Manukau vs Tonga

The NZ Herald had a story yesterday on the division in Manukau City Council over the Mayor unilaterally approving sending staff to Tonga to help rebuild their capital after the riots.

While the story is balanced in that it talks to both camps, it fails to mention what I regard as the key aspect of the story. For that you need to go to a blog.

There you find out that the town planners being sent to Tonga are rather needed back home. You see the Council reports it only processed 50% of resource consents within the regulatory deadlines . That’s an appalling figure – only half done within the time set down in law!

Now if they were processing 95% of applications within the legal time limit, one might be more open to helping out Tonga, but when they are so appallingly failing in their own city within their own statutory deadlines, that makes it a no brainer to not remove essential staff.

That evil woman

The Family Court has put online some of its previous decisions regarding Jones v Skelton with regards to Jayden Headley.

I read them last night and the more I read the angrier I got. You can only be appalled at the behaviour of Kay Skelton. What she, and her parents, have done to Jayden and to Chris Jones is appalling. She has lied to the court, faked DNA results, broken dozens of court orders, and done everything possible to drive the father out of his son’s life. This included suggesting he was not the father and giving the court fake DNA results to prove it.

Skelton should be in jail for a long long time, and that is regardless of any finding over the kidnapping. She is an appalling, even evil, person. Her parents seem equally appalling. Don’t take my word for it – go read the dozens of pages of court judgements. Here’s a summary:

* Court ordered interim supervised weekly (later fortnightly) access for Jones in June 2001

* No visits occurred until Nov 2001 and then only seven visits over six months until April 2002

* By 2001, Skelton has gone through *five* Solictors. By 2006 it is hard to keep count but I estimate she has gone through 20 lawyers – changing them everytime to delay court appearances

* From April 2002 ignored all court orders and started to raise (for the first time) paternity doubts

* In Dec 2002 further court orders were made for access for Chris Jones. Note he never sought primary custody at this stage. All he wanted was some time with his son

* After this order, Skelton moved to Australia without telling the court or the father. She returned eight months later in Aug 2003 when facing Hague Convention proceedings

* Further access visits are sporadic as mother often claims Jayden is sick or unwilling to see the father. Jayden now says he doesn’t want to see his father, but it becomes clear he has been coached by his grandparents to say this “Poppa says I don’t have to see him anymore and Mum says he (Jones) is a bad, bad man”

* Then Jayden started claiming that Chris Jones was not his father. Again obviously fed to him by his mother and her parents, who were trying to remove Jones from his son’s life.

* In an interview with the Judge, the grandfather Dick Headley was found to be not a credible witness

* The Court ruled in Sep 2005 that Jones was to be given access twice a week and also that the Court would become Jayden’s guardian. His mother retained primary custody.

* The next court ruling was June 2006. They received a report from the mother from DNA Solutions Ltd stating that Brett Skelton was 99.9% the father of Jayden.

* Skelton refused to consent to a further test or to authorise DNA Solutions to release the samples it used. The court ordered a further test and consented on behalf of Jayden for this test.

* Skelton refused to obey the court order and make Jayden available for a mouth swab. Skelton also then alleged physical abuse by Jones. These were not found credible. Finally they took a sample from Jayden at school. These confirmed Jones was the father and the previous results were either fake (from different people to those named) or forged.

* The court found “there are no limits to the steps she is willing to take to cut Chris Jones out of Jayden’s life as if the former had never existed.”

* The court then ordered Jones to have primary custody. Soon after Jayden was kidnapped.

The Court has done a big favour in making this public. Several things strike me from reading the rulings:

1) This was never a case of a father and mother both wanting primary custody. Jones never sought this at first. All he wanted was to spend time with his boy.

2) The Court in this case has made the right calls.

3) I am amazed that Skelton has suffered no penalty for her constant lies, perjury, fake documents, breaking of court orders, manipulation of the court, going through 20 solicitors as delaying tactics etc. When there are no consequences to bad behaviour, it continues.

4) I can’t see how Skelton can ever be allowed unsupervised access to Jayden again. Her entire history is that she and her poisonous parents will use any access to warp Jayden and/or steal him away.

5) She has only herself to blame. The father, Chris Jones, from all accounts has bent over backwards to be reasonable, has calmly accepted years of delays and excuses, and if she had just allowed him to spend some time with his son, then this need never have happened.

6) The Court, in my opinion, has very clearly seen through Skelton’s ruses and made the correct rulings. But this was relatively easy as she was so over the top with her breach of court orders, excuses, changing of lawyers etc. My concern is that more subtle and more clever tactics may have succeeded.

7) I wonder how many parents have gone through similar.

The NZ Herald have a story, as does Stuff. But I really do urge people to read the five court rulings in full. By 5 pm today the Court will have published its own chronological summary which will be useful.

Australian Political Quiz

A 40 question Aussie political test aligns you with the parties. My results are 84% Liberal aligned, 74% National, 51% Labor, 47% Democrats and 23% Greens.

It places my political outlook as 45.5% which is “right”.

On economic policy I am 86.8% which is “far right”

Social policy is 68.1% which is “right”

Traditional Values is -45.9% which is “left”

Looks pretty accurate to me. On economic issues I would like to sell anything which moves, yet I am decidedly liberal on traditional/moral values.

Hat Tip: No Right Turn

Hear DPF!

I’m being interviewed by Larry Williams on NewstalkZB at 6.10 pm tonight on the CYFSWatch Blog debate.

Also tonight I’m making predictions for 2007 at Unlimited Potential. I’ll blog them after the event.

Tomorrow I’m filling in for Colin Jackson on National Radio’s Nine to Noon Show. Colin does the technology segment from 11.45 am to midday on Thursday, and I’ll be chatting to Lynn Freeman on blogs and no doubt specifically the CYFSWatch Blog.

UPDATE: Also on National Radio Checkpoint tonight. A busy day!

Coup Consequences

It is becoming clear that the NZ Govt is not at all serious about restoring democracy to Fiji, as it hasn’t even bothered to seriously lobby the UN to cease the use of Fijian military. The aid reduction is a farce – funding has been cut to Fiji’s election office, which isn’t going to worry the Commodore at all. And he knows in a few months all the protests will stop and his rule will be recognised.

Human behaviour is very dependent on there being consequences for actions, and the problem is there have been almost no negative consequences for the coup leader, so of course he has no incentive to restore democracy. Here’s a list of measures that I would almost guarantee would work in having elections within a year:

* Cessation of all aid to Fiji until there is an election
* The Commodore to be told that Australian, NZ, US and EU will impose a lifetime travel ban on him unless there are elections within a year
* All Fijian military serving overseas sent back to Fiji within a month
* All members of the Commodore’s extended family to be deported from NZ and Australia, unless permanent residents. Yes this is grossly unfair to them, but it is even more unfair to have democracy taken away from a country
* Escalating travel bans to be placed on all members of the military government – an initial one year travel ban, and every month they stay in office illegally the travel ban is extended by a year.
* Find some international laws the Commodore has broken and file a warrant for his arrest, with extradition requests made to all countries
* Ban all Fijian sports teams from NZ, including the Sevens.

What else can one do to help make the consequences of instituting a coup negate the benefits for the individual concerned? This need not be just for Fiji, but generally?

What the Sydney BDO organisers should have done

“Last year a very very small minority of BDOers used and abused the Australian flag to intimidate some of our newer Australians. We don’t want these losers to think they have a monopoly on the flag which is a symbol of unity and pride for all Australians, not just a few. So we will be handing out free flags and stickers for anyone who wants one, and reclaming the flag from that small minority who abused it.”

The French Presidency

France elects a new President in three months, and rather pleasing is the fact both candidates look to be an improvement on Chirac.

Nicolas Sarkozy is the conservative UMP candidate, and naturally my preference. Sarkozy is a great charismatic orator and an economic reformer – something France needs badly. Chirac loathes him which can only be a good thing.

He is very hard line on law and order, supports a simplified and fairer tax system with lower rates and less loopholes and wants to reduce the budget deficit.

On the down side he wants to reduce the separation between church and state.

The socialist candidate is Segolene Royal, and like Sarkozy she is loathed by many senior figures in her own party. She has fallen behind Sarkozy for the first time, largely because of a proposal by a colleague, widely seen as sabotage, to increase taxes on anyone earning over 4,000 euros a month. And who was this colleague? Her own partner!!

Royal is a bit of a Blairite – also tough on law and order. She has criticised aspects of the 35 hour working week and on the issue of Iran’s nuclear ambitions she took a tougher line than the US. Other than that she is pretty traditional left wing but she is not beholden to party interests so much and would govern by her conscience I believe.

Hence I think either of them would be okay, but Sarkozy would be great.

The CYFSWATCH Blog

There is fault on both sides in relation to the CYFSWATCH Blog. Let’s work through the issues, one by one:

Is there anything wrong with a blog which scrutinises a Govt Dept?

By itself, no. Blogs are all about giving a voice to, and empowering the individual. When people get bad service at a restaurant they blog it.

In a general sense, it can be a good thing for Govt Depts (or any organisation) to know that every person they deal with has an outlet in which they can air grievances if they are treated badly.

Is it unfair to target individual staff?

Yes and no. Teachers have to put up with rate my teacher dot com. Journalists get rated individually every day on blog sites. However the way it is being done here seems vindictive. They only want bad stories and requesting photos, car registration details borders on harassment.

So is this CYFSWATCH blog okay?

No, in my opinion parts of it are disgraceful.

If the blog was being used to describe in detail wrongs done to families, with a minimum of vilification it could be a valuable resource. In fact one or two of the later posts are heart wrenching and do just that.

But posts which refer to staff as “this bitch” and comment on their personal appearances are just nasty. Also many posts make comments which appear to be highly defamatory and unprovable.

The naming of staff is different to say naming a staff member who gives you bad restaurant service. In most situations your relationship with a staff member should always be positive. You should get good service from a waiter, you should get good encouragement from a teacher or lecturer. So to have a bad experience is comparatively unusual.

CYFS staff though by the nature of their jobs are involved in deeply emotional and confrontational episodes with families. I doubt a single staff member goes through a month without having a family member very upset with them. It is the nature of their jobs.

Having said that, I have no doubt some CYFS staff have done very bad things but nevertheless the actual naming and vilification of CYFS staff is undesirable. The call for photos and contact details is deplorable (I note though none have been published yet).

If the site used initials instead of names, and got rid of the more personally offensive posts, then they may find they get a lot more sympathy. Some of the stories on the site are heart wrenching, but of course there may be another side to them.

Is the Government right to try and close the blog down?

No. It breaks no laws that I know of and we should be concerned that the Police e-crime unit are involved in trying to have it taken down. The proper remedy for CYFS is to sue for defamation and/or seek an injunction against the (anonymous) publisher. If a case can be made for harassment, then again that should go to court.

Are you going to link to the site?

No. Lots of other blogs have done so making it easy to find. But at the end of the day I don’t want to link to a site which I disapprove of (in its current format). Yes I linked to neo-nazi sites in the past, but that was for the purpose of humiliating them and showing how pathetic they are.

Not Good

Fiji getting worse

No Right Turn has the latest from Fiji, and it’s all bad.

* The Dictator has got one of his puppets to grant full and unconditional immunity from criminal, civil and professional proceedings for the Dictator and his troops. You have to appreciate the hypocrisy that the attempt to have an amnesty for those who were involved in the last coup, is one of the reasons the Dictator gave for this coup.

* The Dictator has warned that complaining publicly about human rights will be seen as inciting the public. All complaints must be made to his puppets in the Human Rights Commission, and not to the media or you will “be dealt with accordingly”.

* Finally the Dictator has said that elections might be five years away. Five years!!!

Waihopai

Russel Norman blogged how he is down to protest against the Waihopai Listening Base, because shock horror it shares info with our friends and allies.

This is where the Greens have more in common with their pink leanings than anything to do with the environment.

In the post 9/11 environment, if there’s one thing I want us and our allies to do, it is to intercept telecommunications between terrorists. Even if you think Bush is the biggest doofus on earth and the US should pull out of the Middle East, you should be keen to have us contribute to intercept terrorist plots.

Scores and scores of plots have been defeated thanks to interceptions. The number of lives saved would be in the thousands. I want the spy satellites listening in to Al Qaeda cells etc. It save’s lives.

Jayden handed over

Dr Jackie Blue

The NZ Herald is profiling some of the new National MPs. Today it is Dr Jackie Blue.

When asked who she respects outside her own party:

There’s only one person who would get that award and without any hesitation, I’d say Tariana Turia. I worked with her on the health committee and she is a woman of integrity … she just blows me away, quite frankly. I respect her totally: she stands true to herself, true to her [Maori] Party.

Idiotic Aussie Flag ban

And people wonder why you get a backlash sometimes. Organisers of the Australian Big Day Out have backed down on their plans to ban the Australian Flag in case it upset minorities.

John Howard and I think at last count all eight Labor Premiers condemned the idea of the Australian Flag being banned within Australia.

I mean what were the organisers thinking? If there is a problem with flag waving yoboos then deal with the yoboos harshly. But banning the flag is exactly what leads to a greater backlash from people.

Dictators Dying

Mayor Kerry is restanding

As widely expected, Kerry Prendergast has announced she will stand for a third term as Wellington Mayor.

It will be interesting how many Councillors stand against her. Rob Goulden has said he is.

Outside Council, Georgina Beyer has said she is interested, but I don’t think that candidacy is taken terribly seriously.

Preferred PM ratings

In a NZ Herald interview with John Key they tried to get him to commit to a goal of equalling Helen Clark in the Preferred PM stakes by the end fo 2007.

This is a mischievious and near impossible task, and also largely irrelevant. The preferred PM rating has little if any bearing on which party will win an election. Bolger in 1990 had a single figure Preferred Pm rating yet National won by the then biggest landslide in history. In 1999 Helen Clark trailled Shipley as Preferred PM right up until the final weeks of the campaign.

A year out from an election it is very rare to have anyone but the incumbent PM as the Preferred PM. As a measure it is not without some value in measuring trends, but the party vote question is a magnitude more important than Preferred PM.

Parole spin

The NZ Herald has a story stating offenders released on parole are less likely to reoffend and end up back in prison than those who are released without conditions.

Firstly I think a figure showing 43.8% of parolees have been reconvicted within only two years shows how much of a failure the system is.

But as to why the rate is even higher for those who don’t get parole? Well to not get parole you have to be amongst the worst of the worst in prison, so it is no surprise those people have a slightly higher offending rate. I’m actually surprised the difference isn’t far more pronounced.

So the comparison between those who do and do not get parole isn’t a controlled experiment as it is dealing with different sorts of criminals. To see if parole actually does make any difference at all, one would have to randomly select some prisoners to get parole and some not to, and then compare if the conditions of parole lower reoffending. The reality is that Corrections is unable or unwilling to enforce most parole conditions, and the prisoners know this, so I would be surprised if there was a huge difference.

Antarctica Blog

A very good speech

Rodney Hide’s speech to ACT on Campus really is superb. Some extracts:

When I first made it to Parliament I was asked by a fellow who had been around the complex for a long time why I was always so happy. New MPs are supposed to be miserable, he said. The direct comparison was Pam Corkery. She was always sour.

I thought about it for a time. The reason was that I am a Classical Liberal. For me, the government that governs best is the government that governs least.

I don’t believe that politicians and bureaucrats have the information or incentive to tell us what to do better than we can for ourselves. We certainly know how to spend our own money better than politicians can spend it for us. That was my view when I first turned up to Parliament.

Everything that I saw in the first few heady weeks of being an MP confirmed my view of the world. In fact, government was far worse than I had ever imagined.

My theory of government was confirmed by every practice that I witnessed inside it. I was more right about government than I ever had imagined.

For Pam Corkery it was quite different. She believed that government is the solution to every problem and that all government needed was people like her who cared and who knew what the problems were. She figured the problem with government was that the wrong people were running it, i.e. they weren’t her.

For every scam that I exposed there were 10 that I didn’t have time for, 100 I hadn’t properly investigated, and probably a thousand that I didn’t even know about.

For every Minister that I knocked back as useless another incompetent would swell the ranks.

I realised it didn’t matter who was in power; the problem was the same one. Waste and incompetence is inherent in big government.

For years New Zealand suffered the ravages of high inflation. It distorted the economy, hindered our prosperity and favoured the rich over the poor.

Politicians like Muldoon blamed the unions. Jim Anderton blamed big business. Winston Peters blamed Asians.

But the real cause was politicians themselves.

The Reserve Bank Act and the Fiscal Responsibility Act have served to align good political decision making with sound economics.

Helen Clark won the 2005 election promising to wipe interest from graduates’ student debt. The policy did nothing for education in New Zealand, it shifted income from truck drivers to accountants.

Labour’s List

It has been a feature of Helen Clark’s leadership that she has protected her Caucus colleagues from more talented candidates for the last three elections. Labour has followed her wishes, and pretty much put all the MPs at the top of the list.

Hence it is significant that she is talking that this should not happen next time. Matt MCarten focuses on this, as does Fran O’Sullivan.

Ironically at the last election National agreed to rank its 25 re-standing MPs in its top 30. But that was done due to the unique circumstances that after such a bad result in 2002, it was obvious National was going to be able in 2005 to bring in considerable extra talent, as well as keep all its current MPs. I certainly hope and expect that there will be no such deal in 2008 and that MPs will face list ranking as they normally do.

So which Labour MPs may be at risk of not getting a winnable list place. Here’s their List MPs:

Michael Cullen – safe as houses if he wishes to carry on
Rick Barker – moderate risk. He is a Minister, but not a particularly good one.
David Paker – low risk. A potential front bencher for their fourth term.
Dover Samuels – extreme risk – may be gone within months
Mita Ririnui – moderate risk – depends who else they can find
Margaret Wilson – low risk – but she may retire if Labour looks unlikely to win
Charles Chauvel – low risk. Thought to be a future Minister.
Ashraf Choudary – moderate risk. PC forces will probably protect him.
Russell Fairbrother – high risk. Not forgiven for losing Napier.
Darien Fenton – low risk. The unions will protect her.
Ann Hartley – medium risk. Being Deputy Speaker may help protect but unlikely.
Dave Heroera – medium risk. Little achievements but at least he didn’t lose a seat.
Shane Jones – no risk.
Moana Mackey – low risk. Young and with a future, but yet to have a chance to prove herself
Sue Moroney – low risk. Another union protectee.
Jill Pettis – high risk, Probably gone before the election.
Maryan Street – no risk. A smart operator.
Dianne Yates – extreme risk. Nothing can save her.

The fight for Vector

Fran O’Sullivan covers the issues around the fight for ownership of Vector, with local Councils lobbying the Government to remove it from the majority ownership of Auckland Energy Consumer Trust.

The recent resignation of three highly regarded Directors from Vector highlights the problems which can arise with elected politicians having majority ownership of a commercial company. I fail to see how increasing the number of politicians owning Vector will help it.

5c and inflation

In her HOS column, Deborah Coddington blames Allan Bollard for contributing to inflation by getting rid of the 5c piece. Now I’m not a huge fan of how Dr Bollard has handled inflation (he has let it get far too high) but on this issue I will defend him.

Let’s look at the worse case scenario. Every single transaction is in cash, and every single transaction has had its cost rounded up by 5c. Now if the average transaction is $50.00 then that 5c increase would contribute a maximum 0.1% to inflation. I suspect it is closer to 0.01% when you consider many transactions are not cash and some are rounded down.

Further on Coddington cites the week before Christmas with “electronic transactions were up 21 per cent on 2005, worth more than $200 million, we start to get some idea of how much extra money we’re handing over, just because Dr Bollard took the 5c piece out and shot it.”

Umm, if they were electronic transactions then the demise of the 5c piece, by definition, doesn’t affect the price. You don’t hand over a single cent extra – the exact amount is electronically charged.

Likewise this is the answer to Coddington’s next question: “If I’m not allowed to hand over 5c when I’m paying by cash, how come the retailers are allowed to charge 5c?”. The answer is because the majority of transactions are not in cash, and the electronic transactions are precise to the cent.

And hating to pick on the one column, but I also have to disagree with her conclusion of profiteering because a BP station states GST was 1c higher than it really was. The receipt claimed GST of $5.24 on a $47.10 transaction and Coddington is correct it should be $5.23(3333…).

I have no idea why the BP station slightly inflates the GST content on their receipts, but at the end of the day it won’t affect any profits. You see their prices are GST inclusive and regardless of what their individual receipts say, their GST liability to the Government will be calculated by dividing their total sales income by nine. Incorrect rounding on an individual receipt won’t affect this.

Now if BP prices it petrol GST exclusive and it then added GST on top, then the one cent difference could be material – in that it overcharged you by one cent. But because the pricing is GST inclusive, its a non material error.

Finally though I am pleased to say there is one area where Deborah has correctly identified a problem. At the end of the article she states “ratcheting up interest rates to try to curb household spending is a stupid exercise when most people have fixed mortgages.”

This is indeed a problem, with both John Key and Michael Cullen concurring on it. The solution is yet to be found.

Spiders on Drugs

Kiwiblog declares Jihad

As Bomber Bradbury at Tumeke compares Kiwiblog to Sheik Feiz Mohammed, I suppose I should make the comparison more accurate by declaring holy war and Jihad.

I also need to start labeling a picked on minority group as pigs. So who shall I call pigs? Oh I have it. You JAFAs are all pigs – we declare jihad against the JAFAs.

This silly response to a silly post was brought to you by Sesame Street, the letter D and the number 6.