The Auckland Waterfront Stadium

Paul Lewis in the HoS is one of a long line of critics of the proposed $700 million stadium on Auckland’s waterfront, championed by Helen Clark.

I’m sceptical of the proposal but not yet vehemently against it. The reason is the outstanding success of Wellington’s waterfront stadium. The WestpacTrust Stadium has been a huge boon for the city. Having a stadium so easy to access with public transport and so close to town people can walk to the nightlife afterwards has boosted attendances massively. I go to half a dozen matches a year at least, and used to almost never go to Athletic Park.

So the location in Auckland is potentially something that could really boost attendance numbers. But the major drawbacks are:

1) Is the cost of $700 million worth it?

2) Who will pay for it?

3) Can it be completed in time for the Rugby World Cup?

The Wellington stadium was initially costed at $70 million and eventually was $130 million. It was primarily funded by local authorities and the private sector.

So the Auckland stadium could well end up costing $1 billion or so. Now if Aucklanders want to spend that much on a stadium, go for it. But if the Government wants to tax me a few hundred dollars to pay for Auckland’s stadium, I’d be very upset. Sure there might be a contribution through Lotteries etc, but it should not be a major funder.

Zealots attack MP

Anti-obesity zealots have attacked poor old Te Atatu MP Chris Carter, because he went along to the opening of a KFC store in Te Atatu and did a photo op there.

Carter should tell them to get a life. Sure you’re a moron if you eat nothing but fast food, but if one has a balanced diet and exercise regularly, then the occassional fast food purchase is not an issue.

I hate it how zealots take a legitimate issue and turn it into a crusade against specific companies or industries.

A cunning fraudster

The HoS has the story of Wayne Patterson who managed toi create 120 false identities to claim $3.5 million of benefits in 2.5 years. Incredible. He was getting $54,000 a fortnight.

Most criminals are pretty stupid, and hence get caught easily. Patterson was alaborate with his plans, with disguises, an apparently cheap house as a front, PO Boxes from Kaitaia to Invercargill etc. What a shame all that intelligence and ability to be used on criminal activity.

After hours of searching at his place, police found around $400,000 of gold bars and a million in cash.

The facte he had multiple passports and drivers licenses should serve as a wakeup call for the respective agencies. I wonder how many times he was enrolled on the electoral roll and whether he voted multiple times also?

United Future and Greens

United Future have said that in future they will work with the Greens on issues where they have common ground.

Could this be preparation for Clark bringing the Greens into coalition, to restore the Govt’s majority once Taito Phillip Field goes?

Hat Tip: Tony Milne

Great Quote

From a phone call this evening:

DPF: Hi Abe, It’s DPF
Abe: Hey DPF can I give you a call back in 5 minutes – I’m just breast feeding at the moment
DPF: Oh I am so going to quote that on the blog

For those wondering Abe was in fact helping his partner express, so she could go out while he looks after the baby!

TV 3 Poll

The TV3 poll tonight is likely to have ramifications for National. Not for the party vote result which has National 40% and Labour 42%. This is not unexpected as every single TV3 poll since the election has shown Labour ahead of National (likewise every single TVNZ poll has shown National ahead of Labour). I will comment on this more in Curia’s monthly polling newsletter out early next week.

But the finding that more National voters picked John Key as best suited to lead National into the next election, than Don Brash, will inevitably have MPs starting to consider their options. The poll had 42% of National voters picking Key, 38% Brash, 11% English and 3% Brownlee.

I would however treat the results with some caution until the full results are made available. The sample size was probably fairly small – less than 400 respondents I guess.

Public Address

Funding of Parties

Russel Norman seems to be inventing figures with his claim the airport billboards cost $70,000 to $90,000 a month. Last election I got billboard prices for Wellington sites as part of the Blumsky campaign, and most were, off memory, around $2,000 a month. Sure the airport ones are bigger and more prime location so will be more than $2,000 a month but Norman’s figures are massively inflated.

He also makes the mistake of thinking a few large donations once every three years constitutes most of National’s income, so hence some big business is funding every activity. Sure business donations are incredibly useful and valued, but one should not under-estimate how much income a party can get from mass membership, like National.

In previous roles I’ve had access to some of the membership and financial stats, and they are confidential, so I am deliberately using figures which are not those numbers. They are roughly in the same ballpark, but should not be taken as an indicator of National’s funding in 2005. I actually have no idea of current membership/finanical stats. I am just using specific numbers as an example.

Let’s say National has 50,000 members. And the average donation from each member is $50. That is $2,500,000 a year just from your annual membership drive. Now let’s also say that you have a direct mail appeal annually to which 30% of members respond with an average $67 donation – that’s another $1.0 million.

Like I say, these are not actual exact figures, but they show how much value there is in having a broad-based party with a strong membership.

And that’s before you even look at the fund-raising done by those members. You have 50 or so strong electorates – if they raise $10,000 each through functions, raffles, movie showings, quiz nights etc that is another $500,000. And some electorates raise much more than $10,000 a year!

It is the support of so many members and hard working activists that allows National to pay for billboards like the airport ones which went up this week.

21 years on the dole

The Dominion Post reports that one NZer has been on the dole for 21 years. Incredible.

Clinton shows how much one can achieve by introducing time limits on certain benefits. Sure you need some flexibility so those with genuine hardship don’t starve, but setting expectations of welfare being of a temporary nature is vital.

Matching the rhetoric

A very insightful column by John Armstrong. He looks at the PM’s talk of NZ becoming carbon-neutral and truly sustainable, and how well they went down.

But he says it will be very hard to match the whetoric with action:

“Carbon neutrality” is a leap of gargantuan proportions. It would require that for every bit of carbon dioxide that ends up as greenhouse gas, an equivalent amount is extracted from the atmosphere and absorbed or buried.

That goes way beyond the Kyoto Protocol, which requires New Zealand to cut emissions by 2012 back to the net amount being pumped into the atmosphere in 1990. So much for that target. Emissions are instead running at more than 20 per cent above 1990 levels – and they are growing. Even the Greens shy away from “carbon neutrality”, preferring to set a goal of reducing net emissions by 60 per cent over the next 40 or so years.

And he recalls a recent quote by the PM:

After all, is this the same Prime Minister who, as the hydro storage lakes were emptying back in March, told Parliament that if it came down to a choice between New Zealanders going without power and having a coal-fired power station to give it to them, “I know what I am going to choose”?

A bouquet and a brickbat

Have to sadly give my ISP, Ihug, a brickbat for the e-mail delays this week. While the evil spamming scum are the cause of the server overload, other ISPs have managed to cope by having greater redundnacy and capacity.

Having incoming e-mail delayed by not just hours but sometimes day is incredibly frustrating. And even worse the outgoing mail servers went down also so I couldn’t even send e-mail. I still as of this morning can’t access the smtp server. Grrr.

The bouquet goes to 2day.com. Had to urgently register a domain name and associated website, and because of not getting e-mail via Ihug didn’t have the passwords to link the website to the domain name. Logged a job with 2day.com’s online help system asking if they could do it for me, and within a couple of hours they had done it. Great service.

Cyberspace Command

Codeshare declined

I heard yesterday that the proposed codeshare arrangement between Air NZ and Qantas had been turned down. I was all ready to congratulate the Government for doing the right thing and putting consumers first.

However reading the NZ Herald this morning I see it was not the NZg which said no, but the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. Thanks Aussies!!

Keep It 18

The NZ Herald reports that support amongst MPs for raising the drinking age to 20 is declining and a close vote is predicted.

They also report on the formation of the Keep It 18 campaign, which I’ve had some involvement in. Young Labour, Young Nationals, Young Greens and ACT on Campus are all working together, along with others, in oppossing raising the drinking age.

And No 100,000 is

Radio Live at 4.45 pm

100,000 comments today

It is likely at some stage today, this blog will pass a massive milestone – 100,000 blog comments!!!

Currently at 99,857. I’ll announce which comment was No 100,000 once we get there. There will be a special prize for the person who is No 100,000 – they get a free life membership of the Labour Party, How? Well when Labour changes the law to force all taxpayers to fund the Labour Party, we’ll all be life members – funding them for life!!

Great political ad

Now that’s a stunt gone wrong

You invent a wonderful new water filtration system, and to promote it you invite four journalists from TV One, TV Three, and the NZ Herald to drink filtered water after it had been mixed with sewage.

The result – all four journalists came down with vomiting and diarrhoea!

The inventors are saying the sickness may have happened because hands were not disinfacted. Yeah Right – or it could be because they served up sewage which didn’t actually get filtered!

Impotent Reviews

The Government seems to specialise in impotent reviews. The so called rates review has such a narrow terms of reference that even United Future is saying nothing will change as a result of it.

I was planning to submit a paper advocating a move away from rates to local income taxes. This would not be a one pager but probably take dozens of hours to put together as a well researched submission. But now I doubt it is worth the effort as the review looks to be impotent.

The other impotent review was that into business costs. A review “with teeth” was announced in May. In its first report we learn that most of the issues raised with them have been ruled to be outside the scope of the review. The only compliance cost reduction identified so far seems to be aligning dates for paying excise duties on alcohol products and alcohol advisory council levies. Woo hoo – break out the party balloons.

Troops respond to Kerry

irak.jpg

Some great humour from the Minnesota National Guard in response to John Kerry telling a group of students if they don’t study hard and get degrees they might find themselves stuck in Iraq. The implication that anyone in the Armed Forces is thick and uneducated has dominated headlines for two days.

While it will hurt the Democrats somewhat, I still think they are likely to win the House next week. The Senate looks to be closer, but less likely to swap majority control.

Around the blogs

An excellent move by the Greens to have co-leader Russel Norman blog on Frog Blog. It will be great to have a second party leader (Rodney is the other) blogging. Also veyr smart for the Greens as a way of getting Russel more known to the public despite not being an MP.

Whale Oil blogs about negative vs positive ads and that one key difference is that negative ads normally have a fact in them, while positive ones do not.

The Kiwi Herald reports on a new pizza from Hell – the abstinence pizza – it will have an ultra thin base of unlevened communion bread with no anchovies, no capers, no cheese and in fact no toppings at all!

Criticising your own party

Jordan Carter defends himself against claims of being merely a Labour mouthpiece. His arguments generally are;

(a) There are some things he can’t comment on in public, due to roles he holds
(b) He has other avenues in which he can raise concerns
(c) He is broadly happy with what the Government does

Now these are all valid to varying degrees, and I’ll return to them shortly to discuss my perspective on them. But for now I want to take people to another post Jordan made the very same day:

The National party under Brash/Key is a party that exists to serve the interests of the very rich and powerful.

The Labour Party under Helen Clark exists to serve the interests of every single New Zealander.

Now with respect to Jordan, it is statements like this which lead people to sometimes criticise his blogging style. Those lines may get a round of cheers at a meeting of Labour Party financial members, but they hardly lend themselves to good debate and go down like cement with the 80% of NZers who are not true believers for a party. It’s so partisan it lacks credibility. It almost paints the contest as one of good and evil. I’d respectfully suggest less slogans like the above would improve things.

Turning back now to the main issue, which is how do you criticise your own party. Now like Jordan I have held senior office within my party (not currently though) and have very strong personal, political and/or professional relationships with most MPs and senior organisational figures. And I value those relationships greatly. So my first rule tends to be that any criticism should be expressed in such a way as to not endanger those relationships. That doesn’t mean I’ll praise things I disagree with, or pretend something has been handled well when it hasn’t. But it does mean I will be temperate with my criticisms, and try not to personalise them.

If I disagree on a policy (and there were several last election I recall criticising) I will usually state my understanding as to why they have adopted such a policy, but still state my disappointment it wasn’t (for example) bolder. That gets my point of view across, but takes the sting out of the criticism.

When National is not performing as well as it could politically, I weigh up my approach carefully. Sometimes, like Jordan, I will just pass on my views directly to MPs and advisors. Sometimes (such as with the Exclusive Brethren issue) I will voice concern on the blog as a way to help pressure for the right decision to be made. Sometimes I will just say nothing as it is obvious that National has stuffed up, and doesn’t need the obvious re-stated.

The other thing I try to do is praise other parties when praise is due. I will in fact go out of my way sometimes to make sure I do this, as I believe it does help the credibility. I said this week that the PM did very well (maybe even better than very well) at her party conference. A couple of weeks ago I praised a NZ First policy. I’ve said nice things about the Greens quite often etc. Sure I disagree with many of their policies but no one party has a monopoly on good ideas and good intentions.

In summary it is somewhat of a tightrope to blog critically about your own party. But I’ve found that so long as one does it in a temperate and restrained way, you can do it without damaging your relationships with key players.

Dave Letterman interviews Borat

Clash of Cultures

The Press reflects on the “uncovered meat” remarks by Australia’s top Muslim cleric. Extracts from their editorial titled Clash of cultures:

Underneath, however, lie more troubling questions about the acceptance by minority communities of freedom and Western values.

The row in Australia is only the latest in which the limits of the openness and tolerance espoused by modern Western societies have been tested by attitudes and practices by migrant groups that are incompatible with that openness and tolerance. In Britain and Europe, migrants, particularly from the Middle East, have until recently been encouraged to retain the customs of the places they have left. This multiculturalism, it was believed, was better than the alternative, generally practised in the United States, of promoting assimilation. European governments have belatedly come to realise, however, that one unintended consequence of multiculturalism has been the growth of a generation of whom many are estranged from the society in which they have grown up and susceptible to the preachings of reactionary religious leaders hostile to those societies.

A visible sign of this separation has been the spread of Islamic dress for women, ranging from headscarves to full burqas that cover the entire body and face. This might ordinarily be unexceptionable were it not for the fact that it is not simply an outward expression of a religious choice. It is more than that. As a former British foreign secretary, Jack Straw, has observed, the veil, especially in its full forms, is a deliberately distancing expression of alienation from the rest of society and even hostility towards it. Further, it is also, as was shown by the Sydney preacher’s remarks, something that in many cases is imposed on unwilling women by belligerent and domineering males with antediluvian views on women’s place in society.

These are part of a realisation, which John Howard’s Government in Australia also subscribes to, that there are some basic, non-negotiable values and attitudes within society that all who join it should learn and share. The issue is not the wearing of veil but what it can represent: an intolerant repudiation of the hard-won freedoms and advances that largely define what those societies are.

I point out that this is exactly what Don Brash was talking about a few months ago – the notion that there are some non-negotiable values such as democracy, freedom of speech, a secular state, equal rights for women etc. which a country has, and which should be made clear to those wishing to live here. A failure to do so can only have bad consequences.