Stadium Petition
An Auckland CBD resident, Susan Grimsdell, has started an online petition against the proposed waterfront stadium. It’s at http://www.petitiononline.com/1stadium.
One more way to have your say!
A few people have asked how the road trip ended, so here’s Day Three for the record.
Left Wanganui late morning. When I asked the hotel what time checkout was, the reply was “Any time you want”. Nice.
You can see the Wanganui River as we drive along it,.
Driving along SH1 we tossed a coin to decide between Marton and Bulls. Marton won. So through Marton we went and then a further coin toss had us heading to Fielding. We continue to plough our way through Simon Power’s electorate but then we note we are heading towards Palmerston North. No, no, no we cried but the rules are the rules. However we were saved just on the outskirts of Palmie with a bypass to Ashurst, and tails won it for us. We were just a few hundred metres from the city centre.
Driving eastwards we see the Manawatu Wind Farm. It’s a great sight and I wish we had more of them. God damn NIMBYs.
Then the coin confirms we are heading to SH2, so over the Manawatu Gorge.
Now heading South we come to the hallowed Tui Brewewy in Mangatainoka. The only Tui sign in the country that says “Yeah left”.
Tui also has a mighty big welcome mat.
After passing through Eketahuna we phone up a friend who was born there to hassle him.
And finally we hit the Rimutakas, where visibility was an optional extra. Cliffs, trucks and fog is always such a good combination.
Left Auckland 2 pm Tuesday and got to Wellington 4 pm Thursday. Travelled a but over 1,000 kms on SH1, SH3 and SH2 plus many other roads. A very fun road trip. Plan is to repeat it next year in the South Island.
An Auckland CBD resident, Susan Grimsdell, has started an online petition against the proposed waterfront stadium. It’s at http://www.petitiononline.com/1stadium.
One more way to have your say!
TVNZ reports an injunction application has been filed with the High Court to prevent the Auckland City and Regional Councils from voting on the waterfront stadium proposal.
I am not surprised. In fact it was first on Dean Knight’s blog that the possibility of action under the Local Government Act was mooted, on the grounds of inadequate consultation.
Two weeks to decide on a billion dollar project was always ridiculous.
The Investigate Blog says they will be breaking a major story in the near future. Hopefully not while I am on a plane!
Someone in National should get a prize for nice lateral thinking. The money owed to broadcasters due to the GST error on election broadcasting is to be spent purchasing broadcasting time on behalf of charities. A real win-win.
National pays the $112,500 it owes, and wants to pay, in a way which doesn’t break the law. The broadcasters get the money, and some charities get to benefit from it all.
Nice, very nice.
The Dom Post reports on how the amended Section 59 bill is going to be a “field day” for lawyers, and that effective lawyers will continue to get parents off, even if they give their kids a bruise which lasts a week.
Now let there be no doubt – if Parliament goes with the Chester Borrows amendment, then giving a child a bruise which lasts a week will be illegal. The definition of reasonable force is drastically lowered to causing “temporary and trifling discomfort”.
The amended Bradford bill does not define reasonable force in any way. It merely amends the circumstances in which such force will be appropriate. I don’t think the bill as amended would help a single child – the additional reasons you can apply reasonable force, combined with the failure to define reasonable force, barely changes the status quo. I’ve always regarded Sue Bradford as one of the best MPs in Parliament. But if she wants to be true to her principles, she should now oppose this Bill as a meaningless gesture which she doesn’t want her name associated with.
As many will know Britney’s ex K-Fed is rumoured to have a tape of their “love making” and to make up for a stingy pre-nup, he is looking to sell it for up to $340 million.
However Britney’s strategy is to hit him where it hurts, and release the tape for free over the Internet.
I can only applaud her strategy 🙂
The Dominion Post has revealed that public servants spend 35,000 hours a year on Trade Me. My only surprise is that it is so low. I bet most work places would have a far higher rate, including Fairfax!
The “worst offender” is Justice Department where 3,015 employees spent 1,386 hours on Trade Me in August. So that is an average of half an hour per employee per month. If we assume only half the staff use Trade Me (and around 50% of NZers do use it) that is one hour per month or three minutes per work day. And last time I checked most staff get 1.5 hours a day of breaks.
The civil service has 40,000 staff in total, so 35,000 hours a year is an hour per staff member. That is around one minute a week per civil servant!!
It looks highly likely that the Hager book will be published within days, with Don Brash amenable in principle to the book being published.
It’s worth noting that the e-mails used in the book are probably a very small sub-set of the ones ilegally obtained from Dr Brash’s computer system. Only one person knows how many were copied, but it could be as high as 10,000. And while it is unfortunate he injunction may be seen as trying to block this book, I maintain it was justified to bring an end to the constant threats from Winston and Helen to reveal bits and peices at their disscretion over the next couple of years. You can’t allow that to stay hanging over you. I would even advocate having them all published now is preferable to the uncertainity of leaving Winston free to release them on his timetable.
John Armstrong calls it a Hobson’s choice. He believes the emails will be fatal for Brash. I can’t judge not having talked to people who have seen them, but the ones released to date have not been out of the ordinary.
At long last Fox News will be available in NZ, not just on Prime after midnight. A lot of people who have never watched Fox thinking it is just a cheer squad for Bush, but they are very wrong. They have some of the best debates and interviews on there, and many good programmes. Sure one or two hosts are over the top, but a channel is more than one or two people. Anyway people will be able to decide for themselves soon if they like it.
A pity al-Jazeera will not be available here. I would certainly be interested in watching it from time to time for their perspective.
Hat Tip: Gareth Robinson
I am off to Hong Kong (briefly) and London for a couple of weeks. Hopefully post every day – will depend as always on access over there.
I’ve got meetings there with some clients and potential clients, and also a couple of conferences to attend. Oh yeah and heaps and heaps of friends to drink and catch up with!
Before Nicky is embraced and hugged to death by the National haters, I thought some quotes on Nicky’s other works by Russell Brown would be a useful context:
“Nicky Hager’s book turns on the science – and the science in it is WRONG.”
“On Hager’s side, we only have the unnamed “experts” in his book. We don’t know who these people are, whether they’re qualified or even, really, if they exist.”
“Nicky Hager actually admitted in Wednesday’s interview with Dean Williams that he had no proof that that was the case.”
Also Nicky Hager was a co-author of the SST Operation Leaf story re the SIS, which was found to be totally wrong, and based on a con.
So while the Brash emails will speak for themselves, if made public, I would take anything Hager says about six senior National Party figures co-operating with his book with a huge grain of salt. Russell Brown has suggested in the past Hager simply makes up anonymous sources. If Hager can not produce even one single name to back up his claims, then they must be treated with suspicion.
Likewise his characterisation of what the e-mails reveal, is simply his characterisation. Personally I would be surprised if there was much there, as Winston had these for over a year and the worst he revealed was some e-mails from Roger Kerr and others encouraging him to run for Leader etc, and of yes an offer of assistance from a US campaign expert (which was declined).
But I don’t know for sure. I suspect Hager will go to court and a Judge will look at the e-mails and proposed book and make a decision about whether there is material in there of public interest sufficient to outweigh the privacy aspect, and the fact they were illegally obtained.
The select committee changes to the Section 59 bill seem to have made a somewhat flawed bill, even worse. It is now going to criminalise parents for smacking their children as a disciplinary measure, yet expands the number of reasons parents can apply force (well beyond smacking) in other situations.
No Right Turn has a good analysis of the extra reasons now inserted as to why you can apply reasonable force:
(a) preventing or minimising harm to the child or another person; or
(b) preventing the child from engaging or continuing to engage in conduct that amounts to a criminal offence; or
(c) preventing the child from engaging or continuing to engage in offensive or disruptive behaviour; or
(d) performing the normal daily tasks that are incidental to good care and parenting.
So you can whack your kid in the face to prevent him from beign disruptive yet you can not smack him for misbehaving. Confused? How did MPs come up with such an abortion? Well it comes down to ideology over common sense.
Let’s accept that a majority of MPs were uncomfortable with criminalising, regardless of degree or circumstances, all force a parent may use with a child. The challenge was how do you then amend the law so not to criminalise good parents.
Basically there are two approaches you can take. The first is that done by the Select Committee, and come up with an exhaustive list of reasons why reasonable force can be used. It incidentially makes enforcement of the law almost impossible as you need to prove the child was not being disruptive or offensive etc etc.
The other approach is that of Chester Borrows. Which is to radically reduce the definition of reasonable force to causing only trifling and temporary discomfort. So it doesn’t try to judge when a parent may need to use some minor force, it sets a very low ceiling on what that force is.
The bill, as amended by select committee, is almost the worst of both worlds. The best argument for repealing Section 59 alltogether is to send a very clear signal to that minority of parents who can’t distinguish between reasonable and unreasonable force, that any force is undesirable. But it no longer does that – in fact it provides more reasons why reasonable force can be used.
MPs should do two things in my opinion. Either:
(a) Repeal Section 59 entirely and live with the electoral consequences
(b) Vote for Chester’s amendment to reduce the definition of reasonable force to “trilfing and temporary discomfort” without limiting the circumstances
But do not let the Bill as it currently stands go forward. It will not even lessen the amount of force deemed reasonable for dealing with “disruptive behaviour” which almost everyone says should be done.
Green activist Nicky Hager has revealed he has written a book based primarily on the Brash e-mails, but can not publish it due to the injunction. It was due to be released today.
Hagar can of course appeal the court order, and if his claims of illegal activities are correct (and that is a very very big if) he could well succeed.
I think it is hugely regrettable that the Labour/Green majority on the Justice & Electoral Select Committee have rejected the sensible compromise by Chester Borrows to amend Section 59 to define reasonable force as that which causes no more than “transitory and trifling” discomfort.
This means they want a total ban on smacking, or parental discipline which causes “transitory and trifling” discomfort.
Winston has been picking up tricks from Helen. He has announced that his staff (without consulting him he says!!!!) destroyed all the Brash e-mails they had when they learnt there was a Police investigation into them.
Just like how Helen’s staff burnt the painting once they heard there was a police investigation into the forgery.
Isn’t this such a good example our senior Ministers set for the public. If the Police are investigating, destroy the evidence before the Police knock on the door.
Around three minutes long. Check it out.
Jeremy Greenbrook has blogged the “power list” of the 50 most powerful NZers from the Listener. I’ll comment on some of the placings but first make it clear I regard power lists as devices to sell newspapers and magazines, and they never bear much relation to reality. The fact I once made an IT/Comms power list is proof positive of this!!!
4 Sam Morgan. Sorry but while Sam is a great guy from all accounts and made some very nice money from Trade Me, he is not the fourth most powerful person in NZ.
23 Heather Simpson – well any list which doesn’t have her in the top ten or top five is not defining power as I do.
15 Pita Sharples. I can’t see how a leader of a party with 4 votes is up there, over Winston Peters who si Foreign Minister, has seven votes and has been able to get a number of policy concessions out of the Govt.
Also I don’t think a single civil servant makes the list except Alan Bollard. The heads of DPMC, SSC, Treasury and MFAT all have considerable power.
The point of protest is generally to raise awareness of, and gather support for your cause. Hence protests should be done in a way which do not alienate the people who might otherwise support you.
Now I am what you could call a potential supporter of the men’s groups who protest against the Family Court. I think in the past there has been bias against men, there have been some awful treatment of fathers by the judicial process and they have my sympathy. I have empathy for the concept of shared parenting rather than one parent having custody etc.
But let me say the tactics of the protesters who target lawyers at their homes on the weekends appals me, and it greatly reduces my desire to support the cause they are promoting. Extremism turns people off. As does reading about how young children of lawyers are having nightmares because of the hours of protest outside their house.
I find the targeting of lawyers involved in the Family Court to be akin to bullying. They are merely advocates doing their job. The protests should be against MPs who make the laws. They are the ones who can change things for you – not lawyers. It comes across as personal and vengeful.
Secondly protests at people’s homes, rather than their offices, is intimidatory. It affects their neighbours, spouses and children, and no just because you have lost your kids is not a reason to harass other kids.
The more these sort of protests carry on, the less likely it is that desired law changes will occur. It’s a pity that some are blinded with (often justifiable) anger, to not see that their tactics are backfiring.
It was inevitable – there is a stadium for sale on Trade Me – it looks suspiciously like an inverted Beehive!
The anti-waterfront lobby meeting saw many unusual coalitions. Hide and Locke opposed in unions, and John Minto and rugby supporters also united in opposition. Bill Hodge from Auckland University highlighted that the legislation planned by the Government to allow the stadium to be built will have to over-ride not just the Resource Management Act but also the Local Government Act, the Public Finance Act and commitments given in other acts in relation to the Treaty of Waitangi.
The Herald has the latest City Council count as eight in favour, six against and six undecided.
And Brian Rudman predicts the stadium would morph into an albatross of debt.
UPDATE: Not PC has an excellent summary of all the speakers at the anti-waterfront meeting. This is again one of the reasons I love blogs – you can get much more detail of what happened at an event, because there are no artificial limits on story size.
Oh dear. In her HoS column attacking the critics of her N&S article on Asian immigration, Deborah Coddington states:
Here’s a disturbing fact: in 2003 four of every five pregnant Asian women aborted their babies. Do we keep abortion as a last-resort method of birth control, or accept it’s a casual approach to contraception?
Now who wants to win a chocolate fish by being the first to post the actual Asian abortion rate in 2003? It’s under half of the 80% stated as a “fact”!
I’m a huge fan of the work of Professor Fergusson, who is profiled in the SST. I especially admire someone who produces research, and defends it, even when it goes against his own personal views. He calls for more “evidence-based policy”, and I couldn’t agree more.
Some of his recent research findings include:
* domestic violence isn’t an exclusively male problem and much of it takes the form of low-level brawling involving both partners
* abortion significantly boosts a young woman’s risk of mental health problems
* cannabis use is linked to use of harder drugs
* circumcision of all baby boys could halve the rate of sexually transmitted diseases
* gays and lesbians suffer higher than average levels of mental illness
* low-level lead exposure negatively affecting children’s IQ
* confirmed sexual abuse was prevalent but found that some perpetrators were female and some victims were male.
The SST has a positive review of Maori Television Service, and indeed TVNZ would love to have as many good things said about it, as MTS has.
MTS certainly have done very well to avoid the excesses of their predecessors with no financial scandals, and some sensible decisions on programming with a mixture of Maori and English language,
My one reservation is we still don’t know how worthwhile the taxpayer investment is, because the ratings figures given out are near meaningless. A cumulative monthly audience of 580,000 measures only those who switched on at least once in the month. By that measure TVNZ and TV3 would have a 3,500,000 audience. It would be good to know how many people watch it say daily and weekly and the audience for their top rating regular programme.
I watched the channel for most of ANZAC Day, and around once every three weeks might watch part of a programme on it. If Sky listed it as Channel Eight, I suspect I would view it more often as I often check out the “general” channels every few days to decide what to record.
The HoS reports on the marquee e-mail which I blogged about yesterday. They have a photo of the bride and groom to be, who point out that at a cost of $30,000 their wedding plans can’t really be called “cheap”.
The office manager turns out to be the wife of the owner (which probably means the sacking is of a temporary nature), and they both appear aghast at what has happened, even “suicidal”. Goodness knows what possessed her to write such an e-mail.
The SST has an article also, but interestingly did nto get the same story with no comment from the Jorgensens who refused to tell the SST if Katrina was his wife.
I still have no idea of which stadium option will prevail. The HoS reports a majority (just) of City Councillor favour the waterfront, but only if it is on Bledisloe wharf, rather than between Marsden and Cook wharves. The port owner has said Bledisloe is not available as it would disrupt the $21 billion a year cargo going through the Port.
The whole idea of making a sane sensible decision within just two weeks is ludicrous. Dean Knight has pointed out that such a short time period for consultation probably breaks the law and makes any decision vulnerable to court action.