Weekly on Newstalk ZB

I now have a regular slot on Newstalk ZB every Tuesday at around 6.30 p.m. It’s part of the Larry WIlliams drivetime programme from 4 pm to 7 pm and Larry and I just chat for 5 to 10 minutes about isuses being discussed on the blogs.

It’s not only about politics, it’s about what might be interesting. Last week for example I mentioned the UK blogger who prematurely announced Margaret Thatcher was dead. This week I am tempted to mention the adultsheepfinder site.

Generally I’ll be aiming to touch on at least three topics. Probably the major political issue of the moment plus a couple of others. I guess Section 59 is the biggest issue at the moment.

Now I hope not to just cover stuff on Kiwiblog, so feel free to suggest items from elsewhere which you think might be good for a quick discussion on radio. Send suggestions through by mid afternoon Tuesday, so I have time to work out what I’ll use.

Israeli Ambassador recalled from El Salvador

The Israeli Ambassador has been recalled from El Salvador, but not for the usual reasons you recall Ambassadors.

it seems His Excellency was found drunk. Okay not the end of the world. He was also mainly naked. Okay that is getting bad. Oh yes he was also bound and gagged and wearing sado-masochistic sex accessories.

So His Excellency is heading home. He should of course have been a NZ Cabinet Minister where such things are no barrier to service 🙂

Princes Street Labour Party

A well placed spy has alerted me to a very dirty and divisive campaign underway for the Chairmanship of the Princes Street branch of the Labour Party.

It involves allegations of violence, threats of defamation, formal complaints to the NZ Council of Labour, claims and counter-claim. All as a lead up to the election next Wednesday.

People involved include incumbent David Do, challenger Alex Foulkes, and Meg Bates (who works for Helen Clark), plus many former officers. E-mails on this stoush are going widely including to Hon Judith Tizard, Anna Crowe (YL Vice-President) Jeremy Greenbrook (likely new President of Young Labour), candidates Phil Twyford and Stuart Nash.

There has also been complaints laid with the Police regarding alleged threats, plus accusations of members being illegally removed from e-mail discussion lists, refusal to allow all candidates access to membership details etc.

All in all, not a fun time for Princes Street Labour. Will Helen sort it out? Will the NZ Council expel anyone? Will anyone sue? Will the Police arrest anyone? And who will be elected?

The dishonesty of the Section 59 abolitionists

The NZ Herald reports on the last minute lobbying regarding the Borrows amendment on the Section 59 bill.

Chester accurately makes the point that the debate shouldn’t be about whether smacking worked, but about whether or not parents who smack should be criminally liable.

The way that supporters of outright repeal of Section 59 have tried to portray opponents has been very dishonest, and in fact reeks of the worst excesses of the US religious right.

Yes that’s right. For take the analogy to abortion. I am pro-choice when it comes to abortion, as I am pro-choice when it comes to parents smacking. However in my personal lifestyle I would hope I would never be involved with an abortion or would ever smack a child of mine.

Now the anti-choice brigade for smacking have tried to portray opponents as people who supporting beating and hitting children.

This is intellectually just as dishonest as the religious right in the US trying to claim someone pro-choice on abortion “supports murdering foetuses”.

Have NZ First had their legal advice yet?

Hey it’s now March and poor old NZ First are still unable to decide whether to do what every other party has done and agree to pay it back, or confirm they will do the big fingers to the taxpayer and refuse to pay it back.

Isn’t six months long enough to decide? In fact wasn’t six weeks long enough?

Public Polls Feb 2007

Rwandan Asylum Seeker

Helen Clark says the chances of a Rwandan asylum seeker getting New Zealand refugee status are “remote” if it is true he is facing genocide charges.

I wouldn’t be as confident as that if I was the PM. After all Ahmed Zaoui was not only facing terrorism charges but had in fact been convicted of terrorism in Belgium and France, yet he was granted refugee status.

Latest Nigerian scam

Virtual Super 14 Round Six

A middling to bad week. Got three out of six games right only, and two by the right margin.

I didn’t pick the Hurricanes vs the Force.

A big drop globally of 15,631 places to 44,738 as I only got 21 points out of a possible 48.

In the bloggers challenge, I have dropped to 30=/86. The top three are Peter McCaffery, Michael Harbrow and Matt. Grant T and James G did well this week with 39 points.

Young Labour poll on Section 59

Heh Family First have just put out a press release claiming Young Labour oppose the Sue Bradford Bill on the basis of the poll on their website which shows 81% of respondents opposed to Section 59 repeal.

Someone will be in trouble with Helen for not rigging the poll properly.

EU on Kyoto

Russel Norman blogs:

In what will hopefully be an historic moment in the campaign to save the planet from catastrophic human induced climate change, the EU Council has agreed to a unilateral 20% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions below 1990 levels by 2020.

Now this indeed does look somewhat positive if you believe that lowering greenhouse gas emissions is the best way to proceed. But let’s first look at whether the EU is on track to meet its existing targets:

The EU15 in 1990 had 4,238 megatonnes of emissions. Their target was to reduce it by 8% to 3,899 by 2008-2012. How much has it reduced? Only 0.8% by 2004. And to quote Wikipedia:

Further complicating the debate over the Kyoto Protocol is the fact that CO2 emissions growth in the US was far ahead of that of the EU-15 from 1990-2000, but from 2000-2004, America’s rate of growth in CO2 emissions was eight percentage points lower than from 1995-2000, while the EU-15 saw an increase of 2.3 points. From 2000-2004, the United States’ CO2 emissions growth rate was 2.1%, compared to the EU-15’s 4.5%. That happened while the US economy was expanding 38% faster than the economies of the EU-15 while experiencing population growth at twice the rate of the EU-15.[73]

As of year-end 2006, the United Kingdom and Sweden were the only EU countries on pace to meet their Kyoto emissions commitments by 2010. While UN statistics indicate that, as a group, the 36 Kyoto signatory countries can meet the 5% reduction target by 2012, most of the progress in greenhouse gas reduction has come from the stark decline in Eastern European countries’ emissions after the fall of communism in the 1990s

Make sure you re-read the post 2000 data. The US has gone up only 2.1% since 2000, while the EU15 has gone up 4.5%, despite 38% higher economic growth in the US, and twice the population growth. So why should we think the EU new target will be any more successful than the existing one?

Now I am not an expert in this area, but I have a question for those who are. If the EU does manage to cut emissions to 20% below 1990 levels, what effect will that have on the average global temperature in 2020? Will it be 1 degree lower than it would be if emissions continued at the same rate? Would it be 0.1 of a degree? Or would it be 0.01 of a degree?

Because surely unless one can be informed of the benefits of the reduction in emissions, can you sensibly decide whether the cost of reducing emissions is justified?

So how much of a temperature reduction would this be?

Rape convictions

The SST reports that the average conviction rate for rapes has gone down form 38% in 1986 – 1995 to 31% for 1996 – 2005.

I would be interested to know how what percentage of guilty pleas occurred in each decade, and what the actual conviction rates for contested rapes are.

The suggestion is that one should be allowed to inform juries of previous convictions. I’m fairly relaxed about doing so, but one would have to do it for all crimes. I think one can trust a jury properly instructed to focus on the facts before them. But it may result in the Police just arresting people with previous criminal records for suspected crimes, on the basis it will be easier to convict them again. This may result in them not finding the actual offender so there are pros and cons.

In terms of actual rape convictions, I would be interested to see some data on how many people charged with rape have previously been found guilty of rape. I suspect it is pretty low, and hence a law change wouldn’t change the conviction rate much. However I do remember being told that it is very common for many rapists to have burglary convictions, so if they were revealed that might increase the conviction rate. But should people get found guilty of rape on the basis they were previously guilty of burglary?

Rape as a crime is always an incredibly difficult area of the justice system, because it is one of the rare crimes where consent is key. Murder is always bad. Assaults are always bad. Burglary is always bad. But rape is the one area where consent is the key difference between a normal everyday activity enjoyed by most NZers, and a heinous evil crime. Sure there are a tiny minority of people who consensually enjoy being assaulted (for example) but that is the exception not the rule.

This is partly why in most countries rape conviction rates are so low. Because unless a jury is convinced beyond reasonable doubt there was no consent, there can be no conviction. Just proof of sex is not enough. With an assault you generally only need prove they did the assault.

The best way to lift conviction rapes is for people to report the rape as soon as possible, and try to preserve forensic evidence. Now that is easier said than done I know. But there is no magical way to make sure rapists do get convicted, and the longer it is left, the harder it is.

No-one at fault

Even Matt McCarten is sick of the buck passing over Graeme Burton. He aptly points out:

* wasn’t the fault of the prison in not informing the Parole Board it thought he was still an evil bugger
* wasn’t the fault of the Probation Service that he wasn’t living or working where he should have been
* wasn’t the fault of the Parole Board, which released him on the unsuspecting public.
* wasn’t the fault of the police, who apparently couldn’t pick him up or interrupt the holidays of their surveillance staff.

McCarten goes on to conclude:

And according to Burton, it’s not his fault, either. We can only conclude Karl Kuchenbecker’s death was an accident, or his own fault for riding a bike in the forest.

Just ridicolous

I am on the record of being no fan of Brethren involvement in NZ politics. In fact I am not a fan of any church getting involved. But it angers and appals me that Mike Williams suggests that MPs should be refusing to meet with constituents who are Brethren. That is absurd and religious bigotry.

An MP should meet with any constituent, regardless of religion. There is a word of difference between meeting constituents in their electorate office to discuss problems or issues, and a meeting with say the hierarchy of a religion to discuss political campaigns.

Could one imagine the outcry if an MP refused to meet a constituent who was a member of a union, just because they don’t approve of that union’s political activities?

Field breaching housing regulations

An interesting story in the HoS which has discovered that several of Taito Phillip Field’s houses have been investigated by the Manukau City Council for breaches of building regulations. As many as four houses may be in breach.

Who would have ever guessed that our Taito may have been less than fully diligent in following the rules?

Inaccuracy in Sharon Shipton story

The HoS reports that Sharon Shipton may lose her job with the Ministry of Justice due to her testifying on behalf of her husband.

The inaccuracy is reporting that she works as a “project manager for the Electoral Commission – a division of the Ministry of Justice”.

The Electoral Commission is not part of the Ministry of Justice. It is a independent statutory body. And last time I checked they only have around two staff.

I suspect that Mrs Shipton works for the Chief Electoral Office, which is a division of the Ministry of Justice, and has quite a few more staff than the Electoral Commission.

Another Rickards allegation

Yet another allegation against Clint Rickards has been made it seems. This one from the 1990s not 1980s. Can’t say I am terribly impressed that it has been leaked to the media. If it stands up they should prosecute. But to have the inquiry head give a running commentary on these witnesses have said this, another said that and we are wanting to talk to someone else seems pretty inappropriate.

South Park Series 11

Disclosures

Help Police, my dope’s been stolen

Maori Sickness

I wonder if a court would allow a Catholic priest to tesitify that a thuggish burglar was possessed by the devil, and hence should not be accountable for their actions?

Because what is the dfiference between that and having someone advocate “Maori sickness” being the reason for the thuggish burglar’s actions, on the basis he possessed a sacred taiaha (long club) and tokotoko (walking stick) which hadn’t been blessed.

Clark’s new standard of ministerial responsibility

John Armstrong writes in the Herald about the buck-passing regarding Graeme Burton murdering while on parole.

As part of this, he astutely observes:

In brushing O’Connor aside, she might also be unintentionally rewriting the concept of individual ministerial responsibility. The old Bob Semple maxim of the minister being “responsible, but not to blame” for his or her department’s failings – and therefore not obliged to resign – has now become the department being both responsible and to blame.

Clark took that view with the Qualifications Authority over the NCEA botch-up. The same applied to Transpower when the lights went out in Auckland last year. And it has happened to the Parole Board and Corrections in the Burton case.

It is further evidence of the obvious – that the concept of individual ministerial responsibility exists only in theory.

Armstrong also notes that while there have been nine Ministerial resignations under Clark, none of them have been as a result of failures by their officials – all nine have been for personal scandals and improper conduct.

A unified Maori voice?

Joris de Bres is advocating the creation of a unified Maori voice through either a Maori House of Parliament or a “council of elders and chiefs”.

I agree a unified Maori voice would be very helpful. But it’s not that easy. First of all any “unified voice” would not be speaking for all Maori, but for at best a majority of Maori. Just like NZUSA does not speak for all students and the National Council of Women does not speak for all women.

One of the great things about political parties is they allow individuals to choose an advocate which is closest to their views.

But that is not to say a national body for Maori would not still be very useful. But any such body should have a democratic basis. A council of elders and chiefs doesn’t sound very democratic to me. And a separate House of Parliament will never be accepted. The existing Maori Council is in theory democratic but has little standing or support nowadays.

Daylight Saving

Sainsbury doing well

The Heralds reports that Close Up has been increasing its market share against John Campbell, since Mark Sainsbury took over.

I’m not surprised. I think Mark is a natural in the role. My only wish is that don’t have close up photos of him on the back of every bus that goes by – his mo is scary enough at normal size, let alone giant size 🙂