs.

Razork blogs about a childcare centre which has banned lego because:

The children were building their assumptions about ownership and the social power it conveys — assumptions that mirrored those of a class-based, capitalist society — a society that we teachers believe to be unjust and oppressive. As we watched the children build, we became increasingly concerned. So we banned the Legos and began their program of re-education. “Our intention was to promote a contrasting set of values: collectivity, collaboration, resource-sharing, and full democratic participation.

After protests the lego was returned but only with rules such as all structures are public structures, and lego people can be saved only by a “team” of kids, not by individuals.

Perhaps Sue Bradford will focus on the capitalist oppression of lego after she finishes trying to ban smacking.

Keith Ng blogs from Sri Lanka. Not from the safe areas (which are very nice) but from Batticaloa in the East which is in the middle of the civil war between the Tamil Tigers and the Government. The post is well illustrated with photos of refugees and is a highly recommended read.

60 Minutes

60 Minutes tonight had a good article on the party pill issue- balanced with views from both sides. The head of emergency medicine at Wgtn Hospital, who was part of the programme, is someone I was at university with down in Otago. Takes a bit of adjustment to see him so respectable now.

But the item which was really great was the last one on Genesis who was brain damaged in a car crash a few years ago. Two of her carers, and friends, are Laural and Sharaine Barrett, the current Miss Universe NZ and her equally beautiful sister.

Beauty pageant contestants can get a lot of ridicule for the stereotype of being dumb and/or wanting world peace etc. But to see those two spend most of their week as full-time caregivers to Genesis and her four year old son was really touching. Couldn’t be further away from the stereotype.

Easter Saturday and Sunday

Easter Saturday saw me head up to Featherston to play at being a boy with toys. Had lunch with Murray, and then we played with his catapults.

First we set up the Mangonel, which uses twisted ropes as its power. The first go around we didn’t twist it too tight but the four croquet balls still made a good 240 feet or so.

Then we swapped to the Trebuchet which uses a pail of stones as its counterweight. This had less power but more accuracy and made around 200 feet.

Finally back to the Mangonel. This time it was wrenched to full power. And Jesus when released it lets out an almighty bang, crashing into its base. The ball soars into the air and when it finally comes down it has broken 300 feet. Very nice for a relatively small device.

A few kids watching at this stage. Strangely they left when I started speculating on how far it could throw a five year old. I was convinced we could clear the fence easily.

A nice drive back over the Rimutakas just in time to change for a big night out with Pamziewamzie and friends. We started off at Hope Brothers and the party got bigger as people we know walked past, like the esteemed Salient editor. Spent several hours there doing beer, then wine, then shots.

We then headed back to the flat Pam was staying at (was a friend of a friend’s) which was just metres away on Eva Street. Now the flat was great – a seven bedroom flat which used to be some sort of commercial or industrial office. There’s one huge room in the middle with the seven bedrooms all off it. The seven flatmates were all early 20s either working of finishing study. It was almost like being back in Dunedin again.

We had a few more drinks there and then headed back into town. Can’t recall the name of the bar we spent most time at, but it was cool. There were five of us – me and four of the girls, two of them down from Auckland and two locals. I tried to sit out the dancing but hey when there’s four lovely people to dance with, it’s not too hard to persuade me to make a fool of myself.

But then Jesus struck, and the bar had to close as it was midnight, and now Easter Sunday. So we headed out onto the streets. The girls then ran into someone handing out fliers for a bar which wasn’t closing, and insisted we head there – especially as they got free entry. Yes it was one of those sort of bars, and no it wasn’t my idea. In fact this was my first (and probably last) ever visit to that establishment. And the irony is it only happened because the other bars had to shut because of Easter Sunday. There must be a moral lesson in there somewhere.

We headed up, and grabbed some more drinks. The prices weren’t too outrageous and we watched some dancing, and then the umm wrestling. Most of our conversation was speculating on whether one of the wrestlers was in fact female or not. I thought she was female based on Adam’s Apple but some of the girls thought she had male facial structure. No-one offered to find out for sure. Funniest moment was leaving as poor Pamzie slipped on some jelly on the floor and landed on her rear in a painful manoeuvre.

The five of us then left and headed back to the flat. Oh yes we also grabbed some Subway which was the first food of the night, and it was now 1 am. I got home a bit before 2 am which wasn’t too bad except bloody Kiwigirl phoned me later that morning, from Vienna, to find out the cricket score. Grrr.

We all then caught up again over lunch, and as it was a brilliantly sunny day, I took everyone up to Massey Memorial. As expected it was a stunning view from up there, and the Aucklanders were suitably impressed (and the Wellingtonians). A wedding party was also up there doing their formal photos.

After that we then did the long drive around the bays, from Shelley to Owhiro Bay, and then up to the Brooklyn wind turbine while the sun was still up. Again a great way to enjoy this late summer we are having.

Finally in the evening we had a huge vegetarian dinner at the flat, cooked nicely by Alex. With hanger ons there were a dozen or so of us, all around the large makeshift table on various couches and arm chairs – very Dunedinish. Dinner and drinks went of for quite a few hours, and it was an ideal end to two very hectic days. Always fun to meet new people, and party with them. Allows me to pretend my chronological age is just an mathematical error.

Monday was much more sedate – recovery day. Housework, blogging, TV, accounts etc.

Botswana

After I defended Steve Maharey against Sean Plunket’s comments re comparisons to Botswana, I got a lot of comments which made me look at Botswana more closely. It is certainly one of the most successful countries from that region.

* Botswana has transformed itself from one of the poorest countries in the world to a middle-income country with a per capita GDP of US$11,410, only half of NZ at $24,797.

* Economic growth averaged over 9% per year from 1966 to 1999.

* It has the highest sovereign credit rating in Africa and has foreign exchange reserves of over US$7 billion

* The Botswana Government provides full scholarships with living expenses to any Botswana citizen in university, either at the University of Botswana or for subjects not offered locally they are provided with a full scholarship to study abroad.

* Their literacy rate at school is around 95% and for the entire population is the second highest in Africa, and will soon become the highest.

Botswana it seems, in fact, has arguably the greatest focus on education of any country, with it consuming over 10% of their GDP. They see it as their future salvation, when their minerals run out.

So upon reflection it was an extraordinarily bad choice to use as an example of why we should not use Cambridge exams.

Vitual Super 14 Week 10

Yay. I picked all six games with the correct team winning. For three of the six I also got the margin right so 39 points out of a maximum 48. My best week ever.

I’ve moved up around 9,000 sports globally and in the NZ Bloggers Challenge am now 22= out of 90 with a score of 264. Span is one point ahead on 265.. Also both Paul Smiths are tied with me. They need a more rare name!

Top bloggers are Brian Burgess on 301, Mark Montgomerie on 297 and Jeremy G-H on 287. Leading female is Amanda from Newyorkality on 269.

Leaked Electoral Law Changes

Labour has started leaking their proposed electoral law changes, as they want to divert attention away from their attempt to raid the taxpayer for political party funding. They hope to get that unpopular money grab through, by linking it to the more popular restrictions they propose.

So the first thing to be aware of at all times, is that one can agree with everything Labour proposes in terms of private funding, yet in no way support taxpayer funding of political parties. They are not linked. One is a cover for the other.

The second thing is that Labour’s changes are clearly designed to change the rules to favour themselves. They never had a problem with anonymous donations when they received more of them than National. People should be very concerned that they plan to ram through changes to the Electoral Act which they have negotiated in secret, rather than seek bi-partisan support for. The Electoral Act is an important constitutional safeguard.

Anyway onto the leaked details:

Require any third party (a group or individual other than a candidate or registered party) to register its intention with the Chief Electoral Officer if it plans to spend more than $5000 nationally and $500 in an electorate.

No problems with that. Lack of disclosure is what the Brethren did wrong last time.

Restrict any third party from spending more than $60,000 nationally or $2000 in an electorate.

$60,000 is a very very low threshold. That barely gives a lobby group a couple of ads in the NZ Herald. It is a limit per voter of two cents expenditure per voter. I think having a limit is fine, seeing political parties have limits, but one has to ask the rationale for one so low it may suppress genuine free speech.

Restrict any third party to New Zealanders or New Zealand-based organisations.

Fine. Not aware of that are not.

Exempt from the new third-party rules groups such as unions or companies when they are communicating directly with their members.

Now here is the first outrageous attempt to favour their own. They appear to make it look neutral by including companies communicating with their members. But when has a company ever told its members how to vote? They don’t even have members. But the union loophole can and does get used to exempt all sorts of propaganda in union publications which can be circulated around workplaces, handed out in streets etc.

Lower the threshold for disclosure of donations from $10,000 to $5000 for parties and from $1000 to $500 for individual candidates.

That seems reasonable. A lower limit than that would risk exposing rank and file donations, and people have a right to keep their party membership secret, just as it is a hallowed right to keep your vote secret.

Do not allow anonymous or trust donations above the $5,000 limit

I think there is strong public support for this. People should be aware though that inevitably more money will flow to third party lobby groups, as happens in the US. I’m not worried either way, but people should not be surprised when lots of lobby groups pop up.

Ban foreign donations except those from expatriate New Zealanders.

Here’s Labour goes for an outrageous tilt. They received $500,000 last election from Owen Glenn who was not born here and has not lived in NZ since 1966. He would still be allowed to donate but Julian Robertson who is alleged to donate to National, would not, despite Robertson owning property in NZ and spends most of his time living here.

No problems if people want to ban foreign donations, but having a loophole to allow someone who has not lived here since 1966 to donate just because he gives money to Labour is outrageous.

Personally I don’t think you need restrictions if you have full disclosure, as the public can decide for themselves if they disapprove of the source of any donations. But if you are going to have restrictions then they should apply fairly. Say no-one who hasn’t lived here in the last ten years being banned.

Include in the definition of donations loans at non-commercial rates, and a party’s goods or properties sold well over their valuation.

Sounds sensible enough – presumably to stop what has happened in the UK for interest free loans not disclosed and being exchanged for peerages.

Require whatever the third party spends to be counted against its $60,000 limit and the limit of the party it is supporting.

Now this part is not clear from the leaked report. The current law already states that if say a union spends $20,000 saying Vote Labour it must be approved by Labour and count as part of its total.

But it seems they are suggesting that negative advertising against other parties must be approved by a party and count as part of its limit. That’s seems ridiculous if true.

If someone runs an anti-NZ First ad, which party has to approve it and have it counted as part of their return? How about an anti-ACT ad? Or an anti-Labour ad?

Overall there are some parts of the changes which are sensible, and should be (and I think will be) supported by almost all parties. But some are clear attempts to gerrymander the electoral laws to help Labour, and should be strongly opposed.

Also we should look at what is not included? The current $4,000 for a corrupt practice is ridiculously light. If Labour has integrity they should be including an increase in this to at least $100,000 for individuals and $1 million for political parties.

Sky and TVNZ Digital

The Dom Post reports that TVNZ has not yet decided whether to allow Sky subscribers to directly access their two new digital channels – TVNZ Home and News 24.

i think it would be a mistake of gigantic proportions for TVNZ to not allow Sky subscribers access through Sky.

As an example, I only watch TV through My Sky. I never use my other remotes. If I can’t get a channel through Sky, then I am not going to watch it.

Allowing access through Sky will mean more viewers for TVNZ and less costs for both TVNZ and subscribers.