Mothers can’t make PM

Julia Gillard, Australian Labor Deputy Leader, claims mothers can’t become Prime Minister.

Someone should mention this to NZ’s first female Prime Minister, Jenny Shipley, who was mother to Ben and Anna.

Or to Margaret Thatcher, Indira Ghandi, Benazir Bhutto, Golda Meir, Sirimavo Bandaranaike, Corazon Aquino, Michelle Bachelet, Sila María Calderón, Kim Campbell, Tansu Çiller, Édith Cresson, Mary Robinson etc etc.

I certainly would state that being a mother does make it harder to get to the top of any field. It does take up a hell of a lot of time and energy. But neither it is the barrier it used to be. There have been plenty of examples of mothers, even with very young children, making it to the top.

So Gillard claiming John Howard would not have made it, if he had been a woman, is nonsense.

Danrnton v Clark case dropped

NZPA reports that the Darnton v Clark case has formally been dropped, because Labour’s retrospective validating legislation has wiped the case out.

It is a centuries old principle that one does not wipe out a current lawsuit by retrospectively amending the law. In this case the constitutional outrage is even stronger because the lawsuit was not against the Crown but against the actual Labour MPs. They personally stood to benefit from the wiping out the lawsuit.

During the committee stage of the validating legislation, an amendment was put up to specifically exempt the Darnton v Clark lawsuit, from being affected by the legislation. Labour and its mates voted against this amendment. If they had accepted the amendment, then the validating legislation would have been far less of an issue.

Come the next election I hope to organise a team of people to attend every meet the candidates meeting of every incumbent Labour MP and ask at every meeting whether they think it is appropriate for MPs to legislate to defeat lawsuits against them in a personal capacity, and that isn’t this a constitutional outrage much worse than anything Muldoon ever did.

It was a classic case of Labour MPs putting themselves above the law. The lawsuit was going to cause political damage to them (the High Court supporting the Auditor-General’s ruling would have blown away their claims that the Auditor-General got it wrong) so they used their role as lawmakers to defeat the lawsuit.

NZ First and United Future also voted against the amendment to allow the lawsuit to proceed. Messrs Dunne and Peters should expect lots of questions about this also.

The Dictator threatens NZ

The Fijian Dictator has taken a break to threaten NZ with trade sanctions and loss of work viasas if we do not relax our travel ban on him and his cronies.

As Clint E would say, Go ahead, make my day.

Cutting off NZ exports to Fiji will hurt Fiji a lot more than it would us. It might lead to his overthrow sooner rather than later.

It’s just a pity NZ sanctions are half hearted and we have yet to ask for the things which would really hurt Fiji like exclusion from the Sevens and having their troops withdrawn from all UN peace keeping.

But the situation of Fiji is an interesting one in terms of how far can one go in resisting a self appointed dictator. Is it legitimate to use force to remove said dictator from office if he shows no signs of giving up power?

Force should be the last, not first, resort of any democracy movement. In the case of the old South Africa, groups like the ANC were right to use force against the Government (not right to target civilians though) as the Government was illegitmate and supressing the majority of the population.

So would it be a good thing for someone to kill off the Commodore, if say in three years he is still in power as dictator? If they did so, that might stop the next self appointed dictator from undertaking a coup, if they realise there might be personal consequences.

Mixing up Johns

Holden resigns

Could not disagree more

No Right Turn compares the comments of Sheik Feiz Mohammed in Australia, who has called for young Muslims to embrace jihad and refers to Jews as pigs, to Holocaust Denier David Irving.

Irving’s utterances lend confort to Jew haters like the President of Iran, but hurt him more than the community.

The consequences of Sheik Mohammed utterances are vastly different though. They lead to bodybags. They lead to explosions. They lead to tube bombings in London and attacks on nuclear power plants in NSW. Australia does not hate Muslims. Australia has more immigrants of more cukltures than probably anywhere outside the USA. Australia hates Muslims who advocate jihad – there is a world of difference.

Some of his exhortions:

… criticises Muslims in Australia for not sacrificing their blood as martyrs and for putting lifestyle ahead of action in response to massacres of Muslims in Afghanistan, Iraq and Palestine.

“In our times it is the fear of death, the fear of sacrificing your finger, your toe, a drop of blood that is more honourable than anything else,” “Why? Because martyrdom to us is, is not as appealing to us, as it was to those ancestors, the great warriors … who lived around the best creature that walked the earth, Mohammed.”

In that and another series called Signs of the Hour, Sheik Feiz labelled Jews “pigs” and exhorted children to jihad.

“We want to have children and offer them as soldiers defending Islam,” he says. “Teach them this: there is nothing more beloved to me than wanting to die as a mujahid. Put in their soft, tender hearts the zeal of jihad and a love of martyrdom.”

Private Charity

Electronic Bail

In 2005 Phil Goff and the Ministry of Justice recommended against introducing electronic bail, but Cabinet went ahead anyway.

The Ministry states the case against succintly:

“If the primary purpose of EM (electronic monitoring) is to reduce inmate numbers, eligibility must be targeted to those who would otherwise be remanded in custody.

However, defendants remanded in custody are more likely to have characteristics or criminal histories that would make them unsuitable for release on bail with EM.”

Still double dipping

Hope for ICANN!

Sometimes I get pessimistic over ICANN, especially when it does dumb things. But sometimes it does very good and ballsy things.

For several years it has been galling that they have not appointed anyone to the role of Manager of Public Participation. This was promised as a vital part of abolishing the directly elected seats on the ICANN Board.

Well now they have not only made an appointment, but have appointed Kieren McCarthy. Kieren writes for The Register and has his own blog. Kieren has been one of the journalists most critical of ICANN and their actions. I would have sworn he was almost persona non grata with certain senior people in ICANN.

So this is a very ballsy move on their part. Kieren should make a real difference towards improving and encourgaing public participation.

A comment from Rape Crisis

Rape Crisis themselves (now called Rape Prevention Education) made a comment on the earlier thread which debated a consent scenario last week. I thought the comment was worthy of highlighting here, especially as it is good to see that this scenario is already used in educationing people, as many commenters suggested should be the case:

I thought I could perhaps clear up a few of the issues here for you! This scenario is used as part of our BodySafe Programme – which is a rape prevention programme in high schools in Auckland. The purpose of using it in the classroom is to start discussion with students. I have never had a class agree whether this is or isn’t rape. The purpose of the scenario is not to answer this question but raise the exact discussions you have had. The main purpose is in the facilitate discussion with the teenagers about how this situation could be prevented from both Jo and Jareds perspective.

The main message been:
That both parties need to be clear about what they want – body language can be very hard to read, especially when teenagers have had drugs or alcohol. Therefore, there are a number of things Jo could do – not go to the bedroom in the first place, make it clear at some stage (ideally before they even get to the bedroom) that she doesn’t want to have sex, or leave the bedroom. Of course there is the possibility that she could then be physically forced to have sex, so we cover this aspect too. We are also trying to educate the males that they need to ask for consent every time they are having sex. Something along the lines of “are you sure you want to do this?” when Jo pulled up her underwear, would have made the outcome of this scenario very different. Teenagers also need to be aware that every person, male or female, has the right to not have sex with someone, no matter what has happened leading up to the point of sex.

From a legal perspective, there are definitely signs that show that consent was not given. The majority of the teenage population that we work with agree that someone pulling up their underwear during sexual activity, shows that they are having second thoughts about having sex. However, I doubt this scenario would ever reach prosecution in a New Zealand court. However, this does not mean that there are not long term effects for both Jo and Jared.

It is great to see so many thoughtful responses on this subject.

Nasty Foreigners

Remember Trevor Mallard attacking Julian Robertson as a US bagman for National, and hence one of those nasty foreigners?

Craig Foss highlights Robertson’s contribution to a 9.5km fence which protects a kiwi-breeding scheme at Ocean Beach, Hawke’s Bay. A wonderful contribution to conservation.

Shortland Street actress change

Shortland Street viewers may have noticed that in a first for the show they have had an actress, Laurie Fell, leave the show yet kept her character of Dr Justine Jones going with new actress Lucy Wigmore. The change got explained away with a new hair colour!

The NZ Herald reports that it seems Fell did not leave, so much as was pushed out, with the information coming from a blog posting on Street Talk. Executive Producer Simon Bennett (whom some of us remember from Usenet days) has even been contributing to the thread.

This is also covered on Throng, and is a good example again of the positive role blogs can play in bringing out information that deviates from the “official line”.

Parole Reform

Stephen Franks, who has spent many months and years studying the parole system, blogs about misconceptions on parole, and how parole should be reformed. The status quo is unacceptable (something even the Govt and Law Commission now agree) and reforms must happen.

Stephen points out that only a small percentage of criminals who breach the trust that was once the key feature of parole are ever recalled, and even fewer serve much of the rest of their sentence. He points to President Clinton’s reforms as the way ahead, but also some changes to the current system while we have it:

* Restore its status as a privilege not a right;
* Board must be satisfied of genuine remorse;
* Board must take account of victim feelings, of community expectations of a price to be paid for crime, and of the effect of any release on judicial control of sentencing. The 2002 law prevents the Board from recognising these factors;
* No appeals against denial of parole – it is a privilege;
* No legal aid to support parole applications – it is a privilege;
* Police and Corrections should regain immediate power to return parolees to custody on discovery of any breach of terms;
* Court involvement on breach only to hear parolee challenges to the recall reasons, or claims that the breach is trivial, or should otherwise be excused;
* Parole offences should automatically be treated as serious of their class for sentencing purposes, because it is a breach of trust, and shows the absence of remorse;
* Publication of full and accurate statistics on parole offending.

I’m also working on some possible reform ideas which I will blog about in the near future.

Geographical spread of Honours

Brian Rudman calculates that Wellingtonians have a two to three times better chance than Aucklanders at receiving Honours from the Queen.

I’ll resist suggesting that is to be expected on grounds of ability to say that Rudman is right that there is a problem here. Not as bad as he makes out, but a problem.

Firstly a capital will always get more honours. It is often where the senior most people in an industry are. Many charities have head offices in Wellington. The judges of the top two courts are in Wellington. The top of the police and the military are here. Almost all Govt Depts have head offices here. I doubt there is a capital in the world which does not receive more honours due to the nature of the jobs in a capital.

But there is one industry where most head offices are not in Wellington. And that is that of business. Most of our business leaders are in Auckland, and in my opinion these wealth creators are woefully under represented in the Honours.

Ruffled Feathers???

Dan Eaton in The Press claims John Key and Bill English have “ruffled feathers by using an interview in Right-wing Investigate magazine to attack Prime Minister Helen Clark and the Government.”

I am amazed at stories like this. Where the hell do the media get the idea that an Opposition Leader should not attack the Government, and that somehow doing so is “ruffling feathers” which is language suggesting it is outside the norm.

Where the hell were the stories about Helen Clark ruffling feathers in 1998 and 1999 with her attacks on Jenny Shipley?

And does the story say whose feathers have been ruffled? The only comment recorded is from the PM’s press secretary.

Stories like this really piss me off. When Michael Cullen uses his wit to savage National MPs, the gallery almost wets its pants with joy (I enjoy Cullen’s wit also). When Peters does an over the top attack on say Brash they cover it adoringly. But then when National’s Leader and Deputy say some negative things about Helen Clark in an magazine read by a few thousand people only, somehow this is tut tut and ruffling feathers.

Free local calls

The Government is reviewing the Kiwishare, more formally known as the Telecommunications Service Obligation.

One of the obligations is the provision of free local calls.

A few years ago I would have labelled that the most important obligation, especially as it meant people can dial in to their ISP without paying additional charges.

In the not too distant future I can see that obligation not being needed. More and more people do almost all their calls from their mobile, dial up Internet will be replaced by broadband and services such as Skype will lessen the usefulness of the obligation.

The only local calls I make on my home phone is my family and for taxis. Everyone else I call is from my mobile(s), and vice versa.

A useful public service

Whale Oil has an “El Jefe” counter which shows to the exact second how much time Taito Phillip Field has spent suspended on full pay. Is he still holidaying in Vanuatu?

It’s been 139 days and 8 hours so far.

It’s nonsense to insist one has to wait for the police inquiry to take action. ACT kicked out Doona Awatere-Huata before police action was complete. Labour should kick him from their Caucus and restore some honour.

More offending opportunities

The Dom Post reports on a rampage by a man freed on electronic bail.

Isn’t it nice how hard the Government works to keep people out of prison so they can commit more crimes. They give you three chances now.

First they let you have a go on electronic bail. Then once convicted they have home detention for you. And then if you can’t get that they have parole after a third of your sentence.

I’m sure with time they’ll come up with even more ways. How about a system where someone else can do your jail time for you? Sort of like a time share!

.xxx back from the dead

Obama is running!

Barack Obama has just announced he is seeking the Democratic candidacy (sell technically setting up a committee but same thing in a couple of weeks) for President of the United States of America.

This will lead to a worried Hillary Clinton announcing her candiacy in the near future.

I think Obama has the potential to be a very good President of the United States. However a mere four years in the Senate is not enough experience, and 2008 is too early for him. If he doesn’t get the nomination, choosing him as the VP candidate would be a very smart move as it could lift black turnout by 5% – 10% or so.

If he does not blot his copybook I suspect he will become President in 2012 or 2016.

Official candidates to date now are:

Democrats

* Senator Joe Biden of Delaware
* Senator Christopher Dodd of Connecticut
* Former Senator John Edwards of North Carolina
* Former Senator Mike Gravel of Alaska
* Representative Dennis Kucinich of Ohio
* Former Governor Tom Vilsack of Iowa
* Senator Barack Obama of Illinois

Republicans

* John H. Cox of Illinois
* Michael Charles Smith of Oregon

Filthy Rich

Another of those filthy rich people has declared they are given most of their millions or billions to charity. This one is Henry Paulson, the US Treasury Secretary and former head of Goldman Sachs.

I have no doubt in my mind that a billion dollars to a private charity has a far far greater beneficial effect on society than a billion dollars more spending by the Government. Hell even the tiny NZ Government can increase health spending by a billion dollars and not show any extra results for the money.

Think what the Red Cross would do with a billion dollars extra, as opposed to the Government.

A fun evening

Hope Bros was a good choice of location for the blogger drinks. We got far better mixing and mingling than at the BB where you tend to be all seated around a long table.

Around 30 or so people there, including many new faces. In previous years it was mainly political types, but had a lot more of the “tech” people there last night.

Didn’t go on too late, so a few of us then grabbed dinner at Uncle Chang’s. Myself, Michael E, Chris B and Welly Girl. Was lots of fun with much hilarious conversation.

Joe Hendren reports that Auckland drinks also went well. Sounds like the Sonic=H2 theory was disproved 🙂

Blogger Drinks Tuesday

A reminder that 2007 blogger drinks are after work Tuesday. Details are:

Date: Tuesday 16 January
Time: 5.30 pm onwards
Place: Hope Brothers Bar, corner Dixon and Eva streets

All are welcome – bloggers, blog commenters and lurkers alike. The aim is to be upstairs, in the area on the right hand side of the top of the stairs.

Dom Post Editorial on Greens

A useful editorial today in the Dom Post, responding to the Greens scorecard of parties on climate change:

Many New Zealanders do have a philosophical commitment to green policies. It is when it comes to practicalities that the necessary compromises begin between that commitment and their other, equally worthy ambitions, such as ensuring New Zealand has an economy capable of delivering a high standard of living, of providing jobs for its young people, and of financing the welfare state.

If New Zealand was populated by maypole-dancing, beancurd-eating, bicycle-embracing voters, the Greens would be in control of the Beehive and eco taxes would abound.

Instead, most New Zealanders have come to a more pragmatic balance between environmental purity and economic reality, a balance that recognises the West Coast snails need to co-exist with mine development.

Dr Norman chides the Labour-led Government for timidity on climate change, and for being unwilling to challenge the economic orthodoxy of the day. The Greens believe in building consensus. He should recognise that is what is needed on climate change policy, not scorecards.

I’m now trying to picture a maypole-dancing, beancurd-eating, bicycle-embracing voter!